Comparison of the Japan Society of Clinical Chemistry reference method and CDC method for HDL and LDL cholesterol measurements using fresh sera

Objectives

In 2009, the Japan Society of Clinical Chemistry (JSCC) recommended a reference method for the measurement of serum high-density lipoprotein cholesterol (HDL-C) and low-density lipoprotein cholesterol (LDL-C) levels. This automated method uses cholesterol esterase-cholesterol dehydrogenase to measure cholesterol levels in fractions obtained after ultracentrifugation and dextran sulfate/magnesium chloride precipitation. In the present study, using fresh samples, we compared the LDL-C and HDL-C levels measured using this method with those measured using the traditional Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC)-beta-quantification (BQ) method.

Design

and methods: Using both the JSCC and CDC-BQ methods, LDL-C/HDL-C levels were measured in 47 non-diseased and 126 diseased subjects, whose triglyceride levels were lower than 11.29 ​mmol/L (1000 ​mg/dL).

Results

For LDL-C, the equation of the line representing the correlation between the two methods was y ​= ​0.991x + 0.009 ​mmol/L; r ​= ​0.999; and Sy/x ​= ​0.025 ​mmol/L, where x is the mean LDL-C level measured using the CDC-BQ method. Similarly, for HDL-C, the equation of the line representing the correlation between the two methods was y ​= ​0.988x + 0.041 ​mmol/L, r ​= ​0.999, and Sy/x ​= ​0.019 ​mmol/L, where x is the mean HDL-C level measured using the CDC-BQ method.

Conclusions

The JSCC method agreed with the CDC-BQ method in cases of both non-diseased and diseased subjects, including those with dyslipidemia.

•

Using both the JSCC and BQ methods, LDL-C/HDL-C levels were measured.

•

The JSCC method agrees with the BQ method.

•

The JSCC reference method is an accurate, simple, and automatable method.

•

The JSCC method is suitable for quantitative analysis of LDL-C and HDL-C levels.