Exploiting Virus Infection to Protect Plants from Abiotic Stresses: Tomato Protection by a Begomovirus

Tomato cultivation is threatened by environmental stresses (e.g., heat, drought) and by viral infection (mainly viruses belonging to the tomato yellow leaf curl virus family-TYLCVs). Unlike many RNA viruses, TYLCV infection does not induce a hypersensitive response and cell death in tomato plants. To ensure a successful infection, TYLCV preserves a suitable cellular environment where it can reproduce. Infected plants experience a mild stress, undergo adaptation and become partially "ready" to exposure to other environmental stresses. Plant wilting and cessation of growth caused by heat and drought is suppressed by TYLCV infection, mainly by down-regulating the heat shock transcription factors, HSFA1, HSFA2, HSFB1 and consequently, the expression of HSF-regulated stress genes. In particular, TYLCV captures HSFA2 by inducing protein complexes and aggregates, thus attenuating an acute stress response, which otherwise causes plant death. Viral infection mitigates the increase in stress-induced metabolites, such as carbohydrates and amino acids, and leads to their reallocation from shoots to roots. Under high temperatures and water deficit, TYLCV induces plant cellular homeostasis, promoting host survival. Thus, this virus-plant interaction is beneficial for both partners.

Interplay between abiotic (drought) and biotic (virus) stresses in tomato plants

With climate warming, drought becomes a vital challenge for agriculture. Extended drought periods affect plant-pathogen interactions. We demonstrate an interplay in tomato between drought and infection with tomato yellow leaf curl virus (TYLCV). Infected plants became more tolerant to drought, showing plant readiness to water scarcity by reducing metabolic activity in leaves and increasing it in roots. Reallocation of osmolytes, such as carbohydrates and amino acids, from shoots to roots suggested a role of roots in protecting infected tomatoes against drought. To avoid an acute response possibly lethal for the host organism, TYLCV down-regulated the drought-induced activation of stress response proteins and metabolites. Simultaneously, TYLCV promoted the stabilization of osmoprotectants' patterns and water balance parameters, resulting in the development of buffering conditions in infected plants subjected to prolonged stress. Drought-dependent decline of TYLCV amounts was correlated with HSFA1-controlled activation of autophagy, mostly in the roots. The tomato response to combined drought and TYLCV infection points to a mutual interaction between the plant host and its viral pathogen.

Tomato Yellow Leaf Curl Virus (TYLCV) Promotes Plant Tolerance to Drought

A growing body of research points to a positive interplay between viruses and plants. Tomato yellow curl virus (TYLCV) is able to protect tomato host plants against extreme drought. To envisage the use of virus protective capacity in agriculture, TYLCV-resistant tomato lines have to be infected first with the virus before planting. Such virus-resistant tomato plants contain virus amounts that do not cause disease symptoms, growth inhibition, or yield loss, but are sufficient to modify the metabolism of the plant, resulting in improved tolerance to drought. This phenomenon is based on the TYLCV-dependent stabilization of amounts of key osmoprotectants induced by drought (soluble sugars, amino acids, and proteins). Although in infected TYLCV-susceptible tomatoes, stress markers also show an enhanced stability, in infected TYLCV-resistant plants, water balance and osmolyte homeostasis reach particularly high levels. These tomato plants survive long periods of time during water withholding. However, after recovery to normal irrigation, they produce fruits which are not exposed to drought, similarly to the control plants. Using these features, it might be possible to cultivate TYLCV-resistant plants during seasons characterized by water scarcity.

The six Tomato yellow leaf curl virus genes expressed individually in tomato induce different levels of plant stress response attenuation

Tomato yellow leaf curl virus (TYLCV) is a begomovirus infecting tomato plants worldwide. TYLCV needs a healthy host environment to ensure a successful infection cycle for long periods. Hence, TYLCV restrains its destructive effect and induces neither a hypersensitive response nor cell death in infected tomatoes. On the contrary, TYLCV counteracts cell death induced by other factors, such as inactivation of HSP90 functionality. Suppression of plant death is associated with the inhibition of the ubiquitin 26S proteasome degradation and with a deactivation of the heat shock transcription factor HSFA2 pathways (including decreased HSP17 levels). The goal of the current study was to find if the individual TYLCV genes were capable of suppressing HSP90-dependent death and HSFA2 deactivation. The expression of C2 (C3 and CP to a lesser extent) caused a decrease in the severity of death phenotypes, while the expression of V2 (C1 and C4 to a lesser extent) strengthened cell death. However, C2 or V2 markedly affected stress response under conditions of viral infection. The downregulation of HSFA2 signaling, initiated by the expression of C1 and V2, was detected in the absence of virus infection, but was enhanced in infected plants, while CP and C4 mitigated HSFA2 levels only in the infected tomatoes. The dependence of analyzed plant stress response suppression on the interaction of the expressed genes with the environment created by the whole virus infection was more pronounced than on the expression of individual TYLCV genes.

Immunity to tomato yellow leaf curl virus in transgenic tomato is associated with accumulation of transgene small RNA

Gene silencing is a natural defense response of plants against invading RNA and DNA viruses. The RNA post-transcriptional silencing system has been commonly utilized to generate transgenic crop plants that are "immune" to plant virus infection. Here, we applied this approach against the devastating DNA virus tomato yellow leaf curl virus (TYLCV) in its host tomato (Solanum lycopersicum L.). To generate broad resistance to a number of different TYLCV viruses, three conserved sequences (the intergenic region [NCR], V1-V2 and C1-C2 genes) from the genome of the severe virus (TYLCV) were synthesized as a single insert and cloned into a hairpin configuration in a binary vector, which was used to transform TYLCV-susceptible tomato plants. Eight of 28 independent transgenic tomato lines exhibited immunity to TYLCV-Is and to TYLCV-Mld, but not to tomato yellow leaf curl Sardinia virus, which shares relatively low sequence homology with the transgene. In addition, a marker-free (nptII-deleted) transgenic tomato line was generated for the first time by Agrobacterium-mediated transformation without antibiotic selection, followed by screening of 1180 regenerated shoots by whitefly-mediated TYLCV inoculation. Resistant lines showed a high level of transgene-siRNA (t-siRNA) accumulation (22% of total small RNA) with dominant sizes of 21 nt (73%) and 22 nt (22%). The t-siRNA displayed hot-spot distribution ("peaks") along the transgene, with different distribution patterns than the viral-siRNA peaks observed in TYLCV-infected tomato. A grafting experiment demonstrated the mobility of 0.04% of the t-siRNA from transgenic rootstock to non-transformed scion, even though scion resistance against TYLCV was not achieved.

Frequent migration of introduced cucurbit-infecting begomoviruses among Middle Eastern countries

BACKGROUND

In the early 2000s, two cucurbit-infecting begomoviruses were introduced into the eastern Mediterranean basin: the Old World Squash leaf curl virus (SLCV) and the New World Watermelon chlorotic stunt virus (WmCSV). These viruses have been emerging in parallel over the last decade in Egypt, Israel, Jordan, Lebanon and Palestine.

METHODS

We explored this unique situation by assessing the diversity and biogeography of the DNA-A component of SLCV and WmCSV in these five countries.

RESULTS

There was fairly low sequence variation in both begomovirus species (SLCV π = 0.0077; WmCSV π = 0.0066). Both viruses may have been introduced only once into the eastern Mediterranean basin, but once established, these viruses readily moved across country boundaries. SLCV has been introduced at least twice into each of all five countries based on the absence of monophyletic clades. Similarly, WmCSV has been introduced multiple times into Jordan, Israel and Palestine.

CONCLUSIONS

We predict that uncontrolled movement of whiteflies among countries in this region will continue to cause SLCV and WmCSV migration, preventing strong genetic differentiation of these viruses among these countries.

First Report of Recombinant Potato virus Y Strains Infecting Potato in Jordan

Potato (Solanum tuberosum L.) is an important vegetable crop in Jordan, occupying second position after olives. In 2012, potatoes were planted on about 6,000 ha with a production of about 141,000 t (2). Potato virus Y (PVY) is a serious problem for potato production worldwide. Recombinant strains of the virus were reported to cause tuber necrotic ringspot disease (PTNRD) in many potato-growing regions of the world. In the last few years, a new recombinant PVY^NTN-NW that belongs to PVY^Z (3) has been reported in the neighboring Syria. It included three recombination patterns, SYR-I, SYR-II, and SYR-III, and caused severe PTNRD (1). Since PVY is easily transmitted from one region to another by aphid vectors and infected potato seeds, this study was initiated to investigate the possible occurrence of PVY strains in Jordan. In October 2013, 33 leaf samples were collected from symptomatic potato plants cv. Spunta from Wadi Rum, Jordan (GPS coordinates 29°31'37.76″ N, 35°42'48.75″ E), the largest potato-producing area in Jordan. Sampled plants displayed leaf mottling and yellowing, symptoms similar to those caused by PVY. All samples were tested for PVY by DAS-ELISA using the ELISA kit (monoclonal cocktail) developed by BIOREBA (Reinach, Switzerland) to detect all PVY isolates. Twenty-nine samples were found positive for PVY by ELISA. To confirm virus infection, total RNA was extracted from all ELISA-positive samples and used as template in uniplex RT-PCR using strain-specific primers (1). The band pattern of PCR amplicons showed that 12 samples were infected with PVY^NTN-NW genotype SYR-III and produced bands of 1,085, 441, and 278 bp. One sample was infected with PVY^NTN (A) and produced bands of 1,307, 633, and 441 bp, and one other sample was infected with PVY^NTN-NW genotype SYR-II and produced bands of 1,085 and 441 bp. Mixed infection with PVY^NTN-NW genotype SYR-III and PVY^NTN (B) was also detected in one sample producing bands of 278, 441, 1,085, and 1,307 bp. To confirm infection with the recombinant strains, PCR fragments of 278 bp amplified from three samples and 1,085 bp obtained from another three samples were directly sequenced and sequences were deposited in GenBank under accession numbers KJ159968, KJ159969, and KJ159970 for the 278-bp fragment and KJ159974, KJ159975, and KJ159976 for the 1,085-bp fragment. Sequence comparison with other PVY strains available in the NCBI database showed that the 278-bp fragment had the highest nucleotide sequence identity (100%) with PVY isolates SYR-III-A26 (AB461467) and SYR-III-2-4 (AB461457) from Syria. BLAST searches also showed that the 1,085-bp fragment shared 99% nucleotide identities with PVY isolates SYR-II-L3 (AB461482) and SYR-II-Be4 (AB461474) from Aleppo, Syria. To our knowledge, this is the first report of PVY recombinants in Jordan, and the first report of PVY^NTN-NW recombinants infecting potato crop outside Syria. Since Europe is the main supplier of potato seeds for farmers in Jordan and Syria, the introduction of PVY^NTN-NW to the region could have happened through infected potato seeds. Results of this study create new challenges for potato growers in Jordan as well as other countries in the region. References: (1) M. Chikh Ali et al. J. Virol. Methods 165:15, 2010. (2) FAO. http://faostat.fao.org/ (3) A. V. Karasev and S. M. Gray. Ann. Rev. Phytopathol. 51:571, 2013.

Detection of Satellite DNA Beta in Tomato Plants with Tomato Yellow Leaf Curl Disease in Jordan

In Jordan, as well as many countries in the region, tomato production is threatened by begomoviruses belonging to the tomato yellow leaf curl virus complex (1). In 2013, an experiment was conducted at Homret Al-Sahen, Jordan (GPS coordinates 32°05'06″ N, 35°38'52″ E), to evaluate different tomato breeding lines for resistance against viruses causing tomato yellow leaf curl disease (TYLCD). Disease symptoms, typical of those caused by TYLCV complex, were observed in many susceptible lines. However, some lines exhibited unusual symptoms including severe leaf curling and stunting. To identify the causal agent of these symptoms, total nucleic acids were extracted from 21 symptomatic plants and used as templates in PCR analysis using nine primers, previously described to detect Tomato yellow leaf curl virus, Tomato yellow leaf curl Sardinia virus, and two recombinants between TYLCV and TYLCSV (3). In addition, the universal primer pair β01/β02 (2) was used to investigate the association of satDNA β with the disease. The PCR products characteristic of TYLCV (664 bp) could be amplified from five plants indicating single infection, while double infection with TYLCV and satDNA β (1,320 bp) was detected in seven plants. Mixed infection with TYLCV, TYLCSV (628 bp), and satDNA β was detected in another seven symptomatic plants and only one plant was infected with TYLCV and TYLCSV. A single plant had mixed infection with TYLCV, TYLCSV, and RecA (a recombinant between TYLCV/TYLCSV) (538 bp) (3). Amplicons obtained from two plants using β01/β02 primers were directly sequenced as 1,320-bp PCR products. Both sequences were found identical and, therefore, this sequence was deposited in the GenBank under the accession number KJ396939. Phylogenetic analysis revealed that this satDNA β sequence had the highest nucleotide (95%) identity with Okra leaf curl virus (OkLCV) satDNA 3 (AF397217) and OkLCV satDNA 10 (AF397215). The contribution of the satDNA β in the modulation of the TYLCD symptoms will be further investigated. Few years ago, another satDNA (Tomβ01-Om) was reported in Oman to be associated with TYLCD (4). However, to the best of our knowledge, this is the first report on the detection of satDNA β in tomato plants infected with viruses causing TYLCD in Jordan. The increasing diversity of begomoviruses causing TYLCD in the region is of great concern due to the possible emergence of more virulent viruses and subsequent increased losses to tomato production. References: (1) G. Anfoka et al. J. Plant Pathol. 90:311, 2008. (2) R. W. Briddon and J. Stanley. Virology 344:198, 2006. (3) S. Davino et al. Virus Res. 143:15, 2009. (4) A. J. Khan et al. Virus Gene 36:169, 2008.

First Report on the Association of Squash leaf curl virus and Watermelon chlorotic stunt virus with Tomato Yellow Leaf Curl Disease

Tomato (Solanum lycopersicum Mill.) is one of the most economically important vegetable crops in Jordan. Tomato cultivation in many countries in the Mediterranean basin is affected by several virus species belonging to Tomato yellow leaf curl virus complex (3). In March 2011, a field experiment was conducted at Horet Al-Sahen region to screen tomato breeding lines for resistance against TYLCD. Unexpectedly, severe TYLCD symptoms, including leaf curling, yellowing, and severe stunting were observed on some plants belonging to the F5 generation of a breeding line that was supposed to be resistant to the virus. One symptomatic plant was transferred into the greenhouse and used for whitefly transmission. The virus isolate was maintained on a susceptible tomato landrace by serial transmission using biotype B of the whitely vector (Bemisia tabaci). To confirm begomovirus infections, total nucleic acids were extracted from leaf tissues as previously described (4) and viral DNA genomes were amplified by rolling circle amplification (RCA) using the TempliPhi Amplification Kit (GE Healthcare). RCA products were then subjected to restriction digestion with different enzymes. Two DNA fragments of 1,035 bp and 1,760 bp were the products of EcoRl-digestion. Following sequencing, BLASTn analysis showed that the small fragment (1,035 bp) (GenBank Accession No. JX444576) corresponding to nts 2,408 to 2,690 of Watermelon chlorotic stunt virus from Jordan (WmCSV-[JO]) (EU561237) had approximately 99% nt identity with WmCSV-[JO] and other isolates from Israel (EF201809) and Iran (AJ245652), while the second fragment (1,760 bp) which corresponds to nts 117 to 1,877 of TYLCV genome had 98% nt identities with the Mexican isolate of TYLCV (FJ609655). Two pairs of primers (TYLCV29F1: TATGGCAATCGGTGTATC/TYLCV29R1: GTGTCCAGGTATAAGTAAG) and (TYLCV29F2: GAGAGCCCAATTTTTCAAG/TYLCV29R2: GGGAATATCTAGACGAAGAA) were used to amplify full TYLCV genome. Sequence analysis showed that TYLCV (JX444575) had the highest (98%) nt identity with the Mexican isolate of TYLCV (FJ609655). Because Squash leaf curl virus and WmCSV were recently reported in Jordan (1,2), we further investigated whether SLCV was also involved in the disease; therefore, two pairs of SLCV-specific primers (SLCVF-Sal (TATAGTCGACGTTGAACCGGATTTGAATG)/SLCVR-Sal (TATAGTCGACCTGAGGAGAGCACTAAATC) (DNA-A) and SLCVF-Hindlll (ATTAAAGCTTAGTGGTTATGCAAGGCG)/SLCVR-Hindlll (ATTAAAGCTTGGCTGCACCATATGAACG) (DNA-B) were used in PCR using RCA products as template. The expected sizes of DNA-A (2,639 bp) (JX444577) and DNA-B (2,607 bp) (JX444574) could successfully be amplified from the original symptomatic plant. Phylogenetic analysis showed that DNA-A was closely related to SLCV isolates from Lebanon (HM368373) and Egypt (DQ285019) with 99% nt identity, while DNA-B had highest nt identity (99%) with the Israeli isolate of SLCV (HQ184437). To our knowledge, this is the first report on the association of SLCV and WmCSV with TYLCD. Further studies will be carried out to investigate whether tomato can act as an inoculum source for these two viruses. References: (1) A. Al-Musa et al. J. Phytopath. 156:311, 2008 (2) A. Al-Musa et al. Virus Genes 43:79, 2011. (3) G. Anfoka et al. J. Plant Pathol. 90:311, 2008. (4) J. L. Potter et al. Plant Dis, 87:1205, 2003.

Watermelon chlorotic stunt virus (WmCSV): a serious disease threatening watermelon production in Jordan

The incidence of watermelon chlorotic stunt disease and the molecular characterization of the Jordanian isolate of Watermelon chlorotic stunt virus (WmCSV-[JO]) are described in this study. Symptomatic leaf samples obtained from watermelon (Citrullus lanatus Thunb.), melon (Cucumis melo L.), squash (Cucurbita pepo), cucumber (Cucumis sativus L.), and bottle gourd (Lagenaria siceraria) plants were tested for WmCSV-[JO] infection by PCR. The virus could be detected in 8 melon and 87 watermelon samples obtained from Ghor Assafi (southern part of Jordan Valley). Three samples collected from Mafraq (eastern part of Jordan) were found mixed infected with WmCSV-[JO] and Squash leaf curl virus. The full-length DNA-A and DNA-B genomes of WmCSV-[JO] were amplified, and sequences were deposited in the GenBank under accession numbers EU561237 and EU561236, respectively. Sequence analysis reveals that WmCSV-[JO] is closely related to other virus isolates from Israel (WmCSV-[IL]), Yemen (WmCSV-[YE]), Iran (WmCSV-[IR]), Lebanon (WmCSV-[LB]), and Sudan (WmCSV-[SD]). DNA-A of WmCSV-[JO] showed highest nucleotide identity (99.42%) with WmCSV-[IL], while DNA-B had highest nucleotide identity (95.52%) with WmCSV-[YE]. Data of this study demonstrate that digestion of DNA-B genome of WmCSV isolates with ApaI enzyme can discriminate between these isolates at the molecular level. Infectious clones of WmCSV-[JO] were constructed and agroinoculated to Nicotiana benthamiana plants. Inoculated plants developed mild disease symptoms 4 weeks post inoculation, while watermelon plants biolistically inoculated with WmCSV-[JO] developed characteristic mottling, yellowing and severe leaf curling symptoms 3 weeks post inoculation.