ENDOR of metalloenzymes

The strength of EPR and ENDOR techniques in revealing structure-function relationships in metalloproteins

Recent technological and methodological advances have strongly increased the potential of electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) and electron nuclear double resonance (ENDOR) techniques to characterize the structure and dynamics of metalloproteins. These developments include the introduction of powerful pulsed EPR/ENDOR methodologies and the development of spectrometers operating at very high microwave frequencies and high magnetic fields. This overview focuses on how valuable information about metalloprotein structure-function relations can be obtained using a combination of EPR and ENDOR techniques. After an overview of the historical development and a limited theoretical description of some of the key EPR and ENDOR techniques, their potential will be highlighted using selected examples of applications to iron-, nickel-, cobalt-, and copper-containing proteins. We will end with an outlook of future developments.

Distance measurements between paramagnetic centers and a planar object by matrix Mims electron nuclear double resonance

Frequency-domain electron nuclear double resonance (ENDOR), two time-domain electron nuclear double resonance techniques, and electron spin echo envelope modulation spectroscopy are compared with respect to their merit in measurements of small hyperfine couplings to nuclei with intermediate gyromagnetic ratio such as 31P. The frequency-domain Mims ENDOR experiment is found to provide the most faithful line shapes. In the limit of long electron-nuclear distances of more than 0.5 nm, sensitivity of this experiment is optimized by matching the first interpulse delay to the transverse relaxation time of the electron spins. In the same limit, Mims ENDOR efficiency scales inversely with the sixth power of distance. Hyperfine splittings as small as 33 kHz can be detected, corresponding to an electron-31P distance of 1 nm. In systems, where a certain kind of nuclei is distributed in a plane, measurements of intermolecular hyperfine couplings can be analyzed in terms of a distance of closest approach of a paramagnetic center to that plane. By applying this technique to spin-labeled lipids in a fully hydrated lipid bilayer it is found that for a fraction of lipids, chain tilt angles can be 25 degrees larger than the mean tilt angle of the lipid chains. This model of all-trans hydrocarbon chains with a broad distribution of tilt angles is also consistent with orientation selection effects in high-field ENDOR spectra.

CW-EPR and ENDOR study of cytochrome c6 from Anabaena PCC 7119

The detailed analysis of the continuous-wave electron paramagnetic resonance and electron nuclear double resonance measurements on cytochrome c(6) from Anabaena PCC7119 reveals several electronic and structural properties of this hemeprotein. The oxidized protein shows two forms that differ in the arrangement of the residues that act as heme axial ligands. Information about the orientation of these residues is obtained for one of the forms, which turns out to differ from that found in the reduced protein from x-ray experiments. The biological significance of these results is discussed.

Principles and applications of ENDOR spectroscopy for structure determination in solution and disordered matrices

Both electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) and electron nuclear double resonance (ENDOR) spectroscopies are extremely powerful and versatile methods for the characterisation of paramagnetic systems in biology, chemistry, and physics. However, by comparison to EPR, ENDOR remains a less widely used technique. In this tutorial review the basic principles of continuous wave ENDOR are described. The theory of orientation selective ENDOR, for structure determination in frozen solutions and powders, is then described. A range of examples, illustrating the type of information obtained from the ENDOR spectrum, is finally presented.

Thirty years of microbial P450 monooxygenase research: Peroxo-heme intermediates—The central bus station in heme oxygenase catalysis

Oxygen has always been recognized as an essential element of many life forms, initially through its role as a terminal electron acceptor for the energy-generating pathways of oxidative phosphorylation. In 1955, Hayaishi et al. [Mechanism of the pyrocatechase reaction, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 77 (1955) 5450-5451] presented the most important discovery that changed this simplistic view of how Nature uses atmospheric dioxygen. His discovery, the naming and mechanistic understanding of the first "oxygenase" enzyme, has provided a wonderful opportunity and scientific impetus for four decades of researchers. This volume provides an opportunity to recognize the breakthroughs of the "Hayaishi School." Notable have been the prolific contributions of Professor Ishimura et al. [Oxygen and life. Oxygenases, Oxidases and Lipid Mediators, International Congress Series, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 2002], a first-generation Hayaishi product, to characterization of the cytochrome P450 monooxygenases.

Transient species involved in catalytic dioxygen/peroxide activation by hemoproteins: possible involvement of protonated Compound I species

Interaction of hemoproteins with peroxide leads in several cases to transient formation of ferric peroxo, ferric hydroperoxo, and "high-valent", formally Fev, oxo or hydroxo Compound species. Here, density functional calculations on ferric peroxo, ferric hydroperoxo, Compound and protonated Compound heme active site models are reported. The theoretical results, including calculated isotropic Fermi contact couplings and anisotropic spin dipole couplings, are found to generally correlate well with experimental EPR/ENDOR data. Hydrogen bonding and solvation affect the ferric-peroxo/ferrous-superoxo electromerism. The transition between the two electromers appears smooth, but neither hydrogen bonding to up to two water molecules, nor solvation appear able to dramatically alter the redox state of the superoxo ligand or of the iron. The presence of almost one full unpaired electron on the iron and of one full unpaired electron on the dioxygenic ligand in the "ferric-peroxo" state suggests a possible description of non-protonated "ferric-peroxo" as {ferric-superoxo+porphyrin radical}. Emerging from the DFT data is the possibility that a protonated Compound has already been detected in ENDOR experiments on cytochrome P450. The general feasibility of a protonated Compound in P450 monooxygenases is probed in light of these findings. To encompass the multiple mechanisms available in P450 for substrate oxidation, we define "mechanistic promiscuity" as the feature allowing an enzyme to perform the same reaction, with the same product, using more than one mechanism.

Spectroscopic approaches to elucidating novel iron-sulfur chemistry in the "radical-Sam" protein superfamily

Electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR), electron-nuclear double resonance (ENDOR), and Mössbauer spectroscopies and other physical methods have provided important new insights into the radical-SAM superfamily of proteins, which use iron-sulfur clusters and S-adenosylmethionine to initiate H atom abstraction reactions. This remarkable chemistry involves the generation of the extremely reactive 5'-deoxyadenosyl radical, the same radical intermediate utilized in B12-dependent reactions. Although early speculation focused on the possibility of an organometallic intermediate in radical-SAM reactions, current evidence points to novel chemistry involving a site-differentiated [4Fe-4S] cluster. The focus of this forum article is on one member of the radical-SAM superfamily, pyruvate formate-lyase activating enzyme, and how physical methods, primarily EPR and ENDOR spectroscopies, are contributing to our understanding of its structure and mechanism. New ENDOR data supporting coordination of the methionine moiety of SAM to the unique site of the [4Fe-4S]2+/+ cluster are presented.

Pyruvate formate-lyase activating enzyme: elucidation of a novel mechanism for glycyl radical formation

Pyruvate formate lyase activating enzyme is a member of a novel superfamily of enzymes that utilize S-adenosylmethionine to initiate radical catalysis. This enzyme has been isolated with several different iron-sulfur clusters, but single turnover monitored by EPR has identified the [4Fe-4S](1+) cluster as the catalytically active cluster; this cluster is believed to be oxidized to the [4Fe-4S](2+) state during turnover. The [4Fe-4S] cluster is coordinated by a three-cysteine motif common to the radical/S-adenosylmethionine superfamily, suggesting the presence of a unique iron in the cluster. The unique iron site has been confirmed by Mossbauer and ENDOR spectroscopy experiments, which also provided the first evidence for direct coordination of S-adenosylmethionine to an iron-sulfur cluster, in this case the unique iron of the [4Fe-4S] cluster. Coordination to the unique iron anchors the S-adenosylmethionine in the active site, and allows for a close association between the sulfonium of S-adenosylmethionine and the cluster as observed by ENDOR spectroscopy. The evidence to date leads to a mechanistic proposal involving inner-sphere electron transfer from the cluster to the sulfonium of S-adenosylmethionine, followed by or concomitant with C-S bond homolysis to produce a 5'-deoxyadenosyl radical; this transient radical abstracts a hydrogen atom from G734 to activate pyruvate formate lyase.

Direct Probing of Copper Active Site and Free Radical Formed during Bicarbonate-dependent Peroxidase Activity of Bovine and Human Copper,Zinc-superoxide Dismutases

Using X-band electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) and electron nuclear double resonance (ENDOR) spectroscopy at liquid helium temperatures, the Cu(II) coordination geometry at the active site of bovine and human copper,zinc-superoxide dismutases (bSOD1 and hSOD1) treated with H(2)O(2) and bicarbonate (HCO(3)(-)) was examined. The time course EPR of wild type human SOD1 (WT hSOD1), W32F hSOD1 mutant (tryptophan 32 substituted with phenylalanine), and bSOD1 treated with H(2)O(2) and HCO(3)(-) shows an initial reduction of active site Cu(II) to Cu(I) followed by its oxidation back to Cu(II) in the presence of H(2)O(2). However, HCO(3)(-) induced a Trp-32-derived radical from WT hSOD1 but not from bSOD1. The mutation of Trp-32 by phenylalanine totally eliminated the Trp-32 radical signal generated from W32F hSOD1 treated with HCO(3)(-) and H(2)O(2). Further characterization of the free radical was performed by UV irradiation of WT hSOD1 and bSOD1 that generated tryptophanyl and tyrosyl radicals. Both proton ((1)H) and nitrogen ((14)N) ENDOR studies of bSOD1 and hSOD1 in the presence of H(2)O(2) revealed a change in the geometry of His-46 (or His-44) and His-48 (or His-46) coordinated to Cu(II) at the active site of WT hSOD1 and bSOD1, respectively. However, in the presence of HCO(3)(-) and H(2)O(2), both (1)H and (14)N ENDOR spectra were almost identical to those derived from native bSOD1. We conclude that HCO(3)(-)-derived oxidant does not alter significantly the Cu(II) active site geometry and histidine coordination to Cu(II) in SOD1 as does H(2)O(2) alone; however, the oxidant derived from HCO(3)(-) (i.e. carbonate anion radical) reacts with surface-associated Trp-32 in hSOD1 to form the corresponding radical.

Spectroscopic and computational insights into the geometric and electronic properties of the A-cluster of acetyl-coenzyme A synthase

For the last two decades, the bifunctional enzyme acetyl-coenzyme A synthase/carbon monoxide dehydrogenase (ACS/CODH) from Moorella thermoacetica has been the subject of considerable research aimed at elucidating the geometric and electronic properties of the A-cluster, which serves as the active site for ACS catalysis. While the recent success in obtaining high-resolution X-ray structures of this enzyme solved many of the mysteries regarding the number, identities, and coordination environments of the metal centers of the A-cluster, fundamental questions concerning the catalytic mechanism of this highly elaborate polynuclear active site have yet to be answered. This Commentary summarizes relevant information obtained from spectroscopic and computational studies on the oxidized, reduced, and CO-bound forms of the A-cluster and highlights some of the key issues regarding the electronic properties and reactivity of this cluster that need to be addressed in future studies.

A superoxo-ferrous state in a reduced oxy-ferrous hemoprotein and model compounds

Cryoreduction of the [FeO2]6 (n = 6 is the number of electrons in 3d orbitals on Fe and pi* orbitals on O2) dioxygen-bound ferroheme through irradiation at 77 K generates an [FeO2]7 reduced oxy-heme. Numerous investigations have examined [FeO2]7 centers that have been characterized as peroxo-ferric centers, denoted [FeO2]per7, in which a ferriheme binds a dianionic peroxo-ligand. The generation of such an intermediate can be understood heuristically if the [FeO2]6 parent is viewed as a superoxo-ferric center and the injected electron localizes on the O-O moiety. We here report EPR/ENDOR experiments which show quite different properties for the [FeO2]7 centers produced by cryoreduction of monomeric oxy-hemoglobin (oxy-GMH3) from Glycera dibranchiata, which is unlike mammalian "globins" in having a leucine in place of the distal histidine; of frozen aprotic solutions of oxy-ferrous octaethyl porphyrin; and of the oxy-ferrous complex of the heme model, cyclidene. These [FeO2]7 centers are characterized as "superoxo-ferrous" centers ([FeO2]sup7), with nearly unit spin density localized on a superoxo moiety which is end-on coordinated to a low-spin ferrous ion. This assignment is based on their g tensors and 17O hyperfine couplings, which are characteristic of the superoxide ion coordinated to a diamagnetic metal ion, and on the absence of detectable ENDOR signals either from the in-plane 14N ligands or from an exchangeable H-bond proton. Such a center would arise if the electron that adds to the [FeO2]6 superoxo-ferric parent localizes on the Fe ion, to make a superoxo-ferrous moiety. Upon annealing to T > 150 K, the [FeO2]sup7 species converts to peroxo/hydroperoxo-ferric ([FeO2H]7) intermediates. These experiments suggest that the primary reduction product is [FeO2]sup7 and that the internal redox transition to [FeO2]per7/[FeO2H]7 states is driven at least in part by H-bonding/proton donation by the environment.

Kinetic isotope effects on the rate-limiting step of heme oxygenase catalysis indicate concerted proton transfer/heme hydroxylation

Heme oxygenase (HO) catalyzes the O2 and NADPH/cytochrome P450 reductase-dependent conversion of heme to biliverdin, free iron ion, and CO through a process in which the heme participates as both dioxygen-activating prosthetic group and substrate. We earlier confirmed that the first step of HO catalysis is a monooxygenation in which the addition of one electron and two protons to the HO oxy-ferroheme produces ferric-alpha-meso-hydroxyheme (h). Cryoreduction/EPR and ENDOR measurements further showed that hydroperoxo-ferri-HO converts directly to h in a single kinetic step without formation of a Compound I. We here report details of that rate-limiting step. One-electron 77 K cryoreduction of human oxy-HO and annealing at 200 K generates a structurally relaxed hydroperoxo-ferri-HO species, denoted R. We here report the cryoreduction/annealing experiments that directly measure solvent and secondary kinetic isotope effects (KIEs) of the rate-limiting R --> h conversion, using enzyme prepared with meso-deuterated heme and in H2O/D2O buffers to measure the solvent KIE (solv-KIE), and the secondary KIE (sec-KIE) associated with the conversion. This approach is unique in that KIEs measured by monitoring the rate-limiting step are not susceptible to masking by KIEs of other processes, and these results represent the first direct measurement of the KIEs of product formation by a kinetically competent reaction intermediate in any dioxygen-activating heme enzyme.The observation of both solv-KIE(298) = 1.8 and sec-KIE(298) = 0.8 (inverse) indicates that the rate-limiting step for formation of h by HO is a concerted process: proton transfer to the hydroperoxo-ferri-heme through the distal-pocket H-bond network, likely from a carboxyl group acting as a general acid catalyst, occurring in synchrony with bond formation between the terminal hydroperoxo-oxygen atom and the alpha-meso carbon to form a tetrahedral hydroxylated-heme intermediate. Subsequent rearrangement and loss of H2O then generates h.