The distribution of lipid attached spin probes in bilayers: application to membrane protein topology

The interaction of small molecules with phospholipid membranes studied by 1H NOESY NMR under magic-angle spinning

The interaction of small molecules with lipid membranes and the exact knowledge of their binding site and bilayer distribution is of great pharmacological importance and represents an active field of current biophysical research. Over the last decade, a highly resolved 1H solid-state NMR method has been developed that allows measuring localization and distribution of small molecules in membranes. The classical solution 1H NMR NOESY technique is applied to lipid membrane samples under magic-angle spinning (MAS) and NOESY cross-relaxation rates are determined quantitatively. These rates are proportional to the contact probability between molecular segments and therefore an ideal tool to study intermolecular interactions in membranes. Here, we review recent 1H MAS NOESY applications that were carried out to study lateral lipid organization in mixed membranes and the interaction of membranes with water, ethanol, small aromatic compounds, peptides, fluorescence labels, and lipophilic nucleosides.

Solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance measurements of HIV fusion peptide to lipid distances reveal the intimate contact of beta strand peptide with membranes and the proximity of the Ala-14-Gly-16 region with lipid headgroups

Human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection begins with fusion between viral and host cell membranes and is catalyzed by the HIV gp41 fusion protein. The approximately 20 N-terminal apolar residues of gp41 are called the HIV fusion peptide (HFP), interact with the host cell membrane, and play a key role in fusion. In this study, the membrane location of peptides which contained the HFP sequence (AVGIGALFLGFLGAAGSTMGARS) was probed in samples containing either only phospholipids or phospholipids and cholesterol. Four HFPs were examined which each contained 13CO labeling at three sequential residues between G5 and G16. The 13CO chemical shifts indicated that HFP had predominant beta strand conformation over the labeled residues in the samples. The internuclear distances between the HFP 13CO groups and the lipid 31P atoms were measured using solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance rotational-echo double-resonance experiments. The shortest 13CO-31P distances of 5-6 A were observed for HFP labeled between A14 and G16 and correlated with intimate association of beta strand HFP and membranes. These results were confirmed with measurements using HFPs singly labeled with 13CO at A6 or A14. To our knowledge, these data are the first measurements of distances between HIV fusion peptide nuclei and lipid P, and qualitative models of the membrane location of oligomeric beta strand HFP which are consistent with the experimental data are presented. Observation of intimate contact between beta strand HFP and membranes provides a rationale for further investigation of the relationship between structure and fusion activity for this conformation.

New BODIPY lipid probes for fluorescence studies of membranes

Many fluorescent lipid probes tend to loop back to the membrane interface when attached to a lipid acyl chain rather than embedding deeply into the bilayer. To achieve maximum embedding of BODIPY (4,4-difluoro-4-bora-3a,4a-diaza-s-indacene) fluorophore into the bilayer apolar region, a series of sn-2 acyl-labeled phosphatidylcholines was synthesized bearing 4,4-difluoro-1,3,5,7-tetramethyl-4-bora-3a,4a-diaza-s-indacene-8-yl (Me(4)-BODIPY-8) at the end of C(3)-, C(5)-, C(7)-, or C(9)-acyl. A strategy was used of symmetrically dispersing the methyl groups at BODIPY ring positions 1, 3, 5, and 7 to decrease fluorophore polarity. Iodide quenching of the phosphatidylcholine probes in bilayer vesicles confirmed that the Me(4)-BODIPY-8 fluorophore was embedded in the bilayer. Parallax analysis of Me(4)-BODIPY-8 fluorescence quenching by phosphatidylcholines containing iodide at different positions along the sn-2 acyl chain indicated that the penetration depth of Me(4)-BODIPY-8 into the bilayer was determined by the length of the linking acyl chain. Evaluation using monolayers showed minimal perturbation of <10 mol% probe in fluid-phase and cholesterol-enriched phosphatidylcholine. Spectral characterization in monolayers and bilayers confirmed the retention of many features of other BODIPY derivatives (i.e., absorption and emission wavelength maxima near 498 nm and approximately 506-515 nm) but also showed the absence of the 620-630 nm peak associated with BODIPY dimer fluorescence and the presence of a 570 nm emission shoulder at high Me(4)-BODIPY-8 surface concentrations. We conclude that the new probes should have versatile utility in membrane studies, especially when precise location of the reporter group is needed.

Molecular interpretation of fluorescence solvent relaxation of Patman and 2H NMR experiments in phosphatidylcholine bilayers

The analysis of time-dependent fluorescence shifts of the bilayer probe 6-hexadecanoyl-2-(((2-(trimethylammonium)ethyl)methyl)amino)naphthalene chloride (Patman) offers valuable information on the hydration and dynamics of phospholipid headgroups. Quenching studies on vesicles composed of four phosphatidylcholines with different hydrocarbon chains (18:1c9/18:1c9, DOPC; 16:0/18:1c9, POPC; 18:1c9/16:0, OPPC; 18:1c6/18:1c6, PCDelta6) show that the chromophore of Patman is defined located at the level of the sn-1 ester-group in the phospholipid, which is invariant to the hydrocarbon chain. The so-called solvent relaxation (SR) approach as well as solid-state 2H NMR reveals that DOPC and PCDelta6 are more hydrated than POPC and OPPC. A strong dependence of SR kinetics on the position of double bond in the investigated fatty acid chains was observed. Apparently, the closer the double bond is located to the hydrated sn-1 ester-group, the more mobile this group becomes. This work demonstrates that the SR approach can report mobility changes within phospholipid bilayers with a remarkable molecular resolution.

Membrane Interactions of Dynorphins,

The dynorphins are primarily endogenous ligands to the kappa-opioid receptor, but a variety of non-opioid effects have also been observed, including direct effects on membranes. The peptides are rich in Arg residues, a characteristic feature of the cell-penetrating peptides. In this investigation, we have examined the interaction of the two peptides dynorphin A and dynorphin B with model membranes. A variety of NMR methods, as well as CD and fluorescence spectroscopy, have been used to characterize the structure of the two peptides and, more importantly, the position of the peptides in phospholipid bicelles. Both peptides interact to a large extent with both zwitterionic and partly negatively charged bicelles but are only marginally structured in either solvent. Dynorphin A was found to insert its N-terminus into the bilayer of the bicelle, while dynorphin B was found to reside on the surface of the bilayer. Despite the high degree of similarity in the sequence of the two peptides, it has previously been observed that dynorphin A has membrane perturbing effects and causes leakage of calcein from large unilamellar phospholipid vesicles while dynorphin B has no such effects. Our results provide a possible explanation for the difference in membrane perturbation.

Peptides in lipid bilayers: the power of simple models

Interactions between proteins and lipids lie at the heart of virtually all membrane processes, but on a molecular level they are still poorly understood. Nowadays, simple model systems comprising designed transmembrane peptides in synthetic lipid bilayers are increasingly being recognized as powerful tools to uncover basic principles of protein-lipid interactions. Such model systems enable detailed analysis of how the properties of lipids influence the structure and dynamics of transmembrane helices, how these helices are anchored at the lipid-water interface, and how the length and composition of transmembrane segments influence the organization and dynamics of membrane lipids. In addition, well-characterized model systems have proven useful to refine computational approaches and to develop new techniques for studies of protein-lipid interactions.

Detailed Description of the Conformation and Location of Membrane-Bound Erythromycin A Using Isotropic Bicelles

Although many nonpeptidic drugs target biological membrane and membrane proteins, it is still difficult to define the membrane-bound structure of the drugs. In this study, we utilized bicelles as a membrane model, since the bicelles, which have planar lipid bilayer portions, are thought to be a more appropriate and practical membrane model than micelles. Bicelles with a small diameter allow for measurements of liquid NMR due to fast tumbling in solution. We targeted erythromycin A (EA) as a membrane-binding compound because it is pointed out that the drug interacts with lysosomal membranes, inhibits phospholipase A, and consequently induces phospholipidosis as a side effect. The conformation of EA in the bicelle was successfully determined on the basis of coupling constants and NOEs. Measurements of intermolecular NOEs and paramagnetic relaxation times revealed that the drug is located shallowly in the membrane surface, with the dimethylamino group being close to the phosphate, and the macrolide portion adjacent to upper sides of the acyl chains. This study shows the general utility of isotropic bicelles for detailed conformational and orientational studies of membrane-associated nonpeptidic drugs.

Investigation of the binding geometry of a peripheral membrane protein

A growing number of modules including FYVE domains target key signaling proteins to membranes through specific recognition of lipid headgroups and hydrophobic insertion into bilayers. Despite the critical role of membrane insertion in the function of these modules, the structural mechanism of membrane docking and penetration remains unclear. In particular, the three-dimensional orientation of the inserted proteins with respect to the membrane surface is difficult to define quantitatively. Here, we determined the geometry of the micelle penetration of the early endosome antigen 1 (EEA1) FYVE domain by obtaining NMR-derived restraints that correlate with the distances between protein backbone amides and spin-labeled probes. The 5- and 14-doxyl-phosphatidylcholine spin-labels were incorporated into dodecylphosphocholine (DPC) micelles, and the reduction of amide signal intensities of the FYVE domain due to paramagnetic relaxation enhancement was measured. The vector of the FYVE domain insertion was estimated relative to the molecular axis by minimizing the paramagnetic restraints obtained in phosphatidylinositol 3-phosphate (PI3P)-enriched micelles containing only DPC or mixed with phosphatidylserine (PS). Additional distance restraints were obtained using a novel spin-label mimetic of PI(3)P that contains a nitroxyl radical near the threitol group of the lipid. Conformational changes indicative of elongation of the membrane insertion loop (MIL) were detected upon micelle interaction, in which the hydrophobic residues of the loop tend to move deeper into the nonpolar core of micelles. The micelle insertion mechanism of the FYVE domain defined in this study is consistent with mutagenesis data and chemical shift perturbations and demonstrates the advantage of using the spin-label NMR approach for investigating the binding geometry by peripheral membrane proteins.

Direct determination of a membrane-peptide interface using the nuclear magnetic resonance cross-saturation method

Membrane-peptide interactions are involved in many crucial biological and pharmacological activities. To clarify the interaction mode of membrane-peptide complexes, it is important to analyze both the dynamic properties and the contact residues of the membrane-bound peptide. In this study, we investigated the dynamic properties of a peptide bound to a lipid bilayer, using relaxation and amide-water exchange analyses, and directly determined the membrane-peptide interface, using the cross-saturation method. For the models of a lipid bilayer and a peptide, isotropic bicelles and mastoparan were used, respectively. The results indicate that mastoparan had a heterogeneous distribution of motion over various timescales and interacted with the lipid bilayer by using its hydrophobic side; the molecule was located within the lipid bilayer rather than on the surface, as thought previously. This study shows that the cross-saturation method is useful for determining the interface of not only protein-protein but also membrane-peptide complexes.

Membrane interaction of neuropeptide Y detected by EPR and NMR spectroscopy

Neuropeptide Y (NPY) is one of the most abundant peptides in the central nervous system of mammals. It belongs to the best-conserved peptides in nature, i.e., the amino acid sequences of even evolutionary widely separated species are very similar to each other. Using porcine NPY, which differs from human NPY only at position 17 (a leucine residue exchanged for a methionine), labeled with a TOAC spin probe at the 2nd, 32nd, or 34th positions of the peptide backbone, the membrane binding and penetration of NPY was determined using EPR and NMR spectroscopy. The vesicular membranes were composed of phosphatidylcholine and phosphatidylserine at varying mixing ratios. From the analysis of the EPR line shapes, the spectral contributions of free, dimerized, and membrane bound NPY could be separated. This analysis was further supported by quenching experiments, which selected the contributions of the bound NPY fraction. The results of this study give rise to a model where the alpha-helical part of NPY (amino acids 13-36) penetrates the membrane interface. The unstructured N-terminal part (amino acids 1-12) extends into the aqueous phase with occasional contacts with the lipid headgroup region. Besides the mixing ratio of zwitterionic and negatively charged phospholipid species, the electrostatic peptide membrane interactions are influenced by the pH value, which determines the net charge of the peptide resulting in a modified membrane binding affinity. The results of these variations indicate that NPY binding to phospholipid membranes depends strongly on the electrostatic interactions. An estimation of the transfer energy of the peptide from aqueous solution to the membrane interface DeltaG supports the preferential interaction of NPY with negatively charged membranes.

Influence of DPH on the structure and dynamics of a DPPC bilayer

We have conducted extensive molecular dynamics (MD) simulations together with differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) and nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) experiments to quantify the influence of free 1,6-diphenyl-1,3,5-hexatriene (DPH) fluorescent probes on the structure and dynamics of a dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine bilayer. Atomistic MD simulations show that in the membrane-water interface the influence of DPH is minor, whereas in the acyl-chain region DPH gives rise to major perturbations. In the latter case, DPH is found to influence a wide range of membrane properties, such as the packing and ordering of hydrocarbon tails and the lateral diffusion of lipid molecules. The effects are prominent but of local nature, i.e., the changes observed in the properties of lipid molecules are significant in the vicinity of DPH, but reduce rapidly as the distance from the probe increases. Long-range perturbations due to DPH are hence not expected. Detailed DSC and (2)H NMR measurements support this view. DSC shows only subtle perturbation to the cooperative behavior of the membrane system in the presence of DPH, and (2)H NMR shows that DPH gives rise to a slight increase in the lipid chain order, in agreement with MD simulations. Potential effects of other probes such as pyrene are briefly discussed.

Mechanism of membrane activity of the antibiotic trichogin GA IV: a two-state transition controlled by peptide concentration

Synthetic fluorescent analogs of the natural lipopeptide trichogin GA IV were used to investigate the peptide position and orientation in model membranes. A translocation assay based on Forster energy transfer indicates that trichogin is associated to both the outer and inner leaflet of the membrane, even at low concentration, when it is not active. Fluorescence quenching measurements, performed by using water soluble quenchers and quenchers positioned in the membrane at different depths, indicate that at low membrane-bound peptide/lipid ratios trichogin lies close to the region of polar headgroups. By increasing peptide concentration until membrane leakage takes place, a cooperative transition occurs and a significant fraction of the peptide becomes deeply buried into the bilayer. Remarkably, this change in peptide position is strictly coupled with peptide aggregation. Therefore, the mechanism of trichogin action can be envisaged as based on a two-state transition controlled by peptide concentration. One state is the monomeric, surface bound and inactive peptide, and the other state is a buried, aggregated form, which is responsible for membrane leakage and bioactivity.

Structural investigations of a human calcitonin-derived carrier peptide in a membrane environment by solid-state NMR

Previous studies have shown that human calcitonin (hCT) and its C-terminal fragment hCT(9-32) translocate in nasal epithelium. Moreover, hCT(9-32) was used as a carrier to internalize efficiently the green fluorescent protein, drugs, and plasmid DNA. To understand the mechanism of the membrane crossing process, we determined structural parameters of the carrier peptide hCT(9-32) in a membrane environment using solid-state NMR. For that purpose, we synthesized a multiply labeled hCT(9-32) peptide comprising four positions with fully (15)N- and (13)C-labeled amino acids. Multilamellar vesicle samples containing varying mixing ratios of hCT(9-32) and phospholipids found in the plasma membrane of nasal epithelium were prepared. The typical axially symmetric powder patterns of (31)P NMR spectra confirmed the presence of lamellar bilayers in our samples. The chemical shift anisotropy of the (31)P NMR spectra of the samples in the presence of hCT(9-32) is slightly reduced, revealing weak interaction of the peptide with the lipid headgroups. The peptide does not penetrate the lipid membrane as indicated by very similar (2)H NMR order parameters of the phospholipid fatty acid chains in the absence and presence of the carrier peptide. This membrane topology was confirmed by measurements of paramagnetic enhancement of relaxation rates. The conformation of hCT(9-32) was investigated by cross polarization magic angle spinning NMR methods. All peptide signals were resolved and fully assigned in two-dimensional proton-driven (13)C spin diffusion experiments. The isotropic chemical shifts of (13)CO, (13)Calpha, and (13)Cbeta provide information about the secondary structure of the carrier peptide. The conformation of hCT(9-32) was further corroborated by quantitative phi torsion angle measurements. Two monomeric structural models are consistent with the data: (i) a linear backbone conformation of hCT(9-32) and (ii) an antiparallel beta-sheet structure. These structures are maintained over a wide range of peptide:lipid mixing ratios. No direct indications for fibril formation of hCT(9-32) were found. Dipolar coupling measurements indicate rather high amplitudes of motion of the peptide.

DOTAP/DOPE and DC-Chol/DOPE lipoplexes for gene delivery: zeta potential measurements and electron spin resonance spectra

Non-viral vectors represent an important alternative in gene delivery. Among these vectors, cationic liposomes are widely studied, because of their ability to form stable complexes with DNA fragments (lipoplexes). In the present work, we report on the characterization by electron spin resonance (ESR) spectroscopy and zeta potential measurements of cationic liposomes and of their complexes with oligonucleotides. Liposomes were made with a zwitterionic lipid, DOPE, and a cationic lipid, either DOTAP or DC-Chol. Oligonucleotides were the 20-base single strand polyA, the 20-base single strand polyT, and the corresponding double strand dsAT. The zeta potential as a function of the oligonucleotide/lipid+ ratio gave an S-shaped titration curve. Well-defined surface potential changes took place upon charge compensation between the cationic lipid heads and the phosphate groups on the oligonucleotides. The inversion point depended on the specific system under study. The bilayer properties and the changes that occurred with the incorporation of DNA fragments were also monitored by ESR spectroscopy of appropriately tailored spin probes. For all the systems investigated, the ESR spectra showed that no major alteration took place after lipoplex formation and molecular packing remained substantially unchanged. Both zeta potential and ESR measurements were in favor of an external mode of packing of the lipoplexes.

Investigating fatty acids inserted into magnetically aligned phospholipid bilayers using EPR and solid-state NMR spectroscopy

This is the first time (2)H solid-state NMR spectroscopy and spin-labeled EPR spectroscopy have been utilized to probe the structural orientation and dynamics of a stearic acid incorporated into magnetically aligned phospholipid bilayers or bicelles. The data gleaned from the two different techniques provide a more complete description of the bilayer membrane system. Both methods provided similar qualitative information on the phospholipid bilayer, high order, and low motion for the hydrocarbon segment close to the carboxyl groups of the stearic acid and less order and more rapid motion at the end towards the terminal methyl groups. However, the segmental order parameters differed markedly due to the different orientations that the nitroxide and C-D bond axes transform with the various stearic acid acyl chain conformations, and because of the difference in dynamic sensitivity between NMR and EPR over the timescales examined. 5-, 7-, 12-, and 16-doxylstearic acids spin-labels were used in the EPR experiments and stearic acid-d(35) was used in the solid-state NMR experiments. The influence of the addition of cholesterol and the variation of temperature on the fatty acid hydrocarbon chain ordering in the DMPC/DHPC phospholipid bilayers was also studied. Cholesterol increased the degree of ordering of the hydrocarbon chains. Conversely, as the temperature of the magnetically aligned phospholipid bilayers increased, the order parameters decreased due to the higher random motion of the acyl chain of the stearic acid. The results indicate that magnetically aligned phospholipid bilayers are an excellent model membrane system and can be used for both NMR and EPR studies.

NMR solution structure and position of transportan in neutral phospholipid bicelles

Transportan is a chimeric cell-penetrating peptide constructed from the peptides galanin and mastoparan, which has the ability to internalize living cells carrying a hydrophilic load. In this study, we have determined the NMR solution structure and investigated the position of transportan in neutral bicelles. The structure revealed a well-defined alpha-helix in the C-terminal mastoparan part of the peptide and a weaker tendency to form an alpha-helix in the N-terminal domain. The position of the peptide in relation to the membrane, as studied by adding paramagnetic probes, shows that the peptide lies parallel to, and in the head-group region of the membrane surface. This result is supported by amide proton secondary chemical shifts.

The potential of fluorescent and spin-labeled steroid analogs to mimic natural cholesterol

Cholesterol analogs are often used to investigate lipid trafficking and membrane organization of native cholesterol. Here, the potential of various spin (doxyl moiety) and fluorescent (7-nitrobenz-2-oxa-1,3-diazol-4-yl (NBD) group) labeled cholesterol analogs as well as of fluorescent cholestatrienol and the naturally occurring dehydroergosterol to mimic the unique properties of native cholesterol in lipid membranes was studied in 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (POPC) membranes by electron paramagnetic resonance, nuclear magnetic resonance, and fluorescence spectroscopy. As cholesterol, all analogs undergo fluctuating motions of large amplitude parallel to the bilayer normal. Native cholesterol keeps a strict orientation in the membrane with the long axis parallel to the bilayer normal. Depending on the chemical modification or the position of the label, cholesterol analogs may adopt an "up-side-down" orientation in the membrane or may even fluctuate between "upright" and up-side-down orientation by rotational motions about the short axis not typical for native cholesterol. Those analogs are not able to induce a comparable condensation of phospholipid membranes as known for native cholesterol revealed by 2H nuclear magnetic resonance. However, cholesterol-induced lipid condensation is one of the key properties of native cholesterol, and, therefore, a well suited parameter to assess the potential of steroid analogs to mimic cholesterol. The study points to extreme caution when studying cholesterol behavior by the respective analogs. Among seven analogs investigated, only a spin-labeled cholesterol with the doxyl group at the end of the acyl chain and the fluorophore cholestatrienol mimic cholesterol satisfactorily. Dehydroergosterol has a similar upright orientation as cholesterol and could be used at low concentration (about 1 mol %), at which its lower potential to enhance lipid packing density does not perturb membrane organization.