Status of Competency-Based Medical Education in Endoscopy Training: A Nationwide Survey of US ACGME-Accredited Gastroenterology Training Programs

OBJECTIVES

The Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) emphasizes the importance of medical trainees meeting specific performance benchmarks and demonstrating readiness for unsupervised practice. The aim of this study was to examine the readiness of Gastroenterology (GI) fellowship programs for competency-based evaluation in endoscopic procedural training.

METHODS

ACGME-accredited GI program directors (PDs) and GI trainees nationwide completed an online survey of domains relevant to endoscopy training and competency assessment. Participants were queried about current methods and perceived quality of endoscopy training and assessment of competence. Participants were also queried about factors deemed important in endoscopy competence assessment. Five-point Likert items were analyzed as continuous variables by an independent t-test and χ(2)-test was used for comparison of proportions.

RESULTS

Survey response rate was 64% (94/148) for PDs and 47% (546/1,167) for trainees. Twenty-three percent of surveyed PDs reported that they do not have a formal endoscopy curriculum. PDs placed less importance (1—very important to 5—very unimportant) on endoscopy volume (1.57 vs. 1.18, P<0.001), adenoma detection rate (2.00 vs. 1.53, P<0.001), and withdrawal times (1.96 vs. 1.68, P=0.009) in determining endoscopy competence compared with trainees. A majority of PDs report that competence is assessed by procedure volume (85%) and teaching attending evaluations (96%). Only a minority of programs use skills assessment tools (30%) or specific quality metrics (28%). Specific competencies are mostly assessed by individual teaching attending feedback as opposed to official documentation or feedback from a PD. PDs rate the overall quality of their endoscopy training and assessment of competence as better than overall ratings by trainees.

CONCLUSIONS

Although the majority of PDs and trainees nationwide believe that measuring specific metrics is important in determining endoscopy competence, most programs still rely on procedure volume and subjective attending evaluations to determine overall competence. As medical training transitions from an apprenticeship model to competency-based education, there is a need for improved endoscopy curricula which are better suited to demonstrate readiness for unsupervised practice.

Botulinum toxin injection after biliary sphincterotomy

BACKGROUND AND STUDY AIMS

Endoscopic biliary sphincterotomy in patients with sphincter of Oddi dysfunction (SOD) is associated with a high risk of pancreatitis after endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography (ERCP), which may be secondary to residual pancreatic sphincter hypertension. It was hypothesized that botulinum toxin injection could be used to reduce pancreatic sphincter hypertension temporarily in SOD patients after biliary sphincterotomy, thereby reducing the rate of procedure-induced pancreatitis.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

All patients undergoing ERCP with manometry due to a suspected biliary SOD were asked to participate in the study. Patients with elevated basal sphincter pressures were randomly assigned to receive either botulinum toxin or a sham saline injection after biliary sphincterotomy. Fifty units of botulinum toxin were delivered via a sclerotherapy needle in the form of two 25-U injections of 0.25 ml each into the pancreatic sphincter. In patients in the sham arm, 0.50 ml of saline was injected into the duodenal lumen.

RESULTS

Between 12 February 1999 and 29 November 2000, a total of 98 patients were referred for ERCP with manometry; 86 consented to participate in the study, and 26 had elevated baseline pressures and underwent random assignment. Twelve received botulinum toxin injection and 14 were randomly assigned to receive the sham injection. A total of six patients in the sham group (43 %) developed procedure-induced pancreatitis, compared with three patients in the botulinum toxin group (25 %; P = 0.34).

CONCLUSIONS

Biliary sphincterotomy in patients with sphincter of Oddi dysfunction without pancreatic protection is risky and should no longer be carried out. This study demonstrates that botulinum toxin injection into the residual pancreatic sphincter after biliary sphincterotomy is technically feasible and safe, showing a trend toward a reduced post-ERCP pancreatitis rate in patients with sphincter of Oddi dysfunction. Further studies will need to confirm the validity of these experimental results before this technique can be used routinely.

First cut, then blend: an electrocautery technique affecting bleeding at sphincterotomy

BACKGROUND AND STUDY AIMS

The use of pure cut electrocautery current for endoscopic sphincterotomy lowers pancreatitis rates following endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography (ERCP), but at the expense of greater localized bleeding which partially obscures the endoscopic view. We hypothesized that localized bleeding could be decreased by using blended current at the end of the sphincterotomy, without losing the benefit associated with pure cut current of lower post-ERCP pancreatitis benefit.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Patients undergoing sphincterotomy were randomly allocated to receive pure cut current alone or a sequential combination of pure cut then blended current. In the sequential combination patients, the first 75 - 80 % of the sphincterotomy was done using pure cut current at 30 W and the remainder completed at a blend 2 setting (pure cut plus coagulation current), also at 30 W.

RESULTS

142 patients were enrolled in the study. No statistical difference was noted between the two groups in the rates of overall pancreatitis or bleeding requiring transfusion. When comparing visible bleeding rates (more than a few drops), we found that there was significantly more bleeding (P < 0.05) in the pure cut group (31/75, 41 %) at the time of sphincterotomy compared with the sequential combination group (16/67, 23 %).

CONCLUSIONS

A sequential combination of pure cut and blended current for sphincterotomy caused less visible bleeding than pure cut alone. This occurred without a change in the rate of post-ERCP pancreatitis.

Acute cytomegalovirus infection complicated by vascular thrombosis: a case report

We present a case report of a previously healthy adult with cytomegalovirus infection that was complicated by extensive mesenteric arterial and venous thrombosis. To our knowledge, this is the first reported case of this syndrome in an immunocompetent individual who had no predisposing risk factors for thrombosis, and it demonstrates the propensity for cytomegalovirus to be involved in vascular disease.

The accuracy of EUS and helical CT in the assessment of vascular invasion by peripapillary malignancy

BACKGROUND

The relative accuracy of helical CT and EUS for defining the local resectability of peripapillary malignancies is undefined.

METHODS

Fifty-one patients with a peripapillary malignancy and no metastatic disease were prospectively evaluated with helical CT and EUS. Imaging results were compared with surgical staging, and a tumor was defined as resectable when there was no macroscopic or microscopic residual tumor.

RESULTS

Nine patients had surgically confirmed locally unresectable disease, which was accurately predicted by EUS in 6 patients (sensitivity 67%) and by helical CT in 3 patients (sensitivity 33%; p = 0.35). When only patients with complete EUS examinations were included, the sensitivities of EUS and helical CT for vascular invasion were 100% and 33% (p = 0.06), respectively. When all patients not undergoing surgery because of imaging evidence of locally unresectable disease were included, the sensitivities were 100% and 62.5% (p = 0.02), respectively. One of 15 patients with a tumor amenable to surgical resection was labeled as unresectable by EUS but subsequently had a local recurrence of the tumor. The specificities of EUS (93%) and helical CT (100%) were similar.

CONCLUSION

EUS is more sensitive than helical CT for detecting vascular invasion by peripapillary malignancies and should be added to staging protocols, particularly when findings on helical CT are equivocal.

Extracorporeal lithotripsy. An important adjunct in the nonoperative management of retained or recurrent bile duct stones

Retained or recurrent bile duct stones can be successfully removed in up to 80% to 85% of patients with the use of percutaneous or endoscopic techniques. However, problems related to difficult biliary access, large stones, and biliary strictures may decrease the success rate of this approach. We evaluated the safety and efficacy of extracorporeal shock-wave lithotripsy (ESWL) in 16 patients with complicated biliary stones treated prospectively over a 24-month period. Successful stone fragmentation was achieved in 15 patients (94%) using a Dornier HM3 lithotripter (average of 2290 shocks at 22 kV). Three patients (19%) required a second ESWL treatment. Biliary clearance of stone fragments was spontaneous in seven (43%) of the patients and required additional treatment in eight (57%) of the patients. Complications from ESWL were minor and included transient hematuria and ecchymoses at the skin entry site. Extracorporeal shock-wave lithotripsy failed in one patient (6%) with a biliary stricture and surgery was required. At hospital discharge, all patients were asymptomatic and stone free. Treatment with ESWL appears to be a safe and effective adjunct for selected patients with complex biliary stone disease.

Colonic xanthomatosis. Relationship to disordered motility and review of the literature

We report two additional cases of colonic xanthomatosis associated with persistent rectal symptoms. Disordered colonic motility in the areas of lipid infiltration was documented in one patient. We conclude these lesions may have a pathophysiologic role in the alteration of intestinal motility which appears to be the cause of our patients' symptoms.

Endoscopic diagnosis of gastritis: causative factors in 100 patients

The frequency of gastritis in relation to its various predisposing conditions is unclear, as is the respective distribution of damage caused by its predisposing conditions. We studied 100 patients with the endoscopic diagnosis of gastritis. The incidence of gastritis in our university gastroenterology endoscopy service was 23%. A history of aspirin (ASA) or nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug (NSAID) use was present in 42%. No predisposing factors were found in 28% of cases. Stress gastritis was present in 10% of patients, all of whom were in the intensive care unit. Alcoholism, gastric resection, and portal hypertension were considered causative in 19%. Multiple predisposing factors were uncommon (3%). Coincident duodenal ulcer(s) and erosive duodenitis were common and were more frequent in the patients having idiopathic gastritis (46%) than in those who used ASA or NSAIDs (29%). The antrum was the portion of the stomach most frequently involved. This antral distribution of damage was predominant in both the ASA/NSAID-associated cases and in the idiopathic group. In contrast, patients with stress gastritis were more likely to have involvement of the gastric fundus and body.

Esophageal reflux and dysmotility as the basis for persistent cervical symptoms

To examine a possible esophageal basis for cervical symptoms, we studied 63 patients with persistent cervical complaints, 36 patients with gastroesophageal reflux but no cervical symptoms, and ten normal subjects. Patients were evaluated for a history of pyrosis and regurgitation and underwent otolaryngologic examination, barium esophagram, upper endoscopy, esophageal biopsy, standard esophageal manometrics, acid reflux testing, and Bernstein examination, as well as tests of esophageal dysmotility and acid clearance time before and after bethanechol (50 micrograms/kg, two doses). Standard diagnostic examinations usually were normal in patients with cervical symptoms. Pyrosis, regurgitation, and a positive Bernstein examination were uncommon in patients with cervical symptoms. This occurred despite frequent acid reflux (68%) and poor acid clearance (79%). Esophageal dysmotility also was common (63%). Patients with reflux but no cervical symptoms and normal subjects had a normal acid clearance time, and dysmotility was unusual (8%). We conclude that patients with cervical symptoms have diminished esophageal sensitivity despite frequent and long acid exposure. The pathophysiologic significance of this observation is discussed.

Biliary obstruction secondary to an extramedullary plasmacytoma of the pancreas: confusion with pancreatitis on computed tomography

A 29-year-old woman with a history of a maxillary plasmacytoma treated with radiation therapy presented with painless jaundice. A computed tomography (CT) scan revealed biliary dilatation and diffuse pancreatic enlargement suggestive of pancreatitis. Percutaneous transhepatic cholangiography demonstrated encasement of the distal common bile duct by an extrinsic mass. At exploratory laparotomy, a large mass replacing the entire pancreas was found. Pathologic examination confirmed plasmacytoma. This report presents a unique case of extramedullary plasmacytoma involving the pancreas early in a patient's clinical course. The CT appearance was similar to that of acute pancreatitis.

A submucosal antral mass caused by cytomegalovirus infection in a patient with acquired immunodeficiency syndrome

A 29-yr-old homosexual man with acquired immunodeficiency syndrome presented with watery diarrhea and fever. Upper gastrointestinal endoscopy was performed to obtain duodenal aspirates and biopsies. A 4-cm submucosal mass in the gastric antrum was identified. Subsequent abdominal CT scan confirmed the presence of this antral mass. An attempt at CT guided needle biopsy was nondiagnostic. Because the mass possibly represented a Kaposi's sarcoma or lymphoma, exploratory laparotomy and open biopsy was performed. Examination of the biopsy specimen showed inflammatory debris with multiple intranuclear cytomegalovirus inclusions. This report describes a case of a submucosal antral mass caused by localized cytomegalovirus infection in a patient with acquired immunodeficiency syndrome.

Ca2+ channel blockers stimulate ileal and colonic water absorption

The effects of calcium channel blockers on water transport in the rat ileum and distal colon were studied in vivo using the single-pass perfusion technique. Parenteral but not intraluminal verapamil, and parenteral nifedipine increased ileal water absorption, with effects lasting at least 60 min. In contrast, i.p. verapamil had no effect on rat distal colonic water absorption, whereas intraluminal verapamil significantly stimulated colonic water absorption. Similarly, perfusing the rat descending colon with low-Ca2+ Ringer's-HCO3 stimulated colonic water absorption. Verapamil was not antisecretory because the theophylline-induced decrease in ileal water transport was similar in control animals and in animals pretreated with i.p. verapamil. In addition, nifedipine stimulated active Na and Cl absorption in rabbit ileum. These studies demonstrate that the Ca2+ channel blockers verapamil and nifedipine stimulate basal absorption of water in rat ileum and distal colon in vivo, and stimulate active Na and Cl absorption in rabbit ileum in vitro. The verapamil stimulation of colonic water absorption from the luminal surface was duplicated by perfusion with a low-Ca2+ bathing solution. This suggests the presence of apical membrane Ca2+ channels in rat colon, which appear to be involved in regulation of basal water transport, and that these Ca2+ channels are in a partially open state under basal conditions. Because verapamil stimulates absorption systemically (ileum) as well as intraluminally (colon), Ca2+ channel blockers have properties that might be useful in treatment of diarrheal diseases.

Effect of dopamine and bromocriptine on rat ileal and colonic transport. Stimulation of absorption and reversal of cholera toxin-induced secretion

Water and electrolyte transport were determined in rat ileum and colon using the single-pass perfusion technique. Intraperitoneal dopamine caused prompt stimulation of both ileal and colonic water absorption. The dopamine effect was mediated by both specific dopamine and alpha 2-adrenergic receptors. Haloperidol, a specific dopamine antagonist, and yohimbine, an alpha 2-adrenergic antagonist, inhibited the effect of dopamine in ileal absorption; both antagonists alone had no effect on basal water transport. Bromocriptine (intravenous and intraluminal) stimulated ileal and colonic water absorption, which was inhibited by haloperidol and yohimbine, and reversed cholera toxin-induced ileal secretion. Magnitude and time-courses of the increased water absorption in ileal loops, inoculated with saline, were the same as in loops, inoculated with saline, suggesting that bromocriptine acted to reverse cholera toxin-induced secretion by stimulating absorption. Bromocriptine had no effect on the cyclic adenosine monophosphate increase caused by cholera toxin. We conclude (a) dopamine stimulates water absorption in vivo in rat ileum and colon; (b) this dopamine effect is via specific dopamine and alpha 2-receptors; (c) bromocriptine stimulates water absorption in ileum and colon and also acts by dopamine and alpha 2-receptors; and (d) bromocriptine reverses cholera toxin-induced secretion.

Trifluoperazine reversal of secretory diarrhea in pancreatic cholera

Diarrhea in a patient with pancreatic cholera syndrome caused by a vasoactive intestinal polypeptide producing pancreatic islet-cell carcinoma responded rapidly and dramatically to the phenothiazine trifluoperazine. Treatment with intravenous somatostatin decreased the plasma vasoactive intestinal polypeptide level without changing the diarrhea. The chemotherapeutic agent chlorozotocin, the 2-chloroethyl analogue of streptozocin, caused a decrease in plasma vasoactive intestinal polypeptide but caused significant renal toxicity with proteinuria.