Building a framework to decolonize global emergency medicine

Background

Global emergency medicine (GEM) is situated at the intersection of global health and emergency medicine (EM), which is built upon a history of colonial systems and institutions that continue to reinforce inequities between high-income countries (HICs) and low- and middle-income countries (LMICs) today. These power imbalances yield disparities in GEM practice, research, and education.

Approach

The Global Emergency Medicine Academy (GEMA) of the Society for Academic Emergency Medicine formed the Decolonizing GEM Working Group in 2020, which now includes over 100 worldwide members. The mission is to address colonial legacies in GEM and catalyze sustainable changes and recommendations toward decolonization at individual and institutional levels. To develop recommendations to decolonize GEM, the group conducted a nonsystematic review of existing literature on decolonizing global health, followed by in-depth discussions between academics from LMICs and HICs to explore implications and challenges specific to GEM. We then synthesized actionable solutions to provide recommendations on decolonizing GEM.

Results

Despite the rapidly expanding body of literature on decolonizing global health, there is little guidance specific to the relatively new field of GEM. By applying decolonizing principles to GEM, we suggest key priorities for improving equity in academic GEM: (1) reframing partnerships to place LMIC academics in positions of expertise and power, (2) redirecting research funding toward LMIC-driven projects and investigators, (3) creating more equitable practices in establishing authorship, and (4) upholding principles of decolonization in the education of EM trainees from LMICs and HICs.

Conclusions

Understanding the colonial roots of GEM will allow us to look more critically at current health disparities and identify inequitable institutionalized practices within our profession that continue to uphold these misguided concepts. A decolonized future of GEM depends on our recognition and rectification of colonial-era practices that shape structural determinants of health care delivery and scientific advancement.

Implementation and outcomes of a comprehensive emergency care curriculum at a low-resource referral hospital in Liberia: A novel approach to application of the WHO Basic Emergency Care toolkit

BACKGROUND

Emergency care is vital in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs) but many frontline healthcare workers in low-resource settings have no formal training in emergency care. To address this gap, the World Health Organization (WHO) developed Basic Emergency Care (BEC): Approach to the acutely ill and injured, a multi-day, open-source course for healthcare workers in low-resource settings. Building on the BEC foundation, this study uses an implementation science (IS) lens to develop, implement, and evaluate a comprehensive emergency care curriculum in a single emergency facility in Liberia.

METHODS

A six-month emergency care curriculum consisting of BEC content, standardized WHO clinical documentation forms, African Federation of Emergency Medicine (AFEM) didactics, and clinical mentorship by visiting emergency medicine (EM) faculty was designed and implemented using IS frameworks at Redemption Hospital, a low-resource public referral hospital in Monrovia, the capital of Liberia. Healthcare worker performance on validated knowledge-based exams during pre- and post-intervention testing, post-course surveys, and patient outcomes were used to evaluate the program.

RESULTS

Nine visiting EM physicians provided 1400 hours of clinical mentorship and 560 hours of didactic training to fifty-six Redemption Hospital staff over six-months. Median test scores improved 20.0% (p<0.001) among the forty-three healthcare workers who took both the pre- and post-intervention tests. Participants reported increased confidence in caring for medical and trauma patients and comfort performing emergency care tasks on post-course surveys. Emergency unit (EU)/Isolation unit (IU) mortality decreased during the six-month implementation period, albeit non-significantly. Course satisfaction was high across multiple domains.

DISCUSSION

This study builds on prior research supporting WHO efforts to improve emergency care globally. BEC implementation over a six-month timeframe using IS principles is an effective alternative strategy for facilities in resource-constrained environments wishing to strengthen emergency care delivery.

Measuring quality of pre-hospital traumatic shock care-development and validation of an instrument for resource-limited settings

BACKGROUND AND AIMS

Improving the quality of pre-hospital traumatic shock care, especially in low- and middle-income countries, is particularly relevant to reducing the large global burden of disease from injury. What clinical interventions represent high-quality care is an actively evolving field and often dependent on the specific injury pattern. A key component of improving the quality of care is having a consistent way to assess and measure the quality of shock care in the pre-hospital setting. The objective of this study was to develop and validate a chart abstraction instrument to measure the quality of trauma care in a resource-limited, pre-hospital emergency care setting.

METHODS

Traumatic shock was selected as the tracer condition. The pre-hospital quality of traumatic shock care (QTSC) instrument was developed and validated in three phases. A content development phase utilized a rapid literature review and expert consensus to yield the contents of the draft instrument. In the instrument validation phase, the QTSC instrument was created and underwent end user and content validation. A pilot-testing phase collected user feedback and performance characteristics to iteratively refine draft versions into a final instrument. Accuracy and inter- and intra-rater agreement were calculated.

RESULTS

The final QTSC instrument contains 10 domains of quality, each with specific criteria that determine how the domain is measured and the level of quality of care rendered. The instrument is over 90% accurate and has good inter- and intra-rater reliability when used by trained pre-hospital provider users in South Africa. Pre-hospital provider user feedback indicates the tool is easy to learn and quick to use.

CONCLUSION

We created and validated a novel chart abstraction instrument that can reliably and accurately measure the quality of pre-hospital traumatic shock care. We provide a systematic methodology for developing and validating a quality of care tool for resource-limited care settings.

Using the South African Triage Scale for prehospital triage: a qualitative study

Background

Triage is a critical component of prehospital emergency care. Effective triage of patients allows them to receive appropriate care and to judiciously use personnel and hospital resources. In many low-resource settings prehospital triage serves an additional role of determining the level of destination facility. In South Africa, the Western Cape Government innovatively implemented the South African Triage Scale (SATS) in the public Emergency Medical Services (EMS) service in 2012. The prehospital provider perspectives and experiences of using SATS in the field have not been previously studied.

Methods

In this qualitative study, focus group discussions with cohorts of basic, intermediate and advanced life support prehospital providers were conducted and transcribed. A content analysis using an inductive approach was used to code transcripts and identify themes.

Results

15 EMS providers participated in three focus group discussions. Data saturation was reached and four major themes emerged from the qualitative analysis: Implementation and use of SATS; Effectiveness of SATS; Limitations of the discriminator; and Special EMS considerations. Participants overall felt that SATS was easy to use and allowed improved communication with hospital providers during patient handover. Participants, however, described many clinical cases when their clinical gestalt triaged the patient to a different clinical acuity than generated by SATS. Additionally, they stated many clinical discriminators were too subjective to effectively apply or covered too broad a range of clinical severity (e.g., ingestions). Participants provided examples of how the prehospital environment presents additional challenges to using SATS such as changing patient clinical conditions, transport times and social needs of patients.

Conclusions

Overall, participants felt that SATS was an effective tool in prehospital emergency care. However, they described many clinical scenarios where SATS was in conflict with their own assessment, the clinical care needs of the patient or the available prehospital and hospital resources. Many of the identified challenges to using SATS in the prehospital environment could be improved with small changes to SATS and provider re-training.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12873-021-00522-3.

Validity and reliability of the South African Triage Scale in prehospital providers

Background

The South African Triage Scale (SATS) is a validated in-hospital triage tool that has been innovatively adopted for use in the prehospital setting by Western Cape Government (WCG) Emergency Medical Services (EMS) in South Africa. The performance of SATS by EMS providers has not been formally assessed. The study sought to assess the validity and reliability of SATS when used by WCG EMS prehospital providers for single-patient triage.

Methods

This is a prospective, assessment-based validation study among WCG EMS providers from March to September 2017 in Cape Town, South Africa. Participants completed an assessment containing 50 clinical vignettes by calculating the three components — triage early warning score (TEWS), discriminators (pre-defined clinical conditions), and a final SATS triage color. Responses were scored against gold standard answers. Validity was assessed by calculating over- and under-triage rates compared to gold standard. Inter-rater reliability was assessed by calculating agreement among EMS providers’ responses.

Results

A total of 102 EMS providers completed the assessment. The final SATS triage color was accurately determined in 56.5%, under-triaged in 29.5%, and over-triaged in 13.1% of vignette responses. TEWS was calculated correctly in 42.6% of vignettes, under-calculated in 45.0% and over-calculated in 10.9%. Discriminators were correctly identified in only 58.8% of vignettes. There was substantial inter-rater and gold standard agreement for both the TEWS component and final SATS color, but there was lower inter-rater agreement for clinical discriminators.

Conclusion

This is the first assessment of SATS as used by EMS providers for prehospital triage. We found that SATS generally under-performed as a triage tool, mainly due to the clinical discriminators. We found good inter-rater reliability, but poor validity. The under-triage rate of 30% was higher than previous reports from the in-hospital setting. The over-triage rate of 13% was acceptable. Further clinically-based and qualitative studies are needed.

Trial registration

Not applicable.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12873-021-00406-6.

Cost-effectiveness of emergency care interventions in low and middle-income countries: a systematic review

OBJECTIVE

To systematically review and appraise the quality of cost-effectiveness analyses of emergency care interventions in low- and middle-income countries.

METHODS

Following the PRISMA guidelines, we systematically searched PubMed®, Scopus, EMBASE®, Cochrane Library and Web of Science for studies published before May 2019. Inclusion criteria were: (i) an original cost-effectiveness analysis of emergency care intervention or intervention package, and (ii) the analysis occurred in a low- and middle-income setting. To identify additional primary studies, we hand searched the reference lists of included studies. We used the Consolidated Health Economic Evaluation Reporting Standards guideline to appraise the quality of included studies.

RESULTS

Of the 1674 articles we identified, 35 articles met the inclusion criteria. We identified an additional four studies from the reference lists. We excluded many studies for being deemed costing assessments without an effectiveness analysis. Most included studies were single-intervention analyses. Emergency care interventions evaluated by included studies covered prehospital services, provider training, treatment interventions, emergency diagnostic tools and facilities and packages of care. The reporting quality of the studies varied.

CONCLUSION

We found large gaps in the evidence surrounding the cost-effectiveness of emergency care interventions in low- and middle-income settings. Given the breadth of interventions currently in practice, many interventions remain unassessed, suggesting the need for future research to aid resource allocation decisions. In particular, packages of multiple interventions and system-level changes represent a priority area for future research.

Conversion of the severe to the moderate disease phenotype with donor leukocyte microchimerism in canine leukocyte adhesion deficiency

Leukocyte adhesion deficiency-1 (LAD-1), a genetic immunodeficiency disease characterized by life-threatening bacterial infections, results from the defective adherence and migration of leukocytes due to mutations in the leukocyte integrin CD18 molecule. Canine LAD (CLAD) represents the canine homologue of the severe phenotype of LAD-1 in children. In previous studies we demonstrated that non-myeloablative stem cell transplantation from matched littermates resulted in mixed donor-host chimerism and reversal of the disease phenotype in CLAD. In this study, we describe two CLAD dogs with less than 2% donor leukocyte chimerism following non-myeloablative transplant. Both dogs are alive more than 24 months after transplant with an attenuated CLAD phenotype resembling the moderate deficiency phenotype of LAD. The improvement in the CLAD phenotype with very low levels of donor CD18(+) leukocytes correlated with the preferential egress of the CD18(+) neutrophils into extravascular sites. The clinical response with very low levels of donor CD18(+) leukocytes in CLAD supports using this model for testing gene therapy strategies since the low levels of gene-corrected hematopoietic cells expected with hematopoietic gene therapy would likely have a therapeutic effect in CLAD.

Sarcomere number adaptation after retinaculum transection in adult mice

Skeletal muscle has been shown to adjust serial sarcomere number in response to chronic static length changes. However, the adaptive responses to alterations in the dynamic environment are less well defined. The adaptations of the adult mouse tibialis anterior (TA) muscle to altered length and excursion were investigated by surgical transection of the flexor retinaculum. TA moment arm and muscle excursion increased by 38&plusmn;7 % (mean &plusmn; s.e.m.) and fully extended (plantarflexed) muscle length was decreased by 8 % after flexor retinaculum transection. In spite of the significant shortening of the muscle in full plantar- and dorsiflexion, serial sarcomere number decreased by 10&plusmn;1 % after 2 weeks of recovery. Gait analysis of these transected animals revealed a 14&plusmn;3 % decrease in dorsiflexion angular velocity after transection. The decrease in angular velocity was less than the increase in moment arm and, as a result, muscle velocity was calculated to increase by 20&plusmn;4 %. These data suggested that the muscle adapted in response to the underlying change in length, irrespective of the altered excursion or velocity.

Initial stability of a modular uncemented, porous-coated femoral stem: a mechanical study

A versatile modular hip system was used to evaluate the initial stability of a cementless femoral stem in anatomically consistent composite bones. Four implant bone configurations of varying proximal and distal fit/fill were tested. The implanted femurs were tested on an Instron 1331 materials testing machine in neutral loading and flexion loading; both translational micromotions and rotations of the implant relative to the bone were recorded on all three axes of motion, accounting for all 6 degrees of freedom of joint motion. Implants were then sectioned, and both endosteal canal fit and intramedullary canal fill were measured. Results indicate that (1) loading the implant in flexion by out-of-plane forces significantly increases both relative translation and rotation at the interface, (2) increasing the proximal fit reduces implant rotation about its longitudinal axis in flexion loading and (3) increasing the distal canal fit and fill increases prosthesis rotation about its longitudinal axis in flexion loading. These results indicate that the femoral stem is more unstable in out-of-plane loading, such as during stair climbing, and that increasing the proximal fit may enhance the initial rotational stability of an uncemented femoral stem.

A genetic comparison of behavioral actions of ethanol and nicotine in the mirrored chamber

Human alcoholics are almost invariably heavy users of tobacco, perhaps because both ethanol and nicotine may have anxiolytic activity. However, studies in humans have not uniformly detected anxiolytic effects because significant individual differences in anxiolytic actions of these agents seem to exist. One factor that seems to contribute to these individual differences is tolerance to ethanol. Individuals who are more sensitive to depressant actions of alcohol seem to show anxiolytic actions more readily. Consequently, we examined the relative sensitivities of the ethanol-sensitive (to the anesthetic actions of ethanol) long-sleep (LS) and ethanol-resistant short-sleep (SS) mouse lines to diazepam, ethanol, nicotine, and ethanol-nicotine combinations in the mirrored chamber test. This test measures approach-conflict behavior. Ethanol and nicotine evoked changes in mirrored chamber activities that resembled those elicited by diazepam. These effects were seen at doses that did not markedly affect locomotor activity, thereby suggesting that these changes in behavior represent anxiolytic actions. The LS-SS mice did not differ in sensitivity to diazepam, but the SS were more uniformly responsive to the other drugs. Only the SS showed clear evidence for interactions between ethanol and nicotine. If the changes in mirrored chamber behavior elicited by ethanol, nicotine, and combinations of the two drugs occur because of anxiety reduction, it seems that the SS mouse line is more responsive to anxiolytic actions of these drugs.

Baroreflex responses to the stress of severe hemorrhage in the rat

In two groups of anesthetized (sodium pentobarbital), mature Sprague-Dawley rats, 1) aged 2 years and weighing 300-400 grams, 2) aged 6 months weighing 200-300 grams, baroreflex-induced circulatory responses to pressor (graded doses phenylephrine) and depressor (graded doses nitroglycerine) agents were compared to those occurring during progressive hemorrhage in the same animals. Graded withdrawals of blood from the femoral artery elicited progressive hypotension accompanied by bradycardia rather than expected tachycardia. Graded doses of phenylephrine (2.5 ug to 40 ug bolus, via femoral vein) regularly induced elevations in arterial blood pressure with associated reflex bradycardia. Similarly graded doses of nitroglycerine induced a marked decline in arterial blood pressure, without expected tachycardia. As hypotension became more severe (during hemorrhage), atrioventricular conduction slowed and A-V block developed, resulting in statistically greater slowing in ventricular than in atrial excitation and contractile cycles. Heart failure during hemorrhage in the rat is characterized sequentially by severe bradycardia, depressed atrial contractile force, impaired conduction and A-V block, terminating in ventricular, atrial, and finally, in pacemaker failure. Baroreceptor reflexes were blunted or even absent in both young and old animals during induced hypotension.

Gross and microscopic anatomy of the vagal innervation of the rat heart

Intrinsic cardiac ganglia and their vagal innervation are described from gross and microscopic dissections and functional studies in the anesthetized, open-chest, adult rat. Dissecting microscope sketches of the ventral and dorsal aspects of the rat heart provide gross descriptions of the anatomical course of the vagal cardiac nerves. Histological sectioning of adipose tissue packets surrounding the terminal endings of vagal branches distributed to the roots of the great cardiac vessels (aorta, pulmonary artery, precaval veins) revealed clusters of autonomic ganglia. These packets or "fat pads" were located: (1) along the dorsal surface of the right precava and extending medially toward the aortic root, (2) deep to the aortic arch, (3) in the angle between the root of the left precava and the pulmonary artery on the superior-dorsal surface of the left atrium, and (4) in the rostro-dorsal interatrial septum. Vagal distributions of small terminal branches were traced to each of these pads, which contained numerous autonomic ganglia. Electrical excitation of right or left cervical vagus elicited varying degrees of sinus slowing, slowing of A-V conduction, and suppression in atrial contractile force. Very small quantities (0.5 mg in 10 microliters saline) of the ganglionic blocking agent, hexamethonium (C6) were injected selectively into a single fat pad, followed by repetition of right or left vagal stimulation, with careful analysis of changes in heart rate (paced and unpaced), A-V conduction, and contractile force.