Thrombin has dual trypsin-like and chymotrypsin-like specificity

BACKGROUND

The residue at the site of activation of protein C is Arg in all species except the ray-finned fish, where it is Trp. This feature raises the question of whether thrombin is the physiological activator of protein C across vertebrates.

OBJECTIVES

To establish if thrombin can cleave at Trp residues.

METHODS

The activity of wild-type thrombin and mutant D189S was tested with a library of chromogenic substrates and toward wild-type protein C and mutants carrying substitutions at the site of cleavage.

RESULTS

Thrombin has trypsin-like and chymotrypsin-like specificity and cleaves substrates at Arg or Trp residues. Cleavage at Arg is preferred, but cleavage at Trp is significant and comparable with that of chymotrypsin. The D189S mutant of thrombin has broad specificity and cleaves at basic and aromatic residues without significant preference. Thrombin also cleaves natural substrates at Arg or Trp residues, showing activity toward protein C across vertebrates, including the ray-finned fish. The rate of activation of protein C in the ray-finned fish is affected by the sequence preceding Trp at the scissile bond.

CONCLUSION

The results provide a possible solution for the paradoxical presence of a Trp residue at the site of cleavage of protein C in ray-finned fish and support thrombin as the physiological activator of protein C in all vertebrates. The dual trypsin-like and chymotrypsin-like specificity of thrombin suggests that the spectrum of physiological substrates of this enzyme is broader currently assumed.

Structural architecture of the acidic region of the B domain of coagulation factor V

BACKGROUND

Coagulation factor (F)V features an A1-A2-B-A3-C1-C2 domain organization and functions as the inactive precursor of FVa, a component of the prothrombinase complex required for rapid thrombin generation in the penultimate step of the coagulation cascade. An intramolecular interaction within the large B domain (residues 710-1545) involves the basic region (BR, residues 963-1008) and acidic region (AR, residues 1493-1537) and locks FV in its inactive state. However, structural information on this important regulatory interaction or on the separate architecture of the AR and BR remains elusive due to conformational disorder of the B domain.

OBJECTIVES

To reveal the structure of the BR-AR interaction or of its separate components.

METHODS

The structure of FV is solved by cryogenic electron microscopy.

RESULTS

A new 3.05 Å resolution cryogenic electron microscopy structure of FV confirms the overall organization of the A and C domains but resolves the segment 1507 to 1545 within a largely disordered B domain. The segment contains most of the AR and is organized as recently reported in FV short, a spliced variant of FV with a significantly shorter and less disordered B domain.

CONCLUSION

The similar architecture of the AR in FV and FV short provides structural context for physiologically important interactions of this region with the BR in FV and with the basic C-terminal end of tissue factor pathway inhibitor α in FV short.

Cryo-EM structure of coagulation factor V short

Coagulation factor V (fV) is the precursor of activated fV (fVa), an essential component of the prothrombinase complex required for the rapid activation of prothrombin in the penultimate step of the coagulation cascade. In addition, fV regulates the tissue factor pathway inhibitor α (TFPIα) and protein C pathways that inhibit the coagulation response. A recent cryogenic electron microscopy (cryo-EM) structure of fV has revealed the architecture of its A1-A2-B-A3-C1-C2 assembly but left the mechanism that keeps fV in its inactive state unresolved because of an intrinsic disorder in the B domain. A splice variant of fV, fV short, carries a large deletion of the B domain that produces constitutive fVa-like activity and unmasks epitopes for the binding of TFPIα. The cryo-EM structure of fV short was solved at 3.2 Å resolution and revealed the arrangement of the entire A1-A2-B-A3-C1-C2 assembly. The shorter B domain stretches across the entire width of the protein, making contacts with the A1, A2, and A3 domains but suspended over the C1 and C2 domains. In the portion distal to the splice site, several hydrophobic clusters and acidic residues provide a potential binding site for the basic C-terminal end of TFPIα. In fV, these epitopes may bind intramolecularly to the basic region of the B domain. The cryo-EM structure reported in this study advances our understanding of the mechanism that keeps fV in its inactive state, provides new targets for mutagenesis and facilitates future structural analysis of fV short in complex with TFPIα, protein S, and fXa.

Cryo-EM structures of coagulation factors

A State of the Art lecture titled "Cryo-EM structures of coagulation factors" was presented at the ISTH Congress in 2022. Cryogenic electron microscopy (cryo-EM) is a revolutionary technique capable of solving the structure of high molecular weight proteins and their complexes, unlike nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR), and under conditions not biased by crystal contacts, unlike X-ray crystallography. These features are particularly relevant to the analysis of coagulation factors that are too big for NMR and often recalcitrant to X-ray investigation. Using cryo-EM, we have solved the structures of coagulation factors V and Va, prothrombinase on nanodiscs, and the prothrombin-prothrombinase complex. These structures have advanced basic knowledge in the field of thrombosis and hemostasis, especially on the function of factor V and the molecular mechanism for prothrombin activation, and set the stage for exciting new lines of investigation. Finally, we summarize relevant new data on this topic presented during the 2022 ISTH Congress.

The active site region plays a critical role in Na+ binding to thrombin

The catalytic activity of thrombin and other enzymes of the blood coagulation and complement cascades is enhanced significantly by binding of Na+ to a site >15 Å away from the catalytic residue S195, buried within the 180 and 220 loops that also contribute to the primary specificity of the enzyme. Rapid kinetics support a binding mechanism of conformational selection where the Na+-binding site is in equilibrium between open (N) and closed (N∗) forms and the cation binds selectively to the N form. Allosteric transduction of this binding step produces enhanced catalytic activity. Molecular details on how Na+ gains access to this site and communicates allosterically with the active site remain poorly defined. In this study, we show that the rate of the N∗→N transition is strongly correlated with the analogous E∗→E transition that governs the interaction of synthetic and physiologic substrates with the active site. This correlation supports the active site as the likely point of entry for Na+ to its binding site. Mutagenesis and structural data rule out an alternative path through the pore defined by the 180 and 220 loops. We suggest that the active site communicates allosterically with the Na+ site through a network of H-bonded water molecules that embeds the primary specificity pocket. Perturbation of the mobility of S195 and its H-bonding capabilities alters interaction with this network and influences the kinetics of Na+ binding and allosteric transduction. These findings have general mechanistic relevance for Na+-activated proteases and allosteric enzymes.

Zymogen and activated protein C have similar structural architecture

Activated protein C is a trypsin-like protease with anticoagulant and cytoprotective properties that is generated by thrombin from the zymogen precursor protein C in a reaction greatly accelerated by the cofactor thrombomodulin. The molecular details of this activation remain elusive due to the lack of structural information. We now fill this gap by providing information on the overall structural organization of these proteins using single molecule FRET and small angle X-ray scattering. Under physiological conditions, both zymogen and protease adopt a conformation with all domains vertically aligned along an axis 76 Å long and maximal particle size of 120 Å. This conformation is stabilized by binding of Ca2+ to the Gla domain and is affected minimally by interaction with thrombin. Hence, the zymogen protein C likely interacts with the thrombin-thrombomodulin complex through a rigid body association that produces a protease with essentially the same structural architecture. This scenario stands in contrast to an analogous reaction in the coagulation cascade where conversion of the zymogen prothrombin to the protease meizothrombin by the prothrombinase complex is linked to a large conformational transition of the entire protein. The presence of rigid epidermal growth factor domains in protein C as opposed to kringles in prothrombin likely accounts for the different conformational plasticity of the two zymogens. The new structural features reported here for protein C have general relevance to vitamin K-dependent clotting factors containing epidermal growth factor domains, such as factors VII, IX, and X.

Role of the activation peptide in the mechanism of protein C activation

Protein C is a natural anticoagulant activated by thrombin in a reaction accelerated by the cofactor thrombomodulin. The zymogen to protease conversion of protein C involves removal of a short activation peptide that, relative to the analogous sequence present in other vitamin K-dependent proteins, contains a disproportionately high number of acidic residues. Through a combination of bioinformatic, mutagenesis and kinetic approaches we demonstrate that the peculiar clustering of acidic residues increases the intrinsic disorder propensity of the activation peptide and adversely affects the rate of activation. Charge neutralization of the acidic residues in the activation peptide through Ala mutagenesis results in a mutant activated by thrombin significantly faster than wild type. Importantly, the mutant is also activated effectively by other coagulation factors, suggesting that the acidic cluster serves a protective role against unwanted proteolysis by endogenous proteases. We have also identified an important H-bond between residues T176 and Y226 that is critical to transduce the inhibitory effect of Ca2+ and the stimulatory effect of thrombomodulin on the rate of zymogen activation. These findings offer new insights on the role of the activation peptide in the function of protein C.

Probing prothrombin structure by limited proteolysis

Prothrombin, or coagulation factor II, is a multidomain zymogen precursor of thrombin that undergoes an allosteric equilibrium between two alternative conformations, open and closed, that react differently with the physiological activator prothrombinase. Specifically, the dominant closed form promotes cleavage at R320 and initiates activation along the meizothrombin pathway, whilst the open form promotes cleavage at R271 and initiates activation along the alternative prethrombin-2 pathway. Here we report how key structural features of prothrombin can be monitored by limited proteolysis with chymotrypsin that attacks W468 in the flexible autolysis loop of the protease domain in the open but not the closed form. Perturbation of prothrombin by selective removal of its constituent Gla domain, kringles and linkers reveals their long-range communication and supports a scenario where stabilization of the open form switches the pathway of activation from meizothrombin to prethrombin-2. We also identify R296 in the A chain of the protease domain as a critical link between the allosteric open-closed equilibrium and exposure of the sites of cleavage at R271 and R320. These findings reveal important new details on the molecular basis of prothrombin function.

Enhancing the anticoagulant profile of meizothrombin

Meizothrombin is an active intermediate generated during the proteolytic activation of prothrombin to thrombin in the penultimate step of the coagulation cascade. Structurally, meizothrombin differs from thrombin because it retains the auxiliary Gla domain and two kringles. Functionally, meizothrombin shares with thrombin the ability to cleave procoagulant (fibrinogen), prothrombotic (PAR1) and anticoagulant (protein C) substrates, although its specificity toward fibrinogen and PAR1 is less pronounced. In this study we report information on the structural architecture of meizothrombin resolved by SAXS and single molecule FRET as an elongated arrangement of its individual domains. In addition, we show the properties of a meizothrombin construct analogous to the anticoagulant thrombin mutant W215A/E217A currently in Phase I for the treatment of thrombotic complications and stroke. The findings reveal new structural and functional aspects of meizothrombin that advance our understanding of a key intermediate of the prothrombin activation pathway.

Interplay between conformational selection and zymogen activation

Trypsin-like proteases are synthesized as zymogens and activated through a mechanism that folds the active site for efficient binding and catalysis. Ligand binding to the active site is therefore a valuable source of information on the changes that accompany zymogen activation. Using the physiologically relevant transition of the clotting zymogen prothrombin to the mature protease thrombin, we show that the mechanism of ligand recognition follows selection within a pre-existing ensemble of conformations with the active site accessible (E) or inaccessible (E*) to binding. Prothrombin exists mainly in the E* conformational ensemble and conversion to thrombin produces two dominant changes: a progressive shift toward the E conformational ensemble triggered by removal of the auxiliary domains upon cleavage at R271 and a drastic drop of the rate of ligand dissociation from the active site triggered by cleavage at R320. Together, these effects produce a significant (700-fold) increase in binding affinity. Limited proteolysis reveals how the E*-E equilibrium shifts during prothrombin activation and influences exposure of the sites of cleavage at R271 and R320. These new findings on the molecular underpinnings of prothrombin activation are relevant to other zymogens with modular assembly involved in blood coagulation, complement and fibrinolysis.

Why Ser and not Thr brokers catalysis in the trypsin fold

Although Thr is equally represented as Ser in the human genome and as a nucleophile is as good as Ser, it is never found in the active site of the large family of trypsin-like proteases that utilize the Asp/His/Ser triad. The molecular basis of the preference of Ser over Thr in the trypsin fold was investigated with X-ray structures of the thrombin mutant S195T free and bound to an irreversible active site inhibitor. In the free form, the methyl group of T195 is oriented toward the incoming substrate in a conformation seemingly incompatible with productive binding. In the bound form, the side chain of T195 is reoriented for efficient substrate acylation without causing steric clash within the active site. Rapid kinetics prove that this change is due to selection of an active conformation from a preexisting ensemble of reactive and unreactive rotamers whose relative distribution determines the level of activity of the protease. Consistent with these observations, the S195T substitution is associated with a weak yet finite activity that allows identification of an unanticipated important role for S195 as the end point of allosteric transduction in the trypsin fold. The S195T mutation abrogates the Na(+)-dependent enhancement of catalytic activity in thrombin, activated protein C, and factor Xa and significantly weakens the physiologically important allosteric effects of thrombomodulin on thrombin and of cofactor Va on factor Xa. The evolutionary selection of Ser over Thr in trypsin-like proteases was therefore driven by the need for high catalytic activity and efficient allosteric regulation.

WEDGE: an anticoagulant thrombin mutant produced by autoactivation

BACKGROUND

The production of therapeutically relevant proteases typically involves activation of a zymogen precursor by external enzymes, which may raise regulatory issues about availability and purity. Recent studies of thrombin precursors have shown how to engineer constructs that spontaneously convert to the mature protease by autoactivation, without the need for external enzymes.

OBJECTIVES

Autoactivation is an innovative strategy that promises to simplify the production of proteases of therapeutic relevance, but has not been tested in practical applications. The aim of this study was to provide a direct test of this strategy.

METHODS

An autoactivating version of the thrombin mutant W215A/E217A (WE), which is currently in preclinical development as an anticoagulant, was engineered.

RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS

The autoactivating version of WE can be produced in large quantities, like WE made in BHK cells or Escherichia coli, and retains all significant functional properties in vitro and in vivo. The results serve as proof of principle that autoactivation is an innovative and effective strategy for the production of trypsin-like proteases of therapeutic relevance.

Autoactivation of thrombin precursors

Trypsin-like proteases are synthesized as inactive zymogens and convert to the mature form upon activation by specific enzymes, often assisted by cofactors. Central to this paradigm is that the zymogen does not convert spontaneously to the mature enzyme, which in turn does not feed back to activate its zymogen form. In the blood, the zymogens prothrombin and prethrombin-2 require the prothrombinase complex to be converted to the mature protease thrombin, which is unable to activate prothrombin or prethrombin-2. Here, we show that replacement of key residues within the activation domain causes these zymogens to spontaneously convert to thrombin. The conversion is started by the zymogen itself, which is capable of binding ligands at the active site, and is abrogated by inactivation of the catalytic residue Ser-195. The product of autoactivation is functionally and structurally equivalent to wild-type thrombin. Zymogen autoactivation is explained by conformational selection, a basic property of the trypsin fold uncovered by structural and rapid kinetics studies. Both the zymogen and protease undergo a pre-existing equilibrium between active and inactive forms. The equilibrium regulates catalytic activity in the protease and has the potential to unleash activity in the zymogen to produce autoactivation. A new strategy emerges for the facile production of enzymes through zymogen autoactivation that is broadly applicable to trypsin-like proteases of biotechnological and clinical interest.

Crystal structures of prethrombin-2 reveal alternative conformations under identical solution conditions and the mechanism of zymogen activation

Prethrombin-2 is the immediate zymogen precursor of the clotting enzyme thrombin, which is generated upon cleavage at R15 and separation of the A chain and catalytic B chain. The X-ray structure of prethrombin-2 determined in the free form at 1.9 Å resolution shows the 215-217 segment collapsed into the active site and occluding 49% of the volume available for substrate binding. Remarkably, some of the crystals harvested from the same crystallization well, under identical solution conditions, diffract to 2.2 Å resolution in the same space group but produce a structure in which the 215-217 segment moves >5 Å and occludes 24% of the volume available for substrate binding. The two alternative conformations of prethrombin-2 have the side chain of W215 relocating >9 Å within the active site and are relevant to the allosteric E*-E equilibrium of the mature enzyme. Another unanticipated feature of prethrombin-2 bears on the mechanism of prothrombin activation. R15 is found buried within the protein in ionic interactions with E14e, D14l, and E18, thereby making its exposure to solvent necessary for proteolytic attack and conversion to thrombin. On the basis of this structural observation, we constructed the E14eA/D14lA/E18A triple mutant to reduce the level of electrostatic coupling with R15 and promote zymogen activation. The mutation causes prethrombin-2 to spontaneously convert to thrombin, without the need for the snake venom ecarin or the physiological prothrombinase complex.

Crystallographic and kinetic evidence of allostery in a trypsin-like protease

Protein allostery is based on the existence of multiple conformations in equilibrium linked to distinct functional properties. Although evidence of allosteric transitions is relatively easy to identify by functional studies, structural detection of a pre-existing equilibrium between alternative conformations remains challenging even for textbook examples of allosteric proteins. Kinetic studies show that the trypsin-like protease thrombin exists in equilibrium between two conformations where the active site is either collapsed (E*) or accessible to substrate (E). However, structural demonstration that the two conformations exist in the same enzyme construct free of ligands has remained elusive. Here we report the crystal structure of the thrombin mutant N143P in the E form, which complements the recently reported structure in the E* form, and both the E and E* forms of the thrombin mutant Y225P. The side chain of W215 moves 10.9 Å between the two forms, causing a displacement of 6.6 Å of the entire 215-217 segment into the active site that in turn opens or closes access to the primary specificity pocket. Rapid kinetic measurements of p-aminobenzamidine binding to the active site confirm the existence of the E*-E equilibrium in solution for wild-type and the mutants N143P and Y225P. These findings provide unequivocal proof of the allosteric nature of thrombin and lend strong support to the recent proposal that the E*-E equilibrium is a key property of the trypsin fold.

Thrombin mutant W215A/E217A treatment improves neurological outcome and reduces cerebral infarct size in a mouse model of ischemic stroke

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Treatment of ischemic stroke by activation of endogenous plasminogen using tissue plasminogen activator is limited by bleeding side effects. In mice, treatment of experimental ischemic stroke with activated protein C improves outcomes; however, activated protein C also has bleeding side effects. In contrast, activation of endogenous protein C using thrombin mutant W215A/E217A (WE) is antithrombotic without hemostasis impairment in primates. Therefore, we investigated the outcome of WE-treated experimental ischemic stroke in mice.

METHODS

The middle cerebral artery was occluded with a filament for 60 minutes to induce ischemic stroke. Vehicle, recombinant WE, or tissue plasminogen activator was administered during middle cerebral artery occlusion or 2 hours after middle cerebral artery occlusion. Neurological performance was scored daily. Intracranial bleeding and cerebral infarct size, defined by 2,3,5-triphenyltetrazolium chloride exclusion, were determined on autopsy. Hemostasis was evaluated using tail bleeding tests.

RESULTS

WE improved neurological performance scores, increased laser Doppler flowmetry-monitored post-middle cerebral artery occlusion reperfusion of the parietal cortex, and reduced 2,3,5-triphenyltetrazolium chloride-defined cerebral infarct size versus vehicle controls. However, unlike tissue plasminogen activator, WE did not increase tail bleeding or intracranial hemorrhage.

CONCLUSIONS

WE treatment is neuroprotective without hemostasis impairment in experimental acute ischemic stroke in mice and thus may provide an alternative to tissue plasminogen activator for stroke treatment.

Redesigning allosteric activation in an enzyme

Enzyme activation by monovalent cations is widely documented in plants and the animal world. In type II enzymes, activation entails two steps: binding of the monovalent cation to its allosteric site and transduction of this event into enhanced catalytic activity. The effect has exquisite specificity for either Na(+) or K(+), the most abundant cations present in physiological environments. Enzymes requiring K(+) such as kinases and molecular chaperones are not activated as well or at all by the larger cation Cs(+) or the smaller cations Na(+) and Li(+). Enzymes requiring Na(+) such as β-galactosidase and clotting proteases are not activated as well by Li(+), or the larger cations K(+), Rb(+), and Cs(+). Efforts to switch specificity between Na(+) and K(+) in this large class of enzymes and completely redesign the mechanism of allosteric transduction leading to enhanced catalytic activity have so far been unsuccessful. Here we show how mutagenesis of two loops defining the Na(+) binding site of thrombin, a Na(+)-activated clotting protease, generates a construct that is most active in the presence of K(+) toward synthetic and physiological substrates. The effect is the result of a higher binding affinity and more efficient allosteric transduction of binding into enhanced catalytic activity for K(+) compared to Na(+), which represents a complete reversal of the properties of wild type. In addition, the construct features altered specificity toward physiological substrates resulting in a significant anticoagulant profile. The findings are relevant to all Na(+)-activated proteases involved in blood coagulation and the complement system.

Engineering thrombin for selective specificity toward protein C and PAR1

Thrombin elicits functional responses critical to blood homeostasis by interacting with diverse physiological substrates. Ala-scanning mutagenesis of 97 residues covering 53% of the solvent accessible surface area of the enzyme identifies Trp(215) as the single most important determinant of thrombin specificity. Saturation mutagenesis of Trp(215) produces constructs featuring k(cat)/K(m) values for the hydrolysis of fibrinogen, protease-activated receptor PAR1, and protein C that span five orders of magnitude. Importantly, the effect of Trp(215) replacement is context dependent. Mutant W215E is 10-fold more specific for protein C than fibrinogen and PAR1, which represents a striking shift in specificity relative to wild-type that is 100-fold more specific for fibrinogen and PAR1 than protein C. However, when the W215E mutation is combined with deletion of nine residues in the autolysis loop, which by itself shifts the specificity of the enzyme from fibrinogen and PAR1 to protein C, the resulting construct features significant activity only toward PAR1. These findings demonstrate that thrombin can be re-engineered for selective specificity toward protein C and PAR1. Mutations of Trp(215) provide important reagents for dissecting the multiple functional roles of thrombin in the blood and for clinical applications.