Adaptive tolerance of CD4+ T cells in vivo: multiple thresholds in response to a constant level of antigen presentation

Epitope-based precision immunotherapy of Type 1 diabetes

Antigen-specific immunotherapies (ASITs) address important clinical needs in treating autoimmune diseases. However, Type 1 diabetes is a heterogeneous disease wherein patient characteristics influence responsiveness to ASITs. Targeting not only disease-relevant T cell populations, but also specific groups of patients using precision medicine is a new goal toward achieving effective treatment. HLA-restricted peptides provide advantages over protein as antigens, however, methods for profiling antigen-specific T cells need to improve in sensitivity, depth, and throughput to facilitate epitope selection. Delivery approaches are highly diverse, illustrating the many ways relevant antigen-presenting cell populations and anatomical locations can be targeted for tolerance induction. The role of persistence of antigen presentation in promoting durable antigen-specific tolerance requires further investigation. Based on the outcome of ASIT trials, the field is moving toward using patient-specific variations to improve efficacy, but challenges still lie on the path to delivering more effective and safer treatment to the T1D patient population.

Conversion of Anergic T Cells Into Foxp3- IL-10+ Regulatory T Cells by a Second Antigen Stimulus In Vivo

T cell anergy is a common mechanism of T cell tolerance. However, although anergic T cells are retained for longer time periods in their hosts, they remain functionally passive. Here, we describe the induction of anergic CD4⁺ T cells in vivo by intravenous application of high doses of antigen and their subsequent conversion into suppressive Foxp3^- IL-10⁺ Tr1 cells but not Foxp3⁺ Tregs. We describe the kinetics of up-regulation of several memory-, anergy- and suppression-related markers such as CD44, CD73, FR4, CD25, CD28, PD-1, Egr-2, Foxp3 and CTLA-4 in this process. The conversion into suppressive Tr1 cells correlates with the transient intracellular CTLA-4 expression and required the restimulation of anergic cells in a short-term time window. Restimulation after longer time periods, when CTLA-4 is down-regulated again retains the anergic state but does not lead to the induction of suppressor function. Our data require further functional investigations but at this stage may suggest a role for anergic T cells as a circulating pool of passive cells that may be re-activated into Tr1 cells upon short-term restimulation with high and systemic doses of antigen. It is tentative to speculate that such a scenario may represent cases of allergen responses in non-allergic individuals.

Control of T Cell Responses, Tolerance and Autoimmunity by Regulatory T Cells: Current Concepts

Regulatory T cells have emerged as an important mechanism of regulating tolerance and T cell responses. CD4+ regulatory T cells can be divided into two main groups, natural regulatory T cells, which express high levels of CD25 on their cell surface and phenotypically diverse adaptive (antigen induced) regulatory T cells. Natural regulatory T cells are made in the thymus, and require strong costimulatory signals for induction and maintenance, express a transcription factor called Foxp3, and function by a largely unknown mechanism. Adaptive (antigen induced) regulatory T cells are made by sub-optimal antigenic signals in the periphery, in the presence of immunosuppressive cytokines, often in special circumstances, such as chronic viral infections or after mucosal administration of antigen, and rely on cytokines such as IL-10 and TGF-β for suppression. Regulatory T cells offer a great potential for the treatment of autoimmune diseases and during transplantation.

PD-1 expression is upregulated on adapted T cells in experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis but is not required to maintain a hyporesponsive state

T cell adaptation is an important peripheral tolerogenic process which ensures that the T cell population can respond effectively to pathogens but remains tolerant to self‐antigens. We probed the mechanisms of T cell adaptation using an experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE) model in which the fate of autopathogenic T cells could be followed. We demonstrated that immunisation with a high dose of myelin basic protein (MBP) peptide and complete Freund's adjuvant failed to effectively initiate EAE, in contrast to low dose MBP peptide immunisation which readily induced disease. The proportion of autopathogenic CD4⁺ T cells in the central nervous system (CNS) of mice immunised with a high dose of MBP peptide was not significantly different to mice immunised with a low dose. However, autopathogenic T cells in mice immunised with high dose MBP peptide had an unresponsive phenotype in ex vivo recall assays. Importantly, whilst expression of PD‐1 was increased on adapted CD4⁺ T cells within the CNS, loss of PD‐1 function did not prevent the development of the unresponsive state. The lack of a role for PD‐1 in the acquisition of the adapted state stands in striking contrast to the reported functional importance of PD‐1 in T cell unresponsiveness in other disease models.

Density dependent re-tuning of autoreactive T cells alleviates their pathogenicity in a lymphopenic environment

Peripheral T cell tolerance is challenging to induce in partially lymphopenic hosts and this is relevant for clinical situations involving transplant tolerance. While the shortage of regulatory cells is thought to be one reason for this, T cell-intrinsic tolerance processes such as anergy are also poorly triggered in such hosts. In order to understand the latter, we used a T cell deficient mouse model system where adoptively transferred autoreactive T cells are significantly tolerized in a cell intrinsic fashion, without differentiation to regulatory T cells. Intriguingly these T cells often retain sufficient effector functions to trigger autoimmune pathology. Here we find that the high population density of the autoreactive T cells that accumulated in such a host limits the progression of the cell-intrinsic tolerance process in T cells. Accordingly, reducing the cell density during a second transfer allowed T cells to further tune down their responsiveness to antigenic stimulation. The retuning of T cells was reflected by a loss of the T cell's abilities to proliferate, produces cytokines or help B cells. We further suggest, based on altering the levels of chronic antigen using miniosmotic pumps, that the effects of cell-density on T cell re-tuning may reflect the effective changes in the antigen dose perceived by individual T cells. This could proportionally elicit more negative feedback downstream of the TCR. Consistent with this, the retuned T cells showed signaling defects both proximal and distal to the TCR. Therefore, similar to the immunogenic activation of T cells, cell-intrinsic T cell tolerance may also involve a quantitative and progressive process of tuning down its antigen-responsiveness. The progress of such tuning seems to be stabilized at multiple intermediate stages by factors such as cell density, rather than just absolute antigen levels.

Metabolic programming in chronically stimulated T cells: Lessons from cancer and viral infections

T-cell metabolism is central to the shaping of a successful immune response. However, there are pathological situations where T cells are rendered dysfunctional and incapable of eliminating infected or transformed cells. Here, we review the current knowledge on T-cell metabolism and how persistent antigenic stimulation, in the form of cancer and chronic viral infection, modifies both metabolic and functional pathways in T cells.

Self-reactivity as the necessary cost of maintaining a diverse memory T-cell repertoire

The adaptive immune system is expected to protect the host from infectious agents and malignancies, while avoiding robust activation against self-peptides. However, T cells are notoriously inept at protection whenever the pathogen or tumor is persistent in the body for longer periods of time. While this has been thought of as an adaptation to limit the immunopathology from continued effector T-cell responses, it is also likely an extension of the T cell's intrinsic mechanisms which evolved to tolerate self-peptides. Here we deliberate on how the need to tolerate self-peptides might stem from a paradoxical requirement-the utility of such molecules in maintaining a diverse repertoire of pathogen-specific memory T cells in the body. Understanding the mechanisms underlying this intriguing nexus, therefore, has the potential to reveal therapeutic strategies not only for improving immune responses to chronic infections and tumors but also the long-term efficacy of vaccines aimed at cellular immune responses.

The N-Terminal Fraction of Desmoglein 3 Encompassing its Immunodominant Domain is Present in Human Serum: Implications for Pemphigus Vulgaris Autoimmunity

Pemphigus vulgaris (PV) is considered as an autoimmune disease against a tissue-restricted antigen, desmoglein 3, a 130 kDa glycoprotein expressed by keratinocytes of skin and mucous membranes. Therefore, a breakdown of peripheral tolerance is generally invoked to explain this horror autotoxicus. The availability of a self-antigen and the strength of antigenic stimulation represent critical points in the regulation of immune system homeostasis. Our study shows for the first time that the immunodominant fraction of the PV self-antigen is present in sera of healthy individuals and patients as a circulating 30 kDa fragment (sDsg3). These findings provide a good explanation for the N-terminal specificity of antibody production and peptide recognition in PV patients by B and T cell, respectively. Moreover, the presence of the sDsg3 in human sera could allow to reconsider pemphigus as a disease against a circulating antigen; once produced, PV-autoantibodies also recognize the 130 kDa epidermal antigen desmoglein 3 on keratinocyte surface (kDsg3), thus triggering the acantholysis and the clinical manifestations of pemphigus.

Maintenance of peripheral tolerance to islet antigens

Reestablishment of immune tolerance to the insulin-producing beta cells is the desired goal for type 1 diabetes (T1D) treatment and prevention. Immune tolerance to multiple islet antigens is defective in individuals with T1D, but the mechanisms involved are multifaceted and may involve loss of thymic and peripheral tolerance. In this review we discuss our current understanding of the varied mechanisms by which peripheral tolerance to islet antigens is maintained in healthy individuals where genetic protection from T1D is present and how this fails in those with genetic susceptibility to disease. Novel findings in regards to expression of neo-islet antigens, non-classical regulatory cell subsets and the impact of specific genetic variants on tolerance induction are discussed.

Mechanisms of autoimmunity in the non-obese diabetic mouse: effector/regulatory cell equilibrium during peak inflammation

Immune imbalance in autoimmune disorders such as type 1 diabetes may originate from aberrant activities of effector cells or dysfunction of suppressor cells. All possible defective mechanisms have been proposed for diabetes-prone species: (i) quantitative dominance of diabetogenic cells and decreased numbers of regulatory T cells, (ii) excessive aggression of effectors and defective function of suppressors, (iii) perturbed interaction between effector and suppressor cells, and (iv) variations in sensitivity to negative regulation. The experimental evidence available to date presents conflicting information on these mechanisms, with identification of perturbed equilibrium on the one hand and negation of critical role of each mechanism in propagation of diabetic autoimmunity on the other hand. In our analysis, there is no evidence that inherent abnormalities in numbers and function of effector and suppressor T cells are responsible for the immune imbalance responsible for propagation of type 1 diabetes as a chronic inflammatory process. Possibly, the experimental tools for investigation of these features of immune activity are still underdeveloped and lack sufficient resolution, in the presence of the extensive biological viability and functional versatility of effector and suppressor elements.

Tolerance is established in polyclonal CD4(+) T cells by distinct mechanisms, according to self-peptide expression patterns

Studies of repertoires of mouse monoclonal CD4(+) T cells have revealed several mechanisms of self-tolerance; however, which mechanisms operate in normal repertoires is unclear. Here we studied polyclonal CD4(+) T cells specific for green fluorescent protein expressed in various organs, which allowed us to determine the effects of specific expression patterns on the same epitope-specific T cells. Peptides presented uniformly by thymic antigen-presenting cells were tolerated by clonal deletion, whereas peptides excluded from the thymus were ignored. Peptides with limited thymic expression induced partial clonal deletion and impaired effector T cell potential but enhanced regulatory T cell potential. These mechanisms were also active for T cell populations specific for endogenously expressed self antigens. Thus, the immunotolerance of polyclonal CD4(+) T cells was maintained by distinct mechanisms, according to self-peptide expression patterns.

Dynamic tuning of lymphocytes: physiological basis, mechanisms, and function

Dynamic tuning of cellular responsiveness as a result of repeated stimuli improves the ability of cells to distinguish physiologically meaningful signals from each other and from noise. In particular, lymphocyte activation thresholds are subject to tuning, which contributes to maintaining tolerance to self-antigens and persisting foreign antigens, averting autoimmunity and immune pathogenesis, but allowing responses to strong, structured perturbations that are typically associated with acute infection. Such tuning is also implicated in conferring flexibility to positive selection in the thymus, in controlling the magnitude of the immune response, and in generating memory cells. Additional functional properties are dynamically and differentially tuned in parallel via subthreshold contact interactions between developing or mature lymphocytes and self-antigen-presenting cells. These interactions facilitate and regulate lymphocyte viability, maintain their functional integrity, and influence their responses to foreign antigens and accessory signals, qualitatively and quantitatively. Bidirectional tuning of T cells and antigen-presenting cells leads to the definition of homeostatic set points, thus maximizing clonal diversity.

Micro-RNA-155-mediated control of heme oxygenase 1 (HO-1) is required for restoring adaptively tolerant CD4+ T-cell function in rodents

T cells chronically stimulated by a persistent antigen often become dysfunctional and lose effector functions and proliferative capacity. To identify the importance of micro-RNA-155 (miR-155) in this phenomenon, we analyzed mouse miR-155-deficient CD4(+) T cells in a model where the chronic exposure to a systemic antigen led to T-cell functional unresponsiveness. We found that miR-155 was required for restoring function of T cells after programmed death receptor 1 blockade. Heme oxygenase 1 (HO-1) was identified as a specific target of miR-155 and inhibition of HO-1 activity restored the expansion and tissue migration capacity of miR-155(-/-) CD4(+) T cells. Moreover, miR-155-mediated control of HO-1 expression in CD4(+) T cells was shown to sustain in vivo antigen-specific expansion and IL-2 production. Thus, our data identify HO-1 regulation as a mechanism by which miR-155 promotes T-cell-driven inflammation.

Orchestration of pulmonary T cell immunity during Mycobacterium tuberculosis infection: immunity interruptus

Despite the introduction almost a century ago of Mycobacterium bovis BCG (BCG), an attenuated form of M. bovis that is used as a vaccine against Mycobacterium tuberculosis, tuberculosis remains a global health threat and kills more than 1.5 million people each year. This is mostly because BCG fails to prevent pulmonary disease--the contagious form of tuberculosis. Although there have been significant advances in understanding how the immune system responds to infection, the qualities that define protective immunity against M. tuberculosis remain poorly characterized. The ability to predict who will maintain control over the infection and who will succumb to clinical disease would revolutionize our approach to surveillance, control, and treatment. Here we review the current understanding of pulmonary T cell responses following M. tuberculosis infection. While infection elicits a strong immune response that contains infection, M. tuberculosis evades eradication. Traditionally, its intracellular lifestyle and alteration of macrophage function are viewed as the dominant mechanisms of evasion. Now we appreciate that chronic inflammation leads to T cell dysfunction. While this may arise as the host balances the goals of bacterial sterilization and avoidance of tissue damage, it is becoming clear that T cell dysfunction impairs host resistance. Defining the mechanisms that lead to T cell dysfunction is crucial as memory T cell responses are likely to be subject to the same subject to the same pressures. Thus, success of T cell based vaccines is predicated on memory T cells avoiding exhaustion while at the same time not promoting overt tissue damage.

Role of SFB in autoimmune arthritis: an example of regulation of autoreactive T cell sensitivity in the gut

A key role for segmented filamentous bacteria (SFB) has recently been demonstrated in several mouse models of autoimmune diseases, including autoimmune arthritis and multiple sclerosis. The mechanism governing the activation of systemic autoreactive T cell responses by such commensals in the gut, however, remained elusive. In this addendum, we discuss recent results addressing the local regulation of autoreactive T cell sensitivity by these unique bacteria. We found that the presence of SFB in the gut microbiota was sufficient to promote a local inflammatory microenvironment altering the T cell-intrinsic desensitization process normally occurring in response to chronic self-antigen stimulation. In the absence of this key tolerance checkpoint, sustained chronic T cell proliferation, IFNγ production, and B cell activation eventually led to the development of enhanced pathologies in a Th1-driven T cell-transfer model of autoimmune arthritis.

Antigen-dependent integration of opposing proximal TCR-signaling cascades determines the functional fate of T lymphocytes

T cell anergy is a key tolerance mechanism to mitigate unwanted T cell activation against self by rendering lymphocytes functionally inactive following Ag encounter. Ag plays an important role in anergy induction where high supraoptimal doses lead to the unresponsive phenotype. How T cells "measure" Ag dose and how this determines functional output to a given antigenic dose remain unclear. Using multiparametric phospho-flow and mass cytometry, we measured the intracellular phosphorylation-dependent signaling events at a single-cell resolution and studied the phosphorylation levels of key proximal human TCR activation- and inhibition-signaling molecules. We show that the intracellular balance and signal integration between these opposing signaling cascades serve as the molecular switch gauging Ag dose. An Ag density of 100 peptide-MHC complexes/cell was found to be the transition point between dominant activation and inhibition cascades, whereas higher Ag doses induced an anergic functional state. Finally, the neutralization of key inhibitory molecules reversed T cell unresponsiveness and enabled maximal T cell functions, even in the presence of very high Ag doses. This mechanism permits T cells to make integrated "measurements" of Ag dose that determine subsequent functional outcomes.

Molecular mechanisms of T-cell anergy

Anergy is a long-term stable state of T-lymphocyte unresponsiveness to antigenic stimulation associated with the blockade of IL-2 production and proliferation. Anergy is a pathway of peripheral tolerance formation. In this review, mechanisms underlying T-cell tolerization are considered in a classical in vitro model of clonal anergy, and these mechanisms are compared with different pathways of anergy induction in vivo. Special attention is given to regulatory T-lymphocytes because, on one hand, anergy is a specific feature of these cells, and on the other hand anergy is also a mechanism of their action on target cells - effector T-lymphocytes. The role of this phenomenon in the differentiation of regulatory T-cells and also in the development of activation-induced apoptosis in effector T-lymphocytes is discussed.

Specific gut commensal flora locally alters T cell tuning to endogenous ligands

Differences in gut commensal flora can dramatically influence autoimmune responses, but the mechanisms behind this are still unclear. We report, in a Th1-cell-driven murine model of autoimmune arthritis, that specific gut commensals, such as segmented filamentous bacteria, have the ability to modulate the activation threshold of self-reactive T cells. In the local microenvironment of gut-associated lymphoid tissues, inflammatory cytokines elicited by the commensal flora dynamically enhanced the antigen responsiveness of T cells that were otherwise tuned down to a systemic self-antigen. Together with subtle differences in early lineage differentiation, this ultimately led to an enhanced recruitment of pathogenic Th1 cells and the development of a more severe form of autoimmune arthritis. These findings define a key role for the gut commensal flora in sustaining ongoing autoimmune responses through the local fine tuning of T-cell-receptor-proximal activation events in autoreactive T cells.

At low precursor frequencies, the T-cell response to chronic self-antigen results in anergy without deletion

The behavior of self-reactive T cells in the peripheral immune system has often been studied by following the fate of adoptively transferred antigen-specific T cells in antigen expressing mice. In most cases, after a period of expansion, such cells undergo a slow clonal deletion, accompanied by the onset of anergy and/or suppression in the remaining cells. Here, we demonstrate that at initial frequencies approaching those found in normal repertoires, it is possible to completely avoid deletion and still maintain peripheral tolerance. At starting numbers of <1000 T cells, stimulation by chronic self-antigens resulted in a period of robust clonal expansion, followed by a steady plateau phase extending beyond 4 months. Despite their stable persistence, the self-reactive T cells did not convert to a Foxp3⁺ fate. However, they displayed a considerable block in their ability to make IL-2, consistent with the onset of anergy - in a precursor frequency or deletion independent fashion.

Development and tolerization of hyperacute rejection in a transgenic mouse graft versus host model

BACKGROUND

The hyperacute rejection mediated by preexisting antibodies is a major impediment to the success of transplants across allogeneic and xenogeneic barriers. We report a new mouse model that allows us to not only monitor the sensitization of B cells mediating the hyperacute response but also validate therapeutic strategies for tolerizing them.

MODEL

The new model system uses 5C.C7,RAG2 T-cell receptor transgenic T cells and B10.S(9R),CD3[Latin Small Letter Open E] hosts for adoptive transfer experiments.

RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS

In the allogeneic hosts, transgenic T cells expanded briefly before being chronically deleted. Once the deletion was initiated, a second graft of donor cells was used to assess a hyperacute response. The rapid rejection of the second cohort correlated with the appearance of donor-specific antibodies in the serum. Interestingly, chronically stimulated T cells were relatively resistant to hyperacute rejection, suggesting an explanation for the slower rejection kinetics of the first cohort even as the second cohort of identical donor cells was being hyperacutely rejected. Finally, we could tolerize the potential for a hyperacute response, by pretreating recipients with a single infusion of naive donor B cells before the first T-cell transfer. This treatment not only abrogated the development of a hyperacute response but also allowed the primary graft to survive in vivo for extended periods.

Historical overview of immunological tolerance

A fundamental property of the immune system is its ability to mediate self-defense with a minimal amount of collateral damage to the host. The system uses several different mechanisms to achieve this goal, which is collectively referred to as the "process of immunological tolerance." This article provides an introductory historical overview to these various mechanisms, which are discussed in greater detail throughout this collection, and then briefly describes what happens when this process fails, a state referred to as "autoimmunity."

Impairment of immunological synapse formation in adaptively tolerant T cells

Adaptive tolerance is a hyporesponsive state in which lymphocyte Ag receptor signaling becomes desensitized after prolonged in vivo encounter with Ag. The molecular mechanisms underlying this hyporesponsive state in T cells are not fully understood, although a major signaling block has been shown to be present at the level of ZAP70 phosphorylation of linker for activation of T cells (LAT). In this study, we investigated the ability of adaptively tolerant mouse T cells to form conjugates with Ag-bearing APCs and to translocate signaling molecules into the interface between the T cells and APCs. Compared with naive or preactivated T cells, adaptively tolerant T cells showed no dramatic impairment in their formation of conjugates with APCs. In contrast, there was a large impairment in immunological synapse formation. Adaptively tolerant T cells were defective in their translocation of signaling molecules, such as ZAP70, LAT, and phospholipase C γ1, into the T cell-APC contact sites. Although Ag-induced activation of VAV1 was normal, VAV's recruitment into the synapse was also impaired. Interestingly, expressions of both IL-2-inducible T cell kinase and growth factor receptor-bound protein 2-related adaptor downstream of SHC were decreased by 60-80% in adaptively tolerant T cells. These decreases, in addition to the impairment in LAT phosphorylation by ZAP70, appear to be the major impediments to the phosphorylation of SLP76 (SRC homology 2 domain-containing leukocyte protein of 76 kDa) and the recruitment of VAV1, which are important for stable immunological synapse formation.

Self-antigen presentation by mouse B cells results in regulatory T-cell induction rather than anergy or clonal deletion

Multiple mechanisms operate to ensure T-cell tolerance toward self-antigens. Three main processes have been described: clonal deletion, anergy, and deviation to CD4(+) regulatory T cells (Tregs) that suppress autoreactive T cells that have escaped the first 2 mechanisms. Although it is accepted that dendritic cells (DCs) and B cells contribute in maintaining T-cell tolerance to self-antigens, their relative contribution and the processes involved under physiologic conditions remain only partially characterized. In this study, we used different transgenic mouse models to obtain chimeras where a neo self-antigen is expressed by thymic epithelium and/or by DCs or B cells. We found that expression of cognate ligand in the thymus enhances antigen-specific FoxP3(+) cells independently of whether the self-antigen is expressed on thymic epithelium or only on DCs, but not on B cells. On the contrary, self-antigen expression by B cells was very efficient in inducing FoxP3(+) cells in the periphery, whereas self-antigen expression by DC led mainly to deletion and anergy of antigen-specific FoxP3(-) cells. The results presented in this study underline the role of B cells in Treg induction and may have important implications in clinical protocols aimed at the peripheral expansion of Tregs in patients.

T cell anergy as a strategy to reduce the risk of autoimmunity

Some self-reactive immature T cells escape negative selection in the thymus and may cause autoimmune diseases later. In the periphery, if T cells are stimulated insufficiently by peptide-major histocompatibility complex, they become inactive and their production of cytokines changes, a phenomenon called "T cell anergy". In this paper, we explore the hypothesis that T cell anergy may function to reduce the risk of autoimmunity. The underlying logic is as follows: Since those self-reactive T cells that receive strong stimuli from self-antigens are eliminated in the thymus, T cells that receive strong stimuli in the periphery are likely to be non-self-reactive. As a consequence, when a T cell receives a weak stimulus, the likelihood that the cell is self-reactive is higher than in the case that it receives a strong stimulus. Therefore, inactivation of the T cell may reduce the danger of autoimmunity. We consider the formalism in which each T cell chooses its response depending on the strength of stimuli in order to reduce the risk of autoimmune diseases while maintaining its ability to attack non-self-antigens effectively. The optimal T cell responses to a weak and a strong stimulus are obtained both when the cells respond in a deterministic manner and when they respond in a probabilistic manner. We conclude that T cell anergy is the optimal response when a T cell meets with antigen-presenting cells many times in its lifetime, and when the product of the autoimmunity risk and the number of self-reactive T cells has an intermediate value.

Co-inhibitory molecules: Controlling the effectors or controlling the controllers?

Nearly forty years ago the concept was proposed that lymphocytes are negatively regulated by what are now called co-inhibitory signals. Nevertheless, it is only the more recent identification of numerous co-inhibitors and their critical functions that has brought co-inhibition to the forefront of immunologic research. Although co-inhibitory signals have been considered to directly regulate conventional T cells, more recent data has indicated a convergence between co-inhibitory signals and the other major negative control mechanism in the periphery that is mediated by regulatory T cells. Furthermore, it is now clear that lymphocytes are not the sole domain of co-inhibitory signals, as cells of the innate immune system, themselves controllers of immunity, are regulated by co-inhibitors they express. Thus, in order to better understand negative regulation in the periphery and apply this knowledge to the treatment of disease, a major focus for the future should be the definition of the conditions where co-inhibition controls effector cells intrinsically versus extrinsically (via regulatory or innate cells).

T follicular helper cells during immunity and tolerance

Helper T cells are required for the generation of a potent immune response to foreign antigens. Amongst them, T follicular helper (Tfh) cells are specialized in promoting protective, long-lived antibody responses that arise from germinal centers. Within these structures, the specificity of B cell receptors may change, due to the process of random somatic hypermutation aimed at increasing the overall affinity of the antibody response. The danger of emerging self-reactive specificities is offset by a stringent selection mechanism delegated in great part to Tfh cells. Only those B cells receiving survival signals from Tfh cells can exit the germinal centers to join the long-lived pools of memory B cells and bone marrow-homing plasma cells. Thus, a crucial immune tolerance checkpoint to prevent long-term autoantibody production lies in the ability to tolerize Tfh cells and to control positive and negative selection signals delivered by this subset. This review tackles the known mechanisms that ensure Tfh tolerance, many of them shared by other T helper subsets during thymic development and priming, but others unique to Tfh cells. Amongst the latter are checkpoints at the stages of Tfh differentiation, follicular migration, growth, longevity, and quality control of selection signals. Finally, we also discuss the consequences of a breakdown in Tfh tolerance.

Mechanisms maintaining peripheral tolerance

The presentation of self-peptide-MHC complexes in the periphery to potentially autoreactive T cells that have escaped negative selection in the thymus poses an important problem to the immune system. In this review, I discuss data that reveal barriers preventing peripheral T cell recognition of self-peptide-MHC complexes, as well as the physiological mechanisms that ensure the elimination or functional inactivation (anergy) of T cells that do come to recognize self-peptide-MHC and threaten the health of the individual.

The honeymoon phase: intersection of metabolism and immunology

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Even though the honeymoon phase in type 1 diabetes mellitus has been well known, its underlying pathogenic mechanisms remain poorly described. The common explanation that it occurs due to 'beta-cell rest' on initiation of insulin therapy seems inadequate based on recent observations and studies and its underlying immunological aspects overlooked.

RECENT FINDINGS

In this article, we will review the metabolic and immunological aspects of the honeymoon phase and we will present our current model of the pathophysiology of this phase. Our view is that it is one of many phases of remission occurring basically due to development of adaptive immune tolerance along the course of type 1 diabetes. We will also review new findings of the interplay between metabolic factors (ambient glucose level) and immune function.

SUMMARY

The honeymoon phase provides a unique model to understand the pathogenesis of type 1 diabetes. Research to unravel its immune pathogenesis is needed. It may turn out that the optimum form of intervention in type 1 diabetes is one that combines enhancement of antigen-specific adaptive immune tolerance with optimized metabolic control in order to keep cytotoxic T cells anergic.

Themis is a member of a new metazoan gene family and is required for the completion of thymocyte positive selection

T cell antigen receptor (TCR) signaling in CD4(+)CD8(+) double-positive thymocytes determines cell survival and lineage commitment, but the genetic and molecular basis of this process is poorly defined. To address this issue, we used ethylnitrosourea mutagenesis to identify a previously unknown T lineage-specific gene, Themis, which is critical for the completion of positive selection. Themis contains a tandem repeat of a unique globular domain (called 'CABIT' here) that includes a cysteine motif that defines a family of five uncharacterized vertebrate proteins with orthologs in most animal species. Themis-deficient thymocytes showed no substantial impairment in early TCR signaling but did show altered expression of genes involved in the cell cycle and survival before and during positive selection. Our data suggest a unique function for Themis in sustaining positive selection.

T-cell tolerance induced by repeated antigen stimulation: selective loss of Foxp3- conventional CD4 T cells and induction of CD4 T-cell anergy

Repeated immunization of mice with bacterial superantigens induces extensive deletion and anergy of reactive CD4 T cells. Here we report that the in vitro proliferation anergy of CD4 T cells from TCR transgenic mice immunized three times with staphylococcal enterotoxin B (SEB) (3 x SEB) is partially due to an increased frequency of Foxp3(+) CD4 T cells. Importantly, reduced number of conventional CD25(-) Foxp3(-) cells, rather than conversion of such cells to Foxp3(+) cells, was the cause of that increase and was also seen in mice repeatedly immunized with OVA (3 x OVA) and OVA-peptide (OVAp) (3 x OVAp). Cell-transfer experiments revealed profound but transient anergy of CD4 T cells isolated from 3 x OVAp and 3x SEB mice. However, the in vivo anergy was CD4 T-cell autonomous and independent of Foxp3(+) Treg. Finally, proliferation of transferred CD4 T cells was inhibited in repeatedly immunized mice but inhibition was lost when transfer was delayed, despite the maintenance of elevated frequency of Foxp3(+) cells. These data provide important implications for Foxp3(+) cell-mediated tolerance in situations of repeated antigen exposure such as human persistent infections.

Adoptive transfer of transgenic T cells to study mucosal adjuvants

The study of the initiation and regulation of T-cell responses to vaccine antigens is of primary importance in the rational design of mucosal adjuvants. The detection in vivo of T-cell priming following immunization can be performed by using the adoptive transfer model of naïve antigen-specific transgenic T cells into immunocompetent mice. In this work, we discuss the applications of this system for detecting in vivo the primary antigen-specific clonal expansion, the phenotype, and the effector function of transgenic T cells following mucosal immunization. OVA and the mucosal adjuvant CTB were used as a model vaccine formulation and administered by the nasal route to study T-cell priming. T helper and T cytotoxic primary proliferation and expression of activation and migration markers was observed both in draining and distal sites. This method proved to be a powerful tool to study the efficacy of mucosal adjuvants in enhancing T-cell priming.

Cutting edge: contributions of apoptosis and anergy to systemic T cell tolerance

Multiple pathways can induce and maintain peripheral T cell tolerance. The goal of this study was to define the contributions of apoptosis and anergy to the maintenance of self-tolerance to a systemic Ag. Upon transfer into mice expressing OVA systemically, OVA-specific DO11 CD4+ T cells are activated transiently, cease responding, and die. Bim is the essential apoptosis-inducing trigger and apoptosis proceeds despite increased expression of Bcl-2 and Bcl-x. However, preventing apoptosis by eliminating Bim does not restore proliferation or cytokine production by DO11 cells. While Foxp3 is transiently induced, anergy is not associated with the stable development of regulatory T cells. Thus, apoptosis is dispensable for tolerance to a systemic self-Ag and cell-intrinsic anergy is sufficient to tolerize T cells.

Biphasic regulation of Il2 transcription in CD4+ T cells: roles for TNF-alpha receptor signaling and chromatin structure

We describe a novel biphasic regulation of Il2 transcription in naive CD4(+) T cells. Few ( approximately 5%) CD4(+) T cells transcribe Il2 within 6 h of anti-TCR-beta plus anti-CD28 stimulation (early phase). Most naive CD4(+) T cells do not initiate Il2 transcription until after an additional approximately 12 h of T cell stimulation (late phase). In comparison, essentially all previously activated (Pre-Ac) CD4(+) T cells that transcribe Il2 do so with an early-phase response. Late-phase Il2 expression mostly requires c-Rel, CD28, and TNFR signaling. In contrast, early-phase transcription is only partly c-Rel and CD28 dependent and TNFR independent. There was also increased stable DNA accessibility at the Il2 locus and elevated c-Rel expression in resting Pre-Ac CD4(+) cells. Upon T cell activation, a faster and greater increase in DNA accessibility as well as c-Rel nuclear expression were observed in Pre-Ac CD4(+) cells relative to naive CD4(+) T cells. In addition, both acetylated histone H3 and total H3 decreased at the Il2 locus upon rechallenge of Pre-Ac CD4(+) T cells, whereas increased acetylated histone H3 with no change in total H3 was observed following activation of naive CD4(+) T cells. We propose a model in which nucleosome disassembly facilitates rapid initiation of Il2 transcription in CD4(+) T cells, and suggest that a threshold level of c-Rel must be reached for Il2 promoter activity in both naive and Pre-Ac CD4(+) T cells. This is provided, at least partially, by TNFR signaling during priming, but not during recall.

Peripheral CD8+ T cell tolerance to self-proteins is regulated proximally at the T cell receptor

CD8(+) T cell tolerance, although essential for preventing autoimmunity, poses substantial obstacles to eliciting immune responses to tumor antigens, which are generally overexpressed normal proteins. Development of effective strategies to overcome tolerance for clinical applications would benefit from elucidation of the immunologic mechanism(s) regulating T cell tolerance to self. To examine how tolerance is maintained in vivo, we engineered dual-T cell receptor (TCR) transgenic mice in which CD8(+) T cells recognize two distinct antigens: a foreign viral-protein and a tolerizing self-tumor protein. Encounter with peripheral self-antigen rendered dual-TCR T cells tolerant to self, but these cells responded normally through the virus-specific TCR. Moreover, proliferation induced by virus rescued function of tolerized self-tumor-reactive TCR, restoring anti-tumor activity. These studies demonstrate that peripheral CD8(+) T cell tolerance to self-proteins can be regulated at the level of the self-reactive TCR complex rather than by central cellular inactivation and suggest an alternate strategy to enhance adoptive T cell immunotherapy.

Death, adaptation and regulation: The three pillars of immune tolerance restrict the risk of autoimmune disease caused by molecular mimicry

Extensive cross-reactivity in T cell receptor (TCR) recognition of peptide-MHC (pMHC) complexes seems to be essential to give sufficient immune surveillance against invading pathogens. This carries with it an inherent risk that T cells activated during a response to clear an infection can, perhaps years later, respond to a self pMHC of sufficient similarity. This lies at the heart of the molecular mimicry theory. Here we discuss our studies on the disease-causing potential of altered peptide ligands (APL) based on the sequence of a single autoantigenic epitope, the Ac1-9 peptide of myelin basic protein that induces experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis in mice. These show that the window of similarity to self for induction of disease by cross-reactive non-self peptides is actually quite restricted. We show that each of the three pillars of immune tolerance (death, anergy/adaptation and regulation) has a role in limiting the risk of molecular mimicry by maintaining a threshold for harm.

Molecular mechanisms for adaptive tolerance and other T cell anergy models

Since the original description of T cell anergy in CD4 clones from mice and humans, a number of different unresponsive states have been described, both in vivo and in vitro, that have been called anergic. While initial attempts were made to understand the similarities between the different models, it has now become clear from biochemical experiments that many of them have different molecular mechanisms underlying their unresponsiveness. In this review we will detail our own work on the in vivo model referred to as adaptive tolerance and then attempt to compare this biochemical state to the multitude of other states that have been described in the literature.

mTOR at the crossroads of T cell proliferation and tolerance

Several events control the activation, proliferation, and the continued Ag responsiveness of naïve and memory T lymphocytes. Here we review the individual contributions of TCR, CD28, and IL-2-driven signaling to T cell proliferation and anergy avoidance. The role of mTOR as a rheostat capable of integrating extracellular, plasma membrane-associated, and intracellular signals with relevance to T cell priming and tolerance is discussed.

Rapamycin Promotes Emergence of IL-10-Secreting Donor Lymphocyte Infusion-Derived T Cells Without Compromising Their Graft-Versus-Leukemia Reactivity

BACKGROUND

There are limited data examining the effects of pharmacological immunosuppression on the in vivo fate of donor lymphocyte infusions (DLI)-derived T cells, their function, and their antitumor efficacy.

METHODS

We addressed this question in a murine model in which DLI is given to stable mixed chimeras resulting in lymphohematopoietic graft-versus-host (LH-GVH) response. In this model, LH-GVH potency can be directly measured as the kinetics of conversion to full donor chimerism and can be correlated with associated graft-versus-leukemia (GVL) reactivity.

RESULTS

We found discordance in DLI-mediated LH-GVH reactivity depending on the timing of rapamycin (RAPA) administration. Delayed administration of RAPA in contrast to its early administration at the time of adoptive transfer did not interfere with conversion to full donor chimerism. Moreover, delayed administration of RAPA preserved the GVL reactivity of DLI. Analysis of the long-term chimeras showed that regardless of RAPA administration, adoptively transferred T cells mediating the LH-GVH response contribute minimally to the reconstitution of the peripheral T-cell compartment and exhibit profound hyporesponsiveness and decreased production of interleukin (IL)-2 on restimulation in vitro. However, we observed only in the RAPA-treated chimeras that the remaining hyporesponsive DLI-derived CD4+ T cells secrete large amounts of IL-10, a known immunoregulatory cytokine.

CONCLUSIONS

We conclude that delayed administration of RAPA after DLI does not interfere with their LH-GVH reactivity but promotes the emergence of IL-10-secreting DLI-derived CD4+ T cells that might contribute to the drug's known ability to promote bilateral donor host tolerance without interfering with GVL reactivity.

GRAIL Is Up-regulated in CD4+ CD25+ T Regulatory Cells and Is Sufficient for Conversion of T Cells to a Regulatory Phenotype

GRAIL (gene related to anergy in lymphocytes) is an ubiquitin-protein isopeptide ligase (E3) ubiquitin ligase necessary for the induction of CD4(+) T cell anergy in vivo. We have extended our previous studies to characterize the expression pattern of GRAIL in other murine CD4(+) T cell types with a described anergic phenotype. These studies revealed that GRAIL expression is increased in naturally occurring (thymically derived) CD4(+) CD25(+) T regulatory cells (mRNA levels 10-fold higher than naive CD25(-) T cells). Further investigation demonstrated that CD25(+) Foxp3(+) antigen-specific T cells were induced after a "tolerizing-administration" of antigen and that GRAIL expression correlated with the CD25(+) Foxp3(+) antigen-specific subset. Lastly, using retroviral transduction, we demonstrated that forced expression of GRAIL in a T cell line was sufficient for conversion of these cells to a regulatory phenotype in the absence of detectable Foxp3. These data demonstrate that GRAIL is differentially expressed in naturally occurring and peripherally induced CD25(+) T regulatory cells and that the expression of GRAIL is linked to their functional regulatory activity.

Regulatory T cells maintain long-term tolerance to myelin basic protein by inducing a novel, dynamic state of T cell tolerance

The pathogenesis of multiple sclerosis involves a breakdown in T cell tolerance to myelin proteins like myelin basic protein (MBP). Most MBP-specific T cells are eliminated by central tolerance in adult mice, however, the developmentally regulated expression of MBP allows MBP-specific thymocytes in young mice to escape negative selection. It is not known how these T cells that encounter MBP for the first time in the periphery are regulated. We show that naive MBP-specific T cells transferred into T cell-deficient mice induce severe autoimmunity. Regulatory T cells prevent disease, however, suppression of the newly transferred MBP-specific T cells is abrogated by activating APCs in vivo. Without APC activation, MBP-specific T cells persist in the periphery of protected mice but do not become anergic, raising the question of how long-term tolerance can be maintained if APCs presenting endogenous MBP become activated. Our results demonstrate that regulatory T cells induce naive MBP-specific T cells responding to nonactivated APCs to differentiate into a unique, tolerized state with the ability to produce IL-10 and TGF-beta1 in response to activated, but not nonactivated, APCs presenting MBP. This tolerant response depends on continuous activity of regulatory T cells because, in their absence, these uniquely tolerized MBP-specific T cells can again induce autoimmunity.

The lymphopenic mouse in immunology: from patron to pariah

A recent surge of interest in the behavior of T and B cells in lymphopenic model systems has resurrected a certain cynicism about the validity of using such models to answer important immunological questions. Here we discuss this skepticism in a broader historical context.

Cognate CD4+ Help Elicited by Resting Dendritic Cells Does Not Impair the Induction of Peripheral Tolerance in CD8+ T Cells

Peripheral tolerance is required to prevent autoimmune tissue destruction by self-reactive T cells that escape negative selection in the thymus. One mechanism of peripheral tolerance in CD8(+) T cells is their activation by resting dendritic cells (DC). In contrast, DC can be "licensed" by CD4(+) T cells to induce cytotoxic function in CD8(+) T cells. The question that then arises, whether CD4(+) T cell help could impair peripheral tolerance induction in self-reactive CD8(+) T cells, has not been addressed. In this study we show that CD4(+) T cell activation by resting DC results in helper function that transiently promotes the expansion and differentiation of cognate CD8(+) T cells. However, both the CD4(+) and CD8(+) T cell populations ultimately undergo partial deletion and acquire Ag unresponsiveness, disabling their ability to destroy OVA-expressing pancreatic beta cells and cause diabetes. Thus, effective peripheral tolerance can be induced by resting DC in the presence of CD4(+) and CD8(+) T cells with specificity for the same Ag.