T cell tolerance by clonal elimination in the thymus

Abnormal differentiation of thymocytes in mice treated with cyclosporin A

Cyclosporin A (CsA) acts as a powerful immunosuppressive agent, and also, when given in repeated doses, can cause T-cell-dependent graft-versus-host disease and organ-specific autoimmune disease in rodents. This suggests that CsA interferes with the processes governing self-tolerance, either by nullifying the activity of T suppressor cells or by preventing the deletion of autoreactive T cells during ontogeny in the thymus. We report here that irradiated mice given repeated injections of CsA show striking dysfunction of the thymus. There are two different effects, the first of which is that CsA seems to block the differentiation of immature CD4+CD8+ thymocytes into mature CD4+CD8- and CD4-CD8+ cells expressing a high density of T-cell receptors and CD3 molecules. Second, CsA-treated mice show incomplete deletion of T cells expressing T-cell receptor molecules reactive to self H-2 I-E molecules.

Positive and negative selection of an antigen receptor on T cells in transgenic mice

The T-cell repertoire found in the periphery is thought to be shaped by two developmental events in the thymus that involve the antigen receptors of T lymphocytes. First, interactions between T cells and major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules select a T-cell repertoire skewed towards recognition of antigens in the context of self-MHC molecules. In addition, T cells that react strongly to self-MHC molecules are eliminated by a process called self-tolerance. We have recently described transgenic mice expressing the alpha beta T-cell receptor from the cytotoxic T lymphocyte 2C (ref. 11). The clone 2C was derived from a BALB.B (H-2b) anti-BALB/c (H-2d) mixed lymphocyte culture and is specific for the Ld class I MHC antigen. In transgenic H-2b mice, a large fraction of T cells in the periphery expressed the 2C T-cell receptor. These T cells were predominantly CD4-CD8+ and were able to specifically lyse target cells bearing Ld. We now report that in the periphery of transgenic mice expressing Ld, functional T cells bearing the 2C T-cell receptor were deleted. This elimination of autoreactive T cells appears to take place at or before the CD4+CD8+ stage in thymocyte development. In addition, we report that in H-2s mice, a non-autoreactive target haplotype, large numbers of CD8+ T cells bearing the 2C T-cell receptor were not found, providing strong evidence for the positive selection of the 2C T-cell receptor specificity by H-2b molecules.

The SJL/J T cell response to both spontaneous and transplantable syngeneic reticulum cell sarcoma is mediated predominantly by the V beta 17a+ T cell clonotype

Previous studies have revealed that the reticulum cell sarcoma (RCS) of SJL/J (H-2s, IE-) mice express an "IE-like" stimulatory tumor-associated antigen, the expression of which is requisite for stimulating host T cells necessary for tumor growth. Herein, we present evidence that the predominant T cells raised in the syngeneic response to both spontaneous and transplantable RCS tumors are of the V beta 17a TCR clonotype. The V beta 17a+ clonotype of T cells has been shown to interact with IE allogeneic specificities. We demonstrate that all four characterized RCS-specific T cell hybridomas stained positively for the anti-V beta 17a mAb, KJ23a. Additionally, KJ23a, when added to cocultures of the T cell hybridomas and RCS tumors, inhibited the release of IL-2 by the hybridomas. Further, KJ23a was shown to markedly inhibit the proliferation of SJL/J T cells when cocultured with either spontaneous or transplantable RCS tumor cells. When analyzed by flow cytometry, the T cell blast population raised in response to both spontaneous and transplantable RCS were greater than 80% KJ23a+. These T cells were brightly stained by the anti-CD4 mAb, Gk1.5, and, therefore, represent class II-responsive T cells. In corroboration of the in vitro data, T cells derived from mesenteric lymph nodes of RCS tumor-bearing mice had likewise undergone a similar expansion of V beta 17a+, CD4+ T cells. Together, these results indicate that KJ23a+ T cells play an important and predominant role in the response of SJL/J mice to spontaneous RCS tumors and provide further suggestive evidence that the stimulatory antigen(s) on the RCS tumor is IE or an "IE-like" molecule. Significantly, the important role V beta 17a+ T cells play in the response to RCS suggests a potential therapeutic role for KJ23a mAb in the intervention and prevention of RCS tumors in SJL/J mice.

Peripheral but not thymic T cells participate in an autoreactive T cell network

Splenic T cells proliferate in response to the anti-I-Ab reactive T cell hybridoma T1.203 in an H-2-restricted but MHC antigen-independent manner. We propose that this anti-idiotypic response is mediated by "Type 2 autoreactive" T cells that are induced in peripheral lymphoid tissues following interaction with the particular idiotype expressed by the anti-self-I-A T cells. Thus, we define this phenomenon as an idiotype-restricted MHC-related cell interaction. To study the ontogeny of this response, we examined the distribution of Type 2 autoreactive cells. Spleen and lymph node but not thymic C57BL/6 T cells vigorously proliferate to T1.203. Mature (PNA-) as well as immature (PNA+) thymic T cells respond poorly. The frequency of cells responding to T1.203 is far greater in the spleen than in the thymus. The responding T cells were of both Lyt 1+ and Lyt 2+ T phenotype. The results suggest that Type 2 autoreactive cells are induced in peripheral lymphoid tissues following interaction with anti-I-A autoreactive T cells which escape from the thymus or develop in the periphery.

Involvement of distinct murine T-cell receptors in the autoimmune encephalitogenic response to nested epitopes of myelin basic protein

The peptide p89-101 (Val-His-Phe-Phe-Lys-Asn-Ile-Val-Thr-Pro-Arg-Thr-Pro) of myelin basic protein is encephalitogenic in mice expressing H-2q and H-2s antigens. Six of 13 encephalitogen-specific T-cell clones were shown to express the variable beta-chain (V beta) 17a gene product (KJ23a+), whereas seven clones were KJ23a-. Both KJ23a+ and KJ23a- subpopulations were encephalitogenic in SJL/J mice when adoptively transferred. Depletion of KJ23a+ cells in vivo with the administration of the antibody KJ23a suppresses experimental allergic encephalomyelitis induced with KJ23a+ T-cell lines. However, experimental allergic encephalomyelitis induced with either (i) encephalitogenic peptide p89-101, (ii) intact myelin basic protein, or (iii) KJ23a- T cells reactive to p89-101 cannot be prevented with monoclonal antibody KJ23a. These data indicate that in spite of the V beta 17a gene expression in a relatively large proportion of p89-101-specific T cells, such V beta gene use is not essential for the induction of experimental allergic encephalomyelitis in SJL/J mice. These results contrast with the predominance of V beta gene use (V beta 8.2) in T cells reactive to the encephalitogenic fragment (pR1-11) in PL/J mice. One reason for this lack of dominant use of a particular T-cell receptor V beta gene family in the autoimmune response to myelin basic protein in SJL/J mice stems from the observation that two encephalitogenic epitopes exist in p89-101. KJ23a- T cells are stimulated by the deleted peptide p89-100, whereas KJ23a+ T cells are not. Thus, in the response to an encephalitogenic fragment of myelin basic protein containing two nested epitopes, at least two distinct T-cell receptor V beta genes are expressed. These distinct T-cell subpopulations can each trigger experimental allergic encephalomyelitis. These findings have implications for therapy of autoimmune disease with antibodies to the T-cell receptor gene products.

Self-tolerance alters T-cell receptor expression in an antigen-specific MHC restricted immune response

The influence of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) gene products on the T-lymphocyte alpha beta receptor (TCR) repertoire is well documented, but how specificity is also generated for a diverse array of foreign peptide antigens is unknown. One proposed mechanism is that the TCR repertoire is selected by the recognition of processed self-antigens bound to MHC molecules. Here, we examine the influence of non-MHC-encoded self-antigens on the TCR repertoire expressed in an antigen-specific immune response. Most pigeon cytochrome c-specific, Ek alpha Ek beta (Ek) Ia-restricted T cells from B10.A mice express a product of the V alpha 11 gene family in association with a V beta 3 gene-encoded protein. We therefore examined V alpha 11 and V beta 3 gene expression in cytochrome c-specific T-cell lines derived from various mouse strains with different non-MHC genetic backgrounds. T cells from several strains failed to express any V beta 3 due to tolerance induced by Mlsc-encoded self-antigens. Variable levels of V alpha 11 messenger RNA (mRNA) were expressed by antigen-specific T cells from all the strains. In one strain V beta 3 was expressed in the relative absence of V alpha 11. These results directly demonstrate that self-tolerance alters TCR gene usage in the immune response to a foreign antigen, and indicate that TCR V alpha and V beta proteins may, in part, be independently selected.

The T-cell repertoire is heavily influenced by tolerance to polymorphic self-antigens

T cells with V beta 3+ alpha beta receptors are deleted by self-tolerance in mice with particular major histocompatibility complex/self-antigen combinations. This also occurs for other V beta elements. Polymorphism in the major histocompatibility complex and/or the self-antigens that cause massive deletion of T cells using particular V beta elements may be maintained by the need to balance the advantage of a diverse T-cell repertoire against the potential involvement of those elements in autoimmune disease.

Effects of cyclosporine A on T cell development and clonal deletion

Cyclosporine A (CsA) is an important immunosuppressive drug that is widely used in transplantation medicine. Many of its suppressive effects on T cells appear to be related to the inhibition of T cell receptor (TCR)-mediated activation events. Paradoxically, in certain situations CsA is responsible for the induction of a T cell-mediated autoimmunity. The effects of CsA on T cell development in the thymus were investigated to elucidate the physiologic events underlying this phenomenon. Two major effects were revealed: (i) CsA inhibits the development of mature single positive (CD4+8- or CD4-8+) TCR-alpha beta+ thymocytes without discernibly affecting CD4-8- TCR-gamma delta+ thymocytes and (ii) CsA interferes with the deletion of cells bearing self-reactive TCRs in the population of single positive thymocytes that do develop. This suggests a direct mechanism for CsA-induced autoimmunity and may have implications for the relative contribution of TCR-mediated signaling events in the development of the various T cell lineages.

The joining of germ-line V alpha to J alpha genes replaces the preexisting V alpha-J alpha complexes in a T cell receptor alpha, beta positive T cell line

To determine whether T cell receptor genes follow the same principle of allelic exclusion as B lymphocytes, we have analyzed the rearrangements and expression of TCR alpha and beta genes in the progeny of the CD3+, CD4-/CD8- M14T line. Here, we show that this line can undergo secondary rearrangements that replace the pre-existing V alpha-J alpha rearrangements by joining an upstream V alpha gene to a downstream J alpha segment. Both the productively and nonproductively rearranged alleles in the M14T line can undergo secondary rearrangements while its TCR beta genes are stable. These secondary recombinations are usually productive, and new forms of TCR alpha polypeptides are expressed in these cells in association with the original C beta chain. Developmental control of this V alpha-J alpha replacement phenomenon could play a pivotal role in the thymic selection of the T cell repertoire.

Mouse strain differences in subset distribution and T cell antigen receptor expression among CD4-CD8- thymocytes

'Double negative' (CD4-CD8-) thymocytes from adult mice of different inbred strains were examined for surface expression of CD3 and of various forms of the T cell antigen receptor (TcR), as well as for the levels of subpopulations defined by the surface markers HSA ('heat stable antigen', recognized by M1/69, J11d and B2A2), CD5 (Ly 1) and Thy 1. Marked variations were found in the level of the double negative subsets which were surface TcR+, or which were HSA-CD5+; these generally varied together since most CD4-CD8-HSA-CD5+ thymocytes were TCR+. The level of the CD3-TCR complex on the surface of those double negative thymocytes which were TcR+ was as high as on mature T cells in some strains (CBA/Ca), but was much lower in other strains (C57BL/6J). In most mouse strains the CD4-CD8-HSA-CD5+ thymocytes expressed predominantly the alpha beta form of the TcR, with an exceptionally high (70%) usage of V beta 8 gene products. In strains which lacked V beta 8 expressing T cells due to a deletion of the V beta 8 gene region, reduced levels of alpha beta TcR+ cells were found within the CD4-CD8- thymocytes; the HSA-CD5+ subset was then only present at low levels (as in SJL/J and C57BR mice) or was present at a high level but expressed predominantly gamma delta TcR (as in SWR mice). The results suggest that the accumulation of CD4-CD8-TcR+ HSA-CD5+ thymocytes is a selective event, and that their developmental pathway is off the mainstream of T cell maturation in the thymus.

In situ localization of T cell receptor beta chain in the murine thymus: changes in the intrathymic distribution of thymocytes expressing beta chain during fetal development

The expression of T cell receptor beta chain in the developing thymus was examined at the light and electron microscopic levels using the monoclonal antibody F23.1. Cells expressing cytoplasmic forms of beta chain were first observed at Day 16 of gestation, while thymocytes expressing cell surface beta chain were detected about a day later. Clustering of cortical F23.1+ cells was more pronounced in fetal thymus when compared to adult. The density of F23.1+ cells in the subcapsular areas of the thymus was initially lower than that in the rest of the cortex or the medulla. Within the subcapsular and cortical areas of the thymus there was an inverse relationship between the density of F23.1+ cells and cells labeled with the lectin from Dolichos bifloris, which binds to terminal alpha-linked N-acetylgalactosamine residues preferentially expressed by L3T4-/Lyt2- thymocytes. Although this pattern was less pronounced with increasing gestational age, it was still apparent at birth.

T-cell receptor alpha-chain variable-region haplotypes of normal and autoimmune laboratory mouse strains

We used Southern blotting and mRNA analysis to characterize allelic polymorphisms among genes of the T-cell antigen receptor (TCR) alpha-chain variable-region (V alpha) locus in a large panel of normal and autoimmune-susceptible or autoimmune-contributing strains of laboratory mice. Four major V alpha haplotypes were defined on the basis of multiple restriction fragment length polymorphisms for each of nine V alpha subfamily probes used. Southern blotting also revealed haplotype-specific loss of bands within some V alpha subfamilies, consistent with the deletion of particular V alpha genes or sets of genes from haplotype to haplotype. In contrast to the situation in the V beta locus, however, deletion of entire V alpha subfamilies was not observed. The nature of V alpha allelic variability was further explored by using an RNase protection assay to analyze expressed V alpha mRNA sequences in thymocyte RNA. Such analysis revealed both shared and unique patterns of V alpha mRNA expression among the different haplotypes and supported the conclusion that haplotype differences sometimes involve V alpha gene deletions. Interestingly, a disproportionate number of, but not all, autoimmune-susceptible strains, including NZB, SJL, SWR, PL/J, and NOD, share a common V alpha haplotype. The identification of murine TCR V alpha haplotypes should provide a basis for understanding the role of TCR diversity in normal immunoregulatory and immune-response phenomena, as well as autoimmune-disease predisposition.

Two monoclonal rat antibodies with specificity for the beta-chain variable region V beta 6 of the murine T-cell receptor

Two rat monoclonal antibodies (mAbs), 44-22-1 and 46-6B5, which recognize an alloreactive cytotoxic clone, 3F9, have been further tested on a panel of T hybridomas and cytotoxic T-cell clones for binding and functional activities. The mAbs recognized only those cells sharing the expression of the T-cell receptor beta-chain variable region gene V beta 6 with 3F9. All V beta 6+ cells were activated by these mAbs under cross-linking conditions and their antigen-specific activation was blocked by soluble mAb. Furthermore, depletion of 46-6B5+ normal lymph node T cells eliminated all cells expressing the epitope recognized by 44-22-1 and V beta 6 mRNA.

Effects of cyclosporine A on T cell development and clonal deletion

Cyclosporine A (CsA) is an important immunosuppressive drug that is widely used in transplantation medicine. Many of its suppressive effects on T cells appear to be related to the inhibition of T cell receptor (TCR)-mediated activation events. Paradoxically, in certain situations CsA is responsible for the induction of a T cell-mediated autoimmunity. The effects of CsA on T cell development in the thymus were investigated to elucidate the physiologic events underlying this phenomenon. Two major effects were revealed: (i) CsA inhibits the development of mature single positive (CD4+8- or CD4-8+) TCR-alpha beta+ thymocytes without discernibly affecting CD4-8- TCR-gamma delta+ thymocytes and (ii) CsA interferes with the deletion of cells bearing self-reactive TCRs in the population of single positive thymocytes that do develop. This suggests a direct mechanism for CsA-induced autoimmunity and may have implications for the relative contribution of TCR-mediated signaling events in the development of the various T cell lineages.

Selective expression of an antigen receptor on CD8-bearing T lymphocytes in transgenic mice

The major problem in the study of T-cell development is that of tracking thymocytes of a given specificity. Recent studies have exploited natural correlations between the expression of a particular V beta gene segment and T-cell receptor (TCR) specificity. We and others (refs 5, 6 and M. Davis, personal communication) have taken an alternative approach. We have generated transgenic mice expressing the alpha beta antigen receptor from the cytotoxic T-lymphocyte clone 2C (ref. 7). In transgenic mice of the same haplotype as the 2C clone, the 2C TCR was expressed on 20-95% of peripheral T cells. Very few of these T cells carried the CD4 antigen; the vast majority were CD4-CD8+ and were able to lyse targets with the same specificity as the original 2C clone. These results indicate that the alpha beta heterodimer transfers specificity to recipient cells as expected from earlier studies, and that receptor specificity in T-cell repertoire selection is determined by both alpha beta heterodimer and CD4 or CD8 accessory molecules.

Thymic major histocompatibility complex antigens and the alpha beta T-cell receptor determine the CD4/CD8 phenotype of T cells

T-cell receptors and T-cell subsets were analysed in T-cell receptor transgenic mice expressing alpha and beta T-cell receptor genes isolated from a male-specific, H-2Db-restricted CD4-8+ T-cell clone. The results indicate that the specific interaction of the T-cell receptor on immature thymocytes with thymic major histocompatibility complex antigens determines the differentiation of CD4+8+ thymocytes into either CD4+8- or CD4-8+ mature T cells.

Selection of variable-joining region combinations in the alpha chain of the T cell receptor

Most T lymphocytes express an antigen-specific receptor composed of two subunits, alpha and beta, each of which can exhibit structural variability. A complex selection process operates on T cells during development in the thymus such that cells expressing only particular alpha beta-receptors migrate to the periphery. The alpha-chain repertoire was dissected at different stages of the selection process by using the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) technique to amplify only those transcripts of a particular variable region gene (V58). Sequences from these V58 cDNAs reveal the predominant expression of four joining (J) segments by T cells in the adult thymus, suggesting that molecular or cellular processes select particular V alpha J alpha combinations during development. T cells expressing one of these V58J alpha chains appear to have been negatively selected at a later stage, since these transcripts were present in the spleen at approximately one-tenth the level in the thymus. Results also indicate that residues present at the V alpha J alpha junction may be important in an early selection process.

Intrathymic deletion of self-reactive cells prevented by neonatal anti-CD4 antibody treatment

T-cell differentiation in the thymus involves the coordinate expression of genes encoding the alpha and beta chains of the major histocompatibility complex-restricted heterodimeric antigen receptor (TCR) complex, as well as other functionally important molecules such as CD4 and CD8. The repertoire of TCR expressed by T cells is generally thought to be influenced by positive and/or negative selection events occurring when TCRs on developing T cells interact with self-antigens and major histocompatibility complex components. Using a model system in which specific antigen-reactive cells can be monitored by virtue of their preferential expression of certain TCR beta-chain variable (V beta) domains, it has been shown that self-reactive T cells are clonally deleted during development. We report here that clonal deletion of V+ beta 6 cells in Mlsa mice can be prevented by in vivo neonatal administration of monoclonal antibodies directed against CD4. Furthermore, as anti-CD4 monoclonal antibody treatment resulted in the reappearance of V+ beta 6 cells in the mature CD8+ T-cell subset, it is likely that clonal deletion acts on the CD4+CD8+ thymocyte subset and that this subset is an intermediate stage in the differentiation pathway of both CD4+ and CD8+ T-cell lineages.

The heme moiety of cytochrome c is an autoreactive Ir gene-restricted T cell epitope

In these studies, we have shown that the heme moiety of cyt c is a dominant T cell epitope that induces a large proliferative response in lymph node T cells derived from SJL and B10.A mice when presented on either unfixed or fixed syngeneic APCs. Not only is this vigorous response observed for cyt c-primed T cell populations but also for populations obtained from naive SJL or B10.A mice. The reactivity to the heme moiety falls under strict MHC restriction, in that it is present only in murine strains bearing either the I-Ak or I-As molecule and can be blocked by antibodies specific for these class II molecules. Therefore, these findings require that the current models describing the nature of T cell epitopes be extended to include nonpeptide molecules. Furthermore, as the heme moiety is ubiquitous throughout the organism, although sequestered within proteins, the existence of heme-reactive T cell populations in unprimed animals provides another example of the existence of self-reactive T cell clones.

Altered immunoglobulin expression and functional silencing of self-reactive B lymphocytes in transgenic mice

Immunological tolerance has been demonstrated in double-transgenic mice expressing the genes for a neo-self antigen, hen egg lysozyme, and a high affinity anti-lysozyme antibody. The majority of anti-lysozyme B-cells did not undergo clonal deletion, but were no longer able to secrete anti-lysozyme antibody and displayed markedly reduced levels of surface IgM while continuing to express high levels of surface IgD. These findings indicate that self tolerance may result from mechanisms other than clonal deletion, and are consistent with the hypothesis that IgD may have a unique role in B-cell tolerance.

Deletion of self-reactive thymocytes occurs at a CD4+8+ precursor stage

As T cells develop in the thymus, they become tolerant of self-antigens. A major advance in the understanding of how this process occurs was the direct demonstration that cells bearing autoreactive T-cell receptors (TCRs) are physically eliminated from the population of functionally mature T cells present in both the thymus and periphery. We have sought to determine the developmental stage at which autoreactive T cells are eliminated by examining the expression of V beta 17a anti-I-E TCRs under various experimental conditions. In vivo antibody blockage of the CD4 molecule on developing thymocytes of I-E+ C57BR mice was found to inhibit the deletion of V beta 17a-bearing cells from the CD4-8+ single positive thymocyte subset. This result provides strong evidence that deletion of potentially autoreactive T cells occurs at a CD4+8+ precursor stage, that the non-clonally distributed accessory molecules (CD4, CD8) are significant participants in the self-recognition process that leads to clonal elimination, and that thymic class II major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules can influence the repertoire of CD4-8+ cells.

Immunological responsiveness of neonatal A/J mice to isotypic determinants of syngeneic IgE

We have previously shown that adult A/J mice produce high titers of anti-IgE with isotypic or idiotypic specificities in response to challenge with a conjugate of KLH with syngeneic monoclonal IgE. Thus, B cells that can synthesize anti-IgE are present in the mice. Adult mice are unresponsive to unconjugated IgE in CFA, suggesting that tolerance exists at the level of T cells. The present study shows that neonatal mice produce anti-IgE antibodies in response to unconjugated IgE in CFA, but that this capacity is lost after the age of 2-3 wk. The loss of responsiveness corresponds closely with the appearance of detectable IgE in serum, suggesting that the IgE may induce tolerance. The affinities of anti-IgE antibodies produced by neonatal mice fall in the range of values obtained with KLH-IgE in adult mice. Tolerance to unconjugated IgE in CFA can be induced in neonatal mice by administration of IgE in saline. In addition, the tolerant state can be induced by adoptive transfer of spleen cells from adult mice. The time-dependent acquisition of tolerance provides a useful model for studying mechanisms of tolerance and autoimmunity.

A solubilized T-cell receptor from a human leukemia cell line binds to a ligand in the absence of MHC products

A human T cell alpha beta antigen receptor from the acute lymphoblastoid leukemia line HPB-ALL (also called HPB-MLT) binds and is precipitated in detergent-solubilized form by an antigen present on the surface and secreted by several strains of the gram-positive bacterium Staphylococcus aureus. This binding is completely independent of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) antigens. Receptor/ligand binding is unique to this one cell line (i.e., clonotypic) and furthermore completely blocked by an idiotype-specific monoclonal antibody (mAb) to this receptor, but not by three different nonidiotype-specific mAbs. The nature of this interaction appears more similar to immunoglobulin/antigen binding than to T-cell receptor/antigen/MHC/accessory molecule interactions and would suggest that some T-cell receptors may not require MHC products to interact with antigen.

Split tolerance induced by the intrathymic adoptive transfer of thymocyte stem cells

The intrathymic transfer of semiallogeneic CD4/CD8 double-negative (DN) thymocyte stem cells into irradiated host mice resulted in a transient state of chimerism in adoptive host thymus, spleen, and lymph nodes. Host-derived T cells, isolated from the thymus and periphery of the chimeric mice, were found to be specifically nonresponsive to the MHC antigens of the semiallogeneic DN donor in cytotoxicity assays. This nonresponsiveness was not permanent, but persisted as long as appreciable numbers of Thy-1 alloantigen-positive progeny of the DN donor cells could be detected in the spleen and lymph nodes of adoptive host mice. FACS sorting of DN donor cells before intrathymic transfer indicated that nonresponsiveness could be induced by Thy-1+ cells and was therefore not attributable to contaminating thymic macrophages, dendritic cells, or B cells. When FACS-sorted Thy-1+ (bm5 x bm12)F1 DN cells were transferred intrathymically into C57BL/6 hosts, nonresponsiveness to DN donor MHC class I but not class II alloantigen (split tolerance) was observed. These experiments were repeated using FACS-sorted Thy-1+ DN donor cells that were semiallogeneic to the irradiated adoptive host at either MHC class I or class II locus with similar results. Limiting dilution analysis showed that host-derived CTL precursors were tolerant of DN donor MHC class I alloantigen and no evidence for the involvement of suppressor T cells was found. The data indicate that murine thymocytes themselves are capable of tolerizing to MHC class I but not class II alloantigen after intrathymic transfer. The implications for intrathymic T cell differentiation and maintenance of self tolerance are discussed.

Structure-function analysis of Ia molecules: in-phase insertion mutagenesis of the amino-terminal domain of the E beta k polypeptide chain

To identify which segments of the beta 1 domain of the E beta k polypeptide control T cell recognition of antigen, E beta genes were constructed with in-phase insertion mutations. Five independent mutants, with insertions mapping to positions 24, 50 and 93 of the E beta k polypeptide, were obtained. Cell lines expressing these mutated genes were analysed by microfluorometry using a panel of 20 anti-Ek monoclonal antibodies. None of the tested in-phase insertions has resulted in the loss of antibody binding sites. In striking contrast, mutations at position 93 and at a lesser level 50 were indicative of a crucial role of the corresponding regions in T-cell recognition, because they led to significant or complete loss of antigen-presenting function with all but one of the T hybridomas tested. These data are discussed with regard to a model of the foreign antigen binding site of Ia molecules.

Tolerance in T-cell-receptor transgenic mice involves deletion of nonmature CD4+8+ thymocytes

The mechanism of self-tolerance is studied in T-cell-receptor transgenic mice expressing a receptor in many of their T cells for the male (H-Y) antigen in the context of class I H-2Db MHC antigens. Autospecific T cells are deleted in male mice. The deletion affects only transgene-expressing cells with a relatively high surface-density of CD8 molecules, including nonmature CD4+ CD8+ thymocytes, and is not caused by anti-idiotype cells.

Diabetes in transgenic mice resulting from over-expression of class I histocompatibility molecules in pancreatic beta cells

A class I histocompatibility gene, H-2Kb, linked to the rat insulin promoter, is overexpressed in the pancreatic beta cells of transgenic mice. The mice, whether syngeneic or allogeneic to the transgene, develop insulin dependent diabetes without detectable T cell infiltration, suggesting a direct, non-immune role for the transgenic class I molecules in the disease process.

Functional differentiation and repertoire diversification of T cells derived from single progenitor cells

Functions of T cells derived from single progenitor cells were investigated. B10. Thy-1.1 recipient mice were either whole body-irradiated and marrow reconstituted or thymus-shielded, irradiated and marrow reconstituted, and limited numbers (3 x 10(3) or 6 x 10(3] of a 1:1 mixture of bone marrow cells from C57BL/6 and B6.Lyt-2.1 mice were transferred intrathymically (i.t.). Donor-type (Thy-1.2+) cells of the thymus of a small portion of recipients which expressed the phenotype of either Ly-2.2 or Ly-2.1 but not both were regarded to be a clone of T cells derived from a single progenitor cell, and such clones were assayed for polyclonal helper (Th) and polyclonal cytolytic (CTL) activities as well as alloantigen-specific proliferative (mixed lymphocyte reaction; MLR) and CTL activities. Clones taken 4 weeks after transfer (4-week-old clones) which were generated in the thymus of whole body-irradiated recipients showed polyclonal CTL but not polyclonal Th activity, whereas 4-week-old clones generated in the thymus of thymus-shielded recipients showed both polyclonal CTL and Th activities. Similarly, 4-week-old clones generated in whole body-irradiated recipients responded with CTL to alloantigens when induced in the presence of T cell growth factors but not with MLR, whereas 4-week-old clones generated in thymus-shielded recipients showed both MLR and CTL to alloantigens. Repertoire diversification of 4-week-old clones, however, was incomplete, since clones generated in whole body-irradiated recipient did not necessarily respond with CTL to all alloantigens examined, and those generated in thymus-shielded recipients did not necessarily respond with MLR to all the antigens. On the other hand, T cell clones were shown to fully mature by 7 weeks after transfer in terms of cell function as well as repertoire diversification.

Intrathymic elimination of Mlsa-reactive (V beta 6+) cells during neonatal tolerance induction to Mlsa-encoded antigens

The cellular basis of neonatally induced T cell tolerance has been investigated in a model system in which usage of a particular TCR V beta segment (V beta 6) is strongly correlated with reactivity to antigens encoded by the Mlsa genetic locus. Expression of V beta 6 by peripheral T cells was virtually abolished in BALB/c (H-2d, Mlsb) mice rendered neonatally tolerant to DBA/2 (H-2d, Mlsa) lymphoid cells, whereas control V beta 8-bearing T cells remained at near normal levels. Further analysis revealed that elimination of V beta 6+ T cells occurred in the thymus of neonatally tolerant mice and could not be explained by receptor modulation or T cell chimerism. These data thus support the clonal deletion model of tolerance induction.

The effect of thymus environment on T cell development and tolerance

During development in the thymus, T cells are deleted if their receptors are able to recognize self major histocompatibility complex (MHC) proteins. We show that such clonal deletion can occur because of interaction between receptors on T cells and MHC expressed on bone marrow-derived cells. In addition, development in the thymus picks out T cells to mature if their receptors will be restricted for antigen recognition in association with self MHC alleles expressed on thymus epithelial cells. This process is usually thought to involve positive selection of T cells bearing receptors with high and low affinity for MHC on thymus epithelium, and subsequent deletion of high affinity cells by interaction with bone marrow-derived cells. Our data do not fit such a model, but rather suggest that MHC molecules on thymus epithelium and bone marrow-derived cells may not be seen identically by T cell receptors.

Development of CD4-CD8+ cytotoxic T cells requires interactions with class I MHC determinants

Differentiation of bone marrow derived precursors into mature T cells takes place in the thymus. During differentiation, T cells develop the receptor repertoire which allows them to recognize antigen in the context of self major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules. Mature T helper cells (mostly CD4+ CD8-) recognize antigen in the context of class II MHC molecules, whereas cytotoxic T cells (mostly CD4-CD8+) recognize antigen in the context of class I MHC determinants. Thymic MHC-encoded determinants greatly influence the selection of the T-cell receptor repertoire. In addition to positive selection, a negative selection to eliminate self-reactive T-cell clones is thought to occur in the thymus, but how this 'education' occurs is not well understood. It has been suggested that during differentiation an interaction between the T-cell receptor (TCR) and MHC-encoded determinants occurs, leading to the selection of an MHC-restricted receptor repertoire. In support of this hypothesis, class-II-specific, CD4+ CD8- helper T cells fail to develop in mice neonatally treated with anti-class II monoclonal antibody (mAb). As CD4-CD8+ cells differ from the CD4+ CD8- lineage (in function, MHC-restriction specificity and perhaps site of education) we examined whether interactions with MHC determinants are also necessary for the development of class-I-specific T cells. Here we show that mice chronically treated with anti-class I mAb from birth lack CD4-CD8+ cells and cytotoxic T-cell precursors, indicating that most CD4-CD8+ T cells need interaction with class I MHC molecules during differentiation.

Compartmentalization of MHC class II gene expression in transgenic mice

A set of transgenic mouse lines carrying Ek alpha genes with promoter region deletions was created in an attempt to compartmentalize MHC class II gene expression. Fine immunohistological analyses established that one transgenic line is essentially devoid of E complex in the thymic cortex, another displays almost no E in the thymic medulla or on peripheral macrophages, and two lines display no E on greater than 98% of B cells. We have assayed these mice for immune function: E-dependent tolerance, antigen presentation, T cell priming, and antibody response. Certain of the findings are difficult to reconcile with currently popular hypotheses, e.g., tolerance induction to E molecules in the virtual absence of E complex in the thymic medulla and efficient antibody responses to E-restricted antigens when almost all B cells are E-.

Patterns of expression of trichocytic and epithelial cytokeratins in mammalian tissues. II. Concomitant and mutually exclusive synthesis of trichocytic and epithelial cytokeratins in diverse human and bovine tissues (hair follicle, nail bed and matrix, lingual papilla, thymic reticulum)

The hair-forming cells (trichocytes) and the mature hair contain four major trichocytic cytokeratins from each of the subfamilies, basic (Hb1-4) and acidic (Ha1-4); these are related - but not identical - to the epithelial cytokeratins. Here we show, by biochemical methods and immunofluorescence microscopy using antibodies specific for either epithelial or trichocyte cytokeratins, that the same set of hair-type cytokeratins, including two newly identified minor components, designated Hax (type I) and Hbx (type II), are also expressed in cells forming nails, in the filiform papillae of the dorsal surface of human and bovine tongue, and, most surprisingly, in some cells of the epithelial reticulum of bovine and human thymus. By double-label immunofluorescence microscopy, we also show that the expression of the two subsets of cytokeratins, i.e., the epithelial and the trichocytic ones, is not necessarily mutually exclusive, but that certain cells of hair follicles, nail matrix and bed, lingual papillae, and the nonlymphoid cell system of the thymus contain both trichocytic and certain epithelial cytokeratins. This indicates that these cells coexpress representatives of both kinds of cytokeratin. Implications of these findings with respect to problems of regulatory control of cytokeratin synthesis in tissue development and differentiation, and the possible functional meaning of the occurrence of trichocytic cytokeratins in such histologically diverse tissues, are discussed.

Autoreactive T cell clones specific for class I and class II HLA antigens isolated from a human chimera

T cell clones of donor origin that specifically react with recipient cells were obtained from a SCID patient successfully reconstituted by allogeneic fetal liver and thymus transplantation performed 10 yr ago. The majority of these clones displayed both cytotoxic and proliferative responses towards PBL and an EBV-transformed B cell line derived from the patient. In addition, these T cell clones had proliferative and cytotoxic responses towards the parental PBL, EBV cell lines, and PHA blasts. Blocking studies with anti-class I and anti-class II HLA mAbs indicated that the activity of the CD4+ T cell clones was specifically directed against class II HLA antigens of the recipient. On the other hand, the cytotoxic and proliferative responses of the CD8+ T cell clones were specific for class I HLA antigens which are ubiquitously expressed on the recipient cells. Thus, the establishment of transplantation tolerance observed in this stable human chimera is not due to the elimination of host-reactive T cells from the repertoire and suggests the presence of a peripheral autoregulatory suppressor mechanism.

The molecular basis of MHC-restricted antigen recognition by T cells

In order to determine the contribution of the clonotypic T cell receptor (Ti) alpha beta heterodimer to the antigen/MHC specificity of mature T cells, we have transfected cloned Ti alpha and/or beta genes into either human or mouse T cells, and analyzed the transfectants for Ti-T3 expression and responses to antigen and Ia molecules. Our analysis establishes that a single receptor structure (the Ti alpha beta heterodimer) is necessary and sufficient to define the dual specificity of T cell antigen recognition and suggests that in at least certain instances Ti beta chains play a predominant role in MHC restriction specificity, raising the possibility of a "one receptor, two sites" model of T cell recognition.

T-cell receptor V beta use predicts reactivity and tolerance to Mlsa-encoded antigens

T lymphocytes reactive with the product of the Mlsa-allele of the minor lymphocyte stimulating (Mls) locus use a predominant T-cell receptor beta-chain variable gene segment (V beta 6). Such V beta 6-bearing T cells are selectively eliminated in the thymus of Mlsa-bearing mice, consistent with a model in which tolerance to self antigens is achieved by clonal deletion.