Free Volume in Membranes: Viscosity or Tension?

Mechanical properties of the brain: Focus on the essential role of Piezo1-mediated mechanotransduction in the CNS

BACKGROUND

The brain is a highly mechanosensitive organ, and changes in the mechanical properties of brain tissue influence many physiological and pathological processes. Piezo type mechanosensitive ion channel component 1 (Piezo1), a protein found in metazoans, is highly expressed in the brain and involved in sensing changes of the mechanical microenvironment. Numerous studies have shown that Piezo1-mediated mechanotransduction is closely related to glial cell activation and neuronal function. However, the precise role of Piezo1 in the brain requires further elucidation.

OBJECTIVE

This review first discusses the roles of Piezo1-mediated mechanotransduction in regulating the functions of a variety of brain cells, and then briefly assesses the impact of Piezo1-mediated mechanotransduction on the progression of brain dysfunctional disorders.

CONCLUSIONS

Mechanical signaling contributes significantly to brain function. Piezo1-mediated mechanotransduction regulates processes such as neuronal differentiation, cell migration, axon guidance, neural regeneration, and oligodendrocyte axon myelination. Additionally, Piezo1-mediated mechanotransduction plays significant roles in normal aging and brain injury, as well as the development of various brain diseases, including demyelinating diseases, Alzheimer's disease, and brain tumors. Investigating the pathophysiological mechanisms through which Piezo1-mediated mechanotransduction affects brain function will give us a novel entry point for the diagnosis and treatment of numerous brain diseases.

Membrane tension

The cell membrane serves as a barrier that restricts the rate of exchange of diffusible molecules. Tension in the membrane regulates many crucial cell functions involving shape changes and motility, cell signaling, endocytosis, and mechanosensation. Tension reflects the forces contributed by the lipid bilayer, the cytoskeleton, and the extracellular matrix. With a fluid-like bilayer model, membrane tension is presumed uniform and hence propagated instantaneously. In this review, we discuss techniques to measure the mean membrane tension and how to resolve the stresses in different components and consider the role of bilayer heterogeneity.

Disruption of membrane cholesterol organization impairs the activity of PIEZO1 channel clusters

The human mechanosensitive ion channel PIEZO1 is gated by membrane tension and regulates essential biological processes such as vascular development and erythrocyte volume homeostasis. Currently, little is known about PIEZO1 plasma membrane localization and organization. Using a PIEZO1-GFP fusion protein, we investigated whether cholesterol enrichment or depletion by methyl-β-cyclodextrin (MBCD) and disruption of membrane cholesterol organization by dynasore affects PIEZO1-GFP's response to mechanical force. Electrophysiological recordings in the cell-attached configuration revealed that MBCD caused a rightward shift in the PIEZO1-GFP pressure-response curve, increased channel latency in response to mechanical stimuli, and markedly slowed channel inactivation. The same effects were seen in native PIEZO1 in N2A cells. STORM superresolution imaging revealed that, at the nanoscale, PIEZO1-GFP channels in the membrane associate as clusters sensitive to membrane manipulation. Both cluster distribution and diffusion rates were affected by treatment with MBCD (5 mM). Supplementation of polyunsaturated fatty acids appeared to sensitize the PIEZO1-GFP response to applied pressure. Together, our results indicate that PIEZO1 function is directly dependent on the membrane composition and lateral organization of membrane cholesterol domains, which coordinate the activity of clustered PIEZO1 channels.

The monomers, oligomers, and fibrils of amyloid-β inhibit the activity of mitoBKCa channels by a membrane-mediated mechanism

A causative agent of Alzheimer's disease (AD) is a short amphipathic peptide called amyloid beta (Aβ). Aβ monomers undergo structural changes leading to their oligomerization or fibrillization. The monomers as well as all aggregated forms of Aβ, i.e., oligomers, and fibrils, can bind to biological membranes, thereby modulating membrane mechanical properties. It is also known that some isoforms of the large-conductance calcium-activated potassium (BK_Ca) channel, including the mitochondrial BK_Ca (mitoBK_Ca) channel, respond to mechanical changes in the membrane. Here, using the patch-clamp technique, we investigated the impact of full-length Aβ (Aβ_1-42) and its fragment, Aβ_25-35, on the activity of mitoBK_Ca channels. We found that all forms of Aβ inhibited the activity of the mitoBK_Ca channel in a concentration-dependent manner. Since monomers, oligomers, and fibrils of Aβ exhibit different molecular characteristics and structures, we hypothesized that the inhibition was not due to direct peptide-protein interactions but rather to membrane-binding of the Aβ peptides. Our findings supported this hypothesis by showing that Aβ peptides block mitoBK_Ca channels irrespective of the side of the membrane to which they are applied. In addition, we found that the enantiomeric peptide, D-Aβ_1-42, demonstrated similar inhibitory activity towards mitoBK_Ca channels. As a result, we proposed a general model in which all Aβ forms i.e., monomers, oligomers, and amyloid fibrils, contribute to the progression of AD by exerting a modulatory effect on mechanosensitive membrane components.

Enantiomeric Aβ peptides inhibit the fluid shear stress response of PIEZO1

Traumatic brain injury (TBI) elevates Abeta (Aβ) peptides in the brain and cerebral spinal fluid. Aβ peptides are amphipathic molecules that can modulate membrane mechanics. Because the mechanosensitive cation channel PIEZO1 is gated by membrane tension and curvature, it prompted us to test the effects of Aβ on PIEZO1. Using precision fluid shear stress as a stimulus, we found that Aβ monomers inhibit PIEZO1 at femtomolar to picomolar concentrations. The Aβ oligomers proved much less potent. The effect of Aβs on Piezo gating did not involve peptide-protein interactions since the D and L enantiomers had similar effects. Incubating a fluorescent derivative of Aβ and a fluorescently tagged PIEZO1, we showed that Aβ can colocalize with PIEZO1, suggesting that they both had an affinity for particular regions of the bilayer. To better understand the PIEZO1 inhibitory effects of Aβ, we examined their effect on wound healing. We observed that over-expression of PIEZO1 in HEK293 cells increased cell migration velocity ~10-fold, and both enantiomeric Aβ peptides and GsMTx4 independently inhibited migration, demonstrating involvement of PIEZO1 in cell motility. As part of the motility study we examined the correlation of PIEZO1 function with tension in the cytoskeleton using a genetically encoded fluorescent stress probe. Aβ peptides increased resting stress in F-actin, and is correlated with Aβ block of PIEZO1-mediated Ca2+ influx. Aβ inhibition of PIEZO1 in the absence of stereospecific peptide-protein interactions shows that Aβ peptides modulate both cell membrane and cytoskeletal mechanics to control PIEZO1-triggered Ca2+ influx.

Asymmetric mechanosensitivity in a eukaryotic ion channel

Living organisms perceive and respond to a diverse range of mechanical stimuli. A variety of mechanosensitive ion channels have evolved to facilitate these responses, but the molecular mechanisms underlying their exquisite sensitivity to different forces within the membrane remains unclear. TREK-2 is a mammalian two-pore domain (K2P) K⁺ channel important for mechanosensation, and recent studies have shown how increased membrane tension favors a more expanded conformation of the channel within the membrane. These channels respond to a complex range of mechanical stimuli, however, and it is uncertain how differences in tension between the inner and outer leaflets of the membrane contribute to this process. To examine this, we have combined computational approaches with functional studies of oppositely oriented single channels within the same lipid bilayer. Our results reveal how the asymmetric structure of TREK-2 allows it to distinguish a broad profile of forces within the membrane, and illustrate the mechanisms that eukaryotic mechanosensitive ion channels may use to detect and fine-tune their responses to different mechanical stimuli.

The Kinetics and the Permeation Properties of Piezo Channels

Piezo channels are eukaryotic, cation-selective mechanosensitive channels (MSCs), which show rapid activation and voltage-dependent inactivation. The kinetics of these channels are largely consistent across multiple cell types and different stimulation paradigms with some minor variability. No accessory subunits that associate with Piezo channels have been reported. They are homotrimers and each ∼300kD monomer has an N-terminal propeller blade-like mechanosensing module, which can confer mechanosensing capabilities on ASIC-1 (the trimeric non-MSC, acid-sensing ion channel-1) and a C-terminal pore module, which influences conductance, selectivity, and channel inactivation. Repeated stimulation can cause domain fracture and diffusion of these channels leading to synchronous loss of inactivation. The reconstituted channels spontaneously open only in asymmetric bilayers but lack inactivation. Mutations that cause hereditary xerocytosis alter PIEZO1 kinetics. The kinetics of the wild-type PIEZO1 and alterations thereof in mutants (M2225R, R2456K, and DhPIEZO1) are summarized in the form of a quantitative model and hosted online. The pore is permeable to alkali ions although Li⁺ permeates poorly. Divalent cations, notably Ca²⁺, traverse the channel and inhibit the flux of monovalents. The large monovalent organic cations such as tetramethyl ammonium and tetraethyl ammonium can traverse the channel, but slowly, suggesting a pore diameter of ∼8Å, and the estimated in-plane area change upon opening is around 6-20nm². Ruthenium red can enter the channel only from the extracellular side and seems to bind in a pocket close to residue 2496.

GsMTx4: Mechanism of Inhibiting Mechanosensitive Ion Channels

GsMTx4 is a spider venom peptide that inhibits cationic mechanosensitive channels (MSCs). It has six lysine residues that have been proposed to affect membrane binding. We synthesized six analogs with single lysine-to-glutamate substitutions and tested them against Piezo1 channels in outside-out patches and independently measured lipid binding. Four analogs had ∼20% lower efficacy than the wild-type (WT) peptide. The equilibrium constants calculated from the rates of inhibition and washout did not correlate with the changes in inhibition. The lipid association strength of the WT GsMTx4 and the analogs was determined by tryptophan autofluorescence quenching and isothermal calorimetry with membrane vesicles and showed no significant differences in binding energy. Tryptophan fluorescence-quenching assays showed that both WT and analog peptides bound superficially near the lipid-water interface, although analogs penetrated deeper. Peptide-lipid association, as a function of lipid surface pressure, was investigated in Langmuir monolayers. The peptides occupied a large fraction of the expanded monolayer area, but that fraction was reduced by peptide expulsion as the pressure approached the monolayer-bilayer equivalence pressure. Analogs with compromised efficacy had pressure-area isotherms with steeper slopes in this region, suggesting tighter peptide association. The pressure-dependent redistribution of peptide between "deep" and "shallow" binding modes was supported by molecular dynamics (MD) simulations of the peptide-monolayer system under different area constraints. These data suggest a model placing GsMTx4 at the membrane surface, where it is stabilized by the lysines, and occupying a small fraction of the surface area in unstressed membranes. When applied tension reduces lateral pressure in the lipids, the peptides penetrate deeper acting as "area reservoirs" leading to partial relaxation of the outer monolayer, thereby reducing the effective magnitude of stimulus acting on the MSC gate.

Mechanical stress activates NMDA receptors in the absence of agonists

While studying the physiological response of primary rat astrocytes to fluid shear stress in a model of traumatic brain injury (TBI), we found that shear stress induced Ca2+ entry. The influx was inhibited by MK-801, a specific pore blocker of N-Methyl-D-aspartic acid receptor (NMDAR) channels, and this occurred in the absence of agonists. Other NMDA open channel blockers ketamine and memantine showed a similar effect. The competitive glutamate antagonists AP5 and GluN2B-selective inhibitor ifenprodil reduced NMDA-activated currents, but had no effect on the mechanically induced Ca2+ influx. Extracellular Mg2+ at 2 mM did not significantly affect the shear induced Ca2+ influx, but at 10 mM it produced significant inhibition. Patch clamp experiments showed mechanical activation of NMDAR and inhibition by MK-801. The mechanical sensitivity of NMDARs may play a role in the normal physiology of fluid flow in the glymphatic system and it has obvious relevance to TBI.

A general mechanism for drug promiscuity: Studies with amiodarone and other antiarrhythmics

Amiodarone is a widely prescribed antiarrhythmic drug used to treat the most prevalent type of arrhythmia, atrial fibrillation (AF). At therapeutic concentrations, amiodarone alters the function of many diverse membrane proteins, which results in complex therapeutic and toxicity profiles. Other antiarrhythmics, such as dronedarone, similarly alter the function of multiple membrane proteins, suggesting that a multipronged mechanism may be beneficial for treating AF, but raising questions about how these antiarrhythmics regulate a diverse range of membrane proteins at similar concentrations. One possible mechanism is that these molecules regulate membrane protein function by altering the common environment provided by the host lipid bilayer. We took advantage of the gramicidin (gA) channels' sensitivity to changes in bilayer properties to determine whether commonly used antiarrhythmics--amiodarone, dronedarone, propranolol, and pindolol, whose pharmacological modes of action range from multi-target to specific--perturb lipid bilayer properties at therapeutic concentrations. Using a gA-based fluorescence assay, we found that amiodarone and dronedarone are potent bilayer modifiers at therapeutic concentrations; propranolol alters bilayer properties only at supratherapeutic concentration, and pindolol has little effect. Using single-channel electrophysiology, we found that amiodarone and dronedarone, but not propranolol or pindolol, increase bilayer elasticity. The overlap between therapeutic and bilayer-altering concentrations, which is observed also using plasma membrane-like lipid mixtures, underscores the need to explore the role of the bilayer in therapeutic as well as toxic effects of antiarrhythmic agents.

Free Volume in Membranes: Viscosity or Tension?

Many papers have used fluorescent probe diffusion to infer membrane viscosity but the measurement is actually an assay of the free volume of the membrane. The free volume is also related to the membrane tension. Thus, changes in probe mobility refer equally well to changes in membrane tension. In complicated structures like cell membranes, it appears more intuitive to consider variations in free volume as referring to the effect of domains structures and interactions with the cytoskeleton than changes in viscosity since tension is a state variable and viscosity is not.