Knowledge user survey and Delphi process to inform development of a new risk of bias tool to assess systematic reviews with network meta-analysis (RoB NMA tool)

BACKGROUND

Network meta-analysis (NMA) is increasingly used in guideline development and other aspects of evidence-based decision-making. We aimed to develop a risk of bias (RoB) tool to assess NMAs (RoB NMA tool). An international steering committee recommended that the RoB NMA tool to be used in combination with the Risk of Bias in Systematic reviews (ROBIS) tool (i.e. because it was designed to assess biases only) or other similar quality appraisal tools (eg, A MeaSurement Tool to Assess systematic Reviews 2 [AMSTAR 2]) to assess quality of systematic reviews. The RoB NMA tool will assess NMA biases and limitations regarding how the analysis was planned, data were analysed and results were presented, including the way in which the evidence was assembled and interpreted.

OBJECTIVES

Conduct (a) a Delphi process to determine expert opinion on an item's inclusion and (b) a knowledge user survey to widen its impact.

DESIGN

Cross-sectional survey and Delphi process.

METHODS

Delphi panellists were asked to rate whether items should be included. All agreed-upon item were included in a second round of the survey (defined as 70% agreement). We surveyed knowledge users' views and preferences about the importance, utility and willingness to use the RoB NMA tool to evaluate evidence in practice and in policymaking. We included 12 closed and 10 open-ended questions, and we followed a knowledge translation plan to disseminate the survey through social media and professional networks.

RESULTS

22 items were entered into a Delphi survey of which 28 respondents completed round 1, and 22 completed round 2. Seven items did not reach consensus in round 2. A total of 298 knowledge users participated in the survey (14% respondent rate). 75% indicated that their organisation produced NMAs, and 78% showed high interest in the tool, especially if they had received adequate training (84%). Most knowledge users and Delphi panellists preferred a tool to assess both bias in individual NMA results and authors' conclusions. Response bias in our sample is a major limitation as knowledge users working in high-income countries were more represented. One of the limitations of the Delphi process is that it depends on the purposive selection of experts and their availability, thus limiting the variability in perspectives and scientific disciplines.

CONCLUSIONS

This Delphi process and knowledge user survey informs the development of the RoB NMA tool.

User-centered development process of an operating interface to couple a robotic glove with a virtual environment to optimize hand rehabilitation following a stroke

Introduction

Task-specific neurorehabilitation is crucial to optimize hand recovery shortly after a stroke, but intensive neurorehabilitation remains limited in resource-constrained healthcare systems. This has led to a growing interest in the use of robotic gloves as an adjunct intervention to intensify hand-specific neurorehabilitation. This study aims to develop and assess the usability of an operating interface supporting such a technology coupled with a virtual environment through a user-centered design approach.

Methods

Fourteen participants with hand hemiparesis following a stroke were invited to don the robotic glove before browsing through the operating interface and its functionalities, and perform two mobility exercises in a virtual environment. Feedback was collected for improving technology usability. Participants completed the System Usability Scale and ABILHAND questionnaires and their recommendations were gathered and prioritized in a Pugh Matrix.

Results

The System Usability Scale (SUS) score for the operating interface was excellent (M = 87.0 SD = 11.6). A total of 74 recommendations to improve the user interface, calibration process, and exercise usability were identified.

Conclusion

The application of a full cycle of user-centred design approach confirms the high level of usability of the system which is perceived by end users as acceptable and useful for intensifying neurorehabilitation.

Diverged subpopulations in tropical Urochloa (Brachiaria) forage species indicate a role for facultative apomixis and varying ploidy in their population structure and evolution

BACKGROUND

Urochloa (syn. Brachiaria) is a genus of tropical grasses sown as forage feedstock, particularly in marginal soils. Here we aimed to clarify the genetic diversity and population structure in Urochloa species to understand better how population evolution relates to ploidy level and occurrence of apomictic reproduction.

METHODS

We explored the genetic diversity of 111 accessions from the five Urochloa species used to develop commercial cultivars. These accessions were conserved from wild materials collected at their centre of origin in Africa, and they tentatively represent the complete Urochloa gene pool used in breeding programmes. We used RNA-sequencing to generate 1.1 million single nucleotide polymorphism loci. We employed genetic admixture, principal component and phylogenetic analyses to define subpopulations.

RESULTS

We observed three highly differentiated subpopulations in U. brizantha, which were unrelated to ploidy: one intermixed with U. decumbens, and two diverged from the former and the other species in the complex. We also observed two subpopulations in U. humidicola, unrelated to ploidy; one subpopulation had fewer accessions but included the only characterized sexual accession in the species. Our results also supported a division of U. decumbens between diploids and polyploids, and no subpopulations within U. ruziziensis and U. maxima.

CONCLUSIONS

Polyploid U. decumbens are more closely related to polyploid U. brizantha than to diploid U. decumbens, which supports the divergence of both polyploid groups from a common tetraploid ancestor and provides evidence for the hybridization barrier of ploidy. The three differentiated subpopulations of apomictic polyploid U. brizantha accessions constitute diverged ecotypes, which can probably be utilized in hybrid breeding. Subpopulations were not observed in non-apomictic U. ruziziensis. Sexual Urochloa polyploids were not found (U. brizantha, U. decumbens) or were limited to small subpopulations (U. humidicola). The subpopulation structure observed in the Urochloa sexual-apomictic multiploidy complexes supports geographical parthenogenesis, where the polyploid genotypes exploit the evolutionary advantage of apomixis, i.e. uniparental reproduction and clonality, to occupy extensive geographical areas.

Split staphylectomy to address soft palate thickness in brachycephalic dogs: 75 cases (2016-2018)

OBJECTIVES

Describe the split staphylectomy procedure to address soft palate thickness and assess the complications and long-term outcome of this procedure as a part of multi-level surgery for brachycephalic obstructive airway syndrome. To consider whether same-day discharge following this surgery can be recommended.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Medical records of dogs treated for brachycephalic obstructive airway syndrome using the split staphylectomy were reviewed. Owners were contacted to complete a questionnaire assessing initial postoperative concerns, the long-term outcome and the effect of surgery on their dog's quality of life.

RESULTS

Seventy-five dogs underwent split staphylectomy during the study period. The overall complication rate was 8.3%, of which 2.7% were considered major. No life-threatening complications occurred, and no complications were related to the staphylectomy. The questionnaire was completed by 66.7% of owners (median follow-up 459 days), of which 88% felt that surgery had improved the quality of life for their dog. The majority (88%) of dogs were discharged from hospital on the day of surgery. Of the surveyed owners, 14% sought veterinary attention between their dog leaving the hospital and the scheduled postoperative reassessment 2 weeks after surgery. Four dogs were presented for veterinary intervention during this time period, but no intervention was related to the staphylectomy or for a life-threatening condition.

CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE

The split staphylectomy offers a safe, straightforward method of addressing both excess thickness and length of soft palate in dogs with brachycephalic obstructive airway syndrome. Dogs can be discharged on the same day as brachycephalic obstructive airway syndrome surgery including split staphylectomy without an increased risk of complications.

Characterization of buried interfaces using Ga Kα hard X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (HAXPES)

HAXPES enables the detection of buried interfaces with an increased photo electron sampling depth.

P10.02 Combined methods of a micropump system and a chronic cranial window allows tumor observation with multi photon laser scanning microscopy under continuous treatment

BACKGROUND

Glioblastomas are notoriously therapy resistant tumors. As opposed to other tumor entities, no major advances in therapeutic success have been made in the past decades. This has been calling for a deeper biological understanding of the tumor, its growth and resistance patterns. We have been using a xenograft glioma model, where human glioblastoma cells are implanted under chronic cranial windows and studied longitudinally over many weeks and months using multi photon laser scanning microscopy (MPLSM). To test the effect of (new) drugs, a stable and direct delivery system avoiding the blood-brain-barrier has come into our interest.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

We implanted cranial windows and fluorescently labeled human glioblastoma stem-like cells into NMRI nude mice to follow up on the tumor development in our MPLSM model. After tumor establishment, an Alzet® micropump was implanted to directly deliver agents via a catheter system continuously over 28 days directly under the cranial window onto the brain surface. Using the MPLSM technique, the continuous delivery and infusion of drugs onto the brain and into the tumor was measured over many weeks in detail using MPLSM.

RESULTS

The establishment of the combined methods allowed reliable concurrent drug delivery over 28 days bypassing the blood-brain-barrier. Individual regions and tumor cells could be measured and followed up before, and after the beginning of the treatment, as well as after the end of the pump activity. Fluorescently labelled drugs were detectable in the MPLSM and its distribution into the brain parenchyma could be quantified. After the end of the micropump activity, further MPLSM measurements offer the possibility to observe long term effects of the applied drug on the tumor.

CONCLUSION

The combination of tumor observation in the MPSLM and concurrent continuous drug delivery is a feasible and reliable method for the investigation of (novel) anti-tumor agents, especially drugs that are not blood-brain-barrier penetrant. Morphological or even functional changes of individual tumor cells can be measured under and after treatment. These techniques can be used to test new drugs targeting the tumor, its tumor microtubes and tumor cells networks, and measure the effects longitudinally.

0132 Sex Differences in Evening Food Intake and Associated Weight Gain During Insufficient Sleep

Introduction

Timing of food intake has emerged as a novel risk factor for weight gain and obesity. Higher evening food intake, especially during insufficient sleep, is associated with weight gain. We aimed to explore initial changes in evening food intake and the respiratory quotient (RQ) during insufficient sleep and subsequent weight gain. We also explored sex differences.

Methods

28 healthy adults (14F) aged 26.3±4.5y completed a 14–16 daylong laboratory protocol. In their home environment participants maintained one week of ~9h/night sleep schedules and consumed energy balanced diets for 3 days prior to completing the laboratory protocol. The laboratory protocol consisted of 3 baseline days of 9h/night scheduled sleep with energy balanced diets followed by 10 days of 5h/night scheduled sleep with ad-libitum food intake, with (n=14) and without (n=14) weekend recovery sleep. RQ was assessed on days 3 and 5 in a whole room calorimeter. Evening (dinner and after-dinner snacks) energy intake and body weight were assessed daily.

Results

A significant sex by condition effect was observed for evening food intake such that men and women were similar at baseline, but men ate more than women during insufficient sleep, when controlling for body mass (p<0.05). A significant sex by condition effect was also observed for RQ with women showing similar RQ during baseline and insufficient sleep and men showing a higher RQ during insufficient sleep versus baseline (p<0.05). Linear regression with food intake and RQ as predictors of weight gain showed that increased evening food intake, but not RQ, on the second day of sleep restriction was associated with weight gain in men, but not women, at the end of the study eight days later (p<0.05).

Conclusion

Findings suggest that rapid changes in evening food intake during insufficient sleep contributes to subsequent weight gain during sustained insufficient sleep, especially in men.

Support

NIH HL109706, DK111161, TR001082, DK048520, Sleep Research Society Foundation grant 011-JP-16 and Office of Naval Research MURI (N00014-15-1-2809).

Diffusion Properties of Normal-Appearing White Matter Microstructure and Severity of Motor Impairment in Acute Ischemic Stroke

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

The effect of white matter hyperintensities as measured by FLAIR MR imaging on functional impairment and recovery after ischemic stroke has been investigated thoroughly. However, there has been growing interest in investigating normal-appearing white matter microstructural integrity following ischemic stroke onset with techniques such as DTI.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Fifty-two patients with acute ischemic stroke and 36 without stroke were evaluated with a DTI and FLAIR imaging protocol and clinically assessed for the severity of motor impairment using the Motricity Index within 72 hours of suspected symptom onset.

RESULTS

There were widespread decreases in fractional anisotropy and increases in mean diffusivity and radial diffusivity for the acute stroke group compared with the nonstroke group. There was a significant positive association between fractional anisotropy and motor function and a significant negative association between mean diffusivity/radial diffusivity and motor function. The normal-appearing white matter ROIs that were most sensitive to the Motricity Index were the anterior/posterior limb of the internal capsule in the infarcted hemisphere and the splenium of the corpus callosum, external capsule, posterior limb/retrolenticular part of the internal capsule, superior longitudinal fasciculus, and cingulum (hippocampus) of the intrahemisphere/contralateral hemisphere.

CONCLUSIONS

The microstructural integrity of normal-appearing white matter is a significant parameter to identify neural differences not only between those individuals with and without acute ischemic stroke but also correlated with the severity of acute motor impairment.

Sonographic markers of fetal adiposity and risk of Cesarean delivery

OBJECTIVE

Increased fetal size is associated with shoulder dystocia during labor and subsequent need for assisted delivery. We sought to investigate if increased fetal adiposity diagnosed sonographically in late pregnancy is associated with increased risk of operative delivery.

METHODS

This secondary analysis of the Genesis Study recruited 2392 nulliparous women with singleton pregnancy in cephalic presentation, in a prospective, multicenter study, to examine prenatal and intrapartum predictors of Cesarean delivery. Participants underwent ultrasound and clinical evaluation between 39 + 0 and 40 + 6 weeks' gestation. Data on fetal biometry were not revealed to patients or to their managing clinicians. A fetal adiposity composite of fetal thigh adiposity and fetal abdominal wall thickness was compiled for each infant in order to determine whether fetal adiposity > 90^th centile was associated with an increased risk of Cesarean or operative vaginal delivery.

RESULTS

After exclusions, data were available for 2330 patients. Patients with a fetal adiposity composite > 90^th centile had a higher maternal body mass index (BMI) (25 ± 5 kg/m² vs 24 ± 4 kg/m² ; P = 0.005), birth weight (3872 ± 417 g vs 3585 ± 401 g; P < 0.0001) and rate of induction of labor (47% (108/232) vs 40% (834/2098); P = 0.048) than did those with an adiposity composite ≤ 90^th centile. Fetuses with adiposity composite > 90^th centile were more likely to require Cesarean delivery than were those with adiposity composite ≤ 90^th centile (P < 0.0001). After adjusting for birth weight, maternal BMI and need for induction of labor, fetal adiposity > 90^th centile remained a risk factor for Cesarean delivery (P < 0.0001). A fetal adiposity composite > 90^th centile was more predictive of the need for unplanned Cesarean delivery than was an estimated fetal weight > 90^th centile (odds ratio, 2.20 (95% CI, 1.65-2.94; P < 0.001) vs 1.74 (95% CI, 1.29-2.35; P < 0.001). Having an adiposity composite > 90^th centile was not associated with an increased likelihood of operative vaginal delivery when compared with having an adiposity composite ≤ 90^th centile (P = 0.37).

CONCLUSIONS

Fetuses with increased adipose deposition are more likely to require Cesarean delivery than are those without increased adiposity. Consideration should, therefore, be given to adding fetal thigh adiposity and abdominal wall thickness to fetal sonographic assessment in late pregnancy. Copyright © 2019 ISUOG. Published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd.

Behavior of the breathing pyrochlore lattice Ba3Yb2Zn5O11 in applied magnetic field

The breathing pyrochlore lattice material Ba₃Yb₂Zn₅O₁₁ exists in the nearly decoupled limit, in contrast to most other well-studied breathing pyrochlore compounds. As a result, it constitutes a useful platform to benchmark theoretical calculations of exchange interactions in insulating Yb³⁺ magnets. Here we study Ba₃Yb₂Zn₅O₁₁ at low temperatures in applied magnetic fields as a further probe of the physics of this model system. Experimentally, we consider the behavior of polycrystalline samples of Ba₃Yb₂Zn₅O₁₁ with a combination of inelastic neutron scattering and heat capacity measurements down to 75 mK and up to fields of 10 T. Consistent with previous work, inelastic neutron scattering finds a level crossing near 3 T, but no significant dispersion of the spin excitations is detected up to the highest applied fields. Refinement of the theoretical model previously determined at zero field can reproduce much of the inelastic neutron scattering spectra and specific heat data. A notable exception is a low temperature peak in the specific heat at  ∼0.1 K. This may indicate the scale of interactions between tetrahedra or may reflect undetected disorder in Ba₃Yb₂Zn₅O₁₁.

Contribution of patient-advisors during rehabilitation for replantation of digits improves patient-reported functional outcomes: A presentation of concept

Clinical approach to surgical patients has evolved to include previous patients as part of the treating team in the role of "patient-advisors". Knowing that compliance to rehabilitation protocols is significant for a successful functional hand replantation, we set out to quantify functional patient-reported outcomes in individuals enrolled in a Patient-Advisor Program (PAP). We performed a prospective cohort pilot study of all patients admitted for a finger replantation between July 2015 to January 2016. All patients were offered to partake in the PAP, or else they would constitute the control group. Primary endpoints were functional outcomes as reported by patients at 6-8weeks and 4-6months of follow-up. Secondary endpoints were patient-reported pain and quality of life questionnaires. In total, 62 patients were admitted for finger replantation in the studied period, in which 50 agreed to participate in the study, including 7 in the patient-advisors group and 43 in the control group. Patients from the patient-advisors group fared better on mean scores of the Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder and Hand than controls (29.6 vs 34.8 respectively at 4-6months). Improvements in the McGill Pain Questionnaire were also greater in the studied group (19.9 vs 33.3 at 4-6months). Replantation patients benefiting from the PAP demonstrated superior functional outcomes on self-reported questionnaires, which could be explained by a better understanding of rehabilitation protocols and compliance when previous patients are active members of the treating team.

Carboxypeptidase B2 and N play different roles in regulation of activated complements C3a and C5a in mice

Essentials Two basic carboxypeptidases are present in plasma, B2 (CPB2) and N (CPN). Cpb2-/- and Cpn-/- mice were challenged in a hemolytic uremic syndrome (HUS) model vs. wild type. Cpb2-/- exacerbates HUS while Cpn-/- exacerbates cobra venom factor challenge vs. wild type mice. CPB2 and CPN have overlapping but non-redundant roles.

SUMMARY

Background There are two basic carboxypeptidases in plasma. Carboxypeptidase B2 (CPB2) is activated from a circulating zymogen, proCPB2, and carboxypeptidase N (CPN) is constitutively active with both inactivating complement C3a and C5a. Aims To test the roles of CPB2 and CPN in complement-driven mouse models of cobra venom factor (CVF) challenge and hemolytic-uremic syndrome (HUS). Methods Cpb2-/- , Cpn-/- and wild-type (WT) mice were compared in an HUS model induced by Shiga toxin and lipopolysaccharide administration and following CVF administration. Results HUS was exacerbated in Cpb2-/- mice more than in Cpn-/- mice, compared with WT mice. Cpb2-/- mice developed the HUS clinical triad of microangiopathic hemolytic anemia, uremia and thrombocytopenia. Treatment with anti-C5 antibody improved survival of both Cpb2-/- and Cpn-/- mice. In contrast, when challenged acutely with CVF, the reverse phenotype was observed. Cpn-/- mice had markedly worse disease than Cpb2-/- mice, whereas the WT mice were resistant. Conclusions CPN and CPB2 play overlapping but non-redundant roles in regulating complement activation in vivo. The constitutively active CPN is key for inactivation of systemic C5a, whereas CPB2 functions as an on-demand supplementary anaphylatoxin inhibitor in inactivating excessive C5a formed locally.

Mycobacteria in aquarium fish: results of a 3-year survey indicate caution required in handling pet-shop fish

Fish are commonly infected with non-tuberculous mycobacteria (NTM), which should be regarded as potential pathogens when handling aquarium fish and equipment. This study examined 107 aquarium fish from pet shops. Cultivation of the fish samples using different selective media was conducted for identification of NTM. Isolates were identified using the GenoType Mycobacterium common mycobacteria and additional species assays, sequencing of the 16S rRNA and rpoB genes, and real-time PCR assay for identification of Mycobacterium (M.) marinum. Among the investigated fish, 79.4% (85/107) were positive for mycobacteria, with 8.2% (7 of 85) having two mycobacterial species present. Among the positive fish, the common pathogens M. marinum, Mycobacterium fortuitum (M. fortuitum group) and Mycobacterium chelonae were identified in approx. 90% of fish and other NTM species in 10%, including Mycobacterium peregrinum/septicum, Mycobacterium gordonae, Mycobacterium arupense, Mycobacterium kansasii, Mycobacterium ulcerans and Mycobacterium setense. The well-known human pathogen M. marinum was present in 10.6% of the positive fish (9 of 85). The species of mycobacteria identified in the study are not only recognized as aquarium fish pathogens, but can also cause pathology in humans. Microbiological and clinical communities should therefore be sensitized to the role of NTM in infections associated with exposure to aquarium fish.

A Genetic Method To Evaluate the Prevalence of Unique DNA Profiles between Sequential Ground Beef Batches

The delineation of ground beef batches has implications for the management of product disposition policies in the event of Shiga toxin-producing Escherichia coli contamination. Analysis of individual contributor animal-specific DNA profiles can provide valuable empirical data for understanding the dynamics of ground meat production processes and can act as a surrogate for cross-contamination. A genetic method was developed for characterizing the source raw material flow and carryover between discrete batches of ground beef in a large-scale commercial beef grinding operation. The application developed involves the introduction of a genetically distinct source raw material batch into the grinding system and comprehensive sampling of that index batch and subsequent batches followed by single nucleotide polymorphism genotyping of random subsamples. Capture-mark-recapture statistical techniques were used to estimate (i) the number of carcass contributors and (ii) the associated level of carryover between batches. Carryover, expressed as a percentage of the total weight of the batch material (in pounds), was observed between the genetically distinct index batch and the next sequential batch at approximately 1%. The nondetection of additional carryover to subsequent batches, with a detection level of approximately 0.2%, supports a serial dilution model of same source raw material carryover, consistent with the recorded weight of beef trimmings used in each batch. For ground beef manufacturers, this method is a simple approach for validating the independence of finished batches of beef in their grind systems in support of product disposition policies.

Early Experience and Social Grouping in Fear Extinction of Rats

Rats, conditioned to escape shock in a straight 6-ft. runway, were tested for the effects which early rearing and presence of different numbers of social animals had on fear-conditioned escape responses. The most significant findings were that: (a) for animals reared apart, the presence of another animal or animals had little or no effect upon fear-conditioned escape behavior; (b) for animals reared together, the presence of other animals resulted in fear reduction; (c) this fear-reducing influence of other animals seemed to have developed during the early life in a social situation; and (d) the group had to consist of at least three animals before its effects in fear situations were apparent.

Umbilical and fetal middle cerebral artery Doppler reference ranges in a twin population followed longitudinally from 24 to 38 weeks' gestation

OBJECTIVE

To construct monochorionic diamniotic (MCDA) and dichorionic diamniotic (DCDA) twin reference ranges for umbilical artery (UA) pulsatility index (PI), UA resistance index (RI), fetal middle cerebral artery (MCA) PI and peak systolic velocity (PSV) and cerebroplacental ratio (CPR) from 24 weeks' to 38 weeks' gestation and compare these with published normal values for singleton pregnancies.

METHODS

This prospective multicenter cohort study included 1028 unselected twin pairs recruited over a 2-year period. Participants with dichorionic twins underwent fortnightly ultrasound surveillance from 24 weeks' gestation, with monochorionic twins being followed every 2 weeks from 16 weeks until delivery. A total of 7536 fetal Doppler examinations in 618 twin pregnancies were included in the analysis, with reference ranges for MCDA and DCDA pregnancies constructed for each of the Doppler indices using multilevel modeling.

RESULTS

UA-PI and UA-RI appear to be higher in twins than in singletons, and MCA-PI and MCA-PSV appear to be lower. The CPR also appears to be lower in twins than in singletons. Similar MCA indices were observed in MCDA and DCDA twins.

CONCLUSION

We have established longitudinal reference ranges for UA-PI and UA-RI, MCA-PI and MCA-PSV and CPR in twin pregnancies, which appear to differ from those in singleton pregnancies. The derived twin-specific reference ranges may be more appropriate in the surveillance of these high-risk pregnancies. Applying the singleton CPR cut-off of ≤ 1.0 may lead to a large number of false-positive diagnoses of cerebral redistribution in twin fetuses.

Protected areas and freshwater conservation: a survey of protected area managers in the Tennessee and Cumberland River Basins, USA

As the scientific community has highlighted the plight of freshwater species, there have been increasing calls for protected area (PA) designation and management specific to the conservation of aquatic species and ecosystems. In this study we examined PA management in one relatively well-resourced (high levels of financial and technical resources) part of the world: the Tennessee and Cumberland River Basins, USA. We asked managers their perceptions about the current status of freshwater ecosystems within PAs, the sources of stress that are degrading freshwater ecosystem integrity, the degree to which PAs address these stressors, and the availability of technical, human, and financial resources for management activities that benefit freshwater ecosystems and the species they support. Managers generally perceive that freshwater ecosystems within PAs are under low levels of stress, with less than half reporting any alteration to ecosystem integrity, and very few reporting alterations at medium or high levels. Most PAs have fewer resources dedicated to freshwater conservation and management than to other activities, and some PAs completely lack resources for freshwater management. We recommend a review of every PA's goals and objectives and any needed updates to include the conservation of freshwater ecosystems. We also recommend an analysis to determine the most pressing stressors to aquatic life within each PA, stemming from sources both from within and outside of a PA's boundaries, and that this information be used to guide future management. Finally, we suggest that management resources be prioritized for PAs that include large portions of the catchments of their freshwater systems; that can address the dominant sources of stress within the PA; or that contain representative ecosystems, species assemblages or populations of rare, endemic, and threatened species.