Transplantation tolerance and autoimmunity after xenogeneic thymus transplantation

Abnormal regulatory and effector T cell function predispose to autoimmunity following xenogeneic thymic transplantation

Porcine thymus grafts support robust murine and human thymopoiesis, generating a diverse T cell repertoire that is deleted of donor and host-reactive cells, achieving specific xenograft tolerance. Positive selection is mediated exclusively by the xenogeneic thymic MHC. Although thymectomized, T cell-depleted normal mice usually remain healthy following xenogeneic thymic transplantation, thymus-grafted congenitally athymic mice frequently develop multiorgan autoimmunity. We investigated the etiology of this syndrome by adoptively transferring lymphocyte populations from fetal pig thymus-grafted BALB/c nude mice to secondary BALB/c nude recipients. Fetal pig thymus-grafted nude mice generated normal numbers of CD25(+)Foxp3(+)CD4 T cells, but these cells lacked the capacity to block autoimmunity. Moreover, thymocytes and peripheral CD4(+)CD25(-) cells from fetal pig thymus-grafted nude mice, but not those from normal mice, induced autoimmunity in nude recipients. Injection of thymic epithelial cells from normal BALB/c mice into fetal pig thymus grafts reduced autoimmunity and enhanced regulatory function of splenocytes. Our data implicate abnormalities in postthymic maturation, expansion, and/or survival of T cells positively selected by a xenogeneic MHC, as well as incomplete intrathymic deletion of thymocytes recognizing host tissue-specific Ags, in autoimmune pathogenesis. Regulatory cell function is enhanced and negative selection of host-specific thymocytes may potentially also be improved by coimplantation of recipient thymic epithelial cells in the thymus xenograft.

Occurrence of autoimmunity after xenothymus transplantation in T-cell-deficient mice depends on the thymus transplant technique

Xenothymus transplantation under the kidney capsule in athymic rodents frequently leads to multiorgan autoimmunity. Herein, we explore whether this is an intrinsic risk of xenothymus grafting or whether it depends on the transplant technique. We developed a new technique of "venous pouch" thymus grafting (heart-xenothymus) and compared this with the conventional kidney subcapsular technique (kidney-xenothymus) in a rat-into-nude-mouse model. Whereas lethal autoimmunity developed in 90% of kidney-xenothymus recipients, all heart-xenothymus grafted mice remained completely healthy. Autoimmunity in heart-xenothymus recipients was absent despite a significantly improved T-cell generation and was associated with significantly higher CD4+CD25+ T-cell frequencies and CD4+CD25+ cell Foxp3 mRNA levels than those observed in kidney-xenothymus recipients. In conclusion, we describe a novel vascular pouch technique of xenothymus transplantation that prevents the development of autoimmunity in nude mice. Our data further suggest that prevention of autoimmunity is related to a superior development of regulatory T-cells.

Rapidly induced, T-cell–independent xenoantibody production is mediated by marginal zone B cells and requires help from NK cells

Xenoantibody production directed at a wide variety of T lymphocyte–dependent and T lymphocyte–independent xenoantigens remains the major immunologic obstacle for successful xenotransplantation. The B lymphocyte subpopulations and their helper factors, involved in T-cell–independent xenoantibody production are only partially understood, and their identification will contribute to the clinical applicability of xenotransplantation. Here we show, using models involving T-cell–deficient athymic recipient mice, that rapidly induced, T-cell–independent xenoantibody production is mediated by marginal zone B lymphocytes and requires help from natural killer (NK) cells. This collaboration neither required NK-cell–mediated IFN-γ production, nor NK-cell–mediated cytolytic killing of xenogeneic target cells. The T-cell–independent IgM xenoantibody response could be partially suppressed by CD40L blockade.

Xenotransplantation: current status and a perspective on the future

Xenotransplantation using pigs as the transplant source has the potential to resolve the severe shortage of human organ donors. Although the development of relatively non-toxic immunosuppressive or tolerance-inducing regimens will be required to justify clinical trials using pig organs, recent advances in our understanding of the biology of xenograft rejection and zoonotic infections, and the generation of alpha1,3-galactosyltransferase-deficient pigs have moved this approach closer to clinical application. This Review highlights the major obstacles impeding the translation of xenotransplantation into clinical therapies and the potential solutions, providing a perspective on the future of clinical xenotransplantation.

CTLA-4 blockade in murine bone marrow chimeras induces a host-derived antileukemic effect without graft-versus-host disease

We studied the effect of CTLA-4 blockade on graft-versus-leukemia and graft-versus-host responses in a mouse model of minor histocompatibility-mismatched bone marrow transplantation. Early CTLA-4 blockade induced acute graft-versus-host disease. Delayed CTLA-4 blockade resulted in a lethal condition with lymphosplenomegaly, but with stable mixed T-cell chimerism, unchanged alloreactive T-cell frequencies and absent anti-host reactivity in vitro. In contrast, multiorgan lymphoproliferative disease with autoimmune hepatitis and circulating anti-DNA auto-antibodies were documented. Splenic lymphocytes exhibited ex vivo spontaneous proliferation and a marked proliferative response against host-type dendritic cells pulsed with syngeneic (host-type) tissue-peptides. Both phenomena were exclusively mediated by host and not donor T cells, supporting an autoimmune pathogenesis. Selectively host-derived T-cell immune reactivity was equally documented against leukemia-peptide-pulsed dendritic cells, and this was paralleled by a strong in vivo antileukemic effect in anti-CTLA-4-treated and subsequently leukemia-challenged chimeras. In conclusion, delayed CTLA-4 blockade induced a host-derived antileukemic effect, occurring in the context of an autoimmune syndrome and strictly separated from graft-versus-host disease. Both antileukemic and autoimmune responses depended on the allogeneic component, as neither effect was seen after syngeneic bone marrow transplantation. Our findings reveal the potential of using CTLA-4 blockade to establish antileukemic effects after allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplantation, provided autoimmunity can be controlled.

Reconstitution of a functional human immune system in immunodeficient mice through combined human fetal thymus/liver and CD34+ cell transplantation

Studies of the human immune system have been limited by the lack of an appropriate in vivo model. For this reason, efforts have been made to develop murine models with a functional human immune system. We report here that cotransplantation of human fetal thymus/liver tissues and CD34(+) hematopoietic stem/progenitor cells led to the development of sustained human hematopoiesis and a functional human immune system in immunodeficient NOD/SCID mice. The humanized mice showed systemic repopulation with a comprehensive array of human lymphohematopoietic cells, including T cells, B cells, and dendritic cells, and the formation of secondary lymphoid organs. Furthermore, these mice produce high levels of human IgM and IgG antibodies and mediate strong immune responses in vivo as demonstrated by skin xenograft rejection. Thus, the humanized NOD/SCID mice described in this paper provide a powerful model system to study human immune function.

Induction and Maintenance of T-dependent or T-independent Xenotolerance by Nonprimarily-Vascularized Skin or Thymus Grafts

BACKGROUND

The success of clinical xenotransplantation will depend on induction of xenotolerance. We have previously shown that combined xenothymus and vascularized xenoheart transplantation under the coverage of a tolerizing regimen (TR) can induce and maintain full xenotolerance. Here, induction/maintenance of xenotolerance using nonprimarily-vascularized thymus and/or skin grafts was investigated.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Hamster skin or thymus or combined skin and thymus transplantation was performed in nude rat recipients with or without administering a TR (NK cell depletion, day -14; xenoantigen infusion, day -14; Leflunomide, day -14 through +14). Xenotolerance was confirmed by subsequent transplantation of a vascularized hamster heart, measurement of xenoantibody formation, or mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR).

RESULTS

Skin grafts were as effective as vascularized heart grafts to induce/maintain T-independent xenotolerance. Even without TR and despite being rejected themselves, xenoskin grafts lead to progressively developing xenononreactivity. Xenothymus transplantation induced xenotolerance in the T-dependent but not in the T-independent immune compartment, leading to rejection of subsequently transplanted hamster hearts by T-independent mechanisms (production of IgM but not IgG xenoantibodies (Xabs), presence of antihamster MLR nonresponsiveness). Combined skin and thymus xenotransplantation sensitized the T-cell compartment, leading to hyperacute rejection of subsequently transplanted hamster hearts. This was not the case when the skin grafts were transplanted late (2 months) after the thymus grafts.

CONCLUSIONS

Xenogeneic skin and xenogeneic thymus grafts have opposite xenotolerance inducing capacities in the T-independent as compared to the T-dependent immune compartment. Thymus grafts induce and maintain T-dependent but not T-independent xenotolerance. Skin grafts alone induce T-independent xenotolerance but sensitize the T-cell compartment when transplanted concomitantly with thymus grafts.

Effects of a Short Course of Leflunomide on T-Independent B-Lymphocyte Xenoreactivity and on Susceptibility of Xenografts to Acute or Chronic Rejection

BACKGROUND

Leflunomide is a novel immunosuppressive agent with promising activity for xenotransplantation. It is not clear yet which mechanisms of action of leflunomide are responsible for that.

METHODS

In a hamster-to-C57BL/6 nude mouse heart transplantation model, a 2-week course of leflunomide was used after transplantation or for pretreating donors. Nontolerant B lymphocytes were transferred to recipients after transplantation of first or second xenogeneic heart grafts that were transplanted with or without leflunomide treatment.

RESULTS

Hamster xenogeneic hearts transplanted into athymic C57BL/6 nude mice receiving leflunomide did not induce immunoglobulin (Ig) M xenoantibodies (XAb) and survived without signs of chronic rejection. Second xenogeneic hearts transplanted 4 weeks after withdrawal of leflunomide survived without induction of XAb but developed chronic vascular lesions. After injection of naive B lymphocytes at 6 weeks after grafting a first or second hamster heart, only in the latter case were XAb induced. These were deposited in, and provoked acute rejection of, only the second grafts. Pretreatment of donors with leflunomide decreased the ex vivo xenoantibody deposition on the xenogeneic heart endothelia.

CONCLUSIONS

A short posttransplant course of leflunomide induces T-independent B-lymphocyte xenotolerance. Leflunomide treatment also influences xenoantigen expression, as nontolerant B lymphocytes provoke IgM XAb formation and rejection of only second xenografts (transplanted without leflunomide) and not of first xenografts (transplanted with leflunomide treatment). The ex vivo experiments that show that XAb deposition is decreased in leflunomide-pretreated xenografts further confirm this. The latter may also explain the resistance of first and not second xenografts against chronic rejection.

Early Accumulation of Interferon-?? in Grafts Tolerized by Donor-Specific Blood Transfusion: Friend or Enemy?

BACKGROUND

We previously documented an early (day-2) interferon (IFN)-gamma accumulation in cardiac allografts of rats made tolerant by donor-specific blood transfusion (DSBT) but not in rejecting controls. This contrasted with the IFN-gamma peak seen later (day 5) in rejecting but not in tolerant rats.

METHODS

To further examine the role of early intragraft IFN-gamma in DSBT-induced tolerance, we studied whether IFN-gamma up-regulation correlates with the magnitude of the DSBT effect and how IFN-gamma is influenced by interventions abrogating tolerance.

RESULTS

The protective effect of DSBT depended upon the timing of administration: day-12 DSBT induced indefinite graft survival; day-6 DSBT gave a moderate, and day-0 DSBT, no graft prolongation. IFN-gamma up-regulation correlated with the DSBT effect: it was maximal after day-12 DSBT, intermediate after day-6 DSBT, and absent after day-0 DSBT. Tolerant splenocytes transferred tolerance into naive rats in a donor-specific manner, indicating that alloantigen-specific regulatory cells operate. Thymectomy prevented regulatory cells development, caused further amplification of intragraft IFN-gamma, and led to rejection, although graft survival was still prolonged.

CONCLUSIONS

Day 2 intragraft IFN-gamma correlates with the DSBT protective effect. Thymectomy abrogates DSBT-induced tolerance, prevents regulatory cell development, and paradoxically causes further accumulation of intragraft IFN-gamma. These data indicate that DSBT has a stimulatory and a (thymus-dependent) inhibitory effect on early intragraft IFN-gamma. Intragraft IFN-gamma is beneficial, providing it occurs early and remains moderate. The role of intragraft IFN-gamma in tolerance and rejection depends upon the timing and the degree of production and perhaps the type of IFN-gamma producing cells (regulatory or effector).

Xenotransplantation

The continued and growing success of lung allotransplantation has intensified the worldwide shortage of donor organs. Yet, xenotransplantation remains a daunting challenge. Additional molecular incompatibilities and unforeseen complications will continue to be discovered. Progress has been made, notably on the generation of alpha-Gal double knockout pigs. Progressive increases in organ survival times have been seen for most organs after significant investments of time and money. The lung continues to be an organ with the lowest supply of cadaveric donors and the least potential for expanded living donation or mechanical alternatives. As such, the impetus for xenotransplantation is strong. The lung appears to be exquisitely sensitive to xenograft rejection and resistant to strategies that have been moderately successful in other organs. A complex program involving genetically modified donor organs, recipient preparation for antibody removal or tolerance promotion, and multitargeted drug therapy will likely be required for successful clinical application.

Despite efficient intrathymic negative selection of host-reactive T cells, autoimmune disease may develop in porcine thymus-grafted athymic mice: evidence for failure of regulatory mechanisms suppressing autoimmunity

BACKGROUND

CD4 T-cell reconstitution and xenogeneic tolerance is achieved in T cell-depleted, thymectomized C57BL/6 (B6) mice and nude mice by grafting of fetal pig thymus (FP THY). Sixty percent of grafted nude mice and 10% of grafted thymectomized B6 mice develop a clinical illness resembling chronic graft-versus-host disease.

METHODS

Negative selection of mouse T cells in FP THY grafts was studied in "AND" TCR transgenic mice with a negative selecting MHC. Pathologic and immunohistochemical examinations and adoptive transfer assays were performed to determine the role of mouse CD4+ cells in the occurrence of autoimmune disease in this model.

RESULTS

Marked clonal deletion of mouse thymocytes bearing a transgenic TCR ("AND"), which recognizes H2s expressed by host hematopoietic cells, was observed in FP THY grafts. Pathologic and immunohistochemical examinations of the liver, skin, lungs, and kidneys of mice with wasting syndrome showed marked mouse CD4+ T-cell infiltration without detectable pig cells. After adoptive transfer of splenocytes, but not of CD4+ cell-depleted splenocytes, from sick mice along with B6 bone marrow cells to lethally irradiated syngeneic B6 mice, the secondary recipients developed a similar autoimmune syndrome as the donors. Cotransfer of naïve syngeneic splenocytes prevented the occurrence of autoimmune disease in secondary recipients of splenocytes from healthy FP THY-grafted BALB/c nude mice.

CONCLUSION

These results demonstrate a key role for mouse CD4+ T cells in causing autoimmune disease in this model and suggest the importance of regulatory mechanisms in addition to intrathymic clonal deletion for the maintenance of tolerance to recipient antigens.

Pathogenesis of autoimmunity after xenogeneic thymus transplantation

Thymus transplantation is a promising strategy to induce xenotolerance, but may also induce an autoimmune syndrome (AIS). The pathogenesis of this AIS was explored using nude rats as recipients. Thymus grafts consisted of fetal hamster thymic tissue with or without mixing with fetal rat tissue such as thymus, thyroid, salivary gland, and heart. All hamster thymus recipients died of AIS within 2-3 mo. In most recipients of xenothymus mixed with rat tissues such as thymus, thyroid, and salivary gland, but not heart, AIS was prevented, indicating an insufficient presence of rat epithelial cell Ags within the xenothymus. AIS could be transferred to control nude rats by whole splenocytes or by splenocyte subpopulations such as CD3(+), CD3(-), and B lymphocytes, but not by non-T, non-B cells from AIS animals. This transfer could be suppressed by cotransferring either CD4(+) or CD8(+) lymphocytes from euthymic rats, but not by splenocytes from recipients of syngeneic or xenogeneic thymus mixed with rat tissue, indicating a defective generation of regulatory lymphocytes. As for CD4(+) regulatory cells this defect was probably qualitative, because the percentages of CD4(+)CD25(+) or CD4(+)CD45RC(low) populations were normal after xenothymus transplantation. As for the CD8(+) regulatory cells, the defect was quantitative, as CD8(+) cell levels always remained low. The latter was related to the nonvascularized nature of thymus grafts. In conclusion, AIS after xenothymus transplantation in nude rats is due to a combination of insufficient intrathymic presence of host-type epithelial cell Ags and a defective generation of regulatory T lymphocytes.