A systematic study of the release of bisphenol A by orthodontic materials and its biological effects

INTRODUCTION

Bisphenol A (BPA) is a synthetic chemical substance used as a starting ingredient in the manufacturing process of a number or orthodontic materials. It is a well-known endocrine disruptor with low estrogenic properties. The aim of this investigation is to present a systematic review regarding the issue of bisphenol A release by orthodontic materials and its impact in orthodontics.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A systematic analysis was performed by electronic search (between 1936 and 2015) on several data bases. The search was limited by using several specific key-words in two languages, English and French. Two investigators selected the responses, which met the selection criteria.

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

Of the 376 studies found, only 21 met our selection criteria: 11 of these dealt with the release of bisphenol by orthodontic materials and 10 in vitro studies described the effects of BPA leaching from orthodontic materials on human and murine cells. The rate of BPA release was well below the daily tolerable intake (DTI) (50mg/kg/day in 2006, then 50μg/kg/day in 2015) according to the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA). Theoretical exposure to BPA was 11,000 times lower than recommendations. However, other studies have shown the presence of BPA and of monomers released in large quantities at very low doses. The effects of observed BPA varied significantly (toxic and carcinogenic potential) while some studies found no effects at all. The relatively small number of studies dealing with the release of Bisphenol A by orthodontic materials, apart from orthodontic materials and their significant biological effects, has led to the absence of standard protocols and has hindered precise determination of released BPA. Moreover, the lack of coherence between the various methodological approaches and variations in the experimental protocols have resulted in a low level of proof regarding the impact of BPA by orthodontic materials.

RECOMMENDATIONS

Through this study, the authors encourage clinicians to observe the following recommendations designed to reduce the amount of BPA released by materials used in orthodontics: keep the tip of the light-curing lamp as close as possible to the composite and perform indirect rather than direct light-curing; Pumice-polish the composite after bonding so as to reduce the potential amount of BPA released; reduce exposure by brushing or rinsing with a mouthwash during the first hour after bonding; follow a standardized, reproducible and expert-validated research protocol aimed at better understanding of BPA release.

Impaired beta-adrenergic signaling pathway in white adipocytes of suckling fa/fa Zucker rats: a defect in receptor coupling

BACKGROUND

In fa/fa Zucker rats, leptin receptor deficiency is responsible for both a deficit of energy expenditure and hyperphagia which lead to massive obesity and insulin resistance in adulthood. This obesity is also characterised by alterations of the beta-adrenergic signaling pathway.

OBJECTIVE

To determine whether alterations in beta-adrenergic pathway could occur at the onset of obesity when fa/fa rats are not yet hyperinsulinemic.

ANIMALS

Fourteen-day-old suckling fa/fa and Fa/fa littermates (from heterozygous lean (Fa/fa) female and homozygous obese (fa/fa) male mating).

MEASUREMENTS

Membranes were prepared from isolated adipocytes after collagenase treatment of inguinal adipose tissue. The response of adenylyl-cyclase activity to stimulation by isoprenaline, GTPgamma-S or forskolin was studied. Bmax and Kd of (beta1+beta2) and of beta3 adrenoceptors were measured using 3H-CGP saturation binding experiments. mRNA concentration of beta1- and beta3-AR was determined by semi-quantitative RT-PCR. G(s)alpha protein was quantified by Western blotting and Gi protein by ADP-ribosylation.

RESULTS

Despite an almost normal body weight, inguinal fat pad weight was increased two-fold by the expression of fa mutation. This increase was entirely accounted for by fat cell hypertrophy (x2.5 in volume). In fa/fa compared to Fa/fa pups, response of adenylyl cyclase to isoprenaline was decreased two-fold but responses to GTPgammaS or forskolin were unchanged. Density of (beta1+beta2) and beta3-AR was not affected by the fa/fa genotype, as well as G(s)alpha and Gi concentration.

CONCLUSION

Response of inguinal fat cells to catecholamines was decreased without any quantitative modifications of the different elements of the adenylyl cyclase cascade. This suggests an alteration in the coupling between beta-AR and G proteins. Due to the important increase in fat cell volume we hypothesize that changes in the physical properties of plasma membranes and/or changes in cytoskeleton-extracellular-matrix interactions could disturb the beta-adrenergic pathway responsiveness. In addition to the excess of lipid storage, which occurs very early at the onset of obesity, the impairment of the responsiveness to catecholamines reported in this study might worsen the obesity syndrome.

[Hemodynamic consequences of endogenous hyperinsulinism in obese rats with lesions of the ventromedial hypothalamus]

The rat with ventromedian hypothalamus lesions (VMH) is characterized by massive obesity, hyperinsulinemia, increase in parasympathetic tonus and sympathetic depression. The aim of this study was to examine in this model the hemodynamic changes and the baroreflex response and to compare the data with the evaluation of beta adrenergic sensitivity. In VMH rats and Sham operated rats hemodynamic parameters were followed until 8 weeks after operation. Heart rate (HR) and blood pressure (BP) were monitored each week during 24 hours by a telemetric system, a catheter being implanted in aorta. In VMH, HR was significantly lower by the first week (p = 0.02) and until the last measurement. Systolic BP increased progressively in the two groups but was higher in VMH only at 8 weeks (p = 0.03). Compared with Sham rats, 5 days after operation, the percentage of HR acceleration in response to atropine and isoprenaline was significantly higher in VMH, whereas HR response to sodium nitroprussiate was similar in the two groups. Plasma epinephrine and norepinephrine levels were significantly higher in VMH rats. The density of cardiac beta receptors decreased from 15 days to 3 months after operation, similarly in VMH and Sham rats. The affinity of cardiac beta receptors remained stable during the same period and very similar in VMH and Sham rats. This study suggests that in VMH rats 1. bradycardia results mainly from an increase in parasympathetic tone; 2. the increase in reflex tachycardia described in normal rats after insulin infusion needs a normal activity of the sympathetic nervous system; 3. catecholamine levels may be increased despite sympathetic depression, probably as a result of an increase in adrenomedullary secretion possibly due to endogenous hyperinsulinemia; 4. the lack of hypertension in this model including a massive obesity is likely to result from the proper vasodilatory effect of insulin.

Interaction of amiodarone and triiodothyronine on the expression of beta-adrenoceptors in brown adipose tissue of rat

1. This study was undertaken to evaluate in vivo the influence of amiodarone on the effects of triiodothyronine (T3) in brown adipose tissue (BAT) which are independent of thyroid hormone synthesis and of the conversion of thyroxine (T4) to T3. Thyroidectomized rats were given a replacement dose of T3 (0.5 mg kg(-1) p.o. daily for 3 days) with or without amiodarone (50 mg kg(-1) p.o. daily for 1 week). 2. As assessed by RT-PCR, treatment of thyroidectomized rats with T3 caused a 2 fold decrease in beta3-adrenoceptor (beta3-AR) mRNA levels and a 2 fold increase in beta1-AR mRNA levels. 3. Binding studies using [3H]-CGP 12177 as a ligand showed that treatment of thyoidectomized rats with T3 resulted in a 70% decrease in beta3-AR number and in an 80% increase in beta1-AR in BAT membranes. 4. T3-treatment abolished the increase in BAT adenylyl cyclase (AC) activity induced by CGP12177 in thyroidectomized rats. It also decreased the amount of Gi protein (ADP-ribosylation) by 30%. 5. At variance with the literature on the heart, amiodarone administration did not inhibit the positive effect of T3 on beta1-AR expression in BAT in thyroidectomized rats. However, it antagonized the effect of T3 on beta3-AR number, but not on AC activity or on Gi expression. 6. These results indicate that the effects of thyroid hormones on the responsiveness of BAT to catecholamines involves both receptor and post-receptor mechanisms, they also suggest that interaction between amiodarone and thyroid hormones is highly tissue-specific and depends on the beta-AR subtype.

Effects of triiodothyronine administration on the adenylyl cyclase system in brown adipose tissue of rat

This study was undertaken to investigate the effect of triiodothyronine (T3) administration to euthyroid rats on beta 3-adrenoceptor (beta 3-AR) expression and on the different components of the adenylyl cyclase (AC) system in brown adipose tissue (BAT). In rats treated with T3, the beta 3-AR density (assessed by the binding of [3H]CGP-12177) showed a decrease of 50%, as did their mRNA, as analyzed by reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction. In hyperthyroid rats, compared with control rats, there was a 40% increase in G alpha s activity (stimulated by NaF or GTP gamma S) and a fourfold increase in the protein concentration (Western blotting). In contrast, the level of the pertussis toxin substrate Gi declined by 35% in response to T3. Analysis of dose-response curves for isoproterenol and CGP-12177 revealed that neither basal nor stimulated AC activities nor 50% stimulatory concentration for these agonists was changed by T3 administration. In conclusion, these results suggest that downregulation of the beta 3-AR by T3 was counter-balanced by changes in other components of the AC cascade (i.e., Gs and Gi), so no change occurred in the capacity of BAT to generate adenosine 3',5'-cyclic monophosphate.

Triiodothyronine and amiodarone effects on beta 3-adrenoceptor density and lipolytic response to the beta 3-adrenergic agonist BRL 37344 in rat white adipocytes

The beta-adrenergic effects of catecholamines are potentiated by thyroid hormones in adipose tissue. Amiodarone (AM) is structurally similar to thyroid hormones and was used to explore the mechanism of the triiodothyronine (T3) effect on beta-adrenergic receptors (beta-ARs) in adipose tissue. AM decreases the expression of some T3 sensitive genes in various tissues and antagonizes the effect of T3 on its nuclear receptors. In this study, the T3, AM and AM + T3 effects on the beta 1- and beta 3-AR density were assessed on rat white adipocytes by radioligand binding using [3H]CGP 12177 after characterization of these subtypes by displacement of [3H]CGP 12177 binding by isoproterenol, BRL 37344 and noradrenaline. BRL 37344 was used to study beta 3-AR lipolysis. White adipocytes from hyperthyroid rats had increased responsiveness (Emax x 2) and sensitivity (+ 38%) to BRL 37344, while those given AM alone had decreased values. Moreover, AM antagonized the T3 effect on lipolysis. The beta 1-binding characteristics (receptor density [Bmax]: 45 +/- 4 fmol/mg of proteins; dissociation factor [Kd]: 0.96 +/- 0.10 nM) were not modified by either compound. Finally, T3 significantly increased beta 3-AR density (587 +/- 69 versus 363 +/- 25 fmol/mg of proteins) and Kd (38 +/- 2 versus 23 +/- 3 nM), while AM alone had no effect and did not antagonize the T3 effect on beta 3-AR number. In conclusion, the hyperthyroid state in the rat potentiated the lipolytic response of white adipocytes to a specific beta 3-agonist and increased the beta 3-AR density without changing in beta 1-AR number and affinity. Furthermore, the lack of antagonism between AM and T3 on beta 3-AR expression suggests that T3 does not work directly on the beta 3-AR gene. Moreover, AM induced a functional tissular hypothyroid-like effect and its antilipolytic effect probably occurred at a postreceptor level.