In-utero transplantation of parental CD34 haematopoietic progenitor cells in a patient with X-linked severe combined immunodeficiency (SCIDXI)

Mixed lymphocyte culture of human fetal liver cells

OBJECTIVE

In order to study the immunological function of the human fetus in the first and second trimesters, mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) of fetal liver and thymic cells was performed. MLC is a functional test to determine human lymphocyte antigen-D incompatibilities.

METHODS

Human fetal liver and thymic tissue was obtained from abortions in gestational weeks 7-17.5. Forty-seven fetuses were studied with one-way MLC. The cells were stimulated by adding irradiated fetal liver cells, adult bone marrow and peripheral blood lymphocytes. The activity was measured as DNA incorporation of radiolabeled thymidine.

RESULTS

The results indicate that the human fetus is competent to react as early as 11-12 weeks of gestation and in some cases even earlier. In very immature fetal livers (< 8 weeks), the MLC seems to be inhibited.

CONCLUSIONS

Our data suggest that the human fetus can react against foreign transplantation antigens earlier than previous papers have claimed. The onset of reactivity seems to differ considerably among fetuses. The present findings may explain some of the limited success of in utero transplantations of hematopoietic stem cells in human fetuses of normal immunological status.

Immunogenetics: changing the face of immunodeficiency

Tables 1 and 2 highlight the enormous advances that have been made in the definition of the molecular defects underlying primary immunodeficiencies in the past decade. The identification of SAP as the gene defective in XLP now completes the molecular bases of all the recognised X linked syndromes. Of the autosomally inherited syndromes, only the genes for DiGeorge syndrome, hyper-IgE, and perhaps most importantly, common variable immunodeficiency remain to be elucidated. The major clinical benefits of this information have primarily been in offering more accurate and rapid molecular diagnoses. The ability to make a molecular diagnosis also increases the options for earlier definitive treatments such as bone marrow transplantation and somatic gene therapy. Finally, as illustrated by the studies on the functions of WASP and the gamma c/JAK-3 pathway, identification of the gene defect is the first step to understanding the molecular pathogenesis of the immunological abnormalities.

Fetal hematopoietic stem cell transplantation

In utero hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (IUHSCTx) is a promising approach for the treatment of a potentially large number of fetuses affected by congenital hematologic disorders. With technical and molecular advances in prenatal diagnosis, the majority of these diseases can now be diagnosed early in gestation, allowing consideration of prenatal treatment. In addition, technical advances in fetal imaging and intervention make it possible to perform the transplants with relatively minimal risk. It, therefore, stands to reason that there is increasing interest in performing in utero hematopoietic stem cell transplantation at many fetal treatment centers. Although the approach remains experimentally promising, expansion of clinical application will depend on improved understanding of the biological barriers to engraftment in the fetus as well as the development of effective clinical strategies based on the hematopoietic biology of individual disorders. This article presents the current status of this emerging therapeutic approach.

A Kinetic Model for the Homing and Migration of Prenatally Transplanted Marrow

Currently little is known about the mechanisms regulating the homing and the early engraftment of prenatally transplanted hematopoietic cells due to the lack of a relevant functional assay. In this study, we have defined a reproducible kinetic profile of the homing and the early engraftment events in a murine model of prenatal stem cell transplantation. Light density mononuclear cells (LDMCs) from adult C57Pep3b and SJL/J marrow were transplanted by intraperitoneal (IP) injection into C57BL/6 fetuses (106 LDMCs/fetus) at 14 days of gestation. The fetuses were sacrificed at early time points (1.5 to 96 hours) after transplantation. Recipient fetal liver and cord blood were analyzed for donor cell frequency and donor cell phenotype by dual color flow cytometry. Pertinent findings included the following: (1) a triphasic kinetic profile exists after in utero hematopoietic stem cell (HSC) transplantation (homing of circulating donor cells, rapid reduction of donor cell frequency, and donor cell competitive equilibration); (2) homing to the fetal liver is nonselective and reflects the phenotypic profile of the donor population; and (3) the kinetics after the prenatal transplantation of congenic or fully allogeneic cells are identical. This model will facilitate a systematic analysis of the mechanisms that regulate the homing of prenatally transplanted hematopoietic cells.

Prenatal orogastric gene delivery results in transduction of the small bowel in the fetal rabbit

BACKGROUND

Gene therapy for meconium ileus, or other genetic diseases involving the gastrointestinal epithelium, may be possible with prenatal delivery of the CFTR gene to the gastrointestinal tract. Although minimally invasive techniques will probably be used for any future therapy of gastrointestinal disease, it is important to first test this strategy with a reliable animal model.

METHODS

The technique of orogastric fetal gene delivery was assessed using 7 pregnant rabbits (22 days' gestation n = 1, 25 days' gestation n = 4, 28 days' gestation n = 2). Four fetuses from each litter were given an adenoviral vector carrying a marker gene by instilling it into the posterior pharynx with an animal feeding needle (1 x 10(10) particles of ADV/RSV/LacZ suspended in 0.3 ml of saline), with the untreated fetuses serving as control animals.

RESULTS

There were no recoverable fetuses from the does that had surgery at 22 and 28 days (n = 3) due to maternal death (n = 2) and premature delivery (n = 1). Among the 4 does that underwent hysterotomy at 25 days of gestation, 1 underwent cesarean section 2 days after fetal gene delivery and 3 delivered at term, 5 (n = 1) or 6 (n = 2) days following gene delivery. Eleven of the 16 experimental pups and 7 untreated control animals were collected alive, and were sacrificed at delivery for study. Nine of the 11 experimental pups (82%) showed positive blue (LacZ+) nuclei in the small intestine by X-gal staining. No positive cells were found in 7/7 control animals. The presence of the reporter gene LacZ was confirmed in 8/11 (73%) virus-treated pups by PCR with 5/5 control animals negative for LacZ by PCR.

CONCLUSIONS

There was significant maternal and fetal loss related to anesthetic and husbandry issues when surgery was performed at 22 or 28 days of gestation. Based on these preliminary results, we conclude that orogastric gene delivery in the rabbit fetus at 25 days' gestation is an encouraging animal model to study fetal delivery to the gastrointestinal tract.

A Kinetic Model for the Homing and Migration of Prenatally Transplanted Marrow

Currently little is known about the mechanisms regulating the homing and the early engraftment of prenatally transplanted hematopoietic cells due to the lack of a relevant functional assay. In this study, we have defined a reproducible kinetic profile of the homing and the early engraftment events in a murine model of prenatal stem cell transplantation. Light density mononuclear cells (LDMCs) from adult C57Pep3b and SJL/J marrow were transplanted by intraperitoneal (IP) injection into C57BL/6 fetuses (106 LDMCs/fetus) at 14 days of gestation. The fetuses were sacrificed at early time points (1.5 to 96 hours) after transplantation. Recipient fetal liver and cord blood were analyzed for donor cell frequency and donor cell phenotype by dual color flow cytometry. Pertinent findings included the following: (1) a triphasic kinetic profile exists after in utero hematopoietic stem cell (HSC) transplantation (homing of circulating donor cells, rapid reduction of donor cell frequency, and donor cell competitive equilibration); (2) homing to the fetal liver is nonselective and reflects the phenotypic profile of the donor population; and (3) the kinetics after the prenatal transplantation of congenic or fully allogeneic cells are identical. This model will facilitate a systematic analysis of the mechanisms that regulate the homing of prenatally transplanted hematopoietic cells.

Cotransplantation of stroma results in enhancement of engraftment and early expression of donor hematopoietic stem cells in utero

Although promising, clinical and experimental efforts at in utero hematopoietic stem cell (HSC) transplantation currently are limited by minimal donor cell engraftment and lack of early donor cell expression after transplantation. We reasoned that cotransplantation of stromal elements (ST) might condition the fetal microenvironment for the engraftment of donor HSC and facilitate precocious bone marrow (BM) hematopoiesis. In this study we cotransplanted sheep ST, derived from adult or fetal BM, with either adult or fetal HSC, into preimmune fetal sheep. We analyzed donor cell chimerism in BM and peripheral blood and compared levels of chimerism achieved with recipients of HSC alone. In all experimental groups, stromal cotransplantation markedly increased the level of peripheral blood donor cell expression at 60 days after transplantation relative to controls. Adult BM-derived stroma cotransplanted with adult HSC provided the highest levels of circulating donor cells, whereas fetal-derived stroma was less effective. In addition, ST cotransplantation resulted in increased donor cell engraftment in the BM and led to significantly increased levels of donor hematopoiesis for over 30 months after transplant. Cotransplantation of stroma may represent a valuable clinical strategy for optimal application of in utero HSC transplantation.

Prospects for in utero human gene therapy

Gene therapy for the treatment of disease in children and adults is being actively pursued at many medical centers. However, a number of genetic disorders result in irreversible damage to the fetus before birth. In these cases, as well as for those with genetic diseases who may benefit from therapy before symptoms are manifested, in utero gene therapy (IUGT) could be beneficial. Although some successes with in utero gene transfer have been reported in animals, significant questions remain to be answered before IUGT clinical trials would be acceptable. This review analyzes the state of the art and delineates the studies that still need to be performed before it would be appropriate to consider human IUGT.

Prenatal cellular transplantation

Based on the ontogeny of fetal immunologic development, the strategy of fetal cellular transplantation may prove to be the most physiological way to achieve replacement of abnormal hemoglobin, immune cells, or enzyme defects diagnosed early prenatally. Similarly, if cellular transplantation can induce tolerance, postnatal solid organ transplantation may be performed without the need for chronic immunosuppression or with a reduced risk of graft-versus-host disease. This review presents experimental data from the late 1940s until the present for both small and large animal models; it also describes the limited clinical experience with prenatal cellular transplantation.

Umbilical cord blood from preterm human fetuses is rich in committed and primitive hematopoietic progenitors with high proliferative and self-renewal capacity

Human umbilical cord blood (CB) has been recognized as a source of hematopoietic stem cells for transplantation. While hematopoietic properties of neonatal CB from full-term pregnancies have been well characterized, little is known about CB from early gestational ages. We analyzed the content and the growth properties of primitive and committed hematopoietic progenitors in preterm CB from second trimester (week 16-28; n = 17) and early third trimester (week 29-34; n = 17) in comparison with term CB (n = 18). The frequency of CD34+ and CD34+CD38- cells was significantly higher in preterm than in term CB (mean, 2.51% and 0.56% vs 0.88% and 0.13%;p < 0.002). The number of colony forming units (CFU) in preterm CB was about twofold higher (230 +/- 6 vs 133 +/- 14/ 10(5) mononuclear cells; p < 0.05) and correlated with the content of CD34+ progenitors (r = 0.73). Long-term culture initiating cells (LTC-IC) were enriched about 2.5-fold (6.7 +/- 2.9 vs 2.6 +/- 1.2/10(5) cells; p < 0.05). Progenitors from preterm CB could be expanded in stroma-free liquid cultures supplemented with hematopoietic growth factors as efficiently as progenitors from term neonates. In short-term cultures containing erythropoietin (Epo), interleukin (IL)-1, IL-3, and IL-6, or granulocyte- (G-) and granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF) together with stem cell factor (SCF) or Flt3 ligand (FL), expansion of CFUs was six- to eightfold at week 1. In long-term cultures containing thrombopoietin (TPO) and FL, an approximately 1000-fold expansion of multilineage progenitors was observed at week 10. In summary, we show that preterm CB compared with term CB is richer in hematopoietic progenitors, and that precursors from preterm CB can be extensively expanded ex vivo. This may have implications for the development of transplantation and gene transfer strategies targeting circulating fetal stem cells.

Deficient cellular immunity--finding and fixing the defects

The critical role of cellular immunity in resistance to infectious diseases is glaringly revealed by life-threatening infections if T cell function is disrupted by an inherited or acquired immunodeficiency. Although treatment has historically focused on infectious complications, understanding of the cellular and molecular basis of immunodeficiency and technologies useful for enhancing cellular immunity have both been rapidly evolving. A new era of molecular and cellular therapy is emerging as approaches to correct abnormal genes, the loss of T cell subpopulations, and aberrant T cell homeostasis make the transition from bench to bedside.

In utero hematopoietic stem cell transfer: current status and future strategies

Successful prenatal treatment of severe immunodeficiencies by allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplantation in utero has been reported. Though other diseases like hemoglobinopathies or storage diseases are potentially amenable to this novel therapeutic approach, no success has yet been achieved in recipients without severe immunodeficiency. Graft rejection by the developing fetus and/or lack of selective, competitive advantage of donor versus host stem cells preventing stable engraftment seem to be the major obstacles. Several strategies to overcome these hurdles are being explored in preclinical settings, including timing and repeated dosing of stem cell administration to the fetus, ex vivo modification of the transplant, using different fetal compartments as targets for early stem cell transfer, or inducing microchimerism for postnatal transplantation from the same donor. In addition, the exact definition of the basic concept of early fetal immunologic naivete and the understanding of the molecular basics of migration and homing in fetal hematopoiesis system seem mandatory for a successful approach. Gene therapy using ex vivo transduced autologous cord blood cells or direct gene targeting in utero are other potential means to correct hematopoietic and immunologic single gene disorders in utero, though this approach is still away from the stage of clinical trials.

Hematopoietic stem-cell transplantation for the treatment of severe combined immunodeficiency

BACKGROUND

Since 1968 it has been known that bone marrow transplantation can ameliorate severe combined immunodeficiency, but data on the long-term efficacy of this treatment are limited. We prospectively studied immunologic function in 89 consecutive infants with severe combined immunodeficiency who received hematopoietic stem-cell transplants at Duke University Medical Center between May 1982 and September 1998.

METHODS

Serum immunoglobulin levels and lymphocyte phenotypes and function were assessed and genetic analyses performed according to standard methods. Bone marrow was depleted of T cells by agglutination with soybean lectin and by sheep-erythrocyte rosetting before transplantation.

RESULTS

Seventy-seven of the infants received T-cell-depleted, HLA-haploidentical parental marrow, and 12 received HLA-identical marrow from a related donor; 3 of the recipients of haploidentical marrow also received placental-blood transplants from unrelated donors. Except for two patients who received placental blood, none of the recipients received chemotherapy before transplantation or prophylaxis against graft-versus-host disease. Of the 89 infants, 72 (81 percent) were still alive 3 months to 16.5 years after transplantation, including all of the 12 who received HLA-identical marrow, 60 of the 77 (78 percent) who were given haploidentical marrow, and 2 of the 3 (67 percent) who received both haploidentical marrow and placental blood. T-cell function became normal within two weeks after transplantation in the patients who received unfractionated HLA-identical marrow but usually not until three to four months after transplantation in those who received T-cell-depleted marrow. At the time of the most recent evaluation, all but 4 of the 72 survivors had normal T-cell function, and all the T cells in their blood were of donor origin. B-cell function remained abnormal in many of the recipients of haploidentical marrow. In 26 children (5 recipients of HLA-identical marrow and 21 recipients of haploidentical marrow) between 2 percent and 100 percent of B cells were of donor origin. Forty-five of the 72 children were receiving intravenous immune globulin.

CONCLUSIONS

Transplantation of marrow from a related donor is a life-saving and life-sustaining treatment for patients with any type of severe combined immunodeficiency, even when there is no HLA-identical donor.

In utero transplantation of human fetal haemopoietic cells in NOD/SCID mice

We have previously demonstrated that high levels of allogeneic, donor-derived mouse haemopoietic progenitor cells engraft following in utero transplantation in NOD/SCID mice. To evaluate whether the fetal NOD/SCID haemopoietic microenvironment supports the growth and development of human fetal haemopoietic progenitor cells, we injected fetal liver mononuclear cells (FL) or fetal bone marrow (FBM) derived CD34+ cells into NOD/SCID mice on day 13/14 of gestation. At 8 weeks of age 12% of FBM recipients and 10% of FL recipients were found to have been successfully engrafted with CD45+ human cells. CD45+ cells were present in the BM of all chimaeric animals; 5/6 recipients showed engraftment of the spleen, and 4/6 recipients had circulating human cells in the peripheral blood (PB). The highest levels of donor cells were found in the BM, with up to 15% of the nucleated cells expressing human specific antigens. Multilineage human haemopoietic engraftment, including B cells (CD19), myelomonocytic cells (CD13/33) and haemopoietic progenitor cells (CD34), was detected in the BM of chimaeric mice. In contrast, no human CD3+ cells were detected in any of the tissues evaluated. When the absolute number of engrafted human cells in the PB, BM and spleens of chimaeric mice was determined, a mean 16-fold expansion of human donor cells was observed. Although multilineage engraftment occurs in these fetal recipients, both the frequency and the levels of engraftment are lower than those previously reported when human cells are transplanted into adult NOD/SCID recipients.

In utero transplantation for thalassemia

In utero hematopoietic stem cell transplantation is a promising approach for the treatment of a variety of congenital hematologic diseases. Although the approach has been successful for immunodeficiency syndromes, attempts thus far to treat the hemoglobinopathies have failed. In most of these cases the late gestational age at transplantation, source of donor cells, or procedure-related complications, provide an explanation for failure. Nevertheless the biology of thalassemia, in the context of prenatal transplantation, requires examination. In contrast to postnatal bone marrow transplant regimens, engraftment after in utero transplantation requires donor cells to effectively complete for developing receptive sites in the recipient hematopoietic microenvironment. Effective prenatal treatment of thalassemia will depend on the ability of normal cells to engraft and complete in the thalassemic microenvironment. Clinical observations after bone marrow transplantation of amelioration of anemia in beta-thalassemia by relatively low degrees of mixed chimerism, and the apparent selective advantage observed for donor erythropoiesis, suggest prenatal transplantation could succeed. Prenatal strategies involving multiple transplants, donor-specific tolerance induction, and postnatal same-donor transplants should be considered.

Mutation analysis by a non-radioactive single-strand conformation polymorphism assay in nine families with X-linked severe combined immunodeficiency (SCIDX1)

X-linked severe combined immunodeficiency (SCIDX1) is an inherited disease characterized by profound abnormalities of cell-mediated and humoral immunity. Patients with SCIDX1 have defects in the common cytokine receptor gamma chain gene (IL2RG) that encodes a shared, essential component of the receptors for interleukin-2 (IL-2), IL-4, IL-7, IL-9 and IL-15. We have characterized nine SCIDX1 families by using a DNA-based, non-radioactive screening method and DNA sequencing. Nine different mutations were found, scattered from exon 1 to exon 5 of the IL2RG gene. Two of these mutations have been previously identified in other unrelated patients; the other seven are novel mutations that differ from all of the 95 already reported in the IL2RG mutation data base. In addition to describing novel mutations in the IL2RG gene, this study shows that the knowledge of the genetic defect and the use of an efficient, non-radioactive, and rapid screening approach have important implications for prenatal and postnatal diagnosis, carrier female identification, and possibly prenatal therapy.

Stem cell transplantation into the fetal recipient: challenges and prospects

The interest in therapeutic intervention for those inherited disorders that can be diagnosed early in pregnancy has recently intensified. In-utero transplantation of haematopoietic stem cells (IUT-HSC), a therapy which could be proffered before pathological manifestations of a disorder become apparent, offers considerable potential benefit. However, as reports of IUT-HSC procedures become more prolific, it is necessary to consider the optimum modus operandi for each group of disorders targeted for therapy in order to develop effective procedures that make a real difference to the outcome. This review outlines the current status and prospects of IUT-HSC. It also offers a view of some of the challenges for IUT-HSC to overcome to find wider clinical applications.

Microchimerism and tolerance following intrauterine transplantation and transfusion for alpha-thalassemia-1

A fetus homozygous for alpha-thalassemia-1 was given haploidentical paternal CD34 cells at 13, 19 and 24 weeks' gestation and supported through pregnancy by blood transfusion. The fetal hematocrit ranged between 27 and 47% and between one half and three quarters of this hemoglobin was of recipient (Bart's) type. Intrauterine growth proceeded normally and no significant fetal hydrops was detected. Tests for donor HLA antigens, and alpha-globin DNA, were negative on fetal blood samples drawn before birth. A positive signal for alpha-globin DNA was obtained from cord blood and from marrow obtained at 3 months of age, suggesting that some donor stem cells had persisted in the recipient. The infant's blood mononuclear cells showed little proliferative and no cytotoxic response to the donor while responses to a third party were present. Additional paternal CD34 cells given at 3 months age did not reduce transfusion dependency in the subsequent 6 months. Our results show that repeated transfusions can support an alpha-thalassemia-1 fetus through pregnancy, in this instance without significant birth defects or apparent hypoxic tissue injury. The donor stem cells did not have a survival advantage compared with endogenous stem cells, but appeared to survive in the recipient as judged by the persistence of an alpha-globin DNA signal. In vitro studies of alloreactivity suggest tolerization of the host to the donor's MHC disparity. Future efforts will focus on exploiting this tolerance to improve the level of donor chimerism.

Sustained Multilineage Engraftment of Allogeneic Hematopoietic Stem Cells in NOD/SCID Mice After In Utero Transplantation

Substantial barriers exist to the engraftment of hematopoietic cells in mice after in utero transplantation. Although high levels of donor-derived hematopoiesis have been reported in SCID mice, the majority of chimeric recipients exhibit decreasing levels of donor cells over time. To directly test whether the natural killer cell and macrophage activity of the recipients represents a barrier to sustained engraftment, fetal NOD/SCID mice were injected on day 13.5 of gestation with an enriched congenic hematopoietic progenitor cell population. Forty-four percent of pups showed the presence of Ly5.1+ donor cells 4 weeks after transplantation. The mean number of donor-derived nucleated cells in the peripheral blood (PB) was 30%. Although the majority of circulating donor cells were lymphocytes, up to 15% expressed myelomonocytic markers. Serial PB samples from individual mice indicated that the percentage of circulating donor cells increased from 17% to 55% between 4 and 24 weeks. At 6 months posttransplantation, an increased frequency of multilineage, donor-derived cells was also observed in the bone marrow (BM) and the spleen of chimeric recipients. The engraftment of pluripotent hematopoietic stem cells was evaluated by transplanting BM from chimeric mice into irradiated congenic recipients. Irradiated secondary recipients also exhibited multilineage donor-derived hematopoiesis in the PB, BM, and spleen for up to 6 months. These results show that the in utero transplantation of lineage-depleted BM cells into NOD/SCID recipients produces a high frequency of sustained engraftment of allogeneic hematopoietic stem cells.