Epidemiology, Treatment and Health Care Resource Use of Patients with severe Asthma in Germany – a retrospective Claims Data Analysis

BACKGROUND

Asthma causes various clinical symptoms, including unpredictable severe exacerbations, and even though most patients can achieve a reasonable disease control due to adequate treatment, some patients do not. This study seeks to describe healthcare resource utilization (HCRU) and treatment of asthma and severe asthma patients in Germany.

METHOD

A retrospective claims data analysis has been conducted on adult asthma patients and a subset of patients with severe asthma, identified during July 2017 - June 2018. A proxy was used to identify severe asthma patients based on therapy options recommended within the German treatment guideline for treating these patients. These include (i) biologics, (ii) medium/high-dose inhaled corticosteroids (ICS) in conjunction with LABA/montelukast and antibiotics/oral corticosteroids (OCS), and (iii) long-term OCS therapy. HCRU and treatment of patients were observed during a 1-year follow-up period (July 2018 - June 2019).

RESULTS

The study included 388 932 adult asthma patients (prevalence: 7.90%), with 2.51%-12.88% affected by severe asthma (depending on the definition). 22.60% of all asthma patients experienced hospitalizations (severe asthma: 36.11%). Furthermore, 13.59% received OCS (severe asthma: 39.91%), but only 0.18% (severe asthma: 1.25%) received biologics. Only 23.95% (severe asthma: 41.17%) visited a pulmonologist.

CONCLUSIONS

A considerable proportion of severe asthma patients receive long-term OCS therapy. However, less than 50% have seen a pulmonologist who would typically seek a change in treatment to avoid the long-term consequences of OCS. To optimize the treatment of severe asthma in Germany, better referral of these patients to specialists is needed and considering potential treatment alternatives.

Use of Biologic Therapies in the Treatment of Asthma – A Comparative Real World Data Analysis on Healthcare Resource Utilization and Costs Before and After Therapy Initiation

Background

Methods

Results

Conclusion

The impact of potentially inappropriate medication on the development of health care costs and its moderation by the number of prescribed substances. Results of a retrospective matched cohort study

Background

In the growing population of the elderly, drug-related problems are considered an important health care safety issue. One aspect of this is the prescription of potentially inappropriate medication (PIM) which is considered to increase health care costs.

Objective

Using data from the Health Economics of Potentially Inappropriate Medication (HEPIME) study, we aimed to analyze how the number of prescribed substances moderates the association of PIM use as defined by the German PRISCUS list and health care costs applying a longitudinal perspective.

Methods

An initial number of 6,849,622 insurants aged 65+ of a large German health insurance company were included in a retrospective matched cohort study. Based on longitudinal claims data from the four separate quarters of a 12-month pre-period, 3,860,842 individuals with no exposure to PIM in 2011 were matched to 508,212 exposed individuals. Exposure effects of PIM use on health care costs and the number of prescribed substances were measured based on longitudinal claims data from the four separate quarters of the 12-month post-period.

Results

After successful balancing for the development of numerous matching variables during the four quarters of the pre-period, exposed individuals consumed 2.1 additional prescribed substances and had higher total health care costs of 1,237 € when compared to non-exposed individuals in the 1st quarter of the post-period. Controlling for the number of prescribed substances, the difference in total health care costs between both study groups was 401 €. The average effect of one additionally prescribed substance (other than PIM) on total health care costs was increased by an amount of 137 € for those being exposed to a PIM. In quarters 2–4 of the post-period, the differences between both study groups tended to decrease sequentially.

Conclusions

PIM use has an increasing effect on the development of health care costs. This cost-increasing effect of PIM use is moderated by the number of prescribed substances.

Comparative evaluation of methods approximating drug prescription durations in claims data: modeling, simulation, and application to real data

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to compare the predictive accuracy of different methods suggested for approximation of drug prescription durations in claims data.

METHODS

We expanded a well-established modeling and simulation framework to compare approximated drug prescription durations with 'true' (i.e., simulated) durations. Real claims data of persons aged ≥65 years insured by the German nationwide 'Statutory Health Insurance Fund' AOK between 2010 and 2012 provided empiric input parameters that were completed with missing information on actual dosing patterns from an observational cohort. The distinct approximation methods were based on crude measures (one tablet a day), population-averaged measures (defined daily doses), or individually-derived measures (longitudinal coverage approximation of the applied dose, COV). As a proof-of-principle, we assessed the methods' performance to predict the well-characterized bleeding risks of anticoagulant, antiplatelet, and/or non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs.

RESULTS

When applied to modeling and simulation data sets, the closest, least biased, and thus most accurate approximation was observed using the COV approximation. In a real-data example, rather similar results to an external reference were obtained for all methods. However, some of the differences between methods were meaningful, and the most reasonable and consistent results were obtained with the COV approach.

CONCLUSION

Based on theoretically most accurate approximations and practically reasonable estimates, the individual COV approach was preferable over the population-averaged defined daily dose technique, although the latter might be justified in certain situations. Advantages of the COV approach are expected to be even bigger for drug therapies with particularly large dosing heterogeneity. Copyright © 2016 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

A Longitudinal Investigation of Willingness to Pay for Health Insurance in Germany

OBJECTIVE

To investigate factors affecting willingness to pay (WTP) for health insurance of older adults in a longitudinal setting in Germany.

DATA SOURCES

Survey data from a cohort study in Saarland, Germany, from 2008-2010 and 2011-2014 (n₁  = 3,124; n₂  = 2,761) were used.

STUDY DESIGN

Panel data were taken at two points from an observational, prospective cohort study.

DATA COLLECTION

WTP estimates were derived using a contingent valuation method with a payment card. Participants provided data on sociodemographics, lifestyle factors, morbidity, and health care utilization.

PRINCIPAL FINDINGS

Fixed effects regression models showed higher individual health care costs to increase WTP, which in particular could be found for members of private health insurance. Changes in income and morbidity did not affect WTP among members of social health insurance, whereas these predictors affected WTP among members of private health insurance.

CONCLUSIONS

The fact that individual health care costs affected WTP positively might indicate that demanding (expensive) health care services raises the awareness of the benefits of health insurance. Thus, measures to increase WTP in old age should target at improving transparency of the value of health insurances at the moment when individual health care utilization and corresponding costs are still relatively low.

Associations of frailty with health care costs--results of the ESTHER cohort study

BACKGROUND

The concept of frailty is rapidly gaining attention as an independent syndrome with high prevalence in older adults. Thereby, frailty is often related to certain adverse outcomes like mortality or disability. Another adverse outcome discussed is increased health care utilization. However, only few studies examined the impact of frailty on health care utilization and corresponding costs. The aim of this study was therefore to investigate comprehensively the relationship between frailty, health care utilization and costs.

METHODS

Cross sectional data from 2598 older participants (57-84 years) recruited in the Saarland, Germany, between 2008 and 2010 was used. Participants passed geriatric assessments that included Fried's five frailty criteria: weakness, slowness, exhaustion, unintentional weight loss, and physical inactivity. Health care utilization was recorded in the sectors of inpatient treatment, outpatient treatment, pharmaceuticals, and nursing care.

RESULTS

Prevalence of frailty (≥3 symptoms) was 8.0%. Mean total 3-month costs of frail participants were €3659 (4 or 5 symptoms) and €1616 (3 symptoms) as compared to €642 of nonfrail participants (no symptom). Controlling for comorbidity and general socio-demographic characteristics in multiple regression models, the difference in total costs between frail and non-frail participants still amounted to €1917; p < .05 (4 or 5 symptoms) and €680; p < .05 (3 symptoms). Among the 5 symptoms of frailty, weight loss and exhaustion were significantly associated with total costs after controlling for comorbidity.

CONCLUSIONS

The study provides evidence that frailty is associated with increased health care costs. The analyses furthermore indicate that frailty is an important factor for health care costs independent from pure age and comorbidity. Costs were rather attributable to frailty (and comorbidity) than to age. This stresses that the overlapping concepts of multimorbidity and frailty are both necessary to explain health care use and corresponding costs among older adults.

[Which Factors Affect Out-of-pocket Payments for Health Care Services Among Elderly Germans? Results of a Longitudinal Study]

Background: In Germany, out-of-pocket payments (OOPP) account for a large proportion of total health expenditure. However, there are only few investigations on how morbidity-related, sociodemographic and lifestyle factors affect OOPP particularly in the older population. The aim of this study was to identify factors affecting OOPP for health care services among elderly Germans in a longitudinal setting. Methods: This longitudinal study used data from 2 follow-up waves (3-year interval) from a population-based prospective cohort study (ESTHER study) collected in Saarland, Germany. At the first follow-up wave, subjects were between 57 and 84 years old. Participants provided comprehensive data including individual OOPP for the preceding 3 months. Fixed effects (FE) regressions were used to determine factors affecting OOPP. Results: Mean individual OOPP (3-month period) rose from € 119 (first wave) to € 136 (second wave). Longitudinal regressions showed that higher morbidity did not affect OOPP. Moreover, changes in sociodemographic as well as lifestyle factors were not related to changes in OOPP. Solely, exemption of OOPP reduced the dependent variable significantly. Conclusion: In contrast to cross-sectional findings for Germany, OOPP are not related to morbidity and income in this study. This underlines the complex nature of OOPP in old age and the need for longitudinal studies to gain some insight into the underlying causal factors.

[Use and potential risks of over-the-counter analgesics]

BACKGROUND AND AIM

We investigated the use of prescription and non-prescription (over-the-counter, OTC) analgesics and the associated risks in elderly patients with multiple morbidities.

METHODS

Pain medication use was evaluated from the baseline data (2008/2009) of the MultiCare cohort enrolling elderly patients with multiple morbidities who were treated by primary care physicians (trial registration: ISRCTN89818205). We considered opioids (N02A), other analgesics, and antipyretics (N02B) as well as nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs; M01A). OTC use, duplicate prescription, dosages, and interactions were examined for acetylsalicylic acid, diclofenac, (dex)ibuprofen, naproxen, and acetaminophen.

RESULTS

Of 3,189 patients with multiple morbidities aged 65-85 years, 1,170 patients reported to have taken at least one prescription or non-prescription analgesic within the last 3 months (36.7 %). Of these, 289 patients (24.7 % of 1,170) took at least one OTC analgesic. Duplicate prescription was observed in 86 cases; 15 of these cases took the analgesics regularly. In two cases, the maximum daily dose of diclofenac was exceeded due to duplicate prescription. In 235 cases, patients concurrently took a drug with a potentially clinically relevant interaction. In 43 cases (18.3 % of 235) an OTC analgesic, usually ibuprofen, was involved.

DISCUSSION

About one third of the elderly patients took analgesics regularly or as needed. Despite the relatively high use of OTC analgesics, the proportions of duplicate prescription, medication overdoses, and adverse interactions due to OTC products was low.

Loneliness in the elderly is associated with the use of psychotropic drugs

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to evaluate the association between loneliness in elderly people with the use of psychotropic drugs.

METHODS

A subsample of 3111 participants (ages 55-85) of the large population-based German ESTHER study was included in the study. Loneliness was measured by using a three-item questionnaire. Two subgroups were defined according to their degrees of loneliness. Psychotropic drugs were categorized by study doctors. Logistic regression analyses were conducted to determine the association between loneliness subgroups and the use of psychotropic drugs adjusted for psychosocial variables, multimorbidity, depression, anxiety, and somatic symptom severity.

RESULTS

Of the participants 14.1% (95%-CI = [12.9; 15.4]) were estimated to have a high degree of loneliness (women > men); 19% (95%-CI = [17.6; 20.4]) of the participants used psychotropic drugs, 8.4% (95%-CI = [7.5; 9.5]) antidepressants. Logistic regression analysis showed that more lonely participants had significantly higher odds for using psychotropic drugs (OR: 1.495; 95%-CI = [1.121; 1.993]). Depression severity, somatic symptom severity, and female gender were also positively associated with the use of psychotropic drugs.

CONCLUSION

A high degree of subjective loneliness in the elderly is associated with the use of psychotropic drugs, even after adjustment for somatic and psychological comorbidities and psychosocial variables.

Health service use and costs associated with excess weight in older adults in Germany

BACKGROUND

excess weight is a risk factor for numerous co-morbidities that predominantly occur in later life. This study's purpose was to analyse the association between excess weight and health service use/costs in the older population in Germany.

METHODS

this cross-sectional analysis used data of n = 3,108 individuals aged 58-82 from a population-based prospective cohort study. Body mass index (BMI) and waist-to-height ratio (WHtR) were calculated based on clinical examinations. Health service use was measured by a questionnaire for a 3-month period. Corresponding costs were calculated applying a societal perspective.

RESULTS

21.8% of the sample were normal weight, 43.0% overweight, 25.5% obese class 1 and 9.6% obese class ≥2 according to BMI. In 42.6%, WHtR was ≥0.6. For normal weight, overweight, obese class 1 and obese class ≥2 individuals, mean costs (3-month period) of outpatient care were 384€, 435€, 475€ and 525€ (P < 0.001), mean costs of inpatient care were 284€, 408€, 333€ and 652€ (P = 0.070) and mean total costs 716€, 891€, 852€ and 1,244€ (P = 0.013). For individuals with WHtR <0.6 versus ≥0.6, outpatient costs were 401€ versus 499€ (P < 0.001), inpatient costs 315€ versus 480€ (P = 0.016) and total costs 755€ versus 1,041€ (P < 0.001). Multiple regression analyses controlling for sociodemographic variables showed a significant effect of obesity on costs of outpatient care (class 1: +72€; class ≥2: +153€) and total costs (class ≥2: +361€) while the effect of overweight was not significant. WHtR ≥0.6 significantly increased outpatient costs by +79€ and total costs by +189€.

CONCLUSIONS

excess weight is associated with increased service use and cost in elderly individuals, in particular in obese class ≥2 individuals.

Characteristics of medication schedules used by elderly ambulatory patients

PURPOSE

We investigated the prevalence and quality of medication schedules of elderly ambulatory patients and assessed factors associated with the availability of a medication schedule. In particular, we evaluated whether sending out a blank medication schedule template would increase the chances to use such a document.

METHODS

Data originate from the ESTHER study, a cohort study conducted in Saarland, Germany, in which trained study physicians performed home visits. They scanned all medication schedules, recorded the participants' medication, and performed thorough geriatric assessments. As part of the intervention, a blank medication schedule template along with a brochure was mailed to half of the participants (intervention group) 4 weeks prior to the home visits.

RESULTS

In total, 553 of 2470 participants (22.4 %) had a medication schedule. Almost two thirds of the schedules were issued by health care professionals (n = 353, 63.8 %). These schedules offered a higher quality, although important information such as over-the-counter (OTC) medication was regularly missing. Self-reported adherence was higher in participants who used self-issued medication schedules; however, self-reported medication adherence in patients with any medication schedule was poorer compared to those patients not using a schedule. Factors associated with the availability of a medication schedule were male sex, a higher number of medicines to take, and a more complex drug regimen. The intervention did not increase the number of patients having a medication schedule.

CONCLUSION

Only a minority of elderly ambulatory patients had a medication schedule at home. Sending out a brochure along with a blank medication schedule template did not increase the prevalence of medication schedules.

Two techniques to make swallowing pills easier

To evaluate whether 2 techniques (the pop-bottle method for tablets and the lean-forward technique for capsules) ease swallowing of tablets and capsules, we conducted a cross-sectional study including 151 adults of the general German population. Participants swallowed 16 differently shaped placebos, rated their ease of swallowing on an 8-point Likert scale, and swallowed the 2 dosage forms that they had rated most difficult again using the appropriate technique. The pop-bottle method substantially improved swallowing of tablets in 59.7% (169/283) and the lean-forward technique for capsules in 88.6% (31/35). Both techniques were remarkably effective in participants with and without reported difficulties swallowing pills and should be recommended regularly.

Indirect evidence for proton pump inhibitor failure in patients taking them independent of meals

PURPOSE

We investigated the association between conditions of proton pump inhibitor (PPI) treatment failure and food intake in an elderly ambulatory population.

METHODS

Our data originate from a large population-based cohort study. During a home visit done by a trained study physician, patients were asked for each medication to state whether it was taken in relation to a meal (before, concurrently with, and after) or independent of a meal. This information was analyzed for all patients taking a PPI daily and correlated to markers of PPI failure.

RESULTS

Out of 2717 patients participating in a home visit and taking at least one medication, 383 took a PPI daily (14.1%). A PPI intake independent of meals was defined as incorrect and was observed in 64 patients, whereas 319 patients took their PPI in relation to a meal, which was defined as the correct intake. Treatment failure was observed in 10 out of 64 (15.6%) PPI users with incorrect intake and in 18 out of 319 (5.6%) PPI users with correct intake. The risk of treatment failure was threefold higher in patients taking their PPI independent of meals (OR 3.35; 95%CI 1.44-7.76).

CONCLUSION

The higher risk for PPI failure in patients taking PPIs independent of meals suggests that synchronized PPI administration with meals is indeed essential, and better counseling of patients is needed.

Health care costs in the elderly in Germany: an analysis applying Andersen's behavioral model of health care utilization

Background

To analyze the association of health care costs with predisposing, enabling, and need factors, as defined by Andersen’s behavioral model of health care utilization, in the German elderly population.

Methods

Using a cross-sectional design, cost data of 3,124 participants aged 57–84 years in the 8-year-follow-up of the ESTHER cohort study were analyzed. Health care utilization in a 3-month period was assessed retrospectively through an interview conducted by trained study physicians at respondents’ homes. Unit costs were applied to calculate health care costs from the societal perspective. Socio-demographic and health-related variables were categorized as predisposing, enabling, or need factors as defined by the Andersen model. Multimorbidity was measured by the Cumulative Illness Rating Scale for Geriatrics (CIRS-G). Mental health status was measured by the SF-12 mental component summary (MCS) score. Sector-specific costs were analyzed by means of multiple Tobit regression models.

Results

Mean total costs per respondent were 889 € for the 3-month period. The CIRS-G score and the SF-12 MCS score representing the need factor in the Andersen model were consistently associated with total, inpatient, outpatient and nursing costs. Among the predisposing factors, age was positively associated with outpatient costs, nursing costs, and total costs, and the BMI was associated with outpatient costs.

Conclusions

Multimorbidity and mental health status, both reflecting the need factor in the Andersen model, were the dominant predictors of health care costs. Predisposing and enabling factors had comparatively little impact on health care costs, possibly due to the characteristics of the German social health insurance system. Overall, the variables used in the Andersen model explained only little of the total variance in health care costs.

Inequalities in out-of-pocket payments for health care services among elderly Germans--results of a population-based cross-sectional study

Introduction

In order to limit rising publicly-financed health expenditure, out-of-pocket payments for health care services (OOPP) have been raised in many industrialized countries. However, higher health-related OOPP may burden social subgroups unequally. In Germany, inequalities in OOPP have rarely been analyzed. The aim of this study was to examine OOPP of the German elderly population in the different sectors of the health care system. Socio-economic and morbidity-related determinants of inequalities in OOPP were analyzed.

Methods

This cross-sectional analysis used data of N = 3,124 subjects aged 57 to 84 years from a population-based prospective cohort study (ESTHER study) collected in the Saarland, Germany, from 2008 to 2010. Subjects passed a geriatric assessment, including a questionnaire for health care utilization and OOPP covering a period of three months in the following sectors: inpatient care, outpatient physician and non-physician services, medical supplies, pharmaceuticals, dental prostheses and nursing care. Determinants of OOPP were analyzed by a two-part model. The financial burden of OOPP for certain social subgroups (measured by the OOPP-income-ratio) was investigated by a generalized linear model for the binomial family.

Results

Mean OOPP during three months amounted to €119, with 34% for medical supplies, 22% for dental prostheses, 21% for pharmaceuticals, 17% for outpatient physician and non-physician services, 5% for inpatient care and 1% for nursing care. The two-part model showed a significant positive association between income (square root equivalence scale) and total OOPP. Increasing morbidity was associated with significantly higher total OOPP, and in particular with higher OOPP for pharmaceuticals. Total OOPP amounted to about 3% of disposable income. The generalized linear model for the binomial family showed a significantly lower financial burden for the wealthiest quintile as compared to the poorest one.

Conclusions

This is the first study providing evidence of inequalities in OOPP in the German elderly population. Socio-economic and morbidity-related inequalities in OOPP and the resulting financial burden could be identified. The results of this study may contribute to the discussion about the mechanisms causing the observed inequalities and can thus help decision makers to consider them when adapting future regulations on OOPP.

Design and evaluation of an ontology-based drug application database

OBJECTIVES

Several recently published cases of preventable adverse drug reactions were associated with flaws in drug application. However, current clinical decision support (CDS) systems do not properly consider drug application issues and thus do not support effective prevention of such medication errors. With the aim to improve CDS in this respect, we developed a comprehensive model precisely describing all aspects of drug application.

METHODS

The model consists of 1) a schema comprising all relevant attributes of drug application and 2) an ontology providing a hierarchically structured vocabulary of terms that describe the possible values of the schema's attributes. Finally, medical products were annotated by a semi-automatic term assignment process. For evaluation, we developed an algorithm that uses our model to compute a meaningful similarity between medicinal products with respect to their drug application characteristics.

RESULTS

Our schema consists of 22 attributes. The ontology contains 248 terms, textual descriptions, and synonym lists. More than 58,700 medicinal products were automatically annotated with >386,600 terms. 2,450 drugs were manually reviewed by experts, adding >4500 terms. The annotation and similarity measure allow for (similarity) searches, clustering, and proper discrimination of drugs with different drug application characteristics. We demonstrated the value of our approach by means of a set of case studies.

CONCLUSION

Our model enables a detailed description of drug application, allowing for semantically meaningful comparisons of drugs. This is an important prerequisite for improving the ability of CDS systems to prevent prescription errors.

Substantial reduction of inappropriate tablet splitting with computerised decision support: a prospective intervention study assessing potential benefit and harm

Background

Currently ambulatory patients break one in four tablets before ingestion. Roughly 10% of them are not suitable for splitting because they lack score lines or because enteric or modified release coating is destroyed impairing safety and effectiveness of the medication. We assessed impact and safety of computerised decision support on the inappropriate prescription of split tablets.

Methods

We performed a prospective intervention study in a 1680-bed university hospital. Over a 15-week period we evaluated all electronically composed medication regimens and determined the fraction of tablets and capsules that demanded inappropriate splitting. In a subsequent intervention phase of 15 weeks duration for 10553 oral drugs divisibility characteristics were indicated in the system. In addition, an alert was generated and displayed during the prescription process whenever the entered dosage regimen demanded inappropriate splitting (splitting of capsules, unscored tablets, or scored tablets unsuitable for the intended fragmentation).

Results

During the baseline period 12.5% of all drugs required splitting and 2.7% of all drugs (257/9545) required inappropriate splitting. During the intervention period the frequency of inappropriate splitting was significantly reduced (1.4% of all drugs (146/10486); p = 0.0008). In response to half of the alerts (69/136) physicians adjusted the medication regimen. In the other half (67/136) no corrections were made although a switch to more suitable drugs (scored tablets, tablets with lower strength, liquid formulation) was possible in 82% (55/67).

Conclusion

This study revealed that computerised decision support can immediately reduce the frequency of inappropriate splitting without introducing new safety hazards.

[Medical problems and risks of switching drugs according to legal requirements of drug discount contracts in Germany]

INTRODUCTION

Since 2007 German health insurance funds may conclude discount contracts with pharmaceutical companies for individual drugs. According to German legislation pharmacies are liable to preferentially dispense these drugs to patients of the respective funds if the prescribed drug is identical regarding active ingredient, strength, package size, and route of administration, and is approved for the same indication. We aimed to assess the number and nature of clinically relevant differences between prescribed drug and its legal alternatives.

METHODS

Using databases and expert systems of the drug information system AiD KLINIK we evaluated all 258 412 exchangeable drug pairs of the German market currently regulated by discount contracts.

RESULTS

15,7 % of the drug pairs differed in dosage, in one quarter each colour or shape was significantly different, and in roughly 3 % the size of the substituted drug differed by more than 50 %. In 9,43 % splitting characteristics of solid oral doses differed and in 1,87 % the substituted drug contained additives with allergenic potential not present in the primarily selected drug. On average 0,44 clinically relevant differences could be calculated in each substitution.

CONCLUSION

This study has revealed that current legal provision ignore important medical criteria of the substitution process including individual risks (e. g. allergies). Patients will have to change the drug application process and will therefore need appropriate information and training. All these differences between substitutional drug pairs should already be known when prescribing so as to maintain patient safety in the face of this merely cost-saving measure.

Impact of quality circles for improvement of asthma care: results of a randomized controlled trial

RATIONALE AND AIMS

Quality circles (QCs) are well established as a means of aiding doctors. New quality improvement strategies include benchmarking activities. The aim of this paper was to evaluate the efficacy of QCs for asthma care working either with general feedback or with an open benchmark.

METHODS

Twelve QCs, involving 96 general practitioners, were organized in a randomized controlled trial. Six worked with traditional anonymous feedback and six with an open benchmark; both had guided discussion from a trained moderator. Forty-three primary care practices agreed to give out questionnaires to patients to evaluate the efficacy of QCs.

RESULTS

A total of 256 patients participated in the survey, of whom 185 (72.3%) responded to the follow-up 1 year later. Use of inhaled steroids at baseline was high (69%) and self-management low (asthma education 27%, individual emergency plan 8%, and peak flow meter at home 21%). Guideline adherence in drug treatment increased (P = 0.19), and asthma steps improved (P = 0.02). Delivery of individual emergency plans increased (P = 0.008), and unscheduled emergency visits decreased (P = 0.064). There was no change in asthma education and peak flow meter usage. High medication guideline adherence was associated with reduced emergency visits (OR 0.24; 95% CI 0.07-0.89). Use of theophylline was associated with hospitalization (OR 7.1; 95% CI 1.5-34.3) and emergency visits (OR 4.9; 95% CI 1.6-14.7). There was no difference between traditional and benchmarking QCs.

CONCLUSIONS

Quality circles working with individualized feedback are effective at improving asthma care. The trial may have been underpowered to detect specific benchmarking effects. Further research is necessary to evaluate strategies for improving the self-management of asthma patients.

Optimizing information on drug exposure by collection of package code information in questionnaire surveys

PURPOSE

The thorough analysis of special drug characteristics requires information on the specific brand of a drug. This information is often not sought in pharmacoepidemiologic surveys although in many countries packages are labelled with an unequivocal code (in Germany called Pharmazentralnummer (PZN)). We aimed to assess the benefit and quality of PZN information collected in self-completed questionnaires.

METHODS

We performed a survey in 905 ambulatory patients who were asked to list brand name, strength, and the PZN of all drugs they were taking.

RESULTS

The medication list was completed by 97.5% (n = 882) of the responding patients (mean age 67.3 years). Altogether 5543 drugs (100%) were mentioned in the questionnaires and for 4230 (76.3%) the exact drug package could be allocated on the basis of the PZN. When PZN was considered in addition to the drug name the quality of drug coding was significantly improved (p < 0.001) with regard to the allocation of drug package (74% versus 2%), brand (90% versus 70%), and strength (96% versus 86%). The time needed for drug coding was three times shorter.

CONCLUSIONS

The high response rate and high fraction of correct PZN indicate that the collection of package code information is a valuable method to achieve more accurate drug data in questionnaire surveys and to facilitate the drug coding procedure.

Asthma patients with low perceived burden of illness: a challenge for guideline adherence

RATIONALE AND AIMS

The reason why many patients seem to tolerate suffering from sub-optimal treated asthma remains unclear. The aim was to evaluate the guideline adherence combined with quality of life of patients with moderate to severe asthma.

METHODS

256 asthma patients from 43 primary care practices in Saxony-Anhalt filled in a questionnaire including the Asthma Quality of Life Questionnaire (AQLQ), the Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ-D) and questions evaluating the asthma severity, medication and self-management.

RESULTS

43.4% suffered from moderate to severe asthma. Drug treatment accorded with guidelines in 36.9%, drug dosage of inhaled steroids was too low in 34.3%, and 21.5% were not treated according to guidelines. A total of 7.3% of the patients received end-of-dose therapy. AQLQ declined and depression rose with asthma severity and guideline non-adherence (P < 0.001). Only 29.1% received asthma education. However, 64.5% of the patients without education did not want to receive education. They had a higher quality of life, lower depression (P < 0.001) and lower use of steroids (P = 0.016). Higher depression scores where related with hospital admission (OR 3.29; 95% CI 1.57-6.87 for each quartile of PHQ-D) and unscheduled home visits or ambulatory care (OR 1.58; 1.07-2.33).

CONCLUSION

There is a large variation of asthma severity which can partly be explained by the guideline adherence of medication and deficits of patients' management. The perceived burden of illness plays a more important role for education and self-management than the real severity of disease. Therefore, target-oriented interventions are needed to identify and motivate patients at risk.

Higher preference for participation in treatment decisions is associated with lower medication adherence in asthma patients

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the interrelations between medication adherence, self-management, preference for involvement in treatment decisions and preference for information in asthma patients in primary care.

METHODS

One hundred and eighty-five patients from 43 practices completed a series of questionnaires, which included the 'Autonomy Preference Index' (API) [range=0-100], the four-item Morisky self-report medication adherence questionnaire and structured questions about asthma severity, medication and self-management.

RESULTS

The mean (S.D.) for participation preference was 34.5 (15.3) whereas the mean (S.D.) for information preference was 91.1 (9.7). Higher participation preference was associated with stopping medication when feeling better (OR 1.03; 95%CI 1.01-1.06) or feeling worse (OR 1.02; 95%CI 1.0-1.05) but it was not related to asthma severity. Higher information preference was associated with non-adherence to medication (Spearman correlation coefficient 0.166; p=0.035) as well as the wish to receive asthma education (p=0.04) and usage of peak flow meter (p=0.05).

CONCLUSION

Participation preference was low in general. Higher preference for involvement may entail more motivation for self-management but also lower medication adherence. This may be explained by a continuous internal negotiation process to accept the potentially lifelong demands of the disease.

PRACTICE IMPLICATIONS

Patients with lower medication adherence may possibly be addressed and empowered by their enhanced preference for participation in treatment decisions. Physicians offering to share treatment decisions may utilise the patients' participation preference to enhance medication adherence. Due to varying participation preferences, optimal patient preference matching, which involves more flexible use of different communication styles, may be necessary to improve outcomes.

The frequency of inappropriate tablet splitting in primary care

INTRODUCTION

We assessed the frequency and determinants of tablet splitting in primary care in Germany and evaluated the quality of information on divisibility in the Summary of Product Characteristics (SPCs) and in the Package Leaflet (PL) as legal sources of information for health care providers and patients.

METHODS

We performed a cross-sectional questionnaire survey among patients of 59 general practitioners in the German Federal State Saxony-Anhalt in 2005 in order to collect detailed information on all drugs of patients maintained on more than three drugs.

RESULTS

The response rate was 82.1% (n=905) and 3,158 drugs (tablets and dragées) were included in the analyses. Of all drugs, 24.1% were split (762 of 3,158): 8.7% of all split tablets were unscored (66 of 762) and 3.8% of all split tablets were not allowed to be split (29 of 762). Tablets of the higher price categories and higher strengths were twice as likely to be split. Only 22.5% of the SPCs (9 of 40) of the split unscored tablet brands contained explicit information on divisibility and only 36.4% of the PLs (8 of 22) of the split brands that were not allowed to be split stated that splitting was not appropriate.

CONCLUSION

The splitting of tablets in primary care is a frequent habit likely driven by medical and economic considerations. Almost 1% of all tablets are split that must not be fragmented. However, the SPC and PL provide only limited information on divisibility stressing the need to improve this information promptly to avoid medication errors.

Tabletten teilen

Knapp ein Drittel der ambulanten Patienten teilen ihre Tabletten vor der Einnahme. Diese gängige Praxis birgt, neben etlichen Vorteilen, allerdings auch einige Risiken für die Arzneimitteltherapie. Vor allem ältere Patienten sind häufig nicht in der Lage Tabletten exakt zu teilen und die unsachgemäße Teilung z.B. von Retardpräparaten kann zu einer Überdosierung führen. Ob eine Tablette geteilt werden darf, hängt im Wesentlichen von den Wirkstoffeigenschaften, der Galenik, der Form der Tablette und der Beschaffenheit der Bruchkerbe ab. Darüber hinaus muss gesichert sein, dass der Patient über die erforderliche Bereitschaft und Fingergeschicklichkeit verfügt, seine Tabletten zu teilen, um die Compliance nicht zu beeinträchtigen. Nicht zuletzt muss der Patient über die richtige Teilungstechnik informiert sein, damit beim Teilen zwei gleichgroße Bruchstücke entstehen und die Wirksamkeit der Therapie nicht gefährdet wird.