Coupling proton movements to c-ring rotation in F(1)F(o) ATP synthase: aqueous access channels and helix rotations at the a-c interface

Mechanics of coupling proton movements to c-ring rotation in ATP synthase

F1F0 ATP synthases generate ATP by a rotary catalytic mechanism in which H+ transport is coupled to rotation of an oligomeric ring of c subunits extending through the membrane. Protons bind to and then are released from the aspartyl-61 residue of subunit c at the center of the membrane. Subunit a of the F0 sector is thought to provide proton access channels to and from aspartyl-61. Here, we summarize new information on the structural organization of Escherichia coli subunit a and the mapping of aqueous-accessible residues in the second, fourth and fifth transmembrane helices (TMHs). Aqueous-accessible regions of these helices extend to both the cytoplasmic and periplasmic surface. We propose that aTMH4 rotates to alternately expose the periplasmic or cytoplasmic half-channels to aspartyl-61 of subunit c during the proton transport cycle. The concerted rotation of interacting helices in subunit a and subunit c is proposed to be the mechanical force driving rotation of the c-rotor, using a mechanism akin to meshed gears.

Bacterial Na+- or H+-coupled ATP Synthases Operating at Low Electrochemical Potential

In certain strictly anaerobic bacteria, the energy for growth is derived entirely from a decarboxylation reaction. A prominent example is Propionigenium modestum, which converts the free energy of the decarboxylation of (S)-methylmalonyl-CoA to propionyl-CoA (DeltaG degrees =-20.6 kJ/mol) into an electrochemical Na(+) ion gradient across the membrane. This energy source is used as a driving force for ATP synthesis by a Na(+)-translocating F(1)F(0) ATP synthase. According to bioenergetic considerations, approximately four decarboxylation events are necessary to support the synthesis of one ATP. This unique feature of using Na(+) instead of H(+) as the coupling ion has made this ATP synthase the paradigm to study the ion pathway across the membrane and its relationship to rotational catalysis. The membrane potential (Deltapsi) is the key driving force to convert ion translocation through the F(0) motor components into torque. The resulting rotation elicits conformational changes at the catalytic sites of the peripheral F(1) domain which are instrumental for ATP synthesis. Alkaliphilic bacteria also face the challenge of synthesizing ATP at a low electrochemical potential, but for entirely different reasons. Here, the low potential is not the result of insufficient energy input from substrate degradation, but of an inverse pH gradient. This is a consequence of the high environmental pH where these bacteria grow and the necessity to keep the intracellular pH in the neutral range. In spite of this unfavorable bioenergetic condition, ATP synthesis in alkaliphilic bacteria is coupled to the proton motive force (DeltamuH(+)) and not to the much higher sodium motive force (DeltamuNa(+)). A peculiar feature of the ATP synthases of alkaliphiles is the specific inhibition of their ATP hydrolysis activity. This inhibition appears to be an essential strategy for survival at high external pH: if the enzyme were to operate as an ATPase, protons would be pumped outwards to counteract the low DeltamuH(+), thus wasting valuable ATP and compromising acidification of the cytoplasm at alkaline pH.

Identification of a new chondropsin class of antitumor compound that selectively inhibits V-ATPases

We identify a new naturally occurring class of inhibitor of vacuolar H+-ATPases (V-ATPases) isolated from vacuolar membranes of Neurospora crassa and from chromaffin granule membranes of Bos taurus. To date, the new class includes six chondropsins and poecillastrin A, large polyketide-derived macrolide lactams with 33-37 membered rings. In the National Cancer Institute's 60-cell screen the chondropsin class showed a tumor cell growth inhibitory fingerprint essentially indistinguishable from that of the bafilomycin/concanamycin and the salicylihalamide/lobatamide classes of well-established V-ATPase inhibitors. Half-maximal inhibition of V-ATPase activity in vitro occurred at 0.04-0.7 microM for the fungal vacuolar V-ATPase and at 0.4 to >10 microM for the chromaffin granule V-ATPase. Thus, the new inhibitors are somewhat less potent than the other two classes, which typically have Ki values of <10 nM for V-ATPases, and the new inhibitors differ from the other two classes in their specificity. The bafilomycin class inhibits all eucaryotic V-ATPases, the salicylihalamide class inhibits mammalian V-ATPases but not fungal V-ATPases, and the new chondropsin class inhibits the N. crassa V-ATPase better than the chromaffin granule V-ATPase. Two mutations in the N. crassa V-ATPase that affect the binding of bafilomycin had small but reproducible effects on the affinity of chondropsins for the V-ATPase, suggesting the possibility of a similar mechanism of inhibition.

Aqueous access pathways in subunit a of rotary ATP synthase extend to both sides of the membrane

The role of subunit a in promoting proton translocation and rotary motion in the Escherichia coli F1Fo ATP synthase is poorly understood. In the membrane-bound Fo sector of the enzyme, H+ binding and release occur at Asp-61 in the middle of the second transmembrane helix (TMH) of subunit c. Protons are thought to reach Asp-61 at the center of the membrane via aqueous channels formed at least in part by one or more of the five TMHs of subunit a. Aqueous access pathways have previously been mapped to surfaces of aTMH4. Here we have substituted Cys into the second and fifth TMHs of subunit a and carried out chemical modification with Ag+ and N-ethylmaleimide to define the aqueous accessibility of residues along these helices. Access to cAsp-61 at the center of the membrane may be mediated in part by Ag+-sensitive residues 248, 249, 251, and 252 in aTMH5. From the periplasmic surface, aqueous access to cAsp-61 may be mediated by silver-sensitive residues 115, 116, 119, 120, 122, and 126 in aTMH2. The Ag+-sensitive residues in TMH2, -4, and -5 form a continuum extending from the periplasmic to the cytoplasmic side of the membrane. In an arrangement of helices supported by second-site revertant and crosslinking analyses, these residues cluster at the interior of a four-helix bundle formed by TMH2-5. The aqueous access pathways at the interior of subunit a may be gated by a swiveling of helices in this bundle, alternately exposing cytoplasmic and periplasmic half channels to cAsp-61 during the H+ transport cycle.

Interacting helical surfaces of the transmembrane segments of subunits a and c' of the yeast V-ATPase defined by disulfide-mediated cross-linking

Proton translocation by the vacuolar (H+)-ATPase (or V-ATPase) has been shown by mutagenesis to be dependent upon charged residues present within transmembrane segments of subunit a as well as the three proteolipid subunits (c, c', and c"). Interaction between R735 in TM7 of subunit a and the glutamic acid residue in the middle of TM4 of subunits c and c' or TM2 of subunit c" has been proposed to be essential for proton release to the luminal compartment. In order to determine whether the helical face of TM7 of subunit a containing R735 is capable of interacting with the helical face of TM4 of subunit c' containing the essential glutamic acid residue (Glu-145), cysteine-mediated cross-linking between these subunits in yeast has been performed. Cys-less forms of subunits a and c' as well as forms containing unique cysteine residues were constructed, introduced together into a strain disrupted in both endogenous subunits, and tested for growth at neutral pH, for assembly competence and for cross-linking in the presence of cupric-phenanthroline by SDS-PAGE and Western blot analysis. Four different cysteine mutants of subunit a were each tested pairwise with ten different unique cysteine mutants of subunit c'. Strong cross-linking was observed for the pairs aS728C/c'I142C, aA731C/c'E145C, aA738C/c'F143C, aA738C/c'L147C, and aL739C/c'L147C. Partial cross-linking was observed for an additional 13 of 40 pairs analyzed. When arrayed on a helical wheel diagram, the results suggest that the helical face of TM7 of subunit a containing Arg-735 interacts with the helical face of TM4 of subunit c' centered on Val-146 and bounded by Glu-145 and Leu-147. The results are consistent with a possible rotational flexibility of one or both of these transmembrane segments as well as some flexibility of movement perpendicular to the membrane.

Biochemical support for the V-ATPase rotary mechanism: antibody against HA-tagged Vma7p or Vma16p but not Vma10p inhibits activity

V-ATPase null mutants in yeast have a distinct, conditionally lethal phenotype that can be obtained through disruption of any one of its subunits. This enables supplementation of this mutant with the relevant subunit tagged with an epitope against which an antibody is available. In this system, the effect of antibody on the activity of the enzyme can be analyzed. Towards this end we used HA to tag subunits Vma7p, Vma10p and Vma16p, which are assumed to represent, respectively, the shaft, stator and turbine of the enzyme, and used them to supplement the corresponding yeast V-ATPase null mutants. The anti-HA epitope antibody inhibited both the ATP-dependent proton uptake and the ATPase activities of the Vma16p-HA and Vma7p-HA containing complexes, in intact vacuoles and in the detergent-solubilized enzyme. Neither of these activities was inhibited by the antibody in Vma10p-HA containing enzyme. These results support the function of Vma10p as part of the stator, while the other tagged subunits are part of the rotor apparatus. The HA-tag was attached to the N terminus of Vma16p; thus the antibody inhibition points to its accessibility outside the vacuolar membrane. This assumption is supported by the supplementation of the yeast mutant by the homologues of Vma16p isolated from Arabidopsis thaliana and lemon fruit c-DNA. Contrary to yeast, which has five predicted helices, the plant subunit Vma16p has only four. Our results confirm a recent report that only four of the yeast Vma16p complexes are actually transmembrane helices.

Proton translocation driven by ATP hydrolysis in V-ATPases

The vacuolar H(+)-ATPases (or V-ATPases) are a family of ATP-dependent proton pumps responsible for acidification of intracellular compartments and, in certain cases, proton transport across the plasma membrane of eukaryotic cells. They are multisubunit complexes composed of a peripheral domain (V(1)) responsible for ATP hydrolysis and an integral domain (V(0)) responsible for proton translocation. Based upon their structural similarity to the F(1)F(0) ATP synthases, the V-ATPases are thought to operate by a rotary mechanism in which ATP hydrolysis in V(1) drives rotation of a ring of proteolipid subunits in V(0). This review is focused on the current structural knowledge of the V-ATPases as it relates to the mechanism of ATP-driven proton translocation.

ATP synthesis driven by proton transport in F1F0-ATP synthase

Topical questions in ATP synthase research are: (1) how do protons cause subunit rotation and how does rotation generate ATP synthesis from ADP+Pi? (2) How does hydrolysis of ATP generate subunit rotation and how does rotation bring about uphill transport of protons? The finding that ATP synthase is not just an enzyme but rather a unique nanomotor is attracting a diverse group of researchers keen to find answers. Here we review the most recent work on rapidly developing areas within the field and present proposals for enzymatic and mechanoenzymatic mechanisms.

Voltage-gated proton channels and other proton transfer pathways

Proton channels exist in a wide variety of membrane proteins where they transport protons rapidly and efficiently. Usually the proton pathway is formed mainly by water molecules present in the protein, but its function is regulated by titratable groups on critical amino acid residues in the pathway. All proton channels conduct protons by a hydrogen-bonded chain mechanism in which the proton hops from one water or titratable group to the next. Voltage-gated proton channels represent a specific subset of proton channels that have voltage- and time-dependent gating like other ion channels. However, they differ from most ion channels in their extraordinarily high selectivity, tiny conductance, strong temperature and deuterium isotope effects on conductance and gating kinetics, and insensitivity to block by steric occlusion. Gating of H(+) channels is regulated tightly by pH and voltage, ensuring that they open only when the electrochemical gradient is outward. Thus they function to extrude acid from cells. H(+) channels are expressed in many cells. During the respiratory burst in phagocytes, H(+) current compensates for electron extrusion by NADPH oxidase. Most evidence indicates that the H(+) channel is not part of the NADPH oxidase complex, but rather is a distinct and as yet unidentified molecule.

Rotary protein motors

Three protein motors have been unambiguously identified as rotary engines: the bacterial flagellar motor and the two motors that constitute ATP synthase (F(0)F(1) ATPase). Of these, the bacterial flagellar motor and F(0) motors derive their energy from a transmembrane ion-motive force, whereas the F(1) motor is driven by ATP hydrolysis. Here, we review the current understanding of how these protein motors convert their energy supply into a rotary torque.

Aqueous access channels in subunit a of rotary ATP synthase

The role of subunit a in proton translocation by the Escherichia coli F(1)F(o) ATP synthase is poorly understood. In the membrane-bound F(o) sector of the enzyme, H(+) binding and release occurs at Asp(61) in the middle of the second transmembrane helix (TMH) of subunit c. Protons are thought to reach Asp(61) via an aqueous access pathway formed at least in part by one or more of the five TMHs of subunit a. In this report, we have substituted Cys into a 19-residue span of the fourth TMH of subunit a and used chemical modification to obtain information about the aqueous accessibility of residues along this helix. Residues 206, 210, and 214 are N-ethylmaleimide-accessible from the cytoplasmic side of the membrane and may lie on the H(+) transport route. Residues 215 and 218 on TMH4, as well as residue 245 on TMH5, are Ag(+)-accessible but N-ethylmaleimide-inaccessible and may form part of an aqueous pocket extending from Asp(61) of subunit c to the periplasmic surface.

The first putative transmembrane segment of subunit c" (Vma16p) of the yeast V-ATPase is not necessary for function

The yeast vacuolar ATPase (V-ATPase) contains three proteolipid subunits: c (Vma3p), c' (Vma11p), and c" (Vma16p). Each subunit contains a buried glutamate residue that is essential for function, and these subunits are not able to substitute for each other in supporting activity. Subunits c and c' each contain four putative transmembrane segments (TM1-4), whereas subunit c" is predicted to contain five. To determine whether TM1 of subunit c" serves an essential function, a deletion mutant of Vma16p was constructed lacking TM1 (Vma16p-Delta TM1). Although this construct does not complement the loss of Vma3p or Vma11p, it does complement the loss of full-length Vma16p. Vacuoles isolated from the strain expressing Vma16p-Delta TM1 showed V-ATPase activity and proton transport greater than 80% relative to wild type and displayed wild type levels of subunits A and a, suggesting normal assembly of the V-ATPase complex. These results suggest that TM1 of Vma16p is dispensable for both activity and assembly of the V-ATPase. To obtain information about the topology of Vma16p, labeling of single cysteine-containing mutants using the membrane-permeable reagent 3-(N-maleimidylpropionyl)biocytin (MPB) and the -impermeable reagent 4-acetamido-4'-maleimidylstilbene-2,2'-disulfonic acid (AMS) was tested. Both the Cys-less form of Vma16p and eight single cysteine-containing mutants retained greater than 80% of wild type levels of activity. Of the eight mutants tested, two (S5C and S178C) were labeled by MPB. MPB-labeling of S5C was blocked by AMS in intact vacuoles, whereas S178C was blocked by AMS only in the presence of permeabilizing concentrations of detergent. In addition, a hemagglutinin epitope tag introduced into the C terminus of Vma16p was recognized by an anti-hemagglutinin antibody in intact vacuolar membranes, suggesting a cytoplasmic orientation for the C terminus. These results suggest that subunit c" contains four rather than five transmembrane segments with both the N and C terminus on the cytoplasmic side of the membrane.