Operationalizing anthropological theory: four techniques to simplify networks of co-occurring ethnographic codes

The use of data and algorithms in the social sciences allows for exciting progress, but also poses epistemological challenges. Operations that appear innocent and purely technical may profoundly influence final results. Researchers working with data can make their process less arbitrary and more accountable by making theoretically grounded methodological choices. We apply this approach to the problem of simplifying networks representing ethnographic corpora, in the interest of visual interpretation. Network nodes represent ethnographic codes, and their edges the co-occurrence of codes in a corpus. We introduce and discuss four techniques to simplify such networks and facilitate visual analysis. We show how the mathematical characteristics of each one are aligned with an identifiable approach in sociology or anthropology: structuralism and post-structuralism; identifying the central concepts in a discourse; and discovering hegemonic and counter-hegemonic clusters of meaning. We then provide an example of how the four techniques complement each other in ethnographic analysis.

Online community management as social network design: testing for the signature of management activities in online communities

Online communities are used across several fields of human activities, as environments for large-scale collaboration. Most successful ones employ professionals, sometimes called "community managers" or "moderators", for tasks including onboarding new participants, mediating conflict, and policing unwanted behaviour. Network scientists routinely model interaction across participants in online communities as social networks. We interpret the activity of community managers as (social) network design: they take action oriented at shaping the network of interactions in a way conducive to their community's goals. It follows that, if such action is successful, we should be able to detect its signature in the network itself. Growing networks where links are allocated by a preferential attachment mechanism are known to converge to networks displaying a power law degree distribution. Growth and preferential attachment are both reasonable first-approximation assumptions to describe interaction networks in online communities. Our main hypothesis is that managed online communities are characterised by in-degree distributions that deviate from the power law form; such deviation constitutes the signature of successful community management. Our secondary hypothesis is that said deviation happens in a predictable way, once community management practices are accounted for. If true, these hypotheses would give us a simple test for the effectiveness of community management practices. We investigate the issue using (1) empirical data on three small online communities and (2) a computer model that simulates a widely used community management activity called onboarding. We find that onboarding produces in-degree distributions that systematically deviate from power law behaviour for low-values of the in-degree; we then explore the implications and possible applications of the finding.

Aspartate 351 of estrogen receptor alpha is not crucial for the antagonist activity of antiestrogens

The antagonist activity of antiestrogens is due to the presence of a long carbon side chain at positions 7alpha or 11beta or equivalent on their steroid or steroid-like skeletons. These side chains establish hydrophobic interactions with amino acids of the estrogen receptor alpha (ERalpha) ligand binding domain. In addition, a hydrogen bond formed between amino acid Asp-351 and the tertiary amine present at the end of the side chain of partial antiestrogens is considered to be crucial for their antiestrogenicity. Here, we have investigated the role of Asp-351 in antiestrogen action in transiently transfected HeLa and MDA-MB-231 cells. Our results indicate that disruption of the negative charge at position 351 does not increase the agonist activity of partial antiestrogens and thus that the hydrogen bond with the antiestrogen side chain is not determinant in positioning the side chain in an antagonist position. The negative charge at position 351 was not required for transcriptional activity in the presence of hormone, but its presence was necessary for basal activity of the wild-type receptor and constitutive activities of mutants L536P and Y537A, suggesting a role of Asp-351 in stabilizing the active conformation of ERalpha. This stabilizing role of Asp-351 could be due to interaction of Asp-351 with the amide group of the peptide bond between Leu-539 and Leu-540 in helix 12 observed in the active conformation of the ERalpha ligand binding domain.

[How to prevent post-traumatic stress disorder before traumatization occurs?]

OBJECTIVE

To provide an update on methods of preventing the onset of posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) before trauma occurs.

METHOD

Survey and analysis of the literature (mainly articles) found in the Medline, Psychinfo, and Pilot databases.

RESULTS

Most research focuses on identifying risk factors and reinforcing individual resistance as the prime means of preventing PTSD. The severity of the trauma is by far the most serious risk factor. To reinforce resistance and prevent the onset of PTSD, the army has favoured psychoeducational approaches. However, the literature survey has found no pretrauma prevention program for other high-risk occupations.

CONCLUSION

The usefulness of identified risk factors for the primary prevention of PTSD is limited, since with the exception of the trauma itself, they play a minor role on the onset of severe-trauma PTSD. Psychoeducational approaches aimed at reinforcing the resistance of individuals at risk are promising, but their potential has to be further explored in individuals in high-risk trades. Finally, it has been suggested that other avenues of research in the primary prevention (pretrauma) of PTSD be explored. These include the identification of possible protection factors, the influence of genetic make-up and of biological variables, the cumulative effects of exposure to stressors, and the presence of chronic stressors.

[Dangers and therapist obligations: Canadian perspective]

OBJECTIVE

To clarify the position Canadian therapists must adopt regarding their obligation to protect others against patients' potentially violent actions. This obligation is based on jurisprudence which has been well established in the United States since the Tarasoff case, but which does not apply in Canada.

METHOD

A review of jurisprudence in Canada and recent clinical recommendations. The latter are then discussed in the Canadian context and followed by a range of suggested avenues to explore.

CONCLUSION

Professional standards could be established but they should be reviewed on a regular basis and allow flexibility for clinicians.