Improving Clinical Visual Detection—Potential for Caries Clinical Trials

It has been the norm in caries clinical trials to measure caries increment by several different caries-recording systems, including the crude DMF-S/T index. However, there is a reserved attitude as to whether to subdivide the non-cavitated lesions and use arrested lesions in clinical trials. This has been due to the belief that it is not possible to achieve reliable data of the early stages of the disease (Radike, 1972). However, recently, Ekstrand et al. (1997, 1998) showed that it was possible: (1) to differentiate between different stages of non-cavitated occlusal lesions, (2) to differentiate between active and inactive occlusal lesions, and (3) to predict the depth of the lesion. In at least 4 other clinical studies, the reproducibility of recording initial active lesions, cavitated active lesions, and arrested lesions was found to be adequate (Carvalho et al., 1989; Nyvad et al, 1999; Ekstrand et al., 2000; Machiulskiene et al., 2001). Since caries today is a more slowly developing disease in many countries in the world, this will result in prolongation of the duration of the clinical trial, which will increase the costs. As indicated above, there is now sufficient evidence that caries can be clinically diagnosed accurately and reliably in earlier stages as well as in an arrested stage. If such stages of caries are used as outcome variables in caries clinical trials, they may have a positive influence on the trials’ duration and costs.

How different do visuo-tactile criteria assess caries lesions activity status on occlusal surfaces?

OBJECTIVES

We tested the association between active caries lesions assessed by two different criteria and clinical features of these caries lesions.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Three examiners examined forty-nine 3- to 12-year-old children: one examiner used the Nyvad criteria, another examiner used the International Caries Detection and Assessment System with an additional criteria--Lesion Activity Assessment (ICDAS + LAA), and a reference examiner classified lesions regarding plaque stagnation, colour, lustre, cavities, depth and texture. Logistic regressions were used to test associations. For analyses, we grouped sound sites and inactive lesions vs active caries lesions, but also considering only inactive vs active lesions.

RESULTS

Active lesions scored by both criteria were similarly associated with different clinical parameters tested, except when the sound sites were excluded from the analysis. In these cases, active lesions according to ICDAS + LAA were associated only with cavitation and texture. Texture was associated with divergences between criteria when differentiating sound or inactive lesions from active ones. Fewer divergences in differentiating active from inactive lesions were observed when lesions present lustre.

CONCLUSION

Most clinical signs associated with active caries lesions were similar, but texture and severity tend to have a greater importance when using ICDAS + LAA for distinguishing caries activity status. Attention should be given to differences due to texture and lustre when using different indices.

Validation of Visual Caries Activity Assessment: A 2-yr Cohort Study

We evaluated the predictive and construct validity of a caries activity assessment system associated with the International Caries Detection and Assessment System (ICDAS) in primary teeth. A total of 469 children were reexamined: participants of a caries survey performed 2 yr before (follow-up rate of 73.4%). At baseline, children (12-59 mo old) were examined with the ICDAS and a caries activity assessment system. The predictive validity was assessed by evaluating the risk of active caries lesion progression to more severe conditions in the follow-up, compared with inactive lesions. We also assessed if children with a higher number of active caries lesions were more likely to develop new lesions (construct validity). Noncavitated active caries lesions at occlusal surfaces presented higher risk of progression than inactive ones. Children with a higher number of active lesions and with higher caries experience presented higher risk of developing new lesions. In conclusion, the caries activity system associated with the ICDAS presents predictive and construct validity in primary teeth in the assessment of occlusal caries lesions, but predictive validity was not observed in smooth surfaces.

A randomized clinical trial of the anti-caries efficacy of 5,000 compared to 1,450 ppm fluoridated toothpaste on root caries lesions in elderly disabled nursing home residents

Root caries is prevalent in elderly disabled nursing home residents in Denmark. This study aimed to compare the effectiveness of tooth brushing with 5,000 versus 1,450 ppm of fluoridated toothpaste (F-toothpaste) for controlling root caries in nursing home residents. The duration of the study was 8 months. Elderly disabled residents (n = 176) in 6 nursing homes in the Copenhagen area consented to take part in the study. They were randomly assigned to use one of the two toothpastes. Both groups had their teeth brushed twice a day by the nursing staff. A total of 125 residents completed the study. Baseline and follow-up clinical examinations were performed by one calibrated examiner. Texture, contour, location and colour of root caries lesions were used to evaluate lesion activity. No differences (p values >0.16) were noted in the baseline examination with regards to age, mouth dryness, wearing of partial or full dentures in one of the jaws, occurrence of plaque and active (2.61 vs. 2.67; SD, 1.7 vs.1.8) or arrested lesions (0.62 vs. 0.63; SD, 1.7 vs. 1.7) between the 5,000 and the 1,450 ppm fluoride groups, respectively. Mean numbers of active root caries lesions at the follow-up examination were 1.05 (2.76) versus 2.55 (1.91) and mean numbers of arrested caries lesions were 2.13 (1.68) versus 0.61 (1.76) in the 5,000 and the 1,450 ppm fluoride groups, respectively (p < 0.001). To conclude, 5,000 ppm F-toothpaste is significantly more effective for controlling root caries lesion progression and promoting remineralization compared to 1,450 ppm F-toothpaste.

Infiltrating/sealing proximal caries lesions: a 3-year randomized clinical trial

This randomized split-mouth controlled clinical trial aimed at assessing the therapeutic effects of infiltration vs. sealing for controlling caries progression on proximal surfaces. Out of 90 adult students/patients assessed at university clinics and agreeing to participate, 39, each with 3 proximal lesions identified radiographically around the enamel-dentin junction to the outer third of the dentin, were included. Lesions were randomly allocated for treatment to test-A (Infiltration: ICON-pre-product; DMG), test-B (Sealing: Prime-Bond-NT; Dentsply), or control-C (Placebo). Primary outcome after 1, 2, and 3 yrs of radiographically observed lesion progression was assessed by an independent examiner blinded to groups, using pair-wise and digital-subtraction readings. No adverse events occurred. In 37 participants assessed after 3 yrs, 10 lesions (A-4; B-2; C-4) progressed deep into dentin and needed operative treatment. The 3-year therapeutic effect, based on pair-wise radiographic readings between infiltration and placebo, was 37.8% (95% CI: 20.5-55.2%) and that between sealing and placebo was 29.7% (95% CI: 20.2-35.0%). One-year follow-up digital-subtraction readings showed significant differences in lesion progression between infiltration and placebo (P = 0.0012) and between sealing and placebo (P = 0.0269). The study showed that infiltration and sealing are significantly better than placebo treatment for controlling caries progression on proximal lesions. No significant difference was seen between infiltration and sealing (ClinicalTrials.gov number NCT01417832).

The reliability and accuracy of two methods for proximal caries detection and depth on directly visible proximal surfaces: an in vitro study

This study aimed to determine the reliability and accuracy of the ICDAS and radiographs in detecting and estimating the depth of proximal lesions on extracted teeth. The lesions were visible to the naked eye. Three trained examiners scored a total of 132 sound/carious proximal surfaces from 106 primary teeth and 160 sound/carious proximal surfaces from 140 permanent teeth. The selected surfaces were first scored visually, using the 7 classes in the ICDAS. They were then assessed on radiographs using a 5-point classification system. Reexaminations were conducted with both scoring systems. Teeth were then sectioned and the selected surfaces histologically classified using a stereomicroscope (×5). Intrareproducibility values (weighted kappa statistics) for the ICDAS for both primary and permanent teeth were >0.9, and for the radiographs between 0.6 and 0.8. Interreproducibility values for the ICDAS were >0.85, for the radiographs >0.6. For both primary and permanent teeth, the accuracy of each examiner (Spearman's correlation coefficient) for the ICDAS was ≥0.85, and for the radiographs ≥0.45. Corresponding data were achieved when using pooled data from the 3 examiners for both the ICDAS and the radiographs. The associations between the 2 detection methods were measured to be moderate. In particular, the ICDAS was accurate in predicting lesion depth (histologically) confined to the enamel/outer third of the dentine versus deeper lesions. This study shows that when proximal lesions are open for inspection, the ICDAS is a more reliable and accurate method than the radiograph for detecting and estimating the depth of the lesion in both primary and permanent teeth.

Sealing distal proximal caries lesions in first primary molars: efficacy after 2.5 years

BACKGROUND

The prevalence of proximal caries in primary molar teeth is high in many countries.

AIMS

(1) To study by means of a split-mouth design the 1- and 2.5-year efficacy of sealing proximal lesions vs. flossing instructions (control) on primary molar teeth. (2) To assess children's behaviour and pain perception during the procedure.

METHODS

Ninety-one 4- to 6-year-old children from Bogotá, Colombia participated. Participants had to have at least two proximal lesions scored according to the following radiographic classification system: radiolucency (1) in enamel outer half, (2) restricted to enamel-dentine junction, or (3) restricted to dentine outer third. Baseline, 1- and 2.5-year follow-up bitewing radiographs were taken. Test and control lesions were randomly selected. After temporary separation test lesions were sealed (adhesive). Parents/caregivers received a flossing leaflet for their children. Progression of the lesions was assessed by means of independent reading of conventional bitewing radiographs.

RESULTS

One-year (n = 73) test vs. control lesion progression was 27.4 vs. 50.7%, respectively (p < 0.01, McNemar's test), and 2.5-year (n = 56) test vs. control lesion progression was 46.4 vs. 71.4%, respectively (p < 0.01). The dropouts did not differ from those who remained in the study regarding relevant caries baseline data. More than 88% of the participants presented positive to definitively positive behaviour and very low or low pain intensity at both first and second appointments.

CONCLUSION

The sealing technique was superior to flossing instructions both after 1 and 2.5 years of follow-up and the majority of the participants had no anxiety or pain during the treatment.

Plaque, caries level and oral hygiene habits in young patients receiving orthodontic treatment

OBJECTIVE

To assess plaque, caries, and oral hygiene habits amongst patients receiving fixed-orthodontic treatment at the Dental-Clinic, Universidad-El-Bosque, Bogotá, Colombia.

BASIC RESEARCH DESIGN

Test-group: 74 12-29-year-olds receiving fixed-orthodontic treatment; reference-group: 63 12-29-year-olds before they started the orthodontic treatment. Visual examinations (one examiner) recorded the following: Ortho-plaque-Index (OPI) expressed per patient as good, fair and poor-oral-hygiene. Caries was scored with the modified-ICDAS-II criteria as: 0-sound; 1B/1W-brown/white-opacity-after-air-drying; 2B/2W-brown/white-opacity-without-air-drying; 3-microcavity; 4-underlying-shadow; 5/6-distinct/extensive-cavity. Filled/missing surfaces due-to-caries and caries-lesions on buccal surfaces at three sites around the brackets were recorded. A 7-item self-administered oral-hygiene habits' questionnaire was used.

RESULTS

Chi-square test revealed that the oral-hygiene level was significantly better in the reference group compared to the test group (p < 0.05). The traditional mean DMF-S was 6.7 +/- 6.3 in the test- and 6.2 +/- 5.9 in the reference-group (p > 0.05). When adding modified-ICDAS-II lesions scores 1-4, the figure increased to 23.6 +/- 9.4 in the test- and to 13.6 +/- 10.3 in the reference-group (p < 0.001). A total of 96% had > or = 1 white-opacity in the test group versus 56% in the reference group (P < 0.001). In the test-group the buccal-surfaces accounted for most white-opacities and close to 1/3 of these lesions on the upper-anterior teeth were located around the brackets. The questionnaire disclosed that 58% in the test- vs. 44% in the reference-group did not accept having dental caries lesions during the orthodontic treatment.

CONCLUSIONS

The results showed a high prevalence of white-opacities related to orthodontic appliances and indicate the need to implement preventive programmes at the dental clinic.

Sealants in dentistry: outcomes of the ORCA Saturday Afternoon Symposium 2007

Sealants are a successful tool in caries prevention, but their role in preventive strategies after the caries decline has to be discussed. A survey of paediatric departments across Europe revealed that indications for pit and fissure sealants vary considerably, both nationally and internationally. Evidence for effectiveness of sealants in controlling caries in posterior teeth implies that sealants should be an integrated part of management of pit and fissure caries. Still, the indication for occlusal sealants seems to be shifting from primary prevention to a therapeutic decision for caries management of lesions in enamel and the outer part of the dentine. Sealants are also an interesting concept for caries management in approximal surfaces. Clinical trials suggest that novel techniques of sealing or infiltrating approximal lesions show promise. However, approximal sealing techniques are as complex to apply and time-consuming as approximal fillings. The article proposes guidelines for teaching on the use of sealants.

In vitro comparison of Nyvad's system and ICDAS-II with Lesion Activity Assessment for evaluation of severity and activity of occlusal caries lesions in primary teeth

This in vitro study of occlusal surfaces on primary molars aimed to: (1) evaluate the reproducibility of the Nyvad and ICDAS-II visual systems in detecting caries; (2) to test the accuracy of the systems in estimating lesion depth, and (3) to examine the association between the Nyvad system and the Lesion Activity Assessment system, an adjunct to ICDAS-II. Two samples of extracted primary molars (sample 1, n = 38; sample 2, n = 69) were evaluated independently by 2 examiners. In this in vitro study, evaluation of plaque in the Nyvad system was not possible. Histology (sample 2) was used to validate lesion depth. Area under ROC curves (A(z)), sensitivity, specificity and percent agreement of both systems were calculated at D1, D2 and D3 thresholds. Both systems showed kappa for intra- and inter-examiner agreement >0.86 and good correlation with histology: Spearman rho = 0.73 (Nyvad) and 0.78 (ICDAS-II). They presented similar performances except that ICDAS-II showed significantly higher sensitivity (Nyvad 0.89; ICDAS 0.92) and A(z) (Nyvad 0.85; ICDAS 0.90) for the D1 threshold. The correlation between the systems for lesion activity (Cramer's V) was 0.71. Therefore, both visual systems are reliable and can estimate caries lesion depth on primary teeth. Under in vitro conditions, there is no major difference between the Nyvad system and Lesion Activity Assessment in assessing caries activity.

Lesion activity assessment

This chapter focusses on the probability of a caries lesion detected during a clinical examination being active (progressing) or arrested. Visual and tactile methods to assess primary coronal lesions and primary root lesions are considered. The evidence level is rated as low (R(w)), as there are few studies with proper validation. The major problem is lack of an accepted clinical gold standard. Evidence from high-quality basic research and epidemiological, clinical and intervention studies is therefore discussed. High-quality basic research has mapped the patho-anatomical changes occurring in response to cariogenic plaque as well as lesion arrest. Based on this understanding, different clinical scoring systems have been developed to assess the severity/depth and activity of lesions. A recent system has been devised by the International Caries Detection and Assessment System Committee. The literature suggests that there is a fair agreement between visual/tactile external scripts of caries and the severity/depth of the lesion. The reproducibility of the different systems is, in general, substantial. No single clinical predictor is able to reliably assess activity. However, a combination of predictors increases the accuracy of lesion activity prediction for both primary coronal and root lesions. Three surrogate methods have been used for evaluating lesion activity (construct validity); all have disadvantages. If construct validity is accepted as a 'gold standard', it is possible to assess the activity of primary coronal and root lesions reliably and accurately at one examination by using the combined information obtained from a range of indicators--such as visual appearance, location of the lesion, tactile sensation during probing and gingival health.

Frequency and distribution patterns of sealants among 15-year-olds in Denmark in 2003

AIMS

To provide information on the frequency and distribution patterns of sealants in the Public Dental Health Service for Children (PDHSC) in Denmark. A further aim was to determine whether there was a correlation between DMF-S and sealants.

DESIGN

A cross sectional survey using data from 15-year-old Danes in 2003. SAMPLE AND SUBJECTS: The sample consisted of 50 randomly selected municipalities from the 204 municipalities with public clinics. Thirty-nine municipalities (78%) forwarded useful data. A total number of 3,184 15-year-olds were involved in the study.

RESULTS

The mean DMF-S was 2.97 (SD = 1.40) and 42% had a DMF-S = 0. The mean number of sealants was 3.06 (SD = 1.60). Two-thirds of all participants had one or more sealed surfaces. At the individual level the correlation coefficient (rs) between sealants and DMF-S was -0.05 (p < 0.01). The mean number of sealants in one municipality was 0.26, in another 6.00. The surfaces most often sealed, were the occlusal surfaces on permanent second molars (35%), closely followed by the occlusal surfaces on permanent first molars (32%). Sealants on premolars were rare (1.5%). At the municipality level there was no significant correlation between mean DMF-S, % 15-year-olds with a DMF-S = 0 and mean number of sealants (rs = 0.02 (p = 0.90) and rs = 0.06 (p = 0.73), respectively).

CONCLUSION

The data indicate a high use of sealants on molar teeth, a very large inter-municipality variation, no correlation between sealants and DMF-S. These findings suggest that there are no clear guidelines for use of sealants in the PDHSC in Denmark.

Accuracy and reproducibility of conventional radiographic assessment and subtraction radiography in detecting demineralization in occlusal surfaces

Subjective interpretation of paired digital radiographic images viewed side by side to assess occlusal lesion progression, arrest or remineralization is difficult. The aim of this study was to compare the accuracy and reproducibility of a digital subtraction radiography technique and visual assessment of paired digital images in detecting changes in mineral content within occlusal cavities. Forty molar teeth with occlusal cavities were placed in arches and baseline digital radiographs taken. Nineteen teeth were randomly selected and had acid placed in the cavities and digital images taken after 3, 6, 12, 18 and 24 h of acid exposure. Paired baseline images and those taken at the various time intervals were examined side by side and assessed for demineralization by five examiners. Subtraction images prepared from the paired images were assessed in the same way. One fifth of the images were re-examined to determine intra-examiner reproducibility. After 12 h or longer the diagnostic accuracy (mean area under the ROC curve = 0.92-0.98 for subtraction radiography), intra-examiner and inter-examiner reproducibility for detection of demineralization from the subtraction images was significantly better than viewing the paired images side by side (p < 0.01). The subtraction radiography system used was found to be more accurate and reproducible than visual assessment of paired digital images. As such the technique shows promise for monitoring occlusal lesion progression in clinical studies.

Efficacy of sealing proximal early active lesions: an 18-month clinical study evaluated by conventional and subtraction radiography

This study assessed the efficacy of sealing proximal lesions on adult patients using a split-mouth design. Eighty-two 15- to 39-year-olds from the Dental Faculties in Copenhagen and Bogotá participated, each having 2 or more proximal lesions in the following radiographic stages: (1) lesion restricted to the outer half of enamel; (2) lesion from the inner half of enamel including the enamel dentine junction, and (3) lesion restricted to the outer third of dentine. Standardized geometrically aligned baseline and follow-up radiographs were obtained. One randomly selected lesion (test) in each patient was sealed with 1 of 2 resins. The patients were instructed to floss all the proximal lesions 3 times per week. The baseline to 18 months difference in caries lesion progression status was assessed using 3 methods: (1) radiographs were independently assessed visually; (2) radiographs were read in pairs, and (3) using subtraction radiography of digitized images. A total of 72 subjects finished the study (12.2% dropout). The compliance concerning flossing was poor (15%). For the repeated examinations kappa was 0.84 for the visual examination, 0.44 for the paired readings and 0.84 for the subtraction examination. Two test lesions and 1 control lesion were restored. For the independent radiograph assessment method 10 and 26% progressed in the test and control group, respectively (p > 0.05); with the paired radiograph method the corresponding data were 22% in the test and 47% in the control groups (p < 0.01). By subtraction radiography 44% of the test group and 84% of the control were judged to have progressed (p < 0.001). The sealing technique was superior to instructing patients to floss, and subtraction radiography appeared to be the most sensitive method for assessing lesion progression.

Outcomes of a Non-Operative Caries Treatment Programme for Children and Adolescents

This study assessed the effectiveness and performance of a non-operative caries treatment programme (NOCTP) used since 1987 in the municipality of Nexo in Denmark. The NOCTP emphasizes mechanical plaque control and considers the eruption period of molar teeth as a risk factor. The mean DMF-S among 18-year-olds in 1999 and 2000 in Nexo was 1.23 +/- 2.26 and 1.25 +/- 2.01 (medians 0); 55 and 56% had DMF-S = 0. The mean numbers of sealed surfaces were 4.6 +/- 3.25 and 4.0 +/- 3.22, respectively. The cost per child per year was marginally and significantly reduced in the years with the NOCTP compared to that before 1988 (p = 0.05). In 4 comparison municipalities with very low caries experience, mean DMF-S scores among 18-year-olds in 1999 were 2.73-3.25 (medians 1-2) and were significantly higher than in Nexo (p < 0.001). The NOCTP differed from the preventive programmes used in the comparison municipalities in the period 1988-1999 in emphasising care for the erupting molars, the use of a firm guideline and stated goals to be achieved, but with less emphasis on diet. The effectiveness and performance of the NOCTP were both considered high, as very low DMF-S and high %DMF-S = 0 had been achieved by 1999, and 18-year-olds in Nexo had significantly less caries than in the comparison municipalities. The latter difference could not be explained by difference in caries-related background variables.

Visual and tactile assessment of arrested initial enamel carious lesions: an in vivo pilot study

Accurate and reliable assessment of caries activity is important for determining appropriate treatment needs. The aim of this pilot study was to determine whether dentists could differentiate between the appearances (visual and tactile) of lesions inactivated by regular professional oral hygiene and those control lesions which were not cleaned (active). After a 3- to 4-week study period involving 10 children, with 4 similar carious lesions each, it was found that dentists were not able to reliably and reproducibly determine the subtle visual and tactile differences between active and inactive enamel lesions from a one-off clinical examination.

Influence of different variables on the inter-municipality variation in caries experience in Danish adolescents

This investigation sought to estimate the influence a number of variables had on the inter-municipality variation in caries experience across Denmark. Unit of measurement was the municipality with public clinics. Mean DMF-S and %DMF-S = 0 of 15- and 18-year-olds in 1999 were obtained from 204 and 143 municipalities, respectively, out of a total number of 206 municipalities with public clinics. The independent variables were: cost per child per year; children/dentist ratio; auxiliary personal/dentist ratio; fluoride concentration in the water supply [F]; average personal income; % of mothers of the 15- and 18-year-olds with < or =10 years education (EDU-15 or EDU-18); proportion of immigrants; and size of the municipality. Multiple regression analyses disclosed that [F] (p < 0.001) and EDU-15 (p < 0.001) were significant variables among the 15-year-olds explaining 45% of the variation in mean DMF-S and 31% of the variation in % DMF-S = 0. With respect to the 18-year-olds, [F] (p < 0.001) and average personal income (p < 0.001) explained 53% of the variation in mean DMF-S and 30% of the variation in %DMF-S = 0. Few municipalities were characterized as outliers with significantly lower or higher observed caries experience than expected. It is concluded that there is room for other explanatory factors--first and foremost the professional effort made in the individual Public Dental Health Service to control caries.

An in vitro comparison of a combined FOTI/visual examination of occlusal caries with other caries diagnostic methods and the effect of stain on their diagnostic performance

The aims of this in vitro study were to compare the combination of FOTI and visual inspection to other diagnostic methods for the detection and evaluation of the depth of occlusal caries and assess the effect of stain on diagnostic performance. Five diagnostic methods (combined FOTI/Visual (CFV), Visual, FOTI, DIAGNOdent and Electrical Caries Monitor) were considered. Histological validation was performed in the 152 occlusal molar sites (111 teeth) using 350-microm sections and a stereomicroscope. The rank correlation coefficients with histology ranged from 0.42 (DIAGNOdent) to 0.66 (CFV). The area under the ROC curves (AUC) for enamel lesions ranged from 0.82 (ECM) to 0.88 (CFV) and from 0.81 (DIAGNOdent) to 0.91 (CFV) for dentine lesions. The AUC at the dentine level for CFV and FOTI were similar (p > 0.05), but the AUC for CFV was significantly greater than for visual (p < 0.001), DIAGNOdent (p = 0.005) and the ECM (p = 0.04). FOTI was found to be particularly useful for the detection of dentine lesions. The exclusion of stain and brown spot lesions improved performance for all methods. It is concluded that CFV is useful for the determination of occlusal lesion depth and that in the presence of stain and brown spot lesions different cut-off points may be required for the ECM and DIAGNOdent to identify dentine lesions.

Occlusal caries: pathology, diagnosis and logical management

Occlusal caries now accounts for most of the lesions in children aged 8-15 years. This paper presents a ranked visual scoring system for occlusal caries diagnosis. It relates the clinical appearance of the lesion to its activity, the level of infection of the dentine and the histopathology. The appropriate management for each score is suggested.

An in vitro comparison of the ability of fibre-optic transillumination, visual inspection and radiographs to detect occlusal caries and evaluate lesion depth

The aim of this study was to compare the performance of fibre-optic transillumination (FOTI), visual inspection and bite-wing radiographs to detect occlusal caries and estimate the lesion depth. Fifty-nine extracted molars were assessed using FOTI and visual examination by 4 trained examiners and 1 examiner evaluated the bite-wing radiographs. Histological validation was performed using 250-microm sections examined with a stereomicroscope. For the three methods, the correlation between the lesion depth and the histological scores varied from 0.65 to 0.73. For dentinal caries detection, the areas under ROC curves ranged from 0.83 to 0.87. The radiographic method was poor at detecting lesions confined to enamel. FOTI, visual inspection and radiographs showed a good correlation with the histology but had difficulty in distinguishing lesions located deep in enamel or in the outer third of dentine. FOTI was shown to be as accurate as a detailed visual inspection in detecting occlusal caries.

Plaque and gingival status as indicators for caries progression on approximal surfaces

This study aimed to (1) record the plaque and gingival status on sound and carious approximal surfaces and (2) investigate whether the two parameters could predict approximal lesion progression. For this purpose two samples were selected among 18- to 25-year-old patients at the Dental Faculty in Copenhagen. Sample 1 consisted of 45 patients, each having an approximal posterior surface requiring operative treatment and a contralateral approximal space, where both surfaces were radiographically sound. Sample 2 consisted of 25 patients, each having a posterior approximal tooth surface with an enamel/initial dentinal lesion recorded on a bitewing. Plaque and gingival status were classified using 4-point ranked scales. The recordings were performed once on each participant in sample 1. The recordings in sample 2 were repeated 5 times during a 15-month period. In order to assess lesion progression in sample 2, two serial intraoral examinations were performed, i.e. at the beginning and end of the study. Less than 10% of the sound and carious surfaces were recorded as plaque-free, while about 40% had a thick or heavy plaque accumulation. No significant difference was observed between plaque scores on sound and carious surfaces (p = 0.5), in contrast to findings representing the gingival status (p < 0.001). Tooth surfaces requiring operative treatment were associated with bleeding of the gingiva after probing. In sample 2, 3 of the 25 participants did not finish the study. On the remaining participants caries progression was observed in 9 cases (41%), while no progression was observed in 13 cases. Analyses showed that there were no significant differences between plaque scores in cases with caries progression, as compared with no caries progression (p > 0.05). Similar analyses concerning gingival status showed that bleeding of the gingiva was related to cases with progressing caries. Analyses also disclosed no direct association between plaque and gingival status (Spearman correlation coefficient 0.39). Thus, the occurrence of plaque does not have the same predictive power as bleeding after probing in decision-making as to whether or not a lesion progresses.

Detection, diagnosing, monitoring and logical treatment of occlusal caries in relation to lesion activity and severity: an in vivo examination with histological validation

The aims of the present study were to investigate the ability of 3 experienced clinicians to detect occlusal carious lesions, assess their depth, diagnose their activity and define a logical management for each lesion. The material consisted of 35 third molars scheduled for extraction or surgical removal making it possible to validate the accuracy of the clinical recordings histologically. Examinations were carried out at baseline and after 4 months in order to monitor lesion progression. At the first visit a radiograph was taken; the number of filled surfaces was counted and the oral hygiene assessed generally and by disclosing occlusal plaque of the tooth under examination. After cleaning the occlusal surface caries was recorded in a selected investigation site using a visual ranked caries scoring system, as well as an electrical conductance recording (ECM). Apart from counting fillings and taking new radiographs the same procedure was performed at the second visit, which then was followed by extraction of the tooth. After sectioning the tooth lesion depth was recorded, and lesion activity, based on acid production, was assessed using methyl red dye. Lesion activity was also judged by means of polarized light microscopic examinations of the sections. Results showed strong relationships between the visual, ECM and radiographic assessments and both lesion depth and lesion activity. In contrast, all other parameters were poorly related to lesion activity. Changes in visual assessments and in conductance readings from first to second examination were poorly associated with lesion activity. In conclusion, clinicians are able to detect lesions, predict activity and severity and define a logical management of occlusal caries on the basis of a single examination.

Two and a half-year outcome of caries-preventive programs offered to groups of children in the Solntsevsky district of Moscow

This study examined the 2.5-year outcome of preventive programs - based on the Nexö method - offered to three groups of children from Solntsevsky, a district of Moscow. Study group A consisted of 45 3-year-olds, study group B of 50 6-year-olds, and study group C of 50 11-year-olds. A similar number of children were selected as control groups and they followed the normal dental service provided by the local Health Service System in the district. The caries-preventive programs offered to the study groups were based on: (1) education of the child, parents and teachers in the caries disease, (2) training in toothbrushing. In addition, the children in study groups B and C were offered professional plaque removal, applications of sodium fluoride (2%) and sealant applications according to individual needs. The children in groups B and C were clinically examined in March 1994 (baseline) after 1 and 2.5 years, respectively. Because of the age of the children in group A, these children were only examined once, after the study had been completed. After 2.5 years the children in all three study groups had improved their oral health status significantly compared to the children in the control group. The caries experience among the children in study group A was about half of that observed among children in the control group (4.91 def-s versus 8.60 def-s). The program was highly effective in controlling dental caries in the permanent dentition among the children in the study groups, who finished with a mean DMF-S of 0.28 (group B) and 3.12 (group C) compared to 2.24 and 6.35 among the children in the corresponding control groups. Nearly all the children used fluoridated toothpaste. The mean number of visits to the clinic decreased from year 1 to year 2 (5 versus 3.4 in study group B and 4.5 versus 3.3 in study group C). In conclusion, the preventive programs were highly effective with regard to improving the level of oral hygiene, and thereby reducing or even controlling the plaque-induced disease activity.

A new in vitro method for testing the interproximal cleaning potential of toothbrushing

A new laboratory method was developed and used to evaluate the approximal penetration of different toothbrushing techniques. Before brushing, the approximal surfaces on teeth numbers 33 to 38 were covered by a colored coating. After brushing from both the buccal and lingual sides, the teeth were removed and the remaining coatings on the approximal surfaces were photographed and magnified, and their areas were determined by computerization. Two conventional toothbrushing techniques and two toothbrushing techniques specially designed to enhance interproximal access were used. It was found that considerable areas on the approximal surfaces were left untouched by the toothbrush bristles, regardless of the toothbrushing technique employed. The findings suggest that improvements in toothbrush design will be a more important contribution to the attainment of effective interproximal brushing than the development of new brushing techniques. This test method shares many similarities with in vivo conditions and seems also well suited for evaluating interproximal cleaning potential of new toothbrushes.

Do occlusal carious lesions spread laterally at the enamel-dentin junction? A histolopathological study

It is conventionally taught that the carious lesion in dentin undermines the enamel due to lateral spread of the lesion at the enamel-dentin junction (EDJ). The aim of the present study was to challenge this hypothesis by testing an alternative hypothesis, that lateral spread is related to advanced lesions where the dentin is infected. Selected points in the groove-fossa system of 100 unrestored occlusal surfaces were examined and the teeth divided into five groups (scores 0-4) depending on the clinical appearance of the lesion. Teeth were sectioned through these sites and texture of the dentin was assessed by probing. Colour slides of the section face with the more extensive changes in the dentin were projected and the dimensions of the lesions at the EDJ were assessed by three examiners on two separate occasions. Inter- and intra-examiner reproducibility was assessed and found acceptable. Results showed that in 47 teeth demineralisation had not reached the EDJ. In the remaining teeth the presence or absence of lateral spread of the lesion at the EDJ was related to the clinical features of the lesion. Lateral spread was rarely found in lesions with an apparently intact enamel surface (scores 0-2). However, 32% of sites with microcavitation (score 3) and 63% of sites with obvious cavitation (score 4) showed lateral spread. Of those 31 sections which were judged to have soft dentin, 80% had lateral spread. In conclusion, the phenomenon of lateral spread of caries at the FDJ is related to advanced lesions with cavity formation where the dentin is soft and infected.

Structural analyses of plaque and caries in relation to the morphology of the groove-fossa system on erupting mandibular third molars

Using 22 erupting human third mandibular molars, this study investigated: (1) the relationship between the morphology of the interlobal groove and the histological features of caries, (2) the ultrastructural features of the interlobal groove contents, and (3) whether the morphology of interlobal grooves influences the viability of the microorganisms. Posteruption time was classified as (1) < 3 months (7 teeth), (2) 3-12 months (8 teeth) and (3) > 12 months but < 18 months (7 teeth). The teeth were pre- and postfixed, and buccolingual sections were prepared. The mesial/distal interlobal groove on 116 sections was classified as fissure-like or groove-like. All sections were embedded and ground, and microradiographs were made. The interlobal groove contents were analyzed on two sections from each tooth, one with a fissure-like and one with a groove-like morphology, giving a total of 44 sections. Eighteen teeth (82%) had evidence of caries. Severity of caries was associated with length of posteruption time. 'Fissures' were not more prone to caries than 'grooves'. In about 70% of the 'fissures' caries had penetrated deepest at the entrance rather than in the deeper parts. LM and TEM examinations from 1 tooth disclosed erythrocytes, enamel organ cells and pioneers of microorganisms in the interlobal grooves. All other interlobal grooves were occupied by microorganisms, mainly gram-positive coccoids and small rods. Viable microorganisms were seen at the entrance as well as at the bottom part of the 'grooves'. In 'fissures' viable microorganisms were primarily observed at the entrance, while in deeper parts the microorganisms were less viable or dead. A moderate association was observed between the viability of the microorganisms and differences in the depths of caries penetration in the fissures. Thus, the internal morphology of the interlobal grooves influenced the conditions for bacterial growth and this determined the location for caries progression within the groove-fossa system.

Reproducibility and accuracy of three methods for assessment of demineralization depth of the occlusal surface: an in vitro examination

This laboratory study of 100 occlusal surfaces investigated the reproducibility and accuracy of a visual ranked caries scoring system, an electronic caries scoring system (ECM) using a continuous conductance scale, and a radiographic ranked caries scoring system. Histological examination of the teeth served as a gold standard to validate the ability of each system to assess lesion depth and predict softened, demineralized dentine. After training, 3 examiners carried out each scoring system on two separate occasions. Kappa values for visual, ECM and radiographic ranked scoring systems showed good inter- and intra-examiner reproducibility levels and acceptable limits of agreement for ECM readings. When scoring systems were tabulated against histological scores there was a high correlation between the visual and ECM methods and lesion depth in both enamel and dentine, but radiographic examination could not detect enamel caries. When compared to the histological scoring, the Spearman correlation coefficients for the visual scoring ranged between 0.87 and 0.93, for the ECM between 0.80 and 0.85 and for the radiographic scoring system between 0.76 and 0.78. No tooth scored as visually sound had histological evidence of dentine caries. Soft dentine corresponded to demineralization involving the middle third of the dentine or more which was related to visual cavity formation or an ECM reading above 9 (score 3 or 4). The radiograph was an excellent predictor of soft dentine. In conclusion, the new visual system appears promising, but takes time to learn. The reproducibility and accuracy for the ECM is acceptable while radiographs miss early occlusal lesions.

Relationship between external and histologic features of progressive stages of caries in the occlusal fossa

The material comprised 140 extracted maxillary third molars. The central fossa area was examined with a stereomicroscope (SM) (x16) and macroscopically (M) under standardized conditions after cleaning and air-drying. Signs of caries were classified using a detailed scoring system involving 12 (SM) and 8 (M) classification criteria, ranging from 'sound' to 'cavitation with dentine involvement'. Six radiographic scores were used in the classification. Sections 250 microns in thickness were cut in buccolingual direction through the central fossa, and the fossa section with the most extensive stereomicroscopic changes was selected for histologic examination (x16). The histologic enamel and dentine changes were classified independently using 9 and 7 scores, respectively. The correlation between SM and the histologic enamel changes (HE scores) in terms of progressive demineralization and destruction were highly correlated (rs = 0.90). Dentinal changes were also highly correlated with enamel changes (rs = 0.85). The histologic classifications in conjunction with the macroscopical observations made it possible to demonstrate a clear relationship between the external degree of caries progression and the internal enamel and dentine reactions. The data did not support routine usage of radiographic examination for occlusal caries diagnosis.

A method for light microscopy examination of cellular and structural interrelations in undemineralized tooth specimens

This study examines ameloblasts and odontoblasts in relation to mineralizing enamel and dentin in thin undemineralized tooth sections from unerupted and partly erupted human third molars. The material comprised 12 freshly removed third molars. After fixation for 24 h the specimens were dehydrated and embedded in hydroxyethylmethacrylate. Undemineralized sections 10-15 microns thick were prepared with a cutting-grinding system, and radiomicrographs were taken. Postsecretory ameloblasts were seen in different morphologic stages ranging from ruffle- and smooth-ended ameloblasts to cuboidal and squamous cells adhering to incomplete and fully mineralized enamel. The former occurred in the most coronal tooth part, whereas the latter were seen cervically. It was not possible to identify systematic modulation cycles as seen in postsecretory rat incisor ameloblasts. The well-defined subodontoblastic region with cell-free and cell-rich layers was established before tooth eruption. The function of the subodontoblastic region is not fully understood, but our findings suggest that the establishment of the region plays a role in maintaining the specific odontoblast phenotype in the coronal region possibly linked to progressive dentin mineralization.

Restorative caries treatment patterns in Danish 20-year-old males in 1986 and 1991

This study examines the restorative caries treatment pattern in Danish 20-year-old military conscripts in 1986 and 1991. The study groups comprised 85 and 164 males born in 1966 and 1971, respectively. The examination was performed as a part of the routine for each conscript according to directions from Dental Service, Danish Defense Forces and included surface recording of fillings on all teeth except third molars. Two bitewing radiographs were taken of all conscripts in the 1986-group and of those who gave permission (59) in the 1991-group. The mean number of filled surfaces was 10.2 and 8.8 in 1986 and in 1991, respectively. 80% of the occlusal surfaces on permanent first molars were filled in the 1986-group and filled or sealed in the 1991-group in contrast to 45% of permanent second molars. Data from maxillary molars indicated a tendency to placement of fillings related to tooth specific morphology whereas extended fillings involving the entire occlusal surface dominated on mandibular molars. The X-ray examination disclosed that the majority of approximal molar surfaces were classified as sound in both study groups. Less than 1% of the approximal molar surfaces were recorded as having lesions penetrating deep into the dentin. In 1981 and in 1986 the participants in the study groups were 15 yr old. In these years the mean number of filled surfaces in Danish children amounted to 11.0 and 6.9 respectively, which indicates that very few lesions in need of operative treatment developed from age 15 to age 20 in both study groups.

Dental plaque and caries on permanent first molar occlusal surfaces in relation to sagittal occlusion

This study examines the influence of sagittal occlusion on occlusal plaque formation in permanent first molars (PFM) in 72 7-10-yr-olds before loss of primary second molars. Of a total of 288 PFM, 140 (49%) were sealed and 23 (8%) filled. Occlusal plaque was recorded at two levels of examination: 1) visible plaque on the entire surface and 2) detailed macromorphologic mapping. Enamel caries was recorded after professional tooth cleaning. After 48 h without tooth brushing, plaque examinations were repeated. Stone models were used for 1) identification of interocclusal contact areas and 2) classification of sagittal molar occlusion. The detailed mapping of plaque on unfilled surfaces showed a clear pattern of preferential locations related to the macromorphology of the occlusal surfaces. Active caries was restricted to those anatomic structures where plaque accumulated. 48-h median plaque values on mandibular molars in normal and with one cusp distal occlusion were significantly lower (P < 0.01) compared to surfaces in 1/4, 1/2 and 3/4 distal molar occlusion. Maxillary molars with normal and with 1 cusp distal occlusion had lower median plaque values than other sagittal occlusion categories. In general, however, plaque scores were higher in maxillary teeth because more than 2/3 of these teeth were without occlusal contact in the distal part. Mandibular occlusal surfaces in normal and with one cusp distal occlusion had significantly fewer active lesions than teeth with 1/4, 1/2 and 3/4 cusp distal occlusion.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Results after 3 years of non-operative occlusal caries treatment of erupting permanent first molars

The aim of the study was to describe the 3-yr results of a treatment program designed to control occlusal caries on the basis of intensive patient education and professional toothcleaning. The sample consisted of 56 children 6-8 yr old with their permanent right first molars in different stages of eruption. The results were compared with record data from 58 children of the same age who had received a traditional caries treatment program including fissure sealing (control group). After 1 yr a significant reduction of occlusal surfaces with visible plaque was noted in the study group as well as an increased proportion of arrested lesions. These results were maintained after 2 and 3 yr. Ten (9%) teeth were sealed and one filled during the study period. Examination of record data in the control group over a 3-yr period revealed that 76 (65%) first molars were sealed and 7 (6%) were filled. During the first year 1/3 of the children in the study group needed 5-6 recall visits, whereas in the following period all children were only seen 1-4 times. In contrast, 50% of the children in the control group needed 5-6 recalls in the 3rd yr. Our data indicate that professional care for erupting teeth on an individual basis has a long-term effect on occlusal surfaces as well. The alternative technique required less clinical time than the traditional application of sealants.

Light and transmission-electron microscopy study of enamel organ cells in germectomized human third mandibular molars

Using nine serially sectioned germectomized mandibular third molars it was possible to examine light microscopical (LM) and transmission-electron microscopical (TEM) features of maturing human enamel organ cells. The degree of enamel mineralization was estimated by quantitative imbibition studies in polarized light. It was possible to distinguish between three progressive stages of enamel mineralization. The most advanced stage was characterized by external enamel porosity. In the least advanced stages the enamel porosity appeared more extensive beneath a less porous surface layer. Ruffle- and smooth-ended ameloblasts were identified corresponding to the maturing enamel. Smooth-ended ameloblasts were the most frequently observed. However, no preferences for one of the two cell types could be observed in relation to the different stages of enamel mineralization. The maturing human enamel organ cells broadly revealed the same characteristics with respect to morphology features, intracellular organization, and junctional complexes as described in the maturation zone of the rat incisor enamel organ. Our findings therefore add to the view that the basic pattern of amelogenesis is identical in human and rat incisor enamel.

Organic content in occlusal groove-fossa-system in unerupted 3rd mandibular molars: a light and electron microscopic study

A method is described by means of which organic content in fissure areas of 12 unerupted 3rd mandibular molars can be prepared for studies in the light microscope (LM) and in the transmission electron microscope (TEM). Thus, LM and TEM examinations revealed that the organic content throughout the fissure in bone-covered and in mucosa-covered 3rd molars with uncompleted root formation consists of cells belonging to the enamel organ in late or in postmaturative stages. In mucosa-covered teeth with completed root formation it was only possible to identify enamel organ cells at the entrance of the fissure. Deeper parts were occupied by degenerative cells, polymorphonuclear cells and unidentified material. The results indicate that ameloblasts in fissures do not transform to stratified squamous epithelium but gradually degenerate towards terminal stages and remain as such, as the tooth emerges into the oral cavity.

Morphometric analysis of occlusal groove-fossa-system in mandibular third molar

Based on serially cut 200-microns-thick sections from 21 human mandibular third molars, a quantitative characterization was made of the morphology in the mesial and distal interlobal groove. Two parameters were used: depth of interlobal groove and structure angle. The interlobal groove depth varied between 0.13 and 0.55, taken in relation to the maximum crown height. The structure angle varied between 2 degrees and 170 degrees. If the structure angle was less than or equal to 25 degrees, the interlobal groove was classified as a fissure; if the angle was greater than 25 degrees, the interlobal groove was classified as a groove. Only in 18% of the sections did the interlobal groove manifest itself as a fissure. The study demonstrates that it was possible unambiguously to describe the two-dimensional profile of interlobal grooves by groove depth and structure angle.

Results after 1 year of non-operative occlusal caries treatment of erupting permanent first molars

The aim of this study was to evaluate a treatment program designed to control occlusal caries on the basis of intensive patient education and professional toothcleaning. The sample consisted of 56 6-8-yr-old children with their permanent right first molars in different stages of eruption. Data from the program were compared with previous data recorded in a similar sample of children. After 1 yr the majority of children in the study group had their permanent right first molars in full occlusion. A significant decrease of surfaces with easily detectable plaque and an increase of surfaces without plaque was observed. The proportion of arrested lesions increased and active enamel lesions decreased. Fissure sealing was only needed in two teeth in contrast to more than 2/3 of molars in a comparable sample of children. The program proved to be an efficient alternative to fissure sealing in preventing occlusal caries in erupting teeth.

Dental plaque and caries on occlusal surfaces of first permanent molars in relation to stage of eruption

The occlusal surfaces of partly and fully erupted first right permanent molars were examined with respect to the occurrence and distribution of plaque and dental caries in a group of 57 six- to eight-year-old children. The children were classified into four groups ranging from one tooth partially erupted to full occlusion. Occlusal plaque was recorded at two levels of examination: (1) visible plaque and (2) detailed mapping by means of a plaque detector system. Dental caries was recorded after professional cleaning. The recording of plaque was repeated after 48 hr without oral hygiene. The findings showed a significant reduction in the easily detectable plaque in fully erupted teeth, compared with the three groups representing partly erupted teeth. The detailed mapping of plaque showed a clear pattern of preferential locations related to the macromorphology of the occlusal surfaces, and revealed reduction in the frequency of thick plaque accumulation in the fully erupted teeth. The proportion of active lesions was reduced in fully erupted teeth, and arrested lesions were mainly observed in the same group. This indicated that erupting teeth are more likely to develop dental caries, due to favorable conditions for plaque accumulation. Functional usage of teeth in addition to improved access for toothbrushing promoted arrestment of lesions initiated during eruption.