Induction of self-tolerance in mature peripheral B lymphocytes

Signals from a self-antigen induce positive selection in early B cell ontogeny but are tolerogenic in adults

Positive and negative signals from self-Ags shape the B cell repertoire and the development of distinct B cell subsets, but little is known about what distinguishes these signals. To address this question, we have studied the development of anti-hen egg lysozyme MD4 Ig transgene B cells while systematically varying the level, distribution, and timing of exposure to different forms of hen egg lysozyme as a self-Ag. This process has allowed us to explore the effects of Ag independent of BCR specificity. Our findings show how the selection of autoreactive B cells is a competitive process involving immunogenic and tolerogenic forms of self-Ags. Due to a developmental switch during B cell ontogeny, autoreactive anti-hen egg lysozyme MD4 Ig transgene B cells are negatively selected by self-Ags in adult bone marrow but susceptible to positive selection by some of the same self-Ags in fetal and neonatal life. However, the persistence of B1 cells and IgM autoantibodies from early ontogeny enables autoreactive B cells from the adult bone marrow to escape negative selection. Our data suggest that this rescue may be due to the clearance or masking of self-Ag by IgM autoantibody. We discuss the implications of these findings in terms of B cell selection and the maintenance of self-tolerance during early and adult life.

B-cell tolerance

Autoreactive B cells are actively tolerized to more abundant self-antigens by a series of checkpoints involving receptor editing, deletion, anergy and competition for growth factors. In contrast, B cells reactive against rare, sequestered or tissue specific self-antigens remain functionally naïve. During an immune response, the autoimmune danger from these cells is countered by a variety of mechanisms comprising control of self-antigen presentation, limitation of immunogenic and tolerogenic costimuli including T cell help, homeostatic control of growth and strict regulation of germinal centre reactions. In this overview we consider how knowledge of these checkpoints may be used to gain a better understanding of transplant tolerance and the generation of alloantibodies.

Loss of the proapoptotic protein, Bim, breaks B cell anergy

Although B cells that respond with high avidity to self-antigen are eliminated early in their development, many autoreactive B cells escape elimination and are tolerized later in their lives via anergy. Anergic B cells are unresponsive to antigen and die prematurely. It has been suggested that the proapoptotic protein, Bim, controls the fate of anergic B cells. To test this idea, mice lacking Bim were crossed with mice that express soluble hen egg lysozyme and whose B cells bear receptors specific for the protein. In Bim^+/+ mice these B cells are anergic and die rapidly. If the mice lack Bim, however, the B cells live longer, are more mature, respond to antigen, and secrete anti–hen egg lysozyme antibodies. This break of tolerance is not due to expression of endogenous B cell receptors, nor is it dependent on T cells. Rather, it appears to be due to a reduced requirement for the cytokine BAFF. Normal B cells require BAFF both for differentiation and survival. Bim^−/− B cells, on the other hand, require BAFF only for differentiation. Therefore, autoreactive B cells are allowed to survive if they lack Bim and thus accumulate sufficient signals from differentiating factors to drive their maturation and production of autoantibodies.

B cells from aged mice exhibit reduced apoptosis upon B-cell antigen receptor stimulation and differential ability to up-regulate survival signals

During ageing, autoimmune disorders and the higher susceptibility to infectious have been associated with alterations in the humoral immune response. We report that splenic B lymphocytes from aged mice exhibit lower level of apoptosis induced by B-cell antigen receptor (BCR) ligation in vitro. Respect to B cells from young mice the anti-mu stimulated aged B cells show similar Bcl-2 and Bcl-xL expression but differential kinetic of A1 degradation and a higher level of cFLIP and FAIM. Even though B cells from aged mice show minor Fas expression they exhibit the same susceptibility to anti-Fas induced apoptosis. Aged B cells also present upon BCR stimulation, a higher proliferative response and similar level of activation markers expression than B cells from young mice. These data agree with the observation that aged mice exhibit an increment of T2 and mature B cell subset which rapidly enters cell cycle upon BCR engagement. The diminished apoptosis after activation in aged mice could compromise homeostatic mechanism allowing the persistence of self and non-self antigen specific B cells.

Development of Functional B Cells in a Line of SCID Mice with Transgenes Coding for Anti-Double-Stranded DNA Antibody

Deletion or inactivation of anti-self (DNA) B cells has been reported in non-autoimmune mice bearing Ig transgenes that code for Abs with specificity for dsDNA or ssDNA. However, we report a case in which anti-dsDNA B cells appear to escape both deletion and inactivation. We show that B cells (B220+IgM+) can develop in non-autoimmune SCID mice bearing two site-directed transgenes, 3H9(56R) and Vkappa8, that together code for an anti-dsDNA Ab. The B cells appear inactive, because the mice (56RVkappa8 SCID mice) generally lack serum Ig. However, 56RVkappa8 SCID mice are able to produce IgG Ab with specificity for dsDNA when they become "leaky" for T cells or are reconstituted with exogenous T cells from B cell-deficient JH-/- donors. Thus, anti-dsDNA B cells that escape deletion in 56RVkappa8 SCID mice appear fully functional and can differentiate, class switch, and give rise to IgG-producing cells in the presence of T cells and self-Ag.

Differing mechanisms of early and late B cell hyporesponsiveness induced by mixed chimerism

Mixed hematopoietic chimerism induced via nonmyeloablative bone marrow transplantation (BMT) leads to unresponsiveness of anti-Gal alpha1,3Gal beta1,4G1cNAc (Gal) natural antibody (NAb)-producing cells in alpha1,3-galactosyltransferase deficient (GalT(-/-)) mice. We analyzed the mechanisms of anti-Gal-producing B cell unresponsiveness induced by Gal(+/+) BMT. C57BL/6 (B6) GalT(-/-) mice received 3Gy whole-body irradiation and BMT from B6-CD45 congenic mice. BMT led to marked reductions in serum anti-Gal IgM levels and in the numbers of splenic anti-Gal-producing cells by 2 weeks post-BMT. B cells with anti-Gal Ig receptors were present in the spleens of 2-week but not 12-week chimeras. In vitro studies and adoptive transfer studies using B6 GalT(-/-)B cell-deficient recipients showed that B cell hyporesponsiveness to Gal at 2 weeks, but not 12 weeks, depended on persistent Gal antigen. Thus, pre-existing B-1 cells are anergic when there is continuous exposure to Gal, whereas long-term unresponsiveness does not require persistent antigen, implicating clonal deletion and/or receptor editing. These results have implications for the potential use of mixed hematopioetic chimerism as an approach to performing organ transplantation in recipients with pre-existing anti-donor IgM antibodies.

Maintenance of B cell anergy requires constant antigen receptor occupancy and signaling

Immunological tolerance can be mediated by anergy, in which self-reactive B cells persist in the periphery yet remain unresponsive to immunogen. Whether anergy is induced after transient exposure to self antigen and is 'remembered' or requires continuous antigen receptor occupancy and transduction of signals remains unclear. We have explored this using an immunoglobulin-transgenic mouse in which B cells were hapten specific (arsonate) yet cross-reacted with a self antigen that induced anergy in vivo. Many features of anergic cells were rapidly reversed after dissociation of self antigen using hapten competition and these cells regained antigen responsiveness. Our findings indicate that continuous binding of antigen and subsequent receptor signaling are essential for the maintenance of anergy.

Dwindling competition with constant demand: Can homeostatic adjustments explain age-associated changes in peripheral B cell selection?

The close relationship between specificity-based selection and homeostatic processes in maintaining peripheral B cell pools has become increasingly evident. Thus, age-associated changes observed within these pools may reflect homeostatic responses to proximal primary lesions. Marked shifts in the size and dynamics of most B lymphocyte subsets and their progenitors occur with age: perturbations in B lineage precursors result in reduced production of immature B lymphocytes in the bone marrow and transitional pools in the periphery, but these effects appear to be offset by compensatory homeostatic processes at the marrow-periphery interface. We propose a model whereby these "distal" homeostatic adjustments relax the stringency of specificity based selection, affording a potential explanation for the increased frequency of autoreactive specificities with age.

The influence of effector T cells and Fas ligand on lupus-associated B cells

Circulating autoantibodies against dsDNA and chromatin are a characteristic of systemic lupus erythematosus in humans and many mouse models of this disease. B cells expressing these autoantibodies are normally regulated in nonautoimmune-prone mice but are induced to secrete Abs following T cell help. Likewise, anti-chromatin autoantibody production is T cell-dependent in Fas/Fas ligand (FasL)-deficient (lpr/lpr or gld/gld) mice. In this study, we demonstrate that Th2 cells promote anti-chromatin B cell survival and autoantibody production in vivo. FasL influences the ability of Th2 cells to help B cells, as Th2-gld/gld cells support higher titers of anti-chromatin Abs than their FasL-sufficient counterparts and promote anti-chromatin B cell participation in germinal centers. Th1 cells induce anti-chromatin B cell germinal centers regardless of FasL status; however, their ability to stimulate anti-chromatin Ab production positively correlates with their level of IFN-gamma production. This distinction is lost if FasL-deficient T cells are used: Th1-gld/gld cells promote significant titers of anti-chromatin Abs regardless of IFN-gamma production levels. Thus, FasL from effector T cells plays an important role in determining the fate of anti-chromatin B cells.

Analysis of RAG expression by peripheral blood CD5+ and CD5- B cells of patients with childhood systemic lupus erythematosus

BACKGROUND

The assembly of immunoglobulin genes during B cell development in the bone marrow is dependent on the expression of recombination activating genes (RAG) 1 and 2. Recently, RAG expression in peripheral blood IgD+ B cells outside the bone marrow has been demonstrated and is associated with the development of autoimmune diseases.

OBJECTIVE

To investigate RAG expression in the CD5+ or CD5- IgD+ B cell compartment in childhood systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE).

METHODS

Using a combination of flow cytometric cell sorting and reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction analysis of cDNA libraries generated from individual cells, the expression of RAG, VpreB, and CD154 mRNA by individual peripheral blood B cells of three paediatric SLE patients was examined in detail.

RESULTS

While only one patient had a significantly increased frequency of RAG+ B cells in the CD5- B cell population, all patients showed higher frequencies of RAG+ B cells in the CD5+IgD+ B cell population. The frequency of RAG+ IgD+CD5+/- B cells was reduced during intravenous cyclophosphamide treatment. In healthy age matched children, RAG expressing IgD+ B cells were hardly detectable. Coexpression of RAG and VpreB or CD154 mRNA could only be found in SLE B cells.

CONCLUSIONS

RAG expression in peripheral blood B cells of SLE patients is particularly increased in the IgD+CD5+ B cell population. CD5+ and CD5- B cells in SLE have the potential to undergo receptor revision leading to the generation of high affinity pathogenic autoantibodies.

Enumeration and characterization of virus-specific B cells by multicolor flow cytometry

To better characterize B cell responses induced to influenza virus, we developed an assay to directly quantify and characterize virus-specific B cells. We used purified and biotinylated whole virus as well as the major influenza virus surface antigen, hemagglutinin (HA) to label virus-specific B cells induced by immunization of mice with whole influenza virus in adjuvant. Immunization with adjuvant alone caused non-specific binding of whole virus to a large number of B cells in the draining lymph nodes as assessed by flow cytometry. This precluded the use of whole virus as a specific staining reagent. In contrast, staining with bromelain-cleaved purified and biotinylated influenza virus HA identified a small population of B cells (roughly 1%) only in the draining lymph nodes of virus-immunized mice. FACS-purification and subsequent ELISPOT analysis showed that HA-labeled B cells contained the vast majority of virus-specific antibody-secreting cells at day 10 after immunization. Overall, virus-specific antibody-secreting cells comprised roughly 10% of the HA-labeled cells. Using HA-staining in conjunction with 8-color flow cytometry we further demonstrated that close to 90% of the HA-labeled cells were CD19+ IgD- CD23- CD24high CD38low germinal center B cells, many of which had incorporated bromodeoxyuridine, indicating recent cell division in vivo. We conclude that viral HA can be used in conjunction with cell surface and intracytoplasmic stains in multicolor flow cytometry to provide detailed phenotypic and functional information on virus HA-specific B cells.

Epstein-Barr virus LMP2A alters in vivo and in vitro models of B-cell anergy, but not deletion, in response to autoantigen

A significant percentage of the population latently harbors Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) in B cells. One EBV-encoded protein, latent membrane protein 2A (LMP2A), is expressed in tissue culture models of EBV latent infection, in human infections, and in many of the EBV-associated proliferative disorders. LMP2A constitutively activates proteins involved in the B-cell receptor (BCR) signal transduction cascade and inhibits the antigen-induced activation of these proteins. In the present study, we investigated whether LMP2A alters B-cell receptor signaling in primary B cells in vivo and in vitro. LMP2A does not inhibit antigen-induced tolerance in response to strong stimuli in an in vivo tolerance model in which B cells are reactive to self-antigen. In contrast, LMP2A bypasses anergy induction in response to low levels of soluble hen egg lysozyme (HEL) both in vivo and in vitro as determined by the ability of LMP2A-expressing HEL-specific B cells to proliferate and induce NF-kappaB nuclear translocation after exposure to low levels of antigen. Furthermore, LMP2A induces NF-kappaB nuclear translocation independent of BCR cross-linking. Since NF-kappaB is required to bypass tolerance induction, this LMP2A-dependent NF-kappaB activation may complete the tolerogenic signal induced by low levels of soluble HEL. Overall, the findings suggest that LMP2A may not inhibit BCR-induced signals under all conditions as previously suggested by studies with EBV immortalized B cells.

Tumor-induced antibodies resemble the response to tissue damage

Tumor-associated antibodies are frequently detected in cancer patients. To ask whether the recognized antigens are rejection antigens, we screened a cDNA expression library of the mouse TS/A tumor with TS/A-immune serum and isolated 8 IgG-reactive clones, representing self-antigens that were expressed in normal tissues and other tumor lines. Three of the antigens had previously been identified in the human system by this cloning strategy. None of the antigens revealed to be a rejection antigen in normal mice demonstrated by an otherwise effective plasmid immunization. For one of the identified antigens, alpha-catenin, it is shown that the induction of IgG antibodies by protein immunization does not correlate with tumor rejection. For another antigen, vimentin, it is shown that vimentin-deficient but not vimentin-competent mice reject vimentin-expressing tumors indicating T -cell tolerance despite the fact that tumor cell immunization induces antivimentin IgG antibodies. Tissue damage induced by adenovirus infection induced an antibody response similar to tumor cell immunization, exemplified with 2 of the antigens. We conclude that the tumor-induced antibodies mirror tissue damage and that the antibody-inducing antigens can serve as rejection antigens if they are recognized as foreign.

Lower levels of surface B-cell-receptor expression in chronic lymphocytic leukemia are associated with glycosylation and folding defects of the μ and CD79a chains

Low levels of B-cell-receptor (BCR) expression are the hallmark of tumoral B lymphocytes in B-cell chronic lymphocytic leukemia (B-CLL). These cells also respond inadequately to stimulation through the BCR. This receptor consists of a surface immunoglobulin associated with a CD79a/CD79b heterodimer. We previously showed that the intracellular synthesis of BCR components, from transcription onward, is normal. Here, we investigated the glycosylation status and cellular localization of μ, CD79a, and CD79b chains in 10 CLL patients differing in surface immunoglobulin M (IgM) expression. We reported a severe impairment of the glycosylation and folding of μ and CD79a. These defects were associated with the retention of both chains in the endoplasmic reticulum and lower levels of surface IgM expression. In contrast, no clear impairment of glycosylation and folding was observed for CD79b. No sequence defects were identified for BCR components and for the chaperone proteins involved in BCR folding processes. These data show, for the first time, that lower levels of BCR surface expression observed in CLL are accounted for by an impaired glycosylation and folding of the μ and CD79a chains.

On 'reactivity' versus 'tolerance'

In Burnet's review on 'The impact of ideas on immunology' he considers himself an observer of nature using biochemical and molecular analysis for more detailed understanding, a description that applies also to me. I use three examples--repertoire selection of T cells, rules of immune reactivity versus non-reactivity and immunological memory--to illustrate the difficulties we all have in probing nature's immunological secrets and in critically testing immunologists' ideas. At one end of the spectrum of biological research one may argue everything is possible and therefore all results are correct, if correctly measured. But perhaps it is more important to always ask again and again what is frequent and enhances survival versus what is rare and an exception. At the same time one must keep in mind that special situations and special tricks may well be applied for medical benefits, although they may have little impact on physiology and species survival. I will attempt to use disease in virus-infected mice to obtain some answers to what I consider to be important immunological questions with the hope of improving the ratio of answers that are right for the right experimental reasons versus those that are right for the wrong reasons. Some of these experiments falsify hypotheses, previous experiments and interpretations and therefore are particularly important in correcting misleading concepts. They should help to find out which half of immunological ideas and truths in immunological text books written today are likely to be wrong. Ideas are important in immunology, but are often rather demagogically handled and therefore may cost us very dearly indeed. Evaluating immunity to infections and tumours in vivo should help prevent us from getting lost in immunology.

Development of B cells producing natural autoantibodies to thymocytes and senescent erythrocytes

Natural antibodies produced by CD5+ B-1 B cells include those with specificity for senescent erythrocytes (anti-BrMRBC, anti-PtC) and for thymocytes (anti-thymocyte autoantibody, ATA). Here we describe work from our laboratories studying two prototypic examples, V(H)11Vkappa9-encoded anti-BrMRBC and V(H)3609Vkappa21c-encoded ATA. Using V(H)11-mu transgenic mice, we discovered that certain natural autoantibodies utilize V(H) genes that are selected against in bone marrow B cell development, but not fetal liver, effectively restricting their generation to fetal/neonatal life. Studies with ATA-mu transgenic mice demonstrated a critical requirement for self antigen in the accumulation of B cells with this specificity and for the production of high levels of serum ATA. Finally, analysis of B cell development in ATA-mu kappa transgenic mice revealed two distinct responses by B cells to expression of this B cell receptor (BCR): most developing B cells in spleen of adult mice were blocked at an immature stage and only escaped apoptosis by editing their BCR to eliminate the ATA specificity; nevertheless, high levels of serum ATA were observed, indicating that some B cells differentiated to antibody-forming cells without altering their specificity. Thus, our studies reveal mechanisms for restricting the generation of B cells producing natural autoantibodies, demonstrate a key positive selection step in their development, and show that most developing B cells in adult mice bearing such specificities fail to reach a mature stage.

Induction of autoantibody production but not autoimmune disease in HEL transgenic mice vaccinated with HEL in combination with CpG or control oligodeoxynucleotides

CpG oligodeoxynucleotides (ODN) are synthetic DNA sequences that mimic bacterial DNA, and bind to the TLR9 receptor. The cells that express TLR9, B cells and dendritic cells, are stimulated by CpG ODN and induce innate and acquired immune responses. Because CpG ODN induce antigen-independent immune activation there has been much interest in the possibility that they may break self tolerance. To test this hypothesis we used a tolerance model with hen egg lysozyme (HEL)-transgenic (Tg) mice, anti-HEL Ig-Tg mice and double (Dbl)-Tg mice injected with CpG ODN alone or together with HEL self antigen. When cultured in vitro, tolerant B cells responded to CpG ODN in a similar way as the non-tolerant Ig-Tg B cells in terms of cell proliferation, NFkappaB activation and CD69 expression. Despite these potent in vitro stimulatory effects of CpG ODN alone, HEL-Tg mice injected with CpG ODN alone, or in combination with low dose antigen (4 microg HEL), surprisingly did not produce any detectable anti-HEL Ab. However, HEL-Tg or Dbl-Tg mice immunized with CpG ODN plus higher doses of self antigen showed strong antigen-specific humoral responses. Surprisingly, control non-CpG ODN also had partial activity for breaking tolerance and inducing autoantibody production when administered in combination with self antigen, though not when used alone. Despite the production of high titers of anti-HEL Ab in the immunized HEL-Tg mice, no evidence of autoimmune disease was detected. We conclude that immunization with CpG or control ODN in the presence of a high dose of exogenous self antigen, but not treatment with ODN alone, can break tolerance to self antigen without inducing autoimmune disease in this system.

Peripheral B lymphocyte tolerance

This lecture discusses two interrelated topics, B cell tolerance in the peripheral immune system and BAFF. Using the 3-83 antibody transgenic mouse bred to mice carrying cognate antigen in the liver, we previously found that clonal elimination drastically reduced the precursor frequency of autoreactive cells. The consensus model to explain this tolerance is the 2-signal hypothesis, which proposes that in the absence of T cell help BCR stimulation is a negative signal for B cells. However, this model fails to explain how these same B cells can respond to T-independent type II (TI-2) antigens, raising the question of how they distinguish TI-2 antigens from multimeric self determinants. We propose that B cells use NK-like missing self recognition to provide the needed specificity, as foreign antigens are unlikely to carry self markers. The model has implications for the evolution of the immune system, B lymphocyte signaling, tissue specificity of autoimmunity, and microbial subversion of the immune system. Overexpression of the critical B cell survival cytokine BAFF/BLyS has been associated with autoimmunity. We have discovered a novel splice isoform that regulates BAFF activity and may play a role in limiting B cell activity. The novel form, called DBAFF, is able to heteromultimerize with normal BAFF and can suppress receptor binding and proteolytic release from the cell surface. Preliminary studies from transgenic mice overexpressing wild type or DBAFF are consistent with a possible regulatory role for DBAFF, raising the possibility that the relative expression levels of BAFF and DBAFF regulates tolerance.

Specificity-Based Negative Selection of Autoreactive B Cells during Memory Formation

Autoreactive B cells are not completely purged from the primary B cell repertoire, and whether they can be prevented from maturation into memory B cells has been uncertain. We show here that a population of B cells that dominates primary immune responses of BALB/c mice to influenza virus A/PR/8/34 hemagglutinin (HA) are negatively selected in transgenic mice expressing PR8 HA as an abundant membrane-bound Ag (HACII mice). However, a separate population of B cells that contains precursors of memory B cells is activated by PR8 virus immunization and is subsequently negatively selected during the formation of the memory response. Negative selection of PR8 HA-specific B cells altered the specificity of the memory B cell response to a mutant virus containing a single amino acid substitution in a B cell epitope. Strikingly, this skewed reactivity resulted from an increase in the formation of memory B cells directed to non-self-epitopes on the mutant virus, which increased 8-fold in HACII mice relative to nontransgenic mice and precisely compensated for the absence of autoreactive PR8 HA-specific memory B cells. Negative selection of PR8 HA-specific B cells was a dominant process, since B cells from HACII mice could induce negative selection of PR8 HA-specific B cells from BALB/c mice. Lastly, HA-specific memory responses were unaffected by self-tolerance in another lineage of HA-transgenic mice (HA104 mice), indicating that the amount and/or cell type in which self-Ags are expressed can determine their ability to prevent autoreactive memory B cell formation.

Affinity-dependent alterations of mouse B cell development by noninherited maternal antigen

We have examined the passage of maternal cells into the fetus during the gestation and postpartum in mice. Using enhanced green fluorescent protein (EGFP)-transgenic females, we showed that maternal cells frequently gain access to the fetus, mostly in syngeneic pregnancies, but also in allogeneic and outbred crosses. EGFP-transgenic cells, including B, T, and natural killer cells, can persist until adulthood, primarily in bone marrow and thymus. We then asked whether maternal cells, bearing antigens not inherited by the fetus, influence the development of fetal and neonatal B lymphocytes. We have used the B cell receptor 3-83 mu/delta transgenic mouse model, whose B cells recognize the major histocompatibility complex class I molecules H-2Kk and H-2Kb, with a high or moderate affinity, respectively. The fate of transgenic B cells in animals exposed to noninherited H-2Kk or H-2Kb maternal antigens (NIMA) during gestation and lactation was compared with those of nonexposed controls. In H-2Kk-exposed fetuses, NIMA-specific transgenic B cells are partially deleted during late gestation. Nondeleted cells have downmodulated their B cell receptor. In contrast, in NIMA H-2Kb-exposed neonates, transgenic B cells present an activated phenotype, including proliferation, upregulation of surface CD69, and preferential localization in the T cell zone of splenic follicles. This state of activation is still clearly detectable up to 3 wk of age. Thus, we show that fetal and neonatal B cell development is affected by maternal cells bearing antigens noninherited by the fetus and that this phenomenon is highly dependent on the affinity of the B cell receptor for the NIMA.

Selection during development of VH11+ B cells: a model for natural autoantibody-producing CD5+ B cells

Natural autoantibodies constitute a large portion of serum immunoglobulin M (IgM) and bridge the adaptive and innate immune systems, serving as a rapid response to common pathogens. Many arise from a distinctive subset of B cells, termed B-1, that express CD5. Here, we describe our studies with a representative CD5+ B-cell-derived natural autoantibody, the VH11Vkappa9 B-cell receptor (BCR) that binds a determinant on senescent erythrocytes. This specificity represents 5-10% of the CD5+ B-cell subset, with a large portion accounted for by two novel BCRs, VH11Vkappa9 and VH12Vkappa4. We have found that the development of B-lineage cells with a VH11 rearrangement is surprisingly restricted at several crucial bottlenecks: (i). one of the most common VH11 rearrangements generates a heavy-chain protein that only inefficiently assembles a pre-BCR, key for recombinase-activating gene downregulation/allelic exclusion and pre-B-clonal expansion; (ii). cells containing VH11- micro chains lacking N-addition are favored for progression to the B-cell stage, eliminating most bone marrow VH11 rearrangements; and (iii). only a subset of Vkappa-light chains combine with VH11 heavy chain to foster progression to the mature B-cell stage. Together, these constrain VH11 generation to fetal development and may favor production of B cells with the prototype VH11Vkappa9 BCR.

The V(lambda)-J(lambda) repertoire of patients with systemic lupus erythematosus manifests characteristics of the natural antibody repertoire

OBJECTIVE

To understand in detail the mechanisms of autoantibody production in patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE), we performed a comprehensive analysis of the normal human immunoglobulin light chain V(lambda) repertoire and compared it with the V(lambda) repertoire in SLE patients.

METHODS

The SLE V(lambda) repertoire of B cells obtained from 3 SLE patients was analyzed and compared in detail with the V(lambda) repertoire of IgM+ B cells obtained from 3 human fetal spleens and IgM+,CD5+ B cells obtained from 2 normal adults. Conventional IgM+,CD5- B cells obtained from normal adults were used as controls. V(lambda)-J(lambda) rearrangements were amplified from the genomic DNA of individual B cells by polymerase chain reaction.

RESULTS

The expressed V(lambda) repertoire of SLE patients contained several similarities with the expressed repertoire of the fetus and the adult CD5+ B cells. The V(lambda) genes 3L and 1G were overexpressed in the fetus, the adult CD5+ B cells, and the patients with SLE. The selection for rearrangements with restricted junctional diversity by utilization of homology-mediated joining, together with diminished N nucleotide addition, was a prominent feature of fetal, adult CD5+, and SLE B cell repertoires. Furthermore, profound expansion of V(lambda) clones with identical third complementarity-determining regions was observed in the adult CD5+, fetal, and SLE B cell repertoires. Notably, significant numbers of expanded adult CD5+ B cells, fetal, and SLE V(lambda) clones utilized homology-mediated joining at the V(lambda)-J(lambda) junctions.

CONCLUSION

These data demonstrate that the SLE V(lambda)-J(lambda) repertoire manifests characteristics of normal adult IgM+,CD5+ and fetal B cell populations that are known to be enriched for the production of natural autoantibodies.

Editing anti-DNA B cells by Vlambdax

Receptor editing is performed by replacement of Vkappa genes that contribute to autoreactivity. In addition, the Ckappa locus can be deleted by Vkappa rearrangement to intronic or 3' of Ckappa RS sequences (also referred to as kappa deletion elements). B cells that delete the Ckappa can then express lambda light chains. However, the lambda locus, either of man or mouse, does not allow V gene replacement. Nor does it appear to be deleted. Therefore, editing of autoreactive lambda B cells may require alternative pathways. We have found that in anti-DNA heavy chain transgenic mice (tgs) VH3H9/56R, B cells that express anti-DNA receptors comprised of lambda1 in association with an anti-DNA heavy chain often coexpress a kappa chain that prevents DNA binding. We speculate that such isotypically included cells may have low anti-DNA receptor densities, a feature that may lead to self-tolerance. Here we describe a mechanism of preventing DNA binding by expression of a rarely used member of the Vlambda family, Vlambdax. The lambdax B cells of the tgs also express CD25 and may represent B cells that have exhausted light chain editing possibilities.

Requirements for follicular exclusion and competitive elimination of autoantigen-binding B cells

Results from several mouse tolerance models indicate that autoreactive B cells in peripheral lymphoid organs develop an anergic phenotype, migrate to the boundary between the T cell zone and the B cell follicle (T/B boundary), and undergo rapid cell death. We have used B cells from mice that are double-transgenic for soluble hen egg lysozyme (HEL) and an Ig that recognizes HEL with a high affinity to characterize the mechanisms underlying the migration and elimination of autoreactive B cells. In contrast to the situation for acutely activated B cells, we find that anergic B cells have reduced levels of CXCR5, the receptor for the follicular chemokine, CXCL13, and this contributes to their exclusion from follicles. CCR7 expression is required for follicular exclusion of anergic cells, although up-regulation of the receptor does not appear to be necessary. By TUNEL analysis, we observe that excluded anergic cells die in situ at the T/B boundary. We also show that this elimination occurs via a Fas-independent mechanism. Using CCR7(-/-)Ig(HEL)-transgenic B cells we find that localization to the T/B boundary is not a necessary event to achieve the competitive elimination of autoantigen-binding B cells. These findings characterize the mechanism for follicular exclusion of autoantigen-binding B cells and they indicate that B cells compete for survival by mechanisms that are separate from competition for the follicular niche.

B cell selection defects underlie the development of diabetogenic APCs in nonobese diabetic mice

One mechanism whereby B cells contribute to type 1 diabetes in nonobese diabetic (NOD) mice is as a subset of APCs that preferentially presents MHC class II-bound pancreatic beta cell Ags to autoreactive CD4 T cells. This results from their ability to use cell surface Ig to specifically capture beta cell Ags. Hence, we postulated a diabetogenic role for defects in the tolerance mechanisms normally blocking the maturation and/or activation of B cells expressing autoreactive Ig receptors. We compared B cell tolerance mechanisms in NOD mice with nonautoimmune strains by using the IgHEL and Ig3-83 transgenic systems, in which the majority of B cells recognize one defined Ag. NOD- and nonautoimmune-prone mice did not differ in ability to delete or receptor edit B cells recognizing membrane-bound self Ags. However, in contrast to the nonautoimmune-prone background, B cells recognizing soluble self Ags in NOD mice did not undergo partial deletion and were also not efficiently anergized. The defective induction of B cell tolerance to soluble autoantigens is most likely responsible for the generation of diabetogenic APC in NOD mice.

Severely impaired B lymphocyte proliferation, survival, and induction of the c-Myc:Cullin 1 ubiquitin ligase pathway resulting from CD22 deficiency on the C57BL/6 genetic background

Understanding the molecular mechanisms through which CD22 regulates B lymphocyte homeostasis, signal transduction, and tolerance is critical to defining normal B cell function and understanding the role of CD22 in autoimmunity. Therefore, CD22 function was examined in vivo and in vitro using B cells from CD22-deficient (CD22(-/-)) mice. Backcrossing of founder CD22(-/-) mice onto the C57BL/6 (B6) genetic background from a B6/129 mixed background resulted in a dramatically reduced B cell proliferative response following IgM ligation, characterized by a paucity of lymphoblasts and augmented apoptosis. Also, the phenotype of splenic B6 CD22(-/-) B cells was uniquely HSA(high) and IgD(low)/CD21(low) with intermediate levels of CD5 expression, although the percentages of mature and transitional B cells were normal. That B6 CD22(-/-) B cells predominantly underwent apoptosis following IgM ligation correlated with this unique tolerant phenotype, as well as defective induction of the c-Myc:Cullin 1 (CUL1) ubiquitin ligase pathway that is necessary for progression to the S phase of cell cycle. CD40 ligation compensated for CD22 deficiency by restoring lymphoblast development, proliferation, c-Myc and CUL1 expression, and protein ubiquitination/degradation in IgM-stimulated B6 CD22(-/-) B cell cultures. Thereby, this study expands our current understanding of the complex role of CD22 during B cell homeostasis and Ag responsiveness, and reveals that the impact of CD22 deficiency is dictated by the genetic background on which it is rendered. Moreover, this study defines CD22 and CD40 as the first examples of lymphocyte coreceptors that influence induction of the c-Myc:CUL1 ubiquitin ligase pathway.

Excess BAFF Rescues Self-Reactive B Cells from Peripheral Deletion and Allows Them to Enter Forbidden Follicular and Marginal Zone Niches

The role of BAFF in B cell self tolerance was examined by tracking the fate of anti-HEL self-reactive B cells in BAFF transgenic mice using four different models of self-reactive B cell deletion. BAFF overexpression did not affect the development of self-reactive B cells normally deleted in the bone marrow or during the early stages of peripheral development. By contrast, self-reactive B cells normally deleted around the late T2 stage of peripheral development were rescued from deletion, matured, and colonized the splenic follicle. Furthermore, self-reactive B cells normally selectively deleted from the marginal zone repopulated this compartment when excess BAFF was present. Self-reactive B cells rescued by excess BAFF were not anergic. BAFF overexpression therefore rescued only self-reactive B cells normally deleted with relatively low stringency and facilitated their migration into otherwise forbidden microenvironments. This partial subversion of B cell self tolerance is likely to underlie the autoimmunity associated with BAFF overexpression.

A B cell receptor with two Igalpha cytoplasmic domains supports development of mature but anergic B cells

B cell receptor (BCR) signaling is mediated through immunoglobulin (Ig)alpha and Igbeta a membrane-bound heterodimer. Igalpha and Igbeta are redundant in their ability to support early B cell development, but their roles in mature B cells have not been defined. To examine the function of Igalpha-Igbeta in mature B cells in vivo we exchanged the cytoplasmic domain of Igalpha for the cytoplasmic domain of Igbeta by gene targeting (Igbetac-->alphac mice). Igbetac-->alphac B cells had lower levels of surface IgM and higher levels of BCR internalization than wild-type B cells. The mutant B cells were able to complete all stages of development and were long lived, but failed to differentiate into B1a cells. In addition, Igbetac-->alphac B cells showed decreased proliferative and Ca2+ responses to BCR stimulation in vitro, and were anergic to T-independent and -dependent antigens in vivo.

Transgenic Expression of a Human Polyreactive Ig Expressed in Chronic Lymphocytic Leukemia Generates Memory-Type B Cells That Respond to Nonspecific Immune Activation

We generated transgenic mice, designated SMI, expressing unmutated H and L chain Ig genes encoding a low-affinity, polyreactive human (h)IgM/kappa rheumatoid factor. These animals were compared with control AB29 transgenic mice expressing a hIgM/kappa rheumatoid factor specific for human IgG, with no detectable reactivity with mouse proteins. SMI B cells expressed significantly lower levels of surface hIgM/kappa than did the B cells of AB29 mice, but still could be induced to proliferate by surface Ig cross-linking in vitro and could be deleted with anti-Id mAb in vivo. Transgene-expressing B cells of AB29 mice had a B-2 phenotype and were located in the primary follicle. In contrast, a relatively high proportion of hIgM-expressing B cells of SMI mice had the phenotype of B-1 B cells in the peritoneum or marginal zone B cells in the spleen, where they were located in the periarteriolar sheath, marginal zone, and interfollicular areas that typically are populated by memory-type B cells. Although the relative proportions of transgene-expressing B cells in both types of transgenic mice declined with aging, SMI mice experienced progressive increases in the serum levels of IgM transgene protein over time. Finally, SMI transgene-expressing B cells, but not AB29 transgene-expressing B cells, were induced to secrete Ab when cultured with alloreactive T cells. These results indicate that expression of polyreactive autoantibodies can allow for development of B cells that are neither deleted nor rendered anergic, but instead have a phenotype of memory-type or Ag-experienced B cells that respond to nonspecific immune activation.

The cellular location of self-antigen determines the positive and negative selection of autoreactive B cells

Systemic autoimmune disease is frequently characterized by the production of autoantibodies against widely expressed intracellular self-antigens, whereas B cell tolerance to ubiquitous and highly expressed extracellular antigens is strictly enforced. To test for differences in the B cell response to intracellular and extracellular self-antigens, we sequestered a tolerogenic cell surface antigen intracellularly by addition of a two amino acid endoplasmic reticulum (ER) retention signal. In contrast to cell surface antigen, which causes the deletion of autoreactive B cells, the intracellularly sequestered self-antigen failed to induce B cell tolerance and was instead autoimmunogenic. The intracellular antigen positively selected antigen-binding B cells to differentiate into B1 cells and induced large numbers of IgM autoantibody-secreting plasma cells in a T-independent manner. By analyzing the impact of differences in subcellular distribution independently from other variables, such as B cell receptor affinity, antigen type, or tissue distribution, we have established that intracellular localization of autoantigen predisposes for autoantibody production. These findings help explain why intracellular antigens are targeted in systemic autoimmune diseases.

Tolerance through indifference: autoreactive B cells to the nuclear antigen La show no evidence of tolerance in a transgenic model

Systemic autoimmune diseases are characterized by the production of high titer autoantibodies specific for ubiquitous nuclear self-Ags such as DNA, Sm, and La (SS-B), so the normal mechanisms of B cell tolerance to disease-associated nuclear Ags have been of great interest. Mechanisms of B cell tolerance include deletion, anergy, developmental arrest, receptor editing, and B cell differentiation to the B-1 subtype. However, recent studies in our laboratory have suggested that B cell tolerance to the nuclear autoantigen La is limited in normal mice, and tolerance may reside primarily in the T cell compartment. To test this hypothesis, we created Ig transgenic mice expressing the IgM H chain from an mAb specific for a xenogeneic epitope within human La (hLa). These mice were bred with hLa-transgenic mice that constitutively express hLa in a manner comparable to endogenous mouse La. Between 5-15% of transgenic B cells developing in the absence of hLa were specific for hLa, and these cells were neither depleted nor developmentally arrested in the presence of endogenous hLa expression. Instead, these autoreactive B cells matured normally and differentiated into Ab-forming cells, capable of secreting high titer autoantibody. Additionally, the life span of autoreactive hLa-specific B cells was not reduced, and they were phenotypically and functionally indistinguishable from naive nonautoreactive hLa-specific B cells developing in the absence of hLa. Together these data suggest a lack of intrinsic B cell tolerance involving any known mechanisms indicating that these autoreactive B cells are indifferent to their autoantigen.

B-cell antigen-receptor signalling in lymphocyte development

Signalling through the B-cell antigen receptor (BCR) is required throughout B-cell development and peripheral maturation. Targeted disruption of BCR components or downstream effectors indicates that specific signalling mechanisms are preferentially required for central B-cell development, peripheral maturation and repertoire selection. Additionally, the avidity and the context in which antigen is encountered determine both cell fate and differentiation in the periphery. Although the signalling and receptor components required at each stage have been largely elucidated, the molecular mechanisms through which specific signalling are evoked at each stage are still obscure. In particular, it is not known how the pre-BCR initiates the signals required for normal development or how immature B cells regulate the signalling pathways that determine cell fate. In this review, we will summarize the recent studies that have defined the molecules required for B-cell development and maturation as well as the theories on how signals may be regulated at each stage.

Loss of the pro-apoptotic BH3-only Bcl-2 family member Bim inhibits BCR stimulation-induced apoptosis and deletion of autoreactive B cells

During development, the stochastic process assembling the genes encoding antigen receptors invariably generates B and T lymphocytes that can recognize self-antigens. Several mechanisms have evolved to prevent the activation of these cells and the concomitant development of autoimmune disease. One such mechanism is the induction of apoptosis in developing or mature B cells by engagement of the B cell antigen receptor (BCR) in the absence of T cell help. Here we report that B lymphocytes lacking the pro-apoptotic Bcl-2 family member Bim are refractory to apoptosis induced by BCR ligation in vitro. The loss of Bim also inhibited deletion of autoreactive B cells in vivo in two transgenic systems of B cell tolerance. Bim loss prevented deletion of autoreactive B cells induced by soluble self-antigen and promoted accumulation of self-reactive B cells developing in the presence of membrane-bound self-antigen, although their numbers were considerably lower compared with antigen-free mice. Mechanistically, we determined that BCR ligation promoted interaction of Bim with Bcl-2, inhibiting its survival function. These findings demonstrate that Bim is a critical player in BCR-mediated apoptosis and in B lymphocyte deletion.

Transgenic models of tolerance and autoimmunity: with special reference to systemic lupus erythematosus

Transgenic and knockout mouse carrying rearranged antigen-receptor genes have been invaluable for the elucidation of basic mechanisms in autoimmunity and have contributed new models of human autoimmune diseases. Several examples of transgenic models expressing rearranged immunoglobulin genes have been described. These models have provided a window into the events involved in this process, allowing the development and fate of self-reactive lymphocytes to be followed in vivo. In the B cell lineage, as in T cells, self-reactive cells have been found to undergo several distinct fates in vivo: they can be physically eliminated, functionally inactivated, or they can persist unchanged or become activated. Nevertheless the precise understanding of the molecular events leading to lymphocyte deletion, anergy or activation remains a challenge.

Therapeutic vaccination to block receptor-ligand interactions

Many chronic diseases are caused by non-physiological interactions of certain ligands with their receptors. Conventional treatment of these diseases with synthetic drugs or monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) is efficient, but problematic due to the non-compliance of patients and the risk of adverse side effects. Novel therapeutic approaches are focusing on strategies of active immunisation aimed at the induction of a humoral immune response directed against the deleterious receptor-ligand interaction. Autoantibody production has been achieved by several vaccine formulations, including conjugates of self-antigens to foreign T helper (Th) cell epitopes, virus-like particles coated with self-antigens, and naked DNA vectors. All of these approaches have the potential to be developed for clinical use if important safety issues, related to the possible long-term presence of self-reactive antibodies in the serum of vaccinated individuals and the risk of undesired T cell responses, can be properly addressed.

The control of apoptosis in lymphocyte selection

The stochastic nature of rearrangement and diversification of the gene segments encoding immunoglobulins (Igs) and T cell receptors (TCRs) inevitably gives rise to immature B and T lymphocytes that lack antigen receptors or express useless or dangerous (self-antigen-specific) ones. Signaling through antigen receptors promotes survival, proliferative expansion and further differentiation of useful cells and deletion of the useless and dangerous ones. During immune responses, pathogen-specific B and T lymphocytes, as well as cells of the innate immune system, undergo extensive proliferation and develop effector functions, such as antibody secretion, cytotoxicity or cytokine production. To prevent tissue damage by these effector molecules, activated lymphocytes are removed when an infection has been overcome. Together with other mechanisms, including developmental arrest and induction of unresponsiveness (anergy), programmed cell death (apoptosis) of autoreactive lymphocytes safeguards immunological tolerance to self and assists in the development of an effective immune system. We have been investigating the molecular mechanisms that control programmed cell death. This review describes some of our experiments using transgenic and knockout mice, which overexpress or lack apoptosis regulators, that led to discoveries on how life and death decisions are made during development and functioning of the immune system.

Resistance to CpG DNA-induced autoimmunity through tolerogenic B cell antigen receptor ERK signaling

CpG sequences in self-DNA are an important potential trigger for autoantibody secretion in systemic lupus and other systemic autoimmune disorders. It is not known how this ubiquitous threat may be controlled by active mechanisms for maintaining self tolerance. Here we show that two distinct mechanisms oppose autoantibody secretion induced by CpG DNA in anergic B cells that are constantly binding self-antigen. Uncoupling of the antigen receptor (BCR) from a calcineurin-dependent pathway prevents signals that synergize with CpG DNA for proliferation. The BCR does not become desensitized by activating the extracellular response kinase (ERK) MAP kinase pathway, however, and continuous self-antigen signaling to ERK inhibits CpG DNA-induced plasma cell differentiation. These two mechanisms seem to act as a general control against autoantibody production elicited by Toll-like receptors, and their regulation of T cell-independent responses to Toll-like receptor 9 (TLR9) is probably crucial for resistance to systemic autoimmunity.

The naive B cell repertoire predisposes to antigen-induced systemic lupus erythematosus

It is clear that the development of an autoimmune disease usually depends on both a genetic predisposition and an environmental trigger. In this study, we demonstrate that BALB/c mice develop a lupus-like serology following immunization with a peptide mimetope of DNA, while DBA/2 mice do not. We further demonstrate that the critical difference resides within the B cell compartment and that the naive B cell repertoire of DBA/2 mice has fewer B cells specific for the DNA mimetope. Differences in the strength of B cell receptor signaling exist between these two strains and may be responsible for the difference in disease susceptibility. BALB/c mice possess more autoreactive cells in the native repertoire; they display a weaker response to Ag and exhibit less Ag-induced apoptosis of B cells. DBA/2 mice, in contrast, display a stronger B cell receptor signal and more stringent central tolerance. This correlates with resistance to lupus induction. Thus, the degree to which autoreactive B cells have been eliminated from the naive B cell repertoire is genetically regulated and may determine whether a nonspontaneously autoimmune host will develop autoimmunity following exposure to Ag.

Anti-DNA B cells in MRL/lpr mice show altered differentiation and editing pattern

We have studied the regulation of anti-DNA B cells in transgenic mice with a heavy chain transgene (3H9H/56R). This transgene codes for a heavy chain that forms anti-double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) antibody when paired with most members of the endogenous Vkappa repertoire, but certain L chains, referred to as Vkappa editors, do not sustain dsDNA binding in combination with 3H9H/56R. In the nonautoimmune 3H9H/56R BALB/c, most B cells generated do not bind DNA because the transgene itself is edited or is associated with a Vkappa editor. A minor population of B cells (30%) bind dsDNA and express the lambda1 light chain (known to sustain 3H9H/56R DNA binding). These 3H9/56R/lambda1 B cells coexpress a kappa editor, and we propose that the down-regulation of the anti-DNA BCR caused by the dual L chain expression may prevent activation of this kappa/lambda population. These kappa/lambda B cells are sequestered in the marginal zone. Here, we studied the influence of autoimmunity on expression and regulation of 3H9H/56R. In 3H9H/56R MRL/lpr mice, the expression of anti-dsDNA is vastly accelerated. Anti-dsDNA B cells use noneditor kappas but, in addition, most anti-dsDNA B cells have edited the heavy chain transgene. lambda1 B cells (without the coexpression of a kappa editor) are found and the kappa/lambda1 MZ population is absent. Our results suggest that improper editing and failure to sequester autoreactive B cells may contribute to the breakdown of tolerance in MRL/lpr mice.

Sustained activation of Lyn tyrosine kinase in vivo leads to autoimmunity

Genetic ablation of the Lyn tyrosine kinase has revealed unique inhibitory roles in B lymphocyte signaling. We now report the consequences of sustained activation of Lyn in vivo using a targeted gain-of-function mutation (Lyn(up/up) mice). Lyn(up/up) mice have reduced numbers of conventional B lymphocytes, down-regulated surface immunoglobulin M and costimulatory molecules, and elevated numbers of B1a B cells. Lyn(up/up) B cells are characterized by the constitutive phosphorylation of negative regulators of B cell antigen receptor (BCR) signaling including CD22, SHP-1, and SHIP-1, and display attributes of lymphocytes rendered tolerant by constitutive engagement of the antigen receptor. However, exaggerated positive signaling is also apparent as evidenced by the constitutive phosphorylation of Syk and phospholipase Cgamma2 in resting Lyn(up/up) B cells. Similarly, Lyn(up/up) B cells show a heightened calcium flux in response to BCR stimulation. Surprisingly, Lyn(up/up) mice develop circulating autoreactive antibodies and lethal autoimmune glomerulonephritis, suggesting that enhanced positive signaling eventually overrides constitutive negative signaling. These studies highlight the difficulty in maintaining tolerance in the face of chronic stimulation and emphasize the pivotal role of Lyn in B cell signaling.

The unique antigen receptor signaling phenotype of B-1 cells is influenced by locale but induced by antigen

Normal animals contain an autoreactive B lymphocyte subset, the B-1 subset, which is controlled by undefined mechanisms to prevent autoimmunity. Using a V(H)11V(kappa)9 Ig transgenic mouse, with a specificity prototypic of the subset, we have explored conditions responsible for the previously reported Ag hyporesponsiveness of these cells. We report that peritoneal V(H)11V(kappa)9 B cells exhibit typical B-1 behavior with high basal intracellular free Ca(2+) and negligible receptor-mediated calcium mobilization. However, splenic B cells from this mouse, while phenotypically similar to their peritoneal counterparts, including expression of CD5, mount robust B-2-like responses to Ag as measured by calcium influx and altered tyrosine phosphorylation responses. When these splenic cells are adoptively transferred to the peritoneal cavity and encounter their cognate self-Ag, they acquire a B-1 signaling phenotype. The ensuing hyporesponsiveness is characterized by increases in both basal intracellular calcium and resting tyrosyl phosphorylation levels and is highlighted by a marked abrogation of B cell receptor-mediated calcium mobilization. Thus, we show that self-Ag recognition in specific microenvironments such as the peritoneum, and we would propose other privileged sites, confers a unique form of anergy on activated B cells. This may explain how autoreactive B-1 cells can exist while autoimmunity is avoided.

IL-4 promotes Stat6-dependent survival of autoreactive B cells in vivo without inducing autoantibody production

Persistent cross-linking of hen egg lysozyme (HEL)-specific B cell membrane Ig (mIg) in double transgenic mice that express soluble HEL as a self Ag (HEL-Ig mice) decreases B cell mIgM expression, responsiveness, and life span. Because in vitro treatment with IL-4 inhibits T cell apoptosis through a Stat6-independent mechanism, increases mIg expression, and suppresses activation-induced B cell death, we studied IL-4 effects on B cell mIg expression, survival, and Ab secretion in Stat6-sufficient and deficient HEL-Ig mice. IL-4 treatment nearly normalized B cell number and greatly increased the percentage of mature B cells in HEL-Ig mice, but failed to normalize mIgM expression or spontaneous LPS-induced IgM secretion. IL-4 effects on B cell survival and maturation were CD4(+) T cell independent, but Stat6 dependent, and did not involve receptor editing. IL-4 had to be present while B cells were generated to have a detectable effect on autoreactive B cell survival; however, the survival of B cells generated in the presence of IL-4 was substantially increased even after IL-4 was withdrawn. These observations suggest that: 1) activation-induced B cell death and anergy are independent processes; 2) B cells that survive to maturity develop increased resistance to Ag-induced deletion; and 3) IL-4 promotes B and T cell survival through different mechanisms.

Humoral autoimmunity to basement membrane antigens is regulated in C57BL/6 and MRL/MpJ mice transgenic for anti-laminin Ig receptors

Basement membrane proteins are targeted in organ-limited and systemic autoimmune nephritis, yet little is known about the origin or regulation of immunity to these complex extracellular matrices. We used mice transgenic for a nephrotropic systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) Ig H chain to test the hypothesis that humoral immunity to basement membrane is actively regulated. The LamH-Cmu Ig H chain transgene combines with diverse L chains to produce nephrotropic Ig reactive with murine laminin alpha1. To determine the fate of transgene-bearing B cells in vivo, transgenic mice were outcrossed onto nonautoimmune B6 and SLE-prone MRL backgrounds and exposed to potent mitogen or Ag in adjuvant. In this work we demonstrate that transgenic autoantibodies are absent in serum from M6 and M29 lineage transgenic mice and transgenic B cells hypoproliferate and fail to increase Ig production upon exposure to endotoxin or when subjected to B cell receptor cross-linking. Administration of LPS or immunization with autologous or heterologous laminin, maneuvers that induce nonoverlapping endogenous anti-laminin IgG responses, fails to induce a transgenic anti-laminin response. The marked reduction in splenic B cell number suggests that selected LamH-Cmu H chain and endogenous L chain combinations generate autospecificities that lead to B cell deletion. It thus appears that SLE-like anti-laminin B cells have access to and engage a tolerizing self-Ag in vivo. Failure to induce autoimmunity by global perturbations in immune regulation introduced by the MRL autoimmune background and exposure to potent environmental challenge suggests that humoral immunity to nephritogenic basement membrane epitopes targeted in systemic autoimmunity is tightly regulated.

Transmodulation of BCR signaling by transduction-incompetent antigen receptors: implications for impaired signaling in anergic B cells

B cell tolerance can be maintained by functional inactivation, or anergy, wherein B cell Ag receptors (BCR) remain capable of binding Ag, but are unable to transduce signals. Although the molecular mechanisms underlying this unresponsiveness are unknown, some models of B cell anergy are characterized by disruption of proximal BCR signaling events, and by destabilization of the BCR complex. Receptor destabilization is manifest by a reduced ability to coimmunoprecipitate membrane Ig with the Ig-alpha/Ig-beta signal-transducing complex. To begin to explore the possibility that anergy is the consequence of receptor destabilization, we analyzed a panel of B lymphoma transfectants expressing constant amounts of signal-competent Ag receptors and varied amounts of a receptor with identical specificity, but bearing mutations that render it incapable of interacting with Ig-alpha/Ig-beta. This analysis revealed that coaggregation of signal-incompetent receptors prevented Ag-induced Ig-alpha and Syk phosphorylation, mobilization of Ca(2+), and the up-regulation of CD69 mediated by competent receptors. In contrast, Ag-induced Cbl and Erk phosphorylation were unaffected. Data indicate that coaggregation of destabilized receptors (as few as approximately 15% of total) with signal-competent receptors significantly affects the ability of competent receptors to transduce signals. Thus, BCR destabilization may underlie the Ag unresponsiveness of anergic B cells.

Burst-enhancing role of the IgG membrane tail as a molecular determinant of memory

The basis of immune memory leading to heightened secondary antibody responses is a longstanding unanswered issue. Here we show that a single irreversible molecular change in the B cell antigen receptor, which is brought about by immunoglobulin M (IgM) to IgG isotype switching, is sufficient to greatly increase the extrafollicular proliferative burst of antigen-specific B cells. The unique membrane-spanning regions of IgG do not alter the T cell-dependent activation and proliferation of antigen-specific B cells in vivo, but markedly increase the number of progeny cells and plasmablasts that accumulate. These results establish a key molecular determinant of immunological memory and define an unexpected cellular basis by which it enhances the magnitude of secondary antibody responses.

Autoreactive B cells in the marginal zone that express dual receptors

Allotype and isotype exclusion is a property of most lymphocytes. The reason for this property is not known but it guarantees a high concentration of a single receptor, and threshold numbers of receptors may be required for efficient positive and negative selection. Receptor editing compromises exclusion by sustaining recombination even after a functional receptor is formed. Consequently, B cells expressing multiple receptors arise. We have studied such B cells in which one of the two receptors is anti-self, and find that these partially autoreactive B cells accumulate in the marginal zone. The restriction of these cells in this location may help to prevent them from undergoing diversification and developing into fully autoreactive B cells.

Persistence of partially functional double-stranded (ds) DNA binding B cells in mice transgenic for the IgM heavy chain of an anti-dsDNA antibody

One mechanism by which anti-double stranded (ds) DNA B cells are regulated is anergy. Multiple phenotypes have been attributed to anergic B cells in various transgenic models. Differences in the nature of the antigen and in the avidity of antigen-antibody interactions may account for these variations in phenotype. In the present study we describe a population of dsDNA binding B cells that display many of the features of anergic B cells, but have characteristics which suggest they are partially functional as well. These B cells do not spontaneously secrete antibody nor can they be induced to secrete antibody following receptor cross-linking in vitro. Furthermore, they display an immature phenotype and have a shortened lifespan, characteristic of anergic B cells. However, they can be induced to secrete anti-dsDNA antibody following activation with T cell-derived factors as well as with lipopolysaccharide (LPS) and they can be recovered by somatic cell hybridization even in the absence of LPS stimulation prior to fusion. These results suggest that antigen receptor signaling can be uncoupled from signaling induced by T cell-derived factors or LPS and that this may be a mechanism for maintaining tolerance. This may have protective advantages because it may enable B cells to be down-regulated in response to autoantigen yet be available for recruitment in an inflammatory response.

A coordinated change in chemokine responsiveness guides plasma cell movements

Antibody-secreting plasma cells are nonrecirculatory and lodge in splenic red pulp, lymph node medullary cords, and bone marrow. The factors that regulate plasma cell localization are poorly defined. Here we demonstrate that, compared with their B cell precursors, plasma cells exhibit increased chemotactic sensitivity to the CXCR4 ligand CXCL12. At the same time, they downregulate CXCR5 and CCR7 and have reduced responsiveness to the B and T zone chemokines CXCL13, CCL19, and CCL21. We demonstrate that CXCL12 is expressed within splenic red pulp and lymph node medullary cords as well as in bone marrow. In chimeric mice reconstituted with CXCR4-deficient fetal liver cells, plasma cells are mislocalized in the spleen, found in elevated numbers in blood, and fail to accumulate normally in the bone marrow. Our findings indicate that as B cells differentiate into plasma cells they undergo a coordinated change in chemokine responsiveness that regulates their movements in secondary lymphoid organs and promotes lodgment within the bone marrow.