Autoimmune hair loss (alopecia areata) transferred by T lymphocytes to human scalp explants on SCID mice

Genomewide scan for linkage reveals evidence of several susceptibility loci for alopecia areata

Alopecia areata (AA) is a genetically determined, immune-mediated disorder of the hair follicle that affects 1%-2% of the U.S. population. It is defined by a spectrum of severity that ranges from patchy localized hair loss on the scalp to the complete absence of hair everywhere on the body. In an effort to define the genetic basis of AA, we performed a genomewide search for linkage in 20 families with AA consisting of 102 affected and 118 unaffected individuals from the United States and Israel. Our analysis revealed evidence of at least four susceptibility loci on chromosomes 6, 10, 16 and 18, by use of several different statistical approaches. Fine-mapping analysis with additional families yielded a maximum multipoint LOD score of 3.93 on chromosome 18, a two-point affected sib pair (ASP) LOD score of 3.11 on chromosome 16, several ASP LOD scores >2.00 on chromosome 6q, and a haplotype-based relative risk LOD of 2.00 on chromosome 6p (in the major histocompatibility complex locus). Our findings confirm previous studies of association of the human leukocyte antigen locus with human AA, as well as the C3H-HeJ mouse model for AA. Interestingly, the major loci on chromosomes 16 and 18 coincide with loci for psoriasis reported elsewhere. These results suggest that these regions may harbor gene(s) involved in a number of different skin and hair disorders.

Off-label uses of biologics in dermatology: Rituximab, omalizumab, infliximab, etanercept, adalimumab, efalizumab, and alefacept (Part 2 of 2)

Recently, dermatologists have witnessed a revolution in our therapeutic armamentarium with the development of several novel biologic immunomodulators. Although psoriasis remains the only condition in dermatology for which the use of biologic immunomodulators has been approved by the Food and Drug Administration, these drugs have the potential to significantly impact the treatment of several inflammatory conditions in dermatology. This article includes a review of the mechanism of action, dosing, and side-effect profile, as well as a review of the current literature on off-label uses of the CD20-positive B-cell antagonist rituximab, the IgE antagonist omalizumab, the tumor necrosis factor-alpha antagonists infliximab, etanercept, and adalimumab, and the T-cell response modifiers efalizumab and alefacept.

Successful hair transplant of eyebrow alopecia areata

BACKGROUND

Alopecia areata of the eyebrows can be difficult to treat. Intralesional triamcinolone or potent topical steroids are considered the mainstay of medical therapy. This case illustrates the results of an experimental hair transplant to the eyebrows following years of modest response to intralesional triamcinolone.

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to ascertain the benefits of a hair transplant for chronic eyebrow alopecia areata not responding to appropriate medical therapy.

METHODS

A hair transplant was performed with tumescent anesthesia and a total of 85 mini and micrografts placed in the right eyebrow. Followup after the hair transplant occurs every 8 weeks.

RESULTS

The patient was free of eyebrow alopecia areata for 8 months following the initial hair transplant. Although the disease relapsed, hair growth is now manageable with intralesional cortisone injection performed six times per year.

CONCLUSIONS

For the first time in years, this patient was given 8 months of reprieve from his eyebrow alopecia areata and is currently well-maintained on monthly intralesional cortisone which originally was of only modest benefit. The patient is pleased with the outcome.

Induction of cellular immunity against hair follicle melanocyte causes alopecia

Alopecia areata (AA) is generally regarded as an organ-specific autoimmune disease. Although it has been hypothesized that the autoimmunity is mediated by T cells and that hair follicle melanocyte is one of the targets, definitive evidence is lacking. We here demonstrate that AA-like lesions can be induced in mice by inducing CD8(+) T-cell-mediated immunity to hair follicle melanocytes. We found that hair loss was induced in mice-bearing interleukin-12-producing B16 melanoma cells by the depletion of CD4(+) T cells, accompanied by vitiligo-like coat color change. The alopecic lesions varied in size from pachy to extensive. In many instances, hair loss developed and was followed by the regrowth of white hairs. Histological analysis revealed that mononuclear cells infiltrated in and around the bulb region of hair follicles. Furthermore, immunohistochemical examination clearly showed the intra-follicular infiltration of CD8(+) T cells. Neither the vitiligo-like coat color nor AA-like lesions were induced when CD8(+) T cells were codepleted. These observations indicate that the induction of CD8(+) T-cell-mediated immunity against hair follicle melanocytes causes alopecia. It is thought that there are many types of AA with different mechanisms, targets etc. Although hair follicle melanocytes have long been thought to be one of the targets of AA, evidence to support the hypothesis is sparse. Therefore, we believe that our observation is significant to support the hypothesis.

Etanercept does not effectively treat moderate to severe alopecia areata: an open-label study

In this prospective, open-label pilot study, we evaluated the safety and efficacy of etanercept, a TNF-alpha inhibitor, in the treatment of moderate to severe alopecia areata, alopecia totalis, or alopecia universalis. Seventeen otherwise healthy adults with moderate to severe alopecia areata were enrolled. The primary outcome measure was the extent of hair regrowth during and after the end of treatment as evaluated by the Severity of Alopecia Tool (the SALT score). After between 8 and 24 weeks of continuous treatment with etanercept 50 mg given subcutaneously twice weekly, significant regrowth of hair was not shown in any of the subjects treated. Based on these results, etanercept appears to be ineffective in treating subjects with treatment-refractory, moderate to severe alopecia areata, alopecia totalis, or alopecia universalis.

The non-synonymous C1858T substitution in the PTPN22 gene is associated with susceptibility to the severe forms of alopecia areata

Alopecia areata is an acquired hair loss disorder resulting from an immunologically- mediated attack on hair follicles and autoimmunity may play a part in its pathogenesis. The non-synonymous C1858T substitution in the PTPN22 gene, which encodes lymphoid protein tyrosine phosphatase, has been shown to be associated with susceptibility to autoimmune disorders. In this study, the objective was to ascertain whether or not the disease-associated 1858T (W620) allele was associated with alopecia areata. For this, the allelic distribution of the PTPN22 C1858T alleles was determined in 196 English patients with alopecia areata and 507 healthy subjects in a case control study using a restriction fragment length polymorphism-polymerase chain reaction (PCR-RFLP) genotyping method. The results indicated that the frequency of the 1858T allele did not differ significantly between the alopecia areata patient group and the control cohort: of 392 alopecia areata alleles, 41 (10.5%) encoded the W620 variant compared to 86 of 1014 (8.5%) control alleles. However, in patients with severe disease, 25/168 (14.9%) alleles were 1858T and this frequency differed from that in the control group (P = 0.0127; OR, 95% CI = 1.89, 1.17 - 3.05). These results suggest that the non-synonymous C1858T substitution in the PTPN22 gene may have an influence on the severity of alopecia areata and provide further evidence for autoimmunity as an aetiological factor in this disorder.

Phenotypic analysis of T-cells in extensive alopecia areata scalp suggests partial tolerance

This study demonstrates the feasibility and efficacy of using flow cytometric analysis with intracellular cytokine staining for characterization of T-cell phenotype and functional status in extensive alopecia areata (EAA) scalp skin. Cell suspensions were made from scalp punch biopsies taken from 12 patients with long-standing EAA (average disease duration 14 years, 95% hair loss) and six control subjects. EAA samples had a lower percentage of CD-3-expressing cells, but CD-4/CD-8 ratios remained similar to controls. Expression of CD-69 was found only in EAA scalp biopsies, suggesting that T-cells from EAA scalp have undergone activation. No difference was found in tumor necrosis factor alpha expression. Surprisingly, EAA scalp T-cells produced less IL-2 and CD-8 T-cells produced less IFN-gamma. Immunohistochemical staining of formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded specimens demonstrated that IFN-gamma-producing cells in EAA scalp were not greater in number than in normal specimens. The few identified IFN-gamma-producing cells demonstrated no tendency to localize to the perifollicular region, and were similarly distributed as in control specimens. The abnormalities in cytokine production may explain the relative paucity of inflammatory change observed in the clinical setting and suggest that T-cell responses in EAA scalp are tightly, albeit aberrantly, regulated via mechanisms of peripheral T-cell tolerance.

Alopecia Areata: A tissue specific autoimmune disease of the hair follicle

The goal of this review is to introduce the immunologic community to alopecia areata as a model system for the study of tissue directed autoimmune disease. Alopecia areata is marked by autoimmune assault on the hair follicle resulting in hair loss. It is linked to HLA-DQ3 and evidence suggests it is mediated by T-lymphocytes with a TH1 cytokine profile. Hair follicles are an immune protected site with deficient MHC expression. Evidence is presented suggesting that alopecia areata results from loss of immune privilege with presentation of autoantigens. Alopecia areata is one of the most common human autoimmune conditions, with a lifetime risk of approximately 1.7%. Study of alopecia areata in humans is facilitated by the accessibility of scalp for biopsy. It is possible to transfer the condition with lesional human lymphocytes in a human scalp graft/SCID mouse model. There are also spontaneous animal models which share the features of the human condition. For these reasons, alopecia areata is a powerful model for study of the induction and pathogenesis of tissue directed autoimmune disease.

[Alopecia areata in animal models--new insights into pathogenesis and treatment of a T cell-mediated autoimmune disorder]

Alopecia areata is a common disease, but for ethical reasons it seems difficult to perform large-scale studies to elucidate the pathogenesis and to develop new therapeutic approaches in man. It is therefore helpful to develop appropriate animal models. The Dundee experimental bald rat (DEBR) and the C3H/HeJ mouse are well-established animal models for alopecia areata and can be used for the study of genetic aspects, pathogenesis and therapy of the disease. In C3H/HeJ mice alopecia areata can be experimentally induced by grafting lesional skin from an affected mouse to a histocompatible recipient which offers the possibility to study the influence of various factors on the development of the disease. Studies on the C3H/HeJ mouse and the DEBR have corroborated the concept that alopecia areata is a T-cell mediated autoimmune disease and various steps and aspects of the pathogenesis have been elucidated. Based on this knowledge new therapeutic options may be developed such as inhibition of lymphocyte-homing by an anti-CD44v10 antibody, or inhibition of costimulation by monoclonal antibodies. Therapeutic studies in the C3H/HeJ mouse and the DEBR suggest that alopecia areata can be treated by topical tacrolimus but treatment in humans may only be successful after development of an improved vehicle that facilitates penetration of tacrolimus down to the hair bulb. Current investigations in mice are designed to elucidate the mechanisms how contact sensitizers act in the treatment of alopecia areata, and this will hopefully lead to the development of more specific approaches based on the beneficial effect of contact sensitizers.

What Can We Learn from Animal Models of Alopecia areata?

Alopecia areata (AA) is a hair loss disease marked by a focal inflammatory infiltrate of dystrophic anagen stage hair follicles by CD4+ and CD8+ lymphocytes. Although AA is thought to be an autoimmune disorder, definitive proof is lacking. Moreover, characterization of the primary pathogenic mechanisms by which hair loss is induced in AA is limited. In this context, animal models may provide a vital contribution to understanding AA. Recent research using animal models of AA has focused on providing evidence in support of a lymphocyte-mediated pathogenic mechanism consistent with AA as an autoimmune disease. In the future, research with both humans and animal models shall likely concentrate on identifying the primary antigenic epitopes involved in AA and the genetics of AA susceptibility. With a comprehensive understanding of the key elements in AA pathogenesis, new avenues for therapeutic research and intervention will be defined.

Transfer of CD8(+) cells induces localized hair loss whereas CD4(+)/CD25(-) cells promote systemic alopecia areata and CD4(+)/CD25(+) cells blockade disease onset in the C3H/HeJ mouse model

Alopecia areata (AA) is a suspected hair follicle specific autoimmune disease. The potential for cell transfer of AA using the C3H/HeJ mouse model was examined. Cells isolated from lymph nodes and spleens of AA-affected mice using magnetic bead conjugated monoclonal antibodies were subcutaneously injected into normal C3H/HeJ recipients. Within 5 wk, all CD8(+) cell-injected mice exhibited localized hair loss exclusively at the site of injection that persisted until necropsy. In contrast, some CD4(+) and CD4(+)/CD25(-) cell-injected mice developed extensive, systemic AA, and a combination of CD8(+) and CD4(+)/CD25(-) cells injected yielded the highest frequency of systemic AA induction. CD4(+)/CD25(+) cells were less able to transfer the disease phenotype, partially blockaded systemic AA induction by CD4(+)/CD25(-) cells, and prevented CD8(+) cell-induced, injection site-localized hair loss. CD11c(+) and CD19(+) cells failed to promote significant phenotype changes. Increases in co-stimulatory ligands CD40 and CD80, plus increased leukocyte apoptosis resistance with reduced CD95, CD95L, and CD120b expression, were associated with successful alopecia induction. The results suggest that CD8(+) cells may be the primary instigators of the hair loss phenotype. However, systemic disease expression fate is, apparently determined by CD4(+)/CD25(-) cells, while CD4(+)/CD25(+) lymphocytes may play a predominantly regulatory role.

Alopecia areata: revisão e atualização

Trata-se de artigo de revisão em que são analisados os aspectos clínicos, histopatológicos, etiopatogênicos e a terapêutica atual da alopecia areata. Enfatiza-se a posição nosológica atual da alopecia areata como doença auto-imune que se desenvolve em substrato genético e discutem-se os possíveis mecanismos fisiopatológicos da enfermidade, bem como os tratamentos atuais, particularmente para as formas mais graves da doença, compreendendo terapêuticas imunomoduladoras tópicas com dibutilester do ácido esquárico e difenciprona e seus possíveis mecanismos de ação.

Techniques: species' finest blend--humanized mouse models in inflammatory skin disease research

Differences between humans and mice often hamper the transfer of promising results from the bench to the clinic. For ethical reasons, research that involves patients is limited, and so there is an urgent need for models that mimic the human situation as closely as possible. In recent years, there has been considerable progress in generating humanized mouse models, and their application to drug discovery has proved fruitful. So, how can mice be humanized, and how can humanized mice be employed in immunology research and drug discovery? In this article, we answer these questions, focusing on T-cell-mediated skin diseases as an example.

The progressive state, in contrast to the stable or regressive state of alopecia areata, is reflected in peripheral blood mononuclear cells

Alopecia areata (AA) is a putative autoimmune disease of the skin with an inflammatory component that can be treated by the local application of contact sensitizers. Here, we explored whether responsiveness toward diphenylcyclopropenone (DPCP) is reflected by the composition and the activation state of peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs). PBMCs of 43 AA patients, 26 treated and 17 untreated, and of 31 healthy volunteers were tested. AA patients' PBMCs differed from that of healthy donors by a slight increase in CD16- and tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-alpha)-expressing cells. These features were independent of the disease state and treatment. Additional changes in the activation state of PBMCs, upregulation of the costimulatory molecules CD40 and CD80, of the accessory molecule CD154, and of interferon-gamma expression were identified only in AA patients where the disease was advancing, i.e. these changes were independent of the extent of hair loss and were not seen in patients with spontaneous or DPCP treatment-induced, regressing AA. Thus, the progressive state of AA is accompanied by a systemic activation of T cells, and the therapeutic efficacy of treatment can be estimated by restoration of the non-activated state. Furthermore, an increase in CD16(+)- and TNF-alpha-expressing cells may contribute to AA susceptibility.

Alopecia areata susceptibility in rodent models

With our current view of alopecia areata as an autoimmune disease, it is probable that disease development in an individual is dependent on multiple genetic and environmental factors interacting in a complex system. Rodent models afford the opportunity to investigate alopecia areata development and to define the significance of the different factors involved. Recently, rodent model characterization has been conducted using flow cytometry, microarray analysis, and functional studies. From these a pattern of events in alopecia areata development has emerged. Although the preliminary activation events for the onset of alopecia areata remain unknown, the response of the immune system is characterized by antigen presentation and costimulation of lymphocytes in the lymph nodes and skin, a deficiency of CD4+/CD25+ regulatory cells, and an action of activated lymphocytes on hair follicles via Fas/FasL signaling and cytokines. Thus, onset of disease may require appropriate (or inappropriate) expression of stimulatory antigens within the hair follicle, the breakdown of the putative hair follicle immune privilege, the presentation of antigens to the immune system, a failure of immune system regulation, and the ability of the activated immune system to disrupt anagen-stage hair follicles. Once the sequence of events is initiated, it may become a self-perpetuating cycle, with epitope spreading leading to a wider range of targets in chronic alopecia areata. Rodent model studies have provided significant insight into alopecia areata, but much more remains to be explained about the mechanisms of disease development.

Characterization of hair follicle antigens targeted by the anti-hair follicle immune response

Alopecia areata is a common disfiguring hair loss disorder that primarily affects the hair follicle as it enters the prolonged growth phase called anagen. The last few years have yielded an explosion of more rigorously obtained data on the etiology and pathogenesis of this disorder. While a consensus is rapidly building in support of an autoimmune pathogenesis, there are still several enigmatic issues to be resolved. These include the possibility that alopecia areata is really a multientity disorder with causes that are multifactorial. This will have important implications for the research scientist's search for the jigsaw puzzle's largest missing piece--the identification of the target autoantigen(s). There is now much evidence that autoimmune diseases with both T and B cell components have shared target autoantigens/epitopes. It is likely that alopecia areata is similar, as there is now very strong evidence for the generation of autoantibodies as well as autoreactive T cells to hair follicles in the pathogenesis of this disease. The following brief review outlines the progress we have made over the last five to ten years in the characterization of hair follicle antigens targeted by antibodies in alopecia areata. Results of these studies now show that the elicitation of antibodies to hair follicle-specific proteins is a highly conserved phenomenon in all affected species studied to date. Candidate autoantigens that have been identified include the 44/46 kDa hair-specific keratin (expressed in the precortical zone of anagen hair follicles) and trichohyalin (an important intermediate filament-associated protein) expressed in the inner root sheath of the growing hair follicle. Moreover, there is evidence that anti-hair follicle antibodies are modulated during the disease process, can occur before clinically detectable hair loss, and may be reduced in titer during successful treatment. Preliminary data from passive transfer experiments suggest that in some species these antibodies may disrupt hair cycling. We are currently applying a more molecular approach (e.g., cDNA library screening) to identify hair follicle antigens truly associated with the onset of the disorder.

Old wine in new bottles: reviving old therapies for alopecia areata using rodent models

Alopecia areata is regarded as a tissue-restricted autoimmune disease of hair follicles in which follicular activity is arrested because of the continued activity of lymphocytic infiltrates. Actual loss of hair follicles does not occur, even in hairless lesions. A variety of immunomodulating therapies, including contact sensitizers and immunomodulators, are part of the usual armamentarium for this disorder. None of these treatments have been consistent in their efficacy, and many have untoward side effects. Nevertheless, their uses in valid animal models provide a tool to dissect out molecular mechanisms of therapeutic effects. For several decades, both mechlorethamine (for the treatment of cutaneous T cell lymphoma) and anthralin (for the treatment of psoriasis) have been used successfully. When these therapies were tested in rat and mouse alopecia areata models, we found anthralin and mechlorethamine to be the most effective topical modalities, respectively. The underlying cellular mechanisms may act through targeting infiltrative lymphocytes, and the molecular mechanisms may involve specific cytokine expression changes. These visible, accessible, and unilaterally treated animal model systems are ideal for studying novel alopecia areata therapies, particularly in terms of their in vivo molecular mechanisms of action.

Chronic delayed-type hypersensitivity reaction as a means to treat alopecia areata

The acute phase of alopecia areata (AA) is characterized by an increase in CD44v3+ and CD44v10+ skin-infiltrating leucocytes (SkIL). Induction of a contact eczema, one of the therapeutic options in AA, can be mitigated strongly by a blockade of CD44v10. The observation that induction of a delayed type hypersensitivity (DTH) reaction abrogates an autoimmune reaction, where both responses apparently use similar effector mechanisms, is surprising and prompted us to search for the underlying mechanisms. AA-affected C3H/HeJ mice were treated with the contact sensitizer SADBE (squaric acid dibutylester) and leucocyte subpopulations and their activation state was evaluated in SkIL and draining lymph nodes. AA-affected mice exhibited an increased number of SkIL with a predominance of T lymphocytes. After treatment with the contact sensitizer SADBE recovery of SkIL was reduced and monocytes predominated. However, a significantly increased number of leucocytes was recovered from draining lymph nodes. Draining lymph node cells from untreated and treated AA mice exhibited all signs of recent activation with high-level expression of co-stimulatory and accessory molecules and an increased percentage of CD44v3+ and CD44v10+ leucocytes. In contrast, SkIL of SADBE-treated AA mice contained relatively few activated T cells and reduced numbers of CD44v3+ and CD44v10+ cells. Thus, the activation state and the distribution of leucocyte subsets in SADBE-treated AA mice are consistent with a blockade of leucocyte extravasation. Accordingly, the therapeutic effect of long-term SADBE treatment may rely on impaired leucocyte traffic.

Decreased serum ferritin is associated with alopecia in women

Alopecia in women is a common problem, and conflicting observational data have failed to determine whether an association exists between alopecia and iron deficiency in women. We therefore utilized an analytical cross-sectional methodology to evaluate whether common types of alopecia in women are associated with decreased tissue iron stores, as measured by serum ferritin. We studied patients with telogen effluvium (n = 30), androgenetic alopecia (n = 52), alopecia areata (n = 17), and alopecia areata totalis/universalis (n = 7). The normal group consisted of 11 subjects without hair loss from the same referral base and source population as those patients with alopecia. We analyzed the data utilizing the unpaired Student's t test assuming unequal variances with an alpha adjustment for multiple comparisons to assess whether the mean ages, ferritin levels, and hemoglobin levels of women without hair loss differed from the means in each alopecia group. The mean age of patients and normals did not differ significantly. We found that the mean ferritin level (ng per ml [95% confidence intervals]) in patients with androgenetic alopecia (37.3 128.4, 46.1]) and alopecia areata (24.9 [17.2, 32.6]) were statistically significantly lower than in normals without hair loss (59.5 [40.8, 78.1]). The mean ferritin levels in patients with telogen effluvium (50.1 [33.9, 66.33]) and alopecia areata totalis/universalis (52.3 [23.1, 81.5]) were not significantly lower than in normals. Our findings have implications regarding therapeutics, clinical trial design, and understanding the triggers for alopecia.

Restoration of hair growth with topical diphencyprone in mouse and rat models of alopecia areata

BACKGROUND

The contact sensitizer, diphencyprone (DPCP), is one of the most effective therapies for the more severe forms of alopecia areata (AA).

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to determine the efficacy of topical DPCP on the 2 available rodent models for AA, and to determine the underlying therapeutic mechanisms.

METHODS

AA-affected mice and rats were treated unilaterally with topical DPCP on the ventral and dorsal surface, respectively. The opposite sides were treated with vehicle alone. Skin biopsy specimens were collected from both sides for histologic analysis.

RESULTS

Hair regrowth was observed on the treated sides in the majority of the animals of both species. Immunohistochemical analyses revealed reduction of intrafollicular CD8(+) lymphocyte infiltrates after successful treatment in mice.

CONCLUSION

The AA-like hair disorder of these 2 rodent models can be used as a tool for furthering our understanding of human AA and the therapeutic actions of DPCP.

Autoimmunity: Alopecia Areata

Strong direct and indirect evidence supports an autoimmune etiology for alopecia areata. T lymphocytes that have been shown to be oligoclonal and autoreactive are predominantly present in the peribulbar inflammatory infiltrate. Alopecia areata frequently occurs in association with other autoimmune diseases, such as thyroiditis and vitiligo, and autoantibodies to follicular components have been detected. Finally, the use of immune modulating drugs, including corticosteroids and contact sensitizers such as dyphencyprone, can be beneficial in the management of this disease. Recent studies have demonstrated that alopecia areata scalp skin grafted onto nude mice with severe combined immunodeficiency grow hair and that infiltrating lymphocytes in the graft are lost. It is now also possible to induce alopecia areata in human scalp explants on these mice by injecting T lymphocytes with scalp homogenate. Neuropeptides produced by cutaneous nerves are known to modify immune reactivity and, in all likelihood, affect the alopecia areata process. Future studies may show that modulation of neuropeptide expression is associated with hair regrowth. Likewise, testing the efficacy of the newly developed immunomodulatory agents in patients with alopecia areata may lead to the introduction of novel therapies for this immune-mediated disease of the hair follicle.

A natural canine homologue of alopecia areata in humans

BACKGROUND

Alopecia areata (AA) is suspected to be an autoimmune disease directed preferentially against hair follicles (HF) affecting both humans and various mammalian species. Recently, two rodent models of AA were described, namely the ageing C3H/HeJ mouse and the DEBR rat. Despite several case reports of canine AA in the literature, there has been no systematic assessment of the disease in these companion animals, and it is also not known whether dogs with AA could be useful as an outbred homologue of this disease in humans.

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate the clinical, histopathological and immunopathological features of 25 dogs with AA and compare these data with those found in the human disease.

PATIENTS/METHODS

Twenty-five client-owned dogs exhibiting macroscopic alopecia with peri- or intrabulbar lymphocytic infiltrates were selected for study. Biopsies and sera were obtained and assessed by histopathology, direct immunofluorescence of immunoreactant deposition, immunohistochemistry for lymphocyte markers, indirect immunofluorescence and immunoblotting analysis of circulating serum IgG, selective immunoprecipitation of HF proteins by serum IgG, and passive transfer of purified canine IgG into naïve C57BL/10 mice.

RESULTS

Clinical signs including alopecia, skin hyperpigmentation and leucotrichia usually developed during adulthood and were first seen on the face, followed by the forehead, ears and legs. Spontaneous remission of alopecia occurred in 60% of dogs and regrowing hair shafts were often non-pigmented. Histological examination of skin biopsy specimens revealed peri- and intrabulbar mononuclear cell infiltrates affecting almost exclusively anagen HF. Direct immunofluorescence analysis detected HF-specific IgG in 73% of dogs, while indirect immunofluorescence revealed circulating IgG autoantibodies to the HF inner and outer root sheaths, matrix and precortex. Immunoblotting analysis revealed IgG reactivity to proteins in the 45-60 kDa molecular weight range and with a 200-220 kDa doublet. The latter was identified as trichohyalin by selective immunoprecipitation. Purified HF-reactive IgG, pooled from AA-affected dogs, was injected intradermally to the anagen skin of naïve mice where it was associated with the local retention of HFs in an extended telogen phase in AA-treated skin compared with that seen in controls.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings are very similar to those reported for human AA patients; therefore, they support the consideration of dogs with AA as a useful homologue for the study of the pathogenesis of this common autoimmune disease of humans.

The hair follicle and immune privilege

This essay reviews the available evidence that the proximal hair follicle epithelium generates and maintains an area of relative immune privilege during a defined segment of the hair cycle (i.e., during anagen). This immune privilege is chiefly characterized by a very low level of expression of MHC class Ia antigens and by the local production of potent immunosuppressive agents, such as alpha-MSH and TGF-beta1. We discuss the putative functions of immune privilige of the anagen hair bulb, favoring the view that immune privilege serves mainly to sequester anagen- and/or melanogenesis-associated autoantigens from immune recognition by autoreactive CD8+ T cells. On this basis, we develop how the "immune privilege collapse model" of alopecia areata pathogenesis was conceived. In our discussion of the clinical implications of immune privilege, we outline the currently available evidence in support of this still hypothetical scenario to explain the initiation, progression, and termination of alopecia areata lesions. We review the most recent evidence from our laboratory that alpha-MSH, IGF-1, and TGF-beta1 can downregulate IFN-gamma-induced ectopic MHC class I expression in human anagen hair bulbs in vitro. Finally, we suggest that hair follicle-derived alpha-MSH, IGF-gamma, and TGF-beta1 form part of a constitutively active "IP restoration machinery" of the anagen hair bulb, which we propose to be recruited whenever the hair follicle suffers immune injury. Finally, we sketch some particularly promising avenues for future investigation into the far too long ignored hair follicle immune privilege.

Therapy of alopecia areata: on the cusp and in the future

Over the past decade, basic research has established alopecia areata as a T cell-mediated autoimmune disease and has clarified many of its genetic, cellular, and molecular aspects. Perifollicular and intrafollicular mononuclear cell infiltrates directed at anagen hair bulbs are characteristic and striking histologic features in early alopecia areata. The inflammatory infiltrate is composed predominantly of activated CD4+ and CD8+ T cells, together with macrophages and Langerhans cells. The initiation phase of alopecia areata is mediated by type 1 cytokines, including interleukin-2, interferon-gamma, and tumor necrosis factor-alpha. Like other diseases with a strong autoimmune component, alopecia areata has associated with it specific human leukocyte antigens, which determine susceptibility, severity, chronicity, and resistance. New topical immunomodulating drugs and biologic therapies that have been developed, or that are in development, for the treatment of other immune-mediated inflammatory skin diseases will likely be effective in alopecia areata as well. The present discussion addresses the treatment of alopecia areata within the framework of these new modalities.

Neurotrophins and their role in pathogenesis of alopecia areata

Neurotrophins comprise a family of structurally and functionally related proteins that are critical for the development and maintenance of cutaneous innervation. They also fulfill multiple non-neurotrophic functions in skin, including regulation of epidermal proliferation and apoptosis, control of hair follicle development and cycling, and melanogenesis. Numerous indications suggest that neurotrophins play an important role in the pathogenesis of a variety of autoimmune diseases. In this review, we focus on the role of neurotrophins in the pathogenesis of alopecia areata, an autoimmune disorder that affects actively growing hair follicles. Recent data suggest that neurotrophins and their receptors are differentially expressed among the subsets of immune cells in alopecia areata-affected skin. Experimental data suggest that neurotrophins may regulate both the cyclic activity of the hair follicle and the functions of immune cells of inflammatory infiltrates. Additional research is required to bridge the gap between our current knowledge of neurotrophin functions in skin affected by alopecia areata and our knowledge of their potential clinical applications. Progress in this area of research will hopefully lead to the development of multiple applications for neurotrophins and their agonists/antagonists in alopecia areata and other hair growth disorders.

Alopecia Areata: Autoimmunity—The Evidence Is Compelling

There is strong evidence indicating that alopecia areata is a tissue-specific, autoimmune disease. Hair loss is associated with a perifollicular lymphocytic infiltrate made up primarily of CD4+ cells, along with a CD8+ intrafollicular infiltrate. Evidence of immune activation includes expression of HLA-DR; HLA-A,B,C; and ICAM-1 on the follicular epithelium. It is likely that the follicular expression of HLA-DR and ICAM-1 is induced by interferon-gamma produced by T cells. Antibodies to follicular epithelium are often present, but their significance is not known. Lesional scalp from alopecia areata patients grafted onto nude mice regrows hair coincident with a loss of infiltrating lymphocytes from the graft. Hair loss can be transferred to human scalp explants on SCID mice by injection of lesional T cells. It is necessary to activate the T cells by culture with follicular autoantigens. Melanocyte-associated antigens are also capable of activating T cells to induce hair loss, suggesting that they are capable of functioning as autoantigens for alopecia areata. Parallel evidence in rodent models of spontaneous alopecia areata also strongly supports a role for T cells in the pathogenesis of this condition.

The pathogenesis of alopecia areata in rodent models

Rodent models of human disease provide an important tool in the investigation of genetic and environmental activation factors, disease pathogenesis, and the development of new and improved treatments. Up to 20% of aged C3H/HeJ mice and 70% of Dundee Experimental Bald Rats (DEBR) develop alopecia areata (AA), a nonscarring, inflammatory hair loss disease with a suspected autoimmune pathogenesis. These rodent models are currently employed in determining the genetic basis of AA, understanding the mechanisms of disease initiation and progression, and defining potential endogenous and environmental influences. Induction of AA by skin graft transfer between affected and unaffected mice has been employed to examine skin and immune system changes during AA pathogenesis. Manipulation of inflammatory cells in vivo indicates AA is primarily a cell mediated disease with auto-antibody production as a secondary event. Whether the AA activating factors are exogenous or endogenous antigens, or involve normal or aberrant epitope expression remains to be elucidated. However, current research suggests a self contained disease cycle involving four key events: (1) Failure of the putative anagen stage hair follicle immune privilege and exposure of hair follicle located AA inciting epitopes to the immune system; (2) Antigen presentation, costimulation, and activation of responsive lymphocytes by antigen presenting cells; (3) Activated inflammatory cell migration to, and infiltration of, hair follicles; (4) The subsequent disruptive actions of the inflammatory cell infiltrate on the hair follicles. Each of these events is vulnerable to therapeutic intervention, and rodent models will be fundamentally involved in developing new treatments for AA.

Topical mechlorethamine restores autoimmune-arrested follicular activity in mice with an alopecia areata-like disease by targeting infiltrated lymphocytes

Alopecia areata is an autoimmune disease targeted at hair follicles with infiltrated T lymphocytes probably playing an important role in the pathogenesis. It was reported in 1985 that mechlorethamine was effective on alopecia areata patients. This has never been confirmed since. The aims of the study were to investigate the effects of mechlorethamine on balding C3H/HeJ mice affected with an alopecia-areata-like disease and to study the underlying mechanisms. Mice were treated on half of the dorsal skin with mechlorethamine and the contralateral side was treated with the vehicle ointment. After 10 wk of mechlorethamine therapy, a full pelage of hair covered the treated side in all the mice and was maintained during the study, whereas the vehicle-treated sides showed either no change or continued hair loss. Immunohistochemistry revealed that infiltrated CD4+ and CD8+ lymphocytes were eliminated from the treated side. In vitro cell viability assay showed that lymphocytes were much more sensitive to the cytotoxic effects of mechlorethamine than skin and hair follicular cells. RNase protection assay and real-time reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction showed that tumor necrosis factor alpha/beta, interleukin-12, and interferon-gamma were inhibited by mechlorethamine upon successful treatment. Our findings support that mechlorethamine restores follicular activity by selectively targeting infiltrated lymphocytes in vivo in alopecia-areata-affected mice.

Transfer of alopecia areata in the human scalp graft/Prkdc(scid) (SCID) mouse system is characterized by a TH1 response

Alopecia areata is an autoimmune condition directed at hair follicles, which results in loss of hair. We have previously demonstrated that it is possible to transfer hair loss, along with the immunohistologic findings of alopecia areata, to human scalp grafts on Prkdc(scid) (SCID) mice by injection of autologous activated lesional T-cells. This study examines the cytokine profile of T-cells and follicular epithelium following transfer of hair loss. Two consistent findings significantly (P < 0.01) associated with hair loss were production of interferon-gamma-inducible protein-10 kDa (IP-10) by follicular epithelium (13/13), and production of INF-gamma by infiltrating T-cells (10/12). Noninjected control grafts regrew hair, and were generally negative for IP-10 (positive 2/9), and INF-gamma (positive 2/9), but expressed of IL-10 on the follicular epithelium (7/9). These data support an INF-gamma TH1 pathogenesis for hair loss in alopecia areata.

Autoimmune hair loss induced by alloantigen in C57BL/6 mice

Exponentially growing Meth-A cells expressing H-2K(d).D (d) antigen were found to induce alopecia when injected intraperitoneally into normal C57BL/6 mice, which express the H-2K(b).D (b) antigen. However, the capacity to induce alopecia disappeared when Meth-A cells were treated with K252a, which inhibits protein kinases. Histologically, skin in affected areas showed dense mononuclear cell infiltration and a focal foreign-body giant-cell reaction in hair follicles. The subtyping of lymphocytes in peripheral blood demonstrated a significant difference between normal mice and Meth-A cell-injected mice. To further examine the mechanism by which the alloantigen induces alopecia, lymphocytes isolated from the peripheral blood of normal C57BL/6 mice were cultured in medium containing Meth-A cell homogenate, phytohemagglutinin (PHA) and recombinant mouse interleukin-2 (rm IL-2), and intravenously injected into normal C57BL/6 mice. The adoptive transfer of the lymphocytes induced alopecia in a similar way. These findings suggest that the protein kinase-modulated alloantigen induces alopecia by disturbing the immunological homeostasis, and that lymphokine-activated killer cells play an important role in induction of alopecia by cross-reacting with hair follicles.

Resistance to alopecia areata in C3H/HeJ mice is associated with increased expression of regulatory cytokines and a failure to recruit CD4+ and CD8+ cells

Grafting alopecia areata affected C3H/HeJ mouse skin to littermates induces alopecia areata, but high dietary soy oil reduces alopecia areata susceptibility. Alopecia areata affected and resistant mice were characterized to evaluate possible mechanisms involved in alopecia areata resistance. Of 44 mice that received alopecia areata affected skin grafts but failed to develop alopecia areata, only two of 22 receiving further alopecia areata affected skin grafts developed alopecia areata, whereas 39 of 44 controls developed alopecia areata. Alopecia areata affected skin contained increased numbers of CD4+ and CD8+ cells, increases in pro inflammatory T helper 1 and T helper 2 type cytokines, and upregulation of CD28, CD40L, and their ligands. In draining lymph nodes, a relatively high number of antigen-presenting cells was recovered, whereas several CD44v variants were downregulated. In contrast, alopecia areata resistant mouse skin did not display increased numbers of CD4+ and CD8+ cells, whereas counter-regulatory cytokines interleukins 4 and 10 were upregulated. High expression of CD28, CD80, CD86, CD40, CTLA4, CD44v variants, and FasL occurred in alopecia areata resistant mouse spleens. In vitro, lymph node cells of susceptible and resistant mice responded equally to a mitogenic stimulus, but only lymph node cells from alopecia areata affected mice displayed an increased response with T cell receptor stimulation via anti-CD3 cross-linking. These results suggest alopecia areata is a cell-mediated autoimmune disease, but alopecia areata affected skin graft hosts may resist alopecia areata onset through active counter-regulatory mechanisms. Because alopecia areata resistant mice showed unimpaired responsiveness and a transient inflammatory response towards the graft, it is suggested that alopecia areata develops as a consequence of an inappropriate immune response regulation.

Seventeen cases of alopecia areata: combination of SADBE topical immunotherapy with other therapies

Topical immunotherapy is effective for severe alopecia areata. However, there are patients with alopecia areata refractory to topical immunotherapy alone. We tried SADBE (squaric acid dibutylester) topical immunotherapy combined with topical dry ice cryotherapy, carpronium chloride (a parasympathetic nerve stimulant) and/or oral cepharanthin (a biscoclaur alkaloid) in alopecia areata refractory to topical SADBE. Seventeen patients with alopecia areata (3 multiple, 3 ophiasis, 5 totalis and 6 universalis) were treated with SADBE in our department in 1999 to 2001. In 3 cases (2 multiple and 1 universalis) out of the 17 cases, cosmetically acceptable regrowth of hair was observed in several months with topical SADBE alone. In the other 14 cases, the SADBE therapy alone for several months (mean: 6.9 months) resulted in no or poor regrowth of hair. However, with subsequent combination therapy of topical SADBE for several months (mean: 7.6 months), satisfactory regrowth of hair was observed in 6 of the 14 cases. Our cases indicate that combination therapy of topical SADBE with other therapies can be a choice for alopecia areata which is refractory to topical SADBE therapy alone.

Transient CD44 variant isoform expression and reduction in CD4(+)/CD25(+) regulatory T cells in C3H/HeJ mice with alopecia areata

Alopecia areata, an autoimmune disease affecting anagen stage hair follicles, can be induced by grafting spontaneous alopecia areata affected skin to normal-haired C3H/HeJ mice. As the onset of alopecia areata can be significantly retarded by anti-CD44 variant isoform 10 treatment, it was interesting to explore the underlying disease mechanism. Two weeks after transplanting alopecia areata affected skin, expression of CD44 variant isoforms 3, 6, 7, and 10 was strikingly upregulated as compared with sham-grafted mice. By 6 wk after grafting, CD44 variant isoform levels had returned to normal, whereas in draining lymph nodes, CD44 variant isoform expression was slightly decreased. Leukocytes in the skin of mice with chronic alopecia areata expressed a hematopoietic isoform of CD44 and CD44 variant isoform 6 at an elevated level, but CD44 variant isoform 3 expression was reduced. Cytokine expression in leukocytes of chronic alopecia areata affected skin was higher than in normal-haired controls. Cytokine expression also increased postsurgery in sham and alopecia areata grafted mice, but remained elevated only in mice receiving alopecia areata affected skin. Finally, from the skin of mice with chronic alopecia areata and of mice transplanted with alopecia areata affected skin, an increased number of CD4(+) and CD8(+) cells, but a strongly decreased number of CD4(+)/CD25(+) regulatory T cells was recovered. Thus, expression of CD44 variant isoforms is important for the migration of leukocytes during the initial period of alopecia areata. CD44, however, is apparently not involved in the maintenance of the disease state, which is characterized by high cytokine expression levels, an increased number of CD4(+) and CD8+ cells, but a low level of CD4(+)/CD25(+) suppressor cells.

'Activation-induced cell death': a special program able to preserve the homeostasis of the skin?

The 'activation-induced cell death' (AICD) is a molecular system leading to death of antigen-activated T lymphocytes, in order to avoid accumulation of harmful cytokine-releasing cells. This article reviews both the molecular mechanisms working in AICD and the role played by such mechanisms in preventing a number of skin diseases. Specifically, because AICD removes activated and autoreactive T cells through a CD95-/CD95-L-mediated suicide, skin diseases were scrutinized in which such valuable machinery could be lacking. Indeed, at least some inflammatory skin diseases, including psoriasis and atopic dermatitis, can be sustained by an increased survival of activated T lymphocytes associated with deficient CD95-/CD95-L-mediated AICD of such strong pro-inflammatory cells. In addition, autoreactive skin diseases, including, e.g. alopecia areata, lichen planus and other lichenoid tissue reactions, can be related to autoreactive T lymphocytes which could be unable to undergo CD95-/CD95-L-mediated AICD. Finally, a lack of AICD may be executive even in favoring cutaneous T cell lymphoma. Thus, because inflammatory, autoreactive and neoplastic skin diseases can be associated with a deficient CD95-/CD95-L-mediated suicide of activated T cells, AICD is likely to represent a fundamental program to preserve the homeostasis of the skin. Therapeutic approaches able to restore the AICD machinery promise to successfully treat such relevant skin diseases.

Melanocyte-associated T cell epitopes can function as autoantigens for transfer of alopecia areata to human scalp explants on Prkdc(scid) mice

Alopecia areata is a tissue restricted autoimmune condition affecting the hair follicle, resulting in hair loss. The goal of this study was to test the hypothesis that the autoantigen of alopecia areata is melanocyte associated. Potential autoantigens were tested in the human scalp explant/Prkd(scid) CB-17 mouse transfer system. Scalp T cells from lesional (bald) alopecia areata scalp were cultured with antigen-presenting cells, and antigen, along with interleukin-2. The T cells were then injected into autologous lesional scalp grafts on SCID mice, and hair regrowth was measured. Hair follicle homogenate was used as an autoantigen control. T cells cultured with melanoma homogenate induced statistically significant reduction in hair growth (p <0.01 by ANOVA). HLA-A2-restricted melanocyte peptide epitopes were then tested with lesional scalp T cells from HLA-A2-positive alopecia areata patients. Melanocyte-peptide-activated T cells significantly reduced the number of hairs regrowing in two experiments with six patients (p <0.001 by ANOVA). Injected scalp grafts showed histologic and immunochemical changes of alopecia areata. The most consistent peptide autoantigens were the Gp100-derived G9-209 and G9-280 peptides, as well as MART-1 (27-35). Melanocyte peptide epitopes can function as autoantigens for alopecia areata. Multiple peptides were recognized, suggesting epitope spreading.

Impaired responses of peripheral blood mononuclear cells to T-cell stimulants in alopecia areata patients with a poor response to topical immunotherapy

BACKGROUND

Topical immunotherapy with a contact allergen is effective in alopecia areata (AA). However, the mechanism of the effect is still unknown, and pretreatment prediction of the outcome of therapy in each patient remains difficult.

OBJECTIVES

To predict the clinical effect of this therapy in AA patients, we investigated the relationship between clinical responses to topical immunotherapy and in vitro proliferative responses of peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) to T-cell stimulants.

METHODS

PBMC were taken from 67 AA patients before or during diphenylcyclopropenone immunotherapy and from 14 healthy controls, and proliferative responses to phytohaemagglutinin and staphylococcal enterotoxin B were evaluated by measuring [3H]-thymidine incorporation.

RESULTS

PBMC from the AA patients with a good clinical response to immunotherapy showed a normal level of proliferation, whereas PBMC from the poor responders showed a markedly suppressed proliferative response and interleukin (IL)-2 production, but increased IL-4 production compared with the controls.

CONCLUSIONS

The proliferative response of PBMC to T-cell stimulants may be one of the indicators of the clinical effect of topical immunotherapy for AA.

Towards a molecular understanding of hair loss and its treatment

Most common forms of hair loss (alopecia) are caused by aberrant hair follicle cycling and changes in hair follicle morphology. However, current treatments for alopecia do not specifically target these processes. We are now beginning to identify the molecules and molecular pathways that control normal hair follicle formation, cycling and growth. In parallel, new techniques are being developed for delivering molecules to hair follicles. Here, we outline the characteristics of common hair loss diseases, and discuss ways in which recent advances in hair follicle biology could be translated into effective therapies for these conditions.

Treatments for androgenetic alopecia and alopecia areata: current options and future prospects

Androgenetic alopecia and alopecia areata are common disorders of the hair follicle which may heavily influence self esteem and self image. Androgenetic alopecia is caused by the heightened sensitivity of scalp follicles to dihydro- testosterone whereas alopecia areata is induced by an autoimmune reaction. Current drug treatment approaches include the use of regrowth stimulators such as topical minoxidil and oral finasteride for androgenetic alopecia, as well as topical minoxidil, dithranol (anthralin), corticosteroids, contact sensitisers, and psoralen plus ultraviolet A irradiation (PUVA) therapy for alopecia areata. Combination regimens are also proposed. However, extreme cases of either type of alopecia do not generally respond well to these existing treatments. For this reason, new therapeutic strategies are directed towards both improving the targeting of existing agents, as well as the development of novel hypertrichotic modalities.

[Is alopecia areata a psychosomatic disease?]

INTRODUCTION

Destruction of hair follicles by lymphocytes induces alopecia aerata. Hence, immunological mechanisms are involved in this disease, as for numerous dermatoses. Nonetheless, alopecia aerata appears to be a psychosomatic disease. Is there any contradiction?

CURRENT KNOWLEDGE AND KEY POINTS

Alopecia aerata often occurs after stress, particularly during mourning. Psychiatric disorders are more frequent in patients with alopecia than in healthy subjects. But these disorders might be secondary to the visible hair disease. Psychopathological mechanisms need to be clarified but alexithymia seems to be the key for understanding how stress could induce hair loss. In the skin (and the scalp) all functions are narrowly controlled by nerve fibers. Among these functions are hair growth and immunity. Immune cells and hair follicle cells possess receptors for neurotransmitters, which are synthesized by neuronal endings. When activated, these receptors are able to modulate cell properties. The same phenomena are described with stress-induced hormones. In alopecia aerata, like in numerous other diseases, psychosomatics and immunology are not opposed because immune cells are controlled by the nervous system through neurotransmitters.

FUTURE PROSPECTS AND PROJECTS

Research needs to be thorough in both the fields of psychology and neurobiology. Psychotherapies or psychotropes appear to be useful in the treatment of alopecia aerata.

Controls of hair follicle cycling

Nearly 50 years ago, Chase published a review of hair cycling in which he detailed hair growth in the mouse and integrated hair biology with the biology of his day. In this review we have used Chase as our model and tried to put the adult hair follicle growth cycle in perspective. We have tried to sketch the adult hair follicle cycle, as we know it today and what needs to be known. Above all, we hope that this work will serve as an introduction to basic biologists who are looking for a defined biological system that illustrates many of the challenges of modern biology: cell differentiation, epithelial-mesenchymal interactions, stem cell biology, pattern formation, apoptosis, cell and organ growth cycles, and pigmentation. The most important theme in studying the cycling hair follicle is that the follicle is a regenerating system. By traversing the phases of the cycle (growth, regression, resting, shedding, then growth again), the follicle demonstrates the unusual ability to completely regenerate itself. The basis for this regeneration rests in the unique follicular epithelial and mesenchymal components and their interactions. Recently, some of the molecular signals making up these interactions have been defined. They involve gene families also found in other regenerating systems such as fibroblast growth factor, transforming growth factor-beta, Wnt pathway, Sonic hedgehog, neurotrophins, and homeobox. For the immediate future, our challenge is to define the molecular basis for hair follicle growth control, to regenerate a mature hair follicle in vitro from defined populations, and to offer real solutions to our patients' problems.

Hair on a gene string: recent advances in understanding the molecular genetics of hair loss

The hair follicle is finally, after remaining a mystery for many years, beginning to yield some of its molecular secrets. The past decade has seen unprecedented and ever quickening advances in understanding the molecular genetics of the many single gene disorders, which have alopecia as a major feature. This article reviews recent novel clinical and experimental observations, which have shed new light on the basic molecular mechanisms underlying hair morphogenesis, differentiation, keratinization and cycling. We consider recent progress in understanding structural hair defects and complex traits and consider where future developments are likely to occur.