Distinct elongation stalls during translation are linked with distinct pathways for mRNA degradation

Translation elongation as a rate limiting step of protein production

The impact of synonymous codon choice on protein output has important implications for understanding endogenous gene expression and design of synthetic mRNAs. Synonymous codons are decoded at different speeds, but simple models predict that this should not drive protein output. Instead, translation initiation should be the rate limiting step for production of protein per mRNA, with little impact of codon choice. Previously, we used a neural network model to design a series of synonymous fluorescent reporters and showed that their protein output in yeast spanned a seven-fold range corresponding to their predicted translation elongation speed. Here, we show that this effect is not due primarily to the established impact of slow elongation on mRNA stability, but rather, that slow elongation further decreases the number of proteins made per mRNA. We combine simulations and careful experiments on fluorescent reporters to show that translation is limited on non-optimally encoded transcripts. Using a genome-wide CRISPRi screen, we find that impairing translation initiation attenuates the impact of slow elongation, showing a dynamic balance between rate limiting steps of protein production. Our results show that codon choice can directly limit protein production across the full range of endogenous variability in codon usage.

Comprehensive translational profiling and STE AI uncover rapid control of protein biosynthesis during cell stress

Translational control is important in all life, but it remains a challenge to accurately quantify. When ribosomes translate messenger (m)RNA into proteins, they attach to the mRNA in series, forming poly(ribo)somes, and can co-localize. Here, we computationally model new types of co-localized ribosomal complexes on mRNA and identify them using enhanced translation complex profile sequencing (eTCP-seq) based on rapid in vivo crosslinking. We detect long disome footprints outside regions of non-random elongation stalls and show these are linked to translation initiation and protein biosynthesis rates. We subject footprints of disomes and other translation complexes to artificial intelligence (AI) analysis and construct a new, accurate and self-normalized measure of translation, termed stochastic translation efficiency (STE). We then apply STE to investigate rapid changes to mRNA translation in yeast undergoing glucose depletion. Importantly, we show that, well beyond tagging elongation stalls, footprints of co-localized ribosomes provide rich insight into translational mechanisms, polysome dynamics and topology. STE AI ranks cellular mRNAs by absolute translation rates under given conditions, can assist in identifying its control elements and will facilitate the development of next-generation synthetic biology designs and mRNA-based therapeutics.

Massively parallel identification of sequence motifs triggering ribosome-associated mRNA quality control

Decay of mRNAs can be triggered by ribosome slowdown at stretches of rare codons or positively charged amino acids. However, the full diversity of sequences that trigger co-translational mRNA decay is poorly understood. To comprehensively identify sequence motifs that trigger mRNA decay, we use a massively parallel reporter assay to measure the effect of all possible combinations of codon pairs on mRNA levels in S. cerevisiae. In addition to known mRNA-destabilizing sequences, we identify several dipeptide repeats whose translation reduces mRNA levels. These include combinations of positively charged and bulky residues, as well as proline-glycine and proline-aspartate dipeptide repeats. Genetic deletion of the ribosome collision sensor Hel2 rescues the mRNA effects of these motifs, suggesting that they trigger ribosome slowdown and activate the ribosome-associated quality control (RQC) pathway. Deep mutational scanning of an mRNA-destabilizing dipeptide repeat reveals a complex interplay between the charge, bulkiness, and location of amino acid residues in conferring mRNA instability. Finally, we show that the mRNA effects of codon pairs are predictive of the effects of endogenous sequences. Our work highlights the complexity of sequence motifs driving co-translational mRNA decay in eukaryotes, and presents a high throughput approach to dissect their requirements at the codon level.

Orb2 enables rare-codon-enriched mRNA expression during Drosophila neuron differentiation

Regulation of codon optimality is an increasingly appreciated layer of cell- and tissue-specific protein expression control. Here, we use codon-modified reporters to show that differentiation of Drosophila neural stem cells into neurons enables protein expression from rare-codon-enriched genes. From a candidate screen, we identify the cytoplasmic polyadenylation element binding (CPEB) protein Orb2 as a positive regulator of rare-codon-dependent mRNA stability in neurons. Using RNA sequencing, we reveal that Orb2-upregulated mRNAs in the brain with abundant Orb2 binding sites have a rare-codon bias. From these Orb2-regulated mRNAs, we demonstrate that rare-codon enrichment is important for mRNA stability and social behavior function of the metabotropic glutamate receptor (mGluR). Our findings reveal a molecular mechanism by which neural stem cell differentiation shifts genetic code regulation to enable critical mRNA stability and protein expression.

The kinase Rio1 and a ribosome collision-dependent decay pathway survey the integrity of 18S rRNA cleavage

The 18S rRNA sequence is highly conserved, particularly at its 3'-end, which is formed by the endonuclease Nob1. How Nob1 identifies its target sequence is not known, and in vitro experiments have shown Nob1 to be error-prone. Moreover, the sequence around the 3'-end is degenerate with similar sites nearby. Here, we used yeast genetics, biochemistry, and next-generation sequencing to investigate a role for the ATPase Rio1 in monitoring the accuracy of the 18S rRNA 3'-end. We demonstrate that Nob1 can miscleave its rRNA substrate and that miscleaved rRNA accumulates upon bypassing the Rio1-mediated quality control (QC) step, but not in healthy cells with intact QC mechanisms. Mechanistically, we show that Rio1 binding to miscleaved rRNA is weaker than its binding to accurately processed 18S rRNA. Accordingly, excess Rio1 results in accumulation of miscleaved rRNA. Ribosomes containing miscleaved rRNA can translate, albeit more slowly, thereby inviting collisions with trailing ribosomes. These collisions result in degradation of the defective ribosomes utilizing parts of the machinery for mRNA QC. Altogether, the data support a model in which Rio1 inspects the 3'-end of the nascent 18S rRNA to prevent miscleaved 18S rRNA-containing ribosomes from erroneously engaging in translation, where they induce ribosome collisions. The data also demonstrate how ribosome collisions purify cells of altered ribosomes with different functionalities, with important implications for the concept of ribosome heterogeneity.

Mechanisms of Translation-coupled Quality Control

Stalling of ribosomes engaged in protein synthesis can lead to significant defects in the function of newly synthesized proteins and thereby impair protein homeostasis. Consequently, partially synthesized polypeptides resulting from translation stalling are recognized and eliminated by several quality control mechanisms. First, if translation elongation reactions are halted prematurely, a quality control mechanism called ribosome-associated quality control (RQC) initiates the ubiquitination of the nascent polypeptide chain and subsequent proteasomal degradation. Additionally, when ribosomes with defective codon recognition or peptide-bond formation stall during translation, a quality control mechanism known as non-functional ribosomal RNA decay (NRD) leads to the degradation of malfunctioning ribosomes. In both of these quality control mechanisms, E3 ubiquitin ligases selectively recognize ribosomes in distinct translation-stalling states and ubiquitinate specific ribosomal proteins. Significant efforts have been devoted to characterize E3 ubiquitin ligase sensing of ribosome 'collision' or 'stalling' and subsequent ribosome is rescued. This article provides an overview of our current understanding of the molecular mechanisms and physiological functions of ribosome dynamics control and quality control of abnormal translation.

Decoding the Heterogeneity and Specialized Function of Translation Machinery Through Ribosome Profiling in Yeast Mutants of Initiation Factors

The nuanced heterogeneity and specialized functions of translation machinery are increasingly recognized as crucial for precise translational regulation. Here, high-throughput ribosomal profiling (ribo-seq) is used to analyze the specialized roles of eukaryotic initiation factors (eIFs) in the budding yeast. By examining changes in ribosomal distribution across the genome resulting from knockouts of eIF4A, eIF4B, eIF4G1, CAF20, or EAP1, or knockdowns of eIF1, eIF1A, eIF4E, or PAB1, two distinct initiation-factor groups, the "looping" and "scanning" groups are discerned, based on similarities in the ribosomal landscapes their perturbation induced. The study delves into the cis-regulatory sequence features of genes influenced predominantly by each group, revealing that genes more dependent on the looping-group factors generally have shorter transcripts and poly(A) tails. In contrast, genes more dependent on the scanning-group factors often possess upstream open reading frames and exhibit a higher GC content in their 5' untranslated regions. From the ribosomal RNA fragments identified in the ribo-seq data, ribosomal heterogeneity associated with perturbation of specific initiation factors is further identified, suggesting their potential roles in regulating ribosomal components. Collectively, the study illuminates the complexity of translational regulation driven by heterogeneity and specialized functions of translation machinery, presenting potential approaches for targeted gene translation manipulation.

Synonymous codon usage regulates translation initiation

Nonoptimal synonymous codons repress gene expression, but the underlying mechanisms are poorly understood. We and others have previously shown that nonoptimal codons slow translation elongation speeds and thereby trigger messenger RNA (mRNA) degradation. Nevertheless, transcript levels are often insufficient to explain protein levels, suggesting additional mechanisms by which codon usage regulates gene expression. Using reporters in human and Drosophila cells, we find that transcript levels account for less than half of the variation in protein abundance due to codon usage. This discrepancy is explained by translational differences whereby nonoptimal codons repress translation initiation. Nonoptimal transcripts are also less bound by the translation initiation factors eIF4E and eIF4G1, providing a mechanistic explanation for their reduced initiation rates. Importantly, translational repression can occur without mRNA decay and deadenylation, and it does not depend on the known nonoptimality sensor, CNOT3. Our results reveal a potent mechanism of regulation by codon usage where nonoptimal codons repress further rounds of translation.

RNF14-dependent atypical ubiquitylation promotes translation-coupled resolution of RNA-protein crosslinks

Reactive aldehydes are abundant endogenous metabolites that challenge homeostasis by crosslinking cellular macromolecules. Aldehyde-induced DNA damage requires repair to prevent cancer and premature aging, but it is unknown whether cells also possess mechanisms that resolve aldehyde-induced RNA lesions. Here, we establish photoactivatable ribonucleoside-enhanced crosslinking (PAR-CL) as a model system to study RNA crosslinking damage in the absence of confounding DNA damage in human cells. We find that such RNA damage causes translation stress by stalling elongating ribosomes, which leads to collisions with trailing ribosomes and activation of multiple stress response pathways. Moreover, we discovered a translation-coupled quality control mechanism that resolves covalent RNA-protein crosslinks. Collisions between translating ribosomes and crosslinked mRNA-binding proteins trigger their modification with atypical K6- and K48-linked ubiquitin chains. Ubiquitylation requires the E3 ligase RNF14 and leads to proteasomal degradation of the protein adduct. Our findings identify RNA lesion-induced translational stress as a central component of crosslinking damage.

Quantification of elongation stalls and impact on gene expression in yeast

Ribosomal pauses are a critical part of cotranslational events including protein folding and localization. However, extended ribosome pauses can lead to ribosome collisions, resulting in the activation of ribosome rescue pathways and turnover of protein and mRNA. While this relationship has been known, there has been little exploration of how ribosomal stalls impact translation duration at a quantitative level. We have taken a method used to measure elongation time and adapted it for use in Saccharomyces cerevisiae to quantify the impact of elongation stalls. We find, in transcripts containing Arg CGA codon repeat-induced stalls, a Hel2-mediated dose-dependent decrease in protein expression and mRNA level and an elongation delay on the order of minutes. In transcripts that contain synonymous substitutions to nonoptimal Leu codons, there is a decrease in protein and mRNA levels, as well as similar elongation delay, but this occurs through a non-Hel2-mediated mechanism. Finally, we find that Dhh1 selectively increases protein expression, mRNA level, and elongation rate. This indicates that distinct poorly translated mRNAs will activate different rescue pathways despite similar elongation stall durations. Taken together, these results provide new quantitative mechanistic insight into the surveillance of translation and the roles of Hel2 and Dhh1 in mediating ribosome pausing events.

Proteostasis regulation through ribosome quality control and no-go-decay

Cell functionality relies on the existing pool of proteins and their folding into functional conformations. This is achieved through the regulation of protein synthesis, which requires error-free mRNAs and ribosomes. Ribosomes are quality control hubs for mRNAs and proteins. Problems during translation elongation slow down the decoding rate, leading to ribosome halting and the eventual collision with the next ribosome. Collided ribosomes form a specific disome structure recognized and solved by ribosome quality control (RQC) mechanisms. RQC pathways orchestrate the degradation of the problematic mRNA by no-go decay and the truncated nascent peptide, the repression of translation initiation, and the recycling of the stalled ribosomes. All these events maintain protein homeostasis and return valuable ribosomes to translation. As such, cell homeostasis and function are maintained at the mRNA level by preventing the production of aberrant or unnecessary proteins. It is becoming evident that the crosstalk between RQC and the protein homeostasis network is vital for cell function, as the absence of RQC components leads to the activation of stress response and neurodegenerative diseases. Here, we review the molecular events of RQC discovered through well-designed stalling reporters. Given the impact of RQC in proteostasis, we discuss the relevance of identifying endogenous mRNA regulated by RQC and their preservation in stress conditions. This article is categorized under: RNA Turnover and Surveillance > Turnover/Surveillance Mechanisms Translation > Regulation.

Is there a localized role for translational quality control?

It is known that mRNAs and the machinery that translates them are not uniformly distributed throughout the cytoplasm. As a result, the expression of some genes is localized to particular parts of the cell and this makes it possible to carry out important activities, such as growth and signaling, in three-dimensional space. However, the functions of localized gene expression are not fully understood, and the underlying mechanisms that enable localized expression have not been determined in many cases. One consideration that could help in addressing these challenges is the role of quality control (QC) mechanisms that monitor translating ribosomes. On a global level, QC pathways are critical for detecting aberrant translation events, such as a ribosome that stalls while translating, and responding by activating stress pathways and resolving problematic ribosomes and mRNAs at the molecular level. However, it is unclear how these pathways, even when uniformly active throughout the cell, affect local translation. Importantly, some QC pathways have themselves been reported to be enriched in the proximity of particular organelles, but the extent of such localized activity remains largely unknown. Here, we describe the major QC pathways and review studies that have begun to explore their roles in localized translation. Given the limited data in this area, we also pose broad questions about the possibilities and limitations for how QC pathways could facilitate localized gene expression in the cell with the goal of offering ideas for future experimentation.

Molecular Highway Patrol for Ribosome Collisions

During translation, messenger RNAs (mRNAs) are decoded by ribosomes which can stall for various reasons. These include chemical damage, codon composition, starvation, or translation inhibition. Trailing ribosomes can collide with stalled ribosomes, potentially leading to dysfunctional or toxic proteins. Such aberrant proteins can form aggregates and favor diseases, especially neurodegeneration. To prevent this, both eukaryotes and bacteria have evolved different pathways to remove faulty nascent peptides, mRNAs and defective ribosomes from the collided complex. In eukaryotes, ubiquitin ligases play central roles in triggering downstream responses and several complexes have been characterized that split affected ribosomes and facilitate degradation of the various components. As collided ribosomes signal translation stress to affected cells, in eukaryotes additional stress response pathways are triggered when collisions are sensed. These pathways inhibit translation and modulate cell survival and immune responses. Here, we summarize the current state of knowledge about rescue and stress response pathways triggered by ribosome collisions.

Translation-coupled mRNA quality control mechanisms

mRNA surveillance pathways are essential for accurate gene expression and to maintain translation homeostasis, ensuring the production of fully functional proteins. Future insights into mRNA quality control pathways will enable us to understand how cellular mRNA levels are controlled, how defective or unwanted mRNAs can be eliminated, and how dysregulation of these can contribute to human disease. Here we review translation-coupled mRNA quality control mechanisms, including the non-stop and no-go mRNA decay pathways, describing their mechanisms, shared trans-acting factors, and differences. We also describe advances in our understanding of the nonsense-mediated mRNA decay (NMD) pathway, highlighting recent mechanistic findings, the discovery of novel factors, as well as the role of NMD in cellular physiology and its impact on human disease.

Polysome propensity and tunable thresholds in coding sequence length enable differential mRNA stability

The half-life of mRNAs, as well as their translation, increases in proportion to the optimal codons, indicating a tight coupling of codon-dependent differential translation and degradation. Little is known about the regulation of this coupling. We found that the mRNA stability gain in yeast depends on the mRNA coding sequence length. Below a critical length, codon optimality fails to affect the stability of mRNAs although they can be efficiently translated into short peptides and proteins. Above this threshold length, codon optimality-dependent differential mRNA stability emerges in a switch-like fashion, which coincides with a similar increase in the polysome propensity of the mRNAs. This threshold length can be tuned by the untranslated regions (UTR). Some of these UTRs can destabilize mRNAs without reducing translation, which plays a role in controlling the amplitude of the oscillatory expression of cell cycle genes. Our findings help understand the translation of short peptides from noncoding RNAs and the translation by localized monosomes in neurons.

Massively parallel identification of sequence motifs triggering ribosome-associated mRNA quality control

Decay of mRNAs can be triggered by ribosome slowdown at stretches of rare codons or positively charged amino acids. However, the full diversity of sequences that trigger co-translational mRNA decay is poorly understood. To comprehensively identify sequence motifs that trigger mRNA decay, we use a massively parallel reporter assay to measure the effect of all possible combinations of codon pairs on mRNA levels in S. cerevisiae. In addition to known mRNA-destabilizing sequences, we identify several dipeptide repeats whose translation reduces mRNA levels. These include combinations of positively charged and bulky residues, as well as proline-glycine and proline-aspartate dipeptide repeats. Genetic deletion of the ribosome collision sensor Hel2 rescues the mRNA effects of these motifs, suggesting that they trigger ribosome slowdown and activate the ribosome-associated quality control (RQC) pathway. Deep mutational scanning of an mRNA-destabilizing dipeptide repeat reveals a complex interplay between the charge, bulkiness, and location of amino acid residues in conferring mRNA instability. Finally, we show that the mRNA effects of codon pairs are predictive of the effects of endogenous sequences. Our work highlights the complexity of sequence motifs driving co-translational mRNA decay in eukaryotes, and presents a high throughput approach to dissect their requirements at the codon level.

Specific recognition and ubiquitination of translating ribosomes by mammalian CCR4-NOT

Translation affects messenger RNA stability and, in yeast, this is mediated by the Ccr4-Not deadenylation complex. The details of this process in mammals remain unclear. Here, we use cryogenic electron microscopy (cryo-EM) and crosslinking mass spectrometry to show that mammalian CCR4-NOT specifically recognizes ribosomes that are stalled during translation elongation in an in vitro reconstituted system with rabbit and human components. Similar to yeast, mammalian CCR4-NOT inserts a helical bundle of its CNOT3 subunit into the empty E site of the ribosome. Our cryo-EM structure shows that CNOT3 also locks the L1 stalk in an open conformation to inhibit further translation. CCR4-NOT is required for stable association of the nonconstitutive subunit CNOT4, which ubiquitinates the ribosome, likely to signal stalled translation elongation. Overall, our work shows that human CCR4-NOT not only detects but also enforces ribosomal stalling to couple translation and mRNA decay.

Control of mRNA fate by its encoded nascent polypeptide

Cells tightly regulate mRNA processing, localization, and stability to ensure accurate gene expression in diverse cellular states and conditions. Most of these regulatory steps have traditionally been thought to occur before translation by the action of RNA-binding proteins. Several recent discoveries highlight multiple co-translational mechanisms that modulate mRNA translation, localization, processing, and stability. These mechanisms operate by recognition of the nascent protein, which is necessarily coupled to its encoding mRNA during translation. Hence, the distinctive sequence or structure of a particular nascent chain can recruit recognition factors with privileged access to the corresponding mRNA in an otherwise crowded cellular environment. Here, we draw on both well-established and recent examples to provide a conceptual framework for how cells exploit nascent protein recognition to direct mRNA fate. These mechanisms allow cells to dynamically and specifically regulate their transcriptomes in response to changes in cellular states to maintain protein homeostasis.

Orb2 enables rare-codon-enriched mRNA expression during Drosophila neuron differentiation

Regulation of codon optimality is an increasingly appreciated layer of cell- and tissue-specific protein expression control. Here, we use codon-modified reporters to show that differentiation of Drosophila neural stem cells into neurons enables protein expression from rare-codon-enriched genes. From a candidate screen, we identify the cytoplasmic polyadenylation element binding (CPEB) protein Orb2 as a positive regulator of rare-codon-dependent expression in neurons. Using RNA sequencing, we reveal that Orb2-upregulated mRNAs in the brain with abundant Orb2 binding sites have a rare-codon bias. From these Orb2-regulated mRNAs, we demonstrate that rare-codon enrichment is important for expression control and social behavior function of the metabotropic glutamate receptor (mGluR). Our findings reveal a molecular mechanism by which neural stem cell differentiation shifts genetic code regulation to enable critical mRNA and protein expression.

The ribosome quality control factor Asc1 determines the fate of HSP70 mRNA on and off the ribosome

Cells survive harsh environmental conditions by potently upregulating molecular chaperones such as heat shock proteins (HSPs), particularly the inducible members of the HSP70 family. The life cycle of HSP70 mRNA in the cytoplasm is unique-it is translated during stress when most cellular mRNA translation is repressed and rapidly degraded upon recovery. Contrary to its 5' untranslated region's role in maximizing translation, we discovered that the HSP70 coding sequence (CDS) suppresses its translation via the ribosome quality control (RQC) mechanism. The CDS of the most inducible Saccharomyces cerevisiae HSP70 gene, SSA4, is uniquely enriched with low-frequency codons that promote ribosome stalling during heat stress. Stalled ribosomes are recognized by the RQC components Asc1p and Hel2p and two novel RQC components, the ribosomal proteins Rps28Ap and Rps19Bp. Surprisingly, RQC does not signal SSA4 mRNA degradation via No-Go-Decay. Instead, Asc1p destabilizes SSA4 mRNA during recovery from heat stress by a mechanism independent of ribosome binding and SSA4 codon optimality. Therefore, Asc1p operates in two pathways that converge to regulate the SSA4 mRNA life cycle during stress and recovery. Our research identifies Asc1p as a critical regulator of the stress response and RQC as the mechanism tuning HSP70 synthesis.

Quantification of elongation stalls and impact on gene expression in yeast

Ribosomal pauses are a critical part of co-translational events including protein folding and localization. However, extended ribosome pauses can lead to ribosome collisions, resulting in the activation of ribosome rescue pathways and turnover of protein and mRNA. While this relationship has been known, the specific threshold between permissible pausing versus activation of rescue pathways has not been quantified. We have taken a method used to measure elongation time and adapted it for use in S. cerevisiae to quantify the impact of elongation stalls. We find, in transcripts containing Arg CGA codon repeat-induced stalls, a Hel2-mediated dose-dependent decrease in protein expression and mRNA level and an elongation delay on the order of minutes. In transcripts that contain synonymous substitutions to non-optimal Leu codons, there is a decrease in protein and mRNA levels, as well as similar elongation delay, but this occurs through a non-Hel2-mediated mechanism. Finally, we find that Dhh1 selectively increases protein expression, mRNA level, and elongation rate. This indicates that distinct poorly translated codons in an mRNA will activate different rescue pathways despite similar elongation stall durations. Taken together, these results provide new quantitative mechanistic insight into the surveillance of translation and the roles of Hel2 and Dhh1 in mediating ribosome pausing events.

Co-Translational Quality Control Induced by Translational Arrest

Genetic mutations, mRNA processing errors, and lack of availability of charged tRNAs sometimes slow down or completely stall translating ribosomes. Since an incomplete nascent chain derived from stalled ribosomes may function anomalously, such as by forming toxic aggregates, surveillance systems monitor every step of translation and dispose of such products to prevent their accumulation. Over the past decade, yeast models with powerful genetics and biochemical techniques have contributed to uncovering the mechanism of the co-translational quality control system, which eliminates the harmful products generated from aberrant translation. We here summarize the current knowledge of the molecular mechanism of the co-translational quality control systems in yeast, which eliminate the incomplete nascent chain, improper mRNAs, and faulty ribosomes to maintain cellular protein homeostasis.