NZB mice exhibit a primary T cell defect in fetal thymic organ culture

Animal models of systemic lupus erythematosus and their applications in drug discovery

INTRODUCTION

Systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is a multisystem autoimmune disease with substantial phenotypic heterogeneity. Currently, our understanding of the pathogenesis is still limited, and as a result, specific and efficacious therapies are lacking. Various mouse models have been established to serve as powerful tools that will promote a better understanding of the disease and the ability to test novel drugs before clinical application.

AREAS COVERED

The authors review the existing mouse models of SLE in terms of pathogenesis and manifestations, as well as their applications in drug discovery and development. The areas of focus include promising novel therapeutics that could benefit patients in the future and the contribution of mouse models used in preclinical studies.

EXPERT OPINION

Given the diversity of SLE mouse models with different characteristics, researchers must select a suitable model based on the mechanism involved. The use of multiple models is needed for drug testing studies to evaluate drug efficacy on different genetic backgrounds and other mechanisms to provide a reference for clinical trials.

Reduced thymic Aire expression and abnormal NF-kappa B2 signaling in a model of systemic autoimmunity

The thymic stromal niche normally directs the production and export of a self-tolerant T cell repertoire. Many models of spontaneous autoimmunity, however, develop thymic architectural abnormalities before disease onset. Although this is suspected to affect central tolerance induction, creating an autoimmune predisposition, in-depth analysis of the microenvironment within these thymi is lacking, such that the mechanisms and likely direct effects on the T cell repertoire are unknown or speculative. Here we show that NZB mice, the first described model for systemic autoimmunity, demonstrate a complex thymic phenotype, including a lack of the autoimmune regulator (Aire), early defects in thymic epithelial cell (TEC) expansion, and evidence for altered NF-kappaB2 signaling. Analysis of medullary TEC revealed a numerical loss of the Aire-expressing MHC class II(high) (mTEC-high) subset as well reduced Aire protein and mRNA per cell. RelB expression was also reduced, while chemokines CCL19 and CCL21 were increased. Unexpectedly, the proportion of cortex and medulla in the NZB mice was normal from 36 wk, despite worsening architectural abnormalities. These data show that the NZB defect is more complex than previously appreciated, segregating into early numerical TEC deficiencies that correct with age, late degeneration of the niche architecture that does not affect TEC number, and a persistent reduction in Aire and RelB expression per cell acquired upon mTEC-high differentiation.

Autoreactive B Cells in Lupus-Prone New Zealand Black Mice Exhibit Aberrant Survival and Proliferation in the Presence of Self-Antigen In Vivo

To identify defects in B cell tolerance that may contribute to the production of autoantibodies in New Zealand Black (NZB) mice, we crossed soluble hen egg white lysozyme (sHEL) and anti-HEL Ig transgenes (Ig Tg) onto the NZB background. In this study, we have examined one of the first checkpoints involved in maintenance of peripheral B cell tolerance, follicular exclusion and elimination of self-reactive B cells in the absence of T cell help. Freshly isolated anti-HEL Ig Tg B cells were labeled with CFSE, adoptively transferred into sHEL recipients, and the fate of self-reactive anti-HEL Ig Tg B cells was followed using flow cytometry and immunofluorescence microscopy. Although anti-HEL Ig Tg B cells from NZB mice are appropriately excluded from B cell follicles in NZB sHEL recipient mice, they demonstrate aberrant survival, proliferation, and generation of anti-HEL Ab-producing cells. This abnormal response results from an intrinsic defect in NZB B cells, requires the presence of CD4(+) T cells, and is facilitated by the splenic environment in NZB mice. Thus, NZB mice have immune defects that interact synergistically to allow autoreactive B cells to become activated despite the presence of tolerizing autoantigens.

BMP4 acts upstream of FGF in modulating thymic stroma and regulating thymopoiesis

Thymocyte development is a non-cell-autonomous process that requires signals provided by the thymic stroma. Bone morphogenetic proteins (BMPs) and fibroblast growth factors (FGFs) derived from thymic stroma have been implicated as possible regulators of T-cell development. Using thymic organ culture, this study demonstrates that both BMP4 and FGF7/FGF10 arrest early T-cell development at the CD4-CD8-CD44+CD25- (double-negative 1 [DN1]) population and at the CD4-CD8- double-negative (DN) to CD4+CD8+ double-positive (DP) transition in a stromal compartment-dependent manner. Furthermore, BMP4 functions upstream of FGF7/FGF10, as the effects of BMP can be suppressed by cotreatment with an FGF receptor antagonist. BMP4 also acts directly on the thymic stroma to up-regulate the stroma-specific transcription factor Foxn1 and stroma-expressed chemokines. Taken together, the data in this report demonstrate that BMP acts upstream of FGF in the regulation of early T-cell development and that BMP4 acts primarily through the thymic stroma, thereby altering the thymic microenvironment and affecting thymopoiesis.

Age-related alterations in the lymphohematopoietic and B-lineage precursor populations in NZB mice

Significant disturbances in B lineage populations of New Zealand Black (NZB) mice have been reported, both with respect to their phenotypes as well as to their function. Notably, there is a profound age-dependent decrease in B-cell precursors in this strain of lupus prone mice. In efforts to characterize the impact of this disturbance in disease, we performed an intensive phenotypic and B-cell population analysis in young and old NZB mice. Our results revealed that there was a significant age-dependent decrease in B cell precursors at all levels of the B-cell-lineage developmental pathway. Analysis of the proliferative capacity of these cell populations showed a comparative decrease in cycling activity in the B-cell-lineage populations of old NZB mice. Furthermore, these cell subsets were much more susceptible to spontaneous apoptosis when compared with similar populations from age-matched BALB/c or young NZB mice. Since the frequency of cells that express the interleukin-7 receptor (IL-7R) declines as NZB mice age, we hypothesize that impairment of IL-7R signal transduction pathways could contribute to severe perturbations of B-cell function in aged NZB mice.

A defective NF-kappa B/RelB pathway in autoimmune-prone New Zealand black mice is associated with inefficient expansion of thymocyte and dendritic cells

New Zeland Black (NZB) mice develop an autoimmune disease involving an abnormal B cell response to peripheral self Ags. This disease is associated with defects in other cell types and thymic stromal organization. We present evidence that NZB cells of various lineages, including thymocytes, fibroblasts, and dendritic precursor cells, show impaired proliferation and enhanced cell death in culture upon stimulation compared with non-autoimmune-prone mice such as C57BL/6. This phenotype explains the reduced efficiency of maturation of bone marrow-derived dendritic cells and the loss of TNF- or IL-1-dependent thymocyte costimulation. Upon TNF-induced activation of NZB thymocytes, nuclear translocation and DNA binding of RelA- and RelB-dependent NF-kappaB heterodimers are significantly reduced. This phenotype has a transcriptional signature, since the NZB, but not the nonobese diabetic, thymic transcriptome shows striking similarities with that of RelB-deficient thymuses. This partial NF-kappaB deficiency detected upon activation by proinflammatory cytokines could explain the disorganization of thymic microenvironments in NZB mice. These combined effects might reduce the efficiency of central tolerance and expose apoptotic debris generated during inflammatory processes to self recognition.

Impaired development of T lymphoid precursors from pluripotent hematopoietic stem cells in New Zealand Black mice

Bone marrow cells from autoimmune-prone New Zealand Black (NZB) mice are less efficient at colonizing fetal thymic lobes than cells from normal strains. This study demonstrates that the reduced capacity of NZB bone marrow cells to repopulate the thymus does not result from their inability to migrate to or enter the thymus. Rather, the T lymphopoietic defect of NZB mice is due to an impaired ability of pluripotent hematopoietic stem cells (PHSCs) to generate more committed lymphoid progeny, which could include common lymphoid precursors and/or other T cell-committed progenitors. Although PHSCs from NZB mice were not as efficient at thymic repopulation as comparable numbers of PHSCs from control strains, the ability of common lymphoid precursors from NZB mice to repopulate the thymus was not defective. Similarly, more differentiated NZB T cell precursors included in the intrathymic pool of CD4(-)CD8(-) cells also exhibited normal T lymphopoietic potential. Taken together, the results identify an unappreciated defect in NZB mice and provide further evidence that generation of lymphoid progeny from the PHSCs is a regulated event.

Mice lacking the orphan G protein-coupled receptor G2A develop a late-onset autoimmune syndrome

Mice with a targeted disruption of the gene encoding a lymphoid-expressed orphan G protein-coupled receptor, G2A, demonstrate a normal pattern of T and B lineage differentiation through young adulthood. As G2A-deficient animals age, they develop secondary lymphoid organ enlargement associated with abnormal expansion of both T and B lymphocytes. Older G2A-deficient mice (>1 year) develop a slowly progressive wasting syndrome, characterized by lymphocytic infiltration into various tissues, glomerular immune complex deposition, and anti-nuclear autoantibodies. G2A-deficient T cells are hyperresponsive to TCR stimulation, exhibiting enhanced proliferation and a lower threshold for activation. Our findings demonstrate that G2A plays a critical role in controlling peripheral lymphocyte homeostasis and that its ablation results in the development of a novel, late-onset autoimmune syndrome.

Increased expression of mXBP-1 (TREB-5) in thymic B cells in New Zealand mice

New Zealand Black mice as well as several other murine models of murine lupus are well known for premature degeneration of thymus and development of autoimmunity. To focus on molecular events unique to murine lupus, we performed differential display using arbitrary primer pairs to distinguish NZB versus BALB/c thymus at 5 weeks of age. Following an extensive analysis of DNA bands that were either consistently up or downregulated and from studies of expression pattern of thymic genes by in situ nucleic acid hybridization, we focused on one clone that was consistently differentially expressed between NZB and BALB/c thymus. This clone was isolated, sequenced, and identified as the murine homologue of the human X box binding protein (hXBP-1), also known as TREB 5. mXBP-1 was found to be consistently upregulated in B cells in the thymic cortex of NZB and (NZBxNZW)F1, but not BALB/c, C3H/HeJ or C57BL/6 mice. In addition, it was dramatically elevated in MRL/ lpr but not MRL/++ mice; similarly, it was increased in BXSB/ Yaa male but not BXSB female thymic cortex. Of particular interest was an absence of mXBP-1 expression in the thymus of NZB/ Bln- Igh6(null)homozygotes. mXBP-1 has several putative functions, including the regulation of MHC class II expression and by virtue of its ability to recognize CRE-like elements shown to be involved in HTLV-1 transcription.

Expression of connexin 43 (Cx43) is critical for normal hematopoiesis

Gap junctions are intercellular channels, formed by individual structural units known as connexins (Cx), that allow the intercellular exchange of various messenger molecules. The finding that numbers of Cx43-type gap junctions in bone marrow are elevated during establishment and regeneration of the hematopoietic system has led to the hypothesis that expression of Cx43 is critical during the initiation of blood cell formation. To test this hypothesis, lymphoid and myeloid development were examined in mice with a targeted disruption of the gene encoding Cx43. Because Cx43−/− mice die perinatally, initial analyses were performed on Cx43−/−, Cx43+/−, and Cx43+/+ embryos and newborns. The data indicate that lack of Cx43 expression during embryogenesis compromises the terminal stages of primary T and B lymphopoiesis. Cx43−/− embryos and neonates had a reduced frequency of CD4+ and T-cell receptor-expressing thymocytes and surface IgM+cells compared to their Cx43+/+ littermates. Surprisingly, Cx43+/− embryos/neonates also showed defects in B- and T-cell development similar to those observed in Cx43−/− littermates, but their hematopoietic system was normal at 4 weeks of age. However, the regeneration of lymphoid and myeloid cells was severely impaired in the Cx43+/− mice after cytoablative treatment. Taken together, these data indicate that loss of a single Cx43 allele can affect blood cell formation. Finally, the results of reciprocal bone marrow transplants between Cx43+/+ and Cx43+/− mice and examination of hematopoietic progenitors and stromal cells in vitro indicates that the primary effects of Cx43 are mediated through its expression in the hematopoietic microenvironment.

Expression of connexin 43 (Cx43) is critical for normal hematopoiesis

Gap junctions are intercellular channels, formed by individual structural units known as connexins (Cx), that allow the intercellular exchange of various messenger molecules. The finding that numbers of Cx43-type gap junctions in bone marrow are elevated during establishment and regeneration of the hematopoietic system has led to the hypothesis that expression of Cx43 is critical during the initiation of blood cell formation. To test this hypothesis, lymphoid and myeloid development were examined in mice with a targeted disruption of the gene encoding Cx43. Because Cx43−/− mice die perinatally, initial analyses were performed on Cx43−/−, Cx43+/−, and Cx43+/+ embryos and newborns. The data indicate that lack of Cx43 expression during embryogenesis compromises the terminal stages of primary T and B lymphopoiesis. Cx43−/− embryos and neonates had a reduced frequency of CD4+ and T-cell receptor-expressing thymocytes and surface IgM+cells compared to their Cx43+/+ littermates. Surprisingly, Cx43+/− embryos/neonates also showed defects in B- and T-cell development similar to those observed in Cx43−/− littermates, but their hematopoietic system was normal at 4 weeks of age. However, the regeneration of lymphoid and myeloid cells was severely impaired in the Cx43+/− mice after cytoablative treatment. Taken together, these data indicate that loss of a single Cx43 allele can affect blood cell formation. Finally, the results of reciprocal bone marrow transplants between Cx43+/+ and Cx43+/− mice and examination of hematopoietic progenitors and stromal cells in vitro indicates that the primary effects of Cx43 are mediated through its expression in the hematopoietic microenvironment.