Cell migration and chimerism after whole-organ transplantation: the basis of graft acceptance

Successful outcome of acute graft-versus-host disease in a liver allograft recipient by withdrawal of immunosuppression

BACKGROUND

Graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) after liver transplantation is uncommon, and the outcome is almost always fatal. Since 1987, about 30 cases have been described, and patient survival is mostly exceptional.

METHODS

A 29-year-old man underwent retransplantation due to chronic cholestatic syndrome, 5 years after his first liver transplantation. Indication for the first liver transplantation was acute liver failure caused by exsiccosis. After the second transplantation, the patient had an initially uneventful course, developing thrombocytopenia at day 21 followed by skin rash and septic complications. Diagnosis of acute GVHD was made by using serological techniques for HLA-A and HLA-DRB and subsequently by fluorogenic sequence-specific primed polymerase chain reaction. In addition, donor lymphocytes were marked by immunohistochemical methods via biopsies of the skin. Immunosuppressive therapy was withdrawn to allow the patient's own immune system to eliminate donor cells.

RESULTS

By withdrawing the immunosuppressive therapy, clinical and morphological signs of GVHD vanished. The patient is doing well without recurrence 13 months after transplantation.

CONCLUSION

Withdrawal of immunosuppressive therapy is a promising approach in the treatment of acute GVHD to allow the patient's immune system to reconstitute itself, reject offending lymphocytes, and avoid lethal septic complications.

Dendritic cells: immune regulators in health and disease

Dendritic cells (DCs) are bone marrow-derived cells of both lymphoid and myeloid stem cell origin that populate all lymphoid organs including the thymus, spleen, and lymph nodes, as well as nearly all nonlymphoid tissues and organs. Although DCs are a moderately diverse set of cells, they all have potent antigen-presenting capacity for stimulating naive, memory, and effector T cells. DCs are members of the innate immune system in that they can respond to dangers in the host environment by immediately generating protective cytokines. Most important, immature DCs respond to danger signals in the microenvironment by maturing, i.e., differentiating, and acquiring the capacity to direct the development of primary immune responses appropriate to the type of danger perceived. The powerful adjuvant activity that DCs possess in stimulating specific CD4 and CD8 T cell responses has made them targets in vaccine development strategies for the prevention and treatment of infections, allograft reactions, allergic and autoimmune diseases, and cancer. This review addresses the origins and migration of DCs to their sites of activity, their basic biology as antigen-presenting cells, their roles in important human diseases and, finally, selected strategies being pursued to harness their potent antigen-stimulating activity.

High frequency of epithelial chimerism in liver transplants demonstrated by microdissection and STR-analysis

It has recently been shown that epithelial cells derived from stem cells originating outside the liver are integrated into liver allografts. Whether epithelial intragraft chimerism protects transplants from rejection or chronic transplant dysfunction, and whether it interferes with recurrence of primary liver disease, is not known. Twenty-seven sequential biopsies derived from 9 liver-transplant recipients were studied for chimerism of hepatocytes and cholangiocytes. The target cells were isolated by laser microdissection after cytokeratin immunolabeling and genotyped using DNA analysis of a highly polymorphic short tandem repeat. Irrespective of whether early (up to 4 weeks) or late (more than 12 months) posttransplantation biopsies were studied, cholangiocyte chimerism was almost constantly found in 91% of the samples. No significant differences occurred between samples derived from patients with chronic organ dysfunction (n = 3), recurrent hepatitis (n = 3), or mild, unspecific changes (n = 3). By contrast, hepatocyte chimerism tended to occur later (55% vs. 22%) and appeared to be associated with recurrent hepatitis (67% vs. 27%). In this respect, chronic organ dysfunction did not differ from mild, unspecific changes. While cholangiocyte chimerism represents a constant and early phenomenon in liver transplantations, an enhanced chimeric integration of recipient-derived hepatocytes can be observed in recurrent hepatitis, supporting the concept of an increased recruitment of extrahepatic progenitor cells to the liver in chronic hepatitis.

Transplantation tolerance from a historical perspective

Although transplantation immunology as a distinctive field began with the development of experimental models that showed the feasibility of bone marrow transplantation, organ engraftment was accomplished first in humans, and was thought for many years to occur by drastically different mechanisms. Here, we present our view of the concepts of allograft acceptance and acquired tolerance from a historical perspective, and attempt to amalgamate them into simple and unifying rules that might guide improvements in clinical therapy.

Neurologic Complications of Organ Transplantation

Over the past four decades, remarkable advances have been made in the field of organ transplantation. Improved surgical techniques and perioperative care have reduced the mortality and morbidity of many organ transplant procedures to acceptable levels. The creation of national and international organ registries has resulted in a more efficient system for organ procurement and use. Advances in immunology and the introduction of more potent immunomodulating agents have led to doubling of survival rates for those with transplanted grafts. Unfortunately, a high rate of neurologic complications associated with organ transplantation persists. Cerebral embolization, hypoxia, and bleeding remain frequent after heart and lung transplantation. Prolonged thrombocytopenia associated with bone marrow transplantation still leads to catastrophic cerebral hemorrhage. Although the period of neutropenia following bone marrow transplantation has been reduced by the use of growth factors, and the routine use of potent prophylactic antibiotic and antiviral agents has reduced the incidence of infection, unusual or resistant central nervous system (CNS) infections continues to arise, often creating difficult treatment choices. Furthermore, the more effective classes of immunosuppressants may have direct toxic effects on the nervous system. The major challenge for the future is to develop agents and strategies for management that can effect selective tolerance to the donated organ without paralyzing the immune system's ability to fight infection. Such agents must also have limited or no toxicity to the nervous and other organ systems. The observations by Starzl on the existence of leukocyte chimerism years after transplantation suggest that understanding and building on this natural phenomenon may hold promise for solving major problems in the field of organ transplantation.

Antigenic load and peripheral chimeric levels in entire and partial liver allograft recipients

Orthotopic partial liver transplantation (PLT) models were developed in rats to explore the unique role of the liver in transplant tolerance. In PVG rats, syngeneic PLT established that surgical reduction to one-third of the liver and orthotopic transplantation permitted survival. Allogeneic PLT in the PVG to DA liver-tolerant model, both 50% and 33%, did not affect the tolerogeneic property of the liver, with all PLT recipients surviving indefinitely. Blood samples taken at various time points for detection of donor cells using flow cytometry showed a steady increase in donor cell chimerism in both PLT and whole liver transplantation (WLT) recipients that persisted throughout the 3-month observation period. At each time point, the level of donor cell chimerism in PLT was higher than that in WLT. We conclude that transplantation of one-third of the liver is compatible with survival in rats. Reduction of antigenic load by means of hepatectomy does not affect the tolerogenic effect of the liver in the PVG to DA LT model because of the remarkable regeneration capability of the liver. Peripheral chimeric levels increase progressively after WLT, suggesting that this is an ongoing immunological phenomenon. The earlier and increased chimerism after PLT may be associated with liver regeneration.

Immunologic events and long-term survival after combined heart and kidney transplantation: a 12-year single-center experience

BACKGROUND

In this study we compare the incidence of cardiac rejection and long-term survival after combined heart and kidney transplantation (HK) and single heart transplantation (H). Combined HK transplantation is a surgical option for patients with irreversible cardiac and renal failure. However, long-term results of combined HK transplantation on immunologic events and patient survival remain unknown.

METHODS

Between 1988 and 1997, 12 consecutive patients underwent combined HK transplantation (HK group) at a single institution. A control group (H group) of 24 single heart transplant recipients operated on within the same period was matched for age, pre-operative pulmonary vascular resistance, hepatic insufficiency and gender mismatch. Recipients and donors were ABO compatible without HLA antigen matching. All patients received immediate triple immunosuppression that included cyclosporine. Because of early renal dysfunction, cyclosporine was switched to anti-thymocyte globulin in 5 patients from the HK group and in 1 patient from the H group (p = 0.01).

RESULTS

Actuarial freedom from heart rejection at 6 months and at 1 year following transplantation averaged 90 +/- 9% and 70 +/- 14% in the HK group, and 65 +/- 10% and 49 +/- 11% in the H group, respectively (p = 0.023). Actuarial survival at 1, 5 and 12 years was not significantly different between groups, at 66%, 55% and 28% in the HK group, and 66%, 44% and 32% in the H group, respectively (p = 0.66).

CONCLUSION

The incidence of cardiac rejection was significantly lower. Long-term survival in the HK group was similar to that in the H group. Putative mechanisms of decreased cardiac rejection in the HK group include allogeneic stimulation, donor-derived dendritic cells and induction by anti-thymocyte globulins. The need for long-term immunosuppression may be reduced after combined heart and kidney transplantation.

Ordered array of dendritic cells and CD8+ lymphocytes in portal infiltrates in chronic hepatitis C

AIMS

Despite the importance of dendritic cells in stimulating primary and secondary immune responses by presenting antigens to T-lymphocytes in draining lymph nodes and peripheral tissues, respectively, very limited information is available on the presence and localization of these cells in hepatitis C virus (HCV)-related chronic active hepatitis. Therefore, we addressed the ultrastructure, immunophenotype, distribution and relationships to lymphatics of dendritic cells in portal infiltrates of this disease.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Part of percutaneous diagnostic liver biopsies (Knodell's histological assessment index: 9-13) was processed for electron microscopy and for immunohistochemical detection of immune system cell membrane antigens and of the lymphatic endothelium marker podoplanin. In portal infiltrates, cells with electron microscopical and cell marker features of dendritic cells and expressing the activation markers CD54, CD80, CD83 and CD86 were organized in a discontinuous network, that embedded CD8+ lymphocytes in close contact with dendritic cells and came in contact with hepatocytes, sometimes infiltrating beyond the limiting plate. Also, dendritic cells were found within newly formed lymphatic capillaries in thin, infiltrated septa among hepatocytes.

CONCLUSIONS

This evidence strongly suggests a critical role of dendritic cells and newly formed lymphatics in the pathogenesis and organization of the immune infiltrate that characterizes HCV-related chronic active hepatitis.

The "privileged" liver and hepatic tolerogenicity

The mechanism underlying the immunological advantage of hepatic allografts relative to other organs is incompletely understood. We used molecular probes for the repetitive units on the Y chromosome, to identify an increasing number of male liver venous endothelial cells in needle biopsy samples of men who received female donor liver grafts. We have also shown repopulation of liver endothelium by bone marrow derived cells in a male to female mouse bone marrow transplant model. We conclude that the liver has unique venous endothelium characterized by turnover and replacement by bone marrow derived cells.

Clinical intestinal transplantation: a decade of experience at a single center

OBJECTIVE

To assess the long-term efficacy of intestinal transplantation under tacrolimus-based immunosuppression and the therapeutic benefit of newly developed adjunct immunosuppressants and management strategies.

SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA

With the advent of tacrolimus in 1990, transplantation of the intestine began to emerge as therapy for intestinal failure. However, a high risk of rejection, with the consequent need for acute and chronic high-dose immunosuppression, has inhibited its widespread application.

METHODS

During an 11-year period, divided into two segments by a 1-year moratorium in 1994, 155 patients received 165 intestinal allografts under immunosuppression based on tacrolimus and prednisone: 65 intestine alone, 75 liver and intestine, and 25 multivisceral. For the transplantations since the moratorium (n = 99), an adjunct immunosuppressant (cyclophosphamide or daclizumab) was used for 74 transplantations, adjunct donor bone marrow was given in 39, and the intestine of 11 allografts was irradiated with a single dose of 750 cGy.

RESULTS

The actuarial survival rate for the total population was 75% at 1 year, 54% at 5 years, and 42% at 10 years. Recipients of liver plus intestine had the best long-term prognosis and the lowest risk of graft loss from rejection (P =.001). Since 1994, survival rates have improved. Techniques for early detection of Epstein-Barr and cytomegaloviral infections, bone marrow augmentation, the adjunct use of the interleukin-2 antagonist daclizumab, and most recently allograft irradiation may have contributed to the better results.

CONCLUSION

The survival rates after intestinal transplantation have cumulatively improved during the past decade. With the management strategies currently under evaluation, intestinal transplant procedures have the potential to become the standard of care for patients with end-stage intestinal failure.

Weaning of immunosuppression in living donor liver transplant recipients

BACKGROUND

Some reported studies have indicated the possibility of immunosuppression withdrawal in cadaveric liver transplantation. The aim of this study was to evaluate the possibility and feasibility of weaning living donor liver transplant recipients from immunosuppression.

METHODS

From June of 1990 to October of 1999, 63 patients were considered to be weaned from immunosuppression. They consisted of 26 electively weaned patients and 37 either forcibly or incidentally weaned patients (nonelective weaning) due to various causes but mainly due to infection. Regarding elective weaning, we gradually reduced the frequency of tacrolimus administration for patients who survived more than 2 years after transplantation, maintained a good graft function, and had no rejection episodes in the preceding 12 months. The frequency of administration was reduced from the conventional b.i.d. until the start of weaning to q.d., 4 times a week, 3 times a week, twice a week, once a week, twice a month, once a month, and finally, the patients were completely weaned off with each weaning period lasting from 3 to 6 months. The reduction method of nonelective weaning depended on the clinical course of each individual case. When the patients were clinically diagnosed to develop rejection during weaning, then such patients were treated by a reintroduction of tacrolimus or an additional steroid bolus when indicated.

RESULTS

Twenty-four patients (38.1%) achieved a complete withdrawal of tacrolimus with a median drug-free period of 23.5 months (range, 3-69 months). Twenty-three patients (36.5%) are still being weaned at various stages. Sixteen patients (25.4%) encountered rejection while weaning at median period of 9.5 months (range, 1-63 months) from the start of weaning. All 16 were easily treated with the reintroduction of tacrolimus or additional steroid bolus therapy.

CONCLUSIONS

We were able to achieve a complete withdrawal of immunosuppression in some selected patients. Although the mechanism of graft acceptance in these patients has yet to be elucidated, we believe that a majority of long-term patients undergoing living donor liver transplantation may, thus, be potential candidates to be successfully weaned from immunosuppression.

Evans' syndrome complicating chronic graft versus host disease after cadaveric liver transplantation

Acute graft versus host disease (GVHD) occurred in a patient after cadaveric liver transplantation from an HLA disparate donor. Immunosuppression resulted in a remission, but chronic GVHD with a scleroderma-like syndrome ensued. This was further complicated by immune hemolytic anemia and thrombocytopenia (Evan's syndrome). Semi-quantitative microsatellite analysis of circulating lymphoid cells showed that T cells were predominantly of donor origin, thereby explaining the chronic GVHD. The marrow hematopoietic cells remained recipient, so that the immune cytopenias were expected to be alloimmune in nature. However, the red cell antibodies were shown to have anti-C and anti-e specificity, with both the donor (R1R1) and recipient (R1r) possessing the C and e antigens. Therefore, the immune hemolysis might be considered both alloimmune and autoimmune. The patient finally died of sepsis. This case illustrates that chronic GVHD due to stable donor T cell engraftment may rarely occur in liver transplantation despite HLA disparity. Immunosuppression may result in dysregulation of T cell functions, leading to alloimmune and autoimmune problems.

Influence of pretransplant pregnancy on survival of renal allografts from living donors

BACKGROUND

The presence of a small number of cells of donor origin in organ transplant recipients (microchimerism) may influence allograft survival and may induce tolerance. Postpartum women may be microchimeric to offspring hematopoietic cells up to 27 years. We hypothesized that mothers receiving renal allografts from offspring would have better graft survival compared with either fathers receiving allografts from offspring, or mothers receiving allografts from nonoffspring donors.

METHODS

We analyzed 1803 living related kidney transplants from the UNOS database performed between January 1, 1990, and December 31, 1995, for mothers and fathers who received grafts from offspring with one haplotype match. We also compared these mothers with parous females receiving a kidney from nonoffspring donors (spouse and other biologically related or unrelated family members). A multivariate logistic regression method was used to analyze the effect of donor type, as well as other recipient, donor, and transplant characteristics, on graft and patient survival.

RESULTS

Mothers receiving one haplotype-matched offspring renal allografts did not have better graft survival at 1 or 3 years posttransplant compared with fathers receiving similar grafts. There was also no difference in graft or patient survival between mothers receiving kidney grafts from either offspring or nonoffspring donors. Graft survival in mothers with multiple pregnancies was poorer than those with a single pregnancy.

CONCLUSIONS

It is possible that persistent microchimerism of fetal cells in maternal circulation may, for some mothers, cause a detectable improvement in graft or patient survival. Comparison of female and male recipients from the UNOS database did not reveal any differences in outcomes. If mothers are tolerant to their offspring, our results indicate that this microchimerism may not improve renal allograft or patient survival in offspring donor to maternal recipient combinations. Lastly, more sensitive pretransplant cross-match assays may need to be implemented in multiparous women, given our results.

A novel strategy for organ allografts using sublethal (7 Gy) irradiation followed by injection of donor bone marrow cells via portal vein

A new strategy for organ allografts that does not require recourse to immunosuppressants is established in mice. The strategy includes sublethal (7 Gy) irradiation followed by the injection of donor bone marrow cells (BMCs) via the portal vein (P.V.) and organ allografts 1 day after irradiation. Irradiation doses (< or =7 Gy) are found to allow the recipients to survive without the need to reconstitute the BMCs, as the recipient hematolymphoid cells can gradually recover. One hundred percent of recipients irradiated with 7 Gy followed by either P.V. or i.v. injection of donor BMCs accept organ allografts (the skin, pancreas, and adrenal glands) for more than 1 year. However, organ allograft survival rates decrease when irradiation doses are reduced; the skin graft survival rate of mice treated with 6.5 Gy and P.V. injection of BMCs is 79%, whereas that of mice treated with 6.5 Gy and i.v. injection is 50%, indicating that the P.V. injection of BMCs induces persistent tolerance more effectively than the i.v. injection. H-2 typing reveals that almost all the hematolymphoid cells (>98%) in the peripheral blood and hematolymphoid organs are donor-derived even 1 year after the treatment (7 Gy and P.V.). The T cells are tolerant to both donor-type and host-type MHC determinants. The major mechanism underlying the persistent tolerance induced by this strategy seems to be because of clonal deletion. This simple and safe strategy would be of great advantage for human organ transplantation.

Different kinetics of donor cell populations after isolated liver and combined liver/small bowel transplantation

Spontaneous tolerance induction after liver transplantation also supports additional transplants, e.g. a small bowel graft, from the same donor (tolerogenic effect). Chimerism serves as a possible explanation of this phenomenon. Isolated liver (LTx) and combined liver/small bowel transplantation (LSBTx) are compared. LSBTx and LTx were performed in the BN --> LEW rat strain combination without immunosuppression. Parenchymal damage during rejection was monitored by sequential standard histology. Donor/recipient populations were identified and further differentiated for immunohistochemical single and double staining. A small number of donor specific leukocytes can be detected on all days in host organs (microchimerism). A significantly larger donor leukocyte population survives long-term in the sinusoids of liver (graft chimerism). Sinusoidal donor leukocytes survive rejection and recover in number after tolerance induction. Rejection of liver allografts and infiltration by host leukocytes are more pronounced after LSBTx than after LTx. Accordingly, during rejection a steeper decline of sinusoidal donor leukocytes is observed after LSBTx and recovery after tolerance induction is not as marked. Microchimerism apparently plays no significant role in either transplantation model. The number of sinusoidal donor leukocytes, however, mirrors closely host immune responses.

Prospective study of microchimerism in renal allograft recipients: association between HLA-DR matching, microchimerism and acute rejection

The presence of donor-derived hematopoietic cells in blood and various tissues of the organ recipients, termed allogeneic microchimerism, has been considered to play an essential role in establishment of organ acceptance. In this study, we prospectively determined the presence of peripheral blood microchimerism (PBM) in 20 male-to-female renal allograft recipients up to 30 months post-transplantation. Recipients were categorized according to the pattern of microchimerism into microchimeric and nonmicrochimeric groups, and then state of human leukocyte antigens (HLA) Class II (DR/DQ) matching, episodes of acute rejection, age at transplantation, renal function, and history of blood transfusion were compared. DNA was extracted from donor, pre-transplant, and post-transplant (1 wk; 1, 3, 6, 12, 18, 24, and 30 months) peripheral blood samples. We analyzed PBM using nested polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplification specific for the SRY region of the Y chromosome with a sensitivity up to 1:1 000 000. Microchimerism was detected in 13 (65%) of 20 recipients at various intervals. The highest frequency of microchimerism was at 1 wk (55%). Among microchimeric recipients, none were positive on all post-transplant analyses. Interestingly, nonmicrochimeric cases were negative throughout the study. The three recipients with an episode of acute rejection during the first week after transplantation were all in the nonmicrochimeric group with completely mismatched HLA-DR antigens. HLA-DR incompatibility was significantly lower (t-test, p<0.05) in microchimeric cases (1.0+/-0.58) than in nonmicrochimeric ones (1.9+/-0.38). But regarding HLA-DQ and other clinical parameters mentioned above, significant difference was not observed. We propose that there is an association between HLA-DR matching, microchimerism and acute graft rejection in our recipients. Our study demonstrates that, with routine immunosuppressive protocols, higher compatibility of HLA-DR antigens facilitates microchimerism induction. Then, development of new stronger immunosuppressive protocols (including conditioning) or augmentation of chimeric state (by donor-specific bone marrow infusion), especially in completely mismatched HLA-DR renal allograft recipients, may be useful for graft acceptance.

Microchimeric cells from the peripheral blood associated with cardiac grafts are bone marrow derived, long-lived and maintain acquired tolerance to minor histocompatibility antigen H-Y

BACKGROUND

Although it has been well established that the microchimerism occurs in the peripheral blood of the recipients after various settings in both clinical and experimental organ transplantation, nevertheless, their roles in inducing and maintaining acquired transplantation tolerance are controversial. Furthermore, regarding the cell lineages, kinetics, and functions of the cells that constitute the microchimerism after organ transplantation, solid information is not available.

METHODS

Using rat heterotopic heart isografts from bone marrow chimeras between cross-sex and applying polymerase chain reaction with specific primers to rat sex determining region of Y chromosome, a relationship between a state of microchimerism and induction as well as maintenance of acquired tolerance to H-Y antigen were examined.

RESULTS

Microchimeric cells of the peripheral blood (MCPB) after cardiac grafting contain bone marrow-derived and radiation-sensitive cells. Furthermore, removal of the primary cardiac grafts revealed that microchimeric cells in the peripheral blood are long-lived cells, i.e., more than 6 months. When the female rats that had contained long-lasting MCPB, were innoculated with syngeneic male dendritic cells, failure to sensitize female toward male specific antigen H-Y was found to occur.

CONCLUSIONS

Thus it was suggested that radiation-sensitive, bone marrow derived, long-lived MCPB play a significant role in maintaining acquired transplantation tolerance to minor histocompatibility antigen H-Y.

Early chimerism of macrophages and lymphocytes in lung transplant recipients is predictive of graft tolerance

BACKGROUND

The persistence of donor cells derived from the graft (chimerism) has been documented in various tissues after organ transplantation. It was suggested that stable chimerism might reflect a state of donor-specific tolerance. Chimerism of macrophages and lymphocytes were studied over time after lung transplantation as well as its impact on graft tolerance.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Macrophages and lymphocytes were purified from bronchoalveolar lavage sequentially obtained from 24 patients between 1 and 41 months posttransplantation (20, 22, 24, and 17 patients at, respectively, 1, 3, 6, and 12 months). DNA was extracted from these cells and their recipient-donor origin was evaluated by PCR amplification of highly polymorphic DNA regions (minisatellites).

RESULTS

We show that the remaining donor cells over the first month vary from 10 up to 50% and 5 up to 55% for lymphocytes and macrophages respectively (+/-2 SD). All patients presented some chimerism up to the 6th postoperative month. Good correlation was observed between the residual amount of donor lymphocytes and macrophages during the first 3 months (P<0.001). Patients with at least 30% donor lymphocytes at 1 month after transplantation had less rejections (> or =stage II) in the follow up (P=0.0007). The same observation is true for donor macrophages although to lower extend (P=0.02). The chimerism lost its predictive value beyond 3 months.

CONCLUSIONS

These data demonstrate that a level of chimerism above 30% of either donor lymphocytes or macrophages at 1 month is related to a better state of graft tolerance. However, chimerism decreases markedly beyond 3 months and has then no predictive value.

Mixed chimerism and transplantation tolerance

Achieving transplantation tolerance is an important goal in the effort to reduce long-term morbidity and mortality in organ transplant recipients. Robust, lifelong, donor-specific tolerance can be reliably achieved by induction of mixed chimerism in various animal models. To date, the clinical application of these proto-cols has been impeded partly by the potential toxicity of the required host conditioning regimens and the lack of successful studies in large animals. This article reviews the progress achieved in recent years in developing considerably milder conditioning protocols in rodents, and in extending some of these models to achieve permanent mixed chimerism and tolerance in large animals. Advances in the induction of xenogeneic tolerance through mixed chimerism are also discussed.

Intestinal transplantation for children with short bowel syndrome

Intestinal transplantation has emerged as a feasible alternative in the treatment of children with short gut syndrome. The challenges in the management of these patients include maintaining a tight balance between the degree of immunosuppression necessary to prevent graft-versus-host disease and rejection. At the same time, this amount of immunosuppression is associated with a high risk for lymphoproliferative disorders and intestinal-derived sepsis. Current 3-year patient and graft survival rates are 55% and 50%, respectively. The indications, morbidity, and timing for referral are discussed.

TOLERANCE TO MUSCULOSKELETAL ALLOGRAFTS WITH TRANSIENT LYMPHOCYTE CHIMERISM IN MINIATURE SWINE1

BACKGROUND

Although transplantation of musculoskeletal allografts in humans is technically feasible, the adverse effects of long-term immunosuppression subject the patient to high risks for correcting a non-life-threatening condition. Achieving immunologic tolerance to musculoskeletal allografts, without the need for chronic immunosuppression, could expand the clinical application of limb tissue allografting. Tolerance to musculoskeletal allografts has been accomplished previously in miniature swine in our laboratory. Although stable, mixed chimerism has been suggested as the mechanism underlying long-term tolerance in a rat limb model, the mechanism of this tolerance induction has not been established. This report explores the possible relationship between hematopoietic chimerism and tolerance to musculoskeletal allografts in swine.

METHODS

Twelve miniature swine underwent vascularized musculoskeletal allograft transplantation from histocompatibility complex (MHC) matched, minor antigen-mismatched donors. Eight animals received a 12-day coprse of cyclosporine, one of which was excluded due to subtherapeutic levels. Four recipients were not immunosuppressed. Serial biopsies to assess graft viability and flow cytometry to assess chimerism were performed. Donor and third-party skin grafts were placed on recipients with surviving allografts greater than 100 days to validate tolerance.

RESULTS

Both groups developed early peripheral chimerism, but this chimerism became undetectable by postoperative day 19 in the cyclosporine group and by day 13 in the control group. Animals receiving cyclosporine developed permanent tolerance to their allografts, whereas those not receiving cyclosporine rejected their allografts in 6-9 weeks. Animals demonstrating tolerance to their bone allografts also demonstrated prolonged donor skin graft survival.

CONCLUSIONS

Induction of tolerance to musculoskeletal allografts can be achieved in the MHC matched swine. Although hematopoietic chimerism is present in the immediate postoperative period, persistent, long-term chimerism does not seem to be necessary for maintenance of such tolerance.

Donor dendritic cells and recipient Kupffer cells in the induction of donor-specific immune hyporesponsiveness

The aim of this study was to investigate the ability of portovenously administered donor antigens to induce immune hyporesponsiveness. Lewis (LEW, RT-1l) rats received Brown Norway (BN, RT-1n) rat donor splenocytes, via either the portal vein (PV group) or the peripheral vein (IV group). The immune responses of LEW rats, treated with either donor BN or third party Wistar King A (WKA, RT-1k) splenocytes were established by the persistence of donor dendritic cells (DCs) in the host liver measured using fluorescence microscopy and flow cytometry and by the mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR). The effect of intravenous gadolinium chloride (GDCl3) on the blockade of Kupffer cell function prior to portovenous administration of splenocytes was also assessed. The MLR response was strongly inhibited in a BN-restricted manner after portovenous administration of donor BN splenocytes, but not by venous nor by portovenous administration of WKA splenocytes. Immunosuppression was blocked by pretreatment with GDCl3. The percentage of donor DCs in hepatic non-parenchymal cells (NPCs) was significantly higher in the PV group compared with the IV group. Treatment with GDCl3 decreased the percentage of donor DCs. In addition, cytotoxic T lymphocyte antigen 4 (CTLA4/CD152), which may function as an immune attenuator, was strongly stained, and B7 was weakly stained in recipient liver in the PV group compared with the IV group. These results suggest that both donor DCs and recipient Kupffer cells (self DCs) are involved in the induction of immune hyporesponsiveness by donor cells. This occurs via portovenous administration, in which a signal of the CTLA4-B7 pathway played an important part in inhibiting the interaction of CD28 and its B7 ligands.

Cyclophosphamide-induced tolerance in rat orthotopic liver transplantation

BACKGROUND

We previously established a cyclophosphamide (CP)-induced tolerance system in rodent skin graft models. In this study, we applied this system to rat liver transplantation.

METHODS

Lewis recipients were inoculated on day -2 with spleen and bone marrow cells (SC+BMC) from Dark Agouti (DA) donors, followed by 100 mg/kg CP on day 0. On day 25, DA livers were orthotopically grafted. We assessed the alloresponses to the donors of the long-term surviving recipients, using the second skin grafting and in vitro assay.

RESULTS

The recipients that had been treated with SC+BMC and CP survived for more than 165 days. None of control group that received SC+BMC alone (mean survival times [MST]=13.8 days), CP alone (MST=40.0), SC+BMC from third-party PVG rats and CP (MST=45.0), or no treatment (MST=13.8) survived over 50 days. The donor-specific tolerance was confirmed by second skin grafts onto recipients with permanent DA liver grafts, which accepted DA skins (MST>75) but not PVG (MST=8.3). However, the lymphocytes from the tolerant recipients showed alloresponse to DA in vitro. To investigate whether the T helper type 2 deviation contributed to this "split tolerance," we assessed the production of cytokines in mixed lymphocyte reaction. Interleukin 2 and interferon-gamma were detected but interleukin 4 was not.

CONCLUSIONS

These data showed that this protocol induced split tolerance in rat liver transplantation and, furthermore, the mechanism of split tolerance was not due to T helper 2 deviation.

Analysis of alloreactivity and intragraft cytokine profiles in living donor liver transplant recipients with graft acceptance

Although some previous studies have indicated the possibility of immunosuppression withdrawal in clinical liver transplantation, the mechanism of graft acceptance is not clear. The aim of this study is to elucidate the alloreactivity against the donor and intragraft cytokine profiles in living donor liver transplant (LDLT) recipients with graft acceptance. In October 1999, we had 23 patients who survived without immunosuppression after LDLT with a median drug-free period of 25 months (range: 3-69 months). They consisted of six patients who were electively weaned by an elective weaning protocol and 17 either forcibly or accidentally weaned patients due to various causes but mainly due to infection. We evaluated the alloreactivity against the donor in these patients by a mixed lymphocyte reaction and intragraft cytokine profiles by real-time reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction. The development of donor-specific hyporeactivity was observed in the patients with graft acceptance. The cytokine pattern in the supernatant of the culture medium revealed a down regulation of T helper (Th) 1 cytokine INF gamma against the donor while no significant difference was seen in Th2 cytokine IL-10. Regarding the intragraft cytokine profiles, we could find no amplification of Thl cytokines (IL-2, INF y) and IL-4 while some of the patients revealed a gene expression of IL-10 with no significant difference from that of the normal, untransplanted liver specimen. In addition, no difference was observed in any other cytokines (IL-1beta, IL-8, IL-15, TNFalpha) compared with those of the normal controls. We propose that the down regulation of Th1 cytokine is one possible mechanism of graft acceptance in LDLT recipients.

Donor bone marrow-derived chimeric cells present in renal transplant recipients infused with donor marrow. I. Potent regulators of recipient antidonor immune responses

BACKGROUND

Even though a number of transplant centers have adopted donor-specific bone marrow cell (DBMC) infusions to enhance donor cell chimerism, to date there has been no direct evidence linking chimerism with tolerance induction in human organ transplant recipients.

METHODS

Cells of donor phenotype were isolated 1 year postoperatively from the peripheral blood lymphocytes and iliac crest bone marrow of 11 living-related-donor (LRD) renal transplant recipients, who had received perioperative donor bone marrow cell infusions. These recipient-derived donor (RdD) cells were characterized phenotypically by flow cytometric analysis and functionally as modulators in mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR) and cell-mediated lympholysis (CML) assays.

RESULTS

The yield of RdD cells ranged from 0.1 to O.9% of the starting material with the majority being TcRalphabeta, CD3 positive T cells, a substantial percentage of which coexpressed CD28. At 1 year posttransplant almost 50% of the LRD-kidney/DBMC recipients tested so far exhibited donor-specific unresponsiveness in MLR (7/17) and CML (6/13) reactions and this trend was further enhanced at 23 years. In the recipients with residual positive antidonor immune responses, the RdD cells inhibited recipient antidonor MLR and CML responses significantly more strongly than freshly isolated and similarly treated iliac crest bone marrow cells from the donor. RdD cells also inhibited the MLR of the recipient to third party allogeneic stimulator cells; however, this nonspecific effect was significantly weaker than specific inhibition. We also established long-term bone marrow cultures stimulated every 2 weeks with irradiated alogeneic feeder cells, that had similar functional properties thus possibly providing us with an in vitro correlate the RdD cells.

CONCLUSIONS

These results clearly support the notion that the infused donor cells play a positive role in the induction and/or maintenance of transplant tolerance.

Involvement of multiple subpopulations of human bone marrow cells in the regulation of allogeneic cellular immune responses

BACKGROUND

The identity of the cells in the human bone marrow that function as effective regulators of in vitro and possibly in vivo cellular immune responses is not well established.

METHODS

Cell subpopulations were isolated from cadaver donor vertebral-body bone marrow cells (DBMC) by using immuno-magnetic microbeads and were tested as inhibitors (modulators) in cell-mediated lympholysis (CML) and mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR) responses of normal peripheral blood lymphocytes stimulated with irradiated cadaver donor spleen cells.

RESULTS

Compared with spleen cells as controls, un-irradiated T-cell depleted DBMC inhibited both the MLR and CML responses of allogeneic responder cells in a dose dependent manner (as in our previous reports). The inhibition was also mediated by a number of purified subpopulations including pluripotent CD34+ stem cells, and their CD34 negative early progeny of both lymphoid and myeloid lineages. These included DBMC enriched for non-T-cell lymphoid precursors (NT-LP/DBMC; i.e., DBMC depleted of CD3, CD15, and glycophorin-A positive cells) and DBMC positively selected for CD38+, CD2+, CD5+, and CD1+ lymphoid cells (all were depleted of CD3+ cells) as well as CD33+ (but CD15 negative) myeloid precursors. However, positively selected CD19+ B-cells and CD15+ myeloid cells did not inhibit the MLR and CML responses. The NT-LP/DBMC that had been repeatedly stimulated with irradiated allogeneic peripheral blood lymphocytes caused the strongest inhibition of the MLR and CML responses of the same allogeneic cells with 200 times fewer modulator cells needed than uncultured DBMC (P<0.001). Flow cytometric analysis revealed that majority of cells in these cell lines had become CD3+ TcR-alphabeta+ CD4+ and CD28+ cells.

CONCLUSION

A variety of less differentiated cells of various lineages residing in the human bone marrow are immunoregulatory in vitro. Among them, there is at least one subset that can undergo differentiation in vitro into regulatory T cells that can be maintained in long-term cultures.

Immunomodulation for intestinal transplantation by allograft irradiation, adjunct donor bone marrow infusion, or both

BACKGROUND

The passenger leukocytes in the intestine have a lineage profile that predisposes to graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) in some animal models and have inferior tolerogenic qualities compared with the leukocytes in the liver, other solid organs, and bone marrow. Elimination by ex vivo irradiation of mature lymphoid elements from the bowel allografts is known to eliminate the GVHD risk. We hypothesized that infusion of donor bone marrow cells (BMC) in recipients of irradiated intestine would improve tolerogenesis without increasing the risk of GVHD.

METHODS

Orthotopic small intestine transplantation was performed with the GVHD-prone Lewis (LEW)-to-Brown Norway (BN) combination and the reverse GVHD-resistant BN-to-LEW model under a short course of tacrolimus treatment (1 mg/kg/day, days 0-13, 20, 27). Grafts were irradiated ex vivo, using a 137Cs source. In selected experimental groups, donor BMC (2.5 x 10(8)) were infused on the day of small intestine transplantation.

RESULTS

The unmodified LEW intestine remained intact, whether transplanted alone or with adjunct donor BMC infusion, but all of the BN recipients died of GVHD after approximately 2 months. Intestinal graft irradiation (10 Gy) effectively prevented the GVHD and prolonged survival to 92.5 days, but all of the BN recipients died with chronic rejection of the LEW grafts, which was prevented by infusion of adjunct donor BMC without causing GVHD. In the GVHD-resistant reverse strain direction (BN-->LEW), all intestinal recipients treated for 27 days with tacrolimus survived > or =150 days without regard for graft irradiation or adjunct BMC, but chronic rejection was severe in the irradiated intestine, moderate in the unaltered graft, and least in the irradiated intestine transplanted with adjunct BMC. Mild arteritis in the 150 day allografts of both strain combinations (i.e., LEW--> BN and BN-->LEW) may have been irradiation associated, but this was prevented when weekly doses of tacrolimus were continued for the duration of the experiment rather than being stopped at 27 days.

CONCLUSIONS

Recipients are protected from GVHD by irradiating intestinal allografts, but the resulting leukocyte depletion leads to chronic rejection of the transplanted bowel. The chronic rejection is prevented with adjunct donor BMC without causing GVHD. Although application of the strategy may be limited by the possibility of radiation injury, the results are consistent with the paradigm that we have proposed to explain organ-induced graft acceptance, tolerance, and chronic rejection.

Role of dendritic cells in the immune response against allografts

Graft-derived 'passenger' dendritic cells have been classically considered as the instigators of acute organ rejection. However, recent advances have revealed that dendritic cells are also involved in the induction/maintenance of peripheral tolerance. This paper briefly reviews the most recent knowledge of the role of donor and recipient dendritic cells during the immune response against allografts, and of the clinical potential of 'tolerogenic' dendritic cells.

Immunologic considerations for therapeutic strategies utilizing allogeneic hepatocytes: hepatocyte-expressed membrane-bound major histocompatibility complex class I antigen sensitizes while soluble antigen suppresses the immune response in rats

Understanding the immunologic effects of hepatocytes is critical because of the potential to use these cells for bioartificial livers, as a vehicle for gene transfer, and as a means to induce donor-specific immunosuppression in organ transplantation. However, this understanding is complicated by the fact that hepatocytes express membrane-bound and soluble forms of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I antigen, each with the potential to induce different immune responses. In the present study we first determined the immunologic effect of normal donor-derived hepatocytes in a rat heart transplant model. We then used ex vivo hepatocyte gene transfer to examine the immunologic effects of different forms of hepatocyte-expressed MHC class I antigen. Results showed that intrasplenic injection of purified, donor-strain-specific hepatocytes into recipients primes alloimmunity, as evidenced by acceleration of heart allograft rejection. Interestingly, injection of autologous hepatocytes transfected ex vivo with DNA encoding only membrane-bound donor MHC class I antigen (RT1.A(a)) also accelerated allograft rejection. However, hepatocytes transfected to express only secreted donor MHC antigen prolonged transplant survival. Limiting-dilution analysis of lymphocytes from animals treated with hepatocytes producing only secreted alloantigen showed an antigen-specific reduction in cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) and helper T lymphocyte (HTL) precursors. Further analysis of CTL populations by flow cytometry revealed a relatively high percentage of nonviable cells, implying that soluble antigen promotes allospecific CTL death. In summary, this study suggests that hepatocyte-expressed MHC class I molecules have opposing immunologic effects, with the membrane-bound antigen inducing immunologic sensitization, and the soluble antigen promoting donor-specific immunosuppression.

Donor and recipient leukocytes in organ allografts of recipients with variable donor-specific tolerance: with particular reference to chronic rejection

We have attributed organ engraftment to clonal exhaustion-deletion of host-versus-graft and graft-versus-host reactions that are reciprocally induced and governed by migratory donor and recipient leukocytes. The so-called donor passenger leukocytes that migrate from the allograft into the recipients have been thoroughly studied (chimerism), but not the donor leukocytes that remain in, or return to, the transplanted organ. Therefore, using flow cytometry we determined the percentage and lineages of donor leukocytes in cell suspensions prepared from Lewis (LEW) cardiac allografts to 100 days posttransplantation. The LEW hearts were transplanted to naïve untreated Brown Norway (BN) recipients (group 2), to naïve BN recipients treated with a 28-day or continuous course of tacrolimus (TAC) (groups 3 and 4), and to drug-free BN recipients pretolerized by earlier bone marrow cell (BMC) or orthotopic LEW liver transplantation (groups 5 and 6). The findings in the heart cell suspensions were correlated with the results from parallel histopathologic-immunocytochemical studies and other studies of the grafts and of host tissues. Although the LEW heart allografts were rejected in 9.6 days by the unmodified recipients of group 2, all beat for 100 days in the recipients of groups 3 through 6. Nevertheless, all of the long-surviving cardiac allografts (but not the isografts in group 1) were the targets of an immune reaction at 5 days, reflected by dramatic increases in the ratio of leukocytes to nonleukocyte nucleated cells from normal values of 1:5-1:6 to 1:1-5:1 and by manifold other evidence of a major inflammatory event. The acute changes returned to baseline by 100 days in the chronic rejection (CR) free hearts of groups 4 and 6, but not in the CR-afflicted hearts of short-course TAC group 3 or the less-severely damaged hearts of the BMC-prime group 5. The freedom from CR in groups 4 and 6 was associated with a large donor contribution to the intracardiac leukocyte population at 5 days (28.6% and 22% in the respective groups) and at 100 days (30.5% in group 4 and 8.4% in group 6) compared with 2% and 1.2% at 100 days in the CR-blighted allografts of the partially tolerant animals of groups 3 and 5. Whether large or small, the donor leukocyte fraction always included a subset of class II leukocytes that had histopathologic features of dendritic cells. These class II(+) cells were of mixed myeloid (CD11b/c(+)) and lymphoid lineages; their migration was markedly inhibited by TAC and accelerated by donor-specific priming and TAC discontinuance. Although a large donor leukocyte population and a normal leukocyte/nonleukocyte cell ratio were associated with freedom from CR, these findings and the lineage profile of the intracardiac leukocytes were not associated with tolerance in the animals of groups 3 and 4 under active TAC treatment. The findings in this study, singly and in their entirety, are compatible with our previously proposed leukocyte migration-localization paradigm of organ allograft acceptance and tolerance.

Long-term (>1 year) analyses of chimerism and tolerance in mixed allogeneic chimeric mice using normal mouse combinations

We examined the induction of tolerance using pancreas allografts over the long term (>1 year) in mice for the human application of mixed allogeneic bone marrow transplantation (BMT). T cell-depleted BM cells (BMCs) of C57BL/6 (B6) and C3H/He (C3H) mice were transplanted at various ratios into lethally irradiated B6 mice. The percentages of C3H cells in the chimeric mice gradually decreased, finally declining to only a small percentage, except when the ratio of donor to recipient BMCs was 100:1. However, despite the marked decreases in C3H-type cells, all the pancreas allografts of C3H mice were accepted when more than 1% C3H cells were detected in the peripheral blood. To examine the relationships between percentages of transplanted donor cells and acceptance of pancreas allografts, various percentages of donor and recipient BMCs (5% to 30%) were transplanted. It was found that more than 10% donor cells were necessary for the pancreas allografts to be accepted. In vitro assays for mixed lymphocyte reaction and generation of cytotoxic T-lymphocytes revealed that spleen cells in chimeric mice accepting pancreas allografts are tolerant to both host-type and donor-type major histocompatibility complex (MHC) determinants, but show a vigorous responsiveness to third-party MHC determinants. Since donor-type hemopoietic stem cells (HSCs) were detected in the BM and the liver of the chimeric mice, donor-derived HSCs and donor-derived hematolymphoid cells are responsible for the induction of tolerance. It should be noted that the percentage of donor-type HSCs is higher in the liver (6.2%) than in the BM (0.9%).

Detection of host and donor cells in sex-mismatched rat nerve allografts using RT-PCR for a Y chromosome (H-Y) marker

The donor and host source of support cells, such as Schwann cells, in nerve allograft segments have been the subject of debate. The objective of the present study was to assess the utility of a molecular technique that probes for a Y chromosome expressed gene (H-Y) in distinguishing host from donor tissue in sex-mismatched nerve allograft segments. Forty-two Lewis rats received bilateral syngeneic Lewis or allogeneic ACI rat peroneal nerve grafts, with or without cyclosporin A (CsA) treatment. At different times thereafter animals were sacrificed and samples were harvested. We transplanted males and females reciprocally, to study both survival of donor cells (persisting H-Y mRNA in male grafts by transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR), and graft infiltration by host cells (detectable H-Y mRNA in female grafts). A kinetic analysis revealed a progressive loss of viable donor cells (loss of H-Y mRNA signal) from allografts, beginning 2-3 weeks, and culminating at 4 weeks, with little detectable H-Y in the absence of CsA treatment. CsA treatment led to prolonged survival of allograft cells, confirmed by detectable H-Y mRNA. By studying female grafts in male rats we could confirm that loss of viable donor tissue in allografts was accompanied by infiltration of host (H-Y mRNA positive) cells, whereas no H-Y mRNA signal was seen in males receiving autografts from females or in immunosuppressed allograft segments. These data suggest that reverse RT-PCR analysis for a Y chromosome gene product can be a valuable tool to assess the origin of viable cells in sex-mismatched nerve allotransplantation tissue.

Microchimerism and rejection: a meta-analysis

AIMS

To study the relationship between graft rejection and microchimerism with and without donor bone marrow infusion in recipients of kidney, liver, heart and lung transplants. Selection of manuscripts. Thirty-seven manuscripts presenting clinical data on microchimerism and rejection, published between 1991 and 1997, were identified. Of these, 16 were excluded due to duplication or insufficient data. Inclusion criteria were data on microchimerism, bone marrow infusion and rejection episodes.

STATISTICAL TESTS

A mixed effect logistic model was used to test for homogeneity of transplant centers. The centers were found to be homogeneous for rejection rates controlling for microchimerism and bone marrow infusion. Using rejection episodes at 3, 6, and 12 months post-transplant as the outcome, we evaluated logistic regression models to derive odds ratios for rejection with microchimerism and with bone marrow infusion for each organ.

RESULTS

Microchimerism was generally associated with a higher incidence of acute rejection for heart, lung, and kidney transplants and a lower incidence for liver transplants, especially at 12 months and above. Bone marrow infusion decreased the risk of acute rejection for heart transplants and increased the risk for lung and, to a lesser extent, for liver transplants. No consistent effect was seen in kidney transplants. At 12 months and longer, microchimerism was associated with a decreased incidence of chronic rejection in recipients of lung transplants, but there were insufficient data to determine this outcome for other organs.

CONCLUSIONS

(i) Microchimerism was detected in the majority of patients. (ii) The effect of microchimerism and bone marrow infusion on rejection episodes varied with the organ and, for a given organ, it was time-dependent. (iii) These findings demonstrate the need for more extensive studies on microchimerism and donor-specific hyporesponsiveness.

Concanavalin A simultaneously primes liver hematopoietic and epithelial progenitor cells for parallel expansion during liver regeneration after partial hepatectomy in mice

Liver hematopoietic progenitor cells (LHPC) and liver epithelial progenitor cells (LEPC) share a remarkable number of growth and differentiation-controlling receptor-ligand signaling systems. These likely account for the ability of the liver to support hematopoiesis in fetal life, and possibly for suggestions that LHPC can differentiate into hepatocytes. In these experiments, the kinetics and magnitude of LHPC and LEPC activation and expansion were studied by using a concanavalin A (Con A) liver injury model followed by partial hepatectomy (PH). Studies were performed in interleukin 6-deficient (IL-6(-/-)) mice and wild-type (IL-6(+/+)) controls, which show equal susceptibility to Con A- induced injury, because IL-6/gp130 signaling has been implicated in both LHPC and LEPC expansion. Con A pretreatment primed LHPC and LEPC for a rapid and parallel expansion after PH in IL-6(+/+) mice, which was significantly blunted and delayed in the IL-6(-/-) mice. Exogenous IL-6 given immediately before PH after Con A, augmented both LHPC and LEPC expansion in the IL-6(-/-) mice. Thus, the proinflammatory cytokine IL-6, commonly produced in liver injury and inflammatory disease, is an important growth factor involved in the expansion of LHPC and LEPC. This observation has implications for both hepatic carcinogenesis and transplantation.

Microchimerism in bone marrow–derived CD34+ cells of patients after liver transplantation

Lymphoid and dendritic cells of donor origin can be detected in the recipient several years after a solid organ transplantation. This phenomenon is termed microchimerism and could play a role in the induction of tolerance. The fate of other hematopoietic cells transferred by liver transplantation, in particular of stem and progenitor cells, is unknown. For this reason, we studied peripheral blood and bone marrow samples of 12 patients who had received a liver transplant from an HLA-DR mismatched donor. Eight patients were long-term survivors between 2.8 and 10.1 years after allografting. CD34+ cells from bone marrow were highly enriched with the use of a 2-step method, and a nested polymerase chain reaction was applied to detect donor cells on the basis of allelic differences of the HLA-DRB1 gene. Rigorous controls with DRB1 specificities equal to the donor and host were included. In 5 of 8 long-term liver recipients, donor-specific CD34+ cells could be detected in bone marrow. Microchimerism in the CD34+ cell fraction did not correlate to the chimeric status in peripheral blood. In conclusion, our results demonstrate a frequent microchimerism among bone marrow–derived CD34+ cells after liver transplantation. The functional role of this phenomenon still needs to be defined.

Microchimerism in bone marrow–derived CD34+ cells of patients after liver transplantation

Lymphoid and dendritic cells of donor origin can be detected in the recipient several years after a solid organ transplantation. This phenomenon is termed microchimerism and could play a role in the induction of tolerance. The fate of other hematopoietic cells transferred by liver transplantation, in particular of stem and progenitor cells, is unknown. For this reason, we studied peripheral blood and bone marrow samples of 12 patients who had received a liver transplant from an HLA-DR mismatched donor. Eight patients were long-term survivors between 2.8 and 10.1 years after allografting. CD34+ cells from bone marrow were highly enriched with the use of a 2-step method, and a nested polymerase chain reaction was applied to detect donor cells on the basis of allelic differences of the HLA-DRB1 gene. Rigorous controls with DRB1 specificities equal to the donor and host were included. In 5 of 8 long-term liver recipients, donor-specific CD34+ cells could be detected in bone marrow. Microchimerism in the CD34+ cell fraction did not correlate to the chimeric status in peripheral blood. In conclusion, our results demonstrate a frequent microchimerism among bone marrow–derived CD34+ cells after liver transplantation. The functional role of this phenomenon still needs to be defined.