Quality of the Information provided by ChatGPT for Patients in Breast Plastic Surgery: Are we already in the future?

Introduction

In recent years, artificial intelligence (AI) has gained popularity, even in the field of plastic surgery. It is increasingly common for patients to use the internet to gather information about plastic surgery, and AI-based chatbots, such as ChatGPT, could be employed to answer patients' questions.The aim of this study was to evaluate the quality of medical information provided by ChatGPT regarding three of the most common procedures in breast plastic surgery: breast reconstruction, breast reduction, and augmentation mammaplasty.

Methods

The quality of information was evaluated through the expanded EQIP scale. Responses were collected from a pool made by ten resident doctors in plastic surgery and then processed by SPSS software ver. 28.0.

Results

The analysis of the contents provided by ChatGPT revealed sufficient quality of information across all selected topics, with a high bias in terms of distribution of the score between the different items. There was a critical lack in the "Information data field" (0/6 score in all the 3 investigations) but a very high overall evaluation concerning the "Structure data" (>7/11 in all the 3 investigations).

Conclusion

Currently, AI serves as a valuable tool for patients; however, engineers and developers must address certain critical issues. It is possible that models like ChatGPT will play an important role in improving patient's consciousness about medical procedures and surgical interventions in the future, but their role must be considered ancillary to that of surgeons.

Clinical pathological correlates of renal biopsy in elderly patients

BACKGROUND

Reports have shown that well-defined histological patterns do not always correspond to equally clear clinical pictures, particularly so in elderly patients.

METHODS

With the aim of assessing clinicopathological correlations in the population aged >65 years with that of lower age, we retrospectively analyzed computerized records of renal needle biopsies consecutively performed in the decade 1991-2000 in our unit.

RESULTS

Among the 392 eligible subjects, there were 150 patients 65 years of age and more, 76 of whom were over 70. The average serum creatinine was 2.9 mg/dl, with values > 3.5 mg/dl in 25% of cases. The major indication to biopsy was nephrotic syndrome followed by chronic renal failure both in the young adult and the elderly population. The rapidly progressive form led more often to renal biopsy in the elderly patients, and the different prevalence was statistically significant (p < 0.05), as was the higher prevalence of urinary anomalies in the young-adult population. Regarding renal histology, the crescentic necrotizing forms were significantly more frequent in the elderly patients, while IgAN, minimal change disease and SLE predominate in young adults. The most relevant result is the greater prevalence of crescentic necrotizing glomerulonephritis in elderly patients, not only in the cases presenting clinically as rapidly progressive renal failure and acute renal failure, but also in those with the clinical picture of chronic renal failure.

CONCLUSIONS

Re-evaluation of our case files verifies the importance of the bioptic approach in selected cases with stages 3-4 chronic kidney damage. This holds true especially for elderly patients.

Nutritional and prognostic correlates of bioimpedance indexes in hemodialysis patients

We carried out a cross sectional and longitudinal study to assess whether bioimpedance indexes (resistance, Rz; reactance, Xc; phase angle, PA) reflect the nutritional status of hemodialysis (HD) patients, and bear a significant association with their long-term survival. The bioimpedance data of 131 patients on chronic HD treatment were compared with those of 272 healthy controls matched for age and sex. Nutritional status was assessed by anthropometric variables, serum albumin (SA), normalized protein catabolic rate (nPCR), and subjective global assessment (SGA). All three bioimpedance indexes varied significantly with HD treatment, however, with the exception of Xc in post-HD, they were on average significantly (P < 0.016) different from controls either pre- and post-HD. Post-HD PA appeared to be the best index of nutritional status, being significantly correlated with SA, age, mid arm muscle circumference (MAMC), SGA, and nPCR (R2 = 0.44; P < 0.01). However, depending on the cut-off levels, PA failed to detect clinically overt malnutrition in one to two thirds of the patients with the worst SGA score. During the follow-up the changes in bioimpedance indexes reflected poorly the changes in dry blood weight, only delta Rz bore a significant correlation (r = 0.29; P < 0.01) with delta body wt. Patients having baseline phase angle values within the lower quartile had a significantly lower two-year survival rate than patients having higher values (59.3% vs. 91.3%; P < 0.01). Cox's analysis (proportional hazard model) showed that phase angle as a predictor of death outweighed all other parameters included in the model (age, SA, nPCR, MAMC, SGA), with a relative risk of 2.6 (95% CI = 1.6 to 4.2). Bioimpedance indexes do not appear to be reliable in detecting clinically overt depletion of lean body mass. However, the strong association of PA with patient survival suggests that this bioimpedance index reflects some dimension of the illness, which is not fully identifiable with the deranged nutritional status.

Evaluation of body composition during low-dose estrogen oral contraceptives treatment

OBJECTIVE

To determine in a prospective study if the use of two low-dose estrogen oral contraceptives is associated with changes in weight or body composition.

DESIGN

80 outpatients referring to the family planning service, aged 18-43 years were randomly assigned to a treatment with the EE/desogestrel or EE/gestodene association, 20 patients with IUD, aged 26-40 years, were selected as a control group. Anthropometric data and body composition were taken at enrollment and after 6 and 12 months.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Anthropometric measurements included body mass index (BMI), body composition estimated by mean of Bioelectrical Impendance Analysis (BIA).

RESULTS

In the three groups weight, BMI, and total body water (TBW), and body cellular mass (BCM) remained unchanged during the study period.

CONCLUSIONS

The use of EE/desogestrel and EE/gestodene is not associated with significant variations of body weight and body composition during one year treatment.

Hepatitis B vaccination in dialysis patients and nutritional status

35 dialysis patients underwent anti-HBV vaccination. We classified patients in responders or non-responders using an anti-HBs titer of 50 UI/l as the discriminating serum level and tried to assess whether the antibody response bears any relationship with the nutritional status. 26 patients (74%) reached the target atb titer, which was maintained during follow-up (average 360 UI/l). The weak response in the other 9, with values never exceeding 20 UI/l, was short-lived. Anthropometric and impedenziometric parameters were higher in responders than in nonresponders, but the difference did not reach statistical significance. We conclude that the atb titer which discriminates uremics in responders or not must be greater than 50 UI/l and that the nutritional status may interfere with the seroconversion rate, but this conclusion needs to be validated in a wider population.