Retinoic acid, local cell-cell interactions, and pattern formation in vertebrate limbs

Retinoic acid and thyroid hormone may function through similar and competitive pathways in regenerating axolotls

The objective of this study was to determine whether thyroid hormone (TH) would interfere with retinoic acid (RA), which proximalizes axolotl larvae regenerate limb pattern. RA and TH are ligands for members of the steroid hormone thyroid hormone nuclear binding protein superfamily which form functional homodimers, but may also form stable heterodimers with the RXR protein and may recognize identical DNA sequences. TH alone does not affect limb pattern but induces metamorphosis in regenerating animals. Coinjected animals do not metamorphose, and when compared to RA controls regenerate more proximal and in some cases anteroposterior (AP) and dorsoventral (DV) duplicate limb structures. In addition, the tissues that are normally lost or changed during metamorphosis appear to be sensitized resulting in the formation of (1) new dorsal gill lamellae accompanied by bifurcation and broadening of the original gill lamellae, (2) partial resorption of the tail fin, and (3) changes in eye position and snout morphology. Bifurcation of gill lamellae tips, but not the formation of supernumerary gills, is also observed in animals treated with RA alone. These results indicate that the molecular mechanism of RA and TH function through similar and perhaps competitive pathways.

The role of Alx-4 in the establishment of anteroposterior polarity during vertebrate limb development

We have determined that Strong's Luxoid (lstJ) [corrected] mice have a 16 bp deletion in the homeobox region of the Alx-4 gene. This deletion, which leads to a frame shift and a truncation of the Alx-4 protein, could cause the polydactyly phenotype observed in lstJ [corrected] mice. We have cloned the chick homologue of Alx-4 and investigated its expression during limb outgrowth. Chick Alx-4 displays an expression pattern complementary to that of shh, a mediator of polarizing activity in the limb bud. Local application of Sonic hedgehog (Shh) and Fibroblast Growth Factor (FGF), in addition to ectodermal apical ridge removal experiments suggest the existence of a negative feedback loop between Alx-4 and Shh during limb outgrowth. Analysis of polydactylous mutants indicate that the interaction between Alx-4 and Shh is independent of Gli3, a negative regulator of Shh in the limb. Our data suggest the existence of a negative feedback loop between Alx-4 and Shh during vertebrate limb outgrowth.

Hedgehog family member is expressed throughout regenerating and developing limbs

Members of the hedgehog family have been shown to play a key role in many developmental processes, including limb patterning and chondrogenesis. We have therefore investigated whether members of this family are also expressed during regeneration of the adult urodele limb and are regulated by retinoic acid (RA), since this derivative induces proximodistal duplications in regenerating limbs, and has been shown to regulate sonic hedgehog (shh) in the developing limbs of birds and mammals. We report here that a newt homologue of Xenopus banded hedgehog, called N-bhh, is uniformly expressed by mesenchymal blastemal cells from the initial stages of regeneration and is up-regulated by RA. In addition, we show that N-bhh is uniformly expressed in the early limb bud of the newt embryo. Since bhh has not been detected in developing limbs of higher vertebrates, its expression in developing and regenerating newt limbs may be related to the regenerative capability of urodeles.

Gene expression during amphibian limb regeneration

Limb regeneration in adult urodeles is an important phenomenon that poses fundamental questions both in biology and in medicine. In this review, we focus on recent advances in the characterization of the regeneration blastema at cellular and molecular levels and on the current understanding of the molecular basis of limb regeneration and its relationship to development. In particular, we discuss (i) the spatiotemporal distribution of genes and gene products in the mesenchyme and wound epidermis of the regenerating limb, (ii) how growth is controlled in the regeneration blastema, and (iii) molecules that are likely to be involved in patterning the regenerating limb such as homeobox genes and retinoids.

Cell cycle length affects gene expression and pattern formation in limbs

The relationship between growth and pattern specification during development remains elusive. Some molecules known to function as growth factors are also potent agents of pattern formation. This raises the possibility that growth factors could act in pattern formation via an effect on the cell cycle. We have tested the significance of the length of the cell cycle for gene expression and pattern formation in developing chick limb buds by locally slowing the cell cycle. When anterior cell cycles are lengthened by reversible inhibition of DNA replication or by other means, some genes characteristic of the posterior polarizing region are expressed, and digit duplication is observed. Conversely, when posterior cell cycles are slowed, expression of some posterior-specific genes is inhibited, but the pattern is normal. These results indicate that control of the length of the cell cycle could play a primary role in pattern formation by influencing the complement of genes expressed in a particular region of the embryo.

Inhibition of prostate ductal morphogenesis by retinoic acid

PURPOSE

To examine the effect of retinoic acid on prostate ductal morphogenesis.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Newborn male Balb/C mice were injected with 25 mg./kg. all-trans retinoic acid or vehicle alone. Animals were sacrificed at 60 days of age and prostate ductal morphology was quantitatively assessed by microdissection. Total prostate DNA was quantitated by DPA assay.

RESULTS

The greatest effect was seen in the ventral prostate. Retinoic acid treated animals showed a 20% decrease in mean number of branch-points (p = 0.0006) with a corresponding 13% decrease in duct tips (p = 0.026). The combined ventral and dorsal prostate showed an effect with a 12% decrease in ductal branchpoints (p = 0.048). There was no effect on animal or organ weight and no effect on DNA content within the prostate. There was no difference in the prostate histology of treated and control animals.

CONCLUSION

Retinoic acid administration in the newborn period inhibits mouse prostate ductal morphogenesis. This effect appears independent of an inhibition of overall growth.

Expression of Sonic hedgehog gene in regenerating newt limb blastemas recapitulates that in developing limb buds

This study aimed at characterizing the Sonic hedgehog (shh) gene in newt limbs, which encodes a signaling molecule of the zone of polarizing activity (ZPA) responsible for determining the anterior-posterior axis of the embryonic chicken and mouse limbs. The reverse transcription-PCR showed that adult newt regenerating limbs express shh genes. In situ hybridization experiments demonstrated that shh genes were expressed in mesenchymal cells of the posterior region of both embryonic buds and regenerating blastemas of newt limbs, strongly suggesting the presence of ZPA in these tissues. Experiments of the axial reversal graft of blastemas further supported this suggestion. The grafted blastemas regenerated supernumerary limbs, and this has been explained by three models: the polar coordinate model, the boundary model, and the polarizing zone model. In favor of the third model, the shh gene was expressed not only in the original region (new anterior region) of the graft, but also ectopically in the other region (new posterior region) of the same graft. This study implies that the regenerating limb blastema produces ZPA as the signaling center of the AP patterning as in the developing limb bud and, therefore, supports the notion that the limb regeneration recapitulates the limb development.

Retinoic acid changes the proximodistal developmental competence and affinity of distal cells in the developing chick limb bud

In the developing chick limb bud, retinoic acid (RA) has a striking effect on anteroposterior axis formation, resulting in a duplicated pattern of digits. There is no evidence, however, that RA affects proximodistal axis formation in the developing chick limb bud, although RA induces proximodistal duplication in regenerating amphibian limbs. We describe a series of investigations on the effect of RA on the proximodistal axis in the chick limb bud. A RA-containing bead applied to the anterior margin of the chick limb bud at stage 20 induces the anteroposterior duplication of autopodial structures at the wrist level. We found that the RA-treated tissue has the ability to form more proximal structures. When a tissue graft from the RA-treated anterior region was implanted into a stage 17 wing bud (in which the stylopod is developing in the progress zone), the graft produced a humerus, radius-ulna, and digits. When the graft was implanted into a stage 19 wing bud (in which the zeugopod is developing in the progress zone), a zeugopod and digits were formed. These results were associated with changes in the expression of Hox-A genes in the RA-treated grafts, whose domains were reorganized to be similar to those in host tissues 24 h after grafting. When a small graft of RA-treated tissue was implanted into the apex of a stage 19 wing bud, the cells were found in the zeugopod and autopod, whereas cells of control fragments were found only in the autopod region. In vitro, distal cells from different stage limb buds are known to segregate from each other. However, RA-treated stage 24 distal cells did not sort out from stage 20 distal cells and mixed homogeneously. These results suggest that RA induces distal cells to adopt "younger" properties which render them susceptible to forming more proximal patterns under the direction of host signals. The effects of RA on proximodistal patterns in developing chick limb buds appear to differ from its effects on proximodistal patterns in regenerating urodele limbs because RA can induce the proximodistal duplication in situ in the regenerating limbs.

Amphibian limb regeneration: rebuilding a complex structure

The ability to regenerate complex structures is widespread in metazoan phylogeny, but among vertebrates the urodele amphibians are exceptional. Adult urodeles can regenerate their limbs by local formation of a mesenchymal growth zone or blastema. The generation of blastemal cells depends not only on the local extracellular environment after amputation or wounding but also on the ability to reenter the cell cycle from the differentiated state. The blastema replaces structures appropriate to its proximodistal position. Axial identity is probably encoded as a graded property that controls cellular growth and movement through local cell interactions. The molecular basis is not understood, but proximodistal identity in newt blastemal cells may be respecified by signaling through a retinoic acid receptor isoform. The possibility of inducing a blastema on a mammalian limb cannot be discounted, although the molecular constraints are becoming clearer as we understand more about the mechanisms of urodele regeneration.

An essential role for retinoid signaling in anteroposterior neural patterning

The vertebrate central nervous system (CNS) is induced by signals emanating from the dorsal mesoderm, or organizer, that divert the ectoderm away from an epidermal and towards a neural fate. Additional signals from the organizer pattern the neural ectoderm along the anteroposterior axis. We devised highly specific methods utilizing constitutively active or dominant negative receptors to evaluate the role of retinoids in neural patterning. Microinjection of these reagents either augments or reduces retinoid signaling in specific regions of the embryo. We show that increased receptor activity suppresses anterior neural structures while dominant negative receptors lead to anterior enhancement. Similarly, microinjection of the dominant negative receptor leads to the loss of posterior marker genes. We demonstrate that retinoid receptors comprise a critical component in neural posteriorization and are required for proper neuronal differentiation. These results support a quantitative role for retinoid signaling in regionalization of the CNS.

Retinoic acid is required for the initiation of outgrowth in the chick limb bud

BACKGROUND

Retinoic acid (RA) is present in the chick limb bud, and excess RA induces limb duplications. Here, we have investigated the role of endogenous RA during chick limb development by preventing the synthesis of RA and testing the effect on various genes expressed during limb initiation and outgrowth.

RESULTS

We demonstrate that the stage 20/21 limb bud synthesizes didehydroretinoic acid (ddRA), and that the posterior half of the limb bud synthesizes ddRA at a higher rate than the anterior half. Disulphiram inhibits this synthesis at micromolar concentrations. Administering disulphiram to embryos prior to limb bud outgrowth (stages 12-18) abolishes outgrowth, and no limb develops in the majority of cases. Disulphiram treatment also prevents the expression of Sonic hedgehog (Shh), but the expression of the fibroblast growth factor-8 gene (Fgf-8) appears as normal in the ectoderm over the prospective limb bud. The application of a bead soaked in RA can rescue Shh expression. Disulphiram treatment of later limb buds (stages 20-23) similarly down-regulates Shh, and also Fgf-4, expression, whereas the expression of Fgf-8, as at earlier stages, is initially unaffected. Again, RA can rescue the expression of Shh in these limb buds.

CONCLUSIONS

RA, in conjunction with Fgf-8, may be needed for the induction of the chick limb bud and the induction of Shh and Fgf-4 expression. The expression of Shh and Fgf-4 remains dependent upon the continued synthesis of RA within the limb bud. Didehydroretinoic acid is the major active retinoid in the stage 20 chick limb bud.

Novel retinoic acid receptor ligands in Xenopus embryos

Retinoids are a large family of natural and synthetic compounds related to vitamin A that have pleiotropic effects on body physiology, reproduction, immunity, and embryonic development. The diverse activities of retinoids are primarily mediated by two families of nuclear retinoic acid receptors, the RARs and RXRs. Retinoic acids are thought to be the only natural ligands for these receptors and are widely assumed to be the active principle of vitamin A. However, during an unbiased, bioactivity-guided fractionation of Xenopus embryos, we were unable to detect significant levels of all-trans or 9-cis retinoic acids. Instead, we found that the major bioactive retinoid in the Xenopus egg and early embryo is 4-oxoretinaldehyde, which is capable of binding to and transactivating RARs. In addition to its inherent activity, 4-oxoretinaldehyde appears to be a metabolic precursor of two other RAR ligands, 4-oxoretinoic acid and 4-oxoretinol. The remarkable increase in activity of retinaldehyde and retinol as a consequence of 4-oxo derivatization suggests that this metabolic step could serve a critical regulatory function during embryogenesis.

Regulative interactions in zebrafish neural crest

Zebrafish trunk neural crest cells that migrate at different times have different fates: early-migrating crest cells produce dorsal root ganglion neurons as well as glia and pigment cells, while late-migrating crest cells produce only non-neuronal derivatives. When presumptive early-migrating crest cells were individually transplanted into hosts such that they migrated late, they retained the ability to generate neurons. In contrast, late-migrating crest cells transplanted under the same conditions never generated neurons. These results suggest that, prior to migration, neural crest cells have intrinsic biases in the types of derivatives they will produce. Transplantation of presumptive early-migrating crest cells does not result in production of dorsal root ganglion neurons under all conditions suggesting that these cells require appropriate environmental factors to express these intrinsic biases. When early-migrating crest cells are ablated, late-migrating crest cells gain the ability to produce neurons, even when they migrate on their normal schedule. Interactions among neural crest cells may thus regulate the types of derivatives neural crest cells produce, by establishing or maintaining intrinsic differences between individual cells.

Restricted expression of a novel retinoic acid responsive gene during limb bud dorsoventral patterning and endochondral ossification

Using a differential substractive hybridization cloning procedure we have recently identified Stra6 as a novel retinoic acid-induced gene in murine P19 embryonal carcinoma cells. The putative amino acid sequence of Stra6 shows no similarity with previously characterised proteins. We report here the pattern of expression of Stra6 transcripts during mouse limb development as revealed by in situ hybridization. In 8.5-9.0 days post-coitum (dpc) embryos, Stra6 was expressed in the lateral plate mesenchyme prior to limb bud outgrowth. By 9.5 dpc, expression was restricted to the proximal and dorsal forelimb bud mesoderm. Over the next 2 gestational days, Stra6 expression was specific of the dorsal mesoderm of the undifferentiated forelimb and hindlimb buds with the exception of their distal-most region or progress zone. A novel proximal-ventral expression domain appeared, however, by 11.0-11.5 dpc. Stra6 also remained expressed in the flank mesoderm. From 11.5-13.5 dpc, Stra6 expression was restricted to the superficial mesenchyme surrounding the chondrogenic blastemas, and progressively extended until the distal extremities of the limbs upon disappearance of the progress zone. Progressive restriction of Stra6 expression to perichondrium and developing muscles was seen at 13.5-14.5 dpc. Upon the initiation of endochondral ossification (15.5-16.5 dpc), Stra6 expression was limited to the area of perichondrium opposing cells of high metabolic and proliferative activity (the elongation zone). We suggest that Stra6 may play a role in early dorsoventral limb patterning and later in the control of endochondral ossification.

Effects of all-trans-retinoic acid on skeletal pattern, 5'HoxD gene expression, and RAR beta 2/beta 4 promoter activity in embryonic mouse limbs

Mouse embryos were exposed to all-trans-retinoic acid on day 11 or day 12 of development and the resulting skeletal pattern alterations compared with early effects on Hoxd-11 and Hoxd-13 expression domains and RAR-beta 2/beta 4 promoter activity. The effects on skeletal pattern showed a clear correlation between the timing of retinoic acid exposure and the sequence of mesenchymal condensation. Ectopic RAR-beta 2/beta 4 promoter activity was detected within 2 hr of exposure to retinoic acid, and was present throughout the limb bud after 5 hr; it remained high in the apical ectodermal ridge and proximal mesenchyme after 12 hr, by which time the abnormal digital pattern could be seen. HoxD gene expression domains in the distal handplate were narrowed by 5 hr after maternal retinoic acid administration on day 11. Following retinoic acid treatment on both day 11 and day 12, the normal downregulation of Hoxd-11 and Hoxd-13 in the digital mesenchymal condensations was retarded. There was no evidence to suggest that RAR-beta 2/beta 4 promoter activity mediates the effects of RA on HoxD gene expression, but ectopic promoter activity is a useful indicator of at least some of the sites in which RA levels are raised. We suggest (1) that the apical ectodermal ridge is the most functionally significant of these sites, (2) that raised retinoic acid levels in the ridge result in altered gene expression and/or altered cell proliferation within this epithelium, (3) that both altered HoxD gene expression domains and altered skeletal pattern formation are secondary to this effect. There was a good correlation between the effects of retinoic acid on Hoxd-11 and Hoxd-13 expression and delay of skeletal differentiation, suggesting that this may be a direct effect.

Comparative distribution of GAD65 and GAD67 mRNAs and proteins in the rat spinal cord supports a differential regulation of these two glutamate decarboxylases in vivo

Gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA) synthesis can result from the action of at least two glutamic acid decarboxylase (GAD) isoforms, GAD65 and GAD67, possibly involved in distinct mechanisms. We have made the hypothesis that GAD65 may respond to short-term changes and is present in neurons with a phasic activity, while GAD67 may rather provide GABA for the metabolic pool and for supporting tonic levels of synaptic transmission (Erlander et al.: Neuron 7:91-100, 1991; Feldblum et al.: J Neurosci Res 34:689-706, 1993). In the present work we have tested this hypothesis in the rat spinal cord where both types of activities have been identified. The correlation of GABA immunodetection with the distribution of GAD65 and GAD67 mRNAs and proteins has evinced in the dorsal horn a differential regulation of the two isoforms. In situ hybridization has revealed, in the dorsal horn, relatively higher levels of GAD67 mRNA than of GAD65, while immunodetection of the proteins demonstrated numerous punctate profiles with both GAD antisera. Reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) data confirmed the abundance of the GAD67 transcripts compared to GAD65 in the rat spinal cord. In contrast, within the ventral horn, there was a greter number of GAD67-immunoreactive (IR) profiles mostly located around motoneurons. The paucity of GAD65 immunoreactivity in the ventral horn cannot be related to a different accessibility of the antigens to the epitopes since on the same section a dense GAD65 staining was detected in the dorsal horn. Hence, a number of biochemical and electrophysiological data support the concept of the involvement of glycine as the major inhibitory system within the ventral horn which may explain the low levels of GAD transcription in this region. The paucity of GAD65 in the ventral horn may also reflect a functional difference, suggesting a predominance of GAD67 in neurons under tonic activity. In the dorsal horn, where neurons with phasic and tonic firing patterns have been disclosed, GAD65 may, in addition, provide GABA for responses to short-term changes.

Transformations in null mutants of Hox genes: do they represent intercalary regenerates?

In the minds of many, Hox gene null mutant phenotypes have confirmed the direct role that these genes play in specifying the pattern of vertebrate embryos. The genes are envisaged as defining discrete spatial domains and, subsequently, conferring specific segmental identities on cells undergoing differentiation along the antero-posterior axis. However, several aspects of the observed mutant phenotypes are inconsistent with this view. These include: the appearance of other, unexpected transformations along the dorsal axis; the occurrence of mirror-image duplications; and the development of anomalies outside the established domains of normal Hox gene expression. In this paper, Hox gene disruptions are shown to elicit regeneration-like responses in tissues confronted with discontinuities in axial identity. The polarities and orientations of transformed segments which emerge as a consequence of this response obey the rules of distal transformation and intercalary regeneration. In addition, the incidence of periodic anomalies suggests that the initial steps of Hox-mediated patterning occurs in Hensen's node. As gastrulation proceeds, mesoderm cell cycle kinetics impose constraints upon subsequent cellular differentiation. This results in the delayed manifestation of transformations along the antero-posterior axis. Finally, a paradigm is sketched in which temporal, rather than spatial axial determinants direct differentiation. Specific, testable predictions are made about the role of Hox genes in the establishment of segmental identity.

Hst-1 (FGF-4) antisense oligonucleotides block murine limb development

The initiation of limb development depends on the site specific proliferation of the mesenchyme by the signals from the apical ectodermal ridge (AER) in embryonic mouse. We have previously reported that the local expression of Hst-1/Fgf-4 transcripts in AER of the mouse limb bud is developmentally regulated, expressed at 11 and 12 days post coitus (p.c.) embryo. In an effort to further understand the role of Hst-1/FGF-4 in mouse limb development, an antisense oligodeoxynucleotides (ODNs) study was performed. We first established a novel organ culture system to study mouse limb development in vitro. This system allows mouse limb bud at 9.5-10-d p.c. embryo, when placed on a sheet of extracellular matrix in a defined medium, to differentiate into a limb at 12.5-d p.c. embryo within 4.5 d. Using this organ culture system, we have shown that exposure of 9.5-10-d p.c. embryonal limb bud explants to antisense ODNs of Hst-1/FGF-4 blocks limb development. In contrast, sense and scrambled ODNs have no inhibitory effect on limb outgrowth, suggesting that Hst-1/FGF-4 may work as a potent inducing factor for mouse limb development.

Analysis of an enhancer trap expressed in regenerating Drosophila imaginal discs

In Drosophila, imaginal discs are the undifferentiated larval precursors of the pattern of epidermal and sensory neural cells in each adult segment. Although cell fates are already specified by late third instar, disc fragments can either regenerate or duplicate after growth in culture. The outcome depends on signaling between cells across the healed wound and involves a redeployment of the expression patterns of selector genes and other disc pattern genes. We recently used the enhancer-trap method to screen for such genes that are expressed ectopically at the wound-heal site in imaginal discs undergoing regeneration. Here we report the cloning by plasmid rescue of transcribed sequences adjacent to one such enhancer-trap insertion. Using Northern analysis and in situ hybridization we show that one transcript is expressed in the embryo and in imaginal discs in a pattern similar to that of the enhancer trap. We also, by imprecise excision of the enhancer-trap insertion, generated a series of flanking deletions that were mapped using Southern analysis and complementation.

Vertebrate limb development

The recent identification of Wnt-7a as a signalling molecule in dorsal/ventral patterning means that we now have a known signal for control of each of the three limb axes. Fibroblast growth factors can allow proximal/distal patterning and Sonic hedgehog gene expression signals anterior/posterior patterning. Networks of these signals not only coordinate cell responses, but also mutually maintain each other. A positive feedback loop is established which coordinates expression of Sonic hedgehog in mesenchyme cells of the polarizing region and Fgf-4 expression in overlying apical ridge ectoderm. Wnt-7a expression in dorsal ectoderm also influences Sonic hedgehog expression in the polarizing region. Initiation of development of a complete limb can be achieved with just one signal, a growth factor.

Regulation of HoxA expression in developing and regenerating axolotl limbs

Homeobox genes are important in the regulation of outgrowth and pattern formation during limb development. It is likely that homeobox genes play an equally important role during limb regeneration. We have isolated and identified 17 different homeobox-containing genes expressed by cells of regenerating axolotl limbs. Of these, nearly half of the clones represent genes belonging to the HoxA complex, which are thought to be involved in pattern formation along the proximal-distal limb axis. In this paper we report on the expression patterns of two 5′ members of this complex, HoxA13 and HoxA9. These genes are expressed in cells of developing limb buds and regenerating blastemas. The pattern of expression in developing axolotl limb buds is comparable to that in mouse and chick limb buds; the expression domain of HoxA13 is more distally restricted than that of HoxA9. As in developing mouse and chick limbs, HoxA13 likely functions in the specification of distal limb structures, and HoxA9 in the specification of more proximal structures. In contrast, during regeneration, HoxA13 and HoxA9 do not follow the rule of spatial colinearity observed in developing limbs. Instead, both genes are initially expressed in the same population of stump cells, giving them a distal Hox code regardless of the level of amputation. In addition, both are reexpressed within 24 hours after amputation, suggesting that reexpression may be synchronous rather than temporally colinear. Treatment with retinoic acid alters this Hox code to that of a more proximal region by the rapid and differential downregulation of HoxA13, at the same time that expression of HoxA9 is unaffected. HoxA reexpression occurs prior to blastema formation, 24–48 hours after amputation, and is an early molecular marker for dedifferentiation.

Re-programming of expression of the KGFR and bek variants of fibroblast growth factor receptor 2 during limb regeneration in newts (Notophthalmus viridescens)

We have previously shown, by in situ hybridization, that fibroblast growth factor receptor 2 (FGFR2) is present in the basal layer of wound epithelium during limb regeneration in newts (Notophthalmus viridescens). In contrast, FGFR1 expression is observed throughout the blastema mesenchyme but is distinctly absent from the wound epithelium (Poulin et al. [1993] Development 119:353-361). Sequence analysis revealed that we have isolated both the KGFR and bek variants of FGFR2. These two variants differ only in the second half of the last of their three (or two) Ig-like domains. In this report, we show the expression patterns of FGFR2 variants during limb regeneration by in situ hybridization. During the pre-blastema stages of regeneration, FGFR2 expression was observed in the basal layer of the wound epithelium and in the cells of the periosteum. The wound epithelial hybridization was observed when the KGFR-specific probe was used while the bek-specific probe hybridized to mRNA in the cells of the periosteum. As regeneration progresses to the blastema stages, KGFR expression continued to be observed in the basal layer of the wound epithelium with additional hybridization seen in the blastema mesenchyme closely associated with the bisected bones. The bek-specific hybridization pattern observed at this stage corresponds specifically to the mesenchymal hybridization. In the differentiation stages of regeneration, the mesenchymal expression of FGFR2 becomes restricted to the cells of the condensing cartilage and later to the perichondrium. Interestingly, there appears to be a dorsoventral gradient of the expression of both KGFR and bek variants of FGFR2, which are opposite each other at the later stages of regeneration. Thus, re-programming of expression of the two FGFR2 variants is required during the initial wound closure of limb regeneration. Remarkably, the expression patterns of KGFR and bek mimic those observed in the mouse limb bud during early embryonic development (Orr-Urtreger et al. [1993] Dev. Biol. 18:475-486). Moreover, our results suggest that the two FGFR2 variants have distinct roles in limb regeneration. Further investigation regarding the potential sources of the FGF ligands will help establish the roles that FGFs and FGFRs play in limb regeneration.

Distribution of all-trans-, 13-cis- and 9-cis-retinoic acid to whole rat embryos and maternal serum following oral administration of a teratogenic dose of all-trans-retinoic acid

Maternal administration of 200 mg/kg all-trans-retinoic acid to rat embryos at early limb stages of development (day 12 to day 13.5 post coitum) results in limb reduction defects. In order to determine the duration of exposure of the embryo to raised levels of all-trans-retinoic acid, we have used high performance liquid chromatography to measure retinoid levels at a series of time intervals following maternal administration on day 12.5 post coitum. Raised levels of all-trans-retinoic acid and 13-cis-retinoic acid were detectable in embryos after 30 min., reached a peak at 2 hr, and had fallen sharply by 4 hr. 13-cis-Retinoic acid levels were undetectable after 4 hr, and all-trans-retinoic acid levels after 8 hr. 9-cis-retinoic acid levels rose more slowly, were less elevated, and fell more gradually than the other two retinoids. The retinoid profiles in maternal serum were similar. The results indicate that induction of limb abnormalities by all-trans-retinoic acid in rat embryos is associated with a relatively short-term rise in embryonic retinoid levels.

Relationship between retinoic acid and sonic hedgehog, two polarizing signals in the chick wing bud

Local application of all-trans-retinoic acid (RA) to the anterior margin of chick limb buds results in pattern duplications reminescent of those that develop after grafting cells from the zone of polarizing activity (ZPA). RA may act directly by conferring positional information to limb bud cells, or it may act indirectly by creating a polarizing region in the tissue distal to the RA source. Here we demonstrate that tissue distal to an RA-releasing bead acquires polarizing activity in a dose-dependent manner. Treatments with pharmacological (beads soaked in 330 micrograms/ml) and physiological (beads soaked in 10 micrograms/ml) doses of RA are equally capable of inducing digit pattern duplication. Additionally, both treatments induce sonic hedgehog (shh; also known as vertebrate hedgehog-1, vhh-1), a putative ZPA morphogen and Hoxd-11, a gene induced by the polarizing signal. However, tissue transplantation assays reveal that pharmacological, but not physiological, doses create a polarizing region. This differential response could be explained if physiological doses induced less shh than pharmacological doses. However, our in situ hybridization analyses demonstrate that both treatments result in similar amounts of mRNA encoding this candidate ZPA morphogen. We outline a model describing the apparently disparate effects of pharmacologic and physiological doses RA on limb bud tissue.

Elastin exhibits a distinctive temporal and spatial pattern of distribution in the developing chick limb in association with the establishment of the cartilaginous skeleton

In this work we have analyzed the presence of elastic components in the extracellular matrices of the developing chick leg bud. The distributions of elastin and fibrillin were studied immunohistochemically in whole-mount preparations using confocal laser microscopy. The association of these constituents of the elastic matrix with other components of the extracellular matrix was also studied, using several additional antibodies. Our results reveal the transient presence of an elastin-rich scaffold of extracellular matrix fibrillar material in association with the establishment of the cartilaginous skeleton of the leg bud. The scaffold consisted of elastin-positive fibers extending from the ectodermal surface of the limb to the central cartilage-forming regions and between adjacent cartilages. Fibrillin immunolabeling was negative in this fibrillar scaffold while other components of the extracellular matrix including: tenascin, laminin and collagens type I, type III and type VI; appeared codistributed with elastin in some regions of the scaffold. Progressive changes in the spatial pattern of distribution of the elastin-positive scaffold were detected in explant cultures in which one expects a modification in the mechanical stresses of the tissues related to growth. A scaffold of elastin comparable to that found in vivo was also observed in high-density micromass cultures of isolated limb mesodermal cells. In this case the elastic fibers are observed filling the spaces located between the cartilaginous nodules. The fibers become reoriented and attach to the ectodermal basal surface when an ectodermal fragment is located at the top of the growing micromass. Our results suggest that the formation of the cartilaginous skeleton of the limb involves the segregation of the undifferentiated limb mesenchyme into chondrogenic and elastogenic cell lineages. Further, a role for the elastic fiber scaffold in coordinating the size and the spatial location of the cartilaginous skeletal elements within the limb bud is also suggested from our observations.

Cleft hand/foot: clinical and developmental aspects

Isolated limb reduction defects occur in approximately 1 in 2000 live births within which central ray anomalies are an important subgroup. Most affected persons have mild or moderate functional impairment. Considerable psychological morbidity may also occur. While there have been major strides forwards in our understanding of vertebrate limb development, the mechanisms responsible for central ray deformities remain poorly understood. Several case reports of central clefting anomalies associated with chromosomal rearrangements or interstitial deletions of 7q21.2-q21.3 suggest that this chromosomal region is important for limb development.

Retinoic acid and homeobox gene regulation

Hox genes have been shown to be important regulators of pattern formation in vertebrates. Retinoic acid has been shown to affect the expression of Hox genes in vitro and in vivo, and some of its effects on development correspond to changes in Hox gene expression. The idea that retinoic acid is not simply a powerful pharmocological agent, but rather that it plays an important role in creating the normal expression patterns of Hox genes, is provided by the recent identification of retinoic acid responsive enhancers near Hox genes.

Limb and lower-body duplications induced by retinoic acid in mice

The zygote and subsequent preimplantation stages of early mammalian development are susceptible to certain chemical perturbations that cause abnormal development of the conceptus. In certain cases, disruption in patterns of gene expression could be a primary event leading to abnormal development. To investigate this hypothesis, we treated pregnant mice with trans-retinoic acid, a known modulator of gene expression. Treatments were administered at various times during pregastrulation stages and the presumed onset of gastrulation. trans-Retinoic acid induced a distinctive set of malformations, as manifest by supernumerary and ectopic limbs and duplication of portions of the lower body, but only when administered during the period of 4.5-5.5 days after mating. (Other malformations were induced at different stages.) The limb and lower-body duplications suggest that exogenous trans-retinoic acid may influence not only the pattern for the hindlimbs but also that for the entire lower body. Since it appears likely that the embryos were affected in the late blastocyst and proamniotic-embryo stages, the provocative possibility arises that aspects of pattern formation of limbs and lower body actually occur prior to gastrulation.

Inhibition of the chondrocyte phenotype by retinoic acid involves upregulation of metalloprotease genes independent of TGF-beta

Retinoic acid has been identified as a key morphogen governing pattern formation in the developing cartilaginous skeleton. Retinoids have also been implicated in the premature closure of the cartilage growth plate following vitamin A intoxication or administration of retinoids for dermatologic conditions. Previous studies of the mechanism of action of retinoids in non-chondrogenic cells have concluded that retinoic acid is a negative regulator of AP-1 responsive metalloprotease genes. We show that inhibition of expression of the cartilage phenotype by retinoic acid in epiphyseal chondrocytes is associated with positive regulation of AP-1 responsive metalloprotease genes, as well as induction of gene expression for the two components of the transcription factor AP-1, c-fos and c-jun. Despite the similar effects of TGF-beta 1 on expression of cartilage matrix proteins and metalloproteases in this culture system, no appreciable changes in the expression of TGF-beta isoforms were evident in response to retinoic acid treatment. The present investigation demonstrates that regulation of AP-1 responsive genes by retinoic acid can be either positive or negative, depending on the target cell type, and illuminates new mechanisms by which retinoic acid and other retinoids may exert control during development and growth of the limb.

New approaches to amphibian limb regeneration

Limb regeneration in urodele amphibians proceeds by the formation of a blastema, a growth zone of mesenchymal progenitor cells. Here, I review the origin of the blastema and its positional identity. The ability to culture and reimplant newt blastemal cells, and to transfect them in culture and in situ using a particle delivery system, has yielded new information about the action of retinoic acid on the blastema and the reversal of muscle differentiation during limb regeneration.

Pattern duplication by retinoic acid treatment in the regenerating limbs of Korean salamander larvae, Hynobius leechii, correlates well with the extent of dedifferentiation

In the regenerating limbs of Korean salamanders, Hynobius leechii, retinoic acid (RA) induces duplication of skeletal structures in the proximodistal (PD) axis and often in the transverse axes. In the present study, the stage-dependent effects of RA for the duplication of limb skeletal structures at two amputation levels, the distal stylopodium and the distal zeugopodium, were studied using larval limbs of Korean salamanders. The results showed that the mean level of proximalization (MLP) by RA treatment increased during the stages of dedifferentiation and early bud formation while the MLP declined thereafter in both amputation levels. The decline of the MLP at the later stages of regeneration was due to the high frequency of hypomorphic regeneration or blocked regeneration. When the effects of RA treatment at two amputation levels were compared, the overall trends were similar but the actual timing was delayed for 2-4 days in the proximal level of amputation. Furthermore, the peak level of proximalization was achieved earlier and the peak level remained longer in the distal stylopodial level of amputation compared to the distal zeugopodial level of amputation. Since the histological observations revealed that the dedifferentiation period was also extended up to 2-4 days in the proximal level of amputation, the acid phosphatase activity during the course of regeneration was measured to look for a quantitative relationship between the enzyme activity and the states of dedifferentiation. The results show that the level and the duration of acid phosphatase activity in the upper arm regenerates are both higher and longer than those in the lower arm regenerates. Furthermore, RA treatment caused an increase in acid phosphatase activity. Thus our results suggest that the state of dedifferentiation might be closely linked to the extent of proximalization of regenerating limbs by RA treatment.

Isoform-specific induction of a retinoid-responsive antigen after biolistic transfection of chimaeric retinoic acid/thyroid hormone receptors into a regenerating limb

Retinoic acid (RA) induces secretory differentiation in the wound epidermis of a regenerating amphibian limb. We investigated the role of individual RA receptor (RAR) types in the newt wound epidermis by introducing chimaeric RA/thyroid hormone (T3) receptors (chi alpha 1 and chi delta 1) that can be activated by T3. A biolistic particle delivery system was employed to transfect cells in the wound epidermis of a regenerating limb and approximately 10% of the cells in targeted surface areas expressed marker genes. Both chi alpha 1 and chi delta 1 were comparable in their ability to stimulate transcription of a synthetic reporter construct through a RA response element after activation with T3 in situ. This activation was also comparable to that obtained by the endogenous complement of RARs in the RA-treated, transfected wound epidermis. The RA-inducible WE3 antigen, a marker for secretory differentiation, which distinguishes the wound epidermis from normal skin (Tassava, R. A., Johnson-Wint, B. and Gross, J. 1986, J. Exp. Zool. 239, 229–240), was used to assess the functional role of chi alpha 1 and chi delta 1. Chimaeric receptors were transfected with an alkaline phosphatase marker gene, activated with T3, and the expression of both the marker and WE3 was analyzed by double-label immunofluorescence. Newt limbs transfected with chi delta 1 showed many double-labelled cells dependent on the presence of T3, whereas contralateral limbs transfected with an alkaline phosphatase marker lacking chimaeric receptor sequences did not.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

The effect of vitamin A (retinoids) on pattern formation implies a uniformity of developmental mechanisms throughout the animal kingdom

Retinoids are low molecular weight, lipophilic derivatives of vitamin A which have a profound effect upon the development of a diverse array of animals. Here, I review these effects on Invertebrates: a colonial hydroid, a colonial ascidian, and Vertebrates: the regenerating amphibian limb, the developing chick limb bud, the regenerating amphibian tail, the anteroposterior axis of the early embryo, the developing chick embryo skin. There is a striking uniformity of effect of retinoids on pattern formation when applied to these diverse organisms. The majority react by being posteriorized in their development, although additional effects can also be seen. Several hypotheses which can explain these results are discussed along with the deduction that they lead to: retinoids may be components of a universal developmental mechanism or they may simply act in a similar way to alter a universal developmental mechanism. In either case the experimental analysis of retinoid effects on development has important implications for the evolution of developmental mechanisms.

Test of a model for the effects of retinoic acid on urodele limb regeneration

Previous studies have shown that in axolotls (Ambystoma mexicanum), retinoic acid (RA) treatment evokes pattern completion in limb regenerates derived from anterior and dorsal half zeugopodia (lower arms and legs), but causes regenerative failure in posterior and ventral half zeugopodia. Pattern completion in anterior and dorsal half limbs may be explained by postulating that intercalary regeneration occurs in the antero-posterior (AP) and dorsoventral (DV) axes between blastema cells that are posteriorized (anterior half limb) or ventralized (dorsal half limb) by RA, and circumferential anterodorsal cells that remain unaffected by RA and thus maintain their original positional identities. The contrasting regenerative failure of RA-treated posterior and ventral half zeugopodia may likewise be explained by postulating that all the blastema cells in the posterior half are posteriorized, and all the cells in the ventral half are ventralized by RA, thus eliminating differentials in transverse positional identity essential for blastema formation and outgrowth. To test these postulates we grafted blastemas derived from limbs halved in the AP and DV axes of control and RA-treated animals to untreated whole limb stumps and analyzed the patterns of supernumerary (SN) regeneration. The site or location of SN formation will demonstrate (1) whether RA has posteriorized and ventralized the positional identity of the blastema cells and (2) if blastema cells in the periphery of the anterodorsal quadrant of the limb are resistant to these RA-induced changes in positional identity.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Heterogeneity in the expression of fibroblast growth factor receptors during limb regeneration in newts (Notophthalmus viridescens)

Two closely related fibroblast growth factor receptors, FGFR1 and FGFR2, have been cloned from a newt (Notophthalmus viridescens) limb blastema cDNA library. Sequence analysis revealed that we have isolated both the bek and KGFR variants of FGFR2. These two variants differ only in the second half of the last of their three Ig-like domains. The expression patterns of FGFR1 and FGFR2 during limb regeneration have been determined by in situ hybridization. During the preblastema stages of regeneration, FGFR2 expression is observed in the basal layer of the wound epithelium and in the cells of the periosteum. As regeneration progresses to the blastema stages, FGFR2 expression continues to be observed in the basal layer of the wound epithelium with additional hybridization seen in the blastema mesenchyme closely associated with the bisected bones. From the early bud to the mid-bud blastema stage, FGFR1 expression is observed throughout the blastema mesenchyme but, unlike FGFR2, is distinctly absent from the wound epithelium. In the differentiation stages of regeneration, the mesenchymal expression of FGFR2 becomes restricted to the cells of the condensing cartilage and later to the perichondrium. During these later stages of regeneration, the wound epithelium hybridization to the FGFR2 probe is no longer observed. The expression patterns of these receptors suggest that FGFR1 and FGFR2 have distinct roles in limb regeneration, despite their sharing a number of the FGF ligands. Further investigation regarding the potential sources of the FGF ligands will help establish the role that FGFs and FGFRs play in limb regeneration.

Retinoic acid induction and regional differentiation prefigure olfactory pathway formation in the mammalian forebrain

We have used an in vitro assay to identify sources of retinoic acid (RA) and transgenic mice to identify target domains in the developing forebrain. RA participates in a sequence of events that leads to the establishment of the olfactory pathway. First, the lateral cranial mesoderm activates an RA-inducible transgene in neuroepithelial cells in the olfactory placode and the ventrolateral forebrain. Then, neurons and neurites begin to differentiate in these two regions. Finally, olfactory axons grow specifically into the ventrolateral forebrain and subsequently are limited to the olfactory bulb rudiment. The coordination of these events, perhaps by common signals, implies that retinoid induction and retinoid-activated region-specific transcriptional regulation may help to define a forebrain subdivision and the peripheral neurons that provide its primary innervation.

Embryonic induction

The current understanding of the mechanism of embryonic induction is reviewed. The embryological data which are necessary to establish the existence of an inductive process are described and the criteria for the identification of inducing factors are discussed. These criteria comprise: a demonstration that the factor has the appropriate biological activity, that it is expressed in biologically available form at the correct time and place in the embryo, and that when it is inhibited in vivo, the interaction should fail. Current understanding of the molecular basis of competence and threshold responses is discussed. Four case studies are examined in further detail: the dorsoventral patterning in Drosophila is controlled by a gradient of the decapentaplegic gene product, a member of the TGF beta superfamily. Mesoderm induction in Xenopus embryos is thought to be controlled by several factors acting in concert: activins, fibroblast growth factors (FGFs), Wnt proteins and bone morphogenetic proteins (BMPs). The formation of the kidney in higher vertebrates involves a permissive interaction and some molecules are known to be necessary for the process but the identity of the primary inducing signal remains elusive. The anteroposterior pattern in the chick limb is controlled by a morphogen gradient emitted by the zone of polarising activity (ZPA). Although closely mimicked by retinoic acid (RA), this substance is probably not itself the morphogen. In general, the technical advances of recent years have enabled dramatic progress to be made in understanding the molecular basis of embryonic induction. Although much remains to be done, the methods of investigation are now well established.

Different distributions of GAD65 and GAD67 mRNAs suggest that the two glutamate decarboxylases play distinctive functional roles

Two genes encode two forms of glutamate decarboxylase, GAD65 and GAD67. Because the two GADs differ in subcellular distribution and interactions with the cofactor pyridoxal phosphate, the two enzymes may play different roles in gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA) production. In this study we have used in situ hybridization to compare the regional and cellular distributions of the two GAD mRNAs in rat brain. Both GAD mRNAs are abundant in olfactory bulb, olfactory tubercle, zona incerta, reticular nucleus of the thalamus, oculomotor nuclei, and pontine tegmental area. GAD65 mRNA is more abundant in several structures of the visual system, including the lateral geniculate nuclei, superior colliculi, and olivary pretectal nucleus, as well as in several hypothalamic and pontine nuclei. In contrast, GAD67 mRNA is more abundant in neocortex, the granular layer of olfactory bulb, lateral and medial septum, globus pallidus, inferior colliculi, and cerebellar cortex. Both GAD mRNAs are present in interneurons as well as in projection neurons, and both are present in neurons with different types of synapses, including dendrodendiritic, axosomatic, and axodendritic synapses. GAD65 mRNA predominates in the visual and the neuroendocrine systems, which are more subject to phasic changes, while GAD67 is present at relatively higher concentrations in many tonically active neurons. GAD65 and GAD67 together may provide more flexibility in the regulation of GABA synthesis than either could alone.

Isoform-specific immunological detection of newt retinoic acid receptor delta 1 in normal and regenerating limbs

Retinoic acid (RA) exerts a variety of effects on the regenerating urodele limb including positional respecification of the blastema. The major RA receptor expressed in the newt limb and blastema is the delta 1 isoform and, in order to detect delta 1 in this context, we have made five affinity-purified antibodies against fusion proteins and peptides from non-overlapping regions of the molecule. These antibodies have been evaluated by reaction with transfected COS-7 cells, newt limb cells in culture and newt limb tissue sections. The most informative antibodies were RP6, directed against N-terminal region A sequence, and RP8, directed against C-terminal sequence. In western blots of blastemal extracts, delta 1 protein was detected as two major bands of immunoreactivity at positions consistent with the employment of two candidate methionine initiators identified by cDNA sequencing. Staining of adult limb sections with RP6 and RP8 showed reactivity in half of the nuclei in epidermal and mesenchymal tissues, a heterogeneity that was observed with adjacent nuclei in muscle fibres. In the regenerating limb, nuclei in the blastemal mesenchyme and wound epidermis were strongly reactive, although no axial variation in expression was detected.

Pattern formation in a secondary field: a hierarchy of regulatory genes subdivides the developing Drosophila wing disc into discrete subregions

The legs and wings of insects and vertebrates develop from secondary embryonic fields that arise after the primary body axes have been established. In order to understand how the insect imaginal wing field is patterned, we have examined in detail the temporal and spatial expression patterns of, and epistatic relationships between, four key regulatory genes that are specifically required for wing formation in Drosophila. The wingless protein, in a role surprisingly distinct from its embryonic segment polarity function, appears to be the earliest-acting member of the hierarchy and crucial for distinguishing the notum/wing subfields, and for the compartmentalization of the dorsal and ventral wing surfaces. The wingless product is required to restrict the expression of the apterous gene to dorsal cells and to promote the expression of the vestigial and scalloped genes that demarcate the wing primordia and act in concert to promote morphogenesis.