Vitamin A-deficient quail embryos have half a hindbrain and other neural defects

Abnormal anteroposterior and dorsoventral patterning of the limb bud in the absence of retinoids

We describe here how the early limb bud of the quail embryo develops in the absence of retinoids, including retinoic acid. Retinoid-deficient embryos develop to about stage 20/21, thus allowing patterns of early gene activity in the limb bud to be readily examined. Genes representing different aspects of limb polarity were analysed. Concerning the anteroposterior axis, Hoxb-8 was up-regulated and its border was shifted anteriorly whereas shh and the mesodermal expression of bmp-2 were down-regulated in the absence of retinoids. Concerning the apical ectodermal genes, fgf-4 was down-regulated whereas fgf-8 and the ectodermal domain of bmp-2 were unaffected. Genes involved in dorsoventral polarity were all disrupted. Wnt-7a, normally confined to the dorsal ectoderm, was ectopically expressed in the ventral ectoderm and the corresponding dorsal mesodermal gene Lmx-1 spread into the ventral mesoderm. En-1 was partially or completely absent from the ventral ectoderm. These dorsoventral patterns of expression resemble those seen in En-1 knockout mouse limb buds. Overall, the patterns of gene expression are also similar to the Japanese limbless mutant. These experiments demonstrate that the retinoid-deficient embryo is a valuable tool for dissecting pathways of gene activity in the limb bud and reveal for the first time a role for retinoic acid in the organisation of the dorsoventral axis.

Mechanism of hyperthermia effects on CNS development: rostral gene expression domains remain, despite severe head truncation; and the hindbrain/otocyst relationship is altered

To study the mechanism of hyperthermia on the development of the rostral neural tube, we used a model in which closely-staged presomite 9.5-day rat embryos were exposed in culture to 43 degrees C for 13 min, and then cultured further for 12-48 hr. This treatment had little effect on the development of the rest of the embryo, but resulted in a spectrum of brain defects, the most severe being a lack of all forebrain and midbrain structures. Whole-mount in situ hybridisation was used to monitor the expression domains of Otx2, Emx2, Krox20, and hoxb1. These showed that there were no ectopic expression patterns, for any gene at any stage examined. Even in those embryos which apparently lacked all forebrain and midbrain structures, there were expression domains of Otx2 and Emx2 in the most rostral neural tissue, and these retained their nested dorso-ventral boundaries, showing that cells fated to form rostral brain were not wholly eliminated. Thus, heat-induced rostral neural tube truncation is of a quite different mechanism from the respecification proposed for retinoic acid, despite their very similar phenotypes. In the hindbrain region of treated embryos, we observed decreased intensity of Krox20, staining and an abnormal relationship developed between the position of hoxb1 expression and the otocyst and pharyngeal arches. In the most extreme cases, this domain was shifted to be more caudal than the rostral edge of the otocyst, while the otocyst retained its normal position relative to the pharyngeal arches. We interpret this as a growth imbalance between neuroepithelium and overlying tissues, perhaps due to a disruption of signals from the midbrain/hindbrain boundary.

Role of retinoids in the CNS: differential expression of retinoid binding proteins and receptors and evidence for presence of retinoic acid

Retinoic acid (RA), a retinoid metabolite, acts as a gene regulator via ligand-activated transcription factors, known as retinoic acid receptors (RARs) and retinoid X receptors (RXRs), both existing in three different subtypes, alpha, beta and gamma. In the intracellular regulation of retinoids, four binding proteins have been implicated: cellular retinol binding protein (CRBP) types I and II and cellular retinoic acid binding protein (CRABP) types I and II. We have used in situ hybridization to localize mRNA species encoding CRBP- and CRABP I and II as well as all the different nuclear receptors in the developing and adult rat and mouse central nervous system (CNS), an assay to investigate the possible presence of RA, and immunohistochemistry to also analyse CRBP I- and CRABP immunoreactivity (IR). RXRbeta is found in most areas while RARalpha and -beta and RXRalpha and -gamma show much more restricted patterns of expression. RARalpha is found in cortex and hippocampus and RARbeta and RXRgamma are both highly expressed in the dopamine-innervated areas caudate/putamen, nucleus accumbens and olfactory tubercle. RARgamma could not be detected in any part of the CNS. Using an in vitro reporter assay, we found high levels of RA in the developing striatum. The caudate/putamen of the developing brain showed strong CRBP I-IR in a compartmentalized manner, while at the same time containing many evenly distributed CRABP I-IR neurons. The CRBP I- and CRABP I-IR patterns were closely paralleled by the presence of the corresponding transcripts. The specific expression pattern of retinoid-binding proteins and nuclear retinoid receptors as well as the presence of RA in striatum suggests that retinoids are important in many brain structures and emphasizes a role for retinoids in gene regulatory events in postnatal and adult striatum.

Differential expression of retinoid receptors in the adult mouse central nervous system

The immunocytochemical distribution of retinoid receptors has been analysed in the mouse adult central nervous system. All retinoic acid receptors (alpha, beta and gamma) and retinoid X receptors (alpha, beta and gamma) were detected and found to exhibit specific patterns of expression in various areas of the telencephalon, diencephalon and rhombencephalon. The protein localization of several retinoic acid receptors and retinoid X receptors did not correlate with the distribution of the corresponding RNA transcripts, as studied by in situ hybridization and RNase protection assays. This suggests that the expression of retinoid receptors could be post-transcriptionally regulated, which may contribute to their specific localization in the adult nervous system.

Distinct functions for Aldh1 and Raldh2 in the control of ligand production for embryonic retinoid signaling pathways

During vertebrate embryogenesis retinoic acid (RA) synthesis must be spatiotemporally regulated in order to appropriately stimulate various retinoid signaling pathways. Various forms of mammalian aldehyde dehydrogenase (ALDH) have been shown to oxidize the vitamin A precursor retinal to RA in vitro. Here we show that injection of Xenopus embryos with mRNAs for either mouse Aldh1 or mouse Raldh2 stimulates RA synthesis at low and high levels, respectively, while injection of human ALDH3 mRNA is unable to stimulate any detectable level of RA synthesis. This provides evidence that some members of the ALDH gene family can indeed perform RA synthesis in vivo. Whole-mount immunohistochemical analyses of mouse embryos indicate that ALDH1 and RALDH2 proteins are localized in distinct tissues. RALDH2 is detected at E7.5-E10.5 primarily in trunk tissue (paraxial mesoderm, somites, pericardium, midgut, mesonephros) plus transiently from E8.5-E9.5 in the ventral optic vesicle and surrounding frontonasal region. ALDH1 is first detected at E9.0-E10. 5 primarily in cranial tissues (ventral mesencephalon, dorsal retina, thymic primordia, otic vesicles) and in the mesonephros. As previous findings indicate that embryonic RA is more abundant in trunk rather than cranial tissues, our findings suggest that Raldh2 and Aldh1 control distinct retinoid signaling pathways by stimulating high and low RA biosynthetic activities, respectively, in various trunk and cranial tissues.

Regionalized metabolic activity establishes boundaries of retinoic acid signalling

The competence of a cell to respond to the signalling molecule retinoic acid (RA) is thought to depend largely on its repertoire of cognate zinc finger nuclear receptors. XCYP26 is an RA hydroxylase that is expressed differentially during early Xenopus development. In Xenopus embryos, XCYP26 can rescue developmental defects induced by application of exogenous RA, suggesting that the enzymatic modifications introduced inhibit RA signalling activities in vivo. Alterations in the expression pattern of a number of different molecular markers for neural development induced upon ectopic expression of XCYP26 reflect a primary function of RA signalling in hindbrain development. Progressive inactivation of RA signalling results in a stepwise anteriorization of the molecular identity of individual rhombomeres. The expression pattern of XCYP26 during gastrulation appears to define areas within the prospective neural plate that develop in response to different concentrations of RA. Taken together, these observations appear to reflect an important regulatory function of XCYP26 for RA signalling; XCYP26-mediated modification of RA modulates its signalling activity and helps to establish boundaries of differentially responsive and non-responsive territories.

Neurons derived in vitro from ES cells express homeoproteins characteristic of motoneurons and interneurons

We have characterized different neuronal subpopulations derived from in vitro differentiation of embryonic stem (ES) cells using as markers the expression of several homeodomain transcription factors. Following treatment of embryo-like aggregates with retinoic acid (RA), Pax-6, a protein expressed by ventral central nervous system (CNS) progenitors is induced. In contrast, Pax-7 expressed in vivo by dorsal CNS progenitors, and erbB3, a gene expressed by neural crest cells and its derivatives, are almost undetectable. CNS neuronal subpopulations generated expressed combinations of markers characteristic of somatic motoneurons (Islet-1/2, Lim-3, and HB-9), cranial motoneurons (Islet-1/2 and Phox2b) and interneurons (Lim-1/2 or EN1). Molecular characterization of neuron subtypes generated from ES cells should considerably facilitate the identification of new genes expressed by restricted neuronal cell lineages.

The RXRalpha ligand-dependent activation function 2 (AF-2) is important for mouse development

We have engineered a mouse mutation that specifically deletes the C-terminal 18 amino acid sequence of the RXRalpha protein. This deletion corresponds to the last helical alpha structure (H12) of the ligand-binding domain (LBD), and includes the core of the Activating Domain of the Activation Function 2 (AF-2 AD core) that is thought to be crucial in mediating ligand-dependent transactivation by RXRalpha. The homozygous mutants (RXRalpha af2(o)), which die during the late fetal period or at birth, exhibit a subset of the abnormalities previously observed in RXRalpha −/− mutants, often with incomplete penetrance. In marked contrast, RXRalpha af2(o)/RXRbeta −/− and RXRalpha af2(o)/RXRbeta −/− /RXRgamma −/− compound mutants display a large array of malformations, which nearly recapitulate the full spectrum of the defects that characterize the fetal vitamin A-deficiency (VAD) syndrome and were previously found in RAR single and compound mutants, as well as in RXRalpha/RAR(alpha, beta or gamma) compound mutants. Analysis of RXRalpha af2(o)/RAR(alpha, beta or gamma) compound mutants also revealed that they exhibit many of the defects observed in the corresponding RXR alpha/RAR compound mutants. Together, these results demonstrate the importance of the integrity of RXR AF-2 for the developmental functions mediated by RAR/RXR heterodimers, and hence suggest that RXR ligand-dependent transactivation is instrumental in retinoid signalling during development.

Vertebrate development: a nervous vitamin

The vitamin A-related retinoids have recently been shown to be involved in the development of the central nervous system, both in specifying position along the head-to-tail axis and in the development of a specific subset of motor neurons.

Defects in embryonic hindbrain development and fetal resorption resulting from vitamin A deficiency in the rat are prevented by feeding pharmacological levels of all-trans-retinoic acid

Vitamin A is required for reproduction and normal embryonic development. We have determined that all-trans-retinoic acid (atRA) can support development of the mammalian embryo to parturition in vitamin A-deficient (VAD) rats. At embryonic day (E) 0.5, VAD dams were fed purified diets containing either 12 micrograms of atRA per g of diet (230 micrograms per rat per day) or 250 micrograms of atRA per g of diet (4.5 mg per rat per day) or were fed the purified diet supplemented with a source of retinol (100 units of retinyl palmitate per day). An additional group was fed both 250 micrograms of atRA per g of diet in combination with retinyl palmitate. Embryonic survival to E12.5 was similar for all groups. However, embryonic development in the group fed 12 micrograms of atRA per g of diet was grossly abnormal. The most notable defects were in the region of the hindbrain, which included a loss of posterior cranial nerves (IX, X, XI, and XII) and postotic pharyngeal arches as well as the presence of ectopic otic vesicles and a swollen anterior cardinal vein. All embryonic abnormalities at E12.5 were prevented by feeding pharmacological amounts of atRA (250 micrograms/g diet) or by supplementation with retinyl palmitate. Embryos from VAD dams receiving 12 micrograms of atRA per g of diet were resorbed by E18.5, whereas those in the group fed 250 micrograms of atRA per g of diet survived to parturition but died shortly thereafter. Equivalent results were obtained by using commercial grade atRA or atRA that had been purified to eliminate any potential contamination by neutral retinoids, such as retinol. Thus, 250 micrograms of atRA per g of diet fed to VAD dams (approximately 4.5 mg per rat per day) can prevent the death of embryos at midgestation and prevents the early embryonic abnormalities that arise when VAD dams are fed insufficient amounts of atRA.

The distribution of endogenous retinoic acid in the chick embryo: implications for developmental mechanisms

The aim of these experiments was to determine the endogenous distribution of retinoic acid (RA) across a wide range of embryonic stages in the chick embryo. By high pressure liquid chromatography, it was revealed that didehydroRA is the most prevalent retinoic acid in the chick embryo and that the tissues of the stage 24 embryo differed widely in their total RA content (didehydroRA + all-trans-RA). Some tissues such as the heart had very little RA and some such as the neural tube had very high levels, the total variation between these two being 29-fold. We showed that these tissues also synthesised RA and released it into the medium, thus validating the use of the F9 reporter cell system for further analyses of younger staged embryos. With these F9 cells, we showed that, at stage 4, the posterior end of the embryo had barely detectably higher levels of RA than the anterior end, but that a significant level of RA generation was detected as soon as somitogenesis began. Then a sharp on/off boundary of RA was present at the level of the first somite. We could find no evidence for a posterior-to-anterior gradient of RA. Throughout further development, various consistent observations were made: the developing brain did not generate RA, but the spinal part of the neural tube generated it at very high levels so there must be a sharp on/off boundary in the region of the hindbrain/spinal cord junction; the mesenchyme surrounding the hindbrain generated RA whereas the hindbrain itself did not; there was a variation in RA levels from the midline outwards with the highest levels of RA in the spinal neural tube followed by lower levels in the somites followed by lower levels in the lateral plate; the posterior half of the limb bud generated higher levels than the anterior half. With these observations, we were able to draw maps of endogenous RA throughout these early stages of chick embryogenesis and the developmental implications of these results are discussed.

Initial retinoid requirement for early avian development coincides with retinoid receptor coexpression in the precardiac fields and induction of normal cardiovascular development

Vitamin A requirement for early embryonic development is clearly evident in the gross cardiovascular and central nervous system abnormalities and an early death of the vitamin A-deficient quail embryo. This retinoid knockout model system was used to examine the biological activity of various natural retinoids in early cardiovascular development. We demonstrate that all-trans-, 9-cis-, 4-oxo-, and didehydroretinoic acids, and didehydroretinol and all-trans-retinol induce and maintain normal cardiovascular development as well as induce expression of the retinoic acid receptor beta2 in the vitamin A-deficient quail embryo. The expression of RARbeta2 is at the same level and at the same sites where it is expressed in the normal embryo. Retinoids provided to the vitamin A-deficient embryo up to the 5-somite stage of development, but not later, completely rescue embryonic development, suggesting the 5-somite stage as a critical retinoid-sensitive time point during early avian embryogenesis. Retinoid receptors RARalpha, RARgamma, and RXRalpha are expressed in both the precardiac endoderm and mesoderm in the normal and the vitamin A-deficient quail embryo, while the expression of RXRgamma is restricted to precardiac endoderm. Vitamin A deficiency downregulates the expression of RARalpha and RARbeta. Our studies provide strong evidence for a narrow retinoid-requiring developmental window during early embryogenesis, in which the presence of bioactive retinoids and their receptors is essential for a subsequent normal embryonic development.

How to build a vertebrate hindbrain. Lessons from genetics

During vertebrate embryogenesis, the hindbrain is the site of a segmentation process which leads to the formation, along the anterior-posterior axis, of 7-8 metameres called rhombomeres. This phenomenon plays an essential role in early hindbrain regionalisation and in the specification of the pattern of developing structures in this region of the brain. Data accumulated during the last 10 years have also shown that rhombomeres are units of gene expression and of cell lineage. Hence, a number of regulatory genes are expressed according to segment-specific patterns in the hindbrain and have been implicated in the pattern formation process. In this review, we focus on the analysis of the function and regulation of these genes along the different steps of hindbrain segmentation, from segment delimitation to acquisition of positional identity. On this basis, we propose a model for the control of early hindbrain development.

Regional pattern of retinoid X receptor-alpha gene expression in the central nervous system of the chicken embryo and its up-regulation by exposure to 9-cis retinoic acid

We have investigated the expression of the retinoid X receptor-alpha (RXRalpha) gene in the developing chicken embryo by using nonradioactive wholemount in situ hybridization. At the earliest stage of development examined (stage 9; Hamburger and Hamilton [1951] J. Morphol. 88:49-92), we detect RXRalpha transcripts in a stretch of neuroepithelium corresponding roughly to the presumptive caudal hindbrain. Upon formation of the rhombomeres at stage 12, a strongly RXRalpha-positive region extends from a sharp rostral limit at the boundary between rhombomeres 6 and 7 caudad to at least the level of somite 9. This pattern of highest expression continues at least until stage 22 but with some variability in the caudal extent. A lower level of expression extends throughout the spinal cord. Transverse sections show that RXRalpha transcripts are expressed in a gradient, with the highest levels near the roof plate and decreasing toward the floor plate. At later stages, the level of expression is highest in the proliferative ventricular zone. However, at reduced levels, RXRalpha transcripts are also detectable in the mantle zone as well as outside the developing central nervous system, for example, in the neural crest and the limb buds. Nine-cis-retinoic acid up-regulates RXRalpha transcripts at stages 19.5-22.0 within a few hours, augmenting but not expanding the expression pattern. Northern blots demonstrate the potential expression of multiple RXRalpha isoforms in the central nervous system at posthatch stages. These results implicate the RXRalpha receptor in both rostrocaudal and transverse patterning of the neural tube.

Graded retinoid responses in the developing hindbrain

The purpose of this study was to make an explicit test of the idea that a retinoid could act as a morphogen, differentially activating genes and specifying anteroposterior (a-p) level in the developing vertebrate central nervous system (CNS). Our approach was to characterize the concentration-dependent effects of retinoic acid (RA) on the neural expression of a set of a-p patterning genes, both in vivo and in an in vitro system for neural patterning. Our results indicate that a retinoid is unlikely to specify a-p level along the entire CNS. Instead, our data support the idea that the developing hindbrain may be patterned by a retinoid gradient. Sequentially more posterior hindbrain patterning genes were induced effectively by sequentially higher RA concentration windows. The most posterior CNS level induced under our RA treatment conditions corresponded to the most posterior part of the hindbrain.

Initiation of rhombomeric Hoxb4 expression requires induction by somites and a retinoid pathway

Anteroposterior (AP) patterning in the vertebrate hindbrain is dependent upon the establishment of segmental domains of Hox expression. We investigated the mechanism that governs the early expression of Hoxb4 and found that transient signaling from the paraxial mesoderm induces expression in the hindbrain. Induction involves a retinoid pathway requiring retinoic acid receptor (RAR) function within the neural plate. Characterization of a prerhombomeric enhancer from Hoxb4 reveals that a retinoic acid (RA) response element is an essential component of the early neural response to somite (s) signaling and can interpret positional information for setting the anterior boundary of expression. These data suggest a mechanism whereby, during normal hindbrain development, Hoxb4 expression is initiated by extrinsic signals and is subsequently maintained by Hox feedback circuits. This mechanism also accounts for the ectopic response of Hoxb4 in rhombomere (r) transpositions and after exposure to retinoids.

Involvement of thyroid hormone and its alpha receptor in avian neurulation

We have analyzed the expression pattern of c-erb A alpha and c-erb A beta which encode the thyroid hormone receptors (T3R alpha and T3R beta) during early chicken embryogenesis. Only c-erb A alpha expression was detected by RT-PCR and whole-mount in situ hybridization. c-erb A alpha transcripts were found to be already present at low level in embryos before egg incubation. During neurulation a marked increase was observed in neurectoderm. A reporter cell line was then constructed and used to demonstrate the release of significant amount of thyroid hormone (T3) from egg yolk by area opaca cells before gastrulation. During gastrulation T3 was found to be enriched in the primitive streak and Hensen's node. Introduction of excess T3 frequently resulted in abnormal development of anterior structures, mainly neural tube defects and anencephalia. These observations suggest that T3R alpha, like the closely related retinoic acid receptors, fulfills functions which are important for embryonic development well before the onset of thyroid gland function.

Genetic interactions between Hoxa1 and Hoxb1 reveal new roles in regulation of early hindbrain patterning

In the developing vertebrate hindbrain Hoxa1 and Hoxb1 play important roles in patterning segmental units (rhombomeres). In this study, genetic analysis of double mutants demonstrates that both Hoxa1 and Hoxb1 participate in the establishment and maintenance of Hoxb1 expression in rhombomere 4 through auto- and para-regulatory interactions. The generation of a targeted mutation in a Hoxb1 3′ retinoic acid response element (RARE) shows that it is required for establishing early high levels of Hoxb1 expression in neural ectoderm. Double mutant analysis with this Hoxb1(3′RARE) allele and other targeted loss-of-function alleles from both Hoxa1 and Hoxb1 reveals synergy between these genes. In the absence of both genes, a territory appears in the region of r4, but the earliest r4 marker, the Eph tyrosine kinase receptor EphA2, fails to be activated. This suggests a failure to initiate rather than maintain the specification of r4 identity and defines new roles for both Hoxb1 and Hoxa1 in early patterning events in r4. Our genetic analysis shows that individual members of the vertebrate labial-related genes have multiple roles in different steps governing segmental processes in the developing hindbrain.

Alcohol dehydrogenase as a critical mediator of retinoic acid synthesis from vitamin A in the mouse embryo

Vitamin A (retinol) must be metabolized to an active retinoid ligand in order to fulfill all of its roles in vertebrate development. During retinoid signaling, retinol is first converted to retinal followed by conversion of retinal to the active ligand retinoic acid, which modulates nuclear retinoic acid receptors (RAR). The alcohol dehydrogenase (ADH) enzyme family may function in the metabolism of retinol, the alcohol form of vitamin A, as well as ethanol metabolism. Some members of the ADH family prefer retinol as a substrate over ethanol, and their ability to oxidize retinol is competitively inhibited by intoxicating levels of ethanol. Likewise, there exists an aldehyde dehydrogenase (ALDH) family containing several members preferring retinal as a substrate over acetaldehyde. The spatiotemporal expression patterns of ADH-IV and two forms of ALDH match the spatiotemporal detection of retinoic acid during mouse embryogenesis, i.e., no detection at 6.5 d of embryogenesis (E6.5), followed by detection at E7.5 in the primitive streak, and then detection in numerous tissues later in development. This suggests that certain forms of ADH and ALDH may cooperate to upregulated retinoic acid synthesis during development. Treatment of mouse embryos at E7.5 with an intoxicating amount of ethanol leads to a reduction in retinoic acid levels. At E7.5, two other mouse enzymes known to metabolize ethanol (ADH-I and P450 2E1) are not expressed, indicating that ADH-IV may be the only enzyme available at this stage to metabolize both ethanol and retinol. These findings suggest that ADH-IV participates in the initiation of retinoid signaling by functioning as a retinol dehydrogenase and that this can be inhibited by ethanol intoxication.

The role of vitamin A in the development of the central nervous system

We describe here the defects that arise in the central nervous system (CNS) of quail embryos when they develop in the absence of vitamin A. It has been assumed that because of the effects of excess vitamin A and its metabolites, particularly retinoic acid (RA), on the CNS they are involved in various aspects of CNS development. We show that this is indeed the case, because these deficient quail embryos have three defects in their CNS. First, the posterior hindbrain fails to develop because the cells fated to form this part of the CNS in the very early embryo die by apoptosis. Second, the neural tube fails to extend neurites into the periphery both in vivo and in vitro. Third, the neural crest cells throughout the embryo die by apoptosis. These results demonstrate a crucial requirement for vitamin A in CNS development.

Vitamin A and embryonic development: an overview

Vitamin A is an essential micronutrient throughout the life cycle. Its active form, retinoic acid via retinoid receptors, is involved in signal transduction pathways regulating development. Both the lack and excess of vitamin A during embryonic development result in congenital malformations. Approaches to examine the function of vitamin A in embryonic development have included treatment with excess retinoids and the use of retinoid receptor knock-out mice, which have provided important insights into the complexity of the retinoid signaling system. A recently explored model is the retinoid ligand knock-out, i.e., the vitamin A-deficient embryo. Early development can be successfully examined in the vitamin A-deficient avian embryo, in which bioactive retinoids can rescue the deficient genotype as well as phenotype. In this model it has been possible to unequivocally link the physiological function of vitamin A to development of heart, embryonal circulatory and central nervous systems and the regulation of heart asymmetry. Several developmental genes regulated by endogenous vitamin A during early embryogenesis have been identified. Retinoid receptors and their endogenous ligands, the vitamin A-active forms, are present in the early embryo. It is the developmentally regulated biogeneration of the vitamin A-active forms via distinct spatio-temporal metabolic pathways that is critically linked to the initiation of retinoid signal transduction during embryonic development.

The development of the vertebrate inner ear

The inner ear is a complex sensory organ responsible for balance and sound detection in vertebrates. It originates from a transient embryonic structure, the otic vesicle, that contains all of the information to develop autonomously into the mature inner ear. We review here the development of the otic vesicle, bringing together classical embryological experiments and recent genetic and molecular data. The specification of the prospective ectoderm and its commitment to the otic fate are very early events and can be related to the expression of genes with restricted expression domains. A combinatorial gene expression model for placode specification and diversification, based on classical embryological evidence and gene expression patterns, is discussed. The formation of the otic vesicle is dependent on inducing signals from endoderm, mesoderm and neuroectoderm. Ear induction consists of a sequence of discrete instructions from those tissues that confer its final identity on the otic field, rather than a single all-or-none process. The important role of the neural tube in otic development is highlighted by the abnormalities observed in mouse mutants for the Hoxa1, kreisler and fgf3 genes and those reported in retinoic acid-deficient quails. Still, the nature of the relation between the neural tube and otic development remains unclear. Gene targeting experiments in the mouse have provided evidence for genes potentially involved in regional and cell-fate specification in the inner ear. The disruption of the mouse Brn3.1 gene identifies the first mutation affecting sensory hair-cell specification, and mutants for Pax2 and Nkx5.1 genes show their requirement for the development of specific regions of the otic vesicle. Several growth-factors contribute to the patterned cell proliferation of the otic vesicle. Among these, IGF-I and FGF-2 are expressed in the otic vesicle and may act in an autocrine manner. Finally, little is known about early mechanisms involved in guiding ear innervation. However, targeted disruption of genes coding for neurotrophins and Trk receptors have shown that once synaptic contacts are established, they depend on specific trophic interactions that involve these two gene families. The accessibility of new cellular and molecular approaches are opening new perspectives in vertebrate development and are also starting to be applied to ear development. This will allow this classical and attractive model system to see a rapid progress in the near future.

Retinoids and their receptors in vertebrate embryogenesis

Vitamin A and its derivatives, the retinoids, participate in formation of diverse embryonic structures, including face, heart, eye, limb and nervous system. Studies of retinoid-deficient and -treated embryos, and of receptor null mutants, provide evidence that this participation involves interactions between retinoids and their receptors. Targeted retinoid application and retinoid deficiency, using in ovo avian embryos, has identified early cardiogenic contributions, including cardiocyte gene expression and differentiation, heart tube fusion and laterality, and segmental identity. Also useful is a mammalian model, which targets retinoid deficiency to distinct gestational windows, circumventing limitations of traditional deficiency studies and current null mutant technologies. Rat embryos made deficient in retinoids during gestational d 11.5-13.5 exhibit specific cardiac, limb, ocular and nervous system deficits. That many of the anomalies previously reported in retinoid receptor null mutants are observed in deficiency confirms that ligand-receptor interactions are essential for embryonic development. Other defects are novel, reemphasizing the functional redundancy of retinoid receptors and that retinoid receptors have multiple and overlapping contributions to morphogenesis.

Inhibition of retinoic acid receptor-mediated signalling alters positional identity in the developing hindbrain

Retinoids regulate gene expression via nuclear retinoic acid receptors, the RARs and RXRs. To investigate the functions of retinoid receptors during early neural development, we expressed a dominant negative RARbeta in early Xenopus embryos. We obtained evidence that dominant negative RARbeta specifically inhibits RAR/RXR heterodimer-mediated, but not RXR homodimer-mediated, transactivation. Both all-trans- and 9-cis-RA-induced teratogenesis were, however, efficiently opposed by ectopic expression of dominant negative RARbeta, indicating that only RAR/RXR transactivation is required for retinoid teratogenesis by each of these ligands. Experiments with two RXR-selective ligands confirmed that activation of RXR homodimers does not cause retinoid teratogenesis. Dominant negative RARbeta thus specifically interferes with the retinoid signalling pathway that is responsible for retinoid teratogenesis. Dominant negative RARbeta-expressing embryos had a specific developmental phenotype leading to disorganization of the hindbrain. Mauthner cell multiplications in the posterior hindbrain, and (both anteriorly and posteriorly) expanded Krox-20 expression domains indicated (partial) transformation of a large part of the hindbrain into (at least partial) rhombomere 3, 4 and/or 5 identity. In contrast, the fore- and midbrain and spinal cord appeared to be less affected. These data indicate that RARs play a role in patterning the hindbrain.

Craniofacial abnormalities induced by the ectopic expression of homeobox genes

In this paper I have tried to bring together work that highlights the role of homeobox genes in generating craniofacial form. I review both normal and disrupted embryogenesis and ask whether mis-expression of the homeobox genes outside their normal domains could be contributing to congenital facial abnormalities arising from either genetic or teratogenic actions. Experimentally generated transgenic mice carrying loss- or gain-of-function mutations in homeobox genes, in combination with their normal expression patterns, have allowed us to compile and test models of embryonic specification based around a Hox/homeobox code. These models form the basis on which the functional questions are considered. There are four major sections covering different experimental approaches designed to ectopically induce homeobox genes in the head. Transgenic mice, where heterologous promoters drive a given Hox gene in the head, have shown that the more posteriorly expressed Hox genes tend to have a significant effect only on the skull bones of mesodermal origin whereas those normally expressed more anteriorly, in the hindbrain and branchial arches, can affect more anterior branchial arch and neural crest-derived structures. Manipulation experiments which can induce homeobox genes in small, localised regions of the facial precursors show clear and dramatic effects of this expression on facial development. Null mutations in predicted repressors of Hox gene expression, however, do not appear to give rise to substantial craniofacial abnormalities. Retinoic acid, on the other hand, is well known for its teratogenic actions and its ability to induce Hox gene expression. Evidence is now accumulating that at least some of its teratogenic actions may be mediated by its regulation of the Hox and other homeobox genes in the head.

Retinoic acid mediates Pax6 expression during in vitro differentiation of embryonic stem cells

Neural cells are found rarely during differentiation of embryonic stem (ES) cells in vitro. To increase the yield of neuronal and glial cells from ES cells, we designed a differentiation procedure in which embryoid bodies were grown in medium containing retinoic acid (RA) and a low level (1%) of fetal calf serum. Using this procedure we were able to obtain neurofilament or glial fibrillary acidic protein-positive cells in 90% of outgrowths of embryonic bodies. Differentiation was dependent on the RA concentration, whereas depletion of RA favored the appearance of cardiac muscle cells. Differentiation of ES cells correlated with increased activity of Pax6, a transcription factor involved in central nervous system development. Pax6 was not expressed in undifferentiated ES cells, nor after differentiation by depletion of leukemia inhibitory factor or by overgrowth. After embryoid body formation and subsequent attachment, only infrequently did a few cells express Pax6. Addition of RA resulted in the appearance of Pax6-expressing cells in a concentration-dependent manner, with a peak at 100 nM RA. The presented differentiation procedure can be used for studying the molecular biology of neurogenesis in vitro.

Xenopus hindbrain patterning requires retinoid signaling

We have asked how posterior neural tissue is patterned in Xenopus by assaying the involvement of endogenous retinoic acid (RA) in this process and by using the labial Hox gene, HoxD1, as a posterior marker. Although RA is able to inhibit anterior gene expression and activate expression of more posterior genes, the normal role of retinoids in anteroposterior (A/P) patterning is unclear. HoxD1 is an early posterior neurectodermal marker, expressed from midgastrula with a later anterior expression limit in the future hindbrain. We previously showed that HoxD1 was induced as an immediate early response to retinoic acid in naive ectoderm (animal caps). Here, we use a truncated RARalpha2.2 receptor (RARDelta) to dominantly interfere with retinoid signaling. In embryos injected with RARDelta expression of HoxD1 is eliminated. Conjugates of ectoderm and dorsolateral mesoderm show that retinoid receptors are required in the ectoderm for HoxD1 induction. Further, expression of Krox-20 in r3 and r5 of the presumptive hindbrain is compressed into a single stripe that suggests elimination of r5. RARalpha2.2 expression almost precisely overlaps that of HoxD1, suggesting that this receptor may normally activate HoxD1. Expression of neither more anterior genes including cement gland, forebrain, and midbrain markers nor a more posterior spinal cord marker is affected by RARDelta. These data suggest that the posterior hindbrain is the region of the nervous system most sensitive to retinoid loss. Finally, we compare the ability of RA and fibroblast growth factor (FGF) to posteriorize isolated anterior neurectoderm and show that both factors can act directly on this substrate. RA acts in a more anterior domain than does FGF; however, neither factor is equivalent to the natural posteriorizing capacity of the posterior mesoderm. We propose that endogenous retinoid and FGF signals pattern largely nonoverlapping regions along the A/P axis and that posterior neural patterning requires multiple inducers.

Gastrulation and homeobox genes in chick embryos

We review the early stages of chick embryogenesis, in particular the formation of the hypoblast, and the ingression of endoderm and mesoderm through the primitive streak. The formation of a trilaminar embryo during gastrulation is accompanied by the specification of body axes. The first axis is already present in the unfertilized egg and runs from the cytoplasmatic animal to the yolk rich vegetal pole. Already within the uterus a second axis conveys bilateral symmetry to the embryo. It extends from a dorsal/anterior to a ventral/posterior position. These axial poles segregate during gastrulation to form the classical coordinates, a dorsal-ventral and an anterior-posterior axis. The establishment of axes is accompanied by the expression of specific combinations of homeobox genes during gastrulation in the chick, as in other metazoa. We review the avian specific information and compare it with findings in other species. A combinatorial homeobox code for the specification of identities during development is discussed.

Temporally-regulated retinoic acid depletion produces specific neural crest, ocular and nervous system defects

Both retinoid receptor null mutants and classic nutritional deficiency studies have demonstrated that retinoids are essential for the normal development of diverse embryonic structures (e.g. eye, heart, nervous system, urogenital tract). Detailed analysis of retinoid-modulated events is hampered by several limitations of these models, including that deficiency or null mutation is present throughout gestation, making it difficult to isolate primary effects, and preventing analysis beyond embryolethality. We developed a mammalian model in which retinoid-dependent events are documented during distinct targeted windows of embryogenesis. This was accomplished through the production of vitamin A-depleted (VAD) female rats maintained on sufficient oral retinoic acid (RA) for growth and fertility. After mating to normal males, these RA-sufficient/VAD females were given oral RA doses which allowed for gestation in an RA-sufficient state; embryogenesis proceeded normally until retinoids were withdrawn dietarily to produce a sudden, acute retinoid deficiency during a selected gestational window. In this trial, final RA doses were administered on E11.5, vehicle at E12.5, and embryos analyzed on E13.5; during this 48 hour window, the last RA dose was metabolized and embryos progressed in a retinoid-deficient state. RA-sufficient embryos were normal. Retinoid-depleted embryos exhibited specific malformations of the face, neural crest, eyes, heart, and nervous system. Some defects were phenocopies of those seen in null mutant mice for RXR alpha(−/−), RXR alpha(−/−)/RAR alpha(−/−), and RAR alpha(−/−)/RAR gamma(−/−), confirming that RA transactivation of its nuclear receptors is essential for normal embryogenesis. Other defects were unique to this deficiency model, showing that complete ligand ‘knock-out’ is required to see those retinoid-dependent events previously concealed by receptor functional redundancy, and reinforcing that retinoid receptors have separate yet overlapping contributions in the embryo. This model allows for precise targeting of retinoid form and deficiency to specific developmental windows, and will facilitate studies of distinct temporal events.

Positional apoptosis during vertebrate CNS development in the absence of endogenous retinoids

We have previously shown that quail embryos that develop in the absence of vitamin A have severe defects in their central nervous system. One defect is a completely missing posterior hindbrain. Here we have studied how this comes about by examining cell death using a wholemount technique. In these A- embryos we observe two narrow bands of ectopic apoptosis. One is in the mesenchyme in the region of the first somite and occurs at the 4–6 somite stage, before neural tube closure. The second band follows immediately afterwards and occurs in the neuroepithelium of the presumptive posterior hindbrain at the 6–8 somite stage. Electron microscopy shows that the dying neuroepithelial cells exhibit the characteristics of apoptosis. Rescuing the embryos by injecting retinol before gastrulation completely prevents these apoptotic events. In an effort to identify some of the genes that may be involved in the apoptotic pathway we show that Msx-2 is upregulated in the apoptotic neuroepithelium and thus may be involved, whereas Bmp-4 is not altered and thus presumably not involved. Since these apoptotic event take place at the time of specification of axial identity and segmentation in the mesenchyme and neuroepithelium we conclude that these cells die because they are wrongly specified in terms of their rostrocaudal position, a novel phenomenon which we refer to as positional apoptosis.

Axial (HNF3beta) and retinoic acid receptors are regulators of the zebrafish sonic hedgehog promoter

The signalling molecule Sonic hedgehog is involved in a multitude of distinct patterning processes during vertebrate embryogenesis. In the nascent body axis of the zebrafish embryo, sonic hedgehog is co-expressed with axial (HNF3beta in mammals), a transcription regulator of the winged helix family. We show here that misexpression of axial leads to ectopic activation of sonic hedgehog expression in the zebrafish, suggesting that axial is a regulator of sonic hedgehog transcription. The sonic hedgehog gene was cloned from zebrafish and its promoter was characterized with respect to activation by axial. Expression of axial or rat HNF3beta in HeLa cells results in activation of co-transfected sonic hedgehog promoter-CAT fusion genes. This effect is mediated by two Axial (HNF3beta) recognition sequences. We furthermore identified a retinoic acid response element (RARE) in the sonic hedgehog upstream region which can be bound by retinoic acid receptor (RAR) and retinoid X receptor (RXR) heterodimers in vitro and confers retinoic acid inducibility to the sonic hedgehog promoter in the HeLa cell system. Our results suggest that both Axial (HNF3beta) and retinoic acid receptors are direct regulators of the sonic hedgehog gene.

Cell movements, neuronal organisation and gene expression in hindbrains lacking morphological boundaries

Rhombomeres are segmental units of the hindbrain that are separated from each other by a specialised zone of boundary cells. Retinoic acid application to a recently segmented hindbrain leads to disappearance of posterior rhombomere boundaries. Boundary loss is preceded by changes in segmental expression of Krox-20 and Cek-8 and followed by alterations in Hox gene expression. The characteristic morphology of boundary cells, their expression of follistatin and the periodic accumulation of axons normally associated with boundaries are all lost. In the absence of boundaries, we detect no change in anteroposterior dispersal of precursor cells and, in most cases, no substantial cell mixing between former rhombomeric units. This is consistent with the idea that lineage restriction can be maintained by processes other than a mechanical barrier composed of boundary cells. Much of the early organisation of the motor nuclei appears normal despite the loss of boundaries and altered Hox expression.

Contribution of retinoic acid receptor gamma to retinoid-induced craniofacial and axial defects

Exogenous retinoic acid (RA) administered during mouse embryogenesis can alter the pattern of the axial skeleton during two developmental periods: an early window (7 to 8.5 days post-coitum; dpc) and a late window (9.5 to 11.5 dpc). Treatment during the early window results in vertebral homeotic transformations (predominantly posteriorizations) concomitant with rostral shifts in Hox gene expression, while treatment at the later window results in similar transformations without detectable alterations in Hox gene expression patterns. Mice null for retinoic acid receptor gamma (RAR gamma) exhibit axial defects, including homeosis of several vertebrae, therefore establishing a role for this receptor in normal axial specification RAR gamma null mutants are also completely resistant to RA-induced spina bifida, which occurs in wildtype embryos treated at 8.5-9.0 dpc, suggesting that this receptor specifically transduces at least a subset of the teratogenic effects of retinoids. To further investigate the role of RAR gamma in RA-induced defects during the early and late windows of retinoid-sensitive vertebral patterning, RAR gamma heterozygotes were intercrossed, pregnant females treated with vehicle or RA at 7.3, 10.5 or 11.5 dpc and full-term fetuses assessed for skeletal defects. Relative to wildtype littermates, RAR gamma null mutants treated at 7.3 dpc were markedly resistant to RA-induced embryolethality, craniofacial malformations, and neural tube defects. Furthermore, while RAR gamma null mutants were modestly resistant to certain vertebral malformations elicited by RA treatment at 7.3, they exhibited more pronounced resistance following treatment at 10.5 and 11.5 dpc. Moreover, several of the vertebral defects inherent to the RAR gamma null phenotype were abolished by RA treatment specifically at 10.5 dpc, suggesting that RAR alpha and/or RAR beta isoforms may substitute for certain RAR gamma functions, and that RAR gamma may elicit its normal effects on vertebral morphogenesis at this developmental stage.

The CRABP I gene contains two separable, redundant regulatory regions active in neural tissues in transgenic mouse embryos

The CRABP I gene is expressed in a spatiotemporal pattern in neural and mesenchymal tissues at the onset of organogenesis. The neural pattern of CRABP I expression includes specific rhombomeres of the hindbrain, neural crest cells and their derivatives the optic stalk, and the central area of the neural retina. We have created transgenic mouse lines with CRABP I 5' and transcribed regions fused to the lacZ structural gene that recapitulate much of this neural pattern of expression. Sequences 5' of the transcription initiation site between -7.8 and -3.2 kb confer beta-galactosidase expression to specific rhombomeres, migrating neural crest cells, trigeminal ganglion, the optic stalk, and the neural retina. We have also defined a region located between exon 1 and exon 8 that confers a portion of this expression pattern, including the mesencephalic projections of the trigeminal ganglion, the inner layer of the neural retina, and the peripheral layer of the posterior hindbrain. CRABP I expression in mesenchyme appears to require sequences in addition to or outside of those examined here.

Initiation of retinoid signaling in primitive streak mouse embryos: spatiotemporal expression patterns of receptors and metabolic enzymes for ligand synthesis

The requirement of vitamin A (retinol) for successful completion of vertebrate embryogenesis is well established. Retinoid signaling involves a two-step metabolic event in which retinol is first converted to retinal, and then retinal is converted to the active ligand retinoic acid, which modulates the transcriptional activity of a nuclear retinoic acid receptor (RAR). During mouse embryogenesis, retinoic acid is not detected at 6.5 days of embryonic development (E6.5) when gastrulation first initiates, but it is detected at E7.5 and later. This suggests that retinoid signaling during embryogenesis may be initiated during the primitive streak stage. Here we have used whole-mount in situ hybridization to examine E6.5-E8.5 mouse embryos for expression of RAR alpha, RAR beta, RAR gamma, and two enzymes, class IV alcohol dehydrogenase (ADH-IV) and class I aldehyde dehydrogenase (ALDH-I), which have been shown to have retinol and retinal dehydrogenase activities, respectively. At E6.5, RAR alpha mRNA was expressed ubiquitously in embryonic and extraembryonic tissues, RAR gamma mRNA was detected throughout all embryonic tissues, but mRNAs for RAR beta, ADH-IV, and ALDH-I were not detected. By E7.5, RAR alpha mRNA was still ubiquitous, RAR beta mRNA was now observed in presumptive hindbrain ectoderm and adjacent mesenchyme, RAR gamma mRNA was still observed in all embryonic tissues, and ADH-IV as well as ALDH-I mRNAs were now both expressed in primitive streak mesoderm. In E8.5 embryos, RAR alpha mRNA was still ubiquitous, RAR beta mRNA was present in the caudal hindbrain as well as the closed neural tube and foregut, RAR gamma mRNA was widespread but most prevalent in caudal embryonic tissues, and mRNAs for both ADH-IV and ALDH-I were expressed in cranial mesenchyme, somites, and paraxial mesoderm. Thus, ADH-IV and ALDH-1, two metabolic enzymes able to convert retinol to retinoic acid, are both initially expressed in primitive streak mesoderm at E7.5 when retinoic acid is first detectable. On the other hand, RAR alpha and RAR gamma expression is widespread and present at E6.5 prior to retinoic acid detection. These results suggest that upregulation of ADH-IV and ALDH-I gene expression in primitive streak mesoderm may lead to retinoic acid synthesis and initiation of retinoid signaling during mouse embryogenesis.

An essential role for retinoid signaling in anteroposterior neural patterning

The vertebrate central nervous system (CNS) is induced by signals emanating from the dorsal mesoderm, or organizer, that divert the ectoderm away from an epidermal and towards a neural fate. Additional signals from the organizer pattern the neural ectoderm along the anteroposterior axis. We devised highly specific methods utilizing constitutively active or dominant negative receptors to evaluate the role of retinoids in neural patterning. Microinjection of these reagents either augments or reduces retinoid signaling in specific regions of the embryo. We show that increased receptor activity suppresses anterior neural structures while dominant negative receptors lead to anterior enhancement. Similarly, microinjection of the dominant negative receptor leads to the loss of posterior marker genes. We demonstrate that retinoid receptors comprise a critical component in neural posteriorization and are required for proper neuronal differentiation. These results support a quantitative role for retinoid signaling in regionalization of the CNS.

Genetic evidence that the retinoid signal is transduced by heterodimeric RXR/RAR functional units during mouse development

We describe here the analysis of congenital malformations in compound mutant fetuses bearing null alleles in one RXR (alpha, beta or gamma) and one RAR (alpha, beta or gamma) isotype gene. A marked synergy was observed between the effects of mutations in RXR alpha and RARs, as a large number of developmental defects previously found mainly in RAR single and compound mutants were recapitulated in specific RXR alpha/RAR compound mutants. Several malformations were seen only in one type of RXR alpha/RAR mutant combination, whereas others were seen in several types of RXR alpha/RAR double mutants. No synergy was observed between the effects of mutations of either RXR beta or RXR gamma mutations and those of any of the RAR mutations. These genetic data suggest that RXR/RAR heterodimers are the functional units transducing the retinoid signal for a large number of RA-dependent processes, and furthermore, that RXR alpha is the main RXR implicated in the developmental functions of RARs. The significance of these observations is discussed with respect to the problem of functional specificity and redundancy among retinoid receptors in vivo.

Paralogous Hox genes: function and regulation

The Hox homeobox gene family plays a pivotal role in regulating patterning and axial morphogenesis in vertebrates. Molecular characterization of the four Hox clusters has shown that they are evolutionarily related with respect to sequence, organization, and expression, suggesting they arose by duplication and divergence. Transgenic analysis has clearly demonstrated the functional roles of individual genes in a broad range of embryonic tissues, and in compound mutants has addressed the issues of cooperativity and redundancy. There is an emerging picture of the cis-regulatory elements underlying Hox expression, and for the 3' members of the clusters there is a considerable degree of conservation between paralogous genes with respect to their functional roles and regulatory control.

Patterning the vertebrate neuraxis

Neuraxial patterning is a continuous process that extends over a protracted period of development. During gastrulation a crude anteroposterior pattern, detectable by molecular markers, is conferred on the neuroectoderm by signals from the endomesoderm that are largely inseparable from those of neural induction itself. This coarse-grained pattern is subsequently reinforced and refined by diverse, locally acting mechanisms. Segmentation and long-range signaling from organizing centers are prominent among the emerging principles governing regional pattern.