Current evidence on the potential therapeutic applications of transcranial magnetic stimulation in multiple sclerosis: a systematic review of the literature

INTRODUCTION

A growing number of studies have evaluated the effects of transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) for the symptomatic treatment of multiple sclerosis (MS).

METHODS

We performed a PubMed search for articles, recent books, and recommendations from the most relevant clinical practice guidelines and scientific societies regarding the use of TMS as symptomatic treatment in MS.

CONCLUSIONS

Excitatory electromagnetic pulses applied to the affected cerebral hemisphere allow us to optimise functional brain activity, including the transmission of nerve impulses through the demyelinated corticospinal pathway. Various studies into TMS have safely shown statistically significant improvements in spasticity, fatigue, lower urinary tract dysfunction, manual dexterity, gait, and cognitive deficits related to working memory in patients with MS; however, the exact level of evidence has not been defined as the results have not been replicated in a sufficient number of controlled studies. Further well-designed, randomised, controlled clinical trials involving a greater number of patients are warranted to attain a higher level of evidence in order to recommend the appropriate use of TMS in MS patients across the board. TMS acts as an adjuvant with other symptomatic and immunomodulatory treatments. Additional studies should specifically investigate the effect of conventional repetitive TMS on fatigue in these patients, something that has yet to see the light of day.

Current evidence on the potential therapeutic applications of transcranial magnetic stimulation in multiple sclerosis: A systematic review of the literature

INTRODUCTION

A growing number of studies have evaluated the effects of transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) for the symptomatic treatment of multiple sclerosis (MS).

METHODS

We performed a PubMed search for articles, recent books, and recommendations from the most relevant clinical practice guidelines and scientific societies regarding the use of TMS as symptomatic treatment in MS.

CONCLUSIONS

Excitatory electromagnetic pulses applied to the affected cerebral hemisphere allow us to optimise functional brain activity, including the transmission of nerve impulses through the demyelinated corticospinal pathway. Various studies into TMS have safely shown statistically significant improvements in spasticity, fatigue, lower urinary tract dysfunction, manual dexterity, gait, and cognitive deficits related to working memory in patients with MS; however, the exact level of evidence has not been defined as the results have not been replicated in a sufficient number of controlled studies. Further well-designed, randomised, controlled clinical trials involving a greater number of patients are warranted to attain a higher level of evidence in order to recommend the appropriate use of TMS in MS patients across the board. TMS acts as an adjuvant with other symptomatic and immunomodulatory treatments. Additional studies should specifically investigate the effect of conventional repetitive TMS on fatigue in these patients, something that has yet to see the light of day.

No proinflammatory signature in CD34+ hematopoietic progenitor cells in multiple sclerosis patients

Autologous hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (aHSCT) has been used as a therapeutic approach in multiple sclerosis (MS). However, it is still unclear if the immune system that emerges from autologous CD34+ hematopoietic progenitor cells (HPC) of MS patients is pre-conditioned to re-develop the proinflammatory phenotype. The objective of this article is to compare the whole genome gene and microRNA expression signature in CD34+ HPC of MS patients and healthy donors (HD). CD34+ HPC were isolated from peripheral blood of eight MS patients and five HD and analyzed by whole genome gene expression and microRNA expression microarray. Among the differentially expressed genes (DEGs) only TNNT1 reached statistical significance (logFC=3.1, p<0.01). The microRNA expression was not significantly different between MS patients and HD. We did not find significant alterations of gene expression or microRNA profiles in CD34+ HPCs of MS patients. Our results support the use of aHSCT for treatment of MS.

Functional antigen-independent synapses formed between T cells and dendritic cells

Immunological synapse formation is usually assumed to require antigen recognition by T cell receptors. However, the immunological synapse formed at the interface between naïve T cells and dendritic cells (DCs) has never been described. We show here that in the absence of antigen, and even of major histocompatibility complex molecules, T cell-DC synapses are formed and lead to several T cell responses: a local increase in tyrosine phosphorylation, small Ca2+ responses, weak proliferation and long-term survival. These responses are triggered more readily in CD4+ T cells than in CD8+ T cells, which express a specific isoform of the repulsive molecule CD43. These phenomena may play a major role in the maintenance of the naïve T cell pool in vivo.

A one-tube polymerase chain reaction protocol demonstrates CC chemokine overexpression in Graves' disease glands

An adaptation of mixed oligonucleotide primed amplification of complementary DNA to detect the profile of CC chemokines in biological samples is presented. By introducing normalization, two correction coefficients, performing a single amplification reaction, and five parallel hybridizations, intrasample and intersample comparisons can be reliably made. This protocol of single tube PCR CC chemokine profiling was applied to tissue samples from an autoimmune thyroid condition, Graves' disease, and from a nonautoimmune condition, multinodular goiter. Results demonstrate overexpression of CC chemokines in Graves' disease, statistically significant for macrophage inflammatory protein-1alpha and -1beta, which correlated with the aberrant human leukocyte antigen class II expression by thyrocytes, as assessed by flow cytometry. Overexpression of CC chemokines probably plays a major role in determining the characteristics of the lymphocytes migrating to the thyroid gland and influences the course of the disease. The study of chemokine profile should be more informative than the study of isolated chemokines and cytokines, and as it can be applied to fine needle aspiration biopsies, it may be useful to clinical research.

HLA-DM and invariant chain are expressed by thyroid follicular cells, enabling the expression of compact DR molecules

Thyroid follicular cells (TFC) in Graves' disease (GD) hyperexpress HLA class I and express ectopic HLA class II molecules, probably as a consequence of cytokines produced by infiltrating T cells. This finding led us to postulate that TFC could act as antigen-presenting cells, and in this way be responsible for the induction and/or maintenance of the in situ autoimmune T cell response. Invariant chain (li) and HLA-DM molecules are implicated in the antigen processing and presentation by HLA class II molecules. We have investigated the expression of these molecules by TFC from GD glands. The results demonstrate that class II+ TFC from GD patients also express li and HLA-DM, and this expression is increased after IFN-gamma stimulation. The level of HLA-DM expression by TFC was low but sufficient to catalyze peptide loading into the HLA class II molecules and form stable HLA class II-peptide complexes expressed at the surface of TFC. These results have implications for the understanding of the possible role of HLA class II+ TFC in thyroid autoimmune disease.

Transcription of a broad range of self-antigens in human thymus suggests a role for central mechanisms in tolerance toward peripheral antigens

The role of the thymus in the induction of tolerance to peripheral antigens is not yet well defined. One impending question involves how the thymus can acquire the diversity of peripheral nonthymic self-Ags for the process of negative selection. To investigate whether peripheral Ags are synthesized in the thymus itself, we have determined the expression of a panel of circulating and cell-bound peripheral Ags, some of which are targets of autoimmune diseases, at the mRNA level in total thymic tissue and in its main cellular fractions. Normalized and calibrated RT-PCR experiments demonstrated the presence of transcripts of nonthymic self-Ags in human thymi from 8 days to 13-yr-old donors. Out of 12 glands, albumin transcripts were found in 12; insulin, glucagon, thyroid peroxidase, and glutamic acid decarboxylase (GAD)-67 in six, thyroglobulin in five, myelin basic protein and retinal S Ag in three, and GAD-65 in one. The levels of peripheral Ag transcripts detected were age-related but also showed marked interindividual differences. Cytokeratin-positive stromal epithelial cells, which are a likely cellular source for these, contained up to 200 transcript copies of the most expressed peripheral Ags per cell. These results implicate the human thymus in the expression of wide representation of peripheral self-Ags and support the view that the thymus is involved in the establishment of tolerance to peripheral Ags. The existence of such central mechanism of tolerance is crucial for the understanding of organ-specific autoimmune diseases.

Single-cell analysis of intrathyroidal lymphocytes shows differential cytokine expression in Hashimoto's and Graves' disease

Most human organ-specific autoimmune diseases such as Hashimoto's thyroiditis (HT) are considered to be Th1 mediated, and a quantitative dominance of Th1 cells in thyroid infiltrates from both Graves' disease (GD) and HT affected glands has been reported. However, Th2 dominance would be expected in GD, where thyroid hyperfunction induced by stimulating antibodies predominates over tissue destruction. We have analyzed the interleukin-4 (IL-4), interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) production by T cells at the single-cell level, both in infiltrating lymphocytes isolated from digested GD and HT thyroid glands and in derived T cell lines, by direct intracellular cytokine detection. Results showed a heterogeneous pattern of cytokine production in bulk GD infiltrates and derived T cell lines, and a similar pattern was observed in the much larger HT infiltrates. Both type 1 and type 2 cytokines were simultaneously produced by the infiltrating populations, and T cells with both patterns as well as intermediate patterns similar to Th0 cells could be detected ex vivo. However, the larger T lymphocytes, presumably activated and responsible for the autoimmune damage, predominantly produced IL-4 in GD and IFN-gamma in HT. The specificity of the Th2 responses in GD was suggested by the enrichment in IL-4 production after antigen-specific expansion of two oligoclonal T cell lines. These data show that both type 1 and type 2 cytokines are produced in the thyroid glands affected by autoimmunity and that the difference between diseases may be the effect of a functionally dominant population at a given time. This in vivo chronically activated antigen-specific population, producing type 1 or type 2 cytokines locally, may be responsible for the effect finally leading to one of the disease states.

Proteasome subunits, low-molecular-mass polypeptides 2 and 7 are hyperexpressed by target cells in autoimmune thyroid disease but not in insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus: implications for autoimmunity

Autoimmune thyroid diseases (AITD) and insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM) are two autoimmune syndromes of unknown etiology with common immune features. One is that the target cells, thyrocytes and pancreatic islet beta cells respectively, hyperexpress several proteins encoded in the HLA region: HLA class I, HLA class II and transporter associated with antigen processing (TAP-1): the clinical course and many aspects of the immunopathology are, however, quite different. Low-molecular-mass polypeptides 2 and 7 (LMP2 and LMP7) are proteasome subunits that increase the efficiency of endogenous antigen processing and are encoded in close vicinity to the TAP genes. We investigated whether LMP2 and LMP7 are hyperexpressed in thyrocytes and islet cells in AITD and IDDM. Thyroid tissue from Graves' disease patients (GD, n = 8) and Hashimoto thyroiditis (HT, n = 1) and pancreatic tissue from IDDM patients (n = 4) as well as control tissues were examined by the two-color indirect immunofluorescence technique. The results demonstrate that, in normal glands, thyrocytes and pancreatic islet cells express comparable moderate to low levels of LMP2 and LMP7. In AITD and IDDM, expression of LMP2/7 in the endocrine cells was disparate: while in AITD glands there was hyperexpression of LMP2 and 7 parallel to that of HLA class I and TAP-1, in the islet cells of recent onset diabetic pancreases (n = 2) the level of LMP2 and 7 expression was totally normal, including islets that were infiltrated by lymphocytes and hyperexpressed HLA class I and TAP-1. These observations suggest different mechanisms of endogenous peptides generation at the target cells in AITD from IDDM. Since this is a key step for the maintenance of peripheral tolerance, it may help to understand some of the different clinical features of the two autoimmune diseases.

Hyperexpression of transporter in antigen processing-1 (TAP-1) in thyroid glands affected by autoimmunity: a contributing factor to the breach of tolerance to thyroid antigens?

According to the 'aberrant HLA expression' hypothesis, endocrine autoimmunity is driven by presentation of self antigens by target cells over-expressing HLA molecules. In autoimmune thyroid diseases (AITD), thyroid follicular cells (thyrocytes) over-express HLA class I and HLA class II molecules. Since efficient presentation of endogenous peptides via class I requires transporters that translocate endogenous peptides from the cytoplasm to the endoplasmic reticulum, i.e. transporters associated with antigen processing (TAP) -1 and -2, the capability of thyrocytes to express TAP and whether TAP is hyperexpressed in AITD glands are issues relevant to the above hypothesis. Results from immunofluorescence and Northern blotting studies on primary thyrocyte cultures and on a thyroid cell line demonstrate that thyrocytes express constitutively TAP-1 at a low level, and that this expression is readily induced by interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) and to a lesser extent by IFN-alpha. In AITD, but not in non-autoimmune glands, thyrocytes hyperexpress TAP-1, as demonstrated by both immunohistopathology and flow cytometry. The cytokine pattern does not bear, as assessed by reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR), a clear relationship with TAP-1 expression. These results have broad implications and suggest that the core concept of the 'aberrant HLA expression' hypothesis of endocrine autoimmunity could be incorporated in the currently prevailing view of 'autoimmunity by breach of peripheral tolerance'.

Self-reactive cytotoxic gamma delta T lymphocytes in Graves' disease specifically recognize thyroid epithelial cells

In this paper we report the isolation of a self-reactive cytotoxic gamma delta T cell line, 158RE.2, that originates from the T lymphocyte population infiltrating the thyroid gland of a patient with Graves' disease. Functional data using this cell line demonstrate that gamma delta T cells expanded in the thyroid tissue specifically recognize a ligand expressed by thyroid epithelial cells and cell lines of endocrine epithelial origin. The TCR expressed by these gamma delta T cells--V gamma I/V delta 5--is unusual in peripheral blood lymphocytes, and its specificity is clearly different from that observed in a high percentage of gamma delta T cells from PBL, which express the common TCR V gamma 9/V delta 2. The V gamma I/V delta 5 receptor is involved in the recognition of the ligand expressed by the thyroid cells, but not in the NK-like activity also displayed by 158RE.2. These cells express CD8 alpha alpha dimers, which participate in the thyroid ligand recognition but not in the NK-like activity. The epithelial cell recognition is not restricted by classical MHC class I or class II molecules, although the CD8 alpha alpha participation in the recognition suggests the involvement of nonclassical MHC molecules. These are the first data to be presented on self-reacting gamma delta T cells in human epithelium.

Self-reactive cytotoxic gamma delta T lymphocytes in Graves' disease specifically recognize thyroid epithelial cells

In this paper we report the isolation of a self-reactive cytotoxic gamma delta T cell line, 158RE.2, that originates from the T lymphocyte population infiltrating the thyroid gland of a patient with Graves' disease. Functional data using this cell line demonstrate that gamma delta T cells expanded in the thyroid tissue specifically recognize a ligand expressed by thyroid epithelial cells and cell lines of endocrine epithelial origin. The TCR expressed by these gamma delta T cells--V gamma I/V delta 5--is unusual in peripheral blood lymphocytes, and its specificity is clearly different from that observed in a high percentage of gamma delta T cells from PBL, which express the common TCR V gamma 9/V delta 2. The V gamma I/V delta 5 receptor is involved in the recognition of the ligand expressed by the thyroid cells, but not in the NK-like activity also displayed by 158RE.2. These cells express CD8 alpha alpha dimers, which participate in the thyroid ligand recognition but not in the NK-like activity. The epithelial cell recognition is not restricted by classical MHC class I or class II molecules, although the CD8 alpha alpha participation in the recognition suggests the involvement of nonclassical MHC molecules. These are the first data to be presented on self-reacting gamma delta T cells in human epithelium.

Hyperinducibility of HLA class II expression of thyroid follicular cells from Graves' disease. A primary defect?

Thyroid follicular cells (thyrocytes) from Graves' disease (GD) patients' thyroid glands express HLA class II molecules "ectopically." This phenomenon has been attributed to induction by locally produced cytokines and may be relevant to disease pathogenesis. We have compared IFN-gamma-mediated induction of HLA class II in thyrocytes from glands affected with GD and a nonautoimmune disease (MNG), to investigate a possible differential regulation of HLA expression between these two pathologies. HLA induction has been measured in primary thyrocyte cultures and control autologous macrophages stimulated or not stimulated with IFN-gamma. Comparison of flow cytometric data using an improved algorithm demonstrated that expression of HLA class II molecules is more readily induced in thyrocytes from GD than from MNG thyroid glands. This higher inducibility was parallel to a faster and stronger induction of HLA class II message in GD thyrocytes but did not correlate with the levels of HLA class II or class I originally expressed by thyrocytes in the tissue or with the degree of lymphocytic infiltration of the gland. There was no association with a particular HLA class II allele or with the presence of IFN-gamma and IL-2 in the tissue, as assessed by reverse transcription-PCR. No differences in the induction of class II were found in macrophages from each group of patients. These results suggest that an intrinsic feature of thyrocytes from GD patients is an up-regulation of HLA class II expression and that this is a characteristic that may facilitate the triggering of autoimmunity to "hyperinducible" thyroid glands.

Hyperinducibility of HLA class II expression of thyroid follicular cells from Graves' disease. A primary defect?

Thyroid follicular cells (thyrocytes) from Graves' disease (GD) patients' thyroid glands express HLA class II molecules "ectopically." This phenomenon has been attributed to induction by locally produced cytokines and may be relevant to disease pathogenesis. We have compared IFN-gamma-mediated induction of HLA class II in thyrocytes from glands affected with GD and a nonautoimmune disease (MNG), to investigate a possible differential regulation of HLA expression between these two pathologies. HLA induction has been measured in primary thyrocyte cultures and control autologous macrophages stimulated or not stimulated with IFN-gamma. Comparison of flow cytometric data using an improved algorithm demonstrated that expression of HLA class II molecules is more readily induced in thyrocytes from GD than from MNG thyroid glands. This higher inducibility was parallel to a faster and stronger induction of HLA class II message in GD thyrocytes but did not correlate with the levels of HLA class II or class I originally expressed by thyrocytes in the tissue or with the degree of lymphocytic infiltration of the gland. There was no association with a particular HLA class II allele or with the presence of IFN-gamma and IL-2 in the tissue, as assessed by reverse transcription-PCR. No differences in the induction of class II were found in macrophages from each group of patients. These results suggest that an intrinsic feature of thyrocytes from GD patients is an up-regulation of HLA class II expression and that this is a characteristic that may facilitate the triggering of autoimmunity to "hyperinducible" thyroid glands.

Characterization of neural cell adhesion molecule (NCAM) expression in thyroid follicular cells: induction by cytokines and over-expression in autoimmune glands

NCAM (CD56) is a cell surface glycoprotein of the immunoglobulin superfamily expressed on neuroendocrine and natural killer (NK) cells which has considerable molecular heterogeneity due to differential splicing and post-translational modifications. NCAM has been detected in the thyroid follicular cells (thyrocytes) immunohistologically. We report here the molecular form, the modulation by cytokines and the levels of expression in thyroid pathology. By using a panel of MoAbs to NCAM on Western blots from thyrocyte extract we have determined that these cells express the 140- and 180-kD forms of NCAM. Exposure of primary cultures of thyrocytes to interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma), and even more, to the combination of IFN-gamma plus tumour necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-alpha) induced a clear increase in the expression of NCAM as assessed by FACS analysis. NCAM expression in thyrocytes was assessed by immunofluorescence in 59 surgical specimens of thyroid glands, and was found increased in 11/17 (64%) of Graves', in 5/25 (20%) of multinodular goitre (MNG) and in occasional adenoma glands. No correlation was found with the expression of HLA class I, class II or the degree of lymphocytic infiltration scored in adjacent sections, but it was often seen in areas infiltrated by macrophages. In conclusion, NCAM is an adhesion molecule whose expression is clearly increased in thyrocytes in autoimmune glands, probably as a consequence of exposure to cytokines locally released. Since one of the forms of NCAM expressed by thyrocytes has the capability to generate intracellular signal it may play a role in normal thyroid function. In addition, NCAM may facilitate the recognition of thyrocytes by lymphocytes, particularly by NK CD56+ lymphocytes.