Why study human embryo development?

Understanding the processes and mechanisms underlying early human embryo development has become an increasingly active and important area of research. It has potential for insights into important clinical issues such as early pregnancy loss, origins of congenital anomalies and developmental origins of adult disease, as well as fundamental insights into human biology. Improved culture systems for preimplantation embryos, combined with the new tools of single cell genomics and live imaging, are providing new insights into the similarities and differences between human and mouse development. However, access to human embryo material is still restricted and extended culture of early embryos has regulatory and ethical concerns. Stem cell-derived models of different phases of human development can potentially overcome these limitations and provide a scalable source of material to explore the early postimplantation stages of human development. To date, such models are clearly incomplete replicas of normal development but future technological improvements can be envisaged. The ethical and regulatory environment for such studies remains to be fully resolved.

Cell specification and functional interactions in the pig blastocyst inferred from single-cell transcriptomics and uterine fluids proteomics

The embryonic development of the pig comprises a long in utero pre- and peri-implantation development, which dramatically differs from mice and humans. During this peri-implantation period, a complex series of paracrine signals establishes an intimate dialogue between the embryo and the uterus. To better understand the biology of the pig blastocyst during this period, we generated a large dataset of single-cell RNAseq from early and hatched blastocysts, spheroid and ovoid conceptus and proteomic datasets from corresponding uterine fluids. Our results confirm the molecular specificity and functionality of the three main cell populations. We also discovered two previously unknown subpopulations of the trophectoderm, one characterised by the expression of LRP2, which could represent progenitor cells, and the other, expressing pro-apoptotic markers, which could correspond to the Rauber's layer. Our work provides new insights into the biology of these populations, their reciprocal functional interactions, and the molecular dialogue with the maternal uterine environment.

Using extended growth of cattle embryos in culture to gain insights into bovine developmental events on embryonic days 8 to 10

We have previously described an extended embryo culture system, based on uterine composition, growth factors and the cell culture additive B27, for growing cattle embryos in vitro beyond embryonic day 7. Here, extended in vitro embryos are compared to embryos developed in the uterus and are used to establish a developmental staging framework useful for understanding developmental events occurring until Day 10. Immunofluorescence or mRNA expression of the ICM/epiblast markers OCT4, SOX2 and NANOG, hypoblast markers GATA6, SOX17 and GATA4 and trophoblast genes CDX2, GATA3, ASCL2 and IFNT revealed the presence of four stages during this period that can be molecularly distinguished. These are expanded blastocyst, hatched blastocyst, hypoblast layering and early hypoblast migration. Interestingly NANOG and SOX17 show reciprocal expression at the expanded blastocyst stage, well before SOX2 and GATA6 expression refines to a similar so-called "salt and pepper" mutually exclusive expression in the ICM at the hatched blastocyst stage. GATA4 expression is only seen from stages when the hypoblast starts migrating around the blastocyst cavity. Intriguingly, trophoblast still expresses GATA6 and OCT4 in all cells during the expanded blastocyst phase, while SOX2 and SOX17 are seen in only some trophoblast cells. By the hypoblast-epiblast layering stage no trophoblast expression remains except for that of OCT4 protein, which starts waning in trophoblast once the hypoblast begins migrating. Lastly, it is shown that cultured embryos exhibit increased expression of the stress marker TP53 in the epiblast and hypoblast at late stages in comparison to embryos produced in the uterine environment.

Evidence implicating sequential commitment of the founder lineages in the human blastocyst by order of hypoblast gene activation

Successful human pregnancy depends upon rapid establishment of three founder lineages: the trophectoderm, epiblast and hypoblast, which together form the blastocyst. Each plays an essential role in preparing the embryo for implantation and subsequent development. Several models have been proposed to define the lineage segregation. One suggests that all lineages specify simultaneously; another favours the differentiation of the trophectoderm before separation of the epiblast and hypoblast, either via differentiation of the hypoblast from the established epiblast, or production of both tissues from the inner cell mass precursor. To begin to resolve this discrepancy and thereby understand the sequential process for production of viable human embryos, we investigated the expression order of genes associated with emergence of hypoblast. Based upon published data and immunofluorescence analysis for candidate genes, we present a basic blueprint for human hypoblast differentiation, lending support to the proposed model of sequential segregation of the founder lineages of the human blastocyst. The first characterised marker, specific initially to the early inner cell mass, and subsequently identifying presumptive hypoblast, is PDGFRA, followed by SOX17, FOXA2 and GATA4 in sequence as the hypoblast becomes committed.

Deriving Human Naïve Embryonic Stem Cell Lines from Donated Supernumerary Embryos Using Physical Distancing and Signal Inhibition

Until recently, naïve pluripotent stem cell lines were not captured from human embryos because protocols were based upon those devised for murine embryonic stem cells. In contrast with early lineage segregation in mouse embryos, human hypoblast specification is not solely dependent upon FGF signaling; consequently, its maturation during embryo explant culture may provide inductive signals to drive differentiation of the epiblast. To overcome this potential risk, here we describe how cells of the immature inner cell mass of human embryos can be physically separated during derivation, achieved via "immunosurgery", to eliminate the trophectoderm, followed by disaggregation of the remaining inner cell mass cells. A modification of a culture regime developed for propagation of human pluripotent stem cells reset to the naïve state is used, which comprises serum-free medium supplemented with various inhibitors of signaling pathways, polarization, and differentiation. Colonies arising from the first plating of an inner cell mass may be pooled for ease of handling, or propagated separately to allow establishment of clonal human naïve embryonic stem cell lines.

Differentiation and Expansion of Human Extra-Embryonic Endoderm Cell Lines from Naïve Pluripotent Stem Cells

In human, endoderm is induced in two waves, with the first being the extra-embryonic primitive endoderm (PrE), otherwise known as hypoblast, induced during blastocyst development, and the second being gastrulation-stage definitive endoderm (DE). The PrE gives rise to the primary and secondary yolk sac, and has supportive functions during pregnancy for nutrient provision, with descendants of this extra-embryonic lineage also playing a role in embryonic patterning. As in DE specification, we recently found that PrE could be induced in vitro by Wnt and Nodal-related signaling, but that the critical difference was in the pluripotent starting point for differentiation. Thus, blastocyst-like naïve human pluripotent stem cells retain the unique capacity to differentiate into PrE cultures, a cell type resembling the pre-implantation hypoblast. The PrE cells could then be expanded as stable naïve extra-embryonic endoderm (nEnd) cell lines, capable of indefinite self-renewal. Here, we describe detailed protocols to differentiate naïve pluripotent stem cells into PrE and then expand the cultures as nEnd, including descriptions of morphology, passaging technique, and troubleshooting.

Naïve human pluripotent stem cells respond to Wnt, Nodal and LIF signalling to produce expandable naïve extra-embryonic endoderm

Embryonic stem cells (ESCs) exist in at least two states that transcriptionally resemble different stages of embryonic development. Naïve ESCs resemble peri-implantation stages and primed ESCs the pre-gastrulation epiblast. In mouse, primed ESCs give rise to definitive endoderm in response to the pathways downstream of Nodal and Wnt signalling. However, when these pathways are activated in naïve ESCs, they differentiate to a cell type resembling early primitive endoderm (PrE), the blastocyst-stage progenitor of the extra-embryonic endoderm. Here, we apply this context dependency to human ESCs, showing that activation of Nodal and Wnt signalling drives the differentiation of naïve pluripotent cells toward extra-embryonic PrE, or hypoblast, and these can be expanded as an in vitro model for naïve extra-embryonic endoderm (nEnd). Consistent with observations made in mouse, human PrE differentiation is dependent on FGF signalling in vitro, and we show that, by inhibiting FGF receptor signalling, we can simplify naïve pluripotent culture conditions, such that the inhibitor requirements closer resemble those used in mouse. The expandable nEnd cultures reported here represent stable extra-embryonic endoderm, or human hypoblast, cell lines.This article has an associated 'The people behind the papers' interview.

A dose-dependent response to MEK inhibition determines hypoblast fate in bovine embryos

BACKGROUND

The segregation of the hypoblast and the emergence of the pluripotent epiblast mark the final stages of blastocyst formation in mammalian embryos. In bovine embryos the formation of the hypoblast has been partially studied, and evidence shows that MEK signalling plays a limited role in the segregation of this lineage. Here we explored the role of different signalling pathways during lineage segregation in the bovine embryo using immunofluorescence analysis of NANOG and SOX17 as readouts of epiblast and hypoblast, respectively.

RESULTS

We show that SOX17 starts to be expressed in 16-32-cell stage embryos, whereas NANOG is first detected from 8-cell stage. SOX17 is first co-expressed with NANOG, but these markers become mutually exclusive by the late blastocyst stage. By assessing the expression kinetics of NANOG/SOX17 we show that inhibition of MEK signalling can eliminate SOX17 expression in bovine blastocysts, without altering NANOG expression. Modulation of WNT, PKC and LIF did not affect NANOG expression in the epiblast when used in combination with the ERK inhibitor.

CONCLUSIONS

This study shows that SOX17 can be used as a reliable early marker of hypoblast in the bovine, and based on its expression profile we show that the hypoblast segregates in day 7 blastocysts. Furthermore, SOX17 expression is abolished using 1 μM of PD0325901, without affecting the NANOG population in the epiblast. Modulation of WNT, PKC and LIF are not sufficient to support enhanced NANOG expression in the epiblast when combined with ERK inhibitor, indicating that additional signalling pathways should be examined to determine their potential roles in epiblast expansion.

Pre-implantation Development of Domestic Animals

During the first days following fertilization, cells of mammalian embryo gradually lose totipotency, acquiring distinct identity. The first three lineages specified in the mammalian embryo are pluripotent epiblast, which later gives rise to the embryo proper, and two extraembryonic lineages, hypoblast (also known as primitive endoderm) and trophectoderm, which form tissues supporting development of the fetus in utero. Most of our knowledge regarding the mechanisms of early lineage specification in mammals comes from studies in the mouse. However, the growing body of evidence points to both similarities and species-specific differences. Understanding molecular and cellular mechanisms of early embryonic development in nonrodent mammals expands our understanding of basic mechanisms of differentiation and is essential for the development of effective protocols for assisted reproduction in agriculture, veterinary medicine, and for biomedical research. This review summarizes the current state of knowledge on key events in epiblast, hypoblast, and trophoblast differentiation in domestic mammals.

Pre-gastrula Development of Non-eutherian Mammals

Marsupials and monotremes differ from eutherian mammals in many features of their reproduction and development. Some features appear to be representative of transitional stages in evolution from therapsid reptiles to humans and mice, particularly with respect to the extraembryonic tissues that have undergone remarkable modifications to accommodate reduced egg size and quantity of yolk/deutoplasm, and increasing emphasis on viviparity and placentation. Trophoblast and hypoblast contribute the epithelial layers in most of the extraembryonic membranes and are the first two lineages to differentiate from the embryonic lineage. How they are specified varies greatly among mammals, perhaps largely due to heterochrony in the stage at which they must function. Differences probably also exist in the stage at which lineages are specified relative to the stage at which they fully commit to differentiation. The dogma of sequential commitment to trophoblast and hypoblast with progressive loss of potency may not be a fundamental feature of early mammalian development, but merely a recently acquired developmental pattern in eutherians, or at least mice.

Visceral endoderm and the primitive streak interact to build the fetal-placental interface of the mouse gastrula

Hypoblast/visceral endoderm assists in amniote nutrition, axial positioning and formation of the gut. Here, we provide evidence, currently limited to humans and non-human primates, that hypoblast is a purveyor of extraembryonic mesoderm in the mouse gastrula. Fate mapping a unique segment of axial extraembryonic visceral endoderm associated with the allantoic component of the primitive streak, and referred to as the "AX", revealed that visceral endoderm supplies the placentae with extraembryonic mesoderm. Exfoliation of the AX was dependent upon contact with the primitive streak, which modulated Hedgehog signaling. Resolution of the AX's epithelial-to-mesenchymal transition (EMT) by Hedgehog shaped the allantois into its characteristic projectile and individualized placental arterial vessels. A unique border cell separated the delaminating AX from the yolk sac blood islands which, situated beyond the limit of the streak, were not formed by an EMT. Over time, the AX became the hindgut lip, which contributed extensively to the posterior interface, including both embryonic and extraembryonic tissues. The AX, in turn, imparted antero-posterior (A-P) polarity on the primitive streak and promoted its elongation and differentiation into definitive endoderm. Results of heterotopic grafting supported mutually interactive functions of the AX and primitive streak, showing that together, they self-organized into a complete version of the fetal-placental interface, forming an elongated structure that exhibited A-P polarity and was composed of the allantois, an AX-derived rod-like axial extension reminiscent of the embryonic notochord, the placental arterial vasculature and visceral endoderm/hindgut.