Plant proteolytic enzymes: possible roles during programmed cell death

Induction of programmed cell death in lily by the fungal pathogen Botrytis elliptica

SUMMARY The genus Botrytis contains necrotrophic plant pathogens that have a wide host range (B. cinerea) or are specialized on a single host species, e.g. B. elliptica on lily. In this study, it was found that B. elliptica-induced cell death of lily displays hallmark features of animal programmed cell death or apoptosis including cytoplasmic shrinkage, nuclear DNA fragmentation and the accumulation of NO as well as H(2)O(2). A pharmacological approach showed that B. elliptica-induced cell death could be modulated by serine and cysteine protease inhibitors including one caspase inhibitor. Blocking phosphatase activity stimulated cell death and concomitant lesion formation, suggesting that B. elliptica-induced cell death is mediated by kinase/phosphatase pathways. Blocking Ca(2+) influx restricted cell death. Blocking steps of sphingolipid biosynthesis delayed lily cell death for several days. B. elliptica culture filtrate (CF) was able to induce lily cell death by means of secreted proteins. Induction of cell death is necessary and sufficient for pathogenicity and host specialization because prior infiltration of B. elliptica CF enabled subsequent infection of lily by the otherwise incompatible pathogens B. cinerea and B. tulipae. The secreted B. elliptica proteins also induced cell death in some but not all Arabidopsis accessions and mutants. Arabidopsis accessions that respond to infiltration of B. elliptica CF also display cell death symptoms upon inoculation with B. elliptica conidia.

Expression of proteinase inhibitor II proteins during floral development in Solanum americanum

The heterologous expression of serine proteinase inhibitor II (PIN2) proteins confers insect resistance in transgenic plants, but little is known of their endogenous roles. We have cloned two cDNAs encoding Solanum americanum PIN2 proteins, SaPIN2a and SaPIN2b. SaPIN2a is highly expressed in stem, particularly in the phloem, suggesting it could possibly regulate proteolysis in the sieve elements. When SaPIN2a was expressed in transgenic lettuce, we observed an inhibition of endogenous trypsin- and chymotrypsin-like activities. Here, we demonstrate that both SaPIN2a and SaPIN2b are expressed in floral tissues that are destined to undergo developmental programmed cell death (PCD), suggesting possible endogenous roles in inhibiting trypsin- and chymotrypsin-like activities during flower development. Northern and western blot analyses revealed that SaPIN2a and SaPIN2b mRNAs and proteins show highest expression early in floral development. In situ hybridization analysis and immunolocalization on floral sections, localized SaPIN2a and SaPIN2b mRNAs and their proteins to tissues that would apparently undergo PCD: the ovules, the stylar transmitting tissue, the stigma and the vascular bundles. Detection of PCD in floral sections was achieved using terminal deoxynucleotidyltransferase-mediated dUTP nick end labeling (TUNEL) analysis. Examination of the mid-style before, and 1 day after, pollination revealed that high expression of SaPIN2a and SaPIN2b in the style was inversely correlated with PCD.

Features of a 103-kb gene-rich region in soybean include an inverted perfect repeat cluster of CHS genes comprising the I locus

The I locus in soybean (Glycine max) corresponds to a region of chalcone synthase (CHS) gene duplications affecting seed pigmentation. We sequenced and annotated BAC clone 104J7, which harbors a dominant i(i) allele from Glycine max 'Williams 82', to gain insight into the genetic structure of this multigenic region in addition to examining its flanking regions. The 103-kb BAC encompasses a gene-rich region with 11 putatively expressed genes. In addition to six copies of CHS, these genes include: a geranylgeranyltransferase type II beta subunit (E.C.2.5.1.60), a beta-galactosidase, a putative spermine and (or) spermidine synthase (E.C.2.5.1.16), and an unknown expressed gene. Strikingly, sequencing data revealed that the 10.91-kb CHS1, CHS3, CHS4 cluster is present as a perfect inverted repeat separated by 5.87 kb. Contiguous arrangement of CHS paralogs could lead to folding into multiple secondary structures, hypothesized to induce deletions that have previously been shown to effect CHS expression. BAC104J7 also contains several gene fragments representing a cation/hydrogen exchanger, a 40S ribosomal protein, a CBL-interacting protein kinase, and the amino terminus of a subtilisin. Chimeric ESTs were identified that may represent read-through transcription from a flanking truncated gene into a CHS cluster, generating aberrant CHS RNA molecules that could play a role in CHS gene silencing.

A proteomic analysis of plant programmed cell death

Programmed cell death (PCD) is an active cellular suicide that occurs in animals and plants throughout development and in response to both abiotic and biotic stresses. In contrast to animals, little is known about the molecular machinery that regulates plant PCD. We have previously identified transcriptomic changes associated with heat- and senescence-induced PCD in an Arabidopsis cell suspension culture [Plant J. 30 (2002) 431]. However, since plant PCD is also likely to involve elements that are regulated post-transcriptionally, we have undertaken a proteomic analysis in the Arabidopsis system. We identified 11 proteins that increased in abundance relative to total protein in both treatments despite extensive degradation of other proteins. We argue that some of these proteins are maintained during PCD and may therefore have specific functions in the PCD pathway. The increased abundance of several antioxidant proteins as well as a measured increase in free Fe2+ content of the cells indicates an oxidative stress in this system. Several mitochondrial proteins were identified, confirming the importance of this organelle during PCD. We also identified an extracellular glycoprotein that may function in the transmission of a 'death signal' from cell to cell. Putative roles for the identified proteins are presented.

Fusicoccin affects cytochrome c leakage and cytosolic 14-3-3 accumulation independent of H-ATPase activation

Fusicoccin (FC) is a well known toxin acting as a 14-3-3 protein-mediated activator of the plasma membrane H(+)-ATPase and the biochemical and physiological changes induced in the cell by this toxin have, up to now, been ascribed to the increased rate of proton extrusion by this pump leading to external acidification and cell hyperpolarization. In a recent work (Malerba M et al. 2003, Physiologia Plantarum, 119: 480-488) it was shown that, besides the previously well studied changes, FC induces a large stimulation of H(2)O(2) production, an activation of alternative respiration and a leakage of cytochrome c from mitochondria. In this article further studies on the relation between the H(2)O(2) overproduction and medium acidification are reported. The increase in the rate of H(2)O(2) accumulation is particularly evident when high concentrations of the toxin ensure a rapid acidification of the medium, but it is not obtained when the time-course of acidification is reproduced by external acid additions. The FC-dependent H(2)O(2) overproduction is strongly inhibited by inhibitors of the H(+)-ATPase activity, such as vanadate and erythrosin B, and it does not occur when the activation of the H(+)-ATPase is prevented by phenylarsine oxide (PAO), an inhibitor of the activating interaction between the enzyme and its regulative 14-3-3 protein. Interestingly, all these inhibitors only partially prevent the leakage of cytochrome c from the mitochondria. A kinetic analysis of FC-dependent changes of 14-3-3s shows that the initial increase in the plasma membrane level of these proteins, presumably due to translocation of free cytosolic forms, is followed by a remarkable increase in the level of the 14-3-3 proteins located in the cytosol. This latter change is not prevented by inhibitors of the activity or activation of the H(+)-ATPase. These results suggest that, besides the H(+)-ATPase activation, FC can induce other cell changes possibly mediated by changes of the regulative 14-3-3 proteins.

The S8 serine, C1A cysteine and A1 aspartic protease families in Arabidopsis

The Arabidopsis thaliana genome has over 550 protease sequences representing all five catalytic types: serine, cysteine, aspartic acid, metallo and threonine (MEROPS peptidase database, http://merops.sanger.ac.uk/), which probably reflect a wide variety of as yet unidentified functions performed by plant proteases. Recent indications that the 26S proteasome, a T1 family-threonine protease, is a regulator of light and hormone responsive signal transduction highlight the potential of proteases to participate in many aspects of plant growth and development. Recent discoveries that proteases are required for stomatal distribution, embryo development and disease resistance point to wider roles for four additional multigene families that include some of the most frequently studied (yet poorly understood) plant proteases: the subtilisin-like, serine proteases (family S8), the papain-like, cysteine proteases (family C1A), the pepsin-like, aspartic proteases (family A1) and the plant matrixin, metalloproteases (family M10A). In this report, 54 subtilisin-like, 30 papain-like and 59 pepsin-like proteases from Arabidopsis, are compared with S8, C1A and A1 proteases known from other plant species at the functional, phylogenetic and gene structure levels. Examples of structural conservation between S8, C1A and A1 genes from rice, barley, tomato and soybean and those from Arabidopsis are noted, indicating that some common, essential plant protease roles were established before the divergence of monocots and eudicots. Numerous examples of tandem duplications of protease genes and evidence for a variety of restricted expression patterns suggest that a high degree of specialization exists among proteases within each family. We propose that comprehensive analysis of the functions of these genes in Arabidopsis will firmly establish serine, cysteine and aspartic proteases as regulators and effectors of a wide range of plant processes.

Nitric oxide-mediated transcriptional changes in Arabidopsis thaliana

Nitric oxide (NO) is an essential regulatory molecule in several developmental processes and in the stress response in both animal and plant systems. Furthermore, key features of plant resistance to pathogens have been shown to depend on NO production, e.g., defense gene expression and the activation of a hypersensitive reaction (HR) in synergy with reactive oxygen species (ROS). Due to the many possible mechanisms of NO action, a clear picture of its involvement in plant resistance to pathogens is far from being achieved. Transcriptional changes related to NO action are likely to play a significant role in resistance and cell death. We investigated the changes in the expression profiles of Arabidopsis thaliana following infiltration with the NO donor sodium nitroprusside, by cDNA-amplification fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) transcript profiling. Altered expression patterns were detected for 120 of the approximately 2,500 cDNAs examined. Sequence analysis revealed homologies with genes involved in signal transduction, disease resistance and stress response, photosynthesis, cellular transport, and basic metabolism or with sequences coding for unknown proteins. Comparison of the expression profiles with data from public microarray sources revealed that many of the identified genes modulated by NO were previously reported to be modulated in disease-related experiments.

The intermembrane space of plant mitochondria contains a DNase activity that may be involved in programmed cell death

The key role for mitochondria in mammalian apoptosis, a form of programmed cell death (PCD), is well established, but a similar role for plant mitochondria is just emerging. In order to unravel the molecular mechanisms linking plant mitochondria to the downstream events of PCD, we have developed an Arabidopsis cell-free system that can be used to monitor biochemical and morphological changes in isolated nuclei that are associated with PCD. Using this system, two activities that resulted in nuclear DNA degradation could be distinguished, both of which were facilitated by the addition of mitochondria. One activity mediated the generation of 30 kb DNA fragments within 3 h and chromatin condensation within 6 h, when nuclei were incubated with mitochondria alone. The second activity required cytosolic extract in addition to mitochondria and resulted in oligonucleosome-sized DNA cleavage after >12 h. Submitochondrial fractionation and pharmacological studies suggested the presence of an Mg2+-dependent nuclease activity in the intermembrane space, which is responsible for the former in vitro activity. The evolutionary conservation of the role of mitochondria in PCD in animals and plants is discussed.

Activation of the programmed cell death pathway by inhibition of proteasome function in plants

Proteasomes constitute the major machinery to degrade or process proteins by ATP/ubiquitin-mediated proteolysis. Recent findings suggest a pivotal role of the ubiquitin/proteasome pathway in the regulation of apoptosis in animal cells. Here we show that virus-induced gene silencing of two different subunits of the 26 S proteasome, the alpha 6 subunit of the 20 S proteasome and RPN9 subunit of 19 S regulatory complex, both activated the programmed cell death (PCD) program, accompanied by reduced proteasome activity and accumulation of polyubiquitinated proteins. These results demonstrate that disruption of proteasome function leads to PCD in plant cells. The affected cells showed morphological markers of PCD, including nuclear condensation and DNA fragmentation, accompanied by the 10-fold higher production of reactive oxygen species and increased ion leakage for 3-fold. Similar to apoptosis in animal system, mitochondrial membrane potential was decreased, cytochrome c released from mitochondria to cytosol, and caspase 9- and caspase 3-like proteolytic activities detected in the cells. Interestingly, this proteasome-mediated PCD stimulated the expression of only a subset of transcripts that are highly induced during pathogen-mediated hypersensitive response cell death, indicating that the two PCD pathways are differentially regulated. Taken together, these results provide the first direct evidence that proteasomes play a role in the regulatory program of PCD in plants. Controlled inhibition of proteasome activities may be involved in developmentally or environmentally activated plant cell death programs.

Identification of dehydration-responsive cysteine proteases during post-harvest senescence of broccoli florets

Harvest-induced senescence of broccoli results in tissue wilting and sepal chlorosis. As senescence progresses, chlorophyll and protein levels in floret tissues decline and endo-protease activity (measured with azo-casein) increases. Protease activity increased from 24 h after harvest for tissues held in air at 20 degrees C. Activity was lower in floret tissues from branchlets that had been held in solutions of sucrose (2% w/v) or under high carbon dioxide, low oxygen (10% CO(2), 5% O(2)) conditions. Four protease-active protein bands were identified in senescing floret tissue by zymography, and the use of chemical inhibitors of protease action suggests that some 44% of protease activity in senescing floret tissue 72 h after harvest is due to the action of cysteine and serine proteases. Four putative cysteine protease cDNAs have been isolated from broccoli floret tissue (BoCP1, BoCP2, BoCP3, BoCP4). The cDNAs are most similar (73-89% at the amino acid level) to dehydration-responsive cysteine proteases previously isolated from Arabidopsis thaliana (RD19, RD21). The mRNAs encoded by the broccoli cDNAs are expressed in floret tissue during harvest-induced senescence with mRNA accumulating within 6 h of harvest for BoCP1, 12 h of harvest for BoCP4 and within 24 h of harvest for BoCP2 and BoCP3. Induction of the cDNAs is differentially delayed when broccoli branchlets are held in solutions of water or sucrose. In addition, the expression of BoCP1 and BoCP3 is inhibited in tissue held in atmospheres of high carbon dioxide/low oxygen (10% CO(2), 5% O(2)). The putative cysteine protease mRNAs are expressed before measurable increases in endo-protease activity, loss of protein, chlorophyll or tissue chlorosis.

Biochemical identification of proteasome-associated endonuclease activity in sunflower

Proteasomes have been purified from sunflower hypocotyles. They elute with a molecular mass of 600 kDa from gel filtration columns and two-dimensional gel electrophoresis indicates that the complex contains at least 20 different protein subunits. Peptide microsequencing revealed the presence of four subunits homologous to subunits Beta2, Beta6, Alpha5 and Alpha6 of plant proteasomes. These proteasomes have chymotrypsin-like activity and the highly purified fraction of this complex is associated with an endonuclease activity hydrolyzing Tobacco mosaic virus RNA and Lettuce mosaic virus RNA with a cleavage pattern showing fragments of well-defined size. This is the first evidence of a RNA endonuclease activity associated with plant proteasomes.

Salt stress induces programmed cell death in prokaryotic organism Anabaena

AIMS

Our main interest is to check if programmed cell death (PCD) can occur in prokaryotic algae and if the morphological and biochemical features of PCD are conserved.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Using TUNEL labelling, fluorescence and light microscopy and DNA gel electrophoresis, we found that cell death with features similar to those in metazoan PCD could be induced in different Anabaena strains after exposure to univalent-cation salts at moderate concentration. These features included specific DNA fragmentation, cytoplasmic vacuolation, and the progressive disorganization, fragmentation and subsequent autolysis of the cell corpse. Further analyses of cell viability and proteinase activity revealed that increased protease activities, decreased DNA content, and loss of plasmalemma integrity were related to the PCD process.

CONCLUSIONS

The results showed that like PCD in eukaryotes, PCD in Anabaena is an active process, and is an adaptation to adverse environments. The features of PCD shared between eukaryotes and Anabaena suggest that PCD mechanisms are conserved during evolution.

SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY

The results will contribute greatly to our understanding of PCD origin and evolution, and are potentially useful in controlling the deluge of algae in some lakes.

Early stages of seed development in Brassica napus: a seed coat-specific cysteine proteinase associated with programmed cell death of the inner integument

A maternal plant exquisitely promotes the success of its offspring by orchestrating embryo development and endowing protection even after the embryos mature. It uses ovule integuments for physical and physiological contact with the developing embryo and for subsequently equipping the seed with a seed coat (testa). The testa is developmentally and metabolically dynamic, but its molecular biology is not well understood. We show here that the inner integument in Brassica napus undergoes organized development and then programmed cell death (PCD), as evident from vacuolation, starch mobilization, DNA fragmentation and eventual compression. We have identified a cysteine proteinase gene (BnCysP1) that is expressed only in the inner integument as it undergoes PCD, well before the embryo begins storage protein synthesis. Two paralogous Cys proteinases have been recruited in rapeseed for the PCD of testa and for leaf senescence, and these differ 25% in their primary structure and post-translational modifications. Despite Arabidopsis being closely related to rapeseed, and an indication of developmental compression of its inner integument, the Arabidopsis genome is suggestive of only one Cys proteinase that shows approximately 72% identity to BnCysP1. It is, however, leaf senescence-associated, and the other Cys proteinases are <52% identical. BnCysP1 also differs from ricinosome-deployed PCD Cys endopeptidases in lacking the hallmark KDEL tail and being glycosylated. BnCysP1, one of the very few plant genes known to function only in the seed coat, will be useful in dissecting post-fertilization development of this important organ in rapeseed.

Mutation of the matrix metalloproteinase At2-MMP inhibits growth and causes late flowering and early senescence in Arabidopsis

This study characterizes the expression and functional significance of the member of the matrix metalloproteinase (MMP) family At2-MMP from Arabidopsis. By transcript analysis, expression of At2-MMP was found in leaves and roots of juvenile Arabidopsis and leaves, roots, and inflorescences of mature flowering plants showing strong increase of transcript abundance with aging. Cell specificity of expression of At2-MMP was studied by in situ hybridizations in leaves and flowers of Arabidopsis. In leaves, the gene was expressed in the phloem, in developing xylem elements, epidermal cells, and neighboring mesophyll cell layers. In flowers, signals were localized in pistils, ovules, and receptacles. In an Arabidopsis mutant (at2-mmp-1) carrying a tDNA insertion in At2-MMP, neither germination nor development of plants was modified in comparison to the wild type in the juvenile rosette stage. Starting with the onset of shoots, growth of roots, leaves, and shoots was inhibited compared with the wild type, and the plants were characterized by late flowering. Besides the flowering, at2-mmp-1 plants showed fast degradation of chlorophyll in leaves and early senescence. These results demonstrate the involvement of At2-MMP in plant growth, morphogenesis, and development with particular relevance for flowering and senescence.

Vascular tissue differentiation and pattern formation in plants

Vascular tissues, xylem and phloem, are differentiated from meristematic cells, procambium, and vascular cambium. Auxin and cytokinin have been considered essential for vascular tissue differentiation; this is supported by recent molecular and genetic analyses. Xylogenesis has long been used as a model for study of cell differentiation, and many genes involved in late stages of tracheary element formation have been characterized. A number of mutants affecting vascular differentiation and pattern formation have been isolated in Arabidopsis. Studies of some of these mutants have suggested that vascular tissue organization within the bundles and vascular pattern formation at the organ level are regulated by positional information.

The Arabidopsis xylem peptidase XCP1 is a tracheary element vacuolar protein that may be a papain ortholog

XCP1 is a xylem-specific papain-like cysteine peptidase in Arabidopsis. To determine whether XCP1 could be involved in tracheary element autolysis, promoter activity and localization of XCP1 were investigated using XCP1 promoter-beta-glucuronidase fusions and immunofluorescence confocal microscopy. A tracheary element expression pattern was detected for XCP1. Results from confocal microscopy and biochemical subcellular fractionation indicated that XCP1 was localized in the vacuole. Ectopic expression of XCP1 resulted in a reduction in plant size in some lines and early leaf senescence, as indicated by early loss of leaf chlorophyll. Reduced plant size was correlated with higher levels of XCP1, as shown by immunoblot and peptidase activity gel analyses. The XCP1 prodomain exhibits exceptionally high similarity (greater than 80%) to the prodomains of papain and other papain-like enzymes isolated from papaya (Carica papaya) laticifers when compared with all other reported papain-like enzymes. The potential for XCP1 and papain to perform common functions as catalysts of autolytic processing following cell death due to programmed suicide or to wounding is discussed.

Regulation and execution of programmed cell death in response to pathogens, stress and developmental cues

Recent studies have expanded our view of the interactions between small molecule signals that regulate the hypersensitive response and other forms of cell suicide in plants. The mitochondrion has received increasing support as a mediator of at least some forms of programmed cell death in plants. In addition, new information provides a glimpse of how plant hormone signaling may be integrated with extensive autolysis, sensitivity to reactive oxygen intermediates and cell death.