A mixed incoherent feed-forward loop contributes to the regulation of bacterial photosynthesis genes

In vivo RNA interactome profiling reveals 3'UTR-processed small RNA targeting a central regulatory hub

Small noncoding RNAs (sRNAs) are crucial regulators of gene expression in bacteria. Acting in concert with major RNA chaperones such as Hfq or ProQ, sRNAs base-pair with multiple target mRNAs and form large RNA-RNA interaction networks. To systematically investigate the RNA-RNA interactome in living cells, we have developed a streamlined in vivo approach iRIL-seq (intracellular RIL-seq). This generic approach is highly robust, illustrating the dynamic sRNA interactomes in Salmonella enterica across multiple stages of growth. We have identified the OmpD porin mRNA as a central regulatory hub that is targeted by a dozen sRNAs, including FadZ cleaved from the conserved 3'UTR of fadBA mRNA. Both ompD and FadZ are activated by CRP, constituting a type I incoherent feed-forward loop in the fatty acid metabolism pathway. Altogether, we have established an approach to profile RNA-RNA interactomes in live cells, highlighting the complexity of RNA regulatory hubs and RNA networks.

Biological Prescience: The Role of Anticipation in Organismal Processes

Anticipation is the act of using information about the past and present to make predictions about future scenarios. As a concept, it is predominantly associated with the psychology of the human mind; however, there is accumulating evidence that diverse taxa without complex neural systems, and even biochemical networks themselves, can respond to perceived future conditions. Although anticipatory processes, such as circadian rhythms, stress priming, and cephalic responses, have been extensively studied over the last three centuries, newer research on anticipatory genetic networks in microbial species shows that anticipatory processes are widespread, evolutionarily old, and not simply reserved for neurological complex organisms. Overall, data suggest that anticipatory responses represent a unique type of biological processes that can be distinguished based on their organizational properties and mechanisms. Unfortunately, an empirically based biologically explicit framework for describing anticipatory processes does not currently exist. This review attempts to fill this void by discussing the existing examples of anticipatory processes in non-cognitive organisms, providing potential criteria for defining anticipatory processes, as well as their putative mechanisms, and drawing attention to the often-overlooked role of anticipation in the evolution of physiological systems. Ultimately, a case is made for incorporating an anticipatory framework into the existing physiological paradigm to advance our understanding of complex biological processes.

Emergent Bistable Switches from the Incoherent Feed-Forward Signaling of a Positive Feedback Loop

Bistability is intrinsically connected to various decision making processes in living systems. The operating principles of a bistable switch, generated from a positive feedback loop, are well understood both in natural and synthetic settings. However, the fate of dynamic modularity of a positive feedback loop is unknown when it is connected to another dynamically modular signaling motif. In order to address this, here we investigate feed-forward signaling of a positive feedback loop to determine the fate of a bistable switch under such signaling. Using the potential energy based high-throughput bifurcation analysis method, we uncover that in addition to the conventional bistability the hybrid motifs generate various emergent bistable switches, namely mushroom and isola switches, which are not produced by the individual motifs. Using random parameter sampling, network perturbation, and phase plane analysis, we establish the design principles of such emergent behaviors. Incoherent feed-forward signaling of a positive feedback loop with distinct regulatory thresholds of the two arms of the feed-forward loop are the key requirements for such emergent behaviors. Our calculations show that the specific types of atypical bistable responses depend on the logic gate configuration of the signals. However, the emergent bistable behaviors of the hybrid networks do not depend on the nature of the positive feedback loop.

A Complex Network of Sigma Factors and sRNA StsR Regulates Stress Responses in R. sphaeroides

Adaptation of bacteria to a changing environment is often accompanied by remodeling of the transcriptome. In the facultative phototroph Rhodobacter sphaeroides the alternative sigma factors RpoE, RpoHI and RpoHII play an important role in a variety of stress responses, including heat, oxidative stress and nutrient limitation. Photooxidative stress caused by the simultaneous presence of chlorophylls, light and oxygen is a special challenge for phototrophic organisms. Like alternative sigma factors, several non-coding sRNAs have important roles in the defense against photooxidative stress. RNAseq-based transcriptome data pointed to an influence of the stationary phase-induced StsR sRNA on levels of mRNAs and sRNAs with a role in the photooxidative stress response. Furthermore, StsR also affects expression of photosynthesis genes and of genes for regulators of photosynthesis genes. In vivo and in vitro interaction studies revealed that StsR, that is under control of the RpoHI and RpoHII sigma factors, targets rpoE mRNA and affects its abundance by altering its stability. RpoE regulates expression of the rpoHII gene and, consequently, expression of stsR. These data provide new insights into a complex regulatory network of protein regulators and sRNAs involved in defense against photooxidative stress and the regulation of photosynthesis genes.

Cell-Free Characterization of Coherent Feed-Forward Loop-Based Synthetic Genetic Circuits

Regulatory pathways inside living cells employ feed-forward architectures to fulfill essential signal processing functions that aid in the interpretation of various types of inputs through noise-filtering, fold-change detection and adaptation. Although it has been demonstrated computationally that a coherent feed-forward loop (CFFL) can function as noise filter, a property essential to decoding complex temporal signals, this motif has not been extensively characterized experimentally or integrated into larger networks. Here we use post-transcriptional regulation to implement and characterize a synthetic CFFL in an Escherichia coli cell-free transcription-translation system and build larger composite feed-forward architectures. We employ microfluidic flow reactors to probe the response of the CFFL circuit using both persistent and short, noise-like inputs and analyze the influence of different circuit components on the steady-state and dynamics of the output. We demonstrate that our synthetic CFFL implementation can reliably repress background activity compared to a reference circuit, but displays low potential as a temporal filter, and validate these findings using a computational model. Our results offer practical insight into the putative noise-filtering behavior of CFFLs and show that this motif can be used to mitigate leakage and increase the fold-change of the output of synthetic genetic circuits.

An incoherent feedforward loop formed by SirA/BarA, HilE and HilD is involved in controlling the growth cost of virulence factor expression by Salmonella Typhimurium

An intricate regulatory network controls the expression of Salmonella virulence genes. The transcriptional regulator HilD plays a central role in this network by controlling the expression of tens of genes mainly required for intestinal colonization. Accordingly, the expression/activity of HilD is highly regulated by multiple factors, such as the SirA/BarA two-component system and the Hcp-like protein HilE. SirA/BarA positively regulates translation of hilD mRNA through a regulatory cascade involving the small RNAs CsrB and CsrC, and the RNA-binding protein CsrA, whereas HilE inhibits HilD activity by protein-protein interaction. In this study, we show that SirA/BarA also positively regulates translation of hilE mRNA through the same mentioned regulatory cascade. Thus, our results reveal a paradoxical regulation exerted by SirA/BarA-Csr on HilD, which involves simultaneous opposite effects, direct positive control and indirect negative control through HilE. This kind of regulation is called an incoherent type-1 feedforward loop (I1-FFL), which is a motif present in certain regulatory networks and represents a complex biological problem to decipher. Interestingly, our results, together with those from a previous study, indicate that HilE, the repressor component of the I1-FFL reported here (I1-FFL_{SirA/BarA-HilE-HilD}), is required to reduce the growth cost imposed by the expression of the genes regulated by HilD. Moreover, we and others found that HilE is necessary for successful intestinal colonization by Salmonella. Thus, these findings support that I1-FFL_{SirA/BarA-HilE-HilD} cooperates to control the precise amount and activity of HilD, for an appropriate balance between the growth cost and the virulence benefit generated by the expression of the genes induced by this regulator. I1-FFL_{SirA/BarA-HilE-HilD} represents a complex regulatory I1-FFL that involves multiple regulators acting at distinct levels of gene expression, as well as showing different connections to the rest of the regulatory network governing Salmonella virulence.

To infect the intestine of a broad range of hosts, including humans, Salmonella is required to express a large number of genes encoding different cellular functions, which imposes a growth penalty. Thus, Salmonella has developed complex regulatory mechanisms that control the expression of virulence genes. Here we identified a novel and sophisticated regulatory mechanism that is involved in the fine-tuned control of the expression level and activity of the transcriptional regulator HilD, for the appropriate balance between the growth cost and the virulence benefit generated by the expression of tens of Salmonella genes. This mechanism forms an incoherent type-1 feedforward loop (I1-FFL), which involves paradoxical regulation; that is, a regulatory factor exerting simultaneous opposite control (positive and negative) on another factor. I1-FFLs are present in regulatory networks of diverse organisms, from bacteria to humans, and represent a complex biological problem to decipher. Interestingly, the I1-FFL reported here is integrated by ancestral regulators and by regulators that Salmonella has acquired during evolution. Thus, our findings reveal a novel I1-FFL of bacteria, which is involved in virulence. Moreover, our results illustrate the integration of ancestral and acquired factors into a regulatory motif, which can lead to the expansion of regulatory networks.

The small DUF1127 protein CcaF1 from Rhodobacter sphaeroides is an RNA-binding protein involved in sRNA maturation and RNA turnover

Many different protein domains are conserved among numerous species, but their function remains obscure. Proteins with DUF1127 domains number >17 000 in current databases, but a biological function has not yet been assigned to any of them. They are mostly found in alpha- and gammaproteobacteria, some of them plant and animal pathogens, symbionts or species used in industrial applications. Bioinformatic analyses revealed similarity of the DUF1127 domain of bacterial proteins to the RNA binding domain of eukaryotic Smaug proteins that are involved in RNA turnover and have a role in development from Drosophila to mammals. This study demonstrates that the 71 amino acid DUF1127 protein CcaF1 from the alphaproteobacterium Rhodobacter sphaeroides participates in maturation of the CcsR sRNAs that are processed from the 3' UTR of the ccaF mRNA and have a role in the oxidative stress defense. CcaF1 binds to many cellular RNAs of different type, several mRNAs with a function in cysteine / methionine / sulfur metabolism. It affects the stability of the CcsR RNAs and other non-coding RNAs and mRNAs. Thus, the widely distributed DUF1127 domain can mediate RNA-binding, affect stability of its binding partners and consequently modulate the bacterial transcriptome, thereby influencing different physiological processes.

Antisense RNA asPcrL regulates expression of photosynthesis genes in Rhodobacter sphaeroides by promoting RNase III-dependent turn-over of puf mRNA

Anoxygenic photosynthesis is an important pathway for Rhodobacter sphaeroides to produce ATP under oxygen-limiting conditions. The expression of its photosynthesis genes is tightly regulated at transcriptional and post-transcriptional levels in response to light and oxygen signals, to avoid photooxidative stress by the simultaneous presence of pigments, light and oxygen. The puf operon encodes pigment-binding proteins of the light-harvesting complex I (genes pufB and pufA), of the reaction centre (genes pufL and pufM), a scaffold protein (gene pufX) and includes the gene for sRNA PcrX. Segmental differences in the stability of the pufBALMX-pcrX mRNA contribute to the stoichiometry of LHI to RC complexes. With asPcrL we identified the third sRNA and the first antisense RNA that is involved in balancing photosynthesis gene expression in R. sphaeroides. asPcrL influences the stability of the pufBALMX-pcrX mRNA but not of the pufBA mRNA and consequently the stoichiometry of photosynthetic complexes. By base pairing to the pufL region asPcrL promotes RNase III-dependent degradation of the pufBALMX-prcX mRNA. Since asPcrL is activated by the same protein regulators as the puf operon including PcrX it is part of an incoherent feed-forward loop that fine-tunes photosynthesis gene expression.[Figure: see text].

Bioinformatic prediction reveals posttranscriptional regulation of the chromosomal replication initiator gene dnaA by the attenuator sRNA rnTrpL in Escherichia coli

DnaA is the initiator protein of chromosome replication, but the regulation of its homoeostasis in enterobacteria is not well understood. The DnaA level remains stable at different growth rates, suggesting a link between metabolism and dnaA expression. In a bioinformatic prediction, which we made to unravel targets of the sRNA rnTrpL in Enterobacteriaceae, the dnaA mRNA was the most conserved target candidate. The sRNA rnTrpL is derived from the transcription attenuator of the tryptophan biosynthesis operon. In Escherichia coli, its level is higher in minimal than in rich medium due to derepressed transcription without external tryptophan supply. Overexpression and deletion of the rnTrpL gene decreased and increased, respectively, the levels of dnaA mRNA. The decrease of the dnaA mRNA level upon rnTrpL overproduction was dependent on hfq and rne. Base pairing between rnTrpL and dnaA mRNA in vivo was validated. In minimal medium, the oriC level was increased in the ΔtrpL mutant, in line with the expected DnaA overproduction and increased initiation of chromosome replication. In line with this, chromosomal rnTrpL mutation abolishing the interaction with dnaA increased both the dnaA mRNA and the oriC level. Moreover, upon addition of tryptophan to minimal medium cultures, the oriC level in the wild type was increased. Thus, rnTrpL is a base-pairing sRNA that posttranscriptionally regulates dnaA in E. coli. Furthermore, our data suggest that rnTrpL contributes to the DnaA homoeostasis in dependence on the nutrient availability, which is represented by the tryptophan level in the cell.

The Reaction of Dimerization by Itself Reduces the Noise Intensity of the Protein Monomer

Because of the small particle number of intracellular species participating in genetic circuits, stochastic fluctuations are inevitable. This intracellular noise is detrimental to precise regulation. To maintain the proper function of a cell, some natural motifs attenuate the noise at the protein level. In many biological systems, the protein monomer is used as a regulator, but the protein dimer also exists. In the present study, we demonstrated that the dimerization reaction reduces the noise intensity of the protein monomer. Compared with two common noise-buffering motifs, the incoherent feedforward loop (FFL) and negative feedback control, the coefficient of variation (COV) in the case of dimerization was 25% less. Furthermore, we examined a system with direct interaction between proteins and other ligands. Both the incoherent FFL and negative feedback control failed to buffer the noise, but the dimerization was effective. Remarkably, the formation of only one protein dimer was sufficient to cause a 7.5% reduction in the COV.

PcrX, an sRNA derived from the 3'- UTR of the Rhodobacter sphaeroides puf operon modulates expression of puf genes encoding proteins of the bacterial photosynthetic apparatus

Facultative phototrophic bacteria like Rhodobacter sphaeroides can produce ATP by anoxygenic photosynthesis, which is of advantage under conditions with limiting oxygen. However, the simultaneous presence of pigments, light and oxygen leads to the generation of harmful singlet oxygen. In order to avoid this stress situation, the formation of photosynthetic complexes is tightly regulated by light and oxygen signals. In a complex regulatory network several regulatory proteins and the small non-coding RNA PcrZ contribute to the balanced expression of photosynthesis genes. With PcrX this study identifies a second sRNA that is part of this network. The puf operon encodes pigment binding proteins of the light-harvesting I complex (PufBA) and of the reaction center (PufLM), a protein regulating porphyrin flux (PufQ), and a scaffolding protein (PufX). The PcrX sRNA is derived from the 3' UTR of the puf operon mRNA by RNase E-mediated cleavage. It targets the pufX mRNA segment, reduces the half-life of the pufBALMX mRNA and as a consequence affects the level of photosynthetic complexes. By its action PcrX counteracts the increased expression of photosynthesis genes that is mediated by protein regulators and is thus involved in balancing the formation of photosynthetic complexes in response to external stimuli.

The Insight into Protein-Ligand Interactions, a Novel Way of Buffering Protein Noise in Gene Expression

Random fluctuations are often considered detrimental in the context of gene regulation. Studies aimed at discovering the noise-buffering strategies are important. In this study, we demonstrated a novel design of attenuating noise at protein-level. The protein-ligand interaction dramatically reduced noise so that the coefficient of variation (COV) became roughly 1/3. Remarkably, in comparison to the other two noise-buffering methods, the negative feedback control and the incoherent feedforward loop, the COV of the target protein in the case of protein-ligand interaction appeared to be less than 1/2 of that of the other two methods. The high correlation of the target protein and the ligand grants the present method great ability to buffer noise. Further, it buffers noise at the stage after translation so it is also capable of attenuating the noise inherited from the process of translation.

RNase E cleavage shapes the transcriptome ofRhodobacter sphaeroidesand strongly impacts phototrophic growth

This study identifies the cleavage sites of the endoribonuclease RNase E in the Rhodobacter sphaeroides transcriptome and demonstrates its effect on oxidative stress resistance and phototrophic growth.

Bacteria adapt to changing environmental conditions by rapid changes in their transcriptome. This is achieved not only by adjusting rates of transcription but also by processing and degradation of RNAs. We applied TIER-Seq (transiently inactivating an endoribonuclease followed by RNA-Seq) for the transcriptome-wide identification of RNase E cleavage sites and of 5′ RNA ends, which are enriched when RNase E activity is reduced in Rhodobacter sphaeroides. These results reveal the importance of RNase E for the maturation and turnover of mRNAs, rRNAs, and sRNAs in this guanine-cytosine-rich α-proteobacterium, some of the latter have well-described functions in the oxidative stress response. In agreement with this, a role of RNase E in the oxidative stress response is demonstrated. A remarkably strong phenotype of a mutant with reduced RNase E activity was observed regarding the formation of photosynthetic complexes and phototrophic growth, whereas there was no effect on chemotrophic growth.

Gene network analysis identifies a central post-transcriptional regulator of cellular stress survival

Cells adapt to shifts in their environment by remodeling transcription. Measuring changes in transcription at the genome scale is now routine, but defining the functional significance of individual genes within large gene expression datasets remains a major challenge. We applied a network-based algorithm to interrogate publicly available gene expression data to predict genes that serve major functional roles in Caulobacter crescentus stress survival. This approach identified GsrN, a conserved small RNA that is directly activated by the general stress sigma factor, σ^T, and functions as a potent post-transcriptional regulator of survival across distinct conditions including osmotic and oxidative stress. Under hydrogen peroxide stress, GsrN protects cells by base pairing with the leader of katG mRNA and activating expression of KatG catalase/peroxidase protein. We conclude that GsrN convenes a post-transcriptional layer of gene expression that serves a central functional role in Caulobacter stress physiology.

Cytokinin Regulates the Etioplast-Chloroplast Transition through the Two-Component Signaling System and Activation of Chloroplast-Related Genes

One of the classical functions of the plant hormone cytokinin is the regulation of plastid development, but the underlying molecular mechanisms remain elusive. In this study, we employed a genetic approach to evaluate the role of cytokinin and its signaling pathway in the light-induced development of chloroplasts from etioplasts in Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana). Cytokinin increases the rate of greening and stimulates ultrastructural changes characteristic for the etioplast-to-chloroplast transition. The steady-state levels of metabolites of the tetrapyrrole biosynthesis pathway leading to the production of chlorophyll are enhanced by cytokinin. This effect of cytokinin on metabolite levels arises due to the modulation of expression for chlorophyll biosynthesis genes such as HEMA1, GUN4, GUN5, and CHLM Increased expression of HEMA1 is reflected in an enhanced level of the encoded glutamyl-tRNA reductase, which catalyzes one of the rate-limiting steps of chlorophyll biosynthesis. Mutant analysis indicates that the cytokinin receptors ARABIDOPSIS HIS KINASE2 (AHK2) and AHK3 play a central role in this process. Furthermore, the B-type ARABIDOPSIS RESPONSE REGULATOR1 (ARR1), ARR10, and ARR12 play an important role in mediating the transcriptional output during etioplast-chloroplast transition. B-type ARRs bind to the promotors of HEMA1 and LHCB6 genes, indicating that cytokinin-dependent transcription factors directly regulate genes of chlorophyll biosynthesis and the light harvesting complex. Together, these results demonstrate an important role for the cytokinin signaling pathway in chloroplast development, with the direct transcriptional regulation of chlorophyll biosynthesis genes as a key aspect for this hormonal control.

The Cpx envelope stress response regulates and is regulated by small noncoding RNAs

The Escherichia coli genome encodes approximately 30 two-component systems that are required for sensing and responding to a variety of environmental and physiological cues. Recent studies have revealed numerous regulatory connections between two-component systems and small noncoding RNAs (sRNAs), which posttranscriptionally regulate gene expression by base pairing with target mRNAs. In this study, we investigated the role of sRNAs in the CpxAR two-component system, which detects and mediates an adaptive response to potentially lethal protein misfolding in the Gram-negative bacterial envelope. Here, we showed for the first time that sRNAs are members of the Cpx regulon. We found that CpxR binds to the promoter regions and regulates expression of two sRNA genes, cyaR and rprA. We also investigated the roles that these sRNAs play in the Cpx response. Cpx repression of cyaR expression creates a feed-forward loop, in which CpxAR increases expression of the inner membrane protein YqaE both directly at the transcriptional level and indirectly at the translational level. Moreover, we found that RprA exerts negative feedback on the Cpx response, reducing Cpx activity in a manner that is dependent on the response regulator CpxR but independent of all of RprA's previously described targets. sRNAs therefore permit the fine-tuning of Cpx pathway activity and its regulation of target genes, which could assist bacterial survival in the face of envelope stress.

Macromolecular networks and intelligence in microorganisms

Living organisms persist by virtue of complex interactions among many components organized into dynamic, environment-responsive networks that span multiple scales and dimensions. Biological networks constitute a type of information and communication technology (ICT): they receive information from the outside and inside of cells, integrate and interpret this information, and then activate a response. Biological networks enable molecules within cells, and even cells themselves, to communicate with each other and their environment. We have become accustomed to associating brain activity - particularly activity of the human brain - with a phenomenon we call "intelligence." Yet, four billion years of evolution could have selected networks with topologies and dynamics that confer traits analogous to this intelligence, even though they were outside the intercellular networks of the brain. Here, we explore how macromolecular networks in microbes confer intelligent characteristics, such as memory, anticipation, adaptation and reflection and we review current understanding of how network organization reflects the type of intelligence required for the environments in which they were selected. We propose that, if we were to leave terms such as "human" and "brain" out of the defining features of "intelligence," all forms of life - from microbes to humans - exhibit some or all characteristics consistent with "intelligence." We then review advances in genome-wide data production and analysis, especially in microbes, that provide a lens into microbial intelligence and propose how the insights derived from quantitatively characterizing biomolecular networks may enable synthetic biologists to create intelligent molecular networks for biotechnology, possibly generating new forms of intelligence, first in silico and then in vivo.

A mixed incoherent feed-forward loop allows conditional regulation of response dynamics

Expression of the SodA superoxide dismutase (MnSOD) in Escherichia coli is regulated by superoxide concentration through the SoxRS system and also by Fur (Ferric uptake regulator) through a mixed incoherent feed forward loop (FFL) containing the RyhB small regulatory RNA. In this work I theoretically analyze the function of this feed forward loop as part of the network controlling expression of the two cytoplasmic superoxide dismutases, SodA and SodB. I find that feed forward regulation allows faster response to superoxide stress at low intracellular iron levels compared to iron rich conditions. That is, it can conditionally modulate the response time of a superimposed transcriptional control mechanism.

Riboregulators and the role of Hfq in photosynthetic bacteria

Anoxygenic and oxygenic bacteria directly convert solar energy into biomass using photosynthesis. The formation and composition of photosynthetic complexes has to be tightly controlled in response to environmental conditions, as exposure to sunlight can be harmful due to the generation of reactive oxygen species and the damaging effects of UV irradiation. Therefore, photosynthetic bacteria are exposed to a particular set of regulatory challenges in addition to those that also affect other bacteria, requiring sophisticated regulatory systems. Indeed, hundreds of potential regulatory RNAs have been identified in photosynthetic model bacteria as well as antisense RNAs (asRNAs) of up to several kb in length that protect certain mRNAs from degradation. The trans-acting small non-coding RNAs (sRNAs), PcrZ and PsrR1, control pigment and photosystem biogenesis in Rhodobacter sphaeroides and cyanobacteria, respectively. The asRNAs IsrR and As1_flv4 act as negative regulators and the asRNAs PsbA2R and PsbA3R as positive effectors of photosynthesis gene expression in Synechocystis 6803.