Enhanced T-cell activation and differentiation in lymphocytes from transgenic mice expressing ubiquitination-resistant 2KR LAT molecules

Linker for activation of T cells (LAT) is critical for the propagation of T-cell signals upon T-cell receptor (TCR) activation. Previous studies demonstrated that substitution of LAT lysines with arginines (2KR LAT) resulted in decreased LAT ubiquitination and elevated T-cell signaling, indicating that LAT ubiquitination is a molecular checkpoint for attenuation of T-cell signaling. To investigate the role of LAT ubiquitination in vivo, we have generated transgenic mice expressing WT and ubiquitin-defective 2KR LAT. On TCR stimulation of T cells from these mice, proximal signaling and cytokine production was elevated in 2KR versus wild-type (WT) LAT mice. Enhanced cytolytic activity as well as T-helper responses were observed on LAT expression, which were further elevated by 2KR LAT expression. Despite greater T-effector function, WT or 2KR LAT expression did not have any effect on clearance of certain pathogens or tumors. Our data support the model that lack of tumor clearance is due to increased differentiation and acquisition of effector phenotype that is associated with suboptimal immunity in an immunotherapy model. Thus, our data further reinforce the role of LAT ubiquitination in TCR signaling and uncovers a novel role for LAT in driving T-cell differentiation.

Heterosubtypic immunity to influenza A virus in mice lacking IgA, all Ig, NKT cells, or gamma delta T cells

The mechanisms of broad cross-protection to influenza viruses of different subtypes, termed heterosubtypic immunity, remain incompletely understood. We used knockout mouse strains to examine the potential for heterosubtypic immunity in mice lacking IgA, all Ig and B cells, NKT cells (CD1 knockout mice), or gamma(delta) T cells. Mice were immunized with live influenza A virus and compared with controls immunized with unrelated influenza B virus. IgA(-/-) mice survived full respiratory tract challenge with heterosubtypic virus that was lethal to controls. IgA(-/-) mice also cleared virus from the nasopharynx and lungs following heterosubtypic challenge limited to the upper respiratory tract, where IgA has been shown to play an important role. Ig(-/-) mice controlled the replication of heterosubtypic challenge virus in the lungs. Acute depletion of CD4+ or CD8+ T cell subsets abrogated this clearance of virus, thus indicating that both CD4+ and CD8+ T cells are required for protection in the absence of Ig. These results in Ig(-/-) mice indicate that CD4+ T cells can function by mechanisms other than providing help to B cells for the generation of Abs. Like wild-type mice, CD1(-/-) mice and gamma(delta) (-/-) mice survived lethal heterosubtypic challenge. Acute depletion of CD4+ and CD8+ cells abrogated heterosubtypic protection in gamma(delta) (-/-) mice, but not B6 controls, suggesting a contribution of gamma(delta) T cells. Our results demonstrate that the Ab and cellular subsets deficient in these knockout mice are not required for heterosubtypic protection, but each may play a role in a multifaceted response that as a whole is more effective than any of its parts.

Vaccination with DNA encoding internal proteins of influenza virus does not require CD8(+) cytotoxic T lymphocytes: either CD4(+) or CD8(+) T cells can promote survival and recovery after challenge

DNA vaccination offers the advantages of viral gene expression within host cells without the risks of infectious virus. Like viral vaccines, DNA vaccines encoding internal influenza virus proteins can induce immunity to conserved epitopes and so may defend the host against a broad range of viral variants. CD8(+) cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) have been described as essential effectors in protection by influenza nucleoprotein (NP), although a lesser role of CD4(+) cells has been reported. We immunized mice with plasmids encoding influenza virus NP and matrix (M). NP + M DNA allowed B6 mice to survive otherwise lethal challenge infection, but did not protect B6-beta(2)m(-/-) mice defective in CD8(+) CTL. However, this does not prove CTL are required, because beta(2)m(-/-) mice have multiple immune abnormalities. We used acute T cell depletion in vivo to identify effectors critical for defense against challenge infection. Since lung lymphocytes are relevant to virus clearance, surface phenotypes and cytolytic activity of lung lymphocytes were analyzed in depleted animals, along with lethal challenge studies. Depletion of either CD4(+) or CD8(+) T cells in NP + M DNA-immunized BALB/c mice during the challenge period did not significantly decrease survival, while simultaneous depletion of CD4(+) and CD8(+) cells or depletion of all CD90(+) cells completely abrogated survival. We conclude that T cell immunity induced by NP + M DNA vaccination is responsible for immune defense, but CD8(+) T cells are not essential in the active response to this vaccination. Either CD4(+) or CD8(+) T cells can promote survival and recovery in the absence of the other subset.

Mechanism of protective immunity against influenza virus infection in mice without antibodies

There is considerable interest in developing viral vaccines intended to induce T cell immunity, especially cytotoxic CD8+ T lymphocytes, when Abs are not protective or are too narrow in viral strain specificity. We have studied protective immunity in doubly inactivated (DI) mice devoid of Abs and mature B cells. When infected with influenza B virus, these mice cleared the virus in a process dependent upon CD8+ T lymphocytes. Cytotoxic activity was detected in lung lymphocytes of DI mice after primary or secondary infection, and was abrogated by depletion of CD8+ cells in vivo. Challenge experiments showed that DI mice could be protected by immunization against reinfection 1 mo later, and protection was virus specific. Depletion of CD4+ or CD8+ T cells in vivo during the challenge period partially abrogated, and depletion of both subsets completely abrogated, the protection. This indicates that both CD4+ and CD8+ T cells are required effectors in the optimal control of virus replication. Thus, when Abs fail to protect against varying challenge viruses, as is the case with variant strains of influenza and HIV, there is hope that T cells might be able to act alone.

Interferon (IFN) consensus sequence-binding protein, a transcription factor of the IFN regulatory factor family, regulates immune responses in vivo through control of interleukin 12 expression

Mice with a null mutation of the gene encoding interferon consensus sequence-binding protein (ICSBP) develop a chronic myelogenous leukemia-like syndrome and mount impaired responses to certain viral and bacterial infections. To gain a mechanistic understanding of the contributions of ICSBP to humoral and cellular immunity, we characterized the responses of control and ICSBP-/- mice to infection with influenza A (flu) and Leishmania major (L. major). Mice of both genotypes survived infections with flu, but differed markedly in the isotype distribution of antiflu antibodies. In sera of normal mice, immunoglobulin (Ig)G2a antibodies were dominant over IgG1 antibodies, a pattern indicative of a T helper cell type 1 (Th1)-driven response. In sera of ICSBP-/- mice, however, IgG1 antibodies dominated over IgG2a antibodies, a pattern indicative of a Th2-driven response. The dominance of IgG1 and IgE over IgG2a was detected in the sera of uninfected mice as well. A seeming Th2 bias of ICSBP-deficient mice was also uncovered in their inability to control infection with L. major, where resistance is known to be dependent on IL-12 and IFN-gamma as components of a Th1 response. Infected ICSBP-deficient mice developed fulminant, disseminated leishmaniasis as a result of failure to mount a Th1-mediated curative response, although T cells remained capable of secreting IFN-gamma and macrophages of producing nitric oxide. Compromised Th1 differentiation in ICSBP-/- mice could not be attributed to hyporesponsiveness of CD4(+) T cells to interleukin (IL)-12; however, the ability of uninfected and infected ICSBP-deficient mice to produce IL-12 was markedly impaired. This indicates that ICSBP is a deciding factor in Th responses governing humoral and cellular immunity through its role in regulating IL-12 expression.

Mechanisms of heterosubtypic immunity to lethal influenza A virus infection in fully immunocompetent, T cell-depleted, beta2-microglobulin-deficient, and J chain-deficient mice

Immunity that is cross-protective between different influenza A virus subtypes (termed heterosubtypic immunity) can be demonstrated readily in some animals but only rarely in humans. Induction of heterosubtypic immunity in humans by vaccines would provide public health benefit, perhaps offering some protection against pandemics or other new influenza A strains. Therefore, we studied mechanisms mediating heterosubtypic immunity in mice. Immunization with either A/H1N1 or A/H3N2 virus protected mice against mortality following heterosubtypic challenge while providing modest reductions in lung virus titers. No cross-protection was seen with distantly related type B influenza virus. Depletion of CD4+ or CD8+ T cells or both around the time of challenge had no significant effect on survival, indicating that these cells are not required at the effector stage. beta2-microglobulin knockout mice could be protected readily against heterosubtypic challenge, confirming that class I-restricted T cells are not required. In beta2-microglobulin -/- mice, depletion of CD4+ T cells partially abrogated heterosubtypic immunity, showing that they play a role in these mice. Passive transfer of Abs to naive recipients protected against subsequent challenge with homologous but not heterosubtypic virus. Because a role for secretory Abs has been suggested, we studied dependence on the J chain, which is required for polymeric Ig receptor-mediated IgA transport. J chain knockout mice were readily protected by heterosubtypic immunity, indicating that polymeric Ig receptor-mediated transport is not required. Better understanding of heterosubtypic immunity should be valuable in analyzing new vaccines, including peptide and DNA vaccines, intended to induce broadly cross-reactive immunity.

Mechanisms of heterosubtypic immunity to lethal influenza A virus infection in fully immunocompetent, T cell-depleted, beta2-microglobulin-deficient, and J chain-deficient mice

Immunity that is cross-protective between different influenza A virus subtypes (termed heterosubtypic immunity) can be demonstrated readily in some animals but only rarely in humans. Induction of heterosubtypic immunity in humans by vaccines would provide public health benefit, perhaps offering some protection against pandemics or other new influenza A strains. Therefore, we studied mechanisms mediating heterosubtypic immunity in mice. Immunization with either A/H1N1 or A/H3N2 virus protected mice against mortality following heterosubtypic challenge while providing modest reductions in lung virus titers. No cross-protection was seen with distantly related type B influenza virus. Depletion of CD4+ or CD8+ T cells or both around the time of challenge had no significant effect on survival, indicating that these cells are not required at the effector stage. beta2-microglobulin knockout mice could be protected readily against heterosubtypic challenge, confirming that class I-restricted T cells are not required. In beta2-microglobulin -/- mice, depletion of CD4+ T cells partially abrogated heterosubtypic immunity, showing that they play a role in these mice. Passive transfer of Abs to naive recipients protected against subsequent challenge with homologous but not heterosubtypic virus. Because a role for secretory Abs has been suggested, we studied dependence on the J chain, which is required for polymeric Ig receptor-mediated IgA transport. J chain knockout mice were readily protected by heterosubtypic immunity, indicating that polymeric Ig receptor-mediated transport is not required. Better understanding of heterosubtypic immunity should be valuable in analyzing new vaccines, including peptide and DNA vaccines, intended to induce broadly cross-reactive immunity.

Mouse monoclonal antibodies to human immunodeficiency virus glycoprotein 120 generated by repeated immunization with glycoprotein 120 from a single isolate, or by sequential immunization with glycoprotein 120 from three isolates

Mouse hybridomas were isolated that produce monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) to several regions of the HIV envelope, gp120, which may be used to map immunogenic regions in animal and human immunity. One series of MAbs was generated by repeated immunization with recombinant gp120 (rgp120) from a single isolate, and a second series by sequential immunization with rgp120 from three isolates. All MAbs bound to rgp120IIIB, but only one bound well to cell surface-expressed gp160. Synthetic peptides spanning much of the length of gp120 were used to map MAb reactivity. Two MAbs were mapped to the C1 region, one to the C2 region, and three to the C5 region by this approach. Six distinct epitopes were detected by competitive binding analysis. One MAb binding the C1 region blocks binding of CD4 to rgp120IIIB, binds by ELISA to rgp120MN (an isolate not used during immunization), and binds to cell surface-expressed gp160. These hybridomas will be made available to the scientific community through a hybridoma culture facility.

Antibody repertoire in the response to a protein antigen. Interrelated idiotypic families in the response to Ia.7

Mouse alloantibodies to Ia.7 display a cross-reactive idiotype (CRI) recognized by xenogeneic anti-idiotypes. The CRI is expressed on serum Abs in all responding individuals and on all anti-Ia.7 mAbs, from mice of appropriate genetic types. In addition, both xenogeneic and allogeneic anti-idiotypes in this system have a striking ability to induce Ia.7-specific responses in mice never exposed to the Ag. Because of these unusual features, we have investigated the biologic and structural basis of the idiotypic sharing in this system. Ia.7-specific Ab populations induced by eight different Ab2 mAbs were analyzed for expression of each of the set of idiotopes. Two obvious explanations for the unusual properties of the system do not appear to be correct. 1) The induction of Ag-specific immunity was not caused by internal imagery; and 2) the Ab2s do not simply recognize the same idiotope, because they induce populations that were found to be distinct in idiotope expression. The biologic properties of the system are instead caused by a pattern of expression of idiotope sets on distinct but related Ab families, and a remarkable linkage of a series of different idiotopes to Ia.7-specific activity. Mouse anti-idiotypic responses failed to recognize the widely shared CRI site, even when sequential immunizations were performed. To examine the structural basis of Id sharing, light chains of three CRI+ mAbs were sequenced. They were found to be extremely homologous to each other and to the germ-line V kappa 21E gene, and they used either J1 or J2. A model containing families of distinct but related V regions is proposed for the anti-Ia.7 repertoire.

Antibody repertoire in the response to a protein antigen. Interrelated idiotypic families in the response to Ia.7

Mouse alloantibodies to Ia.7 display a cross-reactive idiotype (CRI) recognized by xenogeneic anti-idiotypes. The CRI is expressed on serum Abs in all responding individuals and on all anti-Ia.7 mAbs, from mice of appropriate genetic types. In addition, both xenogeneic and allogeneic anti-idiotypes in this system have a striking ability to induce Ia.7-specific responses in mice never exposed to the Ag. Because of these unusual features, we have investigated the biologic and structural basis of the idiotypic sharing in this system. Ia.7-specific Ab populations induced by eight different Ab2 mAbs were analyzed for expression of each of the set of idiotopes. Two obvious explanations for the unusual properties of the system do not appear to be correct. 1) The induction of Ag-specific immunity was not caused by internal imagery; and 2) the Ab2s do not simply recognize the same idiotope, because they induce populations that were found to be distinct in idiotope expression. The biologic properties of the system are instead caused by a pattern of expression of idiotope sets on distinct but related Ab families, and a remarkable linkage of a series of different idiotopes to Ia.7-specific activity. Mouse anti-idiotypic responses failed to recognize the widely shared CRI site, even when sequential immunizations were performed. To examine the structural basis of Id sharing, light chains of three CRI+ mAbs were sequenced. They were found to be extremely homologous to each other and to the germ-line V kappa 21E gene, and they used either J1 or J2. A model containing families of distinct but related V regions is proposed for the anti-Ia.7 repertoire.

Beta 2-microglobulin-deficient mice can be protected against influenza A infection by vaccination with vaccinia-influenza recombinants expressing hemagglutinin and neuraminidase

Immunity to viral infections includes both antibody and T cell components. The contributions of humoral and cell-mediated immune responses vary depending on virus and host factors. We have used an in vivo challenge system to examine protective immunity to influenza A(H1N1) virus infection in immunocompetent B6 (H-2b) mice, and in H-2b mice homozygous for disruption of the gene for beta 2-microglobulin, termed beta 2 mu(-/-) mice. The latter mice do not express conventional MHC class I complexes on cell surfaces and lack CD8+ class I-restricted T cells. Ten vaccinia virus recombinants, each expressing 1 of the 10 proteins of influenza virus, were used to immunize the mice. Normal mice were protected against challenge with influenza virus by vaccination with HA-VAC and NA-VAC, but not by any of the vaccinia vectors expressing one of the eight other influenza virus proteins nor by a mixture of all eight of the latter vectors. Similar results were observed in mice of H-2d or H-2k MHC haplotypes. The beta 2 mu(-/-) mice were also protected by immunization with HA-VAC and NA-VAC, demonstrating that classical CD8+ CTL responses were not required for protection. Depletion of CD4+ T cells in either normal or beta 2 mu(-/-) mice at the time of challenge had little or no effect on protection induced by HA-VAC or NA-VAC, suggesting that preformed antibody is the dominant mediator of protective immunity induced by these recombinants. Antibody responses to vaccinia virus Ag and expressed influenza virus Ag were lower in titer in beta 2 mu(-/-) mice than in normal B6 mice, suggesting an influence of MHC class I complexes, CD8+ T cells, or their products on antibody production.

Beta 2-microglobulin-deficient mice can be protected against influenza A infection by vaccination with vaccinia-influenza recombinants expressing hemagglutinin and neuraminidase

Immunity to viral infections includes both antibody and T cell components. The contributions of humoral and cell-mediated immune responses vary depending on virus and host factors. We have used an in vivo challenge system to examine protective immunity to influenza A(H1N1) virus infection in immunocompetent B6 (H-2b) mice, and in H-2b mice homozygous for disruption of the gene for beta 2-microglobulin, termed beta 2 mu(-/-) mice. The latter mice do not express conventional MHC class I complexes on cell surfaces and lack CD8+ class I-restricted T cells. Ten vaccinia virus recombinants, each expressing 1 of the 10 proteins of influenza virus, were used to immunize the mice. Normal mice were protected against challenge with influenza virus by vaccination with HA-VAC and NA-VAC, but not by any of the vaccinia vectors expressing one of the eight other influenza virus proteins nor by a mixture of all eight of the latter vectors. Similar results were observed in mice of H-2d or H-2k MHC haplotypes. The beta 2 mu(-/-) mice were also protected by immunization with HA-VAC and NA-VAC, demonstrating that classical CD8+ CTL responses were not required for protection. Depletion of CD4+ T cells in either normal or beta 2 mu(-/-) mice at the time of challenge had little or no effect on protection induced by HA-VAC or NA-VAC, suggesting that preformed antibody is the dominant mediator of protective immunity induced by these recombinants. Antibody responses to vaccinia virus Ag and expressed influenza virus Ag were lower in titer in beta 2 mu(-/-) mice than in normal B6 mice, suggesting an influence of MHC class I complexes, CD8+ T cells, or their products on antibody production.

Recombinant human CD4 elicits antibody responses different in epitope specificity from those that cellular CD4 elicits

Recombinant proteins have been proposed as subunit vaccines for many viral, bacterial and parasitic diseases, to reduce adverse side effects associated with inactivated or attenuated vaccines. Yet little is known about the comparative immunogenicity of recombinant proteins vs native forms present in cells or on organisms, and little is known about comparisons of the specificities of such immune responses. In another observation about differing forms of an antigen, about 10% of AIDS patients have anti-CD4 autoantibodies recognizing sites seen in recombinant CD4 (rCD4) but not present on cell surface CD4. We have analyzed antibody responses of mice to human CD4 when presented in recombinant or in cellular form. The response to the whole molecule was examined, as well as the responses to two sites within the molecule. In addition, any effect of immune response genes in the responding animal was sought, which might potentially restrict or modify any response to CD4. Mice immunized with rCD4 generated a large response to rCD4, but a lower response to the cell surface form, implying that additional sites are recognized on the recombinant form that are not recognized in the cellular form. Mice immunized with cells containing surface CD4 had high titers of antibody reactive with whole cells, of which only a small portion was reactive with rCD4. Titers on rCD4 are much lower for these mice than in rCD4-immunized mice. Both forms of CD4 induced antibodies to the gp120 binding site with comparable efficiency. For another site in domain 3 or 4 of CD4, cellular CD4 induced antibodies more frequently than the recombinant form. Immune response gene differences did not play a detectable role in the anti-CD4 response.

Regulatory concerns in human gene therapy

Gene therapy in humans is now being undertaken in an investigational setting. Such therapy involves the administration of biological products to human patients. A document entitled, "Points to Consider in Human Somatic Cell Therapy and Gene Therapy" has been prepared by the Center for Biologics Evaluation and Research (CBER) of the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and is published elsewhere in this issue. This paper provides explanatory material about the CBER regulatory process and the scientific and regulatory basis for the requests for data in that document.

Anti-Leu3a induces combining site-related anti-idiotypic antibody without inducing anti-HIV activity

Development of a vaccine for acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS) has proven difficult, and so alternative approaches such as idiotypic manipulation have been suggested. As applied to AIDS, this approach could involve immunizing with an anti-CD4 antibody resembling gp120, to induce anti-idiotypic antibodies which would bind to gp120. The CD4 binding site on gp120 is conserved, and so, such an immune response should protect against all variants. Induction of anti-human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) immunity has been reported using anti-Leu3a, and this result has led to testing in humans. Negative results obtained by others have been attributed to differences in immunization protocols. Because of the importance of this question, we reinvestigated the potential of anti-Leu3a to induce anti-HIV antibodies, compared with control immunizations with OKT4A (another anti-CD4 antibody) and the irrelevant Ig MOPC-21. Responses to anti-Leu3a showed induction of high-titer anti-idiotypic activity, and included combining-site-related activity. Yet sera showed no binding to gp160 above controls and no detectable neutralizing activity in a sensitive HIV plaque assay, so the anti-idiotypes induced were not internal images of CD4. We conclude that the pronounced anti-HIV responses reported with anti-Leu3a cannot be generalized, and thus that anti-Leu3a does not offer promise as an HIV vaccine. However, these results do not negate the promise of the idiotypic approach, and a vaccine for AIDS based on idiotype manipulation remains a possibility.

Induction of antigen-specific immunity with monoclonal anti-idiotypic antibodies in vivo: differences in potency and comparison of immunochemical properties

Anti-idiotypic (Id) antibodies provide a means other than antigen of clone-specific regulation of immune responses, and have been proposed as an alternative form of vaccine. However, the requirements for effective induction of immunity by anti-Id are not understood. Nine monoclonal anti-idiotope antibodies (anti-Id mAb) were derived in the Ia. 7 model system. While all nine anti-Id mAb induced comparable Ab3 responses in vivo as detected by ELISA, there were dramatic differences in the potency of the antigen-specific components of the responses induced by the nine anti-Id mAb. Anti-Id mAb that were indistinguishable in isotype, combining site relatedness, fine specificity on a panel of mAb, end point binding titers, competitive binding and ability to induce Ab3 differed dramatically in their ability to induce antigen-specific immunity in vivo, thus ruling out several models for explaining differences in induction.

Inheritance of idiotype expression unlinked to the H chain allotype locus. Novel features of genetic control in the Ia.7 system

We have observed a pattern of inherited idiotype expression in three mouse strains that is unexpected from the genetics of the strains: a dominant idiotype that was expressed at high levels in two parental strains was expressed only at low levels in a heavy chain allotype congenic strain derived from them. In the C3H.SW strain, the antibody response to the class II MHC Ag I-E is of limited diversity, with dominant expression of an idiotype and the V kappa 21 L chain. The C57BL/10 strain expresses the same idiotype at high levels, whereas the CWB/12 strain, which was derived by replacing the Ig H chain Igh-Cj allele of C3H.SW with the Igh-Cb allele derived from C57B1/10, has been found to express little of this dominant idiotype. CWB/12 responds, with titers equal to those of the parental strains, to the I-E epitope responsible for dominant idiotype expression, and it expresses normal V kappa 21 levels; thus deficiencies in epitope-specific responsiveness or in V kappa 21 expression cannot explain the low Id expression in CWB/12. Furthermore, Southern blot analysis of three VH families gave no evidence of recombination within the the VH locus of CWB/12, which was Igh-Vb throughout. Black-cross analysis demonstrated that expression of the dominant idiotype segregated independently of Ig allotype, and was therefore due to genes unlinked to the H chain gene locus. To our knowledge, this pattern of Id expression is unprecedented, and indicates the need for caution in the interpretation of studies using allotype congenic strains. It also demonstrates a role for genes outside the Igh locus in the control of Id expression.

Inheritance of idiotype expression unlinked to the H chain allotype locus. Novel features of genetic control in the Ia.7 system

We have observed a pattern of inherited idiotype expression in three mouse strains that is unexpected from the genetics of the strains: a dominant idiotype that was expressed at high levels in two parental strains was expressed only at low levels in a heavy chain allotype congenic strain derived from them. In the C3H.SW strain, the antibody response to the class II MHC Ag I-E is of limited diversity, with dominant expression of an idiotype and the V kappa 21 L chain. The C57BL/10 strain expresses the same idiotype at high levels, whereas the CWB/12 strain, which was derived by replacing the Ig H chain Igh-Cj allele of C3H.SW with the Igh-Cb allele derived from C57B1/10, has been found to express little of this dominant idiotype. CWB/12 responds, with titers equal to those of the parental strains, to the I-E epitope responsible for dominant idiotype expression, and it expresses normal V kappa 21 levels; thus deficiencies in epitope-specific responsiveness or in V kappa 21 expression cannot explain the low Id expression in CWB/12. Furthermore, Southern blot analysis of three VH families gave no evidence of recombination within the the VH locus of CWB/12, which was Igh-Vb throughout. Black-cross analysis demonstrated that expression of the dominant idiotype segregated independently of Ig allotype, and was therefore due to genes unlinked to the H chain gene locus. To our knowledge, this pattern of Id expression is unprecedented, and indicates the need for caution in the interpretation of studies using allotype congenic strains. It also demonstrates a role for genes outside the Igh locus in the control of Id expression.

Genetics of the induction of antigen-specific immunity in anti-idiotype-treated mice and derivation of monoclonal Ab3 antibodies

Antiidiotypic antibodies can be used as a means other than antigen of clone-specific intervention in the immune system. In a number of cases, antiidiotypic antibodies induce potent, antigen-specific responses without exposure of the recipient animals to antigen, and a better understanding of such responses will aid in the application of idiotype manipulation to both immunological and practical problems. The Ia. 7 system expresses a major, cross-reactive idiotype on antibodies to an epitope of the mouse I-E antigen. Here, we examine genetic control of the I-E-specific response to anti-idiotype in this model system. Results demonstrate that both heavy chain allotype-linked and non-allotype-linked loci contribute to the control of this response. In addition, monoclonal antibodies representing the non-antigen-specific portion of the Ab3 response were derived. Two idiotype-positive clones were demonstrated to be of IgM isotype, contrasting with previous data showing that the serum Ab3 response is predominantly IgG1.

Xenogeneic antibodies with apparent public idiotypic specificity for anti-Ia.7 antibodies are directed in part against V kappa 21D and E subgroup marker

Public idiotypes (IdX) expressed on monoclonal antibodies (mAb) against a monomorphic alpha-chain determinant of the I-E molecule (Ia.7 epitope cluster I) have been studied by using xenogeneic anti-Id reagents derived from pig, rabbit, and rat. IdX+ anti-Ia.7 mAb were recently demonstrated to be structurally related by a high frequency expression of the V kappa 21E light chain subgroup. This raised the question of whether V region determinants of the IdX were related to V kappa 21E sequences or whether they were unique to hypervariable regions of Ia.7 binding antibodies. To clarify this question, the possible association between the expression of the public Id (IdX(s)Ia.7) and the presence of V kappa sequences (V kappa 21E and/or J kappa segment) was examined. The reactivity of the anti-Id reagents with a random panel of 28 myeloma products (each containing a light chain from one of the different V kappa 21 subgroups) was studied by assaying the ability of these mAb to inhibit the binding between the anti-Id and anti-Ia.7 mAb. This analysis demonstrates that what has previously been defined as IdX Ia.7 includes determinants shared by V kappa 21E and V kappa 21D light chain V regions. The structures recognized are expressed irrespective of the J kappa segment. In addition, this study demonstrates interspecies variation in immune responses to such V kappa 21E antigenic determinants. Additional IdX components are found on anti-Ia.7 mAb but not on other V kappa 21E or D proteins. Thus V region subgroup considerations have crucial implications for Id characterization. In addition, this work describes the first division of the V kappa 21 subgroup into component parts by a mAb.

Xenogeneic antibodies with apparent public idiotypic specificity for anti-Ia.7 antibodies are directed in part against V kappa 21D and E subgroup marker

Public idiotypes (IdX) expressed on monoclonal antibodies (mAb) against a monomorphic alpha-chain determinant of the I-E molecule (Ia.7 epitope cluster I) have been studied by using xenogeneic anti-Id reagents derived from pig, rabbit, and rat. IdX+ anti-Ia.7 mAb were recently demonstrated to be structurally related by a high frequency expression of the V kappa 21E light chain subgroup. This raised the question of whether V region determinants of the IdX were related to V kappa 21E sequences or whether they were unique to hypervariable regions of Ia.7 binding antibodies. To clarify this question, the possible association between the expression of the public Id (IdX(s)Ia.7) and the presence of V kappa sequences (V kappa 21E and/or J kappa segment) was examined. The reactivity of the anti-Id reagents with a random panel of 28 myeloma products (each containing a light chain from one of the different V kappa 21 subgroups) was studied by assaying the ability of these mAb to inhibit the binding between the anti-Id and anti-Ia.7 mAb. This analysis demonstrates that what has previously been defined as IdX Ia.7 includes determinants shared by V kappa 21E and V kappa 21D light chain V regions. The structures recognized are expressed irrespective of the J kappa segment. In addition, this study demonstrates interspecies variation in immune responses to such V kappa 21E antigenic determinants. Additional IdX components are found on anti-Ia.7 mAb but not on other V kappa 21E or D proteins. Thus V region subgroup considerations have crucial implications for Id characterization. In addition, this work describes the first division of the V kappa 21 subgroup into component parts by a mAb.

Characterization of a dominant anti-Ia idiotype using the IA mutant mouse strain B6.C-H-2bm12

Initial studies of antibody recognition of Ia molecules using the IA mutant mouse strain bm12 suggested that two anti-Ia monoclonal antibodies (mAbs), 25-9-17 and 34-5-3, share several features: (1) indistinguishable serologic specificity including a lack of reactivity with Iabm12, (2) binding of the same spatial epitope (cluster), and (3) definition of a cross-reactive idiotype (CRI) as defined by xenogeneic antisera. In the present study we characterize a rabbit anti-idiotype (anti-Id) to 25-9-17 by affinity chromatography, and demonstrate that it detects at least two distinct idiotopes, one shared by 25-9-17 and 34-5-3 designated CRI (25-9-17) and one unique for 25-9-17 molecules. Experiments were also undertaken to determine whether CRI (25-9-17) represents a measurable component of allogeneic humoral responses to Iab antigens. By both absorption analyses of a polyspecific antiserum and production of antigenically-restricted antisera using bm12 mice, CRI (25-9-17) was found to represent a significant proportion of the antibodies to Iab. By several criteria it was shown that the CRI (25-9-17)+ molecules were among the antibodies defining the serologic lesion of bm12 mice. In preparation for future studies to alter in vivo T-cell responses involving recognition of Ia (e.g. graft vs host disease and allogeneic transplant rejection), various immunization protocols and mouse strains were tested for induction of Id (25-9-17) following in vivo administration of various anti-idiotypic reagents. Rabbit anti-Id (25-9-17) successfully induced CRI (25-9-17) positive molecules in all strains tested regardless of IA or Ig genotype. Moreover, some of these treated mice produced antibodies to an Ia determinant missing on bm12 cells, suggesting that they recognize the same serologic determinant as mAb 25-9-17.

A cell surface ELISA in the mouse using only poly-L-lysine as cell fixative

An ELISA using plates coated with mouse spleen cells has been developed for analysis of antibodies to cell surface antigens. Such assays have been used extensively with human cells or with tumor cells in various species, but application to normal mouse lymphocytes has been limited. Use of normal spleen cells allows access to the genetic resources offered by recombinant, congenic, and mutant mouse strains, in the preparation of cell-coated ELISA plates, the use of glutaraldehyde was found to be unnecessary and it was eliminated, thereby avoiding the destruction of some cell surface determinants. Poly-L-lysine, which was used to treat plates, was found to provide sufficient adherence and preservation of the cells. Binding of biotinylated monoclonal antibodies to cells could be detected at approximately 10 ng/well. In inhibition assays, unlabeled antibodies could be detected at approximately 10 ng/well. Cell-coated plates are stable once prepared, and can be stored for months before use. The assay described can be used to quantitate levels of antibody to a particular epitope, and can also be adapted for screening of fusions for monoclonal antibodies to cell surface antigens.

Idiotypes of anti-major histocompatibility complex antibodies

Our studies to date indicate that treatment with anti-idiotype to monoclonal anti-MHC antibodies can markedly influence the repertoire of anti-MHC antibodies expressed. The antibodies discussed here appear to represent two classes, one of which is public, probably representing expression of a germ line gene, and the second of which probably represents either a somatic variant of a germ line gene or one of a very large number of germ line genes devoted to the same specificity. In either case, this class of idiotype arises only rarely following antigen, but is readily induced by anti-idiotype treatment. There may indeed exist a third class of anti-MHC monoclonal antibodies representing distant somatic diversification from a germ line gene. Our only indication of this so far is that certain idiotypes are only induced after multiple boosts with anti-idiotypes rather than a single treatment. This finding, however, may reflect again the enormous number of different ways in which anti-MHC antibodies to the same nominal specificity can be produced. Finally, our results in adoptive transfer systems indicate that manipulation of idiotype expression by anti-idiotype treatment probably involves a complex pathway of cellular interactions. If, as we expect, these intercellular interactions involve idiotype and/or anti-idiotypic receptors, they should provide a model for mechanistic studies of the in vivo immune network.

Idiotypic and fluorometric analysis of the antibodies that distinguish the lesion of the I-A mutant B6.C-H-2bm12

The serologic lesion of the I-A mutant mouse strain, bm12, was investigated with the use of monoclonal anti-Iab antibodies and anti-idiotypic (Id) reagents produced against these antibodies. In a fluorometric analysis, three different monoclonal anti-Iab antibodies (25-9-17, 34-5-3, 28-16-8) failed to bind bm12 cells, whereas two anti-Iab antibodies (25-5-16 and 17/227), which bound bm12 cells, showed about one-half the fluorescence intensity that they showed in binding to Iab antigens. Of the three monoclonal antibodies that failed to react with bm12 cells, two antibodies (25-9-17 and 34-5-3) were found to bind the same steric site on Iab molecules (cluster I). In contrast, the antibodies (25-5-16 and 17/227) that reacted with both Iab and Iabm12 antigens were found to bind a second distinct site (cluster II). The binding of antibody 28-16-8 to Iab antigens inhibited reciprocally the binding of cluster I and II anti-Iab antibodies, suggesting a possible third site, sterically located intermediate between the other two sites. To assess the relatedness of the antibodies defining the serologic lesion of bm12 mice, xenogeneic and syngeneic anti-Id reagents were produced against antibodies 25-9-17 and 28-16-8. By using these anti-Ids in a binding site-related inhibition assay, a cross-reactive idiotype was detected that is shared by 25-9-17 and 34-5-3 antibodies; thus these two monoclonal antibodies share several features, including 1) idiotypic determinants, 2) failure to bind bm12 cells, 3) binding the same spatial Iab site, and 4) having indistinguishable serologic fine specificity that corresponds with a previously defined predominant alloantigenic determinant recognized in the bm12 anti-Iab humoral response. Therefore, several parameters of antibody recognition of Ia can now be correlated with structural changes in Ia molecules. These findings will potentiate future studies of the T cell recognition of these same Ia epitopes.

Idiotypic and fluorometric analysis of the antibodies that distinguish the lesion of the I-A mutant B6.C-H-2bm12

The serologic lesion of the I-A mutant mouse strain, bm12, was investigated with the use of monoclonal anti-Iab antibodies and anti-idiotypic (Id) reagents produced against these antibodies. In a fluorometric analysis, three different monoclonal anti-Iab antibodies (25-9-17, 34-5-3, 28-16-8) failed to bind bm12 cells, whereas two anti-Iab antibodies (25-5-16 and 17/227), which bound bm12 cells, showed about one-half the fluorescence intensity that they showed in binding to Iab antigens. Of the three monoclonal antibodies that failed to react with bm12 cells, two antibodies (25-9-17 and 34-5-3) were found to bind the same steric site on Iab molecules (cluster I). In contrast, the antibodies (25-5-16 and 17/227) that reacted with both Iab and Iabm12 antigens were found to bind a second distinct site (cluster II). The binding of antibody 28-16-8 to Iab antigens inhibited reciprocally the binding of cluster I and II anti-Iab antibodies, suggesting a possible third site, sterically located intermediate between the other two sites. To assess the relatedness of the antibodies defining the serologic lesion of bm12 mice, xenogeneic and syngeneic anti-Id reagents were produced against antibodies 25-9-17 and 28-16-8. By using these anti-Ids in a binding site-related inhibition assay, a cross-reactive idiotype was detected that is shared by 25-9-17 and 34-5-3 antibodies; thus these two monoclonal antibodies share several features, including 1) idiotypic determinants, 2) failure to bind bm12 cells, 3) binding the same spatial Iab site, and 4) having indistinguishable serologic fine specificity that corresponds with a previously defined predominant alloantigenic determinant recognized in the bm12 anti-Iab humoral response. Therefore, several parameters of antibody recognition of Ia can now be correlated with structural changes in Ia molecules. These findings will potentiate future studies of the T cell recognition of these same Ia epitopes.

Idiotypes of anti-Ia antibodies. II. Effects of in vivo treatment with xenogeneic anti-idiotype

The effects of in vivo treatment with xenogeneic anti-idiotypic antibodies were examined in an anti-Ia idiotypic system. Monoclonal antibody 14-4-4S, specific for Ia.7, has been shown to bear idiotopes that are expressed at readily detectable levels in conventional alloantibody responses. Sera from mice treated with purified anti-idiotypic antibodies (anti-Id) were found to contain inhibitory activity in an ELISA specific for the 14-4-4S Id, whereas sera from control mice treated with heterologous normal Ig did not. In addition, sera of anti-Id-treated C3H.SW mice contained specific anti-I-E activity, shown by binding to B10.A(2R) but not B10.A(4R) LPS blasts in flow microfluorometry. The anti-I-E induced by anti-Id included more IgG1 than IgG2. Even though a significant amount of anti-I-E activity was present in the serum, absorption analysis showed that most of the idiotope-positive antibody was not I-Ek-specific. Penetrance of induction of anti-I-E by anti-Id was 100% in the C3H.SW mice tested, and activity persisted in the serum for at least 8 to 9 mo in some cases. B10 mice produced only marginal anti-I-E activity after treatment, suggesting that induction is due to specific triggering rather than due entirely to a resemblance of anti-Id to the I-E antigen. The results thus indicate long-lasting alterations in an anti-Ia idiotypic system in the absence of exposure to conventional antigen, and represent specific manipulation of anti-Ia immunity.

Idiotypes of anti-Ia antibodies. II. Effects of in vivo treatment with xenogeneic anti-idiotype

The effects of in vivo treatment with xenogeneic anti-idiotypic antibodies were examined in an anti-Ia idiotypic system. Monoclonal antibody 14-4-4S, specific for Ia.7, has been shown to bear idiotopes that are expressed at readily detectable levels in conventional alloantibody responses. Sera from mice treated with purified anti-idiotypic antibodies (anti-Id) were found to contain inhibitory activity in an ELISA specific for the 14-4-4S Id, whereas sera from control mice treated with heterologous normal Ig did not. In addition, sera of anti-Id-treated C3H.SW mice contained specific anti-I-E activity, shown by binding to B10.A(2R) but not B10.A(4R) LPS blasts in flow microfluorometry. The anti-I-E induced by anti-Id included more IgG1 than IgG2. Even though a significant amount of anti-I-E activity was present in the serum, absorption analysis showed that most of the idiotope-positive antibody was not I-Ek-specific. Penetrance of induction of anti-I-E by anti-Id was 100% in the C3H.SW mice tested, and activity persisted in the serum for at least 8 to 9 mo in some cases. B10 mice produced only marginal anti-I-E activity after treatment, suggesting that induction is due to specific triggering rather than due entirely to a resemblance of anti-Id to the I-E antigen. The results thus indicate long-lasting alterations in an anti-Ia idiotypic system in the absence of exposure to conventional antigen, and represent specific manipulation of anti-Ia immunity.

Anti-idiotypes to monoclonal anti-H-2 antibodies. II. Expression of anti-H-2Kk idiotypes on antibodies induced by anti-idiotype or H-2Kk antigen

Anti-idiotypic antibodies were prepared against two monoclonal anti-H-2Kk antibodies, 11-4.1 and 3-83P. These reagents were used to examine idiotype (Id) expression on anti-H-2Kk antibodies induced by the in vivo administration of the anti-idiotypic antibodies and/or H-2Kk antigen. Treatment of BALB/c mice with anti-Id induced both antigen-binding and nonantigen-binding Id-positive molecules in the absence of antigen. The level of production of anti-Id-induced Id (Id') has been shown to be linked to VH genes using allotype congenic mice and backcross analyses. The idiotypes expressed on the Id' induced in anti-Id-treated mice were closely related or identical to those of the original monoclonal anti-H-2Kk antibody. However, the idiotopes were present on immunoglobulins of different subclasses and in some cases were not all expressed on the same molecules, as reflected by differences in their antigen specificities and isoelectric focusing patterns. In vivo administration of anti-Id had a marked influence on the subsequent humoral response to immunization with H-2 antigen.

Idiotypes of anti-Ia antibodies. I. Expression of the 14-4-4S idiotype in humoral immune responses

The idiotype of a mouse monoclonal anti-I-E antibody, 14-4-4S, has been studied using a heterologous anti-idiotypic reagent. This antibody recognizes Ia. 7, an antigenic specificity present in all strains expressing a product of the I-E subregion. Expression of the 14-4-4S idiotype in humoral immune responses was analyzed by an idiotype-specific enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay system. The idiotype was readily detectable in C3H.SW anti-C3H alloantisera, the same immunization combination from which the hybridoma was derived. Absorption analysis demonstrated the anti-I-E specificity of the idiotype-positive molecules in these alloantisera. Penetrance of idiotype expression was high among individual C3H.SW immune mice (9 of 10 tested). To examine genetic requirements for idiotype expression, an immunization was performed using as responders CWB mice, congenic with C3H.SW but differing at the heavy chain allotype loci. Immune sera of individual CWB mice contained very little or no idiotype, demonstrating that levels of idiotype expression are influenced by allotype-linked genes, although the influence of other genes has not been ruled. The 14-4-4S idiotype therefore represents a shared idiotype of anti-Ia antibodies and provides opportunities for analysis of the idiotypes of cellular receptors for the corresponding Ia antigen.

Quantitative measurement of mouse IgG subclasses with the use of heteroantisera: the importance of allotype considerations

Double antibody radioimmunoassays have been used to determine the quantities of IgG1, IgG2a and IgG2b in samples of normal serum IgG from BALB/cJ, AKR/J and C57BL/6J inbred mice. The assays employed subclass-specific goat antisera which had been prepared with BALB/c myeloma proteins as immunogens and as immunoabsorbents. 125I-labeled BALB/c myeloma proteins were used as probes. Results indicate that partial resolution of mouse IgG subclasses was achieved by ion exchange chromatography on DEAE-Sephadex. Nearly all of the protein in BALB/cJ and AKR/J IgG fractions could be accounted for as IgG1, IgG2a and IgG2b, and IgG2a was the predominant species observed. However, considerably less protein in C57BL/6J IgG fractions of purity similar to the BALB/cJ fractions could be accounted for as these three subclasses, and virtually no IgG2a was detected. Furthermore, an IgG2a myeloma protein bearing the C57BL/6 allotype failed to inhibit the IgG2a-specific assay significantly. Thus the IgG2a-specific antibody in the goat heteroantiserum employed appeared to consist nearly exclusively of antibody to BALB/c Ig-1a allotypic determinants. These findings point to the importance of allotype considerations in the use of heteroantisera to quantitate IgG subclasses.