A Multicenter Study of Clinical to Planning Target Volume Margins for Adjuvant Partial Breast Irradiation Delivered on the 1.5T MR-Linear Accelerator

PURPOSE/OBJECTIVE(S)

Adjuvant partial breast irradiation (APBI) for early-stage breast cancer patients delivered on a conventional Linac commonly uses a clinical to planning target volume (CTV-PTV) margin of 10 mm. Published data suggest this margin could be reduced using an MR-guided workflow. This study quantifies the CTV to PTV margin for APBI delivered on the 1.5T MR-Linac (MRL) using an Adapt to Position (ATP) workflow.

MATERIALS/METHODS

All target contouring was done as per the IMPORT LOW trial and MRL Consortium guidelines. The CTV is the tumor bed defined by surgical clips including postsurgical changes. A single center cohort of ten patients was used to assess delineation error on ProKnow DS v1.28.0 by measuring CTV contour displacements on the CT planning scans (pCT) delineated by five breast radiation oncologists. All other error components were measured on treatment planning software on another single center cohort of ten patients. Target deformation error was measured as surgical clip displacements between the pCT and daily pre-treatment (pre-Tx) MRI scans. Intrafraction motion was determined by the CTV displacement between pre- and post-treatment MRIs (post-Tx) in available paired images from five patients. Matching error was estimated as the interobserver variation of three MRL radiographers registering the pCT with daily pre-Tx MRI. Technical delivery accuracy was estimated using the results from routine quality assurance measurements. Beam penumbral width (p) was estimated from the clinical treatment plans. The systematic (Σ) and random errors (σ) for each component were calculated in the left/right (X), superior/inferior (Y) and anterior/posterior (Z) directions. The contribution of these errors to the PTV margin, M was calculated using van Herk's formula with α and β being 2.50 and 1.64 respectively.

RESULTS

For APBI using an MRL ATP workflow, a CTV-PTV margin of 5.7 to 7.6 mm is required to achieve a 90% confidence of CTV coverage by the 95% isodose. Individual error components are in. Table 1 delineation error remains the largest component of error.

CONCLUSION

A minimum CTV-PTV margin of 6-8 mm is required for APBI using an MRL ATP workflow. Although smaller than margins used in conventional Linacs, the clinical benefits (in terms of fibrosis risk) of treating APBI patients on an MRL are likely to be modest. Further margin reductions may be possible using an "Adapt to Shape" workflow with daily online recontouring.

Complexity of the Culex pipiens complex in California

In California, the Culex pipiens complex consists of Culex pipiens, Cx. quinquefasciatus, their hybrids and Culex pipiens form molestus. Using 15 microsatellite markers and a variety of statistical analyses of within- and among-population variation, there is widespread introgression throughout the Central Valley with mostly quinquefasciatus genotypes in the south and pipiens in the north. Those specimens in the Sacramento County area consisted primarily of pipiens-quinquefasciatus and pipiens-molestus hybrids. Populations in Coachella Valley and Los Angeles, CA and Benton, WA were Cx. quinquefasciatus and Cx. pipiens, respectively. Studies are underway to relate these genotypes to phenotypes of autogeny, diapause and vector competence for West Nile Virus.