A role for perforin in downregulating T-cell responses during chronic viral infection

Perforin hyperreleasability and depletion in cytotoxic T cells from patients with exacerbated atopic dermatitis and asymptomatic rhinoconjunctivitis allergica

BACKGROUND

As a plasma membrane pore-forming protein, perforin is essential for T-cell cytotoxicity mediated by lytic granules. Recent studies on the immune system of perforin knockout mice demonstrated striking similarities to the immunopathology of atopic diseases.

OBJECTIVE

We sought to investigate the perforin system of atopic patients.

METHODS

Monoclonal antibodies were used to characterize perforin-positive PBMCs of patients with exacerbated atopic dermatitis (AD) and asymptomatic rhinoconjunctivitis allergica (RCA) by means of immunoflow cytometry. In addition, a perforin release assay was developed to quantify the velocity of ionomycin and phorbol 12-myristate 13-acetate-induced secretion of lytic granules.

RESULTS

In atopic patients significantly fewer lymphocytes contained perforin-positive lytic granules compared with those of healthy control subjects (patients with AD: 14% +/- 5%, n = 13, P <.0001; patients with RCA: 24% +/- 5%, n = 9, P <.01; healthy control subjects: 33% +/- 11%, n = 13). Of all CD8(hi+) cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs), only 18% +/- 9% and 17% +/- 12% were perforin-positive in patients with AD and RCA, respectively, compared with 44% +/- 13% in control subjects (P <.0001). In addition, perforin-positive CD8(hi+) CTLs of atopic patients released their perforin twice as fast and more completely than control CTLs. This means that 50% of initially perforin-positive CD8(hi+) CTLs from patients with AD and RCA released their perforin completely within 32 +/- 16 and 36 +/- 19 minutes, respectively, and an over 85% release was reached within 113 +/- 41 and 118 +/- 60 minutes, respectively. In CTLs of healthy control subjects, however, it took 64 +/- 40 minutes to achieve a 50% release of lytic granules, and an 85% depletion was not reached in 60% of healthy control subjects, even after 180 minutes.

CONCLUSION

The perforin hyperreleasability explains, at least in part, the decreased percentage of perforin-positive CD8(hi+) CTLs in atopic patients. These distortions in the system of lytic granules of atopic patients may contribute to the functional defects observed in T-cell cytotoxicity in vivo and in vitro in patients with AD and RCA.

A fresh look at tumor immunosurveillance and immunotherapy

Despite major advances in our understanding of adaptive immunity and dendritic cells, consistent and durable responses to cancer vaccines remain elusive and active immunotherapy is still not an established treatment modality. The key to developing an effective anti-tumor response is understanding why, initially, the immune system is unable to detect transformed cells and is subsequently tolerant of tumor growth and metastasis. Ineffective antigen presentation limits the adaptive immune response; however, we are now learning that the host's innate immune system may first fail to recognize the tumor as posing a danger. Recent descriptions of stress-induced ligands on tumor cells recognized by innate effector cells, new subsets of T cells that regulate tumor tolerance and the development of spontaneous tumors in mice that lack immune effector molecules, beckon a reflection on our current perspectives on the interaction of transformed cells with the immune system and offer new hope of stimulating therapeutic immunity to cancer.

Spectrum of perforin gene mutations in familial hemophagocytic lymphohistiocytosis

Familial hemophagocytic lymphohistiocytosis (FHL) is an autosomal recessive disease of early childhood characterized by nonmalignant accumulation and multivisceral infiltration of activated T lymphocytes and histiocytes (macrophages). Cytotoxic T and natural killer (NK) cell activity is markedly reduced or absent in these patients, and mutations in a lytic granule constituent, perforin, were recently identified in a number of FHL individuals. Here, we report a comprehensive survey of 34 additional patients with FHL for mutations in the coding region of the perforin gene and the relative frequency of perforin mutations in FHL. Perforin mutations were identified in 7 of the 34 families investigated. Six children were homozygous for the mutations, and one patient was a compound heterozygote. Four novel mutations were detected: one nonsense, two missense, and one deletion of one amino acid. In four families, a previously reported mutation at codon 374, causing a premature stop codon, was identified, and, therefore, this is the most common perforin mutation identified so far in FHL patients. We found perforin mutations in 20% of all FHL patients investigated (7/34), with a somewhat higher prevalence, approximately 30% (6/20), in children whose parents originated from Turkey. No other correlation between the type of mutation and the phenotype of the patients was evident from the present study. Our combined results from mutational analysis of 34 families and linkage analysis of a subset of consanguineous families indicate that perforin mutations account for 20%-40% of the FHL cases and the FHL 1 locus on chromosome 9 for approximately 10%, whereas the major part of the FHL cases are caused by mutations in not-yet-identified genes.

Novel association of haemophagocytic syndrome with Kaposi's sarcoma-associated herpesvirus-related primary effusion lymphoma

Haemophagocytic syndrome (HPS) is a fulminant, often fatal, systemic illness that occurs in association with infection and malignancy. We provide the first report of HPS that heralded a primary effusion lymphoma (PEL), a rare neoplasm linked to Kaposi's sarcoma-associated herpesvirus. The patient was a 38-year-old man with acquired immunodeficiency syndrome who presented with fever, sweats, lymphadenopathy, splenomegaly and refractory anaemia. Examination of the spleen demonstrated haemophagocytosis; analysis of ascites revealed PEL. Treatment with chemotherapy and ganciclovir resulted in complete remission of both conditions. This case illustrates the diagnostic challenges posed by HPS and supports the trial of antiviral agents in combination with chemotherapy in patients with PEL.

Regulation of antigen-specific CD8+ T cell homeostasis by perforin and interferon-gamma

T cell memory depends on factors that regulate expansion and death of these cells after antigenic stimulation. Mice deficient in perforin and interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) exhibited increased expansion, altered immunodominance, and decreased death of antigen-specific CD8+ T cells after infection with an attenuated strain of Listeria monocytogenes, which was cleared from these mice. Expansion of CD8+ T cells was controlled by perforin, whereas IFN-gamma regulated immunodominance and the death phase. Thus, perforin and IFN-gamma regulate distinct elements of CD8+ T cell homeostasis independently of their role as antimicrobial effector molecules.

Perforin-mediated cytotoxicity is critical for surveillance of spontaneous lymphoma

Immune surveillance by cytotoxic lymphocytes against cancer has been postulated for decades, but direct evidence for the role of cytotoxic lymphocytes in protecting against spontaneous malignancy has been lacking. As the rejection of many experimental cancers by cytotoxic T lymphocytes and natural killer cells is dependent on the pore-forming protein perforin (pfp), we examined pfp-deficient mice for increased cancer susceptibility. Here we show that pfp-deficient mice have a high incidence of malignancy in distinct lymphoid cell lineages (T, B, NKT), indicating a specific requirement for pfp in protection against lymphomagenesis. The susceptibility to lymphoma was accentuated by simultaneous lack of expression of the p53 gene, mutations in which also commonly predispose to human malignancies, including lymphoma. In contrast, the incidence and age of onset of sarcoma was unaffected in p53-deficient mice. Pfp-deficient mice were at least 1,000-fold more susceptible to these lymphomas when transplanted, compared with immunocompetent mice in which tumor rejection was controlled by CD8(+) T lymphocytes. This study is the first that implicates direct cytotoxicity by lymphocytes in regulating lymphomagenesis.

Defining CTL-induced pathology: implications for HIV

The relationship between virus and host cells is multifactorial and nonlinear. This indicates that the effect of an immune response on infection can lead to several different outcomes. These include severe immunopathology. We seek to define properties of CTL-induced pathology in viral infections and examine the implications for HIV disease progression. We find that CTL-induced pathology is observed if the rate of viral replication is fast relative to the CTL responsiveness of the host. Theoretical predictions are consistent with empirical data on LCMV infection. These conditions are also sufficient to induce pathology in HIV infection. However, the absence of HIV-specific CTL can result in an equivalent depletion of the CD4 T cell pool as a consequence of the short life span of activated T cells. A mathematical model describing the evolution of HIV coreceptor usage in the context of lytic and nonlytic CD8 cell responses might account for the relatively long time span required to result in disease. Viral evolution toward parameter ranges allowing CTL-induced pathology is difficult to achieve. It requires the emergence of fast viral replication together with escape from nonlytic CTL responses. However, according to the model, fast viral replication can result in the evolution of virus strains that are susceptible to chemokine-mediated inhibition of viral replication.

Immune responses in tuberculosis

The initial interaction of Mycobacterium tuberculosis with phagocytes through Toll-like receptors can affect induction of the adaptive response by inflammatory cytokine production, as well as begin the process of bacterial containment by induction of antimycobacterial functions. Advances in T cell research in tuberculosis include identification of antigens recognized by CD8(+) T cells in infected hosts, elucidation of antimycobacterial mechanisms of T cells and the discovery of CD8(+) T cells that recognize antigens presented by a variety of non-classical molecules.

The complexity of protective immunity against liver-stage malaria

Sterile protective immunity against challenge with Plasmodium spp. sporozoites can be induced in multiple model systems and humans by immunization with radiation-attenuated Plasmodium spp. sporozoites. The infected hepatocyte has been established as the primary target of this protection, but the underlying mechanisms have not been completely defined. Abs, CD8+ T cells, CD4+ T cells, cytokines (including IFN-gamma and IL-12), and NO have all been implicated as critical effectors. Here, we have investigated the mechanisms of protective immunity induced by immunization with different vaccine delivery systems (irradiated sporozoites, plasmid DNA, synthetic peptide/adjuvant, and multiple Ag peptide) in genetically distinct inbred strains, genetically modified mice, and outbred mice. We establish that there is a marked diversity of T cell-dependent immune responses that mediate sterile protective immunity against liver-stage malaria. Furthermore, we demonstrate that distinct mechanisms of protection are induced in different strains of inbred mice by a single method of immunization, and in the same strain by different methods of immunization. These data underscore the complexity of the murine host response to a parasitic infection and suggest that an outbred human population may behave similarly. Data nevertheless suggest that a pre-erythrocytic-stage vaccine should be designed to induce CD8+ T cell- and IFN-gamma-mediated immune responses and that IFN-gamma responses may represent an in vitro correlate of pre-erythrocytic-stage protective immunity.

CD8+ T cell effector mechanisms in resistance to infection

Based on T cell subset depletion studies and the analysis of gene knockout mice, it is evident that CD8(+) T cells contribute to resistance against intracellular infections with certain viral, protozoan, and bacterial pathogens. Although they are known primarily for their capacity to kill infected cells, CD8(+) T cells elaborate a variety of effector mechanisms with the potential to defend against infection. Microbes use multiple strategies to cause infection, and the nature of the pathogenhost interaction may determine which CD8(+) T cell effector mechanisms are required for immunity. In this review, we summarize our current understanding of the effector functions used by CD8(+) T cells in resistance to pathogens. Analyses of mice deficient in perforin and/or Fas demonstrate that cytolysis is critical for immunity against some, but not all, infections and also reveal the contribution of cytolysis to the pathogenesis of disease. The role of CD8(+) T cell-derived cytokines in resistance to infection has been analyzed by systemic treatment with neutralizing antibodies and cytokine gene knockout mice. These studies are complicated by the fact that few, if any, cytokines are uniquely produced by CD8(+) T cells. Thus, the requirement for CD8(+) T cell- derived cytokines in resistance against most pathogens remains to be defined. Finally, recent studies of human CD8(+) T cells reveal the potential for novel effector mechanisms in resistance to infection.

Evolution of the CD8 T-cell repertoire during infections

CD8 T cells exist in a dynamic network whose repertoire remains static in the absence of infection but changes in the presence of foreign antigens. Individuals each have unique T-cell repertoires that continually evolve in the presence of antigen and of cross-reactive heterologous antigens, and homeostatic forces drive deletions in T-cell memory pools to accommodate the entry of new memory cells into a finite immune system.

CD8+ CTL from lungs of Mycobacterium tuberculosis-infected mice express perforin in vivo and lyse infected macrophages

CD8+ T lymphocytes have been implicated in the protective immune response against human and murine tuberculosis. However, the functional role that this cell subset plays during the resolution of infection remains controversial. In this study, we demonstrate the presence of Mycobacterium tuberculosis-specific CD8+ CTL in the lungs and lung-draining lymph nodes of mice infected with M. tuberculosis via the aerosol or i.v. route. These cells expressed perforin in vivo and specifically recognized and lysed M. tuberculosis-infected macrophages in a perforin-dependent manner after a short period of in vitro restimulation. The efficiency of lysis of infected macrophages was dependent upon the time allowed for interaction between macrophage and M. tuberculosis bacilli. Recognition of infected targets by CD8+ CTL was beta 2-microglobulin and MHC class I dependent and was not CD1d restricted. The presented data indicate that CD8+ T cells contribute to the protective immune response during M. tuberculosis infection by exerting cytotoxic function and lysing infected macrophages.

Adaptive immunity and enhanced CD8+ T cell response to Listeria monocytogenes in the absence of perforin and IFN-gamma

Single Ag-specific CD8+ T cells from IFN-gamma-deficient (GKO) or perforin-deficient (PKO) mice provide substantial immunity against murine infection with Listeria monocytogenes. To address the potential for redundancy between perforin and IFN-gamma as CD8+ T cell effector mechanisms, we generated perforin/IFN-gamma (PKO/GKO) double-deficient mice. PKO/GKO-derived CD8+ T cells specific for the immunodominant listeriolysin O (LLO91-99) epitope provide immunity to LM infection similar to that provided by Ag-matched wild-type (WT) CD8+ T cells in the liver but reduced in the spleen. Strikingly, polyclonal CD8+ T cells from immunized PKO/GKO mice were approximately 100-fold more potent in reducing bacterial numbers than the same number of polyclonal CD8+ T cells from immunized WT mice. This result is probably quantitative, because the frequency of the CD8+ T cell response against the immunodominant LLO91-99 epitope is >4.5-fold higher in PKO/GKO mice than WT mice at 7 days after identical immunizations. Moreover, PKO/GKO mice can be immunized by a single infection with attenuated Listeria to resist >80,000-fold higher challenges with virulent organisms than naive PKO/GKO mice. These data demonstrate that neither perforin nor IFN-gamma is required for the development or expression of adaptive immunity to LM. In addition, the results suggest the potential for perforin and IFN-gamma to regulate the magnitude of the CD8+ T cell response to infection.

Competitive coexistence in antiviral immunity

Adaptive immunity to viruses in vertebrates is mediated by two distinct but complementary branches of the immune system: the cellular response, which eliminates infected cells, and the humoral response, which eliminates infectious virus. This leads to an interesting contest, since the two responses compete, albeit indirectly, for proliferative stimuli. How can a host mount a coordinated antiviral campaign? Here we show that competition may lead to a state of "competitive coexistence" in which, counterintuitively, each branch complements the other, with clinical benefit to the host. The principle is similar to free-market economics, in which firms compete, but the consumer benefits. Experimental evidence suggests this is a useful paradigm in antiviral immunity.

Proapoptotic functions of cytotoxic lymphocyte granule constituents in vitro and in vivo

Recent advances in our understanding of cytolytic effector mechanisms include the partial characterization of caspase-independent apoptotic pathways triggered by granzymes, a realization of the vital importance of perforin and granzymes in the defence against certain virus infections in vivo and the first description of hereditary immunodeficiency due to disordered perforin expression in humans.

Nitric oxide synthase-2 and expression of perforin in uterine NK cells

In human, mouse, and rat pregnancy, maternal NK cells accumulate and differentiate at implantation sites. These cells, termed uterine NK (uNK) cells, express NO synthase (NOS)-2 and develop cytolytic molecules such as perforin and granzymes during differentiation in situ. In this study, relationships between expression of the NOS-2 gene, uNK cell population density and tissue distribution, and synthesis of perforin were investigated. Uteri from wild-type (WT) and NOS-2-/- mice were collected at gestation days (g.d.) 8, 10, 12, 14, and 16 (n, >2/g.d.). Histochemical staining failed to reveal any differences between the population densities or tissue distributions of uNK cells in WT and NOS-2-/- uteri at any stage of gestation. By contrast, immunohistochemical staining with anti-perforin Abs demonstrated significantly fewer perforin-positive uNK cells in two uterine compartments of NOS-2-/- mice in comparison to the same compartments in WT mouse uteri. Perforin-positive uNK cells were reduced in NOS-2-/- metrial glands at g.d. 8, 10, and 12 and in decidua basalis at g.d. 12 (p < 0.05). Analysis of perforin protein by immunoblotting confirmed this observation. Northern blot hybridization studies showed that loss of perforin protein in NOS-2-/- mice was accompanied by decreased steady-state levels of perforin mRNA. These results demonstrate that migration of uNK cells into the uterus, selection of residency sites, and proliferation in situ are independent of NOS-2. By contrast, their differentiation, including transcription and translation of the cytotoxic molecule perforin, was shown to rely on normal expression of the NOS-2 gene.

IL-4 diminishes perforin-mediated and increases Fas ligand-mediated cytotoxicity In vivo

CTL have evolved two major mechanisms for target cell killing: one mediated by perforin/granzyme secretion and the other by Fas/Fas ligand (L) interaction. Although cytokines are integral to the development of naive CTL into cytolytic effectors, the role of cytokines on mechanisms of CTL killing is just emerging. In this study, we evaluate the effects of IL-4 in Fas(CD95)/FasL(CD95L)-mediated killing of Fas-overexpressing target cells. Recombinant vaccinia viruses (vv) were constructed to express respiratory syncytial virus M2 Ag alone (vvM2) or coexpress M2 and IL-4 (vvM2/IL-4). MHC-matched Fas-overexpressing target cells (L1210Fas+) were used to measure both perforin- and FasL-mediated killing pathways. In contrast to Fas-deficient (L1210Fas-) target cells, effectors from vvM2/IL-4-immunized mice were able to lyse L1210Fas+ target cells with similar magnitude as vvM2-infected mice. Addition of EGTA/Mg2+ revealed that effectors from vvM2/IL-4-infected mice primarily lyse targets by a Ca2+-independent Fas/FasL pathway. Analysis of FasL expression by flow cytometry showed that IL-4 increased cell surface FasL expression on CD4+ and CD8+ splenocytes, with peak expression on day 4 after infection. These data demonstrate that IL-4 increases FasL expression on T cells, resulting in a shift of the mechanism of CTL killing from a dominant perforin-mediated cytolytic pathway to a dominant FasL-mediated cytolytic pathway.

Perforin pathway is essential for protection of mice against lethal ocular HSV-1 challenge but not corneal scarring

Perforin (cytolysin; pore-forming protein) is expressed in both CD8(+) cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) and natural killer (NK) cells, and is a major factor responsible for the cytolytic activities of these cells. Both CD8(+) T-cells and NK cells are important in eliminating cells infected with certain viruses. We examined the role of perforin in a mouse model of HSV-1 infection using perforin-deficient mice. Naïve perforin knockout (perforin(0/0)) mice were more susceptible to lethal HSV-1 ocular challenge (60% survival), than naïve parental C57BL/6 (100% survival). In contrast, both C57BL/6 and perforin(0/0) mice had similar levels of HSV-1 induced corneal scarring. Vaccination of perforin(0/0) mice induced a significantly higher HSV-1 neutralizing antibody titer than vaccination of C57BL/6 mice, and the mice were completely protected against lethal ocular challenge. These results suggest that in naïve mice ocularly challenged with HSV-1, the perforin pathway was involved in protection against death, but not in protection against corneal scarring.

Perforin gene defects in familial hemophagocytic lymphohistiocytosis

Familial hemophagocytic lymphohistiocytosis (FHL) is a rare, rapidly fatal, autosomal recessive immune disorder characterized by uncontrolled activation of T cells and macrophages and overproduction of inflammatory cytokines. Linkage analyses indicate that FHL is genetically heterogeneous and linked to 9q21.3-22, 10q21-22, or another as yet undefined locus. Sequencing of the coding regions of the perforin gene of eight unrelated 10q21-22-linked FHL patients revealed homozygous nonsense mutations in four patients and missense mutations in the other four patients. Cultured lymphocytes from patients had defective cytotoxic activity, and immunostaining revealed little or no perforin in the granules. Thus, defects in perforin are responsible for 10q21-22-linked FHL. Perforin-based effector systems are, therefore, involved not only in the lysis of abnormal cells but also in the down-regulation of cellular immune activation.

Induction of antiviral antibodies by DNA immunization requires neither perforin-mediated nor CD8(+)-T-cell-mediated lysis of antigen-expressing cells

DNA immunization induces antibodies to the encoded protein, which indicates that the protein must gain access to the extracellular milieu, allowing it to interact with naïve B lymphocytes. It has been suggested that antigen release may be effected by cytotoxic-T-lymphocyte-mediated lysis of transfected antigen-expressing cells; this might be particularly important for the induction of responses to a noncytopathic, cytosolic protein. Here we show that the induction of antibody responses to one such DNA-encoded protein required neither perforin nor CD8(+) T cells. In addition, there was no skewing of the immunoglobulin G isotypes in the absence of perforin.

Immune deficiency, immune silencing, and clonal exhaustion of T cell responses during viral infections

Analyses of the complex regulatory networks leading to T cell survival, death, and immune deficiency have been aided in the past year by the dramatic development of new technologies to identify T cells and assess T cell function. These new techniques have shown that functional inactivation and apoptotic elimination of both virus-specific and non-virus-specific T cell populations mold T cell responses to viral infections.