Effect of blinding and unmasking on the quality of peer review

The objectives of this study were to see whether, in the opinion of authors, blinding or unmasking or a combination of the two affects the quality of reviews and to compare authors' and editors' assessments. In a trial conducted in the British Medical Journal, 527 consecutive manuscripts were randomized into one of three groups, and each was sent to two reviewers, who were randomized to receive a blinded or an unblinded copy of the manuscript. Review quality was assessed by two editors and the corresponding author. There was no significant difference in assessment between groups or between editors and authors. Reviews recommending publication were scored more highly than those recommending rejection.

Platelet indices during normal pregnancy and pre-eclampsia

Platelet count and mean platelet volume (MPV) were estimated in 349 normal pregnancies at various gestational stages, and in 30 cases of pre-eclampsia. A probability plot was constructed from these data using discriminant analysis of MPV versus platelet count for the pre-eclamptic versus normal pregnancies. The sensitivity for pre-eclampsia was 90% (27/30) and the specificity was 83.3%. This plot may be of use in confirming risk of pre-eclampsia.

Effect of nappy liners on temperature stability in very preterm infants

OBJECTIVE

To determine whether absorbent liners used in posturally supportive cloth nappies influence temperature stability in infants < 31 weeks gestation.

METHODOLOGY

Randomized cross-over trial conducted at King Edward Memorial Hospital for Women, Perth, Western Australia. Twenty-three infants nursed in incubators on Infant Servo Control were randomly assigned to wear cloth postural support nappies alternately with or without absorbent liners for 24-h periods over 4 days. Measurements of skin and incubator temperatures were recorded hourly. Times of all nappy changes and infant handling procedures were also recorded.

RESULTS

There was no change in any temperature measurement over time, between days, or between day/night periods. Infants nursed with the liner demonstrated a higher skin temperature (0.04 degrees C), and a lower incubator temperature (1.05 degrees C). A drop in skin temperature of 0.02 degrees C and an increase in incubator temperature of 0.28 degrees C occurred following handling of infants. There was no effect due to sex, gestational age, or actual age of the infants.

CONCLUSION

Use of an absorbent liner within a cloth postural support nappy promotes better temperature regulation in infants < 31 weeks gestation, by reducing incubator temperature and increasing skin temperature.

Risk factors for treatment failure after melarsoprol for Trypanosoma brucei gambiense trypanosomiasis in Uganda

We evaluated the treatment failure rate among late-stage human African trypanosomiasis (HAT) patients treated with melarsoprol in Arua, northern Uganda, between September 1995 and August 1996, and identified the risk factors for treatment failure. We conducted a retrospective cohort study in October 1998, and performed a survival analysis. A treatment failure was defined as a late-stage HAT patient fully treated with melarsoprol and classified as an HAT case at any follow-up visit within 2 years after treatment. Among 428 patients treated in the study period, 130 (30.4%) were identified as treatment failure within 2 years after discharge. The multivariate analysis showed that patients who experienced treatment failure after melarsoprol were more likely to have been admitted as a relapsing case (relative hazard, RH = 11.15 [6.34-19.61]), and to have been diagnosed with trypanosomes in the lymph nodes (RH = 3.19 [2.10-4.83]) or in the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) (RH = 1.66 [1.09-2.53]). The risk of treatment failure also increased with the number of cells in the CSF. The treatment failure rate after melarsoprol observed in Arua is greatly above the expected figures of 3-9%. More research is needed to confirm whether it is related to the variation of melarsoprol pharmacokinetics between individuals, or if it is associated with a reduced susceptibility of the trypanosomes to melarsoprol. The study emphasizes the need for second-line drugs to treat patients that have already received one or several full course(s) of melarsoprol.

Implementation of the ANA report card

A major challenge in healthcare today is measuring the quality of care. To explore nursing's contribution to patients in acute care settings, the American Nurses Association commissioned the development of the "Nursing Report Card." This study explored whether these report card indicators capture quality care. The convenience sample comprised 1,500 patients and 300 nurses from 16 units at an academic medical center. Using regression analysis, the most consistent predictor of outcome indicators was the percentage of RNs of the total staff.

Requirement of a novel gene, Xin, in cardiac morphogenesis

A novel gene, Xin, from chick (cXin) and mouse (mXin) embryonic hearts, may be required for cardiac morphogenesis and looping. Both cloned cDNAs have a single open reading frame, encoding proteins with 2,562 and 1,677 amino acids for cXin and mXin, respectively. The derived amino acid sequences share 46% similarity. The overall domain structures of the predicted cXin and mXin proteins, including proline-rich regions, 16 amino acid repeats, DNA-binding domains, SH3-binding motifs and nuclear localization signals, are highly conserved. Northern blot analyses detect a single message of 8.9 and 5.8 kilo base (kb) from both cardiac and skeletal muscle of chick and mouse, respectively. In situ hybridization reveals that the cXin gene is specifically expressed in cardiac progenitor cells of chick embryos as early as stage 8, prior to heart tube formation. cXin continues to be expressed in the myocardium of developing hearts. By stage 15, cXin expression is also detected in the myotomes of developing somites. Immunofluorescence microscopy reveals that the mXin protein is colocalized with N-cadherin and connexin-43 in the intercalated discs of adult mouse hearts. Incubation of stage 6 chick embryos with cXin antisense oligonucleotides results in abnormal cardiac morphogenesis and an alteration of cardiac looping. The myocardium of the affected hearts becomes thickened and tends to form multiple invaginations into the heart cavity. This abnormal cellular process may account in part for the abnormal looping. cXin expression can be induced by bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) in explants of anterior medial mesoendoderm from stage 6 chick embryos, a tissue that is normally non-cardiogenic. This induction occurs following the BMP-mediated induction of two cardiac-restricted transcription factors, Nkx2.5 and MEF2C. Furthermore, either MEF2C or Nkx2.5 can transactivate a luciferase reporter driven by the mXin promoter in mouse fibroblasts. These results suggest that Xin may participate in a BMP-Nkx2.5-MEF2C pathway to control cardiac morphogenesis and looping.

Effect of open peer review on quality of reviews and on reviewers' recommendations: a randomised trial

OBJECTIVES

To examine the effect on peer review of asking reviewers to have their identity revealed to the authors of the paper.

DESIGN

Randomised trial. Consecutive eligible papers were sent to two reviewers who were randomised to have their identity revealed to the authors or to remain anonymous. Editors and authors were blind to the intervention.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

The quality of the reviews was independently rated by two editors and the corresponding author using a validated instrument. Additional outcomes were the time taken to complete the review and the recommendation regarding publication. A questionnaire survey was undertaken of the authors of a cohort of manuscripts submitted for publication to find out their views on open peer review.

RESULTS

Two editors' assessments were obtained for 113 out of 125 manuscripts, and the corresponding author's assessment was obtained for 105. Reviewers randomised to be asked to be identified were 12% (95% confidence interval 0.2% to 24%) more likely to decline to review than reviewers randomised to remain anonymous (35% v 23%). There was no significant difference in quality (scored on a scale of 1 to 5) between anonymous reviewers (3.06 (SD 0.72)) and identified reviewers (3.09 (0.68)) (P=0.68, 95% confidence interval for difference - 0.19 to 0.12), and no significant difference in the recommendation regarding publication or time taken to review the paper. The editors' quality score for reviews (3.05 (SD 0.70)) was significantly higher than that of authors (2.90 (0.87)) (P<0.005, 95%confidence interval for difference - 0.26 to - 0.03). Most authors were in favour of open peer review.

CONCLUSIONS

Asking reviewers to consent to being identified to the author had no important effect on the quality of the review, the recommendation regarding publication, or the time taken to review, but it significantly increased the likelihood of reviewers declining to review.

Daily injections of fluoxetine induce dose-dependent desensitization of hypothalamic 5-HT1A receptors: reductions in neuroendocrine responses to 8-OH-DPAT and in levels of Gz and Gi proteins

The present studies examined the dose-response relationship of fluoxetine-induced desensitization of hypothalamic postsynaptic 5-HT1A receptors, as measured from the reduced neuroendocrine responses to a 5-HT1A agonist. Because hypothalamic Gz proteins mediate the ACTH and oxytocin responses to 5-HT1A receptor activation, we also determined the effect of fluoxetine on the levels of Gz proteins in the hypothalamus. Rats were injected daily for 14 days with saline or with fluoxetine doses of 0.3, 1, 3, 5, 7. 5, or 10 mg/kg/day. Fluoxetine produced a dose-dependent reduction in the oxytocin, ACTH, and corticosterone responses to the 5-HT1A agonist 8-hydroxy-2-(dipropylamino)tetralin (8-OH-DPAT, 50 micrograms/kg, s.c.). The lowest fluoxetine dose that significantly, although incompletely, reduced the neuroendocrine responses to 8-OH-DPAT was 5 mg/kg/day. The 10 mg/kg/day dose of fluoxetine maximally inhibited all neuroendocrine responses to 8-OH-DPAT. Hypothalamic levels of Gz protein were reduced by both the 7.5 and 10 mg/kg/day doses of fluoxetine, whereas Gi1 protein levels were reduced only after the highest dose (10 mg/kg/day) of fluoxetine. Gi2, Gi3, and Go levels were not reduced by any fluoxetine dose. Cytosolic levels of Gi1 and Gz proteins were unaltered, indicating that reductions in Gz and Gi1 proteins are not caused by a redistribution of the proteins from the membrane into the cytosol. The results from the present study indicate that fluoxetine-induced desensitization of hypothalamic postsynaptic 5-HT1A receptor systems is dose-dependent and may be caused in part by reductions in the hypothalamic levels of Gz proteins.

Application and results of the Manchester Short Assessment of Quality of Life (MANSA)

BACKGROUND

Based on experiences and empirical evidence gained in studies using the Lancashire Quality of Life Profile (LQLP), the Manchester Short Assessment of Quality of Life (MANSA) has been developed as a condensed and slightly modified instrument for assessing quality of life. Its properties have been tested in a sample of community care patients.

METHOD

Fifty-five randomly selected patients on the Care Programme Approach were interviewed using the LQLP, the MANSA and the Brief Psychiatric Rating Scale.

RESULTS

Correlations between subjective quality of life scores on MANSA and LQLP were all 0.83 or higher (0.94 for the satisfaction mean score). Cronbach's alpha for satisfaction ratings was 0.74, and association with psychopathology was in line with results for LQLP as reported in the literature.

CONCLUSIONS

The MANSA is a brief instrument for assessing quality of life focusing on satisfaction with life as a whole and with life domains. Its psychometric properties appear satisfactory.

Fatigue in HIV illness: relationship to depression, physical limitations, and disability

OBJECTIVE

This study was conducted to investigate the prevalence of clinical fatigue reported by gay/bisexual men at all HIV illness stages, and whether fatigue, while associated with depression, independently contributes to limitations in physical function and disability.

METHOD

HIV- men, HIV+ men with CD4 counts >500, HIV+ men with CD4 counts 200 to 500, and men with AIDS were compared on prevalence of clinical fatigue, as defined by a standardized instrument. Among HIV+ men, the relationships among fatigue, depressed mood, major depressive disorder, HIV illness markers (including CD4 count and HIV RNA viral load), physical limitations, and disability were assessed at baseline and after 1 year.

RESULTS

The prevalence of clinical fatigue in men with CD4 counts <500 was 14%, significantly higher than HIV- men and HIV+ men with CD4 counts >500. However, fatigue was not directly correlated with CD4 count or HIV RNA. Fatigue was a chronic symptom that was associated with depressed mood, major depressive disorder, physical limitations, and disability. After 1 year, an increase in depressive symptoms predicted a small amount of variance in fatigue; however, depressive symptoms were not associated with physical limitations or disability after controlling for fatigue.

CONCLUSION

Fatigue is a chronic symptom that is more prevalent in advanced HIV illness, and which, although associated with depression, does not seem to be merely a symptom of depression. Because fatigue contributes independently to physical limitations and disability, it should be assessed and treated.

Pain and depression in HIV illness

The purpose of this study was to examine the relationship among pain and depression, hopelessness, and quality of life in human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)-infected gay men, taking into account the role of HIV symptoms. One hundred sixty-one HIV+ gay men were assessed, with 40 men endorsing HIV-related pain. The HIV+ men with pain had a modal rating of pain within the mild range. They had significantly more advanced disease, more physical and depressive symptoms, and reported less life satisfaction than the men without pain. However, when HIV illness variables are accounted for, the higher depression scores in the men with pain were largely accounted for by somatic rather than cognitive symptoms. While pain is associated with greater physical distress in this cohort of HIV-seropositive gay men, it does not appear to be independently associated with cognitive symptoms of depression. These findings apply to HIV-infected men with mild pain and may not apply to those who experience more severe pain. Nonetheless, these observations highlight the overlap between symptoms of depression and pain and the challenge that clinicians face in assessing patients suffering from pain.

Sequence elements involved in the rescue of IBV defective RNA CD-91

Deletion mutagenesis has been used to identify essential regions for rescue of coronavirus defective RNAs (D-RNAs). Using this technique on a cloned IBV D-RNA CD-91, we have identified a region potentially important in its rescue. Comparing the sequence of D-RNAs rescued with those not rescued we have deduced that a 72 base region corresponding to base number 13,824 to 13,896 in the viral genome is required for rescue. This may be an IBV D-RNA packaging signal or a cis-acting element involved in replication. Further experiments and modification of our techniques will be required to differentiate between the two processes.

Rescue of IBV D-RNA by heterologous helper virus strains

Coronavirus defective RNA (D-RNA) vectors could be developed to deliver selected genes for the production of recombinant coronavirus vaccines. An IBV D-RNA, CD-61, derived from a naturally occurring IBV Beaudette D-RNA, CD-91, is being developed as a D-RNA vector for IBV. In order to use CD-61 as a vector it will require rescue by heterologous strains in addition to Beaudette. Rescue will be determined by recognition of replication and packaging signals within the D-RNA by the helper virus. The 5' and 3' UTRs are believed to contain sequences involved in replication and transcription. The 5' and 3' UTRs of six strains of IBV have been sequenced and experiments performed using six strains of helper virus for rescue of CD-61 to determine whether rescue correlates with sequence conservation within the 5' and 3' UTRs. Results indicate that all strains of helper virus rescued the D-RNA to varying degrees. Sequence comparisons show a high degree of sequence identity in the UTRs, but enough strain differences exist to be used as markers. The 5' and 3' UTRs of the D-RNAs rescued by the heterologous strains were also sequenced and leader switching between the helper virus and the Beaudette leader on the D-RNAs was observed.

Radiofrequency and microwave dielectric properties of aqueous cryoprotectant agents: dimethyl sulphoxide and 2,3-butanediol

Earlier work on the dielectric properties of cryoprotectant agents is extended using a modified measuring cell and method of data reduction yielding results more efficiently over a temperature range from -75 to +25 degrees C at frequencies from 27 MHz to 3 GHz. Dimethyl sulphoxide and butanediol are investigated at lower aqueous concentrations than previously and the implications for electromagnetic rewarming of cryopreserved materials are discussed.

The association of peripheral monocyte derived interleukin 1beta (IL-1beta), IL-1 receptor antagonist, and tumor necrosis factor-alpha with osteoarthritis in the elderly

OBJECTIVE

To examine the association of peripheral blood mononuclear cell (PBMC) derived interleukin 1beta (IL-1beta), IL-1 receptor antagonist (IL-1Ra), tumor necrosis factor alpha (TNF-alpha), and radiographic osteoarthritis (OA) in the elderly.

METHODS

A total of 703 subjects (436 women, 267 men, mean age 78.5+/-4.5 yrs) had both knee and hand radiographs, and cytokines were measured during the 22nd biennial examination of the Framingham Cohort. PBMC derived IL-1beta , IL-1Ra, and TNF-alpha production was assessed using a non-cross reacting polyclonal radioimmunoassay. Knee OA was defined as a score of > 2 using a modified Kellgren and Lawrence scale. The presence of osteophytes and joint space narrowing were scored separately on a 0-3 scale, in which disease was defined a priori as a score > 0 for each feature. Sex-specific odds ratios were calculated for knee OA after adjusting for weight, history of knee injury, and use of estrogen and nonsteroidal antiinflammatory drugs.

RESULT

No uniform associations were found for IL-1beta or IL-1Ra in men, or for TNF-alpha production and radiographic OA in either sex. We found possible associations for the highest levels of IL-1beta production and the presence of knee osteophytes [OR=2.0 (1.2-3.5)] and joint space narrowing [OR=1.7 (1.1-2.8)] in women. Our data suggested a possible protective effect for IL-1Ra production and hand OA in women [OR=0.6 (0.4-1.0)].

CONCLUSION

We found no consistent association of PBMC cytokine production and radiographic OA. However, women with the highest production of IL-1beta and IL-1Ra had respectively higher rates of knee OA and lower rates of hand OA than expected.

Differential rescue of visceral and cardiac defects in Drosophila by vertebrate tinman-related genes

tinman, a mesodermal NK2-type homeobox gene, is absolutely required for the subdivision of the early Drosophila mesoderm and for the formation of the heart as well as the visceral muscle primordia. Several vertebrate relatives of tinman, many of which are predominately expressed in the very early cardiac progenitors (and pharyngeal endoderm), also seem to promote heart development. Here, we show that most of these vertebrate tinman-related genes can readily substitute for Drosophila tinman function in promoting visceral mesoderm-specific marker gene expression, but much less in promoting cardiac-specific gene expression indicative of heart development. In addition, another mesodermal NK2-type gene from Drosophila, bagpipe, which is normally only needed for visceral mesoderm but not heart development, cannot substitute for tinman at all. These data indicate that the functional equivalence of the tinman-related subclass of NK2-type genes (in activating markers of visceral mesoderm development in Drosophila) is specific to this subclass and distinct from other homeobox genes. Despite the apparent overall conservation of heart development between vertebrates and invertebrates, the differential rescue of visceral mesoderm versus heart development suggests that some of the molecular mechanisms of organ formation may have diverged during evolution.

Antenatal steroids, condition at birth and respiratory morbidity and mortality in very preterm infants

AIMS

To investigate (1) perinatal factors affecting condition at birth in very preterm infants (23-32 weeks) and (2) the relationship between poor condition at birth and neonatal respiratory morbidity and mortality.

METHODOLOGY

Convenience sample (n = 479) drawn from a geographic population inception cohort.

RESULTS

Antenatal steroid use reduced the risk of pH < or = 7.20 [Adjusted Odds Ratio 0.29 (95% CI 0.17, 0.50)], one minute Apgar < 4 [0.54 (0.33, 0.88)], and 5 min Apgar < 7 [0.44 (0.23, 0.84)]. Gestational age was significantly related to Apgar score but not cord arterial acid-base status. No other perinatal factor was significant. Poor condition at birth was associated with an increase in the incidence and severity of hyaline membrane disease and death. These effects were lessened in those exposed to steroids.

CONCLUSION

Antenatal steroid use is associated with improved condition at birth and reduces the deleterious effects of poor condition at birth on early respiratory morbidity and mortality.