Feasibility of Dose Escalation in Patients With Intracranial Pediatric Ependymoma

Background and purpose: Pediatric ependymoma carries a dismal prognosis, mainly owing to local relapse within RT fields. The current prospective European approach is to increase the radiation dose with a sequential hypofractionated stereotactic boost. In this study, we assessed the possibility of using a simultaneous integrated boost (SIB), comparing VMAT vs. IMPT dose delivery.

Material and methods: The cohort included 101 patients. The dose to planning target volume (PTV59.4) was 59.4/1.8 Gy, and the dose to SIB volume (PTV67.6) was 67.6/2.05 Gy. Gross tumor volume (GTV) was defined as the tumor bed plus residual tumor, clinical target volume (CTV59.4) was GTV + 5 mm, and PTV59.4 was CTV59.4 + 3 mm. PTV67.6 was GTV+ 3 mm. After treatment plan optimization, quality indices and doses to target volume and organs at risk (OARs) were extracted and compared with the standard radiation doses that were actually delivered (median = 59.4 Gy [50.4 59.4]).

Results: In most cases, the proton treatment resulted in higher quality indices (p < 0.001). Compared with the doses that were initially delivered, mean, and maximum doses to some OARs were no higher with SIB VMAT, and significantly lower with protons (p < 0.001). In the case of posterior fossa tumor, there was a lower dose to the brainstem with protons, in terms of V59 Gy, mean, and near-maximum (D2%) doses.

Conclusion: Dose escalation with intensity-modulated proton or photon SIB is feasible in some patients. This approach could be considered for children with unresectable residue or post-operative FLAIR abnormalities, particularly if they have supratentorial tumors. It should not be considered for infratentorial tumors encasing the brainstem or extending to the medulla.

[Re-irradiation of head and neck cancers: Target volumes, technical evolutions and prospects]

Malignant tumors of the head and neck have a predominantly regional recurrence pattern, with most deaths resulting from this progression. Optimization of re-radiation in recurrence setting is a major objective for these patients. Extensive research has been carried out with the PubMed search engine to find publications dealing with this topic. The first attempts to reirradiate the ORL sphere date back to the 1980s and the first to be performed by intensity modulation conformational radiotherapy (IMRT) date back to the late 1990s. Compared to 3 dimensional conformal radiotherapy, IMRT improves clinical outcomes and reduces toxicity. In IMRT series, associated or not with concomitant chemotherapy, the locoregional control obtained at 2 years was of the order of 45 to 65% and the overall survival of 15 to 60%, depending on predictive factors. Grade 3 acute toxicity occurred on the order of 10 to 30% and late-grade 3 toxicity on the order of 15 to 50%. In a selected population with low volumes tumors, stereotactic re-irradiation at a minimum dose of 35Gy obtained outcome comparable to IMRT. Re-irradiation of head and neck tumors by proton therapy is rare. The toxicity rate appears to be lower than that usually seen after photon therapy. However, we do not have a long follow-up. This technique therefore remains reserved for search protocols and represents a future perspective in these situations.

Pseudoprogression after high-dose busulfan-thiotepa with autologous stem cell transplantation and radiation therapy in children with brain tumors: Impact on survival

Children with a brain tumor treated with high-dose busulfan-thiotepa with autologous stem cell transplantation (ASCT) and radiation therapy (RT) often experience radiographic changes during follow-up. The purpose of the study was to identify the incidence, time course, risk factors, and clinical outcome of this complication. From May 1988 through May 2007, 110 patients (median age, 3.6 years; range, 1 month to 15.3 years) with a brain tumor had received 1 course of high-dose busulfan-thiotepa with stem cell rescue, followed or preceded by RT as part of their treatment. All MRI follow-up examinations were systematically reviewed. Twenty-three patients (21%) developed neuroradiological abnormalities at a median time of 9.2 months (range, 5.6-17.3 months) after ASCT. All contrast-enhancing lesions appeared in patients who had received RT after ASCT and were localized inside the 50-55Gy isodoses. They disappeared in 14 of 23 patients after a median time of 8 months (range, 3-17 months), leaving microcalcifications in some cases. The presence of MRI abnormalities was an independent prognostic factor for overall survival in the multivariate analysis (hazard ratio, 0.12; 95% confidence interval [CI], 0.04-0.33), with a 5-year overall survival rate of 84% among patients with MRI abnormalities (95% CI, 62-94), compared with 27% (95% CI, 19-37) among those without lesions. MRI-detectable pseudoprogression is a common early finding in children treated with high-dose busulfan-thiotepa followed by radiation therapy and is correlated with a better outcome.

Clinical features and treatment of pediatric somatotropinoma: case study of an aggressive tumor due to a new AIP mutation and extensive literature review

CONTEXT

Pediatric somatotropinoma is uncommon but usually more aggressive than in adults, creating therapeutic challenges. No treatment guidelines are available.

OBJECTIVES

To describe the features of pediatric somatotropinomas and to assess therapeutic strategies based on an extensive literature review.

DESIGN

We describe a pediatric case of aggressive somatotropinoma with an AIP mutation. We identified 137 pediatric somatotropinoma cases published between 1981 and 2010, and found 41 cases with AIP mutations in the main review.

RESULTS

We found a slight male preponderance (59%). Median age was 9 years at symptom onset and 14 years at diagnosis. Macroadenomas accounted for 90% of the tumors; 2/3 of the children had hyperprolactinemia at diagnosis. The first-line treatment was pharmacotherapy in one third and surgery in 2/3 of the patients. Pegvisomant was used in 7 patients and produced significant improvement in 4. The male preponderance was higher in the subgroup with AIP mutations. Mutations leading to severe protein abnormalities were more common than reported in adults.

CONCLUSION

Higher invasiveness and tumor volume in pediatric somatotropinomas require complex treatment combinations, which produce variable results. Pegvisomant is an effective drug whose usefulness in children remains to be determined. Genetic screening, particularly for AIP mutations, should be performed routinely.

Hypofractionated radiotherapy in the treatment of diffuse intrinsic pontine glioma in children: a single institution's experience

We report herein our institutional experience in the treatment of diffuse intrinsic pontine glioma (DIPG) with a hypofractionated external-beam radiotherapy schedule. Between April 1996 and January 2004, 22 patients (age 2.9-12.5 years) with newly diagnosed DIPG were treated by hypofractionated radiation therapy delivering a total dose of 45 Gy in daily fractions of 3 Gy, given over 3 weeks. No other treatment was applied concomitantly. Fourteen of the 22 patients received the prescribed dose of 45 Gy in 15 fractions of 3 Gy, and 2 patients received a total dose of 60 and 45 Gy with a combination of two different beams (photons and neutrons). In five cases the daily fraction was modified to 2 Gy due to intolerance, and one patient died due to serious intracranial hypertension after two fractions of 3 Gy and one of 2 Gy. Among 22 children, 14 patients showed clinical improvement, usually starting in the second week of treatment. No grade 3 or 4 acute toxicity from radiotherapy was observed. No treatment interruption was needed. In six patients, steroids could be discontinued within 1 month after the end of radiotherapy. Median time to progression and median overall survival were 5.7 months and 7.6 months, respectively. External radiotherapy with a radical hypofractionated regimen is feasible and well tolerated in children with newly diagnosed DIPG. However, this regimen does not seem to change overall survival in this setting. It could represent a short-duration alternative to more protracted regimens.

Pattern of relapse and outcome of non-metastatic germinoma patients treated with chemotherapy and limited field radiation: the SFOP experience

Over the last two decades, chemotherapy has been introduced in protocols for patients with intracranial germinoma with the objective of reducing the volume and the dose of irradiation without compromising survival rates. The aim of this work is to critically analyze the pattern of relapse in a cohort of patients with nonmetastatic germinoma prospectively treated with chemotherapy followed by focal field radiation. Data of all germinoma patients registered in the French protocol for intracranial germ cell tumors between 1990 and 1999 were reviewed. The pattern of relapse, management, and outcome were analyzed in 10 of 60 patients who developed a recurrence after initial treatment. In 9 patients, the site of recurrence was local or loco-regional, notably in the periventricular area for 8. One patient only had isolated distant leptomeningeal relapse. The review of the sites of relapse suggests that most recurrences could have been avoided with a larger ventricular field of radiation. Treatment at first relapse included chemotherapy (10 patients), high-dose chemotherapy and stem cell transplant (8 patients), and/or radiation therapy (4 patients). Five patients experienced a second relapse. At a median follow-up of 72 months since the first relapse, 8 patients are alive in second or third remission. This review identified an excess of periventricular relapses when the focal field of radiation is used in the combined management of germinoma. These relapses are predominantly marginal or outside radiation fields. Ventricular field radiation appears a logical alternative to decrease the incidence of such relapses. Future trials should aim at better identifying patients who may benefit from local and ventricular radiation, respectively.

Online quality control, hyperfractionated radiotherapy alone and reduced boost volume for standard risk medulloblastoma: long-term results of MSFOP 98

PURPOSE

To determine event free and overall survival, and long-term cognitive sequelae of children with standard-risk medulloblastoma (SRM) treated with hyperfractionated radiotherapy, conformal reduced boost volume without chemotherapy, and online quality assurance.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Forty-eight patients (age 5 to 18 years) were included in the Medulloblastoma-Société Française d'Oncologie Pédiatrique (MSFOP 98) protocol (December 1998 to October 2001). Patients received hyperfractionated radiotherapy (HFRT; 36 Gy, 1 Gy/fraction twice per day) to the craniospinal axis followed by a boost to the tumor bed (1.5-cm margin) to a dose of 68 Gy. Records of craniospinal irradiation were reviewed before treatment started. Neuropsychologic evaluations were done according to the protocol (1, 3, 5, and 7 years after irradiation). Cognitive outcomes were followed longitudinally with full-scale intelligence quotient (FSIQ) obtained with age-adapted Wechsler scales.

RESULTS

After a median follow-up of 77.7 months, 6-year overall survival (OS) and event-free survival (EFS) rates for the cohort were 78% (95% CI, 66% to 90%) and 75%, respectively (95% CI, 62% to 87%). Thanks to quality control, 14 major deviations were detected. Annual full scale IQ decline was 2 points over a 6-year period. Predicted change in FSIQ points per year was 2.15 (95% CI, -1.24 to 3.51) with an intercept (ie, predicted FSIQ) of 93.57 at baseline.

CONCLUSION

HFRT protocol with conformal reduced boost and online quality control allows excellent long-term OS and EFS in the absence of chemotherapy. In addition, FSIQ drops seem to be less pronounced than previously reported with standard irradiation regimens.

High-dose busulfan and thiotepa followed by autologous stem cell transplantation (ASCT) in previously irradiated medulloblastoma patients: high toxicity and lack of efficacy

We previously demonstrated that Busulfan-Thiotepa (Bu-Thio) and ASCT effectively treated patients with locally relapsed medulloblastoma after surgery and conventional chemotherapy. We thus evaluated the administration of Bu-Thio in patients relapsing after conventional CNS irradiation. Patients were scheduled to receive Busulfan (600 mg/m(2)) and Thiotepa (900 mg/m(2)) and ASCT. Resection of residual tumour and additional irradiation were performed if necessary and feasible after Bu-Thio. Toxicity was compared to that observed in 35 patients treated without previous CNS irradiation. From 5/88 to 3/02, 15 patients were treated according to this strategy. Toxicity was significantly higher than that observed in unirradiated patients: thrombocytopenia <50,000/mm(3) lasting 56 days (13-732) (P=0.02) and 30 days (4-124), respectively, HVOD (10/15 and 12/35 patients, respectively) (P=0.06), neurological toxicity (8/15 vs 3/35 patients) (P=0.01). Tumour response was assessable in seven patients and consisted in two CR, three PR and two NR. Currently, two of 15 patients are alive with no evidence of disease. In conclusion, the toxicity of Bu-Thio was significantly more severe in previously irradiated patients. In spite of a high response rate, this strategy failed to improve the prognosis of previously irradiated patients with a relapse from a medulloblastoma.

Treatment of nonmetastatic rhabdomyosarcoma in childhood and adolescence: third study of the International Society of Paediatric Oncology--SIOP Malignant Mesenchymal Tumor 89

PURPOSE

To improve outcome for children with nonmetastatic rhabdomyosarcoma and to reduce systematic use of local therapy.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Five hundred three previously untreated patients aged from birth to 18 years, recruited between 1989 and 1995, were allocated to one of six treatment schedules by site and stage.

RESULTS

Five-year overall survival (OS) and event-free survival (EFS) were 71% and 57%, respectively. Primary site, T-stage, and pathologic subtype were independent factors in predicting OS by multivariate analysis. Differences between EFS and OS reflected local treatment strategy and successful re-treatment for some patients after relapse. Patients with genitourinary nonbladder prostate tumors had the most favorable outcome (5-year OS, 94%): the majority were boys with paratesticular tumors treated successfully without alkylating agents. Patients with stage III disease treated with a novel six-drug combination showed improved survival compared with the Malignant Mesenchymal Tumor 84 study (MMT 84; 5-year OS, 60% v 42%, respectively). OS was not significantly better than that achieved in the previous MMT 84 study, but 49% of survivors were cured without significant local therapy.

CONCLUSION

Selective avoidance of local therapy is justified in some patients, though further work is required to prospectively identify those for whom this is most applicable. Exclusion of alkylating agents is justified for the most favorable subset of patients. The value of the new six-drug chemotherapy combination is being evaluated further in a randomized study (MMT 95).

[Post-radiotherapy hyperthyroidism: a rare complication of cancer treatment in the child]

Abnormalities of thyroid function, specially hypothyroidism, are common complications of head and neck irradiation for childhood cancer. Hyperthyroidism is rare and can be misdiagnosed. We report two observations of this condition.

OBSERVATIONS

The first patient received conventional craniospinal irradiation for a localized medulloblastoma. Three years later, he presented with profuse sweating, irritability and paroxysmal tachycardia. Biologic evaluation revealed a peripheral hyperthyroidism. The patient was treated with antithyroidian hormonal treatment. The second patient received an irradiation for an undifferentiated nasopharyngeal carcinoma. Three years later, she developed a progressive thyrotoxicosis which was attributed to hyperthyroidism after six months of evolution. Hormonal treatment improved the clinical state after several weeks.

CONCLUSION

Hyperthyroidism is a rare complication of head and neck irradiation. This condition justifies a periodic and prolonged evaluation of thyroid function.

[Determination of target volume in pediatric radiotherapy: application to brain tumors]

Pediatric tumors have enjoyed considerable improvements for the past 30 years. This is mainly due to the extensive use of combined therapeutical modalities in which chemotherapy plays a prominent role. In many children, local treatment including radiotherapy, can nowadays be adapted in terms of target volume and dose to the "response" to an initial course of chemotherapy almost on a case by case basis. This makes precise recommendation on local therapy highly difficult in this age group. We will concentrate in this paper on brain tumors in which chemotherapy is of limited value and radiotherapy still plays a key-role.

Combination of photon and proton radiation therapy for chordomas and chondrosarcomas of the skull base: the Centre de Protonthérapie D'Orsay experience

PURPOSE

Prospective analysis of local tumor control, survival, and treatment complications in 44 consecutive patients treated with fractionated photon and proton radiation for a chordoma or chondrosarcoma of the skull base.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Between December 1995 and December 1998, 45 patients with a median age of 55 years (14-85) were treated using a 201-MeV proton beam at the Centre de Protonthérapie d'Orsay, 34 for a chordoma and 11 for a chondrosarcoma. Irradiation combined high-energy photons and protons. Photons represented two-thirds of the total dose and protons one-third. The median total dose delivered within the gross tumor volume was 67 cobalt Gray equivalent (CGE) (range: 60-70).

RESULTS

With a mean follow-up of 30.5 months (range: 2-56), the 3-year local control rates for chordomas and chondrosarcomas were 83.1% and 90%, respectively, and 3-year overall survival rates were 91% and 90%, respectively. Eight patients (18%) failed locally (7 within the clinical tumor volume and 1 unknown). Four patients died of tumor and 2 others of intercurrent disease. In univariate analysis, young age at time of radiotherapy influenced local control positively (p < 0.03), but not in multivariate analysis. Only 2 patients presented Grade 3 or 4 complications.

CONCLUSION

In skull-base chordomas and chondrosarcomas, the combination of photons with a proton boost of one-third the total dose offers an excellent chance of cure at the price of an acceptable toxicity. These results should be confirmed with a longer follow-up.

Postoperative chemotherapy without irradiation for ependymoma in children under 5 years of age: a multicenter trial of the French Society of Pediatric Oncology

PURPOSE

To evaluate a strategy that avoids radiotherapy in first-line treatment in children under 5 years of age with brain or posterior fossa ependymoma, by exclusively administering 16 months of adjuvant multiagent chemotherapy after surgery.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Between June 1990 and October 1998, 73 children with ependymoma (82% with high-grade tumors) were enrolled onto this multicenter trial. Children received adjuvant conventional chemotherapy after surgery consisting of seven cycles of three courses alternating two drugs at each course (procarbazine and carboplatin, etoposide and cisplatin, vincristine and cyclophosphamide) over a year and a half. Systematic irradiation was not envisaged at the end of chemotherapy. In the event of relapse or progression, salvage treatment consisted of a second surgical procedure followed by local irradiation with or without second-line chemotherapy.

RESULTS

Conventional chemotherapy was well tolerated and could be administered in outpatient clinics. No radiologically documented response to chemotherapy more than 50% was observed. With a median follow-up of 4.7 years (range, 5 months to 8 years), the 4-year progression-free survival rate in this series was 22% (95% confidence interval [CI], 13% to 43%) and the overall survival rate was 59% (95% CI, 47% to 71%). Overall, 40% (95% CI, 29% to 51%) of the patients were alive having never received radiotherapy 2 years after the initiation of chemotherapy and 23% (95% CI, 14% to 35%) were still alive at 4 years without recourse to this modality. In the multivariate analysis, the two factors associated with a favorable outcome were a supratentorial tumor location (P =.0004) and complete surgery (P =.0009). Overall survival at 4 years was 74% (95% CI, 59% to 86%) for the patients in whom resection was radiologically complete and 35% (95% CI, 18% to 56%) for the patients with incomplete resection.

CONCLUSION

A significant proportion of children with ependymoma can avoid radiotherapy with prolonged adjuvant chemotherapy. Deferring irradiation at the time of relapse did not compromise overall survival of the entire patient population.

Radiation therapy in the management of childhood brain tumors

Radiation therapy (RT) still plays a major role in the management of intracranial malignancies, together with surgical resection and, more recently, chemotherapy. This is a review of the experience with fractionated external beam RT. In medulloblastomas, combined modalities currently achieve a 5-year survival in excess of 70% in low-risk subgroups and 40% in the subgroups considered to be high risk. For the past decade, the emphasis has been on the quality of life in cured children. Recent advances have mainly aimed at limiting the toxicity of the "prophylactic" craniospinal irradiation by testing dose reductions and altered fractionations. Technical innovations have also greatly benefited gliomas: modern techniques dealing with 3D CT and MRI-based treatment combined with stereotactic positioning of the patients, achieve a high degree of conformity that might improve both local control and longterm neurocognitive and growth sequelae.

[Neovascular glaucoma following proton-beam therapy. Case report]

A 52-year-old-male patient was treated for a posterior choroid melanoma of the right eye. When it was diagnosed, it measured 6mm in thickness and 11.9mm for the largest diameter and had a typical mushroom shape. General investigations found no metastatic disease. It was treated with proton-beam irradiation. Seven years later, the patient experienced increased intraocular pressure associated with cataract and pain. The patient finally accepted enucleation, as the vision of this eye was completely lost and the eye had become painful. Histologic analysis of the eye showed changes affecting both the anterior and the posterior segments of the eye, mostly related to the tumor and the consequences of treatment. Neovascular glaucoma is a major complication that very often leads to enucleation.

[A century of progress in the knowledge and treatment of nephroblastoma]

Since its initial description by Max Wilms over a century ago, nephroblastoma has benefited from considerable improvements both in terms of basic knowledge about it and management of it. Today, the majority of these very young patients can expect a long-term survival in excess of 90% at the price of a light therapy that combines surgical resection, chemotherapy based on ill-toxic agents, and in selected cases, radiotherapy of remarkably low toxicity. The contribution of large international studies will be emphasized here.

[Brachytherapy in the treatment of vesicoprostatic rhabdomyosarcomas in children]

Brachytherapy has been widely used at the Institut Gustave-Roussy since 1972 in pediatric oncology. In genitourinary rhabdomyosarcoma, because of its ballistic and physical characteristics, it represents the optimal treatment whenever irradiation is required and brachytherapy feasible. Between 1976 and 1998, 23 children with bladder or prostate rhabdomyosarcoma were treated with a protocol including brachytherapy, with five of them treated with a salvage brachytherapy. All but one brachytherapy was performed during the surgery. Among the 18 brachytherapies performed as a first-line treatment, eight presented a tumoral evolution: five presented a local evolution, one a local and nodal evolution and two a nodal evolution. Brachytherapy allowed a conservative treatment among ten out of 11 children alive with no evidence of disease. Among the five patients with salvage brachytherapy, two presented a second recurrence. Sequelae were minimal, consisting of one grade I rectitis and one asymptomatic vesical and ureteral reflux. These results are consistent with the published data using more radical treatment. Brachytherapy can represent an alternative to radical surgery, when indications are clearly defined in bladder or prostate rhabdomyosarcoma. This type of treatment can be performed only integrated with other treatments, more particularly with surgery. This approach requires a close cooperation between the different specialists: pediatricians, surgeons and brachytherapists.

[Ewing's sarcoma: towards a common protocol for adults and children]

Ewing sarcoma is an uncommon malignancy that has been frequently managed differently in childhood and adults. This is a review of the international experience that conducted to a common European study called Euro Ewing. This study was launched in 1999.

[Alternating chemotherapy and hyperfractionated accelerated radiotherapy in non-metastatic inflammatory breast cancer]

PURPOSE

Based on encouraging results reported in alternating radiotherapy and chemotherapy in inflammatory breast carcinoma, we have tried in this study to optimize locoregional treatment with a hyperfractionated accelerated radiotherapy schedule alternating with chemotherapy.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

From May 1991 to May 1995, 54 patients, previously untreated, with non-metastatic inflammatory breast cancer were entered in an alternating protocol consisting of eight courses of combined chemotherapy and two series of loco-regional hyperfractionated accelerated radiotherapy with a total dose of 66 Gy. Hyperfractionated accelerated radiotherapy was started after three courses of neoadjuvant chemotherapy (Adriamycin, Vincristine, Cyclophosphamide, Methotrexate, 5-fluoro-uracile) administered every 21 days +/- G.CSF. The first series delivered 45 Gy/three weeks to the breast, the axillary, subclavicular and internal mammary nodes, with two daily sessions of 1.5 Gy separated by an interval of eight hours; the second series consisted of a boost (21 Gy/14 fractions/10 d) alternating with another regimen of anthracycline-based-chemotherapy (a total of five cycles every three weeks). Hormonal treatment was given to all patients.

RESULTS

Of the 53 patients evaluated at the end of the treatment, 44 (83%) had a complete clinical response, seven (13%) had a partial response (> 50%) and two (4%) had tumoral progression. Of the 51 patients who were locally controlled, 18 (35%) presented a locoregional recurrence (LRR); eight (15%) had to undergo a mastectomy. All the patients but two with LRR developed metastases or died of local progressive disease and 26 (50%) developed metastases. With a median follow-up of 39 months (range: 4-74 months), survival rates at three and five years were respectively, 66 and 45% for overall survival and 45 and 36% for disease-free survival.

CONCLUSION

Alternating a combination of chemotherapy and hyperfractionated accelerated radiotherapy is a well-tolerated regimen which provides acceptable local control. The systemic dissemination remains the major problem of inflammatory breast carcinoma and further clinical trials using alternative drug regimens are warranted.

Localized childhood Hodgkin's disease: response-adapted chemotherapy with etoposide, bleomycin, vinblastine, and prednisone before low-dose radiation therapy-results of the French Society of Pediatric Oncology Study MDH90

PURPOSE

The French Society of Pediatric Oncology MDH82 study demonstrated the effectiveness of 20 Gy irradiation of involved fields after doxorubicin, bleomycin, vinblastine, and dacarbazine (ABVD) or mechlorethamine, vincristine, procarbazine, and prednisone/ABVD chemotherapy in children with localized Hodgkin's disease (HD). The response to primary chemotherapy was the only predictor of survival. To reduce long-term treatment complications without compromising efficacy, the MDH90 study was based on a new chemotherapy regimen devoid of both alkylating agents and anthracycline, followed by 20 Gy of radiotherapy (RT) for good responders.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

From January 1990 to July 1996, 202 children were enrolled from 30 institutions. Good responders to four cycles of vinblastine, bleomycin, etoposide (VP16), and prednisone (VBVP) were given 20 Gy of RT and no further therapy. Poor responders were given vincristine, procarbazine, prednisone, and doxorubicin. After a second evaluation, good responders were given 20 Gy of RT, and poor responders were given 40 Gy of RT.

RESULTS

One hundred seventy-one patients (85%) were good responders to VBVP, 27 (15%) were poor responders, and four did not respond. With a median follow-up of 74 months (range, 25 to 117 months), the 5-year overall survival rate (mean +/- SD) is 97.5% +/- 2.1%, and the event-free survival rate (mean +/- SD) is 91.1% +/- 1.8%. Significant predictors of worse event-free survival in multivariate analysis were hemoglobin < 10.5 g/L, "b" biologic class, and nodular sclerosis.

CONCLUSION

These results suggest that most children with clinical stage I and II HD can be treated with chemotherapy devoid of alkylating agents and anthracycline, followed by low-dose RT.

Nonmetastatic pelvic Ewing sarcoma: report of the French society of pediatric oncology

BACKGROUND

Since January, 1984, 59 children with histologically confirmed Ewing sarcoma of the pelvic bone have been treated with three successive chemotherapy protocols recommended by the French Society of Pediatric Oncology. The purpose of the current study was to evaluate the role of surgery and/or radiotherapy in local progression-free, disease-free, and overall survivals (LPFS, DFS, and OS, respectively).

PROCEDURE

We retrospectively examined 59 children treated for nonmetastatic, pelvic Ewing sarcoma over the last 12 years. All were first treated with chemotherapy according to the current French protocol. Six patients developed progressive disease before local treatment and were excluded for local control and survival analysis. Local treatment was surgery alone in 17 cases, radiation therapy in 27 cases, and surgery plus radiation therapy in 9 cases.

RESULTS

With a median of follow-up of 6.5 years, no significant differences in local control or survival were observed with the three chemotherapeutic protocols. Of the 53 patients evaluable for local control, 6 relapsed locally only, 8 had local and distant relapses, and 9 had distant metastases only. The 5-year OS rate was worst for patients with radiotherapy alone compared to those with surgery or combined modality treatment (44 % vs. 72 %, P = 0.043). The 5-year LPFS and DFS rates were worst in the radiotherapy-alone group but not significantly (63% vs. 79%, P = 0. 22 and 42% vs 71%, P =0.07, respectively). The importance of surgery to OS and DFS was confirmed by multivariate analysis (P = 0.026 and P = 0.048, respectively). One surviving patient was diagnosed with in-field fibrosarcoma, which was presumably radiation induced.

CONCLUSIONS

Despite intensive, multiagent chemotherapy, survival from pelvic Ewing sarcoma has not improved over the past decade; however, the survival rate does not seem to be worse than that from Ewing sarcoma at other locations, insofar as at least 50% of the patients were cured. Surgery or a combination of surgery and radiation therapy are the best local treatment; exclusive radiation therapy should be reserved for patients with inoperable lesions or partially or nonchemosensitive tumors or when surgery would be an amputation.

[Radiotherapy using a combination of photons and protons for locally aggressive intracranial tumors. Preliminary results of protocol CPO 94-C1]

PURPOSE

From October 1993 through July 1998, 48 assessable adult patients with non-resectable aggressive intracranial tumors were treated by a combination of high dose photon + proton therapy at the Centre de Protonthérapie d'Orsay.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Grade 1 and 4 gliomas were excluded. Patients benefited from a 3D dose calculation based on high-definition CT and MRI, a stereotactic positioning using implanted fiducial markers and a thermoplastic mask. Mean tumor dose ranged between 63 and 67 Gy delivered in five weekly sessions of 1.8 Gy in most patients, according to the histological types (doses in Co Gy Equivalent, with a mean proton-RBE of 1.1).

RESULTS

With a median 18-month follow-up (range: four-58 months), local control in tumors located in the envelopes and in the skull base was 97% (33/34), and in parenchymal tumors, 43% (6/14) only. Two patients (5%) presented with a clinically severe radiation-induced necrosis (temporal lobe and chiasm).

CONCLUSION

In our experience, high-dose radiation combining photons and protons is a safe and highly efficient procedure in selected malignancies of the skull base and envelopes.

Impact of targeting deviations on outcome in medulloblastoma: study of the French Society of Pediatric Oncology (SFOP)

PURPOSE

To correlate targeting deviation in external beam radiation therapy with site of relapse in a prospective study of 174 patients treated for medulloblastoma.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Between February 1992 and February 1998 the radiotherapy treatment records were reviewed by a panel of radiation oncologists for 174 children treated with radiation therapy for medulloblastoma. The review was done without knowledge of patient outcome. Patterns of relapse were correlated with the results of the quality control review.

RESULTS

Among the 174 patients five relapsed before the start of radiotherapy. One hundred sixty-nine patients were evaluable for correlation between targeting deviation and site of relapse. Number of major deviations in radiation therapy treatment is strongly correlated with the risk of tumor relapse (67% [95% CI: 28-91] of 3-year relapse rate in patient group with 2 major deviations and 78% [95% CI: 35-96] with 3 major deviations). This is particularly correlated with relapse in the frontal region of the brain: 5 relapses occurred in the frontal region in patients with major deviation in this area. An erroneous choice of electron beam energy is also linked with craniospinal fluid (CSF) relapse (3-year relapse rate of 68% [95% CI: 42-86]). Minor deviations in therapy technique are slightly associated with an increased risk of relapse in the same range as the group with only one major deviation.

CONCLUSION

The quality of medulloblastoma radiation therapy technique is strongly correlated with outcome. Pretreatment central quality assurance review or standardized computer-designed blocks would improve survival to an extent equivalent to that attributed to adjuvant chemotherapy.

Proton beam therapy (PT) in the management of CNS tumors in childhood

At the Centre de Protontherapie d'Orsay, nine children with intra-cranial malignancies were treated between July 1994 and January 1998. Immediate and late tolerances were excellent in all cases (follow-up 2 to 50 months). Two patients recurred locally (marginal failures), seven are alive and doing well. At Loma Linda, 28 children were treated between 1991 and 1994, 16 for a benign tumor of the brain and twelve for a malignant one. With a follow-up of seven to 49 months, three patients died (grade 2 to 4 gliomas), one is living with a persistent disease. Four children had treatment-related toxicity (one cataract, two hormonal failures and two seizures). The other children are doing well. At MGH Boston, 18 children with skull base-cervical spine chordomas have been reported. At five years, actuarial survival and disease-free survival have been 68 and 63%, respectively. Children with cervical sites had a worse prognosis (p = 0.008). Four children had radiation-related morbidity: two pituitary failures, one temporal lobe necrosis, one temporal muscle fibrosis. In this experience, such rare tumors seemed to behave in children like in adults.

The role of radiation therapy in the management of craniopharyngioma: a 25-year experience and review of the literature

PURPOSE

To review the outcome and quality of life at 5 years and more of 37 children treated with radiation therapy combined or not with surgical resection for a craniopharyngioma in a single institution.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

From January 1969 through December 1992, 37 children received external therapy at the Institut Gustave Roussy (Villejuif, France). Age ranged between 1 and 15 years (mean 7.4), M/F sex ratio was 0.76. In approximately one-half of the cases (18/37), radiation therapy was applied in conjunction with a surgical resection, and in almost one-half of the cases (18/37) as part of a salvage program following local failure. Total dose ranged between 45 and 56 Gy (median 50) given with a conventional fractionation in most children. Survival (S), event-free survival (EFS) were computerized according to the Kaplan-Meier method and prognostic factors for local failure and functional status analyzed. Functional outcome was evaluated according to the Wen score in 4 grades (gr 1: normal with/without hormonal replacement, gr 4: totally dependent, gr 2 and 3: intermediate disabilities).

RESULTS

At the time of analysis, 24 children (65%) were alive with NED, 4 (11%) alive after failure, and 9 (24%) dead of various causes. Following therapy, S and EFS regularly degraded and didn't seem to reach a plateau before 9 years (5 and 10 year S and EFS, respectively, 91, 65, and 78 and 56.5%). This was due to the occurrence of late failures (5 and 8.5 years) and late lethal complications (1 in-field glioblastoma multiforme at 9 years). A significant gain on EFS followed the introduction of modern imaging (p = 0.03), the association of surgical resection with RT (p = 0.01) and of higher doses of radiation superior or equal to 55 Gy (p = 0.05); a similar gain on S was observed in patients with a good initial performance status (p = 0.05). It is remarkable that surgical salvage of local failures following RT could induce prolonged remission in 4 children. Functional outcome was impaired in all but 5 children out of 35 fully evaluable (86%) and related with the initial symptomatology and/or therapy. Endocrinological, visual, neurological functions were affected in 97, 34, and 40%, respectively. It appeared correlated with the initial performance status (p = 0.02) and possibly with a younger age at treatment (p = 0.07).

CONCLUSIONS

Long-term follow-up beyond 5 years is warranted in craniopharyngioma to assess tumor control and functional outcome after radiation therapy. Although this therapeutical modality provides a high cure rate alone or in combination with surgery and even though at the time of failure, further strategies should aim to limit the severe toxicity (i.e., Wen gr 3 + 4) that was observed in more than one-third of our patients.

[Radiotherapy for leukemias and lymphomas in children]

Children treated for malignant hemopathy have a very good prognosis, yet late effects of the treatments on the length, endocrine function, cognitive function and the risk of secondary malignant tumors must be decreased. These toxicities are described in this article. New protocols and radiation techniques have been developed to reduce these effects. Radiotherapy is prescribed in the treatment of non-Hodgkin lymphoma to prevent high risk of meninges recurrences or to treat meninges disease associated with chemotherapy. Doses of cranial irradiation are limited to 24 Gy. A SFOP trial concluded that doses of 20 Gy are sufficient after good responses to chemotherapy for the treatment of Hodgkin's disease. The target volume is reduced to the initial site of the disease.

Radiation-induced cerebral vasculopathy in children with neurofibromatosis and optic pathway glioma

Occlusive vasculopathy is a potential complication of radiotherapy in children with optic pathway glioma. With a median follow-up of 7 years, 13 of 69 children in this study developed clinical and radiological signs of occlusive vasculopathy after radiotherapy within a median interval of 36 months. The major risk factor was neurofibromatosis type 1. Radiotherapy should no longer be the first treatment in these settings. When radiotherapy is unavoidable, regular screening for cerebral vasculopathy is mandatory, as preventive treatment is available.

The role of preoperative chemotherapy in the treatment of nephroblastoma: the SIOP experience. Societe Internationale d'Oncologie Pediatrique

Treatment of Wilms' tumor is an example of success of modern oncology. A combination of surgery, radiotherapy, and chemotherapy is widely accepted as the efficacious treatment of nephroblastoma. However, timing of each part of the treatment differs, in various protocols: the Societe Internationale d'Oncologie Pediatrique (SIOP) recommends the diagnosis based on imaging and metabolic exclusion of neuroblastoma to reduce the biopsy-related risk of spillage. In patients more than 6 months old, the treatment starts with the preoperative chemotherapy to improve the stage distribution at surgery and decrease the complications rate. Patients with advanced nephroblastoma, as those with vena cava thrombus and lung metastases, can benefit the most from the pretreatment. Results from the SIOP studies 6 and 9 confirm these statements: the stage distribution after the pretreatment reveals more than 50% of cases staged I, the 4-year disease-free survival in pulmonary stages IV was 83%, and of 42 patients with vena cava thrombus still present at surgery, 38 are alive from 27 to 109 months.

[Combined chemoradiotherapy of tumors in the child]

The high chemosensitivity of pediatric tumors along with their natural propensity for an early distant dissemination have stimulated the interest for chemo-radiation combinations in children since the mid 50s. Following the early experiments in nephroblastomas on the interaction of Actinomycin-D and radiotherapy, multiple national and international studies have been conducted since the mid 70s with considerable success: nowadays most pediatric tumors enjoy a long term survival in excess of 70%. Like their adult counterparts, these associations aim to induce an early control of the primary tumor and distant spreading (spatial cooperation) but also, more specifically in children, to limit the toxicity on normal tissues when treatment intensity can be further reduced. The association of an initial chemotherapy followed by local radiation at a dose and in a volume adapted to the response to chemotherapy along with associated prognostic factors has become widely tested in national and international studies conducted in Hodgkin's disease, Ewing's sarcoma, medulloblastomas, and brain tumors in the very young. Conversely, concomitant associations have remained limited to high-risk subgroups (parameningeal rhabdomyosarcomas for example) due to their potential hazards.

Effectiveness of protons and argon ions in initiating lipid peroxidation in low-density lipoproteins

In this study, human low-density lipoprotein (LDL) vesicles were irradiated with 73 MeV protons (LET of 1 keV/microm) and 11.4 MeV/nucleon argon ions (LET of 1.52 MeV/pm) and the effectiveness of charged particles in initiating peroxidation of LDLs was investigated. The LDL suspension (6 g/l) was exposed to protons and to argon ions in a dose range of 24 Gy to 2.4 kGy. Irradiations were carried out at the synchrocyclotron at the CPO and at the UNILAC of the GSI. After irradiation three chemical assays were used to study the progression of peroxidation of LDLs: the formation of conjugated dienes, the formation of thiobarbituric acid-reactive substances (TBARS) and the increase in the relative electrophoretic mobility of the LDLs. The results were compared with those obtained after gamma irradiation. For protons the yields of the peroxidation products were 10 times lower than after gamma irradiation. However, for doses below 200 Gy, protons appeared to be more effective than gamma rays in damaging the protein moiety, as deduced from the observed increase in the relative electrophoretic mobility of the LDLs. The irradiation with argon ions led to a negligible formation of peroxidation products, but an increase in the relative electrophoretic mobility of the LDLs was observed. The results are indicative of a lower yield of lipid peroxidation after irradiation with high-LET particles. In contrast, protons and argon ions appear to be more effective in inducing bulk protein and phospholipid damage than gamma rays.

Primitive cerebral neuroectodermal tumors excluding medulloblastomas: a retrospective study of 30 cases

We present a retrospective study of 30 cases of primitive cerebral neuroectodermal tumors (PNET), excluding medulloblastomas, referred to us postoperatively for additional therapy to evaluate prognostic factors and treatment efficiency. The histologic types were: pinealoblastomas (n = 7); ependymoblastomas (n = 2); medulloepitheliomas (n = 4), and other PNET (n = 17). The tumor was located in the supratentorial area in 24 patients and in the posterior fossa in 6 patients. Among the supratentorial tumors, 8 were metastatic. Maximal surgical resection was performed. Sixteen of 30 patients had no measurable disease after surgery and were considered as standard-risk (SR) cases, and 14 with a local residue or metastasis as high-risk (HR) cases. The objective of postsurgical treatment was to avoid radiotherapy in children below 4 years of age. It consisted of radiotherapy alone in 6 patients, chemotherapy alone in 17, and radiotherapy with chemotherapy in 7. Furthermore, high-dose chemotherapy (busulfan, thiotepa) and autologous bone marrow transplantation, performed in 6 patients, yielded a response rate of 3/6. Event-free survival (EFS) of SR patients was 37% at 3 years (95% confidence interval (CI) 14-60%) and overall survival 44% (95% CI 26-62%). Only 1 of the HR patients achieved a complete remission and all of them died early. The critical prognostic factors appear to be the completeness of initial surgical resection and absence of metastasis. These tumors have a poor prognosis. Novel strategies (high-dose chemotherapy) are needed to improve their outcome because the children concerned are very young and the effects of radiotherapy are particularly deleterious when tumors are situated in the supratentorial area.

Long-term follow up of 69 patients treated for optic pathway tumours before the chemotherapy era

AIM

To analyse the long-term results of conservative management with radiotherapy in patients with optic pathway tumours.

DESIGN

All 69 patients were symptomatic at diagnosis and most neoplasms involved the optic chiasm and hypothalamus.

RESULTS

At 10 years, overall survival and progression free survival were 83% and 65.5%, respectively. After radiotherapy, vision improved in 18 patients and remained stable in 29 other patients. Cerebrovascular complications occurred in nine of 53 patients treated with radiotherapy after a median interval of two and a half years. These complications were five times more frequent in patients with neurofibromatosis type 1 (NF1). Severe intellectual disabilities were present in 18 children, most of whom underwent irradiation at a very young age (median age, 4 years).

IMPLICATIONS

Radiotherapy is a valuable treatment in terms of tumour response, visual outcome, and progression free survival. However, in young children and in patients with NF1, major sequelae are encountered and new treatment strategies should be proposed for these patients.

[Late effects of radiotherapy in children]

Although most pediatric tumors can be cured with lower doses of radiation than their adult counterparts, long-term radiation-induced complications and sequelae remain a major concern both in terms of frequency and intensity. Most of them have been extensively documented in the pre-chemotherapeutic era like those affecting bone, cartilage and soft tissue growth or CNS and endocrine glands. More recently the emphasis has been put on the apparent increasing incidence of reported second malignancies. This could have been favored by the chemo-radiation combinations used in most children but also has been made possible mainly by the extensive follow-up of the increasing cohort of cured children.

Treatment of non-metastatic rhabdomyosarcomas in childhood and adolescence. Results of the second study of the International Society of Paediatric Oncology: MMT84

The second International Society of Paediatric Oncology (SIOP) study for rhabdomyosarcoma (MMT84) had several goals. The two principal aims were: (1) to improve the survival of children with rhabdomyosarcoma; and (2) to reduce the late effects from therapy by restricting the indications for surgery and/or radiotherapy after good response to initial chemotherapy. A further aim was to investigate the role of high-dose chemotherapy in young patients with parameningeal primary tumours. 186 previously untreated eligible patients entered the study. Patients with completely resected primary tumour received three courses of IVA (ifosfamide, vincristine and actinomycin D). Patients with incompletely resected tumour received six to 10 courses of IVA according to stage. Patients achieving complete remission with chemotherapy alone did not usually receive radiotherapy or undergo extensive surgery, but patients remaining in partial remission received local therapy with surgery and/or radiotherapy. Only patients over 5 years of age with parameningeal disease and patients over 12 years with tumours at any site were given systematic irradiation. Complete remission was achieved in 91% (170/186) of all patients. With a median follow-up of 8 years, the 5-year overall survival was 68% (+/- 3% standard error of the mean (SEM) and the 5-year event-free survival 53% (+/- 4% SEM). These results show an improvement over previous SIOP study (RMS75) in which survival was 52% and event-free survival was 47%. Among the 54 patients who exhibited isolated local relapse, 35% (19/54) survived in further remission longer than 2 years after retreatment, including local therapy (surgery +/- radiotherapy). Analysis of the overall burden of therapy received by all surviving children (including primary treatment and treatment for relapse if required) showed that 24% (28/116) were treated by limited surgery followed by three courses of IVA, 29% (34/116) were treated by chemotherapy alone (after initial biopsy) and 13% (15/116) received chemotherapy plus conservative local treatment (limited surgery or radiotherapy for residual disease). Only 34% (39/116) received intensive local therapy defined as radical wide field radiotherapy or radical surgery or both. Compared with the results obtained in the previous SIOP study, treatment in MMT84 was based on response to initial chemotherapy and, despite an overall reduction of the use of local therapy, significantly improved survival for patients with non-metastatic disease. This trial, also for the first time, provides evidence that retreatment after local relapse can achieve long-term second remissions.

A preliminary comparative treatment planning study for radiotherapy of age-related maculopathy

PURPOSE

We present a comparative planning of different approaches for external radiotherapy in age-related maculopathies.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Calculated dose distributions and dose-volume histograms for (a) bilateral irradiation with 6 MV photons, (b) a single lateral-oblique beam using either photons, electrons or protons and (c) an anterior circular proton beam.

RESULTS

For lateral photon or electron beams the dose to the lens is usually lower than 10% of the dose to the macula. The entrance doses for bilateral photon beams are about 50% which increase up to 100% at the orbital bone. About 5 mm of optic nerves are irradiated at the maximal dose while the optic chiasma is spared. A single photon beam gives 50% of the dose to the fellow eye. The electron beam spares the fellow eye but gives a rather inhomogeneous dose to the target volume. For a lateral proton beam, 4 mm of optic nerve receives 90% of the dose, the skin dose is at least 70% of the dose to the macula and the lens and the fellow eye are spared. An anterior proton beam gives 90% of the dose to 1 mm of optic nerve and the 50% isodose approaches the periphery of the lens.

CONCLUSION

Doses to the critical structures can be dramatically diminished for all the techniques by reducing the beam size, but only if very precise set-up techniques are used. Proton beams are an attractive solution, but the impact of such a choice on the use of proton facilities and on the national health system should be carefully evaluated, as well as the risk of radio-induced secondary neoplasias.

Nonmetastatic intracranial germinoma: the experience of the French Society of Pediatric Oncology

BACKGROUND

Standard treatment of localized intracranial germinoma is focal irradiation of the primary tumor (45-50 grays [Gy]) combined with craniospinal radiotherapy (RT). To decrease late effects related to extensive fields of RT, the French Society of Pediatric Oncology decided in 1990 to replace prophylactic RT with chemotherapy (CT) and to deliver focal RT at 40 Gy.

METHODS

Twenty-nine patients with localized, biopsy proven germinoma were included in this study between January 1990 and December 1994. CT consisted of 2 cycles of carboplatin 600 mg/m2 on Day 1, etoposide 150 mg/m2 on Days 1-3, ifosfamide 1.8 g/m2 on Days 22-26, and etoposide 150 mg2 on Days 22-24, followed by RT delivered to the initial tumor volume (40 Gy).

RESULTS

The median age of the 19 boys and 10 girls was 12.8 years; 25 patients had a unifocal tumor in the pineal (13), suprasellar (10), or thalamic (2) area, and 4 patients had a bifocal tumor. Three patients initially had complete surgery. Of the 26 patients evaluable for CT response, 11 had a small amount of tumor residue and 15 no residue; no patient underwent surgery after CT or RT. One patient recurred 3 years after diagnosis and is in his second complete remission. Twenty-eight patients are in their first complete remission after a median follow-up of 32 months (range, 7-68 months); 9 of the 28 have a small amount of tumor residue that is considered nonevolving. Overall survival at 4 years is 100% and event free survival is 93.3% (+/- 6%) after a median follow-up of 32 months.

CONCLUSIONS

This treatment strategy avoids craniospinal RT and reduces focal RT, with results equivalent to those achieved with extensive RT. Thus, the authors consider it a valid treatment of nonmetastatic germinoma.

Efficacy of proton therapy in circumscribed choroidal hemangiomas associated with serious retinal detachment

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of the study is to evaluate the efficacy and safety of proton therapy in complicated circumscribed choroidal hemangiomas.

DESIGN

The study design was a retrospective review.

PARTICIPANTS

Studied were 13 patients (13 eyes) who had circumscribed choroidal hemangioma associated with serous retinal detachment. Of these, four eyes previously underwent laser unsuccessfully.

INTERVENTION

Proton therapy including a total dose of 30 Cobalt-Gray-Equivalent was administered to each eye.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Patients were controlled for initial and final best-corrected visual acuity, slit-lamp examination, intraocular pressure, fundus examination, fluorescein angiography, and tumor thickness on B-scan ultrasonography.

RESULTS

The mean follow-up period was 26 months (range, 9-48 months). Retinal reattachment was obtained in all cases after a mean period of 52 days. The tumor height decreased in all cases. Visual acuity improved to two lines or more in eight eyes (62%) and reached 20/200 or more in nine eyes (69%). No radiation complication was detected during follow-up.

CONCLUSIONS

Proton radiation seems to be effective and safe in the management of choroidal hemangioma associated with serous retinal detachment. It may be useful when photocoagulation can not be performed.

[Initial results of proton therapy in choroidal melanoma at the d'Orsey Center for Proton Therapy; the first 464 cases]

PURPOSE

Retrospective analysis of the treatment of choroidal melanoma with protontherapy at the Centre de protonthérapie d'Orsay, France.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Between September 1991 and September 1995, 612 patients presenting with choroidal melanoma were treated by protontherapy in Orsay. Following initial management of the first 464 patients, results were analyzed, as were results after a 1-year follow-up for 305 patients, a 2-year follow-up for 169 patients, and a 3-year follow-up for 59 patients.

RESULTS

Univariate analysis showed that the actuarial local recurrence rate was 5%, the 3-year survival rate 88%, and the overall metastasic rate 5%. The initial tumor volume was the most significant predictive factor for visual results and metastases. Multivariate analysis revealed that visual results were significantly related to the initial tumor volume, initial retinal detachment, and total dose delivered to the optic nerve and macula.

CONCLUSION

Protontherapy of choroidal melanoma allows in most cases conservation of the eye without modification of survival. Visual results mainly depend on the site and size of the tumor.

Proton dosimetry comparison involving ionometry and calorimetry

A comparison of the absorbed dose to tissue determined by various ionization chambers, Faraday cups, and an A-150 plastic calorimeter was performed in the 200 MeV proton beam of Orsay, France. Four European proton-therapy centers (Clatterbridge, UK, Louvain la Neuve, Belgium, and Nice and Orsay, France) participated in the comparison. An agreement of better than 1% was observed in the absorbed dose to A-150 measured with the different chambers of the participating groups. The mean ratio of the absorbed dose to A-150 determined with the calorimeter to that determined by the different ionization chambers in the different irradiation conditions was found to be 0.952 +/- 0.007 [1 standard deviation (SD)] according to the code of practice used by all the participating centers, based on Janni's tables of stopping powers and a value of 35.2 J/Coulomb for (W(air)/e)p. A better agreement in the mean ratio calorimeter/chamber, 0.985 +/- 0.007 (1 SD) is observed when using the proton stopping power ratio values recently published by the International Commission on Radiation Units and Measurements in Report no. 49. The mean ratio of these doses determined in accordance with the American Association of Physicists in Medicine protocol and using the new recommended stopping power tables becomes 1.002 +/- 0.007 (1 SD). Two Faraday cups agree in measured charge to within 0.8%; however, the calculation of dose is underestimated by up to 17%; compared with ion chamber measurements and seems to be very sensitive to measurement conditions, particularly to the distance to the collimator.