Genetic animal models of alcohol and drug abuse

Methodological issues in psychopathology research

We present an overview of methodological issues involved in conducting psychopathology research, including conceptual, analytic, and interpretive considerations. Research issues germane to structured diagnostic interviewed, comorbidity of mental disorders, and ascertainment and sampling are reviewed. Further, the problem of specificity (with respect to disorder, to differential deficit, and to time) is discussed. Specific issues concerning risk vs protective factors, conducting research with special populations, and the continuity of abnormal and normal functioning are highlighted. Finally, various analogue strategies (human subclinical syndromes, experimental study of "pathological" processes in normals, animal models, and computer simulations) are critiqued. Our review documents many of the impressive methodological developments that have emerged in this field, and we hope our review stimulates additional research that exploits recent methodological advances.

A genetic linkage map of the rat derived from recombinant inbred strains

We have constructed a genetic linkage map in the rat by analyzing the strain distribution patterns of 500 genetic markers in a large set of recombinant inbred strains derived from the spontaneously hypertensive rat and the Brown-Norway rat (HXB and BXH recombinant inbred strains). 454 of the markers could be assigned to specific chromosomes, and the amount of genome covered by the mapped markers was estimated to be 1151 centimorgans. By including a variety of morphologic, biochemical, immunogenetic, and molecular markers, the current map integrates and extends existing linkage data and should facilitate rat gene mapping and genetic studies of hypertension and other complex phenotypes of interest in the HXB and BXH recombinant inbred strains.

Chromosomal mapping of the psychomotor stimulant effects of cocaine in BXD recombinant inbred mice

To elucidate genes associated with cocaine's locomotor stimulant effects, we used recombinant inbred-quantitative trait loci (RI-QTL) analyses to identify chromosomal loci associated with locomotor activity before (baseline) and after cocaine treatment. RI-QTL analyses seek to identify associations between a quantitative measure of a phenotype and one or more previously mapped marker loci across a panel of RI strains. In the present study, 11 BXD RI strains were used to identify several putative QTLs for each phenotype. Both baseline locomotor activity and cocaine's locomotor stimulant effects are polygenic, with both unique and overlapping genetic influences. The largest associations for baseline activity were observed on chromosomes 5 and 9 and the largest associations for cocaine's psychomotor stimulant effects on chromosomes 3 and 17.

Genetic differences in intravenous cocaine self-administration between C57BL/6J and DBA/2J mice

In experiment 1, two different strains of mice [C57BL/6J (B6) and DBA/2J (D2)] were allowed to nosepoke for 5 microliters intravenous (IV) infusions during 2-h daily sessions. Two nosepoke holes were available, only one of which was reinforced on an FR-3 schedule with a 10-s time-out indicated by a light inside the reinforced nosepoke hole. During the first nine sessions, infusions were saline. On subsequent sessions, mice acquired nosepoking for 0.5 mg/kg cocaine. Finally, all mice were extinguished by again receiving only saline infusions. Cocaine acted as a reinforcer in both strains. In experiment 2, different mice from the same two strains were allowed to acquire nosepoking for IV cocaine at one of three unit doses (0.5, 1.0, or 2.0 mg/kg). Although there were no effects of unit dose on rate of acquisition, B6 mice were faster in acquiring self-administration behavior than were D2 mice. Experiment 3 assessed behavior in the same mice, after acquisition had occurred. D2 mice nosepoked at a lower rate at asymptote than did B6 mice, but with a higher preference for the cocaine reinforced hole. Unit doses of cocaine were then manipulated within subjects, from 0.125 to 2.0 mg/kg per infusion. Higher doses yielded lower response rates than lower doses, both between and within subjects. Behavior in D2 mice relative to B6 mice also appeared to be shifted to the left of the dose-response curve measured within-subjects. Together, these findings indicate that although cocaine serves as a reinforcer in both strains, there are genetic differences in the pattern of cocaine self-administration between these two mouse strains.

Mutations affecting sensitivity to ethanol in the nematode, Caenorhabditis elegans

Mutations in nine genes have been identified in the nematode, Caenorhabditis elegans, which control sensitivity to ethanol. The interaction of these genes has been examined and used to determine a genetic pathway controlling sensitivity to ethanol. The nature of this pathway indicates that ethanol exerts its anesthetic actions at more than one site of action. These results also indicate that ethanol is similar in its effects to the volatile anesthetics, enflurane and isoflurane.

Genetic differences in ethanol-induced conditioned taste aversion after ethanol preexposure

The present studies examined the development of ethanol-induced conditioned taste aversion in C57BL/6J (B6) and DBA/2J (D2) mice with a history of ethanol preexposure. In Experiment 1, adult male B6 and D2 mice received four preexposure injections of either saline or 4 g/kg ethanol over an 8-day period. After preexposure, all mice were given five conditioning trials consisting of 1-h access to 0.15% w/v saccharin solution followed immediately by ethanol injections (4 g/kg, IP) on all but the last trial. Drug-naive D2 mice showed greater reductions in saccharin intake. Ethanol preexposure reduced the development of ethanol-induced taste aversion in each strain. However, B6 mice showed little taste aversion overall, hindering the characterization of genetic differences in ethanol's preexposure effect. To address this problem, the parameters for taste conditioning were changed in Experiment 2 to more closely match degree of taste aversion in drug-naive mice across both strains. B6 and D2 mice received four preexposure injections of either saline, 2 g/kg ethanol, or 4 g/kg ethanol, or 4 g/kg ethanol. Subsequently, mice received five conditioning trials consisting of 1-h access to 0.2 M NaCl flavor followed by 4 g/kg ethanol (B6 mice) or 2 g/kg ethanol (D2 mice) on trials 1-4. Ethanol-naive mice of each strain developed similar levels of conditioned taste aversion. Ethanol preexposure produced greater retardation of conditioned aversion in B6 mice than in D2 mice. These results demonstrate genetic differences in the ability of ethanol preexposure to reduce the development of ethanol-induced conditioned taste aversion.

Molecular dissection of quantitative traits: progress and prospects

QTL mapping is an increasingly useful approach to the study and manipulation of complex traits important in agriculture, evolution, and medicine. The molecular dissection of quantitative phenotypes, supplementing the principles of classical quantitative genetics, is accelerating progress in the manipulation of plant and animal genomes. A growing appreciation of the similarities among different organisms and the usefulness of comparative genetic information is making genome analysis more efficient, and providing new opportunities for using model systems to overcome the limitations of less-favorable systems. The expanding repertoire of techniques and information available for studying heredity is removing obstacles to the cloning of QTLs. Although QTL mapping alone is limited to a resolution of 0.1%-1.0% of a genome, use of QTL mapping in conjunction with a search for mapped candidate genes, with emerging technologies for isolation of genes expressed under conditions likely to account for the quantitative phenotype, and with ever more efficient megabase DNA manipulation and characterization bodes well for the prospect of isolating the genetic determinants of QTLs in the foreseeable future. In the words of Thoday (1961), "An extensive attack on quantitative genetics made from this point of view as well as the biometric approach should be a great help in answering questions concerning the nature of polygenes...."

Mapping of quantitative trait loci for blood pressure and cardiac mass in the rat by genome scanning of recombinant inbred strains

In the HXB and BXH recombinant inbred strains derived from the spontaneously hypertensive rat and the normotensive Brown Norway rat, we determined the strain distribution patterns of 500 genetic markers to scan the rodent genome for quantitative trait loci regulating cardiac mass and blood pressure. The markers spanned approximately 1,139 cM of the genome and were tested for correlations with left ventricular mass adjusted for body weight, and with systolic, diastolic, and mean arterial pressures. The marker for the dopamine 1A receptor (Drd1a) on chromosome 17 showed the strongest correlation with left ventricular heart weight (P = .00038, r = -0.59) and the relationship to heart weight was independent of blood pressure. The markers showing the strongest correlations with systolic, diastolic, and mean arterial pressure were D19Mit7 on chromosome 19 (P = .0012, r = .55), D2N35 on chromosome 2 (P = .0008, r = .56), and Il6 on chromosome 4 (P = .0018, r = .53), respectively. These studies demonstrate that the HXB and BXH strains can be effectively used for genome scanning studies of complex traits and have revealed several chromosome regions that may be involved in the genetic control of blood pressure and cardiac mass in the rat.

Convergent Domestication of Cereal Crops by Independent Mutations at Corresponding Genetic Loci

Independent domestication of sorghum, rice, and maize involved convergent selection for large seeds, reduced disarticulation of the mature inflorescence, and daylength-insensitive flowering. These similar phenotypes are largely determined by a small number of quantitative trait loci (QTLs) that correspond closely in the three taxa. The correspondence of these QTLs transcends 65 million years of reproductive isolation. This finding supports models of quantitative inheritance that invoke relatively few genes, obviates difficulties in map-based cloning of QTLs, and impels the comparative mapping of complex pheno-types across large evolutionary distances, such as those that separate humans from rodents and domesticated mammals.

Identifying alcoholism vulnerability alleles

Identification of vulnerability alleles is one starting point for elucidating the web of interactions leading to alcoholism so that treatment and prevention can be improved. Heritability studies indicate that vulnerability alleles exist. Two molecular approaches for identifying them, direct analysis of candidate genes and genetic linkage, are highlighted in this review. Methodological problems that have been partially addressed and limitations for the applicability of the genetic findings are discussed.

Conditioned taste aversions induced by alcohol and lithium in rats selectively bred for ethanol neurosensitivity

Rats that were selectively bred for differences in alcohol-induced sleep time (alcohol neurosensitivity) were tested for differences in formation and extinction of alcohol- and LiCl-induced conditioned taste aversions. Male rats bred for high, control, or low alcohol sensitivity (HAS, CAS, and LAS rats, respectively) were deprived of water and given daily 30 min access to water for a baseline period of 7 days. Rats were then given a novel 0.125% sodium saccharin solution, followed by an intraperitoneal injection of either saline, 2 g/kg of ethanol (at 10% w/v), or 50.9 mg/kg of LiCl (0.15 M) on 3 conditioning days. Each saccharin exposure was followed by a recovery day of access to water. The ethanol-induced saccharin aversion extinguished more rapidly in LAS rats than in CAS or HAS rats (p < 0.05), but LiCl conditioned equivalent aversions in each group. Also, ethanol injection results in large differences in observed resting behavior in these rats (HAS > CAS > LAS), but LiCl injection produced no reliable group differences in resting. The weaker alcohol-induced taste aversion in LAS rats accords with their previously measured higher oral consumption of alcohol (Kulkosky et al., Alcoholism 17:545-551, 1993) and the idea that alcohol intake is limited by an expectancy of postingestive consequences. The weaker ethanol-induced aversion in LAS rats reflects selective breeding of an alcohol-specific trait and not a general difference in aversive conditioning or chemical neurosensitivity.

Classical and neoclassical approaches to the genetic analysis of alcohol-related phenotypes

Theoretical descriptions are given for two breeding methods in animal genetics that might be of use in alcohol research. These methods are marker-based selection and marker-based development of congenic strains, both using DNA markers such as polymerase chain reaction-detectable polymorphisms as the criteria for breeding. Such designs would utilize these markers as indicators of adjacent Quantitative Trait Loci (QTL) that are influential on alcohol-related phenotypes. Issues in the logic and implementation of these methods, such as proximity of the markers and the QTL allele, are explored. A third method, development of congenic strains with phenotypic screening, is also described. This method is currently being used to create two sets of congenic lines on a C57BL/6 inbred mouse background. The criterion phenotype is locomotor activation to 1.5 g/kg (i.p.) ethanol. Data are reported on the success of transferring the activation phenotype from two strains, DBA/2Abg and MOLD/Rk-Abg, onto the nonactivated C57BL/6Abg background. The value of these methods in alcohol research is outlined with regard to both identification of relevant genes and for their use as tools in basic research on mechanism of alcohol action.

Quantitative trait loci that modify the severity of spotting in piebald mice

Mice homozygous for the recessive mutation piebald (s) exhibit a white-spotted coat caused by the defective development of neural crest-derived melanocytes. The severity of white spotting varies greatly, depending on the genetic background on which s is expressed. A backcross between two inbred strains of s/s mice that exhibit large differences in the degree of spotting was used to identify six genetic modifiers of piebald spotting on chromosomes 2, 5, 7, 8, 10, and 13. The loci differed in their spatial contribution to spotting on the dorsal versus ventral surfaces of mice; nonadditive interactions were observed between loci on chromosomes 2 and 5. This study underscores the power of using genetic analyses to identify and analyze loci involved in modifying the severity of phenotypic traits in mice.

Strategies for mapping and identifying quantitative trait loci specifying behavioral responses to alcohol

Most responses to alcohol in both humans and animals are heritable, and this genetic sensitivity to ethanol is determined by multiple genes. However, the number of genes, their identities, and just how they determine susceptibility to the actions of alcohol are unknown. Herein, we describe a multistage strategy for mapping quantitative trait loci (QTLs) using recombinant inbred strains and F2 mice. Precise mapping of the chromosome positions of these QTLs should increase our understanding of the genetic causes for individual differences in behavioral sensitivity to alcohol by (1) identifying genomic markers associated with sensitivity to alcohol, (2) allowing the genes specifying behavior to be cloned by position, and (3) elucidating "candidate" genes demonstrating linkage to markers associated with behavioral responses to alcohol. Syntenic conservation between the mouse and human genomes should facilitate the eventual mapping and cloning of human homologs of these QTLs. Ultimately, cloning of these genes may allow the development of gene therapies or other therapeutic interventions for management or prevention of alcoholism and alcohol abuse.

Localization to chromosome 10 of a locus influencing morphine analgesia in crosses derived from C57BL/6 and DBA/2 strains

A quantitative trait locus (QTL) was detected and mapped to proximal chromosome 10 near the markers Mpmv5 and D10Mit51 with a strong influence on morphine-induced analgesia in the BXD recombinant inbred (RI) strains and in an F2 cross (B6D2F2) between the BXD progenitor strains, C57BL/6 and DBA/2. A LOD score of 3.9 (p < .00002) was seen for analgesia using the hot plate assay. Naloxone Bmax was also associated with this chromosome region in BXD RI mice. The mu opioid receptor gene (Oprm) has recently been mapped to this same chromosome region. The observation that several morphine-related traits and naloxone Bmax appear to be partly determined by this presumed single locus is consistent with the hypothesis that the mu opioid receptor gene, or one of its modulators, is the basis for the QTL.

Localization of genes influencing ethanol-induced conditioned place preference and locomotor activity in BXD recombinant inbred mice

Genetic differences in ethanol's ability to induce conditioned place preference were studied in 20 BXD Recombinant Inbred (RI) mouse strains and in the C57BL/6J and DBA/2J progenitor strains. Male mice from each strain were exposed to a Pavlovian conditioning procedure in which a distinctive floor stimulus (CS+) was paired four times with ethanol (2 g/kg). A different floor stimulus (CS-) was paired with saline. Control mice were injected only with saline. Floor preference testing without ethanol revealed significant genetic differences in conditioned place preference, with some strains spending nearly 80% time on the ethanol-paired floor while others spent only 50% (i.e., no preference). Control mice showed genetic differences in unconditioned preference for the floor cues, but unconditioned preference was not genetically correlated with conditioned preference. There were also substantial genetic differences in ethanol-stimulated activity, but contrary to psychomotor stimulant theory, ethanol-induced activity on conditioning trials was not positively correlated with strength of conditioned place preference. However, there was a significant negative genetic correlation (r = -0.42) between test session activity and preference. Quantitative trait loci (QTL) analyses showed strong associations (P < 0.01) between conditioned place preference and marker loci on chromosomes 4, 8, 9, 18 and 19. Weaker associations (0.01 < P < 0.05) were identified on several other chromosomes. Analysis also yielded several significant QTL for unconditioned preference, ethanol-stimulated activity, and sensitization. Overall, these data support the conclusion that genotype influences ethanol-induced conditioned place preference, presumably via genetic differences in sensitivity to ethanol's rewarding effects. Moreover, several chromosomal regions containing candidate genes of potential relevance to ethanol-induced conditioned place preference have been identified.

Effects of acute and repeated ethanol exposures on the locomotor activity of BXD recombinant inbred mice

Investigations of ethanol's (EtOH's) complex response profile, including locomotor and other effects, are likely to lead to a more in-depth understanding of the constituents of alcohol addiction. Locomotor activity responses to acute and repeated EtOH (2 g/kg, ip) exposures were measured in BXD recombinant inbred (RI) mice and their C57BL/6J (B6) and DBA/2J (D2) progenitors. Both the acute response and the change in initial EtOH response with repeated treatments were strain-dependent. The coefficient of genetic determination was 0.38-0.49 for initial locomotor response to EtOH, and 0.29 for change in response. Changes in response were largely attributable to sensitization of locomotor stimulation. Quantitative trait loci (QTL) analyses identified significant marker associations with basal activity, acute locomotor response, and change in response. Markers were for QTL on several chromosomes, and there was only one case of overlap in marker associations among phenotypes. Acute locomotor response and locomotor sensitization were negatively correlated with 3% EtOH preference drinking data collected in BXD RI strains. Overall, these results demonstrate locomotor sensitization induced by EtOH, suggest independence of genetic determination of locomotor responses to acute and repeated EtOH exposure, and partially support a relationship between reduced sensitivity to the locomotor stimulant/sensitizing effects of EtOH and EtOH consumption.

Alcohol acceptance, preference, and sensitivity in mice. II. Quantitative trait loci mapping analysis using BXD recombinant inbred strains

Quantitative trait loci (QTL) mapping of complex phenotypes has emerged as an important feature of the recombinant inbred (RI) strain methodology. In this second study of our series on alcohol-related behaviors in mice, we examine alcohol acceptance, preference, and hypnotic dose sensitivity (HDS) to a standard dose of alcohol measured in BXD RI strains to identify candidate QTL regions responsible for their heritability. We detected highly significant marker associations for acceptance on chromosome 12 (Eif4e), for preference on chromosome 1 (D1Rti2) and chromosome 7 (D7Mit7), and for HDS on chromosome 7 (Mpmv1). These are the strongest QTL associations that we detected, but several other candidate QTL regions are reported. Given the limited number of BXD RI strains available, the large number of markers used herein, and the consequent chance of identifying false marker associations, these RI QTL mapping results must be seen as tentative, but an important first step toward identifying QTL for alcohol-related behaviors.

Rat mitochondrial aldehyde dehydrogenase polymorphism and major histocompatibility complex RT1.A phenotypes are not associated with alcohol drinking in P and NP rats

Previous studies revealed polymorphisms in mitochondrial aldehyde dehydrogenase (ALDH2) and the major histocompatibility complex RT1.A that appeared in association with alcohol drinking preference in the alcohol-preferring (P) and alcohol-nonpreferring (NP) rat lines. To determine the strength of these associations, the P and NP lines were crossed, and cosegregation studies were performed in the F2 progeny. The ALDH2Q allele and the ALDH2R allele, found in the P and NP lines, respectively, were found not to be associated with the high and low drinking animals in the F2 progeny. Kinetic studies with ALDH2Q and ALDH2R isozymes purified from the mitochondria of P and NP rat livers, respectively, showed that the polymorphism would not be expected to be associated with altered aldehyde metabolism. The association between RT1.A and alcohol preference (RT1.Auu with high and RT1.AII with low alcohol intake) also could not be confirmed in the segregating F2 progeny of the P x NP intercross.

GABAA receptor beta 1, beta 2, and beta 3 subunits: comparisons in DBA/2J and C57BL/6J mice

GABAA receptors link binding of GABA (gamma-aminobutyric acid) to inhibitory chloride flux in the brain. They are the site of action of several important classes of drugs, and have been implicated in animal models of epilepsy and in the actions of alcohol. We compare the sequence and expression of the beta 1, beta 2 and beta 3 subunits of GABAA receptors in two inbred strains of mice, DBA/2J and C57BL/6J, which differ markedly in seizure susceptibility and in a variety of behaviors related to alcohol. Only the beta 3 subunit had strain differences in cDNA nucleotide sequence, which did not affect amino acid sequence but which did create restriction fragment length polymorphisms (RFLPs) potentially useful in gene mapping. We have also tested mouse beta 1 and beta 2 subunits for internal alternative splicing, detecting none.

Personality and the inheritance of smoking behavior: a genetic perspective

In contrast to the extensive research effort to understand the genetic contribution to alcoholism risk, there has been little research directed at understanding genetic influences on smoking behavior. Data from large twin studies in Scandinavia and Australia are consistent with a major genetic influence on the probability that an individual will become a smoker ("initiation") and will persist in the smoking habit once smoking has started ("persistence"). We use data from the 1988/1989 follow-up survey of the Australian NH&MRC twin panel to determine to what degree personality measures (Tridimensional Personality Questionnaire, Eysenck Personality Questionnaire--Revised) and attitudinal and sociodemographic variables (social and political conservatism, education, religious involvement) might account for genetic or environmental influences on smoking. While we find significant phenotypic associations between these variables and smoking, these are too modest to account for much of the genetic variance. Possible mechanisms by which this genetic variance may arise are discussed.

Chromosomal localization of opioid peptide and receptor genes in the mouse

Opiate receptors are the primary targets for the drugs of abuse morphine and heroin. In this study, we completed the localization on mouse chromosomes of the genes encoding mu (Oprm) and kappa (Oprk) receptors, as well as the genes for the opioid propeptides proenkephalin (Penk) and prodynorphin (Pdyn). The genetic mapping was performed using a panel of DNA samples from an interspecific cross [C3H/HeJ-gld and (C3H/HeJ-gld x Mus spretus)F1] that has been characterized for more than 800 markers throughout the genome. The genes are localized on mouse Chr 1 (Oprk, 10 cM from the centromere), Chr 2 (Pdyn, 75 cM from the centromere), Chr 4 (Penk, 1 cM from the centromere) and Chr 10 (Oprm, 10 cM from the centromere). Interestingly, the gene for the mu receptor is located in the same region as a Quantitative Trait Locus for high morphine consumption, thus raising the possibility of its direct role in drug abuse mechanisms.

Chromosome landing: a paradigm for map-based gene cloning in plants with large genomes

The original concept behind map-based or positional cloning was to find a DNA marker linked to a gene of interest, and then to 'walk' to the gene via overlapping clones (e.g. cosmids or YACs). While chromosome walking is straightforward in organisms with small genomes, it is difficult to apply in most plant species, which typically have large, complex genomes. The strategy of chromosome walking is based on the assumption that it is difficult and time consuming to find DNA markers that are physically close to a gene of interest. Recent technological developments invalidate this assumption for many species. As a result, the mapping paradigm has now changed such that one first isolates one or more DNA marker(s) at a physical distance from the targeted gene that is less than the average insert size of the genomic library being used for clone isolation. The DNA marker is then used to screen the library and isolate (or 'land' on) the clone containing the gene, without any need for chromosome walking and its associated problems. Chromosome landing, together with the technology that has made it possible, is likely to become the main strategy by which map-based cloning is applied to isolate both major genes and genes underlying quantitative traits in plant species.

Genetic dissection of complex traits

Medical genetics was revolutionized during the 1980s by the application of genetic mapping to locate the genes responsible for simple Mendelian diseases. Most diseases and traits, however, do not follow simple inheritance patterns. Genetics have thus begun taking up the even greater challenge of the genetic dissection of complex traits. Four major approaches have been developed: linkage analysis, allele-sharing methods, association studies, and polygenic analysis of experimental crosses. This article synthesizes the current state of the genetic dissection of complex traits--describing the methods, limitations, and recent applications to biological problems.

Genetic aspects and risk factors in alcoholism and alcoholic liver disease

There is a great deal of evidence for genetic predisposition to alcoholism; considerably less is known regarding predisposition to alcoholic liver disease. The specific genes involved in either disorder are not well understood, although the enzymes of alcohol metabolism appear to play some role. It will be interesting to determine whether genetic factors that alter the expression of these enzymes, in addition to altering the kinetics of the enzymes, could modify responses to drinking. Work in the next few years will include determination of which responses to alcohol are indeed genetically influenced in twin studies, testing additional candidate genes for alcohol-related traits in populations and families, as well as the application of genomic mapping methodologies to alcoholic pedigrees. The latter strategy will be integrated into the larger number of studies that will grow from the Human Genome Project. Animal studies with selectively bred lines of rodents that differ in voluntary alcohol consumption will lead the way to define the neuronal and behavioral substrates responsible for differences in alcohol-drinking behavior. The use of the quantitative trait locus (QTL) mapping approach in F2 intercross between two inbred strains of rodents with opposite alcohol-response characteristics and in recombinant inbred strains derived from F2 intercross already has and will continue to help identify chromosomal locations of genes relevant to voluntary alcohol consumption. Perhaps in the future selective breeding of rodents and QTL mapping strategies can also be used to determine the biology and genetics of alcohol-induced liver injury.