Attenuation of emotional and nonemotional memories after their reactivation: role of beta adrenergic receptors

A memory trace in its active state is susceptible to interference by amnesic agents, such as hypothermia and electroconvulsive shock, and by NMDA receptor antagonists, suggesting that a time-dependent consolidation process occurs each time a memory is reactivated. The role of beta noradrenergic receptors in reconsolidation in rats was examined in both a positively reinforced radial maze task and a footshock-reinforced conditioned emotional response task. For the former, rats were trained over several days in a spatial reference memory task and received a single reactivation trial followed by propranolol. A temporally graded impairment was observed when propranolol treatment occurred after the memory reactivation trial. In the emotional task, memory impairing effects of propranolol were greater when the drug was administered after a reactivation trial than when administered immediately after the initial training. These results suggest that reactivation of memory triggers a beta receptor-dependent cascade of intracellular events, recapitulating that which occurs during initial postacquisition consolidation, thus permitting reorganization of the existing memory as a function of new information in the retrieval environment. This remarkable lability of an active memory trace provides a new basis for pharmacotherapeutic intervention in such syndromes as Posttraumatic Stress Disorder. beta adrenoreceptor antagonists may be promising pharmacological agents for attenuating debilitating memories at the time of their controlled reactivation.

Learning-induced plasticity of N-methyl-D-aspartate receptors is task and region specific

Changes in binding of [3H]dizocilpine maleate to N-methyl-D-aspartate-sensitive ion channel receptors were evaluated after learning in order to specify brain regions which might be involved in memory formation. Rats were trained in a five-trial session of 40 min, to discriminate among three odours to obtain food reinforcement. Another group was trained in an eight-arm maze to choose always the same three arms to obtain food reinforcement (nine trials over 150 min). In rats killed 30 min after odour discrimination learning, dizocilpine maleate binding was significantly reduced in hippocampal sub-regions CA3, CA1 and fascia dentata and in frontal cortex. After spatial learning, changes in binding were limited to the amygdala, where a decrease was also observed. These results indicate that functional changes occur in specific brain regions after learning and suggest anatomical loci for further study of synaptic changes at a morphological level, after spatial learning or odour discrimination.

Consolidation of Memory for Odor–Reward Association: β-Adrenergic Receptor Involvement in the Late Phase

Experimentally naive rats can learn rapidly to discriminate among three odors to obtain food reinforcement. After three massed trials, they show almost errorless performance. This task has proved to be useful in studying time-dependent postacquisition intracellular processes necessary for long-term memory. The present experiments evaluated the temporal dynamics of the role of β-noradrenergic receptors in long-term consolidation. Rats were implanted with intracerebroventricular cannulae and trained in a single session to find reinforcement in a hole in a sponge impregnated with a particular odor. Injections of the β-receptor antagonist timolol were made at 5 min, 1, 2, or 5 hr after training. Memory and relearning ability were evaluated 48 hr later. Rats treated with timolol 2 hr after training showed a memory deficit at the retention test, but were able to relearn the task normally. Injections at the earlier or later time points were ineffective. The results reinforce previous observations with systemic injections that β-noradrenergic receptors are involved in the late phase of memory consolidation and suggest a critical time window during which they are necessary. The time window is compatible with the current view that long-term memory depends on late involvement of the cAMP cascade leading to new protein synthesis necessary for synaptic reorganization.

Consolidation of memory for odor-reward association: beta-adrenergic receptor involvement in the late phase

Experimentally naive rats can learn rapidly to discriminate among three odors to obtain food reinforcement. After three massed trials, they show almost errorless performance. This task has proved to be useful in studying time-dependent postacquisition intracellular processes necessary for long-term memory. The present experiments evaluated the temporal dynamics of the role of beta-noradrenergic receptors in long-term consolidation. Rats were implanted with intracerebroventricular cannulae and trained in a single session to find reinforcement in a hole in a sponge impregnated with a particular odor. Injections of the beta-receptor antagonist timolol were made at 5 min, 1, 2, or 5 hr after training. Memory and relearning ability were evaluated 48 hr later. Rats treated with timolol 2 hr after training showed a memory deficit at the retention test, but were able to relearn the task normally. Injections at the earlier or later time points were ineffective. The results reinforce previous observations with systemic injections that beta-noradrenergic receptors are involved in the late phase of memory consolidation and suggest a critical time window during which they are necessary. The time window is compatible with the current view that long-term memory depends on late involvement of the cAMP cascade leading to new protein synthesis necessary for synaptic reorganization.

Learning by neurones: role of attention, reinforcement and behaviour

The importance of the behavioural situation, attentional demands of the task, and stimulus-reinforcement contingencies in promoting or permitting experience-dependent neuronal plasticity is argued. Evidence is provided for the specific activation of the locus coeruleus noradrenergic system of the rat by novel stimuli encountered while investigating the environment, as well as during a formal learning situation. Noradrenergic neurons are particularly concerned with changes in the predictive value of the stimulus, when new learning should occur. Noradrenaline, released at LC terminals in target sensory systems, could facilitate shifts in attention, information processing and memory through its well-documented gating and tuning effects and its permissive role in long-term potentiation. Dopamine neurons, which fire persistently to reward during learning, could be involved in maintaining the behavioural response.

Slow oscillations as a probe of the dynamics of the locus coeruleus-frontal cortex interaction in anesthetized rats

Multiunit or single unit activity recorded simultaneously from frontal cortex (FC) and locus coeruleus (LC) under ketamine anesthesia revealed that both regions show slow oscillatory activity, together or separately. If, however, both regions are engaged in this oscillatory activity, there is a systematic relationship between their phases with peak LC firing always following FC firing by 200-400 ms. This was confirmed by cross-correlational analyses, which indicated that the two structures temporarily form a resonant system. The FC-LC resonant state is, however, loose enough to remain open to other intrinsic or extrinsic influences, keeping the measured frequencies of oscillations at each site slightly different, as demonstrated by a detailed analysis of the autocorrelograms. An injection of lidocaine at the frontal cortex site, while sharply reducing the prefrontal activity to essentially zero, leads to an increase of the LC activity and to a modification of the shape of the LC autocorrelogram, but does not change appreciably the phase relationship between the activity in the two structures during the diminishing activity in FC.

Neural cell adhesion molecules play a role in rat memory formation in appetitive as well as aversive tasks

A polyclonal antibody (R1), raised against chick synaptic membrane glycoproteins and recognizing the neural cell adhesion molecule (NCAM) caused amnesia for avoidance tasks when injected into day-old chicks and adult rats 5.5 h post-training. We investigated the effects of R1 antibody on memory formation in a non-aversive task, where stress is minimal: a massed trial odour discrimination task in rats. Preimmune serum or R1 antibody was injected i.c.v. 5.5 h after the last training session. Forty-eight hours after the training session, control rats showed very good retention whereas R1 antibody injection significantly disrupted retention. The results suggest that glycoproteins recognized by R1 in the rat play a specific role in memory formation for appetitive events as well as in memory formation for aversive situations.

Reconsolidation of memory after its reactivation

We report here data suggesting that reactivation of a well-established memory by a retention test triggers cellular events which depend upon N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA) receptors for up to 2 h after reactivation. Rats were overtrained on a maze task requiring integration of distal spatial information contained in cues strategically placed around the maze. Previous experiments showed that pretrial injection of the noncompetitive NMDA receptor antagonist, MK-801, at a dose which had no effect on overt behavior (0.05 mg/kg), markedly disrupted the well-trained performance of the task. Surprisingly, the behavioral deficit persisted on subsequent, drug-free trials, 24 h later. The present experiments showed that post-trial injections produced the same effects on performance on one or two subsequent daily trials. A temporal gradient for this amnestic effect of the drug treatment was established by injecting rats at 5, 30, 60, 90, 120 or 180 min after the performance trial. Only those rats whose MK-801 treatment was delayed for 120 min or more after the trial were able to perform the task normally 24 h later. All other treatment times induced significant amnesia for the task, when the rats were tested 24 h later. A subsequent experiment, using a more difficult version of the task, showed a longer amnesia gradient, but the predrug performance level could be reinstated within one multiple trial test session. Thus, it appears that activation of a well-established memory circuit renders the trace labile, requiring its reconsolidation. To what extent the entire post-acquisition cascade of NMDA receptor-dependent intracellular events is recapitulated each time a memory is activated and reorganised is probably a function of the age and complexity of the memory and the amount of new information to be integrated into the circuit. These results provide physiological evidence for the notion that memory is a dynamic process undergoing continual reorganization as a function of the ongoing experience of the organism.

Antibody to day-old chick brain glycoprotein produces amnesia in adult rats

Polyclonal antibody R-1, raised against a chick synaptic membrane glycoprotein fraction whose synthesis is enhanced following training on a passive avoidance task, produces amnesia when injected into chick forebrain 5.5 h posttraining. The amnestic IgG fraction specifically recognizes a low sialylated isoform of NCAM (Mileusnic Rose, Lancashire, & Bullock, 1995). We have now investigated the effects of this antibody on memory formation in adult rats. R-1, preimmune serum, or saline was injected intracerebroventricularly 5.5 h posttraining through bilaterally implanted cannulae. Rats injected with R-1 and tested 48 h later showed a significant amnesia for avoidance compared with the controls. Amnesia was not apparent at 24 h posttraining. R-1 injections were without effect on spontaneous locomotor or exploratory activity in a holeboard test. The results contribute to the argument that the role of cell adhesion molecules in neuronal plasticity is not limited to the developing nervous system, but they play a more general role in the experience-dependent synaptic remodeling underlying long-term memory.

Novelty-elicited, noradrenaline-dependent enhancement of excitability in the dentate gyrus

In order to relate noradrenaline-dependent potentiation in the dentate gyrus to behavioural events, rats were made to explore an environment in which their encounters with novel stimuli could be strictly controlled and monitored. Previous experiments have shown that an encounter with novel objects in a holeboard elicits a burst response in a large population of noradrenergic neurons of the locus coeruleus. Such a burst response has been demonstrated to produce a large and transient potentiation of the population spike in the dentate gyrus. In the present series of experiments, rats were chronically implanted with stimulating electrodes in the perforant pathway and recording electrodes in the dentate gyrus. Evoked potentials were monitored in the awake rat, first while it was resting quietly in a familiar environment and then while it was exploring the holeboard containing a novel object in a specific hole. There was a tonic increase in population spike amplitude when the rat was placed in the novel holeboard environment, but this effect gradually dissipated. This increase was partly blocked by the beta-noradrenergic antagonist propranolol. In addition there was a robust phasic increase in spike amplitude when the rat encountered a novel stimulus. This phasic response lasted approximately 50-75 s and was absent in animals treated with propranolol. These results show that a behavioural encounter with a novel stimulus can transiently enhance information transmission through the hippocampus, and suggest that activation of the noradrenergic system by the novel stimulus mediates this behavior-dependent gating.

Rapid habituation of auditory responses of locus coeruleus cells in anaesthetized and awake rats

The auditory response of locus coeruleus (LC) neurones evoked by novel tones was investigated in anaesthetized and awake rats. Recording the single unit activity of LC neurones, responses to auditory stimuli are found under anaesthesia as well as in the awake animal. There are three types of LC responses to tone: first and by far the most frequent, a burst of several spikes at onset of the tone; second, a burst at tone offset and lastly, a total inhibition to the tone. All responses present a rapid habituation after the first few presentations of the stimulus. The results support the view that the LC plays a role in mediating responses to environmental changes.

Novelty seeking behavior in the rat is dependent upon the integrity of the noradrenergic system

These experiments were designed to investigate the role of the noradrenergic system in promoting investigation of novelty in rats. Behavior was monitored in a hole board equipped with photoelectric cells strategically placed so that locomotor activity, rearing and investigation of each of the holes could be quantified independently. Specially designed computer software permitted recording of the sequence and cumulative duration of the visits to specific holes throughout the session. Dose-response curves of the sedative effect of the alpha 2 adrenergic receptor agonist clonidine were established, a sedative effect being defined as a decrease in overall horizontal displacements, rearings and hole visits. After a one week interval, the rats were rerun in the holeboard, with novel objects placed in four of the nine holes. Previous experiments had shown that rats spend significantly more time investigating holes containing objects than empty holes in this apparatus and this was replicated here. Doses of clonidine which were below threshold for inducing any sedative effect (10 micrograms/kg) totally eliminated preference for holes with objects while having no effect on total time investigating the holes. A subsequent experiment showed that the beta receptor antagonist propranolol (10 mg/kg) produced a similar effect. These results suggest that the noradrenergic system is implicated in stimulus seeking behavior and the post-synaptic beta receptors are involved in mediating the behavior.

Inhibitory influence of frontal cortex on locus coeruleus neurons

The functional influence of the frontal cortex (FC) on the noradrenergic nucleus locus coeruleus (LC) was studied in the rat under ketamine anesthesia. The FC was inactivated by local infusion of lidocaine or ice-cold Ringer's solution while recording neuronal activity simultaneously in FC and LC. Lidocaine produced a transient increase in activity in FC, accompanied by a decrease in LC unit and multiunit activity. This was followed by a total inactivation of FC and a sustained increase in firing rate of LC neurons. Subsequent experiments revealed antidromic responses in the FC when stimulation was applied to the LC region. The antidromic responses in FC were found in a population of neurons (about 8%) restricted to the dorsomedial area, FR2. The results indicate that there is a strong inhibitory influence of FC on the tonic activity of LC neurons. The antidromic responses in FC to stimulation of the LC region suggest that this influence is locally mediated, perhaps through interneurons within the nucleus or neighboring the LC.

Response to novelty and its rapid habituation in locus coeruleus neurons of the freely exploring rat

Activity of single units of the noradrenergic nucleus locus coeruleus was recorded in rats during active exploration of a novel environment. Novelty was controlled by the placement of objects in given holes in a hole board. The basic protocol included a habituation session in which the holes were empty and an object session in which a novel object was placed in one of the two holes. During the habituation session, when the whole environment was unfamiliar, there was a phasic response the first time the rat visited any hole, which habituated after one visit. During the second session, when one of the holes contained an object, the cell fired when the rat encountered the novel object. There was no response to empty holes in this session. The neuronal response was markedly diminished or entirely absent on the second and subsequent visits to object-containing holes, indicative of rapid habituation. In some rats it was possible to run a second object session, when a new object was introduced into a previously empty hole. Visits to this hole elicited a robust response, which again habituated after one single visit. The results show that the responses of locus coeruleus to novelty or change, which has been demonstrated in formal learning situations, occurs in freely behaving rats while they are learning about a new environment. Moreover, the response to novelty and change in the environment is short-lived, rapidly habituating after one or two encounters with the stimulus.

Noradrenergic hyperactivity in hippocampus after partial denervation: pharmacological, behavioral, and electrophysiological studies

Previous studies have shown that, in addition to partial damage to the cholinergic system, partial fornix section causes changes in the noradrenergic (NA) system and an increase in NA activity in the dorsal hippocampus. Behaviorally, this NA hyperactivity contributes to the deficits observed in the radial arm maze, since a reduction of NA activity restores the performance of rats with a partial fornix lesion. The reorganization of the NA system after partial fornix section should modify its responsiveness, and the present series of experiments examines these changes. In the first experiment, sensitivity to the sedative effects of the alpha 2 agonist clonidine was evaluated by determining a dose-response curve to clonidine in a hole board. Rats with partial fornix lesion were resistant to the sedative effects of clonidine, suggesting differences in alpha 2-receptor sensitivity. In the second experiments, rats were submitted to a test for novelty-seeking behavior in the hole board with objects placed in some holes. Rats with fornix sections spent more time in contact with novel objects than the control rats, a behavior which has previously been observed in hyper-noradrenergic animals. Finally, single-unit recording of locus coeruleus (LC) cells in anesthetized rats showed there were no effects of the partial fornix lesion either on spontaneous firing rate of LC cells or on their responsiveness to clonidine. These last results suggest that the behavioral differences and differences in NA activity observed after partial denervation are a result of local regulation of release at the NA terminals and are not due to changes in the cell bodies within the LC.

Central noradrenergic reactivity to stress in Maudsley rat strains

Maudsley reactive (MR) and Maudsley nonreactive (MNRA) rats were submitted to a single session of acute 5-min immobilization stress and immediately sacrificed by decapitation. Subsequent neurochemical analysis revealed an elevation of 3,4-dihydroxyphenylacetic acid levels in the locus coeruleus and in the ventrolateral medulla, but not in the dorsomedial medulla, of rats of the two strains compared with nonstressed controls. This response was greater in the MR than in the MNRA group, suggesting a strain difference in the reactivity of the central noradrenergic cells to acute stress.

The Maudsley rat strains as a probe to investigate noradrenergic-cholinergic interaction in cognitive function

Central noradrenergic function in relation to cognitive performance was studied in the Maudsley rat strains. Neurochemical studies revealed a higher response to acute stress in the locus coeruleus (LC) in the Maudsley reactives (MR) than in the Maudsley non-reactives (MNRA). Autoradiographic studies showed that MNRAs had greater 125I clonidine binding to alpha 2 receptors in LC, which was accompanied by a higher behavioral sensitivity to clonidine. MRs had a deficit in working memory, but were superior to MNRAs in two reference memory tasks. MRs displayed a stronger preference for novel objects, with no strain differences in general exploratory activity. The behavioral profile of the MRs is similar to rats treated with drugs which enhance noradrenergic function. Furthermore, MNRA rats had greater availability of muscarinic receptors, which correlated with behavioral performance in the spatial working memory task. The differences in noradrenergic and cholinergic systems and their relationship to the behavioral profile make the Maudsley strains a useful tool to probe the interaction between two neurotransmitter systems in cognitive function.

Locus coeruleus-evoked responses in behaving rats: a clue to the role of noradrenaline in memory

Neuromodulatory properties of noradrenaline (NA) suggest that the coreruleo-cortical NA projection should play an important role in attention and memory processes. Our research is aimed at providing some behavioral evidence. Single units of the locus coeruleus (LC) are recorded during controlled behavioral situations, in order to relate LC activation to specific behavioral contexts. LC cells respond in burst to imposed novel sensory stimuli or to novel objects encountered during free exploration. When there is no predictive value of the stimulus or no behavioral response required, there is rapid habituation of the LC response. When a stimulus is then associated with reinforcement, there is a renewed response, which is transient. During extinction, LC neuronal responses reappear. Thus, LC cells respond to novelty or change in incoming information, but do not have a sustained response to stimuli, even when they have a high level of biological significance. The gating and tuning action of NA released in target sensory systems would promote selective attention to relevant stimuli at the critical moment of change. The adaptive behavioral outcome would result from the integration of retrieved memory with the sensory information selected from the environment.

Maudsley rat strains, selected for differences in emotional responses, differ in behavioral response to clonidine and in [125I]clonidine binding in the locus coeruleus

Maudsley rats, selectively inbred for emotionality for over sixty generations, differ in reactivity to stress, both at the peripheral level and within the central noradrenergic system. The present experiments examine to what extent these central differences might be due to differences in the inhibitory processes mediated by alpha 2 autoreceptors within the locus coeruleus. Maudsley reactive rats (MRs), the strain which showed a much higher central noradrenergic response to immobilisation stress, required higher doses of the alpha 2 receptor agonist, clonidine, to induce behavioral sedation than the Maudsley non-reactive rats (MNRA). Autoradiographic studies showed a significantly higher level of binding of 125iodeclonidine in the locus coeruleus of the MNRAs compared to the MRs, indicating that the former had more alpha 2 receptors and/or these receptors had a greater affinity for the agonist. Thus autoinhibitory processes within the locus coeruleus are different in the two strains, which could account for the differences in reactivity to stress seen in the biochemical and behavioral studies.

Limbic forebrain toxin trimethyltin reduces behavioral suppression by clonidine

Trimethyltin (TMT) at moderate doses selectively damages hippocampus and related olfactory cortex and produces learning and memory impairments. TMT also increases forebrain beta-adrenergic ligand binding; this could be ancillary to reduced noradrenergic neurotransmission, which in turn could be involved in the cognitive deficit caused by TMT. If this hypothesis is correct, then the alpha 1-adrenergic agonist clonidine, which inhibits noradrenergic neurotransmission in normal subjects, should be less behaviourally effective after TMT poisoning. Thus, rats treated with water vehicle or TMT (6 mg/kg, PO) were given saline or clonidine IP (5, 10, or 20 micrograms/kg) 30 min before placement in a hole-board apparatus. Exploratory activity was reduced in controls by 10 or 20 micrograms/kg. Clonidine at 10 micrograms/kg was ineffective in rats given TMT. At 20 micrograms/kg, an apparent reduction in exploratory activity was not significant because variability of responding was higher after TMT treatment. The results suggest an impairment in noradrenergic neurotransmission following TMT poisoning.

Locus coeruleus bursts induced by glutamate trigger delayed perforant path spike amplitude potentiation in the dentate gyrus

Glutamate pressure ejections in the vicinity of locus coeruleus (LC) neurons have been shown to produce both short and long-lasting potentiation of perforant path (PP) evoked population spike amplitude in the dentate gyrus (DG). These effects of LC-glutamate activation resemble those produced by direct application of NE in vitro or in vivo. The present study monitored the cellular response of LC neurons to local glutamate ejections concomitant with stimulation of the PP evoked potential. Double barrel micropipettes or 33 ga cannula-electrode assemblies permitted LC unit recording and glutamate ejection at or near the same site in urethane anesthetized rats. Glutamate ejections produced a burst of LC activity lasting 250-400 ms and followed by a depression of unit activity lasting 4.6 min. The maximal spike potentiation produced by LC activation was 158%. The first spike to exceed the control range occurred 34 s after the LC burst. Comparable silent intervals in LC unit activity induced by systemic clonidine were not accompanied by population spike amplitude potentiation. The mean duration of potentiation was 4.4 min except in four cases where responses remained potentiated for the duration of the experiment. The duration of potentiation was not correlated with the termination of LC depression. LC units recovered to baseline rates following glutamate induced depression of activity. The occurrence of potentiation appeared to require that glutamate activation reach a critical number of LC neurons since small glutamate ejections could produce a local burst without eliciting potentiation. Long-lasting changes were also related to larger glutamate volumes (100 nl).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Noradrenergic hyperactivity after partial fornix section: role in cholinergic dependent memory performance

Rats with unilateral or bilateral partial section of the fornix were impaired on an eight arm radial maze task. Neurochemical analysis of hippocampal tissue four weeks after the lesions revealed a 50% reduction of choline acetyltransferase (ChAT) activity. The cholinergic marker was correlated negatively with the number of errors in the maze; the lower the ChAT activity, the higher the error score. The fornix lesion also induced a 50% reduction in norepinephrine (NE), but no change in the noradrenergic metabolite methylhydroxyphenylglycol (MHPG), suggesting a net increase in turnover of NE in these animals. Additional lesion of the noradrenergic system with the neurotoxin DSP4 reduced both MHPG and NE levels by more than 90%, compared to nonlesioned controls, and reversed the behavioral deficit. This treatment had no further effect on cholinergic markers. There was a significant negative correlation between ChAT activity and the index of NE turnover, suggesting that hyperactivity in the noradrenergic system after fornix section inhibits the spared cholinergic function and thus exacerbates the cognitive deficit. The pattern of neurochemical results bear a striking resemblance to those seen in some Alzheimer's patients and suggest that an equilibrium among neurotransmitters is important to cognitive function.

Clonidine reverses spatial learning deficits and reinstates theta frequencies in rats with partial fornix section

Rats received knife-cuts to the dorsal fornix or sham-operations. Half of the animals from each group were injected with clonidine (0.01 mg/kg) and the others with saline before each daily trail of a 10-trial radial 8-arm maze task. The number of choices before the first repetition and the run time were used as performance indices. Lesioned rats were significantly impaired in the acquisition of this task. Clonidine-treated rats, lesioned or not, had an acquisition profile indistinguishable from that of sham-operated saline-injected rats, in spite of their increased run time. When tested one week after the last learning trial in a no-drug condition, lesioned rats treated with clonidine throughout learning maintained a high level of performance during the 5-day retraining phase. A parallel analysis of theta rhythms recorded in an independent group of rats placed in equivalent treatment and/or lesion conditions was then performed. Preoperatively, clonidine injections decreased theta frequency during both alert immobility and movement. Partial fornix lesions produced an increase in theta frequency. Finally, clonidine in fornix-damaged rats decreased theta frequency, thus reinstating the postoperative values at a level statistically no different from that recorded preoperatively. The role of clonidine in restoring the function of the septo-hippocampal input in partially fornix-damaged rats through a noradrenergic modulation of hippocampal acetylcholine release is discussed.