The Frequency of Discordant Variant Classification in the Human Gene Mutation Database: A Comparison of the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics Guidelines and ClinVar

OBJECTIVE

Discordant variant classifications among public databases is one of the well-documented limitations when interpreting the pathogenicity of variants. The aim of this study is to investigate the level of germline variant misannotation from the Human Gene Mutation Database (HGMD) and the annotation concordance between databases.

METHODS

We used a total of 188,106 classified variants (disease-causing mutations [n = 179,454] and polymorphisms [n = 8652]) in 6466 genes from the HGMD. All variants were reanalyzed based on the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics (ACMG) guidelines and compared to ClinVar database variants.

RESULTS

When variants were classified based on the ACMG guidelines, misclassification was observed in 3.47% (2289/65,896) of variants. The overall concordance between HGMD and ClinVar was 97.62% (52,499/53,780) of variants studied.

CONCLUSION

Variants in databases must be used with caution when variant pathogenicity is interpreted. This study reveals the frequency of misannotation of the HGMD variants and annotation concordance between databases in depth.

5' splice site GC>GT and GT>GC variants differ markedly in terms of their functionality and pathogenicity

In the human genome, most 5' splice sites (~99%) employ the canonical GT dinucleotide whereas a small minority (~1%) use the noncanonical GC dinucleotide. The functionality and pathogenicity of 5' splice site GT>GC (+2T>C) variants have been extensively studied but we know very little about 5' splice site GC>GT (+2C>T) variants. Herein, we have addressed this deficiency by performing a meta-analysis of reported +2C>T "pathogenic" variants together with a functional analysis of engineered +2C>T substitutions using a cell culture-based full-length gene splicing assay. Our results establish proof of concept that +2C>T variants are qualitatively different from +2T>C variants in terms of their functionality and suggest that, in sharp contrast to +2T>C variants, most if not all +2C>T variants have no pathological relevance. Our findings have important implications for interpreting the clinical relevance of +2C>T variants and understanding the evolutionary switching between GT and GC 5' splice sites in mammalian genomes.

Sudden Arrhythmic Death During Exercise: A Post-Mortem Genetic Analysis

BACKGROUND

Sudden cardiac death is a natural and unexpected death that occurs within 1 h of the first symptom. Most sudden cardiac deaths occur during exercise, mostly as a result of myocardial infarction. After autopsy, some cases, especially in the young, are diagnosed as cardiomyopathies or remain without a conclusive cause of death. In both situations, genetic alterations may explain the arrhythmia.

OBJECTIVE

Our aim was to identify a genetic predisposition to sudden cardiac death in a cohort of post-mortem cases of individuals who died during exercise, with a structurally normal heart, and were classified as arrhythmogenic death.

METHODS

We analyzed a cohort of 52 post-mortem samples from individuals <50 years old who had a negative autopsy. Next-generation sequencing technology was used to screen genes associated with sudden cardiac death.

RESULTS

Our cohort showed a male prevalence (12:1). Half of the deaths occurred in individuals 41-50 years of age. Running was the most common exercise activity during the fatal event, accounting for 46.15% of cases. Genetic analysis identified 83 rare variants in 37 samples (71.15% of all samples). Of all rare variants, 36.14% were classified as deleterious, being present in 53.84% of all cases.

CONCLUSIONS

A comprehensive analysis of sudden cardiac death-related genes in individuals who died suddenly while exercising enabled the identification of potentially causative variants. However, many genetic variants remain of indeterminate significance, thus further work is needed before clinical translation. Nonetheless, comprehensive genetic analysis of individuals who died during exercise enables the detection of potentially causative variants and helps to identify at-risk relatives.

Rare genetic variants previously associated with congenital forms of long QT syndrome have little or no effect on the QT interval

AIMS

We studied whether variants previously associated with congenital long QT syndrome (cLQTS) have an effect on the QTc interval in a Danish population sample. Furthermore, we assessed whether carriers of variants in cLQTS-associated genes are more prone to experience syncope compared with non-carriers and whether carriers have an increased mortality compared with non-carriers.

METHODS AND RESULTS

All genetic variants previously associated with cLQTS were surveyed using the Human Gene Mutation Database. We screened a Danish population-based sample with available whole-exome sequencing data (n = 870) and genotype array data (n = 6161) for putative cLQTS genetic variants. In total, 33 of 1358 variants previously reported to associate with cLQTS were identified. Of these, 10 variants were found in 8 or more individuals. Electrocardiogram results showed normal mean QTc intervals in carriers compared with non-carriers. Syncope data analysis between variant and non-variant carriers showed that 4 of 227 (1.8%) and 95 of 5861 (1.6%) individuals, respectively, had experienced syncope during follow-up (P = 0.80). There was no significant difference in overall mortality rates between carriers [7/217 (3.2%)] and non-carriers [301/6453 (4.7%)] (P = 0.24).

CONCLUSION

We present QTc data and register data, indicating that 26 cLQTS-associated variants neither had any effect on the QTc intervals nor on syncope propensity or overall mortality. Based on the frequency of individual gene variants, we suggest that the 10 variants frequently identified, assumed to relate to cLQTS, are less likely to associate with a dominant monogenic form of the disease.

A novel mutation in MID1 in a patient with X-linked Opitz G/BBB syndrome

Opitz G/BBB syndrome (OS) is a genetically heterogeneous disease. We report on an OS patient with a novel inherited mutation in MID1. Metaphase analysis showed a normal male karyotype. Array CGH revealed a maternally inherited duplication at Xp22.31 (6,467,203-7,992,261, hg18), the size was estimated to 1.5Mb. Sequence analysis of the MID1 coding region revealed a novel missense mutation in exon 8 (c.1561C>T/p. R521C) which resulted in an ammonia acid substitution (R521C) in the PRX domain of the MID1 protein. The mutation was inherited from unaffected grandmother and mildly affected mother. Prenatal diagnosis was performed for the third pregnancy after identification of the causative mutation in the family. The third fetus was found to be a female carrier. Postnatal follow-up at 2-month-old showed normal phenotype. In conclusion, we reported a familial OS patient with a novel mutation in exon 8 which provided another evidence for that mutation clustered in C-terminal domain of MID1. The newly identified mutation in our patient expands mutation spectrum in MID1 gene.

Two novel mutations in the SLCO2A1 gene in a Chinese patient with primary hypertrophic osteoarthropathy

Primary hypertrophic osteoarthropathy (PHO) is a rare monogenetic disease characterized by digital clubbing, periostosis and pachydermia. Mutations in the 15-hydroxy-prostaglandin dehydrogenase (HPGD) gene and solute carrier organic anion transporter family member 2A1 (SLCO2A1) gene have been shown to be associated with PHO. Here, we described clinical characteristics in a Chinese patient with PHO, and identified two novel mutations in SLCO2A1: a heterozygous guanine-to-thymidine transition at the invariant -1 position of the acceptor site of intron 2 (c.235-1G>T) and a heterozygous missense mutation p.Pro219Leu (c.656C>T) in exon 5.

The effects of non-synonymous single nucleotide polymorphisms (nsSNPs) on protein-protein interactions

Non-synonymous single nucleotide polymorphisms (nsSNPs) are single base changes leading to a change to the amino acid sequence of the encoded protein. Many of these variants are associated with disease, so nsSNPs have been well studied, with studies looking at the effects of nsSNPs on individual proteins, for example, on stability and enzyme active sites. In recent years, the impact of nsSNPs upon protein-protein interactions has also been investigated, giving a greater insight into the mechanisms by which nsSNPs can lead to disease. In this review, we summarize these studies, looking at the various mechanisms by which nsSNPs can affect protein-protein interactions. We focus on structural changes that can impair interaction, changes to disorder, gain of interaction, and post-translational modifications before looking at some examples of nsSNPs at human-pathogen protein-protein interfaces and the analysis of nsSNPs from a network perspective.

Mutation spectrum of primary hyperoxaluria type 1 in Tunisia: implication for diagnosis in North Africa

BACKGROUND

Primary hyperoxaluria type 1 (PH1) is an autosomal recessive inherited metabolic disease, characterized by progressive kidney failure due to renal deposition of calcium oxalate. Mutations in the AGXT gene, encoding the liver-specific enzyme alanine glyoxylate aminotransferase, are responsible for the disease. We aimed to determine the mutational spectrum causing PH1 and to provide an accurate tool for diagnosis as well as for prenatal diagnosis in the affected families.

METHODS

Direct sequencing was used to detect mutations in the AGXT gene in DNA samples from 13 patients belonging to 12 Tunisian families.

RESULTS

Molecular analysis revealed five mutations causing PH1 in Tunisia. The mutations were identified along exons 1, 2, 4, 5 and 7. The most predominant mutations were the Maghrebian "p.I244T" and the Arabic "p.G190R". Furthermore, three other mutations characteristic of different ethnic groups were found in our study population. These results confirm the mutational heterogeneity related to PH1 in Tunisian population. All the mutations are in a homozygous state, reflecting the high impact of endogamy in our population.

CONCLUSION

Mutation analysis through DNA sequencing can provide a useful first line investigation for PH1. This identification could provide an accurate tool for prenatal diagnosis, genetic counseling and screen for potential presymptomatic individuals.