Prx1 and Prx2 in skeletogenesis: roles in the craniofacial region, inner ear and limbs

Severe nasal clefting and abnormal embryonic apoptosis in Alx3/Alx4 double mutant mice

A group of mouse aristaless-related genes has been implicated in functions in the development of the craniofacial skeleton. We have generated an Alx3 mutant allele in which the lacZ coding sequence is inserted in-frame in the Alx3 gene and the sequences encoding the conserved protein domains are deleted. Mice homozygous for this null allele are indistinguishable from wild-type mice. Compound mutants of Alx3 and Alx4, however, show severe craniofacial abnormalities that are absent in Alx4 single mutants. Alx3/Alx4 double mutant newborn mice have cleft nasal regions. Most facial bones and many other neural crest derived skull elements are malformed, truncated or even absent. The craniofacial defects in Alx3/Alx4 double mutant embryos become anatomically manifest around embryonic day 10.5, when the nasal processes appear to be abnormally positioned. This most probably leads to a failure of the medial nasal processes to fuse in the facial midline and subsequently to the split face phenotype. We detected a significant increase in apoptosis localised in the outgrowing frontonasal process in embryonic day 10.0 double mutant embryos, which we propose to be the underlying cause of the subsequent malformations.

Development of the vertebrate inner ear

The inner ear, also called the membranous labyrinth, contains the cochlea, which is responsible for the sense of hearing, and the vestibular apparatus, which is necessary for the sense of balance and gravity. The inner ear arises in the embryo from placodes, which are epithelial thickenings of the cranial ectoderm symmetrically located on either side of hindbrain rhombomeres 5 and 6. Placode formation in mice is first visible at the 12-somite stage and is controlled by surrounding tissues, the paraxial mesoderm and neural ectoderm. Diffusible molecules such as growth factors play an important role in this process. The activity of several genes confers the identity to the placodal cells. Subsequent cellular proliferation processes under influences from the adjacent hindbrain cause the inner ear epithelium to invaginate and form a vesicle called the otocyst. Combinatorial expression of several genes and diffusible factors secreted from the vesicle epithelium and hindbrain control specification of distinct inner ear compartments. Transplantation studies and inner ear in vitro cultures show that each of these compartments is already committed to develop unique inner ear structures. Later developmental periods are principally characterized by intrinsic differentiation processes. In particular, sensory patches differentiate into fully functional sensory epithelia, and the semicircular canals along with the cochlear duct are elaborated and ossified.

Expression patterns of group-I aristaless-related genes during craniofacial and limb development

Aristaless-related proteins are structurally defined by the presence of a paired-type homeodomain and an additional conserved domain, known as aristaless domain or OAR-domain. These proteins can be further categorized in three groups (Int. J. Dev. Biol., 43 (1999) 651). Group-I aristaless-related genes are linked to functions in the development of the craniofacial and appendicular skeleton and are expressed predominantly in the mesenchyme in stages from gastrulation through at least mid-gestation (Mech. Dev., 48 (1994) 245; Mech. Dev., 52 (1995) 51; Development, 124 (1997) 3999; Dev. Biol., 199 (1998) 11; Development, 126 (1999) 495). In view of the highly redundant character of the functions of these genes in patterning craniofacial and limb structures, we found it important to directly compare their expression patterns at critical stages of craniofacial and limb development.

Characterization of the mouse matrilin-4 gene: a 5' antiparallel overlap with the gene encoding the transcription factor RBP-l

We have isolated and characterized the gene encoding mouse matrilin-4 (Matn4), an extracellular matrix protein present in a broad spectrum of tissues. The gene spanned 16 kb, consisted of 12 exons, and localized to chromosome 2. As in all known matrilin genes, the last intron, separating the exons coding for the coiled-coil domain, did not follow the GT-AG rule and belonged to the subgroup of introns having AT-AC at the ends. Matn4 contained two exons in the 5' UTR that could be alternatively spliced. We localized a major and a minor transcription start site to two different untranslated exons: exon 0a and exon 0b. Matn4 divergently overlapped 5' with the gene encoding RBP-L (for recombining binding protein suppressor of hairless-like; Rbpsuhl), a transcription factor with homology to RBP-JK. Exon 1 of Rbpsuhl was located in the second intron of Matn4, whereas exon 0a, the first exon of Matn4, was located in the second intron of Rbpsuhl. The second exons of the respective genes overlapped in an antisense orientation. We mapped the major transcription start of Rbpsuhl to a position approximately 150 nt upstream of the splice acceptor site of the first intron, leading to the synthesis of a truncated variant of RBP-L probably missing the amino-terminal 121 amino acid residues. We analyzed the expression of the different Matn4 and Rbpsuhl transcripts by quantitative RT-PCR; this showed the highest expression for both genes in lung and brain. In situ hybridization of brain sections showed a partially overlapping expression pattern for the two genes.

Prx1andPrx2are upstream regulators of sonic hedgehog and control cell proliferation during mandibular arch morphogenesis

The aristaless-related homeobox genes Prx1 and Prx2 are required for correct skeletogenesis in many structures. Mice that lack both Prx1 and Prx2 functions display reduction or absence of skeletal elements in the skull, face, limbs and vertebral column. A striking phenotype is found in the lower jaw, which shows loss of midline structures, and the presence of a single, medially located incisor. We investigated development of the mandibular arch of Prx1−/−Prx2−/− mutants to obtain insight into the molecular basis of the lower jaw abnormalities. We observed in mutant embryos a local decrease in proliferation of mandibular arch mesenchyme in a medial area. Interestingly, in the oral epithelium adjacent to this mesenchyme, sonic hedgehog (Shh) expression was strongly reduced, indicative of a function for Prx genes in indirect regulation of Shh. Wild-type embryos that were exposed to the hedgehog-pathway inhibitor, jervine, partially phenocopied the lower jaw defects of Prx1−/−Prx2−/− mutants. In addition, this treatment led to loss of the mandibular incisors. We present a model that describes how loss of Shh expression in Prx1−/−Prx2−/− mutants leads to abnormal morphogenesis of the mandibular arch.

Prx1 controls vascular smooth muscle cell proliferation and tenascin-C expression and is upregulated with Prx2 in pulmonary vascular disease

Prx1 and Prx2 are homeobox transcription factors expressed during vasculogenesis. To begin to elucidate how Prx1 and Prx2 are regulated and function in the adult vasculature, in situ hybridization studies were performed. Prx1 and Prx2 mRNAs were not detected in normal adult rat pulmonary arteries; however, both genes were induced with vascular disease, colocalizing to sites of tenascin-C (TN-C) expression. Because catabolism of the extracellular matrix (ECM) is a critical step in the development of vascular disease, we investigated whether changes in vascular smooth muscle cell (SMC)-ECM interactions regulate Prx1 and Prx2. A10 SMCs cultured on native type I collagen showed low levels of Prx1 and Prx2 mRNA expression, whereas cells cultured on denatured collagen showed higher levels of expression of both genes. At a functional level, transfection of SMCs with a Prx1 expression plasmid significantly increased their growth. Because TN-C also promotes SMC growth and its expression is also upregulated by denatured collagen, we tested and thereafter showed that Prx1 expression significantly enhances TN-C gene promoter activity 20-fold. Similar experiments conducted with truncated Prx1 proteins showed that the N-terminal portion and the homeodomain of Prx1 were necessary to induce the bulk of TN-C promoter activity. These findings support the hypothesis that Prx genes are regulated by changes in SMC adhesion and play key morphoregulatory roles during the development and progression of pulmonary vascular disease in adults.

The Wheels mutation in the mouse causes vascular, hindbrain, and inner ear defects

In a screen for mouse mutations with dominant behavioral anomalies, we identified Wheels, a mutation associated with circling and hyperactivity in heterozygotes and embryonic lethality in homozygotes. Mutant Wheels embryos die at E10.5-E11.5 and exhibit a host of morphological anomalies which include growth retardation and anomalies in vascular and hindbrain development. The latter includes perturbation of rhombomeric boundaries as detected by Krox20 and Hoxb1. PECAM-1 staining of embryos revealed normal formation of the primary vascular plexus. However, subsequent stages of branching and remodeling do not proceed normally in the yolk sac and in the embryo proper. To obtain insights into the circling behavior, we examined development of the inner ear by paint-filling of membranous labyrinths of Whl/+ embryos. This analysis revealed smaller posterior and lateral semicircular canal primordia and a delay in the canal fusion process at E12.5. By E13.5, the lateral canal was truncated and the posterior canal was small or absent altogether. Marker analysis revealed an early molecular phenotype in heterozygous embryos characterized by perturbed expression of Bmp4 and Msx1 in prospective lateral and posterior cristae at E11.5. We have constructed a genetic and radiation hybrid map of the centromeric portion of mouse Chromosome 4 across the Wheels region and refined the position of the Wheels locus to the approximately 1.1-cM region between D4Mit104 and D4Mit181. We have placed the locus encoding Epha7, in the Wheels candidate region; however, further analysis showed no mutations in the Epha7-coding region and no detectable changes in mRNA expression pattern. In summary, our findings indicate that Wheels, a gene which is essential for the survival of the embryo, may link diverse processes involved in vascular, hindbrain, and inner ear development.

The identification of Prx1 transcription regulatory domains provides a mechanism for unequal compensation by the Prx1 and Prx2 loci

Transcription regulatory domains of the Prx1a and Prx1b homeoproteins were analyzed in transient transfection assays using artificial promoters as well as an established downstream target promoter (tenascin-c). Activation and repression domains were detected in their common amino end. In the carboxyl end of Prx1a an activation domain and an inhibition/masking region (OAR domain) were detected. The Prx1b isoform, generated by alternative splicing, does not contain these carboxyl activation or inhibition domains. Instead, the data demonstrate that the carboxyl tail of Prx1b contains a potent repressor region. This difference in the carboxyl tail accounts for a 45-fold difference observed in transcription regulatory activity between Prx1a and Prx1b. The data also support the likelihood that this difference between Prx1a and Prx1b is higher in the presence of still undetermined cofactors. DNA binding affinities of Prx1a, Prx1b, and a series of truncation mutants were also examined. The carboxyl tail of Prx1a, which inhibited transcription activation in the transfection assays, also inhibited DNA binding. These differences in biochemical function between Prx1a and Prx1b, as well as the recently described activities of Prx2, provide a mechanism for the unequal compensation between the Prx1 and Prx2 loci.

Genetic and teratogenic approaches to craniofacial development

Craniofacial malformations are the most common birth defects that occur in humans, with facial clefting representing the majority of these defects. Facial clefts can arise at any stage of development due to perturbations that alter the extracellular matrix as well as affect the patterning, migration, proliferation, and differentiation of cells. In this review, we focus on recent advances in the understanding of the developmental basis for facial clefting through the analysis of the effects of gene disruption experiments and treatments with teratogens in both chickens and mice. Specifically, we analyze the results of disruptions to genes such as Sonic hedgehog (Shh), epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR), Distal-less (Dlx), and transforming growth factor beta 3 (TGFbeta3). We also describe the effects that teratogens such as retinoic acid, jervine, and cyclopamine have on facial clefting and discuss mechanisms for their action. In addition to providing insight into the bases for abnormal craniofacial growth, genetic and teratogenic techniques are powerful tools for understanding the normal developmental processes that generate and pattern the face.

Identification of domains mediating transcription activation, repression, and inhibition in the paired-related homeobox protein, Prx2 (S8)

Despite the growing information concerning the developmental importance of the Prx2 protein, the structural determinants of Prx2 function are poorly understood. To gain insight into the transcription regulatory regions of the Prx2 protein, we generated a series of truncation mutants. Both the Prx2 response element (PRE) and a portion of the tenascin promoter, a downstream target of Prx2, were used as reporters in transient transfection assays. This analysis showed that a conserved domain (PRX), found in both Prx1 and Prx2, activated transcription in NIH 3T3 cells. This PRX domain, as well as other functional regions of Prx2, demonstrated both cell-specific and promoter-dependent transcriptional regulation. A second important region, the OAR (aristaless) domain, which is conserved among 35 Paired-type homeodomain proteins, was observed to inhibit transcription. Deletion of this element resulted in a 20-fold increase of transcription from the tenascin reporter in NIH 3T3 cells but not in C2C12 cells. The OAR domain did not function as a repressor in chimeric fusions with the Gal4 DNA binding domain in either cell type, characterizing it as an inhibitor instead of a repressor. These results give insight into the function of the Prx2 transcription factor while establishing the framework for comparison with the two isoforms of Prx1.

Genetic architecture of mandible shape in mice: effects of quantitative trait loci analyzed by geometric morphometrics

This study introduces a new multivariate approach for analyzing the effects of quantitative trait loci (QTL) on shape and demonstrates this method for the mouse mandible. We quantified size and shape with the methods of geometric morphometrics, based on Procrustes superimposition of five morphological landmarks recorded on each mandible. Interval mapping for F(2) mice originating from an intercross of the LG/J and SM/J inbred strains revealed 12 QTL for size, 25 QTL for shape, and 5 QTL for left-right asymmetry. Multivariate ordination of QTL effects by principal component analysis identified two recurrent features of shape variation, which involved the positions of the coronoid and angular processes relative to each other and to the rest of the mandible. These patterns are reminiscent of the knockout phenotypes of a number of genes involved in mandible development, although only a few of these are possible candidates for QTL in our study. The variation of shape effects among the QTL showed no evidence of clustering into distinct groups, as would be expected from theories of morphological integration. Further, for most QTL, additive and dominance effects on shape were markedly different, implying overdominance for specific features of shape. We conclude that geometric morphometrics offers a promising new approach to address problems at the interface of evolutionary and developmental genetics.

Development of the membranous labyrinth of human embryos and fetuses using computer aided 3D-reconstruction

The last detailed description of the development of the inner ear membranous labyrinth goes back to Streeter in 1918. This investigation can be regarded to be of outstanding scientific value. However, at that time no staging system of human embryos existed. In this respect, Streeter's work is outdated. It was the aim of this study to reinvestigate the development of the membranous labyrinth in human embryos and fetuses of which the developmental stages have been determined according to the Carnegie staging system and to compare the results with the literature. Serial histologic sections in the coronal or frontal plane of the heads of human embryos and fetuses of different developmental stages were used for computer aided 3D-reconstruction of the membranous labyrinth. From the obtained results, it is concluded that the endolymphatic duct develops earlier than previously described in the literature. The induction of the differentiation of the endolymphatic duct does not correspond with the superficial ectoderm because the endolymphatic duct develops medial of the otic vesicle. The membranous labyrinth determines the form of the petrosal bone as early as in stage 19 (47-48 days post conception).

The molecular control of upper extremity development: implications for congenital hand anomalies

As the molecular aspects of limb development are being unraveled, more of the congenital anomalies seen by hand surgeons in the clinical setting will have an identifiable molecular basis. The majority of the data available regarding the molecular development of the upper extremity have come from experimental animal studies, specifically the mouse and chicken. These findings are being discovered by either direct surgical and molecular manipulation of the developing limb or by production of mice deficient in specific genes. Relatively few specific human mutations that cause limb abnormalities have been identified. Hand surgeons should be aware of the basic molecular pathways controlling limb development because they are in a unique position to be able to identify patients with such deformities. In turn, detailed clinical descriptions of congenital anomalies affecting the upper extremity will advance the understanding of the cellular events controlled by the molecular pathways of limb development. This review describes the general molecular basis of limb development and correlates it with disease processes affecting the upper extremity.

Perspectives on the evolutionary origin of tetrapod limbs

The study of the origin and evolution of the tetrapod limb has benefited enormously from the confluence of molecular and paleontological data. In the last two decades, our knowledge of the basic molecular mechanisms that control limb development has grown exponentially, and developmental biologists now have the possibility of combining molecular data with many available descriptions of the fossil record of vertebrate fins and limbs. This synthesis of developmental and evolutionary biology has the potential to unveil the sequence of molecular changes that culminated in the adoption of the basic tetrapod limb plan.

The role of homeobox genes in vascular remodeling and angiogenesis

Homeodomain-containing transcription factors are critical in the regulation of cell proliferation, differentiation, and migration, and they play an important role in organogenesis and pattern formation during embryogenesis. There is evidence that some of them are oncogenes or tumor suppressors. The cardiovascular system undergoes extensive remodeling during embryogenesis and disease states such as atherosclerosis and tumor-induced angiogenesis, and homeobox genes may play an important role in regulating these processes. Recently, homeobox genes have been detected in both vascular smooth muscle and endothelial cells, and they are implicated in pathological processes such as arterial restenosis after balloon angioplasty and tumor-induced angiogenesis. The cellular function of some of these genes is beginning to be elucidated. Therefore, we briefly review what is currently known about the involvement of homeobox transcription factors in both physiological and pathological vascular remodeling and angiogenesis.

Genomic organization, sequence and chromosomal localization of the mouse Tbr2 gene and a comparative study with Tbr1

Members of the T-box family are known to play critical roles in the embryonic development of most animal species. Recently, we have isolated its new mammalian member, Tbr2, from mouse embryonic brain. We have also shown that the expression patterns of Tbr2 and the closely related Tbr1 appear to be reciprocal in the developing brain; Tbr2 is expressed in mesencephalon and rhombencephalon, but expression of Tbr1 is restricted to telencephalon. To investigate possible structural and functional relationships of Tbr2 and other T-box containing genes, we analyzed genomic organization of the murine Tbr2 gene. The Tbr2 gene is composed of six exons (1353, 155, 122, 159, 62 and 1035bp), and five introns (920, 643, 602, 85 and 2036bp). This exon/intron organization is very similar to that of Tbr1. We also analyzed the 3.9kb sequence of the 5' promoter region flanking the Tbr2 gene and the corresponding region of the Tbr1 gene. The sites for Brn-2 and Tst-1 were found in the promoter of Tbr2 but not Tbr1. On the contrary, there were eight HNF-3beta binding sites in the Tbr1 gene promoter but only three in the Tbr2 promoter. The differential presence of putative binding sites for these brain-specific transcription factors may explain the reciprocal expression of Tbr1 and Tbr2. Furthermore, a single chromosomal locus for mouse Tbr2 was assigned to 9F3 by fluorescence in-situ hybridization 1.

Pax1/Pax9-Related genes in an agnathan vertebrate, Lampetra japonica: expression pattern of LjPax9 implies sequential evolutionary events toward the gnathostome body plan

Among the transcription factor gene families, Pax genes play important and unique roles in morphological patterning of animal body plans. Of these, Group I Pax genes (Pax1 and Pax9) are expressed in the endodermal pharyngeal pouches in many groups of deuterostomes, and vertebrates seem to have acquired more extensive expression domains in embryos. To understand the evolution of Pax1/Pax9-related genes in basal groups of vertebrates, their cognates were isolated from the Japanese marine lamprey, Lampetra japonica. RT-PCR of larval lamprey cDNA yielded two different fragments containing vertebrate Pax1- and Pax9-like paired domains. The Pax9 orthologue was isolated and named LjPax9. Whole-mount in situ hybridization revealed that this gene was expressed in endodermal pharyngeal pouches, mesenchyme of the velum (the oral pumping apparatus) and the hyoid arch, and the nasohypophysial plate, but not in the somitic mesoderm of the lamprey embryo. These expression patterns could be regarded as a link between the basal chordates and the gnathostomes and are consistent with the phylogenetic position of the lamprey. Especially, the appearance of neural crest seemed to be the basis of velar expression. Homology of the velum and the jaw is also discussed based on the LjPax9 expression in the first pharyngeal pouch and in the velar mesenchyme. We conclude that Pax9 genes have sequentially expanded into new expression domains through evolution as more complicated body plans emerged.

Gata3 loss leads to embryonic lethality due to noradrenaline deficiency of the sympathetic nervous system

Mouse embryos deficient in Gata3 die by 11 days post coitum (d.p.c.) from pathology of undetermined origin. We recently showed that Gata3-directed lacZ expression of a 625-kb Gata3 YAC transgene in mice mimics endogenous Gata3 expression, except in thymus and the sympathoadrenal system. As this transgene failed to overcome embryonic lethality (unpublished data and ref. 3) in Gata3-/- mice, we hypothesized that a neuroendocrine deficiency in the sympathetic nervous system (SNS) might cause embryonic lethality in these mutants. We find here that null mutation of Gata3 leads to reduced accumulation of Th (encoding tyrosine hydroxylase, Th) and Dbh (dopamine beta-hydroxylase, Dbh) mRNA, whereas several other SNS genes are unaffected. We show that Th and Dbh deficiencies lead to reduced noradrenaline in the SNS, and that noradrenaline deficiency is a proximal cause of death in mutants by feeding catechol intermediates to pregnant dams, thereby partially averting Gata3 mutation-induced lethality. These older, pharmacologically rescued mutants revealed abnormalities that previously could not be detected in untreated mutants. These late embryonic defects include renal hypoplasia and developmental defects in structures derived from cephalic neural crest cells. Thus we have shown that Gata3 has a role in the differentiation of multiple cell lineages during embryogenesis.

Ror2, encoding a receptor-like tyrosine kinase, is required for cartilage and growth plate development

Receptor tyrosine kinases often have critical roles in particular cell lineages by initiating signalling cascades in those lineages. Examples include the neural-specific TRK receptors, the VEGF and angiopoietin endothelial-specific receptors, and the muscle-specific MUSK receptor. Many lineage-restricted receptor tyrosine kinases were initially identified as 'orphans' homologous to known receptors, and only subsequently used to identify their unknown growth factors. Some receptor-tyrosine-kinase-like orphans still lack identified ligands as well as biological roles. Here we characterize one such orphan, encoded by Ror2 (ref. 12). We report that disruption of mouse Ror2 leads to profound skeletal abnormalities, with essentially all endochondrally derived bones foreshortened or misshapen, albeit to differing degrees. Further, we find that Ror2 is selectively expressed in the chondrocytes of all developing cartilage anlagen, where it essential during initial growth and patterning, as well as subsequently in the proliferating chondrocytes of mature growth plates, where it is required for normal expansion. Thus, Ror2 encodes a receptor-like tyrosine kinase that is selectively expressed in, and particularly important for, the chondrocyte lineage.

All for one and one for all: condensations and the initiation of skeletal development

Condensation is the pivotal stage in the development of skeletal and other mesenchymal tissues. It occurs when a previously dispersed population of cells gathers together to differentiate into a single cell/tissue type such as cartilage, bone, muscle, tendon, kidney, and lung and is the earliest stage during organ formation when tissue-specific genes are upregulated. We present a synopsis of our current understanding of how condensations are initiated and grown, how their boundaries and sizes are set, how condensation ceases, and how overt differentiation begins. Extracellular matrix molecules, cell surface receptors and cell adhesion molecules, such as fibronectin, tenascin, syndecan, and N-CAM, initiate condensation formation and set condensation boundaries. Hox genes (Hoxd-11-13) and other transcription factors (CFKH-1, MFH-1, osf-2), modulate the proliferation of cells within condensations. Cell adhesion is ensured indirectly through Hox genes (Hoxa-2, Hoxd-13), and directly via cell adhesion molecules (N-CAM and N-cadherin). Subsequent growth of condensations is regulated by BMPs, which activate Pax-2, Hoxa-2 and Hoxd-11 among other genes. Growth of a condensation ceases when Noggin inhibits BMP signalling, setting the stage for transition to the next stage of skeletal development, namely overt cell differentiation. BioEssays 22:138-147, 2000.

Netrin 1 is required for semicircular canal formation in the mouse inner ear

The morphogenetic development of the mammalian inner ear is a complex multistep process, the molecular and cellular details of which are only beginning to be unraveled. We show here that mouse netrin 1, known to be involved in axon guidance and cell migration in the central nervous system, also plays a critical morphogenetic role during semicircular canal formation. netrin 1 is expressed at high levels in the otic epithelium, in cells that will come together to form a fusion plate, a prerequisite for the formation of semicircular canals. In netrin 1 mutant mice, fusion plate formation is severely affected resulting in a reduced anterior semicircular canal and the complete lack of the posterior and lateral canals. Our results suggest that netrin 1 facilitates semicircular canal formation through two different mechanisms: (1) it participates in the detachment of the fusion plate epithelia from the basement membrane, and (2) it stimulates proliferation of the periotic mesenchymal cells which then push the epithelial cell walls together to form the fusion plate.

Pax1 and Pax9 synergistically regulate vertebral column development

The paralogous genes Pax1 and Pax9 constitute one group within the vertebrate Pax gene family. They encode closely related transcription factors and are expressed in similar patterns during mouse embryogenesis, suggesting that Pax1 and Pax9 act in similar developmental pathways. We have recently shown that mice homozygous for a defined Pax1 null allele exhibit morphological abnormalities of the axial skeleton, which is not affected in homozygous Pax9 mutants. To investigate a potential interaction of the two genes, we analysed Pax1/Pax9 double mutant mice. These mutants completely lack the medial derivatives of the sclerotomes, the vertebral bodies, intervertebral discs and the proximal parts of the ribs. This phenotype is much more severe than that of Pax1 single homozygous mutants. In contrast, the neural arches, which are derived from the lateral regions of the sclerotomes, are formed. The analysis of Pax9 expression in compound mutants indicates that both spatial expansion and upregulation of Pax9 expression account for its compensatory function during sclerotome development in the absence of Pax1. In Pax1/Pax9 double homozygous mutants, formation and anteroposterior polarity of sclerotomes, as well as induction of a chondrocyte-specific cell lineage, appear normal. However, instead of a segmental arrangement of vertebrae and intervertebral disc anlagen, a loose mesenchyme surrounding the notochord is formed. The gradual loss of Sox9 and Collagen II expression in this mesenchyme indicates that the sclerotomes are prevented from undergoing chondrogenesis. The first detectable defect is a low rate of cell proliferation in the ventromedial regions of the sclerotomes after sclerotome formation but before mesenchymal condensation normally occurs. At later stages, an increased number of cells undergoing apoptosis further reduces the area normally forming vertebrae and intervertebral discs. Our results reveal functional redundancy between Pax1 and Pax9 during vertebral column development and identify an early role of Pax1 and Pax9 in the control of cell proliferation during early sclerotome development. In addition, our data indicate that the development of medial and lateral elements of vertebrae is regulated by distinct genetic pathways.

Development of the vertebrate ear: insights from knockouts and mutants

The three divisions of the ear (outer, middle and inner) each have an important role in hearing, while the inner ear is also crucial for the sense of balance. How these three major components arise and coalesce to form the peripheral elements of the senses of hearing and balance is now being studied using molecular-genetic approaches. This article summarizes data from studies of knockout and mutant animals in which one or more divisions of the ear are abnormal. The data confirm that development of all three divisions of the ear depends on the genes involved in hindbrain segmentation and segment identity. Genes that are regionally expressed in the inner ear can, when absent or mutated, yield selective ablation of specific inner-ear structures or cell types.