Pubertal and Gonadal Outcomes in 46,XY Individuals with Partial Androgen Insensitivity Syndrome Raised as Girls

INTRODUCTION

Although it was common in the 1970s-1990s to assign female gender of rearing to 46,XY infants with limited virilization of varying etiologies, including those with partial androgen insensitivity syndrome (PAIS), long-term data on outcomes for these individuals are sparse. Therefore, our goal was to use the power of an international registry to evaluate clinical features, surgical management, and pubertal data in patients with a molecularly confirmed diagnosis of PAIS who were born before 2008 and were raised as girls.

METHODS

The current study interrogated the International Disorders of Sex Development Registry for available data on management and pubertal outcomes in individuals with genetically confirmed PAIS who were raised as girls.

RESULTS

Among the 11 individuals who fulfilled the key criteria for inclusion, the external masculinization score (EMS) at presentation ranged from 2 to 6 (median 5); 7 girls underwent gonadectomy before the age of 9 years, whereas 4 underwent gonadectomy in the teenage years (≥ age 13). Clitoral enlargement at puberty was reported for 3 girls (27%) who presented initially at the time of puberty with intact gonads. In the 9 individuals (82%) for whom gonadal pathology data were provided, there was no evidence of germ cell tumor at median age of 8.1 years. All girls received estrogen replacement, and 8/11 had attained Tanner stage 4-5 breast development at the last assessment.

CONCLUSION

In general, although it appears that female assignment in PAIS is becoming uncommon, our data provide no evidence to support the practice of prophylactic prepubertal gonadectomy with respect to the risk of a germ cell tumor.

Maternal Paracetamol Intake During Pregnancy-Impacts on Offspring Reproductive Development

Paracetamol (acetaminophen) is the preferred antipyretic/analgesic for pregnant women as it is believed there are no adverse fetal effects at the recommended dose. However, emerging evidence suggests that intrauterine paracetamol exposure may be associated with certain urogenital/reproductive disorders in the offspring. In this mini-review, we describe human fetal sex development and possible pharmacological mechanisms by which paracetamol may disrupt this process, including reduced testicular production of testosterone and/or insulin-like peptide 3. We then review the available epidemiological literature on associations between maternal paracetamol exposure and offspring sexual development. Three epidemiological studies have reported associations between maternal paracetamol intake and increased risk of cryptorchidism, although five others have not. None have found associations with hypospadias or penile length. Two out of three studies have reported a shorter anogenital distance (a marker of androgen action during the masculinisation programming window, ∼8-14 weeks of gestation) in male infants antenatally exposed to paracetamol. One study has described a dose-dependent relationship between maternal paracetamol consumption and earlier female (but not male) attainment of puberty. Such epidemiological analyses are complicated by various factors, including method of paracetamol exposure assessment (usually retrospective self-report), variation in diagnostic accuracy, selection bias, confounding by clinical indication, and demographic/genetic differences between geographically separated populations. There is an urgent need for stronger evidence in this area, from both relevant experimental studies and large, carefully-designed prospective studies. In the meantime, a precautionary attitude to gestational paracetamol usage should be considered as the evidence for clinically significant reproductive effects in humans is limited.

Growth, puberty and testicular function in boys born small for gestational age with a nonspecific disorder of sex development

OBJECTIVE

Being born small for gestational age (SGA) is frequently associated with unexplained disorders of sex development (nonspecific DSD) in boys. Little is known about their future growth, puberty and testicular function. Our objective is to determine the long-term endocrine outcome of boys born SGA who have a nonspecific DSD.

DESIGN

Boys with a nonspecific DSD born SGA and appropriate for GA (AGA) were retrieved through the International Disorders of Sex Development registry and retrospective data collected, based on a spreadsheet containing 102 items.

PATIENTS AND MEASUREMENTS

In total, 179 boys were included, of which 115 were born SGA and 64 were born AGA. Their growth and pubertal development were compared. Serum LH, FSH, testosterone, AMH and inhibin B levels in infancy and puberty were analysed to assess testicular function.

RESULTS

At 2 years of age, 30% of SGA boys had incomplete or absent catch-up growth. Boys born SGA also had higher LH during minipuberty and lower testosterone in stimulation tests (p = 0.037 and 0.040, respectively), as compared to boys born AGA. No differences were observed in timing or course of puberty or end-pubertal hormone levels.

CONCLUSIONS

Almost one out of three SGA boys with a nonspecific DSD experiences insufficient catch-up growth. In addition, our data suggest dysfunction of infantile Leydig cells or altered regulation of the hypothalamic-pituitary-gonadal axis in SGA boys during childhood. Sex steroid production during puberty seems unaffected.

Gonadectomy in conditions affecting sex development: a registry-based cohort study

OBJECTIVES

To determine trends in clinical practice for individuals with DSD requiring gonadectomy.

DESIGN

Retrospective cohort study.

METHODS

Information regarding age at gonadectomy according to diagnosis; reported sex; time of presentation to specialist centre; and location of centre from cases reported to the International DSD Registry and who were over 16 years old in January 2019.

RESULTS

Data regarding gonadectomy were available in 668 (88%) individuals from 44 centres. Of these, 248 (37%) (median age (range) 24 (17, 75) years) were male and 420 (63%) (median age (range) 26 (16, 86) years) were female. Gonadectomy was reported from 36 centres in 351/668 cases (53%). Females were more likely to undergo gonadectomy (n = 311, P < 0.0001). The indication for gonadectomy was reported in 268 (76%). The most common indication was mitigation of tumour risk in 172 (64%). Variations in the practice of gonadectomy were observed; of the 351 cases from 36 centres, 17 (5%) at 9 centres had undergone gonadectomy before their first presentation to the specialist centre. Median age at gonadectomy of cases from high-income countries and low-/middle-income countries (LMIC) was 13.0 years (0.1, 68) years and 16.5 years (1, 28), respectively (P < 0.0001) with the likelihood of long-term retention of gonads being higher in LMIC countries.

CONCLUSIONS

The likelihood of gonadectomy depends on the underlying diagnosis, sex of rearing and the geographical setting. Clinical benchmarks, which can be studied across all forms of DSD will allow a better understanding of the variation in the practice of gonadectomy.

Real-World Estimates of Adrenal Insufficiency-Related Adverse Events in Children With Congenital Adrenal Hyperplasia

BACKGROUND

Although congenital adrenal hyperplasia (CAH) is known to be associated with adrenal crises (AC), its association with patient- or clinician-reported sick day episodes (SDE) is less clear.

METHODS

Data on children with classic 21-hydroxylase deficiency CAH from 34 centers in 18 countries, of which 7 were Low or Middle Income Countries (LMIC) and 11 were High Income (HIC), were collected from the International CAH Registry and analyzed to examine the clinical factors associated with SDE and AC.

RESULTS

A total of 518 children-with a median of 11 children (range 1, 53) per center-had 5388 visits evaluated over a total of 2300 patient-years. The median number of AC and SDE per patient-year per center was 0 (0, 3) and 0.4 (0.0, 13.3), respectively. Of the 1544 SDE, an AC was reported in 62 (4%), with no fatalities. Infectious illness was the most frequent precipitating event, reported in 1105 (72%) and 29 (47%) of SDE and AC, respectively. On comparing cases from LMIC and HIC, the median SDE per patient-year was 0.75 (0, 13.3) vs 0.11 (0, 12.0) (P < 0.001), respectively, and the median AC per patient-year was 0 (0, 2.2) vs 0 (0, 3.0) (P = 0.43), respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

The real-world data that are collected within the I-CAH Registry show wide variability in the reported occurrence of adrenal insufficiency-related adverse events. As these data become increasingly used as a clinical benchmark in CAH care, there is a need for further research to improve and standardize the definition of SDE.

Testosterone Therapy and Its Monitoring in Adolescent Boys with Hypogonadism: Results of an International Survey from the I-DSD Registry

It is unclear whether testosterone replacement therapy (TRT) in adolescent boys, affected by a range of endocrine diseases that may be associated with hypogonadism, is particularly common. The aim of this study was to assess the contemporary practice of TRT in boys included in the I-DSD Registry. All participating centres in the I-DSD Registry that had boys between 10 and 18 years of age and with a condition that could be associated with hypogonadism were invited to provide further information in 2019. Information on 162 boys was collected from 15 centres that had a median (range) number of 6 boys per centre (1.35). Of these, 30 (19%) from 9 centres were receiving TRT and the median (range) age at the start was 12.6 years (10.8-16.2), with 6 boys (20%) starting at <12 years. Median (range) age of boys not on TRT was 11.7 years (10.7-17.7), and 69 out of 132 (52%) were <12 years. TRT had been initiated in 20 of 71 (28%) boys with a disorder of gonadal development, 3 of 14 (21%) with a disorder of androgen synthesis, and all 7 (100%) boys with hypogonadotropic hypogonadism. The remainder who did not have TRT included 15 boys with partial androgen insensitivity, 52 with non-specific XY DSD, and 3 with persistent Müllerian duct syndrome. Before starting TRT, liver function and blood count were checked in 19 (68%) and 18 boys (64%), respectively, a bone age assessment was performed in 23 (82%) and bone mineral density assessment in 12 boys (43%). This snapshot of contemporary practice reveals that TRT in boys included in the I-DSD Registry is not very common, whilst the variation in starting and monitoring therapy is quite marked. Standardisation of practice may lead to more effective assessment of treatment outcomes.

Frequency of gonadal tumours in complete androgen insensitivity syndrome (CAIS): A retrospective case-series analysis

BACKGROUND

Complete androgen insensitivity syndrome (CAIS) is an X-linked recessive disorder of sex development (DSD) where affected individuals are phenotypically female, but have an XY karyotype and testes. The risk of gonadal tumour development in CAIS may increase with age; incidence rates have been reported to be 0.8-22% in patients who have retained their gonads into adulthood. Consequently, gonadectomy has been recommended either during childhood or after puberty is complete, although there is no consensus on the optimal timing for this procedure.

OBJECTIVE AND HYPOTHESES

To establish the frequency of histological abnormalities in CAIS in relation to the age at gonadectomy.

METHOD

Data were collected from the Cambridge DSD database on patients with CAIS (n = 225; age range 3-88 years) who had undergone gonadectomy, and their age of gonadectomy, gonadal histology and immunohistochemistry.

RESULTS

Evaluable data were obtained from 133 patients. Median age at gonadectomy was 14.0 years (range: 18 days-68 years). Pubertal status was: prepuberty, n = 62; postpuberty, n = 68. Thirteen cases were aged >20 years at gonadectomy. The pattern of histology is summarised in the Summary table.

DISCUSSION

In this large case series of CAIS patients who had undergone gonadectomy, while the combined malignant and premalignant gonadal histology prevalence was 6.0%, the findings confirm the low occurrence of gonadal malignancy in CAIS, with a frequency of 1.5%. The two cases of malignancy were postpubertal. Germ cell neoplasia in situ (GCNIS) was observed in six cases, of which one occurred prepuberty and five postpuberty. The study highlighted difficulties in diagnosis of GCNIS and the need for histological analysis in expert centres.

CONCLUSION

The results support the current recommendation that gonads in CAIS can be retained until early adulthood. The small number of individuals with gonadectomy after age 20 years do not allow firm conclusion regarding later adulthood. Therefore, it is recommended that the option of gonadectomy be discussed in adulthood. Some form of regular surveillance of the gonads is then recommended, although none of the available options are ideal.

Androgen dependent mechanisms of pro-angiogenic networks in placental and tumor development

The placenta and tumors share important characteristics, including a requirement to establish effective angiogenesis. In the case of the placenta, optimal angiogenesis is required to sustain the blood flow required to maintain a successful pregnancy, whereas in tumors establishing new blood supplies is considered a key step in supporting metastases. Therefore the development of novel angiogenesis inhibitors has been an area of active research in oncology. A subset of the molecular processes regulating angiogenesis are well understood in the context of both early placentation and tumorigenesis. In this review we focus on the well-established role of androgen regulation of angiogenesis in cancer and relate these mechanisms to placental angiogenesis. The physiological actions of androgens are mediated by the androgen receptor (AR), a ligand dependent transcription factor. Androgens and the AR are essential for normal male embryonic development, puberty and lifelong health. Defects in androgen signalling are associated with a diverse range of clinical disorders in men and women including disorders of sex development (DSD), polycystic ovary syndrome in women and many cancers. We summarize the diverse molecular mechanisms of androgen regulation of angiogenesis and infer the potential significance of these pathways to normal and pathogenic placental function. Finally, we offer potential research applications of androgen-targeting molecules developed to treat cancer as investigative tools to help further delineate the role of androgen signalling in placental function and maternal and offspring health in animal models.

The Long-Term Outcome of Boys With Partial Androgen Insensitivity Syndrome and a Mutation in the Androgen Receptor Gene

BACKGROUND

In boys with suspected partial androgen insensitivity syndrome (PAIS), systematic evidence that supports the long-term prognostic value of identifying a mutation in the androgen receptor gene (AR) is lacking.

OBJECTIVE

To assess the clinical characteristics and long-term outcomes in young men with suspected PAIS in relation to the results of AR analysis.

METHODS

Through the International Disorders of Sex Development Registry, clinical information was gathered on young men suspected of having PAIS (n = 52) who presented before the age of 16 years and had genetic analysis of AR.

RESULTS

The median ages at presentation and at the time of the study were 1 month (range, 1 day to 16 years) and 22 years (range, 16 to 52 years), respectively. Of the cohort, 29 men (56%) had 20 different AR mutations reported. At diagnosis, the median external masculinization scores were 7 and 6 in cases with and without AR mutation, respectively (P = .9), and median current external masculinization scores were 9 and 10, respectively (P = .28). Thirty-five men (67%) required at least one surgical procedure, and those with a mutation were more likely to require multiple surgeries for hypospadias (P = .004). All cases with an AR mutation had gynecomastia, compared to 9% of those without an AR mutation. Of the six men who had a mastectomy, five (83%) had an AR mutation.

CONCLUSIONS

Boys with genetically confirmed PAIS are likely to have a poorer clinical outcome than those with XY DSD, with normal T synthesis, and without an identifiable AR mutation. Routine genetic analysis of AR to confirm PAIS informs long-term prognosis and management.

Androgen insensitivity syndrome

Androgen insensitivity syndrome (AIS) results from androgen receptor dysfunction and is a common cause of disorder of sex development. The AIS phenotype largely depends on the degree of residual androgen receptor (AR) activity. This review describes the molecular action of androgens and the range of androgen receptor gene mutations, essential knowledge to understand the pathogenesis of the complete and partial forms of this syndrome. A multidisciplinary approach is recommended for clinical management from infancy through to adulthood. Hormone replacement therapy is needed following gonadectomy. Patients who choose to retain the gonads are at risk of developing germ cell tumors for which sensitive circulating tumor markers may soon become available. Whilst the contribution of AR dysfunction to complete AIS is well understood, the involvement of the AR and associated proteins as contributors to partial AIS is an area of active research. Disorders of sex development such as AIS which are related to AR dysfunction offer a breadth of manifestations for the clinician to manage and opportunities for further research on the mechanism of androgen action.

Androgen insensitivity syndrome

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Androgen insensitivity syndrome (AIS) can present with a wide range of phenotypes, and its management requires a multidisciplinary approach from diagnosis in infancy to adulthood. This review provides an update on some clinical and genetic aspects in AIS. Additional outcome data on surgical and psychosexual findings are presented, together with a discussion on the risk of development of gonadal tumours in AIS.

RECENT FINDINGS

This review covers clinical features of AIS, including recent trends in sex of rearing, aspects of androgen receptor gene mutations and longer term outcomes in both complete and partial forms of AIS.

SUMMARY

More follow-up studies are needed to optimize management in AIS, especially in the partial form. Predicting the risk of gonadal tumours is key to determining the timing of gonadectomy or whether to retain the gonads in the long term.

Low frequency of androgen receptor gene mutations in 46 XY DSD, and fetal growth restriction

OBJECTIVE

The diagnosis of partial androgen insensitivity syndrome (PAIS) should be reserved for infants with a pathogenic androgen receptor gene (AR) mutation. However, only about 20% of infants with a clinical phenotype akin to PAIS have an AR mutation. We aimed to identify clinical features associated with the presence of an AR mutation.

METHODS

The external masculinisation score (EMS; normal=12), birth weight (BW), gestational age and BW SD score (BW-SDS) of 164 infants with a 'PAIS-like' phenotype were analysed in the Cambridge Disorders of Sex Development (DSD) Database, of whom 128 (78%) had no AR mutation ('AR mutation-negative') and 36 (22%) had an AR mutation ('AR mutation-positive').

RESULTS

The EMS was similar in AR mutation-negative and AR mutation-positive infants (median, IQR: 5.0, 3.0 to 6.0 vs 4.8, 3.0 to 6.0; p=0.33). AR mutation-negative infants had lower BW (2.33, 1.38 to 3.20 vs 3.18, 2.87 to 3.61 kg; p<0.001), lower gestational age (37.0, 34.0 to 40.0 vs 40.0, 39.0 to 40.0 weeks; p<0.001), and lower BW-SDS (-1.31, -2.33 to -0.46 vs -0.57, -1.19 to 0.33; p=0.001) compared to AR mutation-positive infants. More AR mutation-negative infants (47/128; 37%) than AR mutation-positive infants (2/36; 6%) had BW-SDS <-2 (p<0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

The severity of genital anomalies in this large cohort of infants with a 'PAIS-like' phenotype did not differentiate their AR status. Almost all the infants born small-for-gestational-age do not have an AR mutation. A category of 'XY DSD and fetal growth restriction, as yet unexplained' should be recognised.