Epidemiology, methods of diagnosis, and clinical management of patients with arginase 1 deficiency (ARG1-D): A systematic review

BACKGROUND

Arginase 1 Deficiency (ARG1-D) is a rare, progressive, metabolic disorder that is characterized by devastating manifestations driven by elevated plasma arginine levels. It typically presents in early childhood with spasticity (predominately affecting the lower limbs), mobility impairment, seizures, developmental delay, and intellectual disability. This systematic review aims to identify and describe the published evidence outlining the epidemiology, diagnosis methods, measures of disease progression, clinical management, and outcomes for ARG1-D patients.

METHODS

A comprehensive literature search across multiple databases such as MEDLINE, Embase, and a review of clinical studies in ClinicalTrials.gov (with results reported) was carried out per PRISMA guidelines on 20 April 2020 with no date restriction. Pre-defined eligibility criteria were used to identify studies with data specific to patients with ARG1-D. Two independent reviewers screened records and extracted data from included studies. Quality was assessed using the modified Newcastle-Ottawa Scale for non-comparative studies.

RESULTS

Overall, 55 records reporting 40 completed studies and 3 ongoing studies were included. Ten studies reported the prevalence of ARG1-D in the general population, with a median of 1 in 1,000,000. Frequently reported diagnostic methods included genetic testing, plasma arginine levels, and red blood cell arginase activity. However, routine newborn screening is not universally available, and lack of disease awareness may prevent early diagnosis or lead to misdiagnosis, as the disease has overlapping symptomology with other diseases, such as cerebral palsy. Common manifestations reported at time of diagnosis and assessed for disease progression included spasticity (predominately affecting the lower limbs), mobility impairment, developmental delay, intellectual disability, and seizures. Severe dietary protein restriction, essential amino acid supplementation, and nitrogen scavenger administration were the most commonly reported treatments among patients with ARG1-D. Only a few studies reported meaningful clinical outcomes of these interventions on intellectual disability, motor function and adaptive behavior assessment, hospitalization, or death. The overall quality of included studies was assessed as good according to the Newcastle-Ottawa Scale.

CONCLUSIONS

Although ARG1-D is a rare disease, published evidence demonstrates a high burden of disease for patients. The current standard of care is ineffective at preventing disease progression. There remains a clear need for new treatment options as well as improved access to diagnostics and disease awareness to detect and initiate treatment before the onset of clinical manifestations to potentially enable more normal development, improve symptomatology, or prevent disease progression.

Current status of surviving patients with arginase 1 deficiency in Japan

Arginase 1 (ARG1) deficiency is a rare urea cycle disorder (UCD), with an estimated frequency of 1 per 2,200,000 births in Japan. Patients with ARG1 deficiency develop symptoms in late infancy or pre-school age with progressive neurological manifestations and sometimes present with severe hepatic disease. We previously investigated the status of UCDs in Japan; however, only one patient was identified as having ARG1 deficiency. Therefore, we aimed to investigate the current status of patients with ARG1 deficiency in 2018–2021 because almost 10 years have passed since the previous study. We present the disease history, clinical outcome, and treatment of five surviving patients with ARG1 deficiency and discuss the features of ARG1 deficiency in Japan. We found that clinicians often face difficulty in diagnosing ARG1 deficiency at the early stage of onset because of interpatient variability in onset time and clinical manifestations. Blood L-arginine and guanidino compounds were considered to be the major factors causing adverse neurodevelopmental outcomes. Therefore, early detection and intervention of ARG1 deficiency is essential for improved neurodevelopmental outcomes. Liver transplantation has been considered an effective treatment option that can dramatically improve the quality of life of patients, prior to the neurological manifestation of symptoms caused by ARG1 deficiency.

Spastic gait, intellectual disability and seizures due to a rare mutation causing hyperargininemia

Hyperargininemia is an autosomal recessive disorder caused by a defect in the arginase I enzyme. We present a case of a 20-year-old male with severe spastic gait, intellectual disability and seizures. Metabolic tests revealed high levels of arginine in blood serum. Hyperargininemia was attributed to a likely pathogenic rare mutation of ARG1 gene [Chr6: g131905002_131905002 G>A (p.Arg308Gln) homozygous] detected in Whole Exome Sequencing resulting in deficiency in arginase I enzyme. Following the diagnosis, the patient has been treated with low protein diet, aminoacid and vitamin supplements. The accumulation of arginine, may contribute to the pathogenesis of severe neurological manifestations, however, low protein intake diet may lead to a favorable outcome. Therefore, clinicians should screen for hyperargininemia in early childhood in case of strong clinical suspicion.

Arginase-1 deficiency in neural cells does not contribute to neurodevelopment or functional outcomes after sciatic nerve injury

Arginase-1 (Arg1) is an enzyme controlling the final step of the urea cycle, with highest expression in the liver and lower expression in the lungs, pancreas, kidney, and some blood cells. Arg1 deficiency is an inherited urea cycle disorder presenting with neurological dysfunction including spastic diplegia, intellectual and growth retardation, and encephalopathy. The contribution of Arg1 expression in the central and peripheral nervous system to the development of neurological phenotypes remains largely unknown. Previous studies have shown prominent arginase-1 expression in the nervous system and post-peripheral nerve injury in mice, but very low levels in the naïve state. To investigate neurobiological roles of Arg1, we created a conditional neural (n)Arg1 knockout (KO) mouse strain, with expression eliminated in neuronal and glial precursors, and compared them to littermate controls. Long-term analysis did not reveal any major differences in blood amino acid levels, body weight, or stride gait cycle from 8 to 26-weeks of age. Brain structure measured by magnetic resonance imaging at 16-weeks of age observed only a significant decrease in the volume of the mammillary bodies. We also assessed whether nArg1, which is expressed by sensory neurons after injury, may play a role in regeneration following sciatic nerve crush. Only subtle differences were observed in locomotor and sensory recovery between nArg1 KO and control mice. These results suggest that arginase-1 expression in central and peripheral neural cells does not contribute substantially to the phenotypes of this urea cycle disorder, nor is it likely crucial for post-injury regeneration in this mouse model.

Defective arginine metabolism impairs mitochondrial homeostasis in Caenorhabditiselegans

Arginine catabolism involves enzyme-dependent reactions in both mitochondria and the cytosol, defects in which may lead to hyperargininemia, a devastating developmental disorder. It is largely unknown if defective arginine catabolism has any effects on mitochondria. Here we report that normal arginine catabolism is essential for mitochondrial homeostasis in Caenorhabditiselegans. Mutations of the arginase gene argn-1 lead to abnormal mitochondrial enlargement and reduced adenosine triphosphate (ATP) production in C. elegans hypodermal cells. ARGN-1 localizes to mitochondria and its loss causes arginine accumulation, which disrupts mitochondrial dynamics. Heterologous expression of human ARG1 or ARG2 rescued the mitochondrial defects of argn-1 mutants. Importantly, genetic inactivation of the mitochondrial basic amino acid transporter SLC-25A29 or the mitochondrial glutamate transporter SLC-25A18.1 fully suppressed the mitochondrial defects caused by argn-1 mutations. These findings suggest that mitochondrial damage probably contributes to the pathogenesis of hyperargininemia and provide clues for developing therapeutic treatments for hyperargininemia.

Sodium phenylbutyrate improved the clinical state in an adult patient with arginase 1 deficiency

An adult female patient was diagnosed with arginase 1 deficiency (ARG1-D) at 4 years of age, and had been managed with protein restriction combined with sodium benzoate therapy. Though the treatment was successful in ameliorating hyperammonemia, hyperargininemia persisted. After being under control with a strict restriction of dietary protein, severe fall of serum albumin levels appeared and her condition became strikingly worsened. However, after sodium phenylbutyrate (NaPB) therapy was initiated, the clinical condition and metabolic stability was greatly improved. Current management of ARG1-D is aimed at lowering plasma arginine levels. The nitrogen scavengers, such as NaPB can excrete the waste nitrogen not through the urea cycle but via the alternative pathway. The removal of nitrogen via alternative pathway lowers the flux of arginine in the urea cycle. Thereby, the clinical complications due to insufficient amount of protein intake can be prevented. Thus, NaPB therapy can be expected as a useful therapeutic option, particularly in patients with ARG1-D.

Anesthetic management of a pediatric patient with arginase-1 deficiency undergoing strabismus operation: a case report

Background

Urea cycle disorders are rare; arginase-1 deficiency is one of those extremely rare autosomal recessive metabolic disorders. Arginase-1 is one among the enzymes involved in the production of urea from ammonia in the liver, and its deficiency produces the characteristic feature, hyperargininemia.

Case presentation

We report a case of a girl, aged 5 years and 10 months presenting with arginase-1 deficiency. The patient was scheduled to undergo strabismus surgery for intermittent exotropia under general anesthesia. Preoperative blood tests showed high serum arginine levels, but ammonia levels were within the normal range. Anesthesia was induced with sevoflurane and nitrous oxide via face mask and maintained with sevoflurane, fentanyl, and rocuronium. Vital signs were stable throughout the surgery. There was an intraoperative decrease in blood glucose levels (from 82 mg/dL to 42 mg/dL) that was treated with intravenous glucose. Arginine levels remained high after surgery; however, hyperammonemia did not develop. There were no complications and the patient was discharged on the following day.

Conclusions

We successfully performed general anesthesia in a child with hyperargininemia. Only a few cases of arginase-1 deficiency had been reported and much remains unknown about its pathology. Therefore, information sharing among medical professionals is essential to customize the plan for the management of this disorder in patients.

Recurrent hepatic failure and status epilepticus: an uncommon presentation of hyperargininemia

Argininemia is a rare hereditary disease due to a deficiency of hepatic arginase, which is the last enzyme of the urea cycle and hydrolyzes arginine to ornithine and urea. Herein we report a patient with arginase I (ARG1) deficiency who presented with recurrent nonconvulsive status epilepticus and liver failure. A novel homozygous frameshift mutation c.703_707delGGACTinsAGACTGGACC (p.G235Rfs*20) was detected.

Human hepatocyte transplantation corrects the inherited metabolic liver disorder arginase deficiency in mice

The transplantation, engraftment, and expansion of primary hepatocytes have the potential to be an effective therapy for metabolic disorders of the liver including those of nitrogen metabolism. To date, such methods for the treatment of urea cycle disorders in murine models has only been minimally explored. Arginase deficiency, an inherited disorder of nitrogen metabolism that presents in the first two years of life, has the potential to be treated by such methods. To explore the potential of this approach, we mated the conditional arginase deficient mouse with a mouse model deficient in fumarylacetoacetate hydrolase (FAH) and with Rag2 and IL2-Rγ mutations to give a selective advantage to transplanted (normal) human hepatocytes. On day -1, a uroplasminogen-expressing adenoviral vector was administered intravenously followed the next day with the transplantation of 1 × 10⁶ human hepatocytes (or vehicle alone) by intrasplenic injection. As the initial number of administered hepatocytes would be too low to prevent hepatotoxicity-induced mortality, NTBC cycling was performed to allow for hepatocyte expansion and repopulation. While all control mice died, all except one human hepatocyte transplanted mice survived. Four months after hepatocyte transplantation, 2 × 10¹¹ genome copies of AAV-TBG-Cre recombinase was administered IV to disrupt endogenous hepatic arginase expression. While all control mice died within the first month, human hepatocyte transplanted mice did well. Ammonia and amino acids, analyzed in both groups before and after disruption of endogenous arginase expression, while well-controlled in the transplanted group, were markedly abnormal in the controls. Ammonium challenging further demonstrated the durability and functionality of the human repopulated liver. In conclusion, these studies demonstrate that human hepatocyte repopulation in the murine liver can result in effective treatment of arginase deficiency.

Newborn screening for hyperargininemia due to arginase 1 deficiency

Hyperargininemia caused by Arginase 1 deficiency is a rare disorder of the urea cycle that can be diagnosed by elevation of arginine in newborn screening blood spots when analyzed by tandem mass spectrometry. Hyperargininemia is currently included as a secondary target on the U.S. Recommended Uniform Screening Panel, which directly influences state-based newborn screening. Because of the apparent low disease frequency and lack of case detection and treatment data, detailed attention has not been given to a model newborn screening algorithm including appropriate analytical cutoff values for disease indicators. In this paper we assess the frequency of hyperargininemia in the U.S. identified by newborn screening to date and document the current status and variability of hyperargininemia newborn screening across U.S. newborn screening programs. We also review other data that support improved screening efficacy by utilizing the arginine/ornithine ratio and other amino acid ratios as discriminators in the screening algorithm. Analysis of archived California screening data showed that an arginine cutoff of 50μM combined with an arginine/ornithine ratio of 1.4 would have resulted in a recall rate of 0.01%. Using an arginine cutoff of 60μM and an arginine/(phenylalanine x leucine) ratio of 1.4, reportedly used in one screening program, or the R4S Tool Runner, would have resulted in a recall rate of <0.005%. All 9 diagnosed patients would have been found for either protocol. Thus, use of appropriate ratios as part of the screening algorithm has the potential to increase both screening sensitivity and specificity. Improved newborn screening effectiveness should lead to better case detection and more rapid treatment to lower plasma arginine levels hence improving long term outcome of individuals with hyperargininemia.

Characterization and mRNA expression analysis of a novel ARG1 splicing mutation causing hyperargininemia

OBJECTIVES

Biallelic mutations in the ARG1 gene result in an uncommon autosomal recessive inborn defect of the urea cycle known as hyperargininemia (OMIM #207800). ARG1 splicing mutations are not reported often, and they are probably related to a more severe phenotype than missense mutations. In this article, we describe the results of molecular studies in a young hyperargininemia patient carrying a novel splicing mutation in ARG1.

DESIGN AND METHODS

Molecular analyses included PCR amplification and direct nucleotide sequencing of the ARG1 gene. RT-PCR analysis was performed to investigate the effect of the mutation in mRNA splicing and in the expression of ARG1 isoforms.

RESULTS

Mutational analysis identified a novel homozygous ARG1 IVS4-1G>C point mutation in the patient's DNA. Blood leukocyte mRNA was analyzed to demonstrate the splicing defect caused by this mutation. Sequencing of ARG1 RT-PCR products allowed the characterization of a mutated transcript retaining 51-bp from intron 4. In addition, two new, alternatively spliced ARG1 transcripts lacking either exon 4 or exons 4 and 5 were identified in mRNA from the patient and from controls.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results expand the mutational spectrum in hyperargininemia patients and indicate that the novel splicing mutation results in an aberrant transcript retaining intronic sequences. Two novel alternatively spliced ARG1 transcripts were also recognized.

Lethal phenotype in conditional late-onset arginase 1 deficiency in the mouse

Human arginase deficiency is characterized by hyperargininemia and infrequent episodes of hyperammonemia, which lead to neurological impairment with spasticity, loss of ambulation, seizures, and severe mental and growth retardation; uncommonly, patients suffer early death from this disorder. In a murine targeted knockout model, onset of the phenotypic abnormality is heralded by weight loss at around day 15, and death occurs typically by postnatal day 17 with hyperargininemia and markedly elevated ammonia. This discrepancy between the more attenuated juvenile-onset human disease and the lethal neonatal murine model has remained suboptimal for studying and developing therapy for the more common presentation of arginase deficiency. These investigations aimed to address this issue by creating an adult conditional knockout mouse to determine whether later onset of arginase deficiency also resulted in lethality. Animal survival and ammonia levels, body weight, circulating amino acids, and tissue arginase levels were examined as outcome parameters after widespread Cre-recombinase activation in a conditional knockout model of arginase 1 deficiency. One hundred percent of adult female and 70% of adult male mice died an average of 21.0 and 21.6 days, respectively, after the initiation of tamoxifen administration. Animals demonstrated elevated circulating ammonia and arginine at the onset of phenotypic abnormalities. In addition, brain and liver amino acids demonstrated abnormalities. These studies demonstrate that (a) the absence of arginase in adult animals results in a disease profile (leading to death) similar to that of the targeted knockout and (b) the phenotypic abnormalities seen in the juvenile-onset model are not exclusive to the age of the animal but instead to the biochemistry of the disorder. This adult model will be useful for developing gene- and cell-based therapies for this disorder that will not be limited by the small animal size of neonatal therapy and for developing a better understanding of the characteristics of hyperargininemia.