Clinical Prediction Models and Predictors for Death or Adverse Neurodevelopmental Outcome in Term Newborns with Hypoxic-Ischemic Encephalopathy: A Systematic Review of the Literature

BACKGROUND

Although many predictive parameters have been studied, an internationally accepted, validated predictive model to predict the clinical outcome of asphyxiated infants suffering from hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy is currently lacking. The aim of this study was to identify, appraise and summarize available clinical prediction models, and provide an overview of all investigated predictors for the outcome death or neurodevelopmental impairment in this population.

METHODS

A systematic literature search was performed in Medline and Embase. Two reviewers independently included eligible studies and extracted data. The quality was assessed using PROBAST for prediction model studies and QUIPS assessment tools for predictor studies.

RESULTS

A total of nine prediction models were included. These models were very heterogeneous in number of predictors assessed, methods of model derivation, and primary outcomes. All studies had a high risk of bias following the PROBAST assessment and low applicability due to complex model presentation. A total of 104 predictor studies were included investigating various predictors, showing tremendous heterogeneity in investigated predictors, timing of predictors, primary outcomes, results, and methodological quality according to QUIPS. Selected high-quality studies with accurate discriminating performance provide clinicians and researchers an evidence map of predictors for prognostication after HIE in newborns.

CONCLUSION

Given the low methodological quality of the currently published clinical prediction models, implementation into clinical practice is not yet possible. Therefore, there is an urgent need to develop a prediction model which complies with the PROBAST guideline. An overview of potential predictors to include in a prediction model is presented.

[The importance of administering vitamin K intramuscularly in neonates]

BACKGROUND

Infants who are born in The Netherlands receive oral vitamin K to prevent bleeding due to a vitamin K deficiency. However the incidence of such bleedings are higher compared to other European countries. Therefore, the Dutch Health Council advised in 2017 to change this guideline from oral to intramuscular administration.

CASE DESCRIPTION

A 2 months old girl presented with a fatal intracranial hemorrhage. A day before she developed a hematoma on her foot and orbit. Despite daily oral vitamin K, blood results revealed a severe vitamin K deficiency-related bleeding. Postmortem liver biopsy and genetic studies showed cholestasis as the most likely cause of malabsorption of fat soluble vitamins due to a heterozygous pathogenic variant in the ABCB11 gene, which could possibly be transient.

CONCLUSION

Our case illustrates the importance of revising the national guideline for vitamin K prophylaxis to intramuscular administration, according to the recommendation of the Dutch Health Council.

Hepatic symptoms and histology in 13 patients with a Zellweger spectrum disorder

Patients with a Zellweger spectrum disorder (ZSD) have a defect in the assembly or maintenance of peroxisomes, leading to a multisystem disease with variable outcome. Liver disease is an important feature in patients with severe and milder phenotypes and a frequent cause of death. However, the course and histology of liver disease in ZSD patients are ill-defined. We reviewed the hepatic symptoms and histological findings of 13 patients with a ZSD in which one or several liver biopsies have been performed (patient age 0.2-39 years). All patients had at least some histological liver abnormalities, ranging from minor fibrosis to cirrhosis. Five patients demonstrated significant disease progression with liver failure and early death. In others, liver-related symptoms were absent, although some still silently developed cirrhosis. Patients with peroxisomal mosaicism had a better prognosis. In addition, we show that patients are at risk to develop a hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC), as one patient developed a HCC at the age of 36 years and one patient a precancerous lesion at the age of 18 years. Thus, regular examination to detect fibrosis or cirrhosis should be included in the standard care of ZSD patients. In case of advanced fibrosis/cirrhosis expert consultation and HCC screening should be initiated. This study further delineates the spectrum and significance of liver involvement in ZSDs.

Liver disease predominates in a mouse model for mild human Zellweger spectrum disorder

Zellweger spectrum disorders (ZSDs) are autosomal recessive diseases caused by defective peroxisome assembly. They constitute a clinical continuum from severe early lethal to relatively milder presentations in adulthood. Liver disease is a prevalent symptom in ZSD patients. The underlying pathogenesis for the liver disease, however, is not fully understood. We report a hypomorphic ZSD mouse model, which is homozygous for Pex1-c.2531G>A (p.G844D), the equivalent of the most common pathogenic variant found in ZSD, and which predominantly presents with liver disease. After introducing the Pex1-G844D allele by knock-in, we characterized homozygous Pex1-G844D mice for survival, biochemical parameters, including peroxisomal and mitochondrial functions, organ histology, and developmental parameters. The first 20 post-natal days (P20) were critical for survival of homozygous Pex1-G844D mice (~20% survival rate). Lethality was likely due to a combination of cholestatic liver problems, liver dysfunction and caloric deficit, probably as a consequence of defective bile acid biosynthesis. Survival beyond P20 was nearly 100%, but surviving mice showed a marked delay in growth. Surviving mice showed similar hepatic problems as described for mild ZSD patients, including hepatomegaly, bile duct proliferation, liver fibrosis and mitochondrial alterations. Biochemical analyses of various tissues showed the absence of functional peroxisomes accompanied with aberrant levels of peroxisomal metabolites predominantly in the liver, while other tissues were relatively spared. ur findings show that homozygous Pex1-G844D mice have a predominant liver disease phenotype, mimicking the hepatic pathology of ZSD patients, and thus constitute a good model to study pathogenesis and treatment of liver disease in ZSD patients.

The cholic acid extension study in Zellweger spectrum disorders: Results and implications for therapy

INTRODUCTION

Currently, no therapies are available for Zellweger spectrum disorders (ZSDs), a group of genetic metabolic disorders characterised by a deficiency of functional peroxisomes. In a previous study, we showed that oral cholic acid (CA) treatment can suppress bile acid synthesis in ZSD patients and, thereby, decrease plasma levels of toxic C₂₇ -bile acid intermediates, one of the biochemical abnormalities in these patients. However, no effect on clinically relevant outcome measures could be observed after 9 months of CA treatment. It was noted that, in patients with advanced liver disease, caution is needed because of possible hepatotoxicity.

METHODS

An extension study of the previously conducted pretest-posttest design study was conducted including 17 patients with a ZSD. All patients received oral CA for an additional period of 12 months, encompassing a total of 21 months of treatment. Multiple clinically relevant parameters and markers for bile acid synthesis were assessed after 15 and 21 months of treatment.

RESULTS

Bile acid synthesis was still suppressed after 21 months of CA treatment, accompanied with reduced levels of C₂₇ -bile acid intermediates in plasma. These levels significantly increased again after discontinuation of CA. No significant changes were found in liver tests, liver elasticity, coagulation parameters, fat-soluble vitamin levels or body weight.

CONCLUSIONS

Although CA treatment did lead to reduced levels of toxic C₂₇ -bile acid intermediates in ZSD patients without severe liver fibrosis or cirrhosis, no improvement of clinically relevant parameters was observed after 21 months of treatment. We discuss the implications for CA therapy in ZSD based on these results.

Cholic acid therapy in Zellweger spectrum disorders

INTRODUCTION

Zellweger spectrum disorders (ZSDs) are characterized by a failure in peroxisome formation, caused by autosomal recessive mutations in different PEX genes. At least some of the progressive and irreversible clinical abnormalities in patients with a ZSD, particularly liver dysfunction, are likely caused by the accumulation of toxic bile acid intermediates. We investigated whether cholic acid supplementation can suppress bile acid synthesis, reduce accumulation of toxic bile acid intermediates and improve liver function in these patients.

METHODS

An open label, pretest-posttest design study was conducted including 19 patients with a ZSD. Participants were followed longitudinally during a period of 2.5 years prior to the start of the intervention. Subsequently, all patients received oral cholic acid and were followed during 9 months of treatment. Bile acids, peroxisomal metabolites, liver function and liver stiffness were measured at baseline and 4, 12 and 36 weeks after start of cholic acid treatment.

RESULTS

During cholic acid treatment, bile acid synthesis decreased in the majority of patients. Reduced levels of bile acid intermediates were found in plasma and excretion of bile acid intermediates in urine was diminished. In patients with advanced liver disease (n = 4), cholic acid treatment resulted in increased levels of plasma transaminases, bilirubin and cholic acid with only a minor reduction in bile acid intermediates.

CONCLUSIONS

Oral cholic acid therapy can be used in the majority of patients with a ZSD, leading to at least partial suppression of bile acid synthesis. However, caution is needed in patients with advanced liver disease due to possible hepatotoxic effects.

Zellweger spectrum disorders: clinical manifestations in patients surviving into adulthood

INTRODUCTION

We describe the natural history of patients with a Zellweger spectrum disorder (ZSD) surviving into adulthood.

METHODS

Retrospective cohort study in patients with a genetically confirmed ZSD.

RESULTS

All patients (n = 19; aged 16-35 years) had a follow-up period of 1-24.4 years (mean 16 years). Seven patients had a progressive disease course, while 12 remained clinically stable during follow-up. Disease progression usually manifests in adolescence as a gait disorder, caused by central and/or peripheral nervous system involvement. Nine were capable of living a partly independent life with supported employment. Systematic MRI review revealed T2 hyperintense white matter abnormalities in the hilus of the dentate nucleus and/or peridentate region in nine out of 16 patients. Biochemical analyses in blood showed abnormal peroxisomal biomarkers in all patients in infancy and childhood, whereas in adolescence/adulthood we observed normalization of some metabolites.

CONCLUSIONS

The patients described here represent a distinct subgroup within the ZSDs who survive into adulthood. Most remain stable over many years. Disease progression may occur and is mainly due to cerebral and cerebellar white matter abnormalities, and peripheral neuropathy.

Zellweger spectrum disorders: clinical overview and management approach

Zellweger spectrum disorders (ZSDs) represent the major subgroup within the peroxisomal biogenesis disorders caused by defects in PEX genes. The Zellweger spectrum is a clinical and biochemical continuum which can roughly be divided into three clinical phenotypes. Patients can present in the neonatal period with severe symptoms or later in life during adolescence or adulthood with only minor features. A defect of functional peroxisomes results in several metabolic abnormalities, which in most cases can be detected in blood and urine. There is currently no curative therapy, but supportive care is available. This review focuses on the management of patients with a ZSD and provides recommendations for supportive therapeutic options for all those involved in the care for ZSD patients.

High prevalence of primary adrenal insufficiency in Zellweger spectrum disorders

Zellweger spectrum disorders are a group of autosomal recessive disorders characterized by impaired peroxisome functions. The clinical spectrum is broad, ranging from the classical most severe Zellweger syndrome to patients with a relatively mild phenotype. Treatment options are limited to symptomatic and supportive therapy. During routine follow-up we discovered patients with asymptomatic primary adrenal insufficiency. It is important to detect impaired adrenal function because it has treatment implications. Primary adrenal insufficiency was found in 7/24 patients examined, with 4/7 being asymptomatic. Systematic evaluation of adrenal function, through a Synacthen test, should be included in the clinical management of these patients.

Arginine improves peroxisome functioning in cells from patients with a mild peroxisome biogenesis disorder

Background

Zellweger spectrum disorders (ZSDs) are multisystem genetic disorders caused by a lack of functional peroxisomes, due to mutations in one of the PEX genes, encoding proteins involved in peroxisome biogenesis. The phenotypic spectrum of ZSDs ranges from an early lethal form to much milder presentations. In cultured skin fibroblasts from mildly affected patients, peroxisome biogenesis can be partially impaired which results in a mosaic catalase immunofluorescence pattern. This peroxisomal mosaicism has been described for specific missense mutations in various PEX genes. In cell lines displaying peroxisomal mosaicism, peroxisome biogenesis can be improved when these are cultured at 30°C. This suggests that these missense mutations affect the folding and/or stability of the encoded protein. We have studied if the function of mutant PEX1, PEX6 and PEX12 can be improved by promoting protein folding using the chemical chaperone arginine.

Methods

Fibroblasts from three PEX1 patients, one PEX6 and one PEX12 patient were cultured in the presence of different concentrations of arginine. To determine the effect on peroxisome biogenesis we studied the following parameters: number of peroxisome-positive cells, levels of PEX1 protein and processed thiolase, and the capacity to β-oxidize very long chain fatty acids and pristanic acid.

Results

Peroxisome biogenesis and function in fibroblasts with mild missense mutations in PEX1, 6 and 12 can be improved by arginine.

Conclusion

Arginine may be an interesting compound to promote peroxisome function in patients with a mild peroxisome biogenesis disorder.