Assays and technologies for developing proteolysis targeting chimera degraders

Profiling Cellular Morphological Changes Induced by Dual-Targeting PROTACs of Aurora Kinase and RNA-Binding Protein YTHDF2

Proteolysis targeting chimeras (PROTACs) are new chemical modalities that degrade proteins of interest, including established kinase targets and emerging RNA-binding proteins (RBPs). Whereas diverse sets of biochemical, biophysical and cellular assays are available for the evaluation and optimizations of PROTACs in understanding the involved ubiquitin-proteasome-mediated degradation mechanism and the structure-degradation relationship, a phenotypic method profiling the cellular morphological changes is rarely used. In this study, first, we reported the only examples of PROTACs degrading the mRNA-binding protein YTHDF2 via screening of multikinase PROTACs. Second, we reported the profiling of cellular morphological changes of the dual kinase- and RBP-targeting PROTACs using the unbiased cell painting assay (CPA). The CPA analysis revealed the high biosimilarity with the established aurora kinase cluster and annotated aurora kinase inhibitors, which reflected the association between YTHDF2 and the aurora kinase signaling network. Broadly, the results demonstrated that the cell painting assay can be a straightforward and powerful approach to evaluate PROTACs. Complementary to the existing biochemical, biophysical and cellular assays, CPA provided a new perspective in characterizing PROTACs at the cellular morphology.

Advancing PROTAC Characterization: Structural Insights through Adducts and Multimodal Tandem-MS Strategies

Proteolysis targeting chimeras (PROTACs) are specialized molecules that bind to a target protein and a ubiquitin ligase to facilitate protein degradation. Despite their significance, native PROTACs have not undergone tandem mass spectrometry (MS) analysis. To address this gap, we conducted a pioneering investigation on the fragmentation patterns of two PROTACs in development, dBET1 and VZ185. Employing diverse cations (sodium, lithium, and silver) and multiple tandem-MS techniques, we enhanced their structural characterization. Notably, lithium cations facilitated comprehensive positive-mode coverage for dBET1, while negative polarity mode offered richer insights. Employing de novo structure determination on 2DMS data from degradation studies yielded crucial insights. In the case of VZ185, various charge states were observed, with [M + 2H]2+ revealing fewer moieties than [M + H]+ due to charge-related factors. Augmenting structural details through silver adducts suggested both charge-directed and charge-remote fragmentation. This comprehensive investigation identifies frequently dissociated bonds across multiple fragmentation techniques, pinpointing optimal approaches for elucidating PROTAC structures. The findings contribute to advancing our understanding of PROTACs, pivotal for their continued development as promising therapeutic agents.

A Novel Gain-of-Signal Assay to Detect Targeted Protein Degradation

Targeted protein degradation offers a promising avenue for expanding therapeutic development to previously inaccessible proteins of interest by regulating the target abundance rather than activity. However, current methods to screen for effective degraders serve as major bottlenecks for the development of degrader therapies. Here, we develop a novel assay platform for identification and characterization of macromolecules capable of inducing targeted degradation of oncogenic phosphatase SHP2. Unlike traditional reporter assays that utilize loss-of-signal readouts to detect degradation, our assay platform expresses a robust fluorescence signal in response to the depletion of a target protein and incorporates additional measures intended to prevent undesirable false positives. Using this gain-of-signal assay, we successfully identified novel macromolecule SHP2 degraders from a screen of 192 candidates and proposed design principles for further development of macromolecule degraders. This work demonstrates a proof of concept for gain-of-signal assays as a tool for screening targeted degrader candidates.

Targeted Protein Degradation: Advances, Challenges, and Prospects for Computational Methods

The therapeutic approach of targeted protein degradation (TPD) is gaining momentum due to its potentially superior effects compared with protein inhibition. Recent advancements in the biotech and pharmaceutical sectors have led to the development of compounds that are currently in human trials, with some showing promising clinical results. However, the use of computational tools in TPD is still limited, as it has distinct characteristics compared with traditional computational drug design methods. TPD involves creating a ternary structure (protein-degrader-ligase) responsible for the biological function, such as ubiquitination and subsequent proteasomal degradation, which depends on the spatial orientation of the protein of interest (POI) relative to E2-loaded ubiquitin. Modeling this structure necessitates a unique blend of tools initially developed for small molecules (e.g., docking) and biologics (e.g., protein-protein interaction modeling). Additionally, degrader molecules, particularly heterobifunctional degraders, are generally larger than conventional small molecule drugs, leading to challenges in determining drug-like properties like solubility and permeability. Furthermore, the catalytic nature of TPD makes occupancy-based modeling insufficient. TPD consists of multiple interconnected yet distinct steps, such as POI binding, E3 ligase binding, ternary structure interactions, ubiquitination, and degradation, along with traditional small molecule properties. A comprehensive set of tools is needed to address the dynamic nature of the induced proximity ternary complex and its implications for ubiquitination. In this Perspective, we discuss the current state of computational tools for TPD. We start by describing the series of steps involved in the degradation process and the experimental methods used to characterize them. Then, we delve into a detailed analysis of the computational tools employed in TPD. We also present an integrative approach that has proven successful for degrader design and its impact on project decisions. Finally, we examine the future prospects of computational methods in TPD and the areas with the greatest potential for impact.

Expanding Chemical Probe Space: Quality Criteria for Covalent and Degrader Probes

Within druggable target space, new small-molecule modalities, particularly covalent inhibitors and targeted degraders, have expanded the repertoire of medicinal chemists. Molecules with such modes of action have a large potential not only as drugs but also as chemical probes. Criteria have previously been established to describe the potency, selectivity, and properties of small-molecule probes that are qualified to enable the interrogation and validation of drug targets. These definitions have been tailored to reversibly acting modulators but fall short in their applicability to other modalities. While initial guidelines have been proposed, we delineate here a full set of criteria for the characterization of covalent, irreversible inhibitors as well as heterobifunctional degraders ("proteolysis-targeting chimeras", or PROTACs) and molecular glue degraders. We propose modified potency and selectivity criteria compared to those for reversible inhibitors. We discuss their relevance and highlight examples of suitable probe and pathfinder compounds.

The Quest for Oral PROTAC drugs: Evaluating the Weaknesses of the Screening Pipeline

A targeted bibliographic search exposed the deficiencies within existing PROTAC preclinical pipelines, including missing, poor-quality data and technical limitations in the experimental assays. Several recommendations are proposed to improve the efficiency of preclinical platforms for PROTACs.

Aptamer-Based Targeted Protein Degradation

The selective removal of misfolded, aggregated, or aberrantly overexpressed protein plays an essential role in maintaining protein-dominated biological processes. In parallel, the precise knockout of abnormal proteins is inseparable from the accurate identification of proteins within complex environments. Guided by these precepts, small molecules, or antibodies, are commonly used as protein recognition tools for developing targeted protein degradation (TPD) technology. Indeed, TPD has shown tremendous prospects in chronic diseases, rare diseases, cancer research, and other fields. Meanwhile, aptamers are short RNA or DNA oligonucleotides that can bind to target proteins with high specificity and strong affinity. Accordingly, aptamers are actively used in designing and constructing TPD technology. In this perspective, we provide a brief introduction to TPD technology in its current progress, and we summarize its application challenges. Recent advances in aptamer-based TPD technology are reviewed, together with corresponding challenges and outlooks.

Quantitative measurement of PROTAC intracellular accumulation

In recent years, Proteolysis Targeting Chimera (PROTAC) technology has emerged as one of the most promising approaches to remove disease-associated proteins by utilizing cells' own destruction machinery. To achieve successful degradation of a protein of interest (POI), the heterobifunctional PROTAC molecules must penetrate into the cells first, followed by target engagement and formation of the POI-PROTAC-E3 ligase complex. Based on this understanding, the assessment of cell permeability and in cell target engagement are of great importance to evaluate the efficacy of PROTAC candidates. PROTAC molecules can be classified as non-covalent and covalent, and covalent PROTACs can be further divided into irreversible and reversible covalent. Here, we present a high-throughput assay to prioritize different types of BTK PROTACs by measuring their intracellular accumulation quantitatively, using kinase binding assays and the NanoBRET target engagement platform.

Identification and Characterization of a Novel Indoleamine 2,3-Dioxygenase 1 Protein Degrader for Glioblastoma

Indoleamine 2,3-dioxygenase 1 (IDO1) is a potent immunosuppressive enzyme that inhibits the antitumor immune response through both tryptophan metabolism and non-enzymatic functions. To date, most IDO1-targeted approaches have focused on inhibiting tryptophan metabolism. However, this class of drugs has failed to improve the overall survival of patients with cancer. Here, we developed and characterized proteolysis targeting chimeras (PROTACs) that degrade the IDO1 protein. IDO1-PROTACs were tested for their effects on IDO1 enzyme and non-enzyme activities. After screening a library of IDO1-PROTAC derivatives, a compound was identified that potently degraded the IDO1 protein through cereblon-mediated proteasomal degradation. The IDO1-PROTAC: (i) inhibited IDO1 enzyme activity and IDO1-mediated NF-κB phosphorylation in cultured human glioblastoma (GBM) cells, (ii) degraded the IDO1 protein within intracranial brain tumors in vivo, and (iii) mediated a survival benefit in mice with well-established brain tumors. This study identified and characterized a new IDO1 protein degrader with therapeutic potential for patients with glioblastoma.

PROTACs: Current Trends in Protein Degradation by Proteolysis-Targeting Chimeras

In the recent past, proteolysis-targeting chimera (PROTAC) technology has received enormous attention for its ability to overcome the limitations of protein inhibitors and its capability to target undruggable proteins. The PROTAC molecule consists of three components, a ubiquitin E3 ligase ligand, a linker, and a target protein ligand. The application of this technology is rapidly gaining momentum, especially in cancer therapy. In this review, we first look at the history of degraders, followed by a section on the ubiquitin proteasome system (UPS) and E3 ligases used in PROTAC development. PROTACs are dependent on the UPS for degradation of target proteins. We further discuss the scope and design of degraders and mitigation strategies for overcoming the hook effect seen with degraders. As PROTACs do not follow Lipinski's 'Rule of 5', these molecules face drug metabolism and pharmacokinetic challenges. A detailed section on absorption, distribution, metabolism, and excretion of degraders is provided wherein we discuss methodologies and strategies to surmount the challenges faced by these molecules. For understanding PROTAC-mediated degradation, the characterization and measurement of protein levels in cells is important. Currently used techniques and recent advancements in assessment tools for degraders are discussed. Furthermore, we examine the challenges and emerging technologies that need to be focused on in order to competently develop potent degraders. Many companies are working in this area of emerging new modality and a few PROTACs have already entered clinical trials; the details of the trials are included in this review.

BRD4 Inhibitor GNE-987 Exerts Anticancer Effects by Targeting Super-Enhancer-Related Gene LYL1 in Acute Myeloid Leukemia

Background. AML (acute myeloid leukemia) is a common hematological malignancy in children with poor treatment effects and poor prognosis. Recent studies have shown that as a novel BRD4 (bromodomain containing 4) PROTACs (proteolysis targeting chimeras) degrader, GNE-987 can slow down the growth of various tumors and increase apoptosis, with promising clinical prospects. However, the function and molecular mechanism of GNE-987 in AML remain unclear. This study is aimed at investigating the therapeutic effect of GNE-987 on AML and its underlying mechanism. Methods. The association between BRD4 and AML was assessed by studying public databases. After GNE-987 was added to AML cells, cell proliferation slowed down, the cycle was disturbed, and apoptosis increased. Western blotting was used to detect BRD2 (bromodomain containing 2), BRD3 (bromodomain containing 3), BRD4, and PARP (poly ADP-ribose polymerase) proteins. The effect of GNE-987 on AML cells was analyzed in vivo. RNA-seq (RNA sequencing) and ChIP-seq (chromatin immunoprecipitation sequencing) validated the function and molecular pathways of GNE-987 in processing AML. Results. BRD4 expression was significantly elevated in pediatric AML samples compared with healthy donors. GNE-987 inhibited AML cell proliferation by inhibiting the cell cycle and inducing apoptosis. BRD2, BRD3, and BRD4 were consistent with decreased VHL (Von Hippel Lindau) expression in AML cells. In an AML xenograft model, GNE-987 significantly reduced the hepatosplenic infiltration of leukemia cells and increased the mouse survival time. Based on analysis of RNA-seq and ChIP-seq analyses, GNE-987 could target multiple SE- (super-enhancer-) related genes, including LYL1 (lymphoblastic leukemia 1), to inhibit AML. Conclusions. GNE-987 had strong antitumor activity in AML. GNE-987 could effectively inhibit the expression of SE-related oncogenes including LYL1 in AML. Our results suggested that GNE-987 had broad prospects in the treatment of AML.

Are we ready to design oral PROTACs®?

PROTACs® are expected to strongly impact the future of drug discovery. Therefore, in this work we firstly performed a statistical study to highlight the distribution of E3 ligases and POIs collected in PROTAC-DB, the main online database focused on degraders. Moreover, since the emerging technology of protein degradation deals with large and complex chemical structures, the second part of the paper focuses on how to set up a property-based design strategy to obtain oral degraders. For this purpose, we calculated a pool of seven previously ad hoc selected 2D descriptors for the 2258 publicly available degraders in PROTAC-DB (average values: MW= 972.9 Da, nC= 49.5, NAR= 4.5, PHI= 17.3, nHDon= 4.5, nHAcc= 17.7 and TPSA= 240 Ų) and compared them to a dataset of 50 bRo5 orally approved drugs. Then, a chemical space based on nC, PHI and TPSA was built and subregions with optimal permeability and bioavailability were identified. Bioavailable degraders (ARV-110 and ARV-471) tend to be closer to the Ro5 region, using mainly semi-rigid linkers. Permeable degraders, on the other hand, are placed in an average central region of the chemical space but chameleonicity could allow them to be located closer to the two Arvinas compounds.

Amide-to-Ester Substitution as a Strategy for Optimizing PROTAC Permeability and Cellular Activity

Criteria for predicting the druglike properties of "beyond Rule of 5" Proteolysis Targeting Chimeras (PROTAC) degraders are underdeveloped. PROTAC components are often combined via amide couplings due to their reliability. Amides, however, can give rise to poor absorption, distribution, metabolism, and excretion (ADME) properties. We hypothesized that a bioisosteric amide-to-ester substitution could lead to improvements in both physicochemical properties and bioactivity. Using model compounds, bearing either amides or esters, we identify parameters for optimal lipophilicity and permeability. We applied these learnings to design a set of novel amide-to-ester-substituted, VHL-based BET degraders with the goal to increase permeability. Our ester PROTACs retained intracellular stability, were overall more potent degraders than their amide counterparts, and showed an earlier onset of the hook effect. These enhancements were driven by greater cell permeability rather than improvements in ternary complex formation. This largely unexplored amide-to-ester substitution provides a simple strategy to enhance PROTAC permeability and bioactivity and may prove beneficial to other beyond Ro5 molecules.

Advancing targeted protein degradation for cancer therapy

The human proteome contains approximately 20,000 proteins, and it is estimated that more than 600 of them are functionally important for various types of cancers, including nearly 400 non-enzyme proteins that are challenging to target by traditional occupancy-driven pharmacology. Recent advances in the development of small-molecule degraders, including molecular glues and heterobifunctional degraders such as proteolysis-targeting chimeras (PROTACs), have made it possible to target many proteins that were previously considered undruggable. In particular, PROTACs form a ternary complex with a hijacked E3 ubiquitin ligase and a target protein, leading to polyubiquitination and degradation of the target protein. The broad applicability of this approach is facilitated by the flexibility of individual E3 ligases to recognize different substrates. The vast majority of the approximately 600 human E3 ligases have not been explored, thus presenting enormous opportunities to develop degraders that target oncoproteins with tissue, tumour and subcellular selectivity. In this Review, we first discuss the molecular basis of targeted protein degradation. We then offer a comprehensive account of the most promising degraders in development as cancer therapies to date. Lastly, we provide an overview of opportunities and challenges in this exciting field.

Native Mass Spectrometry for the Study of PROTAC GNE-987-Containing Ternary Complexes

PROteolysis TArgeting Chimeras (PROTACs) promote the degradation, rather than inhibition, of a drug target as a mechanism for therapeutic treatment. Bifunctional PROTAC molecules allow simultaneous binding of both the target protein and an E3-Ubiquitin ligase, bringing the two proteins into close spatial proximity to allow ubiquitinylation and degradation of the target protein via the cell's endogenous protein degradation pathway. We utilized native mass spectrometry (MS) to study the ternary complexes promoted by the previously reported PROTAC GNE-987 between Brd4 bromodomains 1 and 2, and Von Hippel Lindeau E3-Ubiquitin Ligase. Native MS at high resolution allowed us to measure ternary complex formation as a function of PROTAC concentration to provide a measure of complex affinity and stability, whilst simultaneously measuring other intermediate protein species. Native MS provides a high-throughput, low sample consumption, direct screening method to measure ternary complexes for PROTAC development.

Applications of Bacterial Degrons and Degraders - Toward Targeted Protein Degradation in Bacteria

A repertoire of proteolysis-targeting signals known as degrons is a necessary component of protein homeostasis in every living cell. In bacteria, degrons can be used in place of chemical genetics approaches to interrogate and control protein function. Here, we provide a comprehensive review of synthetic applications of degrons in targeted proteolysis in bacteria. We describe recent advances ranging from large screens employing tunable degradation systems and orthogonal degrons, to sophisticated tools and sensors for imaging. Based on the success of proteolysis-targeting chimeras as an emerging paradigm in cancer drug discovery, we discuss perspectives on using bacterial degraders for studying protein function and as novel antimicrobials.

General Stepwise Approach to Optimize a TR-FRET Assay for Characterizing the BRD/PROTAC/CRBN Ternary Complex

Proteolysis-targeting chimeras (PROTACs) degrade target proteins by engaging the ubiquitin-proteasome system. Assays detecting target-PROTAC-E3 ligase ternary complexes are critical for PROTAC development. Both time-resolved fluorescence energy transfer (TR-FRET) assays and amplified luminescent proximity homogeneous assays can characterize ternary complexes and assess PROTAC efficacy; stepwise optimization protocols for these assays are lacking. To identify assay conditions that can be applied to various targets and PROTACs, we used a stepwise approach to optimize a TR-FRET assay of BRD2(BD1)/PROTACs/CRBN ternary complexes. This assay is sensitive and specific and responds to the bivalent PROTACs dBET1, PROTAC BET Degrader-1, and PROTAC BET Degrader-2 but not to non-PROTAC ligands of BRD2(BD1) or CRBN. The activity rank order of dBET1, PROTAC BET Degrader-1, and PROTAC BET Degrader-2 in the TR-FRET assay corresponded with previously reported cell growth inhibition assays, indicating the effectiveness of our assay for predicting PROTAC cellular activity. The TR-FRET ternary complex formation assay for BRD2(BD1)/PROTAC/CRBN can be configured to characterize the binding activities of BRD2(BD1) and CRBN ligands with the same compound activity rank order as that of previously reported binary binding assays for individual targets but with the advantage of simultaneously assessing the ligand activities for both targets. Our assay is modular in nature, as BRD2(BD1) can be replaced with other BRDs and successfully detect ternary complexes without modifying other assay conditions. Therefore, the TR-FRET ternary complex assay for BRDs provides a general assay protocol for establishing assays for other targets and bivalent molecules.

PROTACs and Building Blocks: The 2D Chemical Space in Very Early Drug Discovery

Targeted protein degradation by PROTACs has emerged as a new modality for the knockdown of a range of proteins, and, more recently, it has become increasingly clear that the PROTAC chemical space requires characterization through a pool of ad hoc physicochemical descriptors. In this study, a new database named PROTAC-DB that provides extensive information about PROTACs and building blocks was used to obtain the 2D chemical structures of about 1600 PROTACs, 60 E3 ligands, 800 linkers, and 202 warheads. For every structure, we calculated a pool of seven 2D descriptors carefully identified as informative for large and flexible structures. For comparison purposes, the same procedure was applied to a dataset of about 50 bRo5 approved drugs reported in the literature. Correlation matrices, PCAs, box plots, and other graphical tools were used to define and understand the chemical space covered by PROTACs and building blocks in relation to other compounds. Results show that linkers have different properties than E3 ligands and warheads. Polar descriptors additivity is not respected when passing from building blocks to degraders. Moreover, a very preliminary analysis based on three PROTACs with high, intermediate, and low permeability showed how the most permeable compounds seem to occupy a region closer to bRo5 drugs and, thus, exhibit different properties than impermeable compounds. Finally, a second database, PROTACpedia, was used to discuss the relevance of physicochemical descriptors on degradation activity.

PROTACs are effective in addressing the platelet toxicity associated with BCL-XL inhibitors

BCL-X_L is an anti-apoptotic protein that plays an important role in tumorigenesis, metastasis, and intrinsic or therapy-induced cancer drug resistance. More recently, BCL-X_L has also been identified as a key survival factor in senescent cells. Accumulation of senescent cells has been indicated as a causal factor of aging and many age-related diseases and contributes to tumor relapse and metastasis. Thus, inhibition of BCL-X_L is an attractive strategy for the treatment of cancer and extension of healthspan. However, development of BCL-X_L inhibitors such as navitoclax for clinical use has been challenging because human platelets depend on BCL-X_L for survival. In this review, the authors discuss how BCL-X_L-targeted proteolysis targeting chimeras (PROTACs) afford a novel approach to mitigate the on-target thrombocytopenia associated with BCL-X_L inhibition. The authors summarize the progress in the development of BCL-X_L PROTACs. The authors highlight the in vitro and in vivo data supporting that by hijacking the ubiquitin protein ligase (E3) that are poorly expressed in human platelets, BCL-X_L PROTACs can significantly improve the therapeutic window compared to conventional BCL-X_L inhibitors. These findings demonstrated the potentially broad utility of PROTAC technology to achieve tissue selectivity through recruiting differentially expressed E3 ligases and to reduce on-target toxicity.