Better oral reading and short-term memory in midlife, postmenopausal women taking estrogen

Surgical versus natural menopause: cognitive issues

OBJECTIVE

Women who undergo both natural and surgical menopause experience the loss of cyclic ovarian production of estrogen, but hormonal and demographic differences distinguish these two groups of women. Our objective was to review published evidence on whether the premature cessation of endogenous estrogen production in women who underwent a surgical menopause has deleterious consequences for cognitive aging and to determine whether consequences differ for women if they undergo natural menopause. Studies of estrogen-containing hormone therapy are relevant to this issue.

DESIGN

We reviewed evidence-based research, including the systematic identification of randomized clinical trials of hormone therapy with cognitive outcomes that included an objective measure of episodic memory.

RESULTS

As inferred from very small, short-term, randomized, controlled trials of high-dose estrogen treatment, surgical menopause may be accompanied by cognitive impairment that primarily affects verbal episodic memory. Observational evidence suggests that the natural menopausal transition is not accompanied by substantial changes in cognitive abilities. For initiation of hormone therapy during perimenopause or early postmenopause when the ovaries are intact, limited clinical trial data provide no consistent evidence of short-term benefit or harm. There is stronger clinical trial evidence that initiation of hormone therapy in late postmenopause does not benefit episodic memory or other cognitive skills.

CONCLUSIONS

Further research is needed on the long-term cognitive consequences of surgical menopause and long-term cognitive consequences of hormone therapy initiated near the time of surgical or natural menopause. A potential short-term cognitive benefit might be weighed when a premenopausal woman considers initiation of estrogen therapy at the time of, or soon after, hysterectomy and oophorectomy for benign conditions, although data are still quite limited and estrogen is not approved for this indication. Older postmenopausal women should not initiate hormone therapy to improve or maintain cognitive skills.

Endogenous estrogen is not associated with cognitive performance before, during, or after menopause

OBJECTIVE

In a population-based sample of women (45, 50, or 55 years old), behavioral data and blood serum were collected concurrently, enabling us (1) to investigate cognitive differences among premenopausal, perimenopausal, and postmenopausal groups of women and (2) to evaluate the relationship between blood estrogen levels and cognitive performance.

DESIGN

Groups of premenopausal (n = 129), perimenopausal (n = 58), and postmenopausal (n = 55) women were tested on tasks assessing episodic and semantic memory, verbal fluency, visuospatial performance, and face recognition. Blood serum was collected concurrently for analyses of estrogen levels.

RESULTS

With inclusion of controls for age and education, results showed that there were no differences in cognitive performance among premenopausal, perimenopausal, and postmenopausal groups of women. In addition, there were no associations between blood estrogen levels and cognitive performance.

CONCLUSIONS

These results do not support the hypothesis that estrogen or menopausal status affects cognitive performance in middle-aged women.

Estradiol and tryptophan depletion interact to modulate cognition in menopausal women

Despite an abundance of data in animals, there is little research in humans regarding how estrogen and serotonin (5-HT) may interact to influence cognition. Through the use of estrogen treatment (ET) and tryptophan depletion (TRP-D) in a within-subject design involving healthy menopausal women, we have manipulated both estrogen and 5-HT in order to evaluate their individual and joint effects. Although neither manipulation influenced visuospatial learning, a significant interaction suggested that estrogen exerted a protective effect on verbal memory, such that TRP-D impaired performance to a greater extent before the administration of ET. In consonance with this finding, ET was associated with a small, but positive mood effect on the day following active TRP-D. In addition, ET significantly improved letter-cued verbal fluency with and without TRP-D. Finally, time since last menstrual period was significantly associated with verbal memory scores, such that longer length of hypogonadism resulted in decreased verbal memory performance. These data support the interaction of estrogen and 5-HT in nonreproductive behavior in humans as well as highlight the role of ovarian steroids in cognition.

Complex actions of sex steroids in adipose tissue, the cardiovascular system, and brain: Insights from basic science and clinical studies

Recent publications describing the results of the Women's Health Initiative (WHI) and other studies reporting the impact of hormone therapy on aging women have spurred reexamination of the broad use of estrogens and progestins during the postmenopausal years. Here, we review the complex pharmacology of these hormones, the diverse and sometimes opposite effects that result from the use of different estrogenic and progestinic compounds, given via different delivery routes in different concentrations and treatment sequence, and to women of different ages and health status. We examine our new and growing appreciation of the role of estrogens in the immune system and the inflammatory response, and we pose the concept that estrogen's interface with this system may be at the core of some of the effects on multiple physiological systems, such as the adipose/metabolic system, the cardiovascular system, and the central nervous system. We compare and contrast clinical and basic science studies as we focus on the actions of estrogens in these systems because the untoward effects of hormone therapy reported in the WHI were not expected. The broad interpretation and publicity of the results of the WHI have resulted in a general condemnation of all hormone replacement in postmenopausal women. In fact, careful review of the extensive literature suggests that data resulting from the WHI and other recent studies should be interpreted within the narrow context of the study design. We argue that these results should encourage us to perform new studies that take advantage of a dialogue between basic scientists and clinician scientists to ensure appropriate design, incorporation of current knowledge, and proper interpretation of results. Only then will we have a better understanding of what hormonal compounds should be used in which populations of women and at what stages of menopausal/postmenopausal life.

Verified hormone therapy improves episodic memory performance in healthy postmenopausal women

Studies of hormone therapy (HT) and cognition have yielded conflicting results. The aim of this observational study was to examine the effect of estradiol, via serum verified HT (estradiol, estriol, progesterone) and endogenous estradiol, on 108 healthy postmenopausal women's cognitive performance. The results demonstrated that the 43 HT-users performed at a significantly higher level than non-users on episodic memory tasks and on a verbal fluency task, whereas HT-users and non-users did not differ on tasks assessing semantic memory and spatial visualization. In addition, there was a positive relationship between serum estradiol level and episodic memory performance, indicating that postmenopausal HT is associated with enhanced episodic memory and verbal fluency, independent of age and education. These observational results suggest that HT use may be sufficient to exert small, yet positive effects on female sensitive cognitive tasks. Hormone therapy compliance and formulation is discussed as confounding factors in previous research.

Hormone treatment gives no benefit against cognitive changes caused by acute sleep deprivation in postmenopausal women

The objective was to evaluate whether hormone therapy (HT) gives any benefit against the possible impairment of cognitive performance when challenged by acute sleep deprivation. Twenty postmenopausal women volunteered (age range 59-72 years, mean=64.4 years, SD=4.4): 10 HT users and 10 nonusers. Eleven young women served as a control group for the cognitive age effect (age range 20-26 years, mean age 23.1 years, SD=1.6). The subjects spent four consecutive nights at the sleep laboratory and were exposed to acute sleep deprivation of 40 h. Measures of attention (reaction speed and vigilance), alertness, and mood were administered every 2 h during the daytime and every hour during the sleep deprivation night. Postmenopausal women performed slower than young controls, whereas young controls made more errors. In HT users, the recovery night did not fully restore the performance in the simple and two-choice reaction time tasks, but in nonusers it did so. Sleep deprivation had a detrimental, yet reversible effect on vigilance in all groups. In all groups, sleepiness started to increase after 15 h of sleep deprivation and remained elevated in the morning after the recovery night. Prolonged wakefulness or HT had no effect on mood. In conclusion, sleep deprivation impaired cognitive performance in postmenopausal as well as young women. Postmenopausal women kept up their performance at the expense of reaction speed and young women at the expense of accuracy. One night was not enough for HT users to recover from sleep deprivation. Thus, HT gave no benefit in maintaining the attention and alertness during sleep deprivation.

Estrogen therapy selectively enhances prefrontal cognitive processes: a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study with functional magnetic resonance imaging in perimenopausal and recently postmenopausal women

OBJECTIVE

Estrogen therapy (ET) seems to differentially effect cognitive processes in younger versus older postmenopausal women, suggesting a window of opportunity when ET is most beneficial. Cognitive improvement in younger postmenopausal women has been attributed to ET's influence on hot flushes and sleep, but empiric examination of the mediating role of menopause symptoms versus direct effects of ET on the brain is limited.

DESIGN

In a double-blind trial, 52 women were randomly assigned to estradiol 0.05 mg/day (n = 26) or placebo transdermal patches (n = 26) for 12 weeks. Women completed tests of memory, learning, and executive functioning, and hot flush and sleep assessments at baseline and study end. A subset of women (five ET treated, six placebo treated) also underwent blood oxygenation level-dependent (BOLD) functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) studies.

RESULTS

Nondepressed perimenopausal and postmenopausal women were studied. The majority had hot flushes and sleep impairment. Compared with placebo, ET selectively reduced errors of perseveration during verbal recall (P = 0.03), a frontal system-mediated function, but did not influence other cognitive processes. Women with baseline hot flushes had greater cognitive benefit with ET (P < 0.05). Cognitive benefit was not associated with sleep problems or its improvement. Measures of fMRI BOLD activation during tests of verbal and spatial working memory showed significant increases in frontal system activity with ET (P < 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

Estrogen therapy selectively improves executive functioning as demonstrated by reduced perseverative errors and prefrontal cortex activation during verbal recall tasks. Cognitive improvement with ET is associated with hot flushes, but not with sleep, suggesting that ET has a direct central nervous system effect, rather than an indirect effect mediated through improvement of sleep.

A systematic review of clinical trials of hormone therapy on cognitive function: effects of age at initiation and progestin use

The putative protective effects of hormone therapy (HT) have been cast in doubt by recent findings from the Women's Health Initiative Memory Study showing an increase in dementia and an increased likelihood of impaired cognitive status in women initiating HT after age 65. To explore the external generalizability of those findings to younger postmenopausal women, the medical literature was surveyed for randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trials of treatment with either estrogen alone or estrogen plus a progestin on neuropsychological test performance. Findings from trials in younger women (<65 years) are presented separately from those in older women (>or=65 years). This review finds little support for beneficial cognitive effects in older women of estrogen alone or in combination with progestin. However, evidence from younger women suggests potential beneficial effects in select cognitive domains, particularly among symptomatic women and recently menopausal women, and scant evidence of harm. There is a dearth of studies of the cognitive effects of estrogen plus progestin in younger women. Future studies systematically exploring the effect of age and progestin use are needed to better characterize the effects of HT on cognition in younger women. Without firm evidence of benefit to younger women, it is prudent to caution early postmenopausal women about the cognitive risks observed in WHI, recognizing the low likelihood of dementia at that age.

Estrogen-containing hormone therapy and Alzheimer’s disease risk: Understanding discrepant inferences from observational and experimental research

Estrogen has the potential to influence brain processes implicated in Alzheimer's disease pathogenesis. With the loss of ovarian estrogen production after menopause, estrogen-containing hormone therapy might be expected to influence the risk of Alzheimer's disease. Observational data link use of hormone therapy to reductions in Alzheimer risk, but experimental evidence from the Women's Health Initiative Memory Study trial demonstrates that oral estrogen, with or without a progestin, increases the incidence of dementia for postmenopausal women age 65 years or older. Mechanisms of harm in this setting are unknown. Bias and unrecognized confounding in observational research are leading candidates for discrepant results between observational studies and the Women's Health Initiative Memory Study trial. Studies are also distinguished by differences in outcome measures, hormone therapy formulations, prevalence of menopausal symptoms among study participants, and participant age. Finally, Women's Health Initiative Memory Study findings may not generalize to estrogen use by relatively young women during the menopausal transition or early postmenopause, a class of women who were ineligible for the Women's Health Initiative Memory Study trial. In observational studies, hormone therapy exposure often included use by younger women for menopausal vasomotor symptoms. Although there is no clinical trial evidence that hormone therapy at any age protects against Alzheimer's disease, it remains to be determined whether the age at which hormone exposure occurs or the timing of hormone therapy initiation in relation to the menopause (the critical window hypothesis) modifies treatment outcomes on dementia risk.

Hormone therapy and cognitive function: is there a critical period for benefit?

The large majority of women receiving hormone therapy initiate therapy early in life for the treatment of menopausal symptoms. However, the Women's Health Initiative Memory Study, the only randomized clinical trial to date on hormone therapy and dementia, was carried out in women age 65 and older. That trial provided important insights into the detrimental effects of hormone therapy on dementia in women initiating later in life. The generalizability of those findings to the typical hormone therapy user who initiates earlier in life is unknown. To address this important issue, this review focuses on observational trials of hormone therapy and dementia risk, randomized clinical trials of hormone therapy and cognitive function, and basic science studies. These lines of research provide suggestive, but not definitive, evidence that early initiation of hormone therapy may provide cognitive benefits, particularly to verbal memory and other hippocampally mediated functions. Other forms of hormone therapy, other cognitive domains, and cyclic hormone regimens may not conform to this "critical period hypothesis." Further research is needed to test the validity and limits of this hypothesis.

Hormone replacement therapy and cognitive performance in postmenopausal women—a review by cognitive domain

Laboratory, animal and neuroimaging evidences suggest that hormone replacement therapy (HRT) may be beneficial to human cognition. This systematic review includes 26 studies on the association between HRT and cognition and 17 studies on HRT and risk of dementia. It was hypothesised that HRT would have a positive association with cognitive speed and verbal memory and possibly visual memory but not with executive functioning, and would be associated with a decreased risk of dementia. Evidence for HRT's neuroenhancing and neuroprotective properties was also evaluated. There was significant statistical and clinical heterogeneity among studies precluding meta-analysis. Results showed no consistent relationship between HRT and performance in any cognitive domain. Cross-sectional studies tended to report more positive results than longitudinal studies and randomised-controlled trials, particularly in the areas of verbal memory and executive functioning. HRT was associated with decreased risk of dementia in observational studies, but with increased risk in one randomised-controlled trial. Cognitive improvement or maintenance are not secondary benefits of HRT.

A longitudinal study of cognition change during early menopausal transition in a rural community

OBJECTIVE

To characterize changes in cognition that occur during the hormonal transitions of menopause.

METHOD

We conducted a longitudinal population-based study in Kinmen, Taiwan, recruiting all women age 40-54 years who were premenopausal and without a history of hormone replacement therapy (HRT) or hysterectomy. The cognitive measures used to assess function included the Auditory-Verbal Learning Test, visual memory, verbal fluency, Trail Making Test and digit span.

RESULTS

A total of 694 eligible women participated in the baseline study, and 573 women (83%) completed follow-up 18 months later. After excluding 78 women who received hysterectomy or HRT, the final sample was composed of 495 subjects, of whom 114 (23%) progressed to perimenopause during follow-up. Women who remained premenopausal were younger than those who became perimenopausal (44.7 +/- 2.3 years versus 47.1 +/- 3.0 years, p < 0.01). All follow-up cognitive scores in women who entered perimenopause were slightly better than baseline measures except for Rey Auditory-Verbal Learning Test, which decreased by 0.23 (S.D. = 2.9, p = 0.3). At follow-up, cognitive function except for verbal fluency did not differ significantly between women who stayed premenopausal and those became perimenopausal after controlling for age, education, and baseline cognitive scores. Women who entered perimenopause have an average of 1.3 items (S.D. = 0.4) less in verbal fluency measures as compared with their premenopausal peers at the follow-up period.

CONCLUSIONS

The menopausal transition might not accompany significant cognitive decline except for verbal fluency.

Direct, complex effects of estrogens on basal forebrain cholinergic neurons

Although controversial, estrogens remain one of the few agents purported to influence the incidence of Alzheimer's disease and one of their postulated mechanisms of action is their effects on basal forebrain cholinergic neurons. However, it is unclear whether the responses of cholinergic neurons to estrogens are direct or mediated via the retrograde influences of neurotrophins, known to be induced by estrogens in the hippocampus and neocortex. In the present study, we explore the issue of the primary site of action of estrogens by studying the regulation of expression of genes that characterize mature cholinergic neurons, i.e., choline acetyltransferase, trkA, and p75(NTR) in the medial septum and the nucleus basalis complex. In parallel, we study the hippocampal expression of NGF, BDNF, and NT-3, i.e., neurotrophins with known trophic roles on cholinergic neurons. Gene expression is studied by RT-PCR in ovariectomized female rats with and without estrogen supplementation within the physiological estradiol range and in rats with complete fimbria-fornix transactions treated with estrogen or vehicle. To clarify mechanisms of estrogen transduction in cholinergic neurons, we study the effects of estrogen treatment on fimbria-fornix-lesioned mice with genetic ablations of ER subtypes alpha and beta. The results of the present study suggest that, while estrogens do regulate BDNF expression in the hippocampus and neocortex, they also exert stimulatory non-trophic effects on basal forebrain cholinergic neurons, primarily on ChAT expression. Cholinergic neurons retain their ability to respond to estrogens after their complete separation from the hippocampus. The elimination of ERalpha alters significantly the phenotypic responsiveness of cholinergic neurons to estrogens, whereas elimination of ERbeta appears to have no effect. Our findings support the idea that estrogens directly enhance cholinergic neuron function and that ERalpha plays a significant role in transducing these regulatory effects.

Clinical Pharmacology and Differential Cognitive Efficacy of Estrogen Preparations

Menopause is associated with a significant decline in levels of estrogen, which reportedly leads to several distressing symptoms and adverse health effects on various target tissues including those on bones, heart, and brain. Although effective, the long-term safety and feasibility of therapy with both unopposed and opposed oral conjugated equine estrogen has been questioned by the recent findings of both the Women's Health Initiative (WHI) and the Women's Health Initiative Memory Study (WHIMS). The findings of both these studies have raised several critical issues related to hormone therapy that need to be systematically evaluated in clinical studies. Specifically, these issues relate to the differential efficacy and adverse-effects profile of various forms of estrogen and progestins, the importance of the route of administration of estrogen, the best timing to initiate postmenopausal hormone therapy, and the efficacy of cyclic versus continuous hormone therapy. This article focuses on estrogen and discusses issues related to selecting the best form and route of administration of the hormone. It includes information on basic clinical pharmacology of various forms of estrogen, neuroendocrinology of the menopause, neurobiology of estradiol and estrone, and results of selected basic science and human intervention studies with relevance to identifying the best form and route of administration of estrogen.

Hormone therapy and risk for dementia: where do we go from here?

Prospective observational studies suggest that hormone therapy (HT) might confer protection against the development of Alzheimer's disease. In contrast, recent findings from the Women's Health Initiative Memory Study (WHIMS) indicated a doubling of the risk of all-cause dementia in women randomized to receive HT after age 64. The discrepancy between findings from observational studies and the WHIMS is commonly attributed to the lack of treatment bias in the randomized trial. However, there are other potentially important dfferences between the WHIMS and the observational studies. These include timing of initiation of HT and type of HT regimen used. The present review focuses on the clinical and basic science studies bearing on these clinically important issues. Additional clinical studies are needed to understand the external generalizability of the WHIMS results to populations of women for whom HT remains an indication.

Median raphe mediates estrogenic effects to the hippocampus in female rats

Subcortical regions such as the medial septum-diagonal band of Broca and supramammillary area have been shown to mediate indirect oestrogenic effects on hippocampal morphology and function. Here, the role of the median raphe (MR), a serotonergic subcortical structure, is studied. To this end, 17beta-estradiol-filled 30-gauge cannulae were implanted into the MR of female ovariectomized rats; cholesterol-filled cannulae served as controls. After seven days, using unbiased electron microscopic stereological calculations and semiquantitative analysis, the spine synapse density and surface density of glial fibrillary acidic protein-positive astrocyte processes, respectively, were determined in the stratum radiatum of the CA1 region of the hippocampus. Changes in the serotonergic innervation of the hippocampal CA1 region were determined by immunohistochemistry and subsequent morphometric analysis. In the stratum radiatum of the CA1 region, local estradiol application into the MR resulted in a 47% increase in spine synapse density. Simultaneously, the density of glial fibrillary acidic protein-positive fibers decreased by 16%. The density of serotonin (5-HT) innervation of the strata lacunosum moleculare and radiatum of the CA1 region of the hippocampus was reduced in response to estradiol, as shown by a decrease in the length of fibers (27.6 and 48.3% decrease, respectively) and the number of large varicosities (32.5 and 38.8% decrease, respectively). These observations suggest a major role of the MR in mediating oestrogenic effects on the hippocampus and an involvement of the serotonergic system.