Assessing fitness costs of the resistance of Spodoptera frugiperda (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae) to pyramided Cry1 and Cry2 insecticidal proteins on different host plants

Fall armyworm (FAW), Spodoptera frugiperda (Smith), is one of the major pests targeted by transgenic crops expressing insecticidal proteins from Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) Berliner. However, FAW presents a high capacity to develop resistance to Bt protein-expressing crop lines, as reported in Brazil, Argentina, Puerto Rico and the southeastern U.S. Here, FAW genotypes resistant to pyramided maize events expressing Cry1F/Cry1A.105/Cry2Ab2 (P-R genotype) and Cry1A.105/Cry2Ab2 (Y-R genotype) from Brazil were used to investigate the interactions between non-Bt hosts (non-Bt maize, non-Bt cotton, millet and sorghum) and fitness costs. We also tested a FAW genotype susceptible to Bt maize and F₁ hybrids of the resistant and susceptible genotypes (heterozygotes). Recessive fitness costs (i.e., costs affecting the resistant insects) were observed for pupal and neonate to adult survival of the P-R genotype on non-Bt cotton; larval developmental time of the P-R genotype on millet and sorghum; larval and neonate-to-adult developmental time of the Y-R genotype on non-Bt cotton and sorghum; the fecundity of the Y-R genotype on non-Bt cotton; and mean generation time of both resistant genotypes. However, on non-Bt cotton and non-Bt maize, the P-R genotype had a higher fitness (i.e., fitness benefits), displaying greater fecundity and rates of population increases than the Sus genotype. Non-recessive fitness costs (i.e., costs affecting heterozygotes) were found for fecundity and population increases on millet and sorghum. These findings suggest that, regardless of the disadvantages of the resistant genotypes in some hosts, the resistance of FAW to Cry1 and Cry2 Bt proteins is not linked with substantial fitness costs, and may persist in field conditions once present.

Transcriptome Analysis of Pyrethroid-Resistant Chrysodeixis includens (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae) Reveals Overexpression of Metabolic Detoxification Genes

Chrysodeixis includens (Walker, [1858]) is one of the most important defoliator of soybean in Brazil because of its extensive geographical distribution and high tolerance to insecticides compared with other species of caterpillars. Because of this, we conducted bioassays to evaluate the efficacy of pyrethroid λ-cyhalothrin on a C. includens resistant strain (MS) and a susceptible (LAB) laboratory strain. High throughput RNA sequencing (RNA-seq) of larval head and body tissues were performed to identify potential molecular mechanisms underlying pyrethroid resistance. Insecticide bioassays showed that MS larvae exhibit 28.9-fold resistance to pyrethroid λ-cyhalothrin relative to LAB larvae. RNA-seq identified evidence of metabolic resistance in the head and body tissues: 15 cytochrome P450 transcripts of Cyp6, Cyp9, Cyp4, Cyp304, Cyp307, Cyp337, Cyp321 families, 7 glutathione-S-transferase (Gst) genes, 7 α-esterase genes from intracellular and secreted catalytic classes, and 8 UDP-glucuronosyltransferase (Ugt) were overexpressed in MS as compared with LAB larvae. We also identified overexpression of GPCR genes (CiGPCR64-like and CiGPCRMth2) in the head tissue. To validate RNA-seq results, we performed RT-qPCR to assay selected metabolic genes and confirmed their expression profiles. Specifically, CiCYP9a101v1, CiCYP6ae149, CiCYP6ae106v2, CiGSTe13, CiCOE47, and CiUGT33F21 exhibited significant overexpression in resistant MS larvae. In summary, our findings detailed potential mechanisms of metabolic detoxification underlying pyrethroid resistance in C. includens.

Field-evolved resistance to chitin synthesis inhibitor insecticides by soybean looper, Chrysodeixis includens (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae), in Brazil

Soybean looper (SBL), Chrysodeixis includens (Walker), is an economically important soybean and cotton pest in Brazil. Here, we selected an SBL strain resistant to teflubenzuron using F2 screening, estimated the resistance allele frequency, characterized the inheritance of resistance, investigated fitness costs, evaluated patterns of cross-resistance, and determined the magnitude of resistance. The teflubenzuron-resistant strain (Teflu-R) was selected from field-collected populations with an estimated allele frequency of 0.1700. Estimated LC50 values were 0.010 and 363.61 μg a.i. cm-2 for the susceptible (Sus) and Teflu-R strains, respectively, representing a 36,361-fold resistance ratio (RR). The LC50 values of reciprocal crosses were 1.02 and 0.59 μg a.i. cm-2, suggesting that resistance is autosomally inherited. The low survival of reciprocal crosses (16 and 20%) on teflubenzuron-sprayed leaves indicates incomplete recessive resistance. The number of segregations influencing resistance was 2.72, suggesting a polygenic effect. The Teflu-R strain showed longer development periods as well as lower survival and population growth than the Sus strain, revealing fitness costs. The Teflu-R strain also showed high cross-resistancesto other chitin inhibitor insecticides, such as novaluron (RR = 6147-fold) and lufenuron (RR = 953-fold), but low cross-resistance to methoxyfenozide, flubendiamide, and indoxacarb (RR < 3.45-fold). On discriminatory concentrations of teflubenzuron and novaluron, populations of SBL showed survival rates from 15 to 52%, indicating field resistance to these insecticides. Our findings indicated that resistance to teflubenzuron in SBL is autosomal, recessive, polygenic, and associated with fitness cost. We also found a high cross-resistance to other benzoylphenylureas and a high frequency of resistance to this mode-of-action in SBL in Brazil.

Performance of Seed Treatments Applied on Bt and Non-Bt Maize Against Fall Armyworm (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae)

Fall armyworm (FAW), Spodoptera frugiperda (J. E. Smith), is the main pest of maize in Brazil, attacking plants from emergence to reproductive stages. Here, we conducted studies to evaluate the efficacy of two seed treatments (chlorantraniliprole alone and imidacloprid combined with thiodicarb) on Bt and non-Bt maize in laboratory bioassays with distinct FAW strains that are susceptible, selected for resistance to Bt-maize single (Cry1F) or pyramided (Cry1A.105 + Cry2Ab2) events and F1 hybrids of the selected and susceptible strains (heterozygotes), and in the field against a natural infestation. In the laboratory, leaf-discs from seed treated Bt-maize plants at 7 d after emergence (DAE) increased the mortality of FAW resistant, heterozygote, and susceptible strains up to 24.8%, when compared with the respective maize grown without a seed treatment. In the field against natural infestations of FAW, Bt maize with a seed treatment had ~30% less FAW damage than non-Bt maize with the same seed treatment at 7 and 14 DAE. No differences in FAW damage was observed between Bt and non-Bt maize grown with and without a seed treatment at 21 DAE. Maize seeds treated with chlorantraniliprole alone or imidacloprid and thiodicarb combined presented limited protection against early infestations of FAW strains under laboratory and field studies.

Laboratory and field survival of Spodoptera frugiperda (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae) on Bt and non-Bt maize and its susceptibility to insecticides

BACKGROUND

Field-evolved resistance of fall armyworm (FAW), Spodoptera frugiperda (Smith), has been reported to Bt maize technologies in Brazil. The control failures of FAW by Bt maize increased the use of insecticides for their control. However, no information is available on the interaction between resistant FAW and their response to insecticides. Here, we evaluated the survival of FAW strains on Bt and non-Bt maize in laboratory and field conditions, and their susceptibility to insecticides.

RESULTS

In the laboratory, resistant FAW larvae reared on Bt and non-Bt maize showed a similar susceptibility to spinetoram (LC₅₀  = 0.16-0.18 µg a.i. cm^-2 ) and chlorfenapyr (LC₅₀  = 0.17-0.20 µg a.i. cm^-2 ). However, their susceptibility was lower than that of the susceptible strain reared on non-Bt maize: LC₅₀  = 0.05 (spinetoram) and 0.08 (chlorfenapyr) µg a.i. cm^-2 . In contrast, heterozygous strains had similar susceptibility to the susceptible strain. In field trials, no differences in FAW survival were detected between strains when the commercial dose of two insecticides was applied in Bt and non-Bt maize.

CONCLUSION

FAW strains surviving on Bt and non-Bt maize, at the same development stage, have similar susceptibility to insecticides. The integrated pest management practices and insect resistance management importance of these results are discussed. © 2019 Society of Chemical Industry.

No cross-resistance between ChinNPV and chemical insecticides in Chrysodeixis includens (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae)

Chrysodeixis includens nucleopolyhedrovirus (ChinNPV: Baculoviridae: Alphabaculovirus) is an active ingredient of a biological-based insecticide (Chrysogen®) recommended against soybean looper (SBL), Chrysodeixis includens (Walker, [1858]), in soybean in Brazil. We investigated if SBL strains resistant to chemical insecticides are cross-resistant to the baculovirus ChinNPV. In droplet feeding bioassays, SBL strains resistant to lambda-cyhalothrin and teflubenzuron showed equivalent susceptibility to ChinNPV as heterozygous and susceptible strains, indicating no cross-resistance between ChinNPV and chemical insecticides in SBL. Therefore, the ChinNPV is a valuable new "mode-of-action" tool for SBL resistance management in Brazil.

Susceptibility of Brazilian Populations of Chrysodeixis includens (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae) to Selected Insecticides

Soybean looper (SBL), Chrysodeixis includens (Walker) (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae), is an important pest of soybean and cotton in Brazil. The use of insecticides is one of the main control tactics against this pest. To support Integrated Pest Management (IPM) and Insect Resistance Management (IRM) programs, we characterized the susceptibility of Brazilian populations of SBL to insecticides. Field populations were collected from soybean fields during the 2016-2017 and 2017-2018 crop seasons. In the laboratory, late L2/early L3 larvae were exposed to insecticides in diet-overlay or topical bioassays. Field populations of SBL showed high susceptibility to spinetoram (LC50 = 0.074-0.25 μg a.i. per cm2), indoxacarb (LC50 = 0.46-0.94 μg a.i. per cm2), thiodicarb (LC50 = 9.14-36.61 μg a.i. per cm2), chlorantraniliprole (LC50 = 0.15-0.57 μg a.i. per cm2), flubendiamide (LC50 = 0.45-2.01 μg a.i. per cm2), and chlorfenapyr (LC50 = 0.15-0.25 μg a.i. per cm2); the resistance ratios were less than 16-fold. In contrast, SBL populations have reduced susceptibility to lambda-cyhalothrin (LC50 = 3.71-9.54 μg a.i./cm2), methoxyfenozide (LC50 = 0.67-4.23 μg a.i. per cm2), novaluron (LC50 = 27.52-77.63 μg a.i. per cm2), and teflubenzuron (LC50 = 13.41-73.02 μg a.i. per cm2). The resistance ratios relative to a Lab population (susceptible of reference) was up to 38-, 63-, 1,553-, and 5,215-fold, respectively. These high resistance ratios can be associated with resistance evolution. Implications of these findings to IPM and IRM programs are discussed.

Baseline Susceptibility of Brazilian Populations of Chrysodeixis includens (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae) to C. includens Nucleopolyhedrovirus and Diagnostic Concentration for Resistance Monitoring

The Chrysodeixis includens nucleopolyhedrovirus (ChinNPV: Baculoviridae: Alphabaculovirus) is a registered insecticide for the management of soybean looper, Chrysodeixis includens (Walker, [1858]) in Brazil. We conducted studies of baseline susceptibility of Brazilian populations of C. includens to the ChinNPV (Chrysogen, AgBiTech, Fort Worth, TX) as valuable knowledge in support of Integrated Pest Management and Insect Resistance Management programs. In bioassays, neonates were infected with different concentrations of ChinNPV using the droplet feeding bioassay method. Larvae were then transferred to artificial diet and mortality was assessed at 7 d. Results confirm that neonates from Brazilian populations of C. includens are susceptible to ChinNPV. Concentrations from 1.0 × 103 to 1.0 × 108 occlusion bodies (OBs) per ml caused mortality from 1.5 to 99%, respectively. The LC50 ranged from 1.4 × 105 to 7.7 × 105 OBs per ml for populations of C. includens (5.5-fold variation). Similar variation was detected for the LC90 which ranged from 1.6 × 107 to 7.7 × 107 OBs per ml (4.8-fold variation). Importantly, the field-collected populations showed equivalent susceptibility to the reference susceptible population. This indicates a low interpopulation variation in susceptibility of Brazilian populations of C. includens to ChinNPV, representing natural geographic variation and not variation caused by previous selection pressure. The candidate diagnostic concentration of 2.9 × 108 OBs per ml was estimated based on the pooled data and caused mortality ranging from 98.6 to 100%. This concentration will be used in proactive resistance monitoring programs. The Chrysogen will be a valuable tool as a new mode of action in C. includens resistance management in Brazil.