Modeling anabolic and antiresorptive therapies for fracture healing in a mouse model of osteogenesis imperfecta

Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is a genetic bone fragility disorder that features frequent fractures. Bone healing outcomes are contingent on a proper balance between bone formation and resorption, and drugs such as bone morphogenetic proteins (BMPs) and bisphosphonates (BPs) have shown to have utility in modulating fracture repair. While BPs are used for OI to increase BMD and reduce pain and fracture rates, there is little evidence for using BMPs as local agents for fracture healing (alone or with BPs). In this study, we examined wild-type and OI mice (Col1a2^+/G610C ) in a murine tibial open fracture model with (i) surgery only/no treatment, (ii) local BMP-2 (10 µg), or (iii) local BMP-2 and postoperative zoledronic acid (ZA; 0.1 mg/kg total dose). Microcomputed tomography reconstructions of healing fractures indicated BMP-2 was less effective in an OI setting, however, BMP-2 +ZA led to considerable increases in bone volume (+193% WT, p < 0.001; +154% OI, p < 0.001) and polar moment of inertia (+125% WT, p < 0.01; +248% OI, p < 0.05). Tissue histology revealed a thinning of the neocortex of the callus in BMP-2 treated OI bone, but considerable retention of woven bone in the healing callus with BMP + ZA specimens. These data suggest a cautious approach may be warranted with the sole application of BMP-2 in an OI surgical setting as a bone graft substitute. However, this may be overcome by off-label BP administration.

Preclinical models for orthopedic research and bone tissue engineering

In this review, we broadly define and discuss the preclinical rodent models that are used for orthopedics and bone tissue engineering. These range from implantation models typically used for biocompatibility testing and high-throughput drug screening, through to fracture and critical defect models used to model bone healing and severe orthopedic injuries. As well as highlighting the key methods papers describing these techniques, we provide additional commentary based on our substantive practical experience with animal surgery and in vivo experimental design. This review also briefly touches upon the descriptive and functional outcome measures and power calculations that are necessary for an informative study. Obtaining informative and relevant research outcomes can be very dependent on the model used, and we hope this evaluation of common models will serve as a primer for new researchers looking to undertake preclinical bone studies. © 2017 Orthopaedic Research Society. Published by Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Orthop Res 36:832-840, 2018.

Lineage tracking of mesenchymal and endothelial progenitors in BMP-induced bone formation

To better understand the relative contributions of mesenchymal and endothelial progenitor cells to rhBMP-2 induced bone formation, we examined the distribution of lineage-labeled cells in Tie2-Cre:Ai9 and αSMA-creERT2:Col2.3-GFP:Ai9 reporter mice. Established orthopedic models of ectopic bone formation in the hind limb and spine fusion were employed. Tie2-lineage cells were found extensively in the ectopic bone and spine fusion masses, but co-staining was only seen with tartrate-resistant acid phosphatase (TRAP) activity (osteoclasts) and CD31 immunohistochemistry (vascular endothelial cells), and not alkaline phosphatase (AP) activity (osteoblasts). To further confirm the lack of a functional contribution of Tie2-lineage cells to BMP-induced bone, we developed conditional knockout mice where Tie2-lineage cells are rendered null for key bone transcription factor osterix (Tie2-cre:Osx(fx/fx) mice). Conditional knockout mice showed no difference in BMP-induced bone formation compared to littermate controls. Pulse labeling of mesenchymal cells with Tamoxifen in mice undergoing spine fusion revealed that αSMA-lineage cells contributed to the osteoblastic lineage (Col2.3-GFP), but not to endothelial cells or osteoclast populations. These data indicate that the αSMA+ and Tie2+ progenitor lineages make distinct cellular contributions to bone formation, angiogenesis, and resorption/remodeling.

Animal models of scoliosis

Multiple techniques designed to induce scoliotic deformity have been applied across many animal species. We have undertaken a review of the literature regarding experimental models of scoliosis in animals to discuss their utility in comprehending disease aetiology and treatment. Models of scoliosis in animals can be broadly divided into quadrupedal and bipedal experiments. Quadrupedal models, in the absence of axial gravitation force, depend upon development of a mechanical asymmetry along the spine to initiate a scoliotic deformity. Bipedal models more accurately mimic human posture and consequently are subject to similar forces due to gravity, which have been long appreciated to be a contributing factor to the development of scoliosis. Many effective models of scoliosis in smaller animals have not been successfully translated to primates and humans. Though these models may not clarify the aetiology of human scoliosis, by providing a reliable and reproducible deformity in the spine they are a useful means with which to test interventions designed to correct and prevent deformity.

A murine model of neurofibromatosis type 1 tibial pseudarthrosis featuring proliferative fibrous tissue and osteoclast-like cells

Neurofibromatosis type 1 (NF1) is a common genetic condition caused by mutations in the NF1 gene. Patients often suffer from tissue-specific lesions associated with local double-inactivation of NF1. In this study, we generated a novel fracture model to investigate the mechanism underlying congenital pseudarthrosis of the tibia (CPT) associated with NF1. We used a Cre-expressing adenovirus (AdCre) to inactivate Nf1 in vitro in cultured osteoprogenitors and osteoblasts, and in vivo in the fracture callus of Nf1(flox/flox) and Nf1(flox/-) mice. The effects of the presence of Nf1(null) cells were extensively examined. Cultured Nf1(null)-committed osteoprogenitors from neonatal calvaria failed to differentiate and express mature osteoblastic markers, even with recombinant bone morphogenetic protein-2 (rhBMP-2) treatment. Similarly, Nf1(null)-inducible osteoprogenitors obtained from Nf1 MyoDnull mouse muscle were also unresponsive to rhBMP-2. In both closed and open fracture models in Nf1(flox/flox) and Nf1(flox/-) mice, local AdCre injection significantly impaired bone healing, with fracture union being <50% that of wild type controls. No significant difference was seen between Nf1(flox/flox) and Nf1(flox/-) mice. Histological analyses showed invasion of the Nf1(null) fractures by fibrous and highly proliferative tissue. Mean amounts of fibrous tissue were increased upward of 10-fold in Nf1(null) fractures and bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) staining in closed fractures showed increased numbers of proliferating cells. In Nf1(null) fractures, tartrate-resistant acid phosphatase-positive (TRAP+) cells were frequently observed within the fibrous tissue, not lining a bone surface. In summary, we report that local Nf1 deletion in a fracture callus is sufficient to impair bony union and recapitulate histological features of clinical CPT. Cell culture findings support the concept that Nf1 double inactivation impairs early osteoblastic differentiation. This model provides valuable insight into the pathobiology of the disease, and will be helpful for trialing therapeutic compounds.

Histopathologic retrieval analysis of clinically failed porous tantalum osteonecrosis implants

BACKGROUND

An Osteonecrosis Intervention Implant made of porous tantalum was recently developed to provide structural support and a compatible surface for tissue ingrowth in osteonecrotic femoral heads. From an investigational device exemption study that comprised 113 implants, we carried out a retrieval analysis of clinically failed implants.

METHODS

Seventeen porous tantalum implants that had been used for the treatment of Steinberg stage-II osteonecrosis of the hip were retrieved at the time of conversion to a total hip arthroplasty. Fifteen implants that had been transected near the base of the femoral neck with the proximal portion left in situ within the femoral head underwent histopathologic analysis at an average of 13.4 months (range, three to thirty-six months) after implantation.

RESULTS

Residual osteonecrosis was present in fourteen of the fifteen specimens. Fracture of the subchondral bone of the femoral head was present in all instances, and collapse of the femoral head was present in nine instances (60%). Backscattered scanning electron microscopy confirmed the presence of bone ingrowth in thirteen (87%) of the fifteen specimens. The mean extent of bone ingrowth was 1.9% (range, 0% to 4.4%).

CONCLUSIONS

The retrieved implants were associated with little bone ingrowth and insufficient mechanical support of subchondral bone. The implant design, the surgical technique, its application, and the clinical characteristics of candidates for this procedure should continue to be monitored closely.

A physical vapor deposition method for controlled evaluation of biological response to biomaterial chemistry and topography

The purpose of this study was to characterize a technique to effectively mask surface chemistry without modifying surface topography. A thin layer of titanium was deposited by physical vapor deposition (PVD) onto different biomaterial surfaces. Commercially pure titanium disks were equally divided into three groups. Disks were either polished to a mirror finish, grit blasted with alumina particles, or grit blasted and subsequently plasma sprayed with a commercial grade of hydroxyapatite (HA). A subgroup of each of these treatment types was further treated by masking the entire disk surface with a thin layer of commercially pure titanium deposited by PVD. A comparison of surface topography and chemical composition was carried out between disks within each treatment group. Canine marrow cells were seeded on all disk surfaces to determine the stability of the PVD Ti mask under culture conditions. The PVD process did not significantly alter the surface topography of any samples. The thin titanium layer completely masked the underlying chemistry of the plasma sprayed HA surface and the chemistry of the plasma vapor deposited titanium layer did not differ from that of the commercially pure titanium disks. Aliquots obtained from the media during culture did not indicate any significant differences in Ti concentration amongst the Ti and Ti-masked surfaces. The PVD application of a Ti layer on HA coatings formed a stable, durable, and homogenous layer that effectively masked the underlying surface chemistry without altering the surface topography.

New femoral designs: do they influence stress shielding?

Virtually all contemporary cementless femoral hip stems are designed with the goals of achieving immediate and long-term stability, restoring hip mechanics, and minimizing thigh pain. However, the incorporation of features specifically intended to minimize stress-mediated bone resorption (stress shielding) has been variable. Attempts to reduce bone loss through stem design have yielded inconsistent results and, in certain instances, early and catastrophic failure. Prior beliefs regarding the determinants of stress shielding were based upon the qualitative assessment of bone loss using plain radiographs. These are being challenged, particularly with regard to the role of porous coating level. This is in large part due to the refinement and widespread availability of dual-energy xray absorptiometry (DEXA), which allows quantitative assessment of bone mineral density both pre- and postoperatively. The available evidence indicates stem stiffness plays a dominant role. Progressive bone loss through stress shielding has potentially dire consequences. While such problems have not manifested as severe or widespread clinical issues, the preservation of femoral bone stock is an important and desirable goal.

Wear particles from metal-on-metal total hip replacements: effects of implant design and implantation time

Detailed characterization of wear particles is necessary to understand better the implant wear mechanisms and the periprosthetic tissue response. The purposes of the present study were to compare particle characteristics of current with older designs of metal-on-metal (MM) total hip replacements (THRs), and to determine the effect of implantation time on wear particle characteristics. Metal wear particles isolated from periprosthetic tissues from 19 patients with MM THRs of current and older designs and at different implantation times (very short, longer, and very long) were studied using transmission electron microscopy and energy dispersive X-ray analysis. The particles from the current design implants with implantation times of not more than 15 months (very short-term) were almost exclusively round to oval chromium oxide particles. In all other cases, although the predominance was still round to oval chromium oxide particles, greater proportions of cobalt-chromium-molybdenum (Co-Cr-Mo) particles, mainly needle-shaped, were detected. Very long-term THRs implanted for more than 20 years had the highest percentage of needle-shaped Co-Cr-Mo particles. Particle lengths were not markedly different between the different designs and implantation times except for the current design implants of not more than 15 months, which had a significantly smaller mean length of 39 nm. In conclusion, the implant design did not seem to have a significant influence on particle characteristics whereas the implantation time appeared to have the most effect on the particles. It should be noted that, because of the limited number of tissue retrievals available, some uncertainty remains regarding the generality of these findings.

The effect of microstructure on the wear of cobalt-based alloys used in metal-on-metal hip implants

The influence of microstructure on the wear of cobalt-based alloys used in metal-on-metal hip implants was investigated in a boundary lubrication regime designed to represent the conditions that occurred some of the time in vivo. These cobalt-chromium-molybdenum alloys were either wrought, with a total carbon content of 0.05 or 0.23 wt %, cast with a solution-annealing procedure or simply as-cast but not solution annealed. Bars of these different alloy grades were subjected to various heat treatments to develop different microstructures. The wear was evaluated in a linear-tracking reciprocating pin-on-plate apparatus with a 25 per cent bovine serum lubricant. The wear was found to be strongly affected by the dissolved carbon content of the alloys and mostly independent of grain size or the carbide characteristics. The increased carbon in solid solution caused reductions in volumetric wear because carbon helped to stabilize a face-centred cubic crystal structure, thus limiting the amount of strain-induced transformation to a hexagonal close-packed crystal structure. Based on the observed surface twining in and around the contact zone and the potentially detrimental effect of the hexagonal close-packed phase, it was postulated that the wear of cobalt-based alloys in the present study was controlled by a deformation mechanism.

Effect of microstructure on the dry sliding friction behavior of CoCrMo alloys used in metal-on-metal hip implants

The microstructure and its effect on the friction behavior of a medical grade wrought cobalt-chromium-molybdenum (CoCrMo) alloy for surgical implants were studied in this work. In particular, the effects of compression and carbon (C) content on the above characteristics were analyzed. Increasing amounts of deformation resulted in a decrease in the number of annealing twins in the microstructures. In addition, there was an increase in the volume fraction of the hexagonal closed-packed (HCP) phase due to a strain-induced transformation (SIT) from the metastable face-centered cubic (FCC) phase. The high C (HC) alloy had a lower volume fraction of this SIT phase. Friction studies conducted on these alloys revealed a higher coefficient of friction for the HC alloy and no significant effect of SIT on the friction characteristics.

Zoledronic acid causes enhancement of bone growth into porous implants

The effect of zoledronic acid on bone ingrowth was examined in an animal model in which porous tantalum implants were placed bilaterally within the ulnae of seven dogs. Zoledronic acid in saline was administered via a single post-operative intravenous injection at a dose of 0.1 mg/kg. The ulnae were harvested six weeks after surgery. Undecalcified transverse histological sections of the implant-bone interfaces were imaged with backscattered scanning electron microscopy and the percentage of available pore space that was filled with new bone was calculated. The mean extent of bone ingrowth was 6.6% for the control implants and 12.2% for the zoledronic acid-treated implants, an absolute difference of 5.6% (95% confidence interval, 1.2 to 10.1) and a relative difference of 85% which was statistically significant. Individual islands of new bone formation within the implant pores were similar in number in both groups but were 69% larger in the zoledronic acid-treated group. The bisphosphonate zoledronic acid should be further investigated for use in accelerating or enhancing the biological fixation of implants to bone.

Acid-etched microtexture for enhancement of bone growth into porous-coated implants

We designed an in vivo study to determine if the superimposition of a microtexture on the surface of sintered titanium beads affected the extent of bone ingrowth. Cylindrical titanium intramedullary implants were coated with titanium beads to form a porous finish using commercial sintering techniques. A control group of implants was left in the as-sintered condition. The test group was etched in a boiling acidic solution to create an irregular surface over the entire porous coating. Six experimental dogs underwent simultaneous bilateral femoral intramedullary implantation of a control implant and an acid etched implant. At 12 weeks, the implants were harvested in situ and the femora processed for undecalcified, histological examination. Eight transverse serial sections for each implant were analysed by backscattered electron microscopy and the extent of bone ingrowth was quantified by computer-aided image analysis. The extent of bone ingrowth into the control implants was 15.8% while the extent of bone ingrowth into the etched implants was 25.3%, a difference of 60% that was statistically significant.

These results are consistent with other research that documents the positive effect of microtextured surfaces on bone formation at an implant surface. The acid etching process developed for this study represents a simple method for enhancing the potential of commonly available porous coatings for biological fixation.

Relative contributions of chemistry and topography to the osseointegration of hydroxyapatite coatings

The purpose of the current study was to ascertain the relative contributions of surface chemistry and topography to the osseointegration of hydroxyapatite-coated implants. A canine femoral intramedullary implant model was used to compare the osseous response to commercially pure titanium implants that were either polished, grit-blasted, plasma-sprayed with hydroxyapatite, or plasma-sprayed with hydroxyapatite and masked with a very thin layer of titanium using physical vapor deposition (titanium mask). The titanium mask isolated the chemistry of the underlying hydroxyapatite layer without functionally changing its surface topography and morphologic features. At 12 weeks, the bone-implant specimens were prepared for undecalcified thin section histologic evaluation and serial transverse sections were quantified with backscattered scanning electron microscopy for the percentage of bone apposition to the implant surface. Bone apposition averaged 3% for the polished implants and 23% for the grit-blasted implants. Bone apposition to the hydroxyapatite-coated implants averaged 74% whereas bone apposition to the titanium mask implants averaged 59%. Although there was significantly greater osseointegration with the hydroxyapatite-coated implants, 80% of the maximum bone forming response to the implant surfaces developed with the titanium mask implants. This simple, controlled experiment revealed that topography is the dominant factor governing bone apposition to hydroxyapatite-coated implants.

Primary cementless total hip arthroplasty using a modular femoral component: a minimum 6-year follow-up

We evaluated 59 hips that underwent a primary total hip arthroplasty using an S-ROM modular femoral component at a mean follow-up of 101 months (range, 72-145 months). All cases showed radiographic evidence of bone ingrowth, and there were no femoral revisions for aseptic loosening. The Harris hip score improved from a mean of 40 preoperatively to 89 at final follow-up. Some degree of proximal femoral disuse atrophy from stress shielding occurred in 46 hips (78%), and some degree of femoral osteolysis occurred in 25 hips (42%). Only additional follow-up will reveal whether there is a consequence of both types of proximal femoral bone loss.

Femoral remodeling after porous-coated total hip arthroplasty with and without hydroxyapatite-tricalcium phosphate coating: a prospective randomized trial

We prospectively assessed femoral bone remodeling using dual-energy x-ray absorptiometry for 2 years after total hip arthroplasty. Thirty-nine hips were randomized to receive a titanium proximally porous-coated femoral component with or without hydroxyapatite-tricalcium phosphate coating. Although both stems resulted in alterations in the periprosthetic bone mineral density, the hydroxyapatite-tricalcium phosphate coated stems had significantly less femoral bone loss than the uncoated stems at 2-year follow-up. This reduced femoral bone loss may provide short-term and long-term advantages over noncoated stems.

Effects of digestion protocols on the isolation and characterization of metal-metal wear particles. II. Analysis of ion release and particle composition

The isolation of metal wear particles from hip simulator lubricants is important for understanding wear mechanisms and the tissue response to particulate material. Part I of this study demonstrated that isolation protocols involving digestion reagents can chemically attack metal-metal wear particles, reducing their size and changing their shape. In part II of this study, Co and Cr ion concentrations in solution after each digestion protocol were measured by flame atomic absorption spectrometry, and wear particle composition was determined by X-ray analysis spectra. The exposure of wear particles in water to alkaline solutions caused an increasing release of Cr ions in solution with alkaline concentration and time, and a corresponding decrease in particle Cr peak intensity on X-ray spectra. As a result, particles exposed to 12N KOH for 48 h displayed Co peaks and no Cr. In contrast, enzymatic protocols caused a release of Co ions in solution and a corresponding decrease in particle Co peak intensity on X-ray spectra, especially with sodium phosphate as a buffer. However, when isolating particles from 95% serum, there was an initial protective effect of serum proteins, presumably because of their binding to Co and Cr. As a result, the extent of Cr ion release from metal wear particles in 95% serum after alkaline treatments was diminished, although still present, whereas both enzymatic protocols resulted in a negligible release of Co and Cr ions into solution. Particle composition analysis after enzymatic treatments revealed the presence of chromium oxide particles and CoCrMo particles with variable Co/Cr ratios. After alkaline treatments, the chromium oxide particles increasingly disappeared with time and alkaline concentration, demonstrating a change in particle composition after these treatments. This study demonstrated that digestion reagents can induce chemical changes that affect particle composition. Of all the protocols tested, the enzymatic protocols were the least damaging to the particles and appeared to be the best compromise for isolation and characterization of metal particles, especially in 95% serum. Special care on the choice of buffers should be taken when isolating particles from a lower concentration of serum.

Effects of digestion protocols on the isolation and characterization of metal-metal wear particles. I. Analysis of particle size and shape

Isolation of metal wear particles from hip simulator lubricants or tissues surrounding implants is a challenging problem because of small particle size, their tendency to agglomerate, and their potential for chemical degradation by digestion reagents. To provide realistic measurements of size, shape, and composition of metal wear particles, it is important to optimize particle isolation and minimize particle changes due to the effects of the reagents. In this study (Part I of II), transmission electron microscopy (TEM) was used to examine and compare the effects of different isolation protocols, using enzymes or alkaline solutions, on the size and shape of three different types of cobalt-based alloy particles produced from metal-metal bearings. The effect on particle composition was examined in a subsequent study (Part II). Large particles (<1200 nm) were generated by dry abrasion of CoCrMo alloy against itself and small particles (<300 nm) were generated by hip simulator testing of a metal-metal implant pair in the presence of either distilled-deionized water or a 95% bovine serum solution. The reagents changed particle size and to a lesser extent particle shape. For both large particles and small particles generated in water, the changes in size were more extensive after alkaline than after enzymatic protocols and increased with alkaline concentration and time in solution, up to twofold at 2 h and threefold at 48 h. However, when isolating particles from 95% serum, an initial protective effect of serum proteins and/or lipids was observed. Because of this protective effect, there was no significant difference in particle size and shape for both oval and needle-shaped particles after 2 h in 2N KOH and after enzymatic treatments. However, round particles were significantly smaller after 2 h in 2N KOH than after enzymatic treatments. Particle composition may also have been affected by the 2N KOH treatment, as suggested by a difference in particle contrast under TEM, an issue examined in detail in Part II.

Enhancement of bone growth into porous intramedullary implants using non-invasive low intensity ultrasound

An in vivo study was designed to determine if non-invasive low intensity ultrasound could enhance bone growth into porous intramedullary implants. Fully porous intramedullary rods were implanted bilaterally into the ulnae of six dogs. In each dog, one ulna served as a control and the other was treated with 20 min of daily ultrasound stimulation for 6 consecutive weeks. Analysis of serial transverse sections indicated an average of 119% more bone growth into the ultrasound-treated implants compared with the contralateral controls (P < 0.001). In each of the 6 dogs, there was a significantly greater amount of bone ingrowth on the ultrasound-stimulated side. These data indicate a clear potential for externally applied ultrasound therapy to augment biological fixation.

Fibrous tissue ingrowth and attachment to porous tantalum

This study determined the soft tissue attachment strength and extent of ingrowth to a porous tantalum biomaterial. Eight dorsal subcutaneous implants (in two dogs) were evaluated at 4, 8, and 16 weeks. Upon retrieval, all implants were surrounded completely by adherent soft tissue. Implants were harvested with a tissue flap on the cutaneous aspect and peel tested in a servo-hydraulic tensile test machine at a rate of 5 mm/min. Following testing, implants were dehydrated in a solution of basic fuschin, defatted, embedded in methylmethacrylate, and processed for thin-section histology. At 4, 8, and 16 weeks, the attachment strength to porous tantalum was 61, 71, and 89 g/mm respectively. Histologic analysis showed complete tissue ingrowth throughout the porous tantalum implant. Blood vessels were visible at the interface of and within the porous tantalum material. Tissue maturity and vascularity increased with time. The tissue attachment strength to porous tantalum was three- to six-fold greater than was reported in a similar study with porous beads. This study demonstrated that porous tantalum permits rapid ingrowth of vascularized soft tissue, and attains soft tissue attachment strengths greater than with porous beads.

Potential errors in axial alignment using intramedullary instrumentation for total knee arthroplasty

Accurate restoration of normal limb alignment is crucial for the long-term survivorship of total knee arthroplasty (TKA). A mathematical model was used to evaluate the maximum error in varus and valgus alignment that could occur when cutting the tibia or femur during TKA using intramedullary (IM) guides of varying length and diameter. Minor deviations in the insertion point of IM instrumentation during TKA can result in malalignment of several degrees. This error can be minimized by careful attention to the entry point of the IM instrumentation or by increasing the IM rod diameter and length used during primary TKA.

Bone densitometry: influence of prosthetic design and hydroxyapatite coating on regional adaptive bone remodelling

The objective of this prospective study was to determine if bone densitometry can detect disparities in regional adaptive bone remodelling surrounding the cementless porous-coated femoral component of a hip prosthesis in two titanium alloy implants of different design . These prostheses were the S-ROM (n=69) and the Multilock (n=65). The Multilock implants consisted of two groups; 25 had a 50 micron layer of hydroxyapatite (HA) sprayed over the porous surface of the femoral component and the remaining 40 femoral components were not coated with HA. Densitometry was performed with dual energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA) utilizing the LUNAR ORTHO software to analyse the seven Gruen zones. Bone mineral density measurements were obtained within a week of surgery as a baseline reference and at 6, 12, 24, 36 and 48 months thereafter. At 6 months there was significant mineral loss in all Gruen zones in the three prostheses. By 48 months there were differences in mineral loss between the three prostheses. In the zones adjacent to the porous surface, predominantly zones 1 and 7, the S-ROM exhibited 60% less mineral loss than the Multilock in zone 1, and there was no significant difference in zone 7. Compared to the Multilock-HA, the S-ROM lost 35% less mineral in zone 1, but the Multilock lost 70% less mineral than the S-ROM in zone 7. The Multilock-HA lost 37% and 75% less mineral than the Multilock in zones 1 and 7, respectively, i.e., hydroxyapatite coating tended to preserve bone stalk. Using the Gruen zone area measurements provided by the software, the S-ROM had significantly greater bone resorption in zone 7 at 24 months than either of the Multilocks, which did not differ from each other. In conclusion, DXA has shown differences in periprosthetic adaptive bone remodelling between implants of different design and composition as a function of time.

The Otto Aufranc Award. Wear and lubrication of metal-on-metal hip implants

The implication of polyethylene wear particles as the dominant cause of periprosthetic osteolysis has created a resurgence of interest in metal-on-metal implants for total hip arthroplasty because of their potential for improved wear performance. Twenty-two cobalt chromium molybdenum metal-on-metal implants were custom-manufactured and tested in a hip simulator. Accelerated wear occurred within the first million cycles followed by a marked decrease in wear rate to low steady-state values. The volumetric wear at 3 million cycles was very small, ranging from 0.15 to 2.56 mm3 for all implants tested. Larger head-cup clearance and increased surface roughness were associated with increased wear. Independent effects on wear of material processing (wrought, cast) and carbon content were not identified. Implant wear decreased with increasing lambda ratio, a parameter used to relate lubricant film thickness to surface roughness, suggesting some degree of fluid film lubrication during testing. This study provided important insight into the design and engineering parameters that affect the wear behavior of metal-on-metal hip implants and indicated that high quality manufacturing can reproducibly lead to very low wear.

Characteristics of bone ingrowth and interface mechanics of a new porous tantalum biomaterial

We have studied the characteristics of bone ingrowth of a new porous tantalum biomaterial in a simple transcortical canine model using cylindrical implants 5 x 10 mm in size. The material was 75% to 80% porous by volume and had a repeating arrangement of slender interconnecting struts which formed a regular array of dodecahedron-shaped pores. We performed histological studies on two types of material, one with a smaller pore size averaging 430 microm at 4, 16 and 52 weeks and the other with a larger pore size averaging 650 microm at 2, 3, 4, 16 and 52 weeks. Mechanical push-out tests at 4 and 16 weeks were used to assess the shear strength of the bone-implant interface on implants of the smaller pore size. The extent of filling of the pores of the tantalum material with new bone increased from 13% at two weeks to between 42% and 53% at four weeks. By 16 and 52 weeks the average extent of bone ingrowth ranged from 63% to 80%. The tissue response to the small and large pore sizes was similar, with regions of contact between bone and implant increasing with time and with evidence of Haversian remodelling within the pores at later periods. Mechanical tests at four weeks indicated a minimum shear fixation strength of 18.5 MPa, substantially higher than has been obtained with other porous materials with less volumetric porosity. This porous tantalum biomaterial has desirable characteristics for bone ingrowth; further studies are warranted to ascertain its potential for clinical reconstructive orthopaedics.

The osseous response to corundum blasted implant surfaces in a canine hip model

The purpose of this study was to examine the radiographic and histologic response to corundum blasted implant surfaces of varying roughness in a canine total hip arthroplasty model. Three types of tapered femoral implants were made from titanium alloy and were identical in every respect except surface finish. The entire surface of the femoral implant had a 2.9-, 4.2-, or 6.7-micron average surface roughness (Ra) from blasting with 60-, 24-, or 16-grit corundum particles, respectively. Twenty-two stems in 11 dogs were evaluated at 6 months. Twenty-one of the stems showed osseointegration, whereas in one stem a fibrous interface developed. Abundant new periimplant bone formation occurred, particularly within the intramedullary canal where trabeculae spanned implant to endosteal cortex gaps as large as 5 mm. Bone apposition with the 60-, 24-, and 16-grit stems averaged 31.7%, 32%, and 27.9%, respectively; the differences were not statistically significant. However, the pattern of new bone formation was different in that the average length of each region of bone apposition for the 60- and 24-grit surfaces was 50% greater than that for the coarser 16-grit surface. The observations of this study indicate that because of their highly osteoconductive nature, corundum blasted surfaces represent an important and valuable technology for the design of noncemented implants.

Fatigue behavior of titanium femoral hip prosthesis with proximal sleeve-stem modularity

Modular hip prostheses are increasing in variety and utilization. Component stability, high endurance limit, and minimal particulate debris generation are critical for long-term clinical success. The purpose of this study was to characterize the fatigue response and evaluate the in vitro potential for component motion and wear of the S-ROM¿, a Ti-6Al-4V hip prothesis with a modular design based on a Morse taper connection. A fatigue jib was designed to simulate fixation of the device at the sleeve-bone interface only with distal support mainly against the lateral endosteal cortex. Two series of tests were performed in air at room temperature: one with direct vertical loading (to produce high bending moments in the coronal plane) and one with a compounding loading angle directed at 15 degrees out-of-plane (to include torsional physiological loads). Applied loads using a servohydraulic test machine ranged from 5 x BW (body weight) to 9 x BW (1 x BW = 73 kg, approximately 160 lb) at 10 Hz on an Instron apparatus. No mechanical failures were observed on the 11-mm size stems below 6 x BW for in-plane vertical loading, and at or below 7 x BW for out-of-plane loading. Using displacement monitoring with a sensitivity of 35 mum, no measurable slippage or relative motion was detected between the stem and sleeve when they were properly assembled. Examination of the contact areas with scanning electron microscopy releaved random surface modification (an indication of fretting or burnishing) with occasional evidence of transfer of material between stem and sleeve.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Tissue response to porous tantalum acetabular cups: a canine model

This study evaluated the osseous tissue response to a noncemented metal-backed acetabular component made of a new porous tantalum biomaterial. Eleven dogs with bilateral total hip arthroplasties (22 acetabular implants) were studied for a period of 6 months. Thin section histology, high-resolution radiography, and backscattered scanning electron microscopy revealed that all 22 implants had stable bone-implant interfaces. Regions of bone ingrowth were present in all histologic sections. The depth of bone ingrowth varied from 0.2 mm to the maximal limit of 2 mm. Analyzing contiguous regions of interest across the full bone-implant interface, the mean bone ingrowth for all sections was 16.8% +/- 5.7%. In the peripheral regions of the cup where bone-implant contact was most consistent, bone ingrowth averaged 25.1% +/- 10.1%. The data indicate that the porous tantalum material is effective for biologic fixation in the dog and may provide a suitable alternative to other porous materials used in acetabular cup design.

Temporal changes of periprosthetic bone density in patients with a modular noncemented femoral prosthesis

Bone mineral density changes surrounding a porous-coated proximal modular sleeved hip prosthesis were determined as a function of time over a 24-month period. The periprosthetic bone regions were defined by the 7 Gruen zones. Measurements were obtained with a dual-energy x-ray densitometer using a dedicated software program. Inclusion criteria required that the patients had primary implants, were asymptomatic with Harris hip scores of > or =95 for the duration of the study, and showed no radiographic evidence of loosening. The protocol specified that bone measurements be obtained within 1 week after surgery as a baseline reference and at 3, 6, 9, 12, 18, and 24 months thereafter. A total of 111 consecutive patients were enrolled in this ongoing prospective study, of whom 52 had 4 or more measurements after the initial baseline determination for statistical analysis. At 3 months, all zones showed a significant decrease in bone mineral density relative to the baseline measurements, and their mean loss ranged from 6.5% to 11.2%. By 24 months, mineral losses relative to baseline varied from 0 to 11% for Gruen zones 1 to 6. Relative to the 3-month levels, there was no significant change in zones 1, 4, and 6; a significant improvement in zones 3 and 5; and a small but significant loss in zone 2 at 24 months. Gruen zone 7, the medial femoral neck cortex, differed in that it was the site of greatest bone mineral loss, attaining a mean of 20.2% at 24 months. It was found that the amount of periprosthetic mineral loss at 12 months was independent of the initial baseline reference bone mineral levels. Results of this study show the normal temporal bone mineral changes surrounding a proximally modular porouscoated femoral implant. The pattern of change demonstrated may be peculiar to the prosthesis used in this study because it might differ in implants of different design and material composition.

Effect of flexibility of the femoral stem on bone-remodeling and fixation of the stem in a canine total hip arthroplasty model without cement

The purpose of this study was to compare, with regard to fixation of the implant and femoral bone resorption, two fully porous-coated stems of different stiffnesses in a canine total hip arthroplasty model. A bilateral arthroplasty was carried out with insertion of a titanium-alloy stem (which had stiffness properties comparable with those of the canine femur) on one side and with insertion of a composite stem (which was three to fivefold more flexible than the canine femur) on the contralateral side. Eight femora were evaluated at six months and eight, at eighteen months after the operation, to determine the extent of bone ingrowth, periprosthetic cortical area, intracortical porosity, and bone-remodeling. Despite the markedly greater flexibility of the composite stems, no significant difference could be detected (with the numbers available), with regard to the overall degree of femoral stress-shielding, cortical area, or cortical porosity, between these stems and the stiffer, titanium-alloy stems at either time-period. However, the composite stems had less bone ingrowth and more formation of radiopaque lines than did the titanium-alloy stems. At eighteen months, the values for bone ingrowth were 9.7 +/- 5.38 percent (mean and standard deviation) for the composite stems compared with 28.1 +/- 5.31 percent for the titanium-alloy stems (p = 0.003). Furthermore, the histological sections from the femora containing a composite stem showed radiopaque lines indicative of fibrous ingrowth approximately threefold more often than did those from the femora containing a titanium-alloy stem (p = 0.02).

Femoral cement grading in total hip arthroplasty

The current gold standard for primary total hip arthroplasty is a cemented femoral component combined with a porous-coated acetabular component. Barrack and colleagues described a femoral cement mantle grading system which is increasingly being used to evaluate surgical technique and to compare arthroplasty results. The immediate postoperative radiographs of 100 primary total hip arthroplasty cases from five community surgeons were assessed by three observers to evaluate the overall quality of cement technique, the interobserver variability in cement mantle grading, and specific characteristics of the grading system. All three observers agreed on the grading in only 73% of the x-rays (anteroposterior view, 69%; lateral view, 77%). Compared with reports in the literature from specialized hip arthroplasty centers, a very high proportion of the cases had grade C mantles. To gain a balanced perspective of the global effectiveness and longevity of cemented total hip arthroplasty it is important that follow-up studies be reported upon from representative cross sections of the orthopaedic community.

Fatigue fracture of a forged cobalt-chromium-molybdenum femoral component inserted with cement. A report of ten cases

Ten patients who had had a total hip replacement with a forged cobalt-chromium-molybdenum femoral prosthesis (Precoat or Precoat Plus) inserted with cement were seen with a fatigue fracture of the stem an average of fifty months (range, nineteen to seventy-four months) postoperatively. The average age of the patients was sixty-one years (range, forty-three to seventy-three years), and the average weight was ninety-six kilograms (range, seventy to 130 kilograms). Eight patients had had a primary total hip replacement, and two had had a revision; all of the acetabular components had been inserted without cement. Radiographs that had been made before the fracture were available for four of the eight hips that had had a primary replacement; all four had radiographic evidence of debonding of the cement mantle from the proximal end of the stem. This probably caused exaggerated cantilever bending stresses on the proximal aspect of the stem as the distal end of the stem was well fixed. The radiographs of both hips that had had a revision demonstrated a non-union of the greater trochanter, which had resulted in separation at the cement-bone interface at the proximal portion of the femur before the fracture. Scanning electron micrographs of five of the ten fractured prostheses demonstrated a fatigue fracture that began near the anterolateral corner of the prosthesis, through characters that had been etched on the implant with a laser. Metallurgical analysis indicated subsurface voids or inclusions, or both, immediately under the region that had been etched. This finding is consistent with thermal changes to the microstructure of the alloy that probably caused a focal reduction in the material strength. A high proportion (seven) of the ten stems had a poor cement mantle. Also, of the seven small stems that were used, six had been implanted in patients who weighed more than eighty kilograms, so there was relative undersizing of the prostheses. Early debonding of the proximal end of a Precoat femoral prosthesis from the cement mantle may occur as a result of a thin cement mantle, leading to loosening and possibly to early fatigue fracture of the stem if the distal portion of the stem remains solidly fixed in the distal portion of the cement column. On the basis of our experience, we recommend that patients who have radiographic evidence of a debonded Precoat femoral component should be informed of the risk of fatigue fracture of the stem and be followed closely even though there may be no symptoms of loosening of the femoral component.

The effect of heat treatment on the fatigue strength of microknurled Ti-6Al-4V

Microknurling, a high pressure surface indentation technique, was devised as an alternative to traditional heat-bonded porous coatings found on many orthopedic implants designed for fixation by tissue ingrowth. Heat-bonded porous coating can cause at the surface of an implant stress concentrations that reduce fatigue strength. However, microknurling may reduce stress intensification without eliminating it. Thus the purpose of this work was to explore surface thermal/mechanical processing of Ti-6Al-4V to improve the fatigue strength of microknurled specimens via the production of a Ti-6Al-4V dual microstructure. The latter consists of a surface layer of equiaxed grains known to be effective against crack initiation and a bulk microstructure of lamellar grains that possesses optimum fatigue crack propagation resistance. Rotating-bending fatigue tests showed that such a microstructure had some benefits, but this was offset by the reduction in compressive strains imparted to the surface by the heat treatments needed to obtain this microstructure.

Kinematics of the MATCO hip simulator and issues related to wear testing of metal-metal implants

Metal-metal hip implants have been used clinically in Europe to reduce the risk of wear particle induced osteolysis. Joint simulator devices could provide useful information for design improvement of the modern generation of metal-metal hip implants. Early wear results for metal-metal hip specimens were obtained using a MATCO hip simulator. A detailed kinematic analysis was developed for the MATCO simulator and applied to two of the wear experiments to predict the starting surface motion, contact zone and lubricant film thickness. It was shown that points on cup surfaces were not subjected to a reciprocating interaction with the head during wear at the beginning of testing but as wear proceeded, it was suggested that, in some cases, reciprocating interaction did occur on the cup surface. Comparison between simulator and in vivo kinematics suggested a more realistic representation for cup than for head wear. In the simulator, the Hertzian contact zone moved in a circular path over the cup surface and changed in size in correspondence with the applied load. Elastohydrodynamic lubrication was considered to be possible in the simulator, with estimated fluid film thickness as great as 0.1 micron. However, such thick films were not likely to have occurred at the start of the two wear tests which were examined in detail, although some mixed film lubrication might have accounted for the relatively low wear of one of the specimens. The inclusion of kinematic details, contact mechanics and elastohydrodynamic lubrication analysis in simulator testing protocols and in design of metal metal hip implants was recommended.

Engineering issues and wear performance of metal on metal hip implants

A major concern in total hip arthroplasty is the generation of polyethylene wear particles at the articulating surfaces and resulting macrophage mediated periimplant osteolysis. There is renewed interest in metal on metal bearings as a solution to this problem in view of their potential for greatly improved wear performance. Using a commercially available hip simulator, the wear performance of metal on metal femoral head and acetabular cup combinations was evaluated and various parameters affecting metal on metal implant wear were identified. Nine implants custom manufactured from 2 medical grades of CoCrMo alloy (ASTM F1537-95 and F75-92) were tested within bovine serum as the lubricant to 3 million cycles (equivalent to approximately 3 years of service in vivo). The progressive wear of the components was determined by gravimetric methods at approximately every 300,000 cycles. The wear rates were characterized by an initial period of accelerated wear after which a lower steady state wear rate was observed for subsequent cycles. The presence of calcium phosphate films on the component surfaces, the microstructure of the lower carbon, wrought alloy, and increased effective radii (decreased diametral clearances) were identified as factors that may be favorable to improved wear performance. The extent of the effect on wear of each parameter, however, cannot be discerned at this point and necessitates a study in which parametric changes are more tightly controlled. The present study suggests that the use of metal on metal articulating surfaces may mitigate the problem of osteolysis by offering improved wear performance.

Effect of noninvasive low intensity ultrasound on bone growth into porous-coated implants

Noninvasive low intensity ultrasound has been shown to be an effective means of accelerating bone fracture healing in both animal and clinical studies. An in vivo canine study was designed to determine if noninvasive low intensity ultrasound could influence the rate and extent of bone growth into porous-coated implants. Twenty-two pairs of fully porous transcortical implants were inserted bilaterally into the femora of 12 dogs. In each dog, one femur served as a control and the other was subjected to daily ultrasound stimulation for 2, 3, or 4 weeks. Overall, the ultrasound-stimulated implants demonstrated an 18% increase in bone ingrowth compared with their contralateral controls (p = 0.02). Noninvasive low intensity ultrasound had its greatest effect in the first 2-3 weeks of stimulation. At 2 and 3 weeks, the ultrasound-stimulated implants showed 21 and 16% more ingrowth than their respective contralateral controls. Because noninvasive low intensity ultrasound had a positive effect on bone ingrowth in this experimental investigation, further research is suggested to assess the clinical potential for application to noncemented porous-coated total joint replacements.

Comparison of alloys and designs in a hip simulator study of metal on metal implants

Previous studies of metal on metal hip implants have shown that it is possible to obtain substantially lower volumetric wear than with metal on polyethylene pairings. To work toward design optimization, the gravimetric wear of serum lubricated, metal on metal implants was examined in a hip simulator apparatus. Seventeen implant specimens were fabricated from 3 alloys in various combinations of diameter and clearance and wear tested as many as 3 million cycles. Theory was developed to predict the thickness of elastohydrodynamic lubricant films, the linear wear, and wear zone geometry. To help interpret the data, implant diameter and clearance were combined into a single parameter called effective radius. Implants with larger effective radii (6-11 m) tended to experience lower wear, and theory suggested that this was a result of the correspondingly thicker elastohydrodynamic lubricant films providing an enhanced mixed film lubrication. As in most wear testing, the results were scattered but, overall, a low carbon, wrought alloy had lower wear than either a high carbon, cast alloy or a low carbon, commercial alloy. Because of the small number of specimens tested and possible variations in tribologic parameters such as calcium phosphate film formation and surface microgeometry, there was low statistical reliability of the results.

Effect of rotation on periprosthetic bone mineral measurements in a hip phantom

The effect of rotation on the measurement of periprosthetic bone mineral content and bone mineral density using dual energy xray absorptiometry was studied in 9 anatomic specimen femora implanted with noncemented titanium hip prostheses. An apparatus was constructed to permit accurate femoral rotation through an arc of 30 degrees internal to 30 degrees external rotation in 5 degrees increments. Two scans were obtained at each increment of rotation for a total of 26 scans for each implanted femur. Change in bone mineral content and bone mineral density was measured for each of 7 contiguous periimplant regions (Gruen zones). The precision of the paired bone mineral density measurements was 1.7%. In all Gruen zones, the means of bone mineral content and bone mineral density measurements varied within 5% between 15 degrees internal and 15 degrees external rotation. Variation in limb rotation, as might occur with temporal studies of periimplant bone remodeling, can be tolerated within easily controllable limits without excessive error in bone mineral measurements.

Evaluation of bone ingrowth in proximally and extensively porous-coated anatomic medullary locking prostheses retrieved at autopsy

Three proximally (40 per cent) and five extensively (80 per cent) porous-coated anatomic medullary locking femoral components were retrieved from seven cadavera at autopsy. Each component (with the surrounding, intact femur), was sectioned transversely at one-centimeter intervals. Backscattered scanning electron microscopy was used to evaluate circumferentially the interface between the bone and the porous surface of each section. Bone ingrowth was considered to be present within a field when bone was in contact with the outermost layer of the sintered beads, it was detected within the porous space, and it had penetrated the porous space to a depth of at least one bead diameter. All eight components had some bone growth into the porous space. A mean of 35 per cent of the surface of the implants had bone ingrowth. In the areas where bone was present, 67 per cent of the available porous space on the extensively coated stems and 74 per cent on the proximally coated stems contained bone. With both types of implants, the greatest amount of compact bone ingrowth was found at the level where the porous coating ended. Transverse sections obtained at this level frequently demonstrated that bone ingrowth had occurred circumferentially and that the ingrowth was continuous with and an integral part of the femoral cortex. These direct connections to the cortex could be predicted from the appearance of the radiographs. In the most proximal transverse sections of both types of implants, bone was most frequently connected to the medial side and corners of the implant.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

The susceptibility of smooth implant surfaces to periimplant fibrosis and migration of polyethylene wear debris

The purpose of this investigation was to establish whether the tissue response and migration of polyethylene debris differed at noncemented smooth and porous implant surfaces. This was accomplished through 3 separate but closely related studies: (1) a canine cylindrical implant model with smooth and porous surfaces exposed to polyethylene debris; (2) a canine total hip arthroplasty model analyzing the interface between bone and femoral implants with various porous-coating configurations; and (3) a histologic analysis of autopsy-retrieved, human, noncemented hip prostheses with noncircumferential porous coating. The cylindrical implant model involved the placement of split cylinders, 1/2 porous and 1/2 smooth, into the distal femur and proximal tibia of 4 dogs. Four control implants and 10 test implants (chronically exposed to simulated polyethylene debris with a mean size of 4.7 microns) were examined histologically as long as 30 weeks after surgery. The canine hip study involved the study of 54 noncemented hip prostheses at periods of 1, 6, and 24 months. The prostheses possessed 4 different porous surface configurations: 1 with circumferential porous coating, 2 with noncircumferential coating, and 1 without porous coating. The human retrieval analysis involved the study of 7 cadaveric femora (age, 6 months-5 years) implanted with a straight titanium-alloy prosthesis possessing proximal pads of titanium fiber metal on the anterior, posterior, and medial aspects. With all implants in all 3 studies, there was the common finding of bone ingrowth at the porous implant surface and a fibrous interface or periprosthetic cavity around the portion of the implant that was smooth surfaced. The periprosthetic cavity typically was encapsulated by a thin continuous shell of trabecular bone. In addition, polyethylene debris was found to have preferentially migrated along the smooth implant surfaces. In the longer-term canine and human hip retrievals, polyethylene particles in the micron size range were present within histiocytes, whereas larger particles as much as 100 microns were found within foreign-body giant cells. Of importance for the implants from all 3 studies, with the exception of some pronounced cavities on the lateral aspect of the human hip prostheses, the periimplant cavities around the smooth surfaces were not detectable radiographically. This study clearly established a fundamental principle of relative barriers to particulate debris migration. Smooth implant surfaces are more susceptible than porous surfaces to the development of a fibrous tissue filled periimplant cavity and the subsequent migration of polyethylene wear debris.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Concerns with modularity in total hip arthroplasty

Modularity is being diversified in total hip prostheses to increase surgical latitude in optimizing implant fixation and adjusting hip biomechanics. However, several problems have been clearly identified with implant modularity. First generation metal-backed acetabular components have shown deficiencies in the locking mechanism, the congruency and extent of polyethylene liner support, and polyethylene thickness, all of which have been implicated in accelerated polyethylene wear and failure. Evidence of screw motion against the metal backing, release of particulate material, and focal osteolysis have also been observed. At the head/neck junction evidence of corrosion and fretting has been documented with both similar-metal and mixed-metal taper combinations. Femoral prostheses with other sites of modularity present additional concerns with regard to mechanical integrity and generation of particulate debris by fretting. The modular junctions of three hip prostheses, the S-ROM, Infinity, and RMHS, were subjected to wet environment high cycle mechanical testing in a worst-case loading scenario. Preliminary results at relatively low loads up to three times body weight indicated gross stability of the modular junctions with evidence of minor fretting damage. Analysis of water solutions surrounding the modular junctions after ten to 20 million loading cycles yielded counts of one to three micron sized particles totalling several hundred thousand to several million. It is unknown what quantity of particulate material is sufficient to cause macrophage-mediated osteolysis or whether the debris from modular junctions can cause third-body wear of the articulating surfaces. Modular hip prostheses should be examined under stringent test conditions in order to characterize their fretting behavior and establish their mechanical limitations.

Mechanical compatibility of noncemented hip prostheses with the human femur

It is generally accepted that more flexible implants are needed to reduce stress shielding and postoperative thigh pain. However, there is no detailed information on the stiffness of currently used implants relative to the human femur. The purpose of this study was to determine the stiffness characteristics (bending, torsional, and axial) of human femora relative to commercially available prostheses as a first step in assessing the mechanical compatibility of the implants. This was achieved by computerized tomography scanning of a collection of human femora from proximal to distal at 10 mm intervals, digitizing the cross-sectional contours, and calculating the stiffness characteristics of each section using standard beam theory. The results show that significant stiffness mismatches exist, especially for larger stem sizes and for stems fabricated from cobalt-chrome alloy. Interestingly, certain implant stiffness values are lower than those of the femur for stems up to 15 mm in diameter, substantially so if the implant is made from titanium alloy and incorporates design features that reduce area and moments of inertia. The data suggest that only larger implant sizes need to be adjusted for increased flexibility compared with current stands.

Quantification of implant micromotion, strain shielding, and bone resorption with porous-coated anatomic medullary locking femoral prostheses

Fourteen femora containing porous-coated anatomic medullary locking (AML) femoral prostheses were retrieved from 12 patients at autopsy. Clinical roentgenograms in 13 femora showed bone remodeling changes, indicating that the implants were fixed by osseointegration. Under simulated physiologic loading, micromotion between the implant and the bone was measured using electrical displacement transducers connected to the implant and to the adjacent cortex. The micromotion between the implants at the areas of porous coating and the adjacent cortex in the one case of failed bone ingrowth measured 150 microns. Maximum relative motion between the cortex and the implant in the areas of porous coating for the 13 cases showing signs of bone ingrowth was 40 microns, and this was completely elastic relative displacement. With all implants, the micromotion between the cortex and the stem was always greatest over the uncoated portion of the stem. Four of the implants were proximally porous coated. With these, the micromotion was greater over the uncoated areas than with more extensively coated stems and was always greatest at the uncoated tip of the prosthesis. The amount of micromotion was directly related to the extent of porous coating on the implant. Maximum tip motion for the proximally coated implants was 210 micra, whereas for the fully porous-coated implants, it was 40 microns. In nine of the autopsies, the contralateral normal femur was obtained in addition to the femur containing the AML (the in vivo remodeled femur). These were used for comparative studies of strain shielding and femoral remodeling. Cortical strains were measured in the in vivo remodeled femora and were compared with measurements made in the contralateral normal femora before and following implantation of a stem identical to that present on the clinically treated side. The data showed major strain reductions in all the postmortem implanted normal femora. Comparison of the strain data from the postmortem implanted normal femora with those from the in vivo remodeled femora clearly indicated that extensive bone remodeling did not result in restoration of cortical strain levels anywhere near normal. Strain shielding continued to exist in all of the remodeled specimens, even up to 7.5 years after surgery. This strain shielding was associated with bone remodeling changes that resulted in regional reductions in bone mineral content that ranged from 7% to 78%. These observations are unique, important, and valuable in defining the in vivo function and clinical behavior of this type of porous-coated femoral component.

A quantitative evaluation of periprosthetic bone-remodeling after cementless total hip arthroplasty

Dual-energy x-ray absorptiometry analysis was used to determine the periprosthetic bone-mineral content of ten femora that had been obtained at the autopsies of five elderly patients who had had an AML (anatomic medullary locking) prosthesis in situ for seventeen to eighty-four months. Clinical radiographs showed resorptive remodeling changes characteristic of femora containing this implant. Before the absorptiometry was performed, an identical prosthesis had been inserted into the contralateral, normal femur of each cadaver. The mean difference in the periprosthetic bone-mineral content between the remodeled femora and the femora in which the prosthesis had been implanted post mortem ranged from 7 to 52 per cent, with the bone-mineral content always less in the remodeled femora. The greatest mean decrease in bone-mineral content (45 per cent) occurred adjacent to the proximal one-third of the remodeled femora. The percentage decrease in periprosthetic bone-mineral content in the remodeled femora had an inverse linear relationship with the corresponding bone-mineral content of the contralateral control femora. Preoperative analysis of bone density may therefore be useful for prediction of the extent of resorptive bone-remodeling after total hip replacement.

Evaluation of metallic personalized hemiarthroplasty: a canine patellofemoral model

The purpose of this study was to characterize the response of articular cartilage to weight bearing against a metallic personalized hemiarthroplasty prosthesis. Ten dogs each underwent surgery in which an elastomeric replica of the left femoral patellar groove was made. Using this replica, a 0.5-mm-thick prosthesis was cast in Co-Cr alloy and subsequently the surface was polished to a mirror finish which had a center line average roughness value in the range of human hemiarthroplasty implants. A second surgery was performed to resurface the left trochlea with this prosthesis. Five animals were sacrificed at 3 months and 5 at 6 months. Cartilage damage occurred primarily in the distal region of the patella, and was especially evident at 6 months. Mechanical indentation tests conducted on patellar cartilage in a saline bath at 37 degrees C indicated both increased deformation and residual deformation in the affected areas, indicative of degenerative change. Areas of fibrillation with a depletion of proteoglycans were identified histologically. These areas were only superficial at 3 months but became more extensive at 6 months. Rheological analysis of the synovial fluid of tests joints indicated that a decrease in viscosity occurred from 3 to 6 months, an additional indicator of progressive degeneration. This novel implant model showed that even if a metallic hemiarthroplasty implant had an identical geometry as the joint surface being replaced and had a reasonably smooth surface, cartilage degeneration inevitably resulted.

Producing and avoiding stress shielding. Laboratory and clinical observations of noncemented total hip arthroplasty

Experimental canine model studies of stiff versus flexible, fully porous-coated, metallic femoral stems (differing by three- to fivefold in stiffness characteristics) revealed markedly different resorptive bone remodeling patterns. The flexible stem resulted in about 30% more cortical bone retention adjacent to the implant at one-year postimplantation and larger differences in dogs killed two and three years after surgery. Strain-gauge studies confirmed that there are differences in cortical bone strains with the two stem designs, the flexible stem producing a more uniform and more nearly normal strain distribution medially. Differences in cortical bone remodeling were quantified using dual energy X-ray absorptiometry (DEXA). The bone mineral content in femora with the flexible stem decreased less than 20%, compared to normal. At three years postimplantation, the bone mineral content of the femora with the stiff stem was about 50% that of the femora with the flexible stem. Clinically, DEXA revealed that 5%-15% changes in bone mineral density at various periimplant sites were common within the first two years after surgery; these changes were not usually evident roentgenographically. Serial roentgenographically distinct bone resorption was usually associated with bone mineral density changes of 20%-50%. Five- to 13-year roentgenographic follow-up observations of 213 cases with the Anatomic Medullary Locking prosthesis showed that pronounced bone resorption occurred in 33% of patients. Larger stems (greater than 13 mm in diameter) and stems with extensive porous coating had a significantly higher incidence of pronounced bone resorption than smaller stems and those with proximal coating. The stiffness characteristics of the human femur were established as a function of canal size and compared with those of noncemented hip prostheses. Increased mechanical compatibility was found for stems made of titanium alloy and with design features that reduce cross-sectional area and moment of inertia. Clinical data suggest that to reduce the likelihood of pronounced bone resorption, it would be beneficial for the implant to possess a bending stiffness of about one half to one third that of the human femur.

Results of implant retrieval from postmortem specimens in patients with well-functioning, long-term total hip replacement

The evaluation of postmortem specimens provides a unique opportunity to gain understanding of the interface between host and well-functioning prostheses unavailable from revision specimens that, by nature, are accompanied by the artifacts generated during their removal. The preliminary findings from the relatively limited number of specimens described in this collaborative study demonstrate the value of the effort and are presented to encourage surgeons to participate in this program and to make their patients aware of the value of the information they may provide.