The nucleotide sequence at the origin for assembly on tobacco mosaic virus RNA

Tobacco mosaic virus assembly and disassembly: determinants in pathogenicity and resistance

The structural proteins of plant viruses have evolved to self-associate into complex macromolecules that are centrally involved in virus biology. In this review, the structural and biophysical properties of the Tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) coat protein (CP) are addressed in relation to its role in host resistance and disease development. TMV CP affects the display of several specific virus and host responses, including cross-protection, systemic virus movement, hypersensitive disease resistance, and symptom development. Studies indicate that the three-dimensional structure of CP is critical to the control of these responses, either directly through specific structural motifs or indirectly via alterations in CP assembly. Thus, both the structure and assembly of the TMV CP function as determinants in the induction of disease and resistance responses.

Conundrum of the lack of defective RNAs (dRNAs) associated with tobamovirus Infections: dRNAs that can move are not replicated by the wild-type virus; dRNAs that are replicated by the wild-type virus do not move

Two classes of artificially constructed defective RNAs (dRNAs) of Tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) were examined in planta with helper viruses that expressed one (183 kDa) or both (126 and 183 kDa) of the replicase-associated proteins. The first class of artificially constructed dRNAs had the helicase and polymerase (POL) domains deleted; the second had an intact 126-kDa protein open reading frame (ORF). Despite extremely high levels of replication in protoplasts, the first class of dRNAs did not accumulate in plants. The dRNAs with an intact 126-kDa protein ORF were replicated at moderate levels in protoplasts and in planta when supported by a TMV mutant that expressed the 183-kDa protein but not the 126-kDa protein (183F). These dRNAs were not supported by helper viruses expressing both replicase-associated proteins. De novo dRNAs were generated in plants infected by 183F but not in plants infected with virus with the wild-type replicase. These novel dRNAs each contained a new stop codon near the location of the wild-type stop codon for the 126-kDa protein and had most of the POL domain deleted. The fact that only dRNAs that contained a complete 126-kDa protein ORF moved systemically suggests that expression of a functional 126-kDa protein or the presence of certain sequences and/or structures within this ORF is required for movement of dRNAs. At least two factors may contribute to the lack of naturally occurring dRNAs in association with wild-type TMV infections: an inability of TMV to support dRNAs that can move in plants and the inability of dRNAs that can be replicated by TMV to move in plants.

Roles of partly unfolded conformations in macromolecular self-assembly

From genes to cells there are many steps of hierarchical increments in building up complex frameworks that provide intricate networks of macromolecular interactions, through which cellular activities such as gene expression, signal processing, energy transduction and material conversion are dynamically organized and regulated. The self-assembly of macromolecules into large complexes is one such important step, but this process is by no means a simple aggregation of macromolecules with predefined, rigid complementary structures. In many cases the component molecules undergo either domain rearrangements or folding of disordered portions, which occurs only following binding to their correct partners. The partial disorder is used in some cases to prevent spontaneous assembly at inappropriate times or locations. It is also often used for finely tuning the equilibrium and activation energy of reversible binding. In other cases, such as protein translocation across membranes, an unfolded terminus appears to be the prerequisite for the process as an initiation signal, as well as the physical necessity to be taken into narrow channels. Self-assembly processes of viruses and bacterial flagella are typical examples where the induced folding of disordered chains plays a key role in regulating the addition of new components to a growing assembly. Various aspects of mechanistic roles of natively unfolded conformations of proteins are overviewed and discussed in this short review.

The tobacco mosaic virus particle: structure and assembly

A short account is given of the physical and chemical studies that have led to an understanding of the structure of the tobacco mosaic virus particle and how it is assembled from its constituent coat protein and RNA. The assembly is a much more complex process than might have been expected from the simplicity of the helical design of the particle. The protein forms an obligatory intermediate (a cylindrical disk composed of two layers of protein units), which recognizes a specific RNA hairpin sequence. This extraordinary mechanism simultaneously fulfils the physical requirement for nucleating the growth of the helical particle and the biological requirement for specific recognition of the viral DNA.

Elucidation of the genome organization of tobacco mosaic virus

Proteins unique to tobacco mosaic virus (TMV)-infected plants were detected in the 1970s by electrophoretic analyses of extracts of virus-infected tissues, comparing their proteins to those generated in extracts of uninfected tissues. The genome organization of TMV was deduced principally from studies involving in vitro translation of proteins from the genomic and subgenomic messenger RNAs. The ultimate analysis of the TMV genome came in 1982 when P. Goelet and colleagues sequenced the entire genome. Studies leading to the elucidation of the TMV genome organization are described below.

Self-assembly of tobacco mosaic virus: the role of an intermediate aggregate in generating both specificity and speed

The tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) particle was the first macromolecular structure to be shown to self-assemble in vitro, allowing detailed studies of the mechanism. Nucleation of TMV self-assembly is by the binding of a specific stem-loop of the single-stranded viral RNA into the central hole of a two-ring sub-assembly of the coat protein, known as the 'disk'. Binding of the loop onto its specific binding site, between the two rings of the disk, leads to melting of the stem so more RNA is available to bind. The interaction of the RNA with the protein subunits in the disk cause this to dislocate into a proto-helix, rearranging the protein subunits in such a way that the axial gap between the rings at inner radii closes, entrapping the RNA. Assembly starts at an internal site on TMV RNA, about 1 kb from its 3'-terminus, and the elongation in the two directions is different. Elongation of the nucleated rods towards the 5'-terminus occurs on a 'travelling loop' of the RNA and, predominantly, still uses the disk sub-assembly of protein subunits, consequently incorporating approximately 100 further nucleotides as each disk is added, while elongation towards the 3'-terminus uses smaller protein aggregates and does not show this 'quantized' incorporation.

Milestones in the research on tobacco mosaic virus

Beijerinck's (1898) recognition that the cause of tobacco mosaic disease was a novel kind of pathogen became the breakthrough which eventually led to the establishment of virology as a science. Research on this agent, tobacco mosaic virus (TMV), has continued to be at the forefront of virology for the past century. After an initial phase, in which numerous biological properties of TMV were discovered, its particles were the first shown to consist of RNA and protein, and X-ray diffraction analysis of their structure was the first of a helical nucleoprotein. In the molecular biological phase of research, TMV RNA was the first plant virus genome to be sequenced completely, its genes were found to be expressed by cotranslational particle disassembly and the use of subgenomic mRNA, and the mechanism of assembly of progeny particles from their separate parts was discovered. Molecular genetical and cell biological techniques were then used to clarify the roles and modes of action of the TMV non-structural proteins: the 126 kDa and 183 kDa replicase components and the 30 kDa cell-to-cell movement protein. Three different TMV genes were found to act as avirulence genes, eliciting hypersensitive responses controlled by specific, but different, plant genes. One of these (the N gene) was the first plant gene controlling virus resistance to be isolated and sequenced. In the biotechnological sphere, TMV has found several applications: as the first source of transgene sequences conferring virus resistance, in vaccines consisting of TMV particles genetically engineered to carry foreign epitopes, and in systems for expressing foreign genes. TMV owes much of its popularity as a research mode to the great stability and high yield of its particles. Although modern methods have much decreased the need for such properties, and TMV may have a less dominant role in the future, it continues to occupy a prominent position in both fundamental and applied research.

Tobacco mosaic virus particle structure and the initiation of disassembly

The structure of an intact tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) particle was determined at 2.9 A resolution using fibre diffraction methods. All residues of the coat protein and the three nucleotides of RNA that are bound to each protein subunit were visible in the electron density map. Examination of the structures of TMV, cucumber green mottle mosaic virus and ribgrass mosaic virus, and site-directed mutagenesis experiments in which carboxylate groups were changed to the corresponding amides, showed that initial stages of disassembly are driven by complex electrostatic interactions involving at least seven carboxylate side-chains and a phosphate group. The locations of these interactions can drift during evolution, allowing the viruses to evade plant defensive responses that depend on recognition of the viral coat protein surface.

Historical overview of research on the tobacco mosaic virus genome: genome organization, infectivity and gene manipulation

Early in the development of molecular biology, TMV RNA was widely used as a mRNA [corrected] that could be purified easily, and it contributed much to research on protein synthesis. Also, in the early stages of elucidation of the genetic code, artificially produced TMV mutants were widely used and provided the first proof that the genetic code was non-overlapping. In 1982, Goelet et al. determined the complete TMV RNA base sequence of 6395 nucleotides. The four genes (130K, 180K, 30K and coat protein) could then be mapped at precise locations in the TMV genome. Furthermore it had become clear, a little earlier, that genes located internally in the genome were expressed via subgenomic mRNAs. The initiation site for assembly of TMV particles was also determined. However, although TMV contributed so much at the beginning of the development of molecular biology, its influence was replaced by that of Escherichia coli and its phages in the next phase. As recombinant DNA technology developed in the 1980s, RNA virus research became more detached from the frontier of molecular biology. To recover from this setback, a gene-manipulation system was needed for RNA viruses. In 1986, two such systems were developed for TMV, using full-length cDNA clones, by Dawson's group and by Okada's group. Thus, reverse genetics could be used to elucidate the basic functions of all proteins encoded by the TMV genome. Identification of the function of the 30K protein was especially important because it was the first evidence that a plant virus possesses a cell-to-cell movement function. Many other plant viruses have since been found to encode comparable 'movement proteins'. TMV thus became the first plant virus for which structures and functions were known for all its genes. At the birth of molecular plant pathology, TMV became a leader again. TMV has also played pioneering roles in many other fields. TMV was the first virus for which the amino acid sequence of the coat protein was determined and first virus for which cotranslational disassembly was demonstrated both in vivo and in vitro. It was the first virus for which activation of a resistance gene in a host plant was related to the molecular specificity of a product of a viral gene. Also, in the field of plant biotechnology, TMV vectors are among the most promising. Thus, for the 100 years since Beijerinck's work, TMV research has consistently played a leading role in opening up new areas of study, not only in plant pathology, but also in virology, biochemistry, molecular biology, RNA genetics and biotechnology.

Structure of ribgrass mosaic virus at 2.9 A resolution: evolution and taxonomy of tobamoviruses

Ribgrass mosaic virus (RMV) is a member of the tobamovirus group of plant viruses. The structure has been determined at 2.9 A resolution by fiber diffraction methods, and refined by molecular dynamics methods to an R-factor of 0.095. The carboxyl-carboxylate interactions that drive disassembly in tobamoviruses are present in RMV, but are very different from those in other tobamoviruses. RMV has some of the structural features of a subgroup I tobamovirus, a smaller number from subgroup II, and a number that appear to be unique to the RMV cluster of viruses. The structural studies confirm the evolutionary and taxonomic separation of the RMV cluster from both subgroup I and subgroup II tobamoviruses.

Encapsidation of turnip crinkle virus is defined by a specific packaging signal and RNA size

A protoplast infection assay has been used to reliably examine the viral RNA encapsidation of turnip crinkle virus (TCV). Analysis of the encapsidation of various mutant viral RNAs revealed that a 186-nucleotide (nt) region at the 3' end of the coat protein (CP) gene, with a bulged hairpin loop of 28 nt as its most essential element, was indispensable for TCV RNA encapsidation. When RNA fragments containing the 186-nt region were used to replace the CP gene of a different virus, tomato bushy stunt virus, the resulting chimeric viral RNAs were encapsidated into TCV virions. Furthermore, analysis of the encapsidated chimeric RNA species established that the RNA size was an important determinant of the TCV assembly process.

Bidirectional uncoating of the genomic RNA of a helical virus

An essential step in the initiation of a virus infection is the release of the viral genome from the other constituents of the virus particle, a process referred to as uncoating. We have used reverse transcription and polymerase chain reaction amplification procedures to determine the rate and direction of in vivo uncoating of the rod-shaped tobacco mosaic virus. The virus particles contain a single 6.4-kb RNA molecule that lies between successive turns of a helical arrangement of coat protein subunits. When the particles are introduced into plant cells, the subunits are removed via a bidirectional uncoating mechanism. Within 2-3 min, the part of the viral RNA from the 5' end to a position >70% toward the 3' end has been freed of coat protein subunits. This is followed by removal of subunits from the 3' end of the RNA and sequential uncoating of the RNA in a 3'-to-5' direction. An internal region of the viral RNA is the final part to be uncoated. Progeny virus particles are detected in the cells 35-40 min after inoculation.

Expression of tobacco mosaic virus coat protein and assembly of pseudovirus particles in Escherichia coli

The bidirectional self-assembly of tobacco mosaic virus (TMV, common or U1 strain) has been studied extensively in vitro. Foreign single-stranded RNA molecules containing the TMV origin-of-assembly sequence (OAS, 75-432 nt in length) are also packaged by TMV coat protein (CP) in vitro to form helical pseudovirus particles. To study virus assembly in vivo requires an easily manipulated model system, independent of replication in plants. The TMV assembly machinery also provides a convenient means to protect and recover chimeric gene transcripts of almost any length or sequence for a variety of applications. Native TMV CP expressed in and purified from Escherichia coli formed nonhelical, stacked aggregates after dialysis into pH 5 buffer and was inactive for in vitro assembly with TMV RNA. U1 CP derivatives in which the second amino acid was changed from Ser to Ala or Pro, nonacetylated N termini found in two natural strains of the virus, failed to remediate these anomalous properties. However, in vivo coexpression of CP and single-stranded RNAs (up to approximately 2 kb) containing the TMV OAS gave high yields of helical pseudovirus particles of the predicted length (up to 7.4 +/- 1.4 micrograms/mg of total bacterial protein). If the OAS-containing RNA was first recruited into bacterial polyribosomes, elongation of pseudovirus assembly was blocked. In vivo, E. coli expression of a full-length cDNA clone of the TMV genome (6.4 kb) resulted in high, immunodetectable levels of CP and assembly of sufficient intact genomic RNA to initiate systemic infection of susceptible tobacco plants.

Electron microscopic and molecular characterization of turnip vein-clearing virus

We recently isolated turnip vein-clearing virus (TVCV), a tobamovirus which causes vein clearing in Brassica rapa (turnip) and a mosaic in Nicotiana tabacum (tobacco). We present an electron microscopic and molecular characterization of TVCV. Viral particles from lower epidermis peel contained rod-shaped viral particles, typical of tobamoviruses. Viral RNA extracted from infected turnip leaves was used as template for cDNA synthesis prior to cloning in a plasmid vector. Inserts of selected cDNA clones were sequenced to obtain the nucleotide sequence of the 126 K replicase component. The nucleotide and predicted amino acid sequences were 56 to 59% identical to those of most other sequenced tobamoviruses. The least related sequence, that of cucumber green mottle mosaic virus, was more related to the TVCV lineage than it was to those of the other sequenced tobamoviruses. UV spectroscopy suggested a tryptophan content characteristic of the ribgrass mosaic virus (RMV) group. Fragmentation of the TVCV coat protein by cyanogen bromide treatment produced a profile of fragments indistinguishable from those generated from the coat protein of RMV. Thus, while symptoms of TVCV infection on Nicotiana tabacum cv. Samsun and Nicotiana clevelandii differ from those reported for RMV, TVCV appears to be closely related to RMV.

Assembly of tobacco mosaic virus and TMV-like pseudovirus particles in Escherichia coli

High-level expression of plant viral proteins, including coat protein (CP), is possible in Escherichia coli. Native tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) CP expressed in E. coli remains soluble but has a non-acetylated N-terminal Ser residue and following extraction, is unable to package TMV RNA in vitro under standard assembly conditions. Changing the Ser to Ala or Pro by PCR-mutagenesis did not confer assembly competence in vitro, despite these being non-acetylated N-termini present in two natural strains of TMV. All TMV CPs made in E. coli formed stacked cylindrical aggregates in vitro at pH 5.0 and failed to be immunogold-labelled using a mouse monoclonal antibody specific for helically assembled TMV CP. TMV self-assembly has been studied extensively in vitro, and an origin of assembly sequence (OAS) mapped internally on the 6.4 kb ssRNA genome. Pseudovirus particles can be assembled mono- or bi-directionally in vitro using virus-derived CP and chimeric ssRNAs containing the cognate TMV OAS, but otherwise of unlimited length and sequence. Studies on plant virus assembly in vivo would be facilitated by a model system amenable to site-directed mutagenesis and rapid recovery of progeny particles. When chimeric transcripts containing the TMV OAS were co-expressed with TMV CP in vivo for 2-18 h, helical TMV-like ribonucleoprotein particles of the predicted length were formed in high yield (up to 7.4 micrograms/mg total bacterial protein). In addition to providing a rapid, inexpensive and convenient system to produce, protect and recover chimeric gene transcripts of any length or sequence, this E. coli system also offers a rapid approach for studying the molecular requirements for plant virus "self-assembly" in vivo. Transcription of a full-length cDNA clone of TMV RNA also resulted in high levels of CP expression and assembly of sufficient intact genomic RNA to initiate virus infection of susceptible tobacco plants.

Evidence that the packaging signal for nodaviral RNA2 is a bulged stem-loop

Flock house virus is an insect virus belonging to the family Nodaviridae; members of this family are characterized by a small bipartite positive-stranded RNA genome. The larger genomic segment, RNA1, encodes viral replication proteins, whereas the smaller one, RNA2, encodes coat protein. Both RNAs are packaged in a single particle. A defective-interfering RNA (DI-634), isolated from a line of Drosophila cells persistently infected with Flock house virus, was used to show that a 32-base region of RNA2 (bases 186-217) is required for packaging into virions. RNA folding analysis predicted that this region forms a stem-loop structure with a 5-base loop and a 13-base-pair bulged stem.

Structure of the U2 strain of tobacco mosaic virus refined at 3.5 A resolution using X-ray fiber diffraction

The structure of the U2 strain of tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) has been determined by fiber diffraction methods at 3.5 A resolution, and refined by a combination of restrained least-squares and molecular dynamics methods to an R-factor of 0.096. The structure is extremely similar to that of the common strain of TMV, with the largest differences being in the protein loop that makes up the inner surface of the virus, and in the C-terminal region on the outer surface. Differences in the inner loop can be correlated with differences in the properties of the two viruses.

Structure of tobraviral particles: a model suggested from sequence conservation in tobraviral and tobamoviral coat proteins

Comparisons of the coat protein sequences of four tobraviruses with those of seven tobamoviruses indicate that these proteins share a common evolutionary origin. Numerous amino acids for which specific functions have been identified in the molecular structure of the tobacco mosaic virus vulgare protein have identical or closely similar counterparts among the tobraviral proteins. These include those with roles in the hydrophobic core of the protein, those that contribute to the RNA binding site and those involved in the control of virus assembly. We suggest a model for the structure of the tobraviral particle that not only offers an explanation for the greater diameter of the tobraviral particle but also confirms an early suggestion for RNA placement within this particle.

Effects of terminal deletion mutations on function of the movement protein of tobacco mosaic virus

A series of carboxy- and amino-terminal deletion mutations in the movement protein (MP) gene of tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) were ligated into a cloned TMV cDNA deleted for the endogenous MP gene. RNA transcripts were produced in vitro from clones carrying the various mutated MP genes. The effect of the deletion mutations on local and systemic movements of the infection was evaluated. Deletion of 9 or 33 amino acids from the carboxy terminus of the movement protein did not effect cell-to-cell movement as reflected by local lesion formation on Nicotiana tabacum cv. Xanthi NN plants. Deletion of 55 amino acids resulted in impaired MP that supported the formation of local lesions of 1 mm in diameter compared to lesions of 3-5 mm caused by the wild-type MP. Deletion of 74 amino acids (or more) from the carboxy terminus resulted in a protein that could not support virus movement. Modified viruses that contained repeated sequences in the 3' region of the MP gene lost the repeated sequences during replication and reverted to the wild type. This was evidenced by the size of the MP produced and by sequence analysis of reverse-transcribed PCR-amplified products, following infection by the modified virus. MP deleted for as few as 3 amino acids at the amino terminus could not support virus movement thus indicating that the amino-terminal domain is critical for MP activity.

Direct visualization of the structure of the "20 S" aggregate of coat protein of tobacco mosaic virus. The "disk" is the major structure at pH 7.0 and the Proto-helix at lower pH

We have employed the rapid-freeze technique to prepare specimens for electron microscopy of a coat protein solution of tobacco mosaic virus at equilibrium at pH 7.0 and 6.8, ionic strength 0.1 M and 20 degrees C. The former are the conditions for the most rapid assembly of the virus from its isolated protein and RNA. At both pH values, the equilibrium mixture contains approximately 80% of a "20 S" aggregate and 20% of a "4 S" aggregate (the so-called A-protein). The specimens were prepared either totally unstained or positively stained with methyl mercury nitrate, which binds to an amino acid residue (Cys27) internally located within the subunit, which we show not to affect the virus assembly. The images in the electron microscope are compatible only with the major structure for the "20 S" aggregate at pH 7.0 containing two rings of subunits and these aggregates display the same binding contacts as those seen between the aggregate that forms the asymmetric unit in the crystal, which has been shown by X-ray crystallography to be a disk containing two rings, each of 17 subunits, oriented in the same direction. In contrast, the images from specimens prepared at pH 6.8 show the major structure to be a proto-helix at this slightly lower pH, demonstrating that the technique of cryo-electron microscopy is capable of distinguishing between these aggregates of tobacco mosaic virus coat protein. The main structure in solution at pH 7.0 must therefore be very similar to that in the crystal, although slight differences could occur and there are probably other, minor, components in a mixture of species sedimenting around 20 S under these conditions. The equilibrium between aggregates is extremely sensitive to conditions, with a drop of 0.2 pH unit tipping the disk to proto-helix ratio from approximately 10:1 at pH 7.0 to 1:10 at pH 6.8. This direct determination of the structure of the "20 S" aggregate in solution, under conditions for virus assembly, contradicts some recent speculation that it must be helical, and establishes that, at pH 7.0, it is in fact predominantly a two-layer disk as it had been modelled before.

Normal modes of symmetric protein assemblies. Application to the tobacco mosaic virus protein disk

We use group theoretical methods to study the molecular dynamics of symmetric protein multimers in the harmonic or quasiharmonic approximation. The method explicitly includes the long-range correlations between protein subunits. It can thus address collective dynamic effects, such as cooperativity between subunits. The n lowest-frequency normal modes of each individual subunit are combined into symmetry coordinates for the entire multimer. The Hessian of the potential energy is thereby reduced to a series of blocks of order n or 2n. In the quasiharmonic approximation, the covariance matrix of the atomic oscillations is reduced to the same block structure by an analogous set of symmetry coordinates. The method is applied to one layer of the tobacco mosaic virus protein disk in vacuo, to gain insight into the role of conformational fluctuations and electrostatics in tobacco mosaic virus assembly. The system has 78,000 classical, positional, degrees of freedom, yet the calculation is reduced by symmetry to a problem of order 4,600. Normal modes in the 0-100 cm-1 range were calculated. The calculated correlations extend mainly from each subunit to its nearest neighbors. The network of core helices has weak correlations with the rest of the structure. Similarly, the inner loops 90-108 are uncorrelated with the rest of the structure. Thus, the model predicts that the dielectric response in the RNA-binding region is mainly due to the loops alone.

Novel second-site suppression of a cold-sensitive defect in phage P22 procapsid assembly

The DNA packaging portal of the phage P22 procapsid is formed of 12 molecules of the 90,000 dalton gene 1 protein. The assembly of this dodecameric complex at a unique capsid vertex requires scaffolding subunits. The mechanism that ensures the location of the 12-fold symmetrical portal at only one of the 12 5-fold vertices of an icosahedral virus capsid presents a unique assembly problem, which, in some viruses, is solved by the portal also acting as initiator of procapsid assembly. Phage P22 procapsids, however, are formed in the absence of the portal protein. The 1-csH137 mutation prevents the incorporation of the portal protein into procapsids. In a mixed infection with cs+ phage, the mutant subunits are able to form functional portals, suggesting that the cold-sensitivity does not affect portal-portal interactions, but affects the interaction of portal subunits with some other molecular species involved in the initiation of portal assembly. Interestingly, the cs defect is suppressed by temperature-sensitive folding mutations at four sites in the P22 tailspike gene 9. The suppression is allele-specific; other tailspike tsf mutations fail to suppress the cs defect. Translation through a suppressor site is required for suppression. This observation is unexpected, since analysis of nonsense mutations in this gene indicates that it is not required for procapsid assembly. Examination of the nucleic acid sequences in the neighborhood of each of the suppressor sites shows significant sequence similarity with the scaffolding gene translational initiation region on the late message. This supports a previously proposed model, in which procapsid assembly is normally initiated in a region on the late messenger RNA that includes the gene 8 start site. By this model, the suppressor mutations may be acting through protein-RNA interactions, changing sequences that identify alternative or competing sites at which the mutant portal subunits may be organized for assembly into the differentiated vertex of the phage capsid.

Structure-specific binding of wound tumor virus transcripts by a host factor: involvement of both terminal nucleotide domains

A gel retardation assay was used to demonstrate binding of wound tumor virus transcripts by a protein component of leafhopper vector cell extracts. Comparative binding studies employing terminally modified and internally deleted transcripts established that the segment-specific inverted repeats present in the terminal domains of the viral transcripts were necessary but not sufficient for optimal binding. An additional involvement of internal sequences in either the formation or the stabilization of the binding complex was indicated. Results of competitive binding experiments confirmed the sequence- and structure-specificity of the protein-RNA interaction and revealed apparent differences in the ability of individual viral transcripts to form a stable binding complex. Possible implications of structure-specific interactions between wound tumor virus transcripts and a host component and the role of the terminal inverted repeats are discussed.

Assembly of hybrid RNAs with tobacco mosaic virus coat protein. Evidence for incorporation of disks in 5'-elongation along the major RNA tail

We have shown that during the reassembly of tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) RNA, with the coat protein supplied as a "disk preparation", the lengths of RNA protected from nuclease are "quantized" with steps which correspond to incorporation of the subunits from either a single or, more commonly, both rings of a disk. This interpretation has been challenged and it was suggested that the pattern was due to special, though unspecified features of the sequence of TMV RNA. To test whether the specific sequence of TMV RNA is important during the elongation, rather than just during nucleation, we have now followed growth of particles containing hybrid RNAs, with the TMV RNA origin of assembly but otherwise non-TMV sequences. We have prepared in vitro RNA transcripts containing heterologous RNA 5' to the origin of assembly sequence from TMV RNA, i.e. with a heterologous RNA tail in place of the natural major 5'-tail and no minor tail, and used these for assembly experiments. In each case we observe a banding pattern very similar to that which we had found with native TMV RNA and with a dominant quantum step of just over 100 bases, and sometimes also a step of 50 bases, strongly suggesting that this is not due to any feature of the TMV RNA. This same repeat is also visible even with a heterologous RNA chosen because it had a sequence repeat of 135 or 136 bases, confirming that the quantization is due to a feature of the elongation reaction and in no way to the RNA sequence being encapsidated. We have also followed elongation with the origin of assembly located 5' to the heterologous RNA. This leads to a slower elongation along this 3'-tail, after the initial rapid encapsidation of the origin RNA, which lacks any quantization of length protected. These results are fully compatible with the hypothesis we had advanced earlier, that the major growth along the 5'-tail is from performed aggregates ("disks") while the minor growth along the 3'-tail is from subunits in the "A-protein" adding singly or a few at a time.

Plant viruses: a tool-box for genetic engineering and crop protection

Traditionally, plant viruses are viewed as harmful, undesirable pathogens. However, their genomes can provide several useful 'designer functions' or 'sequence modules' with which to tailor future gene vectors for plant or general biotechnology. The majority (77%) of known plant viruses have single-stranded RNA of the messenger (protein coding) sense as their genetic material. Over the past 4 years, improved in vitro transcription systems and the construction of partial or full-length DNA copies of several plant RNA viruses have enhanced our ability to manipulate and study their genomes, particularly in the context of their pathogenic interactions with host plants. Recently, two forms of genetically engineered protection against plant virus infections have been reported. In both, a virus-related 'interfering' molecule was stably introduced into plants via the DNA-transfer mechanism of Agrobacterium tumefaciens. To date, the choice of 'interfering' molecule has been guided by empirical field-observations and each is effective against only a narrow range of closely-related viruses. As yet, we do not fully understand the molecular mechanism(s) responsible for the observed protection. The ability to manipulate the plant-pathogen relationship is a powerful tool to increase our knowledge and improve future strategies for unconventional cropprotection by genetic engineering techniques.

Localization of multiple TMV encapsidation initiation sites on rbcL gene transcripts

TMV capsid protein reacts with and encapsidates many of the chloroplast DNA transcripts both in vivo and in vitro to form pseudovirions. We report on the encapsidation initiation reaction with one of the major RNA species found in in vivo formed pseudovirions, the mRNA for the chloroplast-encoded large subunit of ribulose bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (rbcL). This mRNA is found to contain at least three sites which are independently capable of reacting with capsid protein oligomers to initiate encapsidation. All three sites react with capsid protein less efficiently in vitro than does the functional viral RNA encapsidation initiation site (ei). The 5' portion of the region that contains the most reactive rbcL site, ei-3, shows significant nucleotide sequence homology with the encapsidation initiation sites of the U1 and Cc strains of TMV and it can assume a folding structure that resembles that postulated for the Cc strain site. A site that acts as a block to rod elongation is present in transcripts from the region just 3' to the segment from which the rbcL mRNA is transcribed, probably close to, or at the transcription termination signal.

Roles of operator and non-operator RNA sequences in bacteriophage R17 capsid assembly

In order to understand the role of sequences other than the translational operator on bacteriophage R17 assembly, in vitro capsid assembly was studied with R17 coat protein and a variety of RNAs. For a series of RNA oligomers of the same chain length, sequences that bind coat protein dimer with a lower affinity require higher concentrations of RNA and protein for assembly. Among a series of non-specific RNA molecules of differing lengths, lower protein and RNA concentrations are required for assembly of capsids containing longer RNAs. For RNA molecules of any length, the presence of a single high-affinity translational operator sequence lowered the concentration requirements for capsid assembly. However, the advantage for encapsidation provided by the operator sequence is small for large RNA molecules. The experiments indicate that in the overall assembly process the interaction of coat protein with non-specific sequences is at least as important as its interaction with the specific translational operator sequence. In light of the data, a mechanism of achieving selective packaging of the R17 genomic RNA in vivo is discussed.

The tobacco mosaic virus assembly origin RNA. Functional characteristics defined by directed mutagenesis

The in vitro reassembly of tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) begins with the specific recognition by the viral coat protein disk aggregate of an internal TMV RNA sequence, known as the assembly origin (Oa). This RNA sequence contains a putative stem-loop structure (loop 1), believed to be the target for disk binding in assembly initiation, which has the characteristic sequence AAGAAGUCG exposed as a single strand at its apex. We show that a 75-base RNA sequence encompassing loop 1 is sufficient to direct the encapsidation by TMV coat protein disks of a heterologous RNA fragment. This RNA sequence and structure, which is sufficient to elicit TMV assembly in vitro, was explored by site-directed mutagenesis. Structure analysis of the RNA identified mutations that appear to effect assembly via a perturbation in RNA structure, rather than by a direct effect on coat protein binding. The binding of the loop 1 apex RNA sequence to coat protein disks was shown to be due primarily to its regularly repeated G residues. Sequences such as (UUG)3 and (GUG)3 are equally effective at initiating assembly, indicating that the other bases are less functionally constrained. However, substitution of the sequences (CCG)3, (CUG)3 or (UCG)3 reduced the assembly initiation rate, indicating that C residues are unfavourable for assembly. Two additional RNA sequences within the 75-base Oa sequence, both of the form (NNG)3, may play subsidiary roles in disk binding. RNA structure plays an important part in permitting selective protein-RNA recognition, since altering the RNA folding close to the apex of the loop 1 stem reduces the rate of disk binding, as does shortening the stem itself. Whereas the RNA sequence making up the hairpin does not in general affect the specificity of the protein-RNA interaction, it is required to present the apex signal sequence in a special conformation. Mechanisms for this are discussed.

Characterization of the TMV encapsidation initiation site on 18S rRNA

Tobacco Mosaic Virus capsid protein oligomers react with and encapsidate 18S rRNA from both plant and mammalian sources in vitro. The site (ei) in 18S rRNA which reacts with capsid protein to initiate the packaging reaction has been localized and partially characterized by testing the ability of transcripts from different regions of a cloned Cucurbita pepo rDNA repeat unit to become encapsidated. The 18S rRNA ei is found to react more slowly with capsid protein than does the functional virion ei and to lie within a 43 nucleotide region which starts at position 157 from the 5' terminus of 18S rRNA. When 6 nucleotides are removed from the 5' end, the remaining 37 nucleotide segment is still reactive, but with reduced efficiency. The primary structure of the reactive segment has limited similarity to the virion ei and can be folded into a stem-loop. The first 18 nucleotides of the ei region is highly conserved from an evolutionary standpoint and this may account for the ability of 18S rRNAs from both plant and mammalian sources to be encapsidated.

Cooperative thermal denaturation of the assembly origin region of TMV RNA

The assembly origin (AO) region of the tobacco mosaic virus RNA melts in an usually narrow (2.5 degrees C) temperature range. In an 0.01 M phosphate buffer the melting temperature of AO was found to be 41.5 degrees C. This value corresponds to the regions with the most stable secondary/tertiary structure of the whole TMV RNA molecule. It is assumed that the AO region has a specific tertiary structure, which is maintained by the long-range interactions as well as by interactions of the pseudoknot type.

Essential features of the assembly origin of tobacco mosaic virus RNA as studied by directed mutagenesis

The assembly origin of tobacco mosaic virus RNA contains three stable hairpin loops. Coat protein disks bind first to loop 1 (the 3' most) during virus assembly, but the whole region is coated in a concerted fashion even in conditions of limiting protein. It is shown by in vitro packaging assays using mutant assembly origin transcripts that rapid and specific assembly initiation occurs in the absence of loops 2 and 3, but is abolished on removal of loop 1. Deletion or alteration of the unpaired AAGAAGUCG sequence at the apex of loop 1 also abolishes rapid packaging; this sequence is therefore instrumental in disk binding. Alteration of this sequence to (A)9 leads to packaging at a very low rate (half time 12 hours) which is apparently non-sequence specific. Substitution of (CCG)3 evokes packaging with a half time of 3 hours, as compared to 15 seconds for the wild type assembly origin. These results suggest that the three-base G periodicity within this sequence element is an important feature in assembly nucleation.

Oligonucleotide binding to the coat protein disk of tobacco mosaic virus. Possible steps in the mechanism of assembly

Binding of the oligoribonucleotides AAG, AAGAAG and AAGAAGUUG to the disk aggregate of tobacco mosaic virus coat protein has been studied in solution under conditions favourable for virus assembly. The two longer oligomers bind strongly with Kd around 1 microM, approach complete saturation of binding sites and cause the formation of long, nicked helical rods resembling the virus. It is suggested that the binding of these oligomers, with sequences chosen from the assembly origin of the viral RNA, simulates the tobacco mosaic virus assembly process. No binding could be detected for AAG, indicating that chain length is a crucial determinant in the interaction. The binding of AAGAAG to coat protein crystals is very much weaker than that observed in solution, and the crystals crack at high oligomer concentrations. The corresponding oligodeoxyribonucleotide, d(AAGAAG), shows no binding to the protein in solution; the interaction is extremely specific for RNA.

Studies of tobacco mosaic virus reassembly with an RNA tail blocked by a hybridised and cross-linked probe

Segments of cloned cDNA to tobacco mosaic virus RNA, 150--300-bases long, have been hybridised and cross-linked to the RNA, which has then been used for reassembly experiments. This enables the elongation reaction, which does not encapsidate the double-stranded region generated, to be stopped at specific regions along the RNA and the resulting particles to be characterised, by measuring the lengths of the rods in the electron microscope. With hybridisation to the 3'-tail the entire RNA contiguous to the nucleation region is encapsidated, from the 5'-terminus up to the modified region. When the double-stranded region is on the 5'-side of the nucleation region, the mean length of the particles corresponds to a situation in which the double-stranded region is unable to enter the central hole of the growing rod, but the 3'-tail of the RNA is completely encapsidated. The longest particles hybridised on the 5'-tail (i.e. in a class longer than the mean length) show an effect complementary to those with a 3'-block, and have lengths which correspond to encapsidation from the modified region to the 3'-terminus, despite the continued presence of the 5'-tail up the rod. In all cases where there is a remaining 5'-tail the lengths observed can only be explained if elongation has occurred substantially, or probably completely, along the 3'-tail. Hence elongation must have occurred simultaneously along both the 5' and 3'-tails of the tobacco mosaic virus RNA after initiation on the internal nucleation region.

Structure of tobacco mosaic virus at 3.6 A resolution: implications for assembly

X-ray fiber diffraction analysis of tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) has led to the building of a molecular model of the intact virus, based on a map at 3.6 A resolution derived from five separated Bessel orders. This has been made possible by advances in the solution of the fiber diffraction phase problem. It is now possible to understand much of the chemical basis of TMV assembly, particularly in terms of intersubunit electrostatic interactions and RNA binding. Consideration of the molecular structure in conjunction with physical chemical studies by several groups of investigators suggests that the nucleating aggregate for initiation of TMV assembly is a short (about two turns) helix of protein subunits, probably inhibited from further polymerization in the absence of RNA by the disordering of peptide loop near the inner surface of the virus.

Coordinated two-disk nucleation, growth and properties, of virus-like particles assembled from tobacco-mosaic-virus capsid protein with poly(A) or oligo(A) of different length

Assembly of nucleoprotein rods from tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) coat protein and poly(A) depends on the presence of 20S disks in a manner very similar to nucleation and growth of virions in reconstitution with TMV RNA. Products assembled with (A) approximately equal to 5000 appear to have the same buoyant density in CsCl, the same nucleotide/protein ratio and the same nuclease stability, as reconstituted and native TMV. Their rate of formation is very similar to the rate of reconstitution with TMV RNA when high-molecular-mass (A) approximately equal to 5000 is used, but becomes a function of chain length particularly with (A) less than or equal to 185. The composition of assembly products can be described sufficiently with the relation between number of capsid polypeptide monomers/particle, np, to the number of nucleotide residues/chain, nnt, of np = 1/3 (nnt + 50) with two important restrictions: (1) particles of less than four turns of helically arranged capsid subunits are unstable, and (2) particles with about 150 or less nucleotides per chain deviate in structure from mature virus and virus-like (= longer) assembly products. This is indicated by changes in both buoyant density in CsCl and optical properties, while 'dislocation' of the disk to the helical arrangement of capsid subunits ('helicalization') and nuclease stability already become established with chains as short as (A) approximately equal to 58 +/- 20. Consequently, we suggest that assembly proceeds through three distinct phases: (1) nucleation (resulting in helicalization) by interaction of nucleic acid with the first disk; (2) stabilization of the primary (unstable!) nucleation complex by addition of a second disk and formation of a four-turn virus-like and stable nucleoprotein helix, which is then fit for (3) elongation by addition of further disks. The question of what makes the TMV protein disk select specifically TMV RNA during virion assembly is discussed in some detail.

Homologous proteins encoded by yeast mitochondrial introns and by a group of RNA viruses from plants

Hensgens et al. (1983a) have demonstrated the existence of distant homology (averaging 19.6%) between the central sections of seven proteins encoded by introns (and one product of an apparently independent gene) in yeast mitochondrial DNA. The homologous regions are typically segments of about 115 amino acids within open reading frames of about 10(3) bases. Genetic studies indicate that at least two of these proteins are required for the splicing of mitochondrial transcripts. This paper reports that two distantly related proteins of Mr 30,000 that are encoded by different strains of tobacco mosaic virus both contain central sections whose amino acid sequences are 15% to 23% identical in a single alignment to those of one group of four intron-encoded proteins, and possess certain groups of conserved residues also characteristic of the mitochondrial proteins. Genetic studies implicate these proteins in the spreading of viral lesions. While this level of identity cannot establish conclusively that the proteins are related, it suggests the possibility of a functional and/or evolutionary connection that would, if borne out, have important implications.

RNA-protein interactions in some small plant viruses

The structure of the three quasi-equivalent protein subunits A, B and C of the spherical, T = 3 southern bean mosaic virus (SBMV) have been carefully built in accordance with a refined electron density map of the complete virus. The lower electron density in the RNA portion of the map could not be explicitly interpreted in terms of a preferred RNA structure on which some icosahedral symmetry might have been imposed. However, the extremely basic nature of the interior surface of the coat protein must be associated with the binding and organization of the RNA. Comparison with the small spherical, T = 1 satellite tobacco necrosis virus (STNV; Liljas et al., J. Mol. Biol. 159, 93-108, 1982) and the T = 1 aggregate of alfalfa mosaic virus (AMV) protein (Fukuyama et al., J. Mol. Biol. 150, 33-41, 1981) showed similar results. The pattern of basic residues on the SBMV coat protein surface facing the RNA is able to dock a 9 base pair double-helical A-RNA structure with surprising accuracy. The basic residues are each associated with a different phosphate and the protein can make interactions with five bases in the minor groove. This may be one of a small number of ways in which the RNA interacts with SBMV coat protein. The self-assembly of SBMV has been studied in relation to the presence of the 63 basic amino-terminal coat protein sequence, pH, Ca2+ and Mg2+ ions and RNA. These results have led to a two-state model where the "relaxed" dimers initially self-assemble into 10-mer caps which nucleate the assembly of T = 1 or T = 3 capsids depending on the charge state of the carboxyl group clusters in the subunit contact region. The two-state condition of dimers in a viral coat protein extends the range of structures originally envisaged by Caspar and Klug (Cold Spring Harbor Symp. Quant. Biol. 27, 1-24, 1962).

Molecular cloning and nucleotide sequence of the 30K and the coat protein cistron of TMV (tomato strain) genome

The cDNA copies of tobacco mosaic virus (TMV)-tomato strain (L) genome were cloned by the method of Okayama and Berg (Mol. Cell. Biol. 2, 161-170. (1982)) and the sequence of 1,614 nucleotides at the 3' end was determined. The sequence encompasses the 30K and the coat protein cistron which are located in residues 685-1, 479 and 203-682 from the 3' end of the genome respectively. The close relationship between the tomato and the common strain was shown on the level of the nucleotide sequence. Highly homologous regions are found in the 3' non-coding region, the assembly origin and the 5' flanking region of the 30K protein cistron. The comparison of the deduced amino acid sequence between the tomato and the common strain shows that the 30K protein is composed of the conserved N-terminal four-fifth and the highly divergent region near the C-terminus.

Multiple proteins and subgenomic mRNAs may be derived from a single open reading frame on tobacco mosaic virus RNA

It has previously been shown that messenger activity for a protein of Mr = ca. 30k exists in RNA fractions extracted from particles of either native or alkali stripped U1 TMV, or from cowpea strain TMV, that are smaller than full genomic length. Analysis of sucrose gradient fractions containing this activity reveals a number of slightly smaller template activities directing synthesis of proteins between 18.5k and 29k in size. All of these messenger activities, including that for the 30k protein, respond to cap analogues in anomalous ways. Discrete RNA species that include active mRNAs for these proteins can be demonstrated in the same fractions by labelling with preparations of vaccinia capping enzyme and [alpha-32P] GTP without prior beta-elimination. Detailed analysis of three of these proteins (of Mr's ca. 30k, 29k and 23k) by peptide mapping and translation of purified vaccinia-labelled RNA demonstrates that all three are unrelated to the large early TMV proteins, but are related to each other in such a way as to form a nested set with staggered N termini and identical C termini. mRNAs of chain lengths ca. 1900 and 1500 bases direct synthesis of the 30k and 23k proteins respectively, an mRNA of about 1850 bases directs both 29k and (perhaps because of cross-contamination) 30k synthesis. Initiation codons for the 29k and 23k proteins have been mapped at positions 4960-4962 and 5191-5193 respectively on TMV RNA. Since all three encapsidated templates have similar properties we conclude that either there is a family of 30k-related proteins with unusual mRNAs, or that none of these in vitro translation products are directed by physiological templates.

N protein of vesicular stomatitis virus selectively encapsidates leader RNA in vitro

The N protein of vesicular stomatitis virus, prepared in a soluble form, was found to self-assemble, and to assemble with RNAs into RNAase-resistant structures with the buoyant density of viral nucleocapsids. It selectively assembled leader RNAs over other viral transcripts. The basis for this selective encapsidation was not the relative size of the viral transcripts or the presence or absence of a 5' cap group, but was sequence-dependent. Partial-assembly experiments demonstrated that leader RNA assembly started within the first 14 nucleotides at the 5' end. Examination of known leader RNA sequences suggests that the sequence responsible for selective assembly by N protein is a five-times-repeated A residue at every third position from the 5' end of the leader chain.