Associations of sNfL with clinico-radiological measures in a large MS population

Predictive potential of serum and cerebrospinal fluid biomarkers for disease activity in treated multiple sclerosis patients

BACKGROUND

Our objective was to explore various biomarkers for predicting suboptimal responses to disease-modifying treatments (DMTs) in patients with MS (pwMS).

METHODS

We conducted a longitudinal, bicentric study with pwMS stratified based on their DMTs responses. Treatment failure (TF) was defined as the onset of a second relapse, presence of two or more T2 new lesions, or disability progression independent of relapse during the follow-up period. We evaluated intrathecal synthesis (ITS) of IgG and IgM using OCB, linear indices, and Reibergrams. Free kappa light chains ITS was assessed using the linear index (FKLCi). NfL and GFAP in serum and CSF, and CHI3L1 in CSF were quantified. Quantitative variables were dichotomized based on the third quartile. Predictive efficacy was assessed through bivariate and multivariate analyses, adjusting for age, sex, EDSS, acute inflammatory activity (AI) -defined as the onset of a relapse or gadolinium-enhancing lesions within a 90-day window of lumbar puncture-, treatment modality, study center, and time from disease onset to treatment initiation. In case of collinearity, multiple models were generated or confounding variables were excluded if collinearity existed between them and the biomarker. The same methodology was used to investigate the predictive potential of various combinations of two biomarkers, based on whether any of them tested positive or exceeded the third quartile.

RESULTS

A total of 137 pwMS were included. FKLCi showed no differences based on AI, no correlation with EDSS and was significantly higher in pwMS with TF (p = 0.008). FKLCi>130 was associated with TF in bivariate analysis (Log-Rank p = 0.004). Due to collinearity between age and EDSS, two different models were generated with each of them and the rest of the confounding variables, in which FKLCi>130 showed a Hazard Ratio (HR) of 2.69 (CI: 1.35-5.4) and 2.67 (CI: 1.32-5.4), respectively. The combination of either FKLC or sNfL exceeding the third quartile was also significant in bivariate (Log-Rank p = 0.04) and multivariate (HR=3.1 (CI: 1.5-6.5)) analyses. However, when analyzed independently, sNfL did not show significance, and FKLCi mirrored the pattern obtained in the previous model (HR: 3.04; CI: 1.51-6.1). Treatment with highefficacy DMTs emerged as a protective factor in all models.

DISCUSSION

Our analysis and the fact that FKLCi is independent of EDSS and AI suggest that it might be a valuable parameter for discriminating aggressive phenotypes. We propose implementing high-efficacy drugs in pwMS with elevated FKLCi.

Prevalence of elevated sNFL in a real-world setting: Results on 908 patients with different multiple sclerosis types and treatment conditions

BACKGROUND

In the field of research for new validated surrogate biomarkers of treatment efficacy, disease activity and progression in Multiple Sclerosis (MS), serum neurofilament light-chain (sNFL) are actually the best candidate for MS patient monitoring. However, before they can be implemented in clinical practice, their usefulness as additional red flag routine measure must be demonstrated. To tackle the problem, this real-life cross-sectional study at the Regional Referring Center for Multiple Sclerosis (CRESM) aims to characterize sNFL levels and prevalence of elevated sNFL, according to our age-dependent cut-off values, in a large group of patients with different types of MS and treatment conditions.

METHODS

908 serum samples from as many MS patients being admitted at CRESM for diagnostic definition and/or during routinary treatment monitoring were consecutively collected between January 2019 and January 2020. sNFL levels were measured by single molecule array (Simoa™) technology on SR-X instrument using NF-light assays (Quanterix); results were interpreted using previously published cut-off values.

RESULTS

Primary and Secondary Progressive MS (PPMS, SPMS) forms demonstrate higher levels and prevalence of elevated sNFL (PPMS= 32 %, SPMS= 21 %) compared to the Relapse and Remitting one (RRMS = 12 %). Besides, naïve samples of RRMS and PPMS subtypes showed higher prevalence of elevated sNFL (RRMS naïve= 31 %, PPMS naïve=67 %) compared to samples from patients treated for more than 12 months (RRMS treat>12m= 9 %, PPMS treat>12m= 19 %); treated SPMS patients demonstrated higher sNFL levels and a prevalence (22 %) of elevated sNFL compared to RRMS treated patients. Focusing on RRMS, no statistical difference was found between groups of patients treated for whatever time (up to or more than 60 months) and with either DMT type (high or low-efficacy DMT). Finally, RRMS patients treated with all DMTs for more than 12 months, with the exception of teriflunomide and alemtuzumab showed a prevalence of elevated sNFL in the range of 5-10 %.

CONCLUSION

in a real-world setting comprising about 1000 MS patients, sNFL quantification was elevated in 5-to-67 % of patients, in different MS forms and treatment conditions. Elevated levels of sNFL must be considered a red-flag suggesting the need of a further clinical monitoring in any circumstance, as it can be indicative of new inflammation, ongoing degeneration or co-morbidities. This study supports the introduction of sNFL quantification in everyday patient management.

Head-to-head comparison of four plasma neurofilament light chain (NfL) immunoassays

BACKGROUND

Neurofilament Light Chain (NfL) is an emerging blood biomarker of neuro-axonal injury and neurodegeneration with the potential to be used in the clinical management of various neurological conditions. Various NfL immunoassays are in development on high-throughput automated systems, but little information is available related to the comparability between assays. In this study, we performed a head-to-head comparison of four NfL immunoassays using plasma samples from individuals with various neurological conditions.

METHODS

EDTA plasma samples in which NfL was ordered clinically were stratified according to diagnosis. NfL concentrations (pg/mL) in plasma were obtained using the Quanterix Simoa®, the Roche Elecsys, the Siemens Healthineers Atellica®IM, and the Fujirebio Lumipulse® NfL assays. Passing-Bablok regression analyses were performed to assess the correlation and bias between methods. Additionally, the distribution of NfL concentrations for each assay was assessed in three disease groups: amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) upon initial diagnosis, ALS treated, and multiple sclerosis (MS).

RESULTS

The R2 between assays were all ≥ 0.95, however, significant proportional bias was observed between some assays. In particular, the Roche Elecsys assay NfL concentrations were significantly lower (∼85 %) when compared against the other three assays. The four assays were comparable with regards to the percentage of patients that were identified as having an elevated NfL result in the various clinical groups: ALS initial diagnoses (83-94 %), ALS untreated (93-100 %), and MS (8-18 %).

CONCLUSIONS

This is the first study describing a head-to-head comparison of four automated NfL immunoassays. We demonstrate that there is a strong correlation between assays but a lack of standardization which is evident by the bias observed between some of the evaluated methods. These analytical differences will be important to consider when using NfL as a biomarker of neurodegeneration.

Understanding multiple sclerosis as a disease spectrum: above and below the clinical threshold

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Research in multiple sclerosis (MS) has long been predicated on clinical groupings that do not reflect the underlying biologic heterogeneity apparent within patient populations. This review explicates the various levels of explanation through which the spectrum of disease is described and investigated both above and below the clinical threshold of detection, as framed by the topographical model of MS, to help advance a cogent mechanistic framework.

RECENT FINDINGS

Contemporary evidence has amended the view of MS as consisting of sequential disease phases in favor of a spectrum of disease with an admixture of interdependent and dynamic pathobiological axes driving tissue injury and progression. Recent studies have shown the presence of acute and compartmentalized inflammation and mechanisms of neurodegeneration beginning early and evolving throughout the disease continuum. Still, the gap between the understanding of immunopathologic processes in MS and the tools used to measure relevant molecular, laboratory, radiologic, and clinical metrics needs attention to enable better prognostication of disease and monitoring for changes along specific pathologic axes and variable treatment outcomes.

SUMMARY

Aligning on a consistently-applied mechanistic framework at distinct levels of explanation will enable greater precision across bench and clinical research, and inform discourse on drivers of disability progression and delivery of care for individuals with MS.

Temporal Relationship Between Serum Neurofilament Light Chain and Radiologic Disease Activity in Patients With Multiple Sclerosis

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Serum neurofilament light chain (sNfL) levels correlate with multiple sclerosis (MS) disease activity, but the dynamics of this correlation are unknown. We evaluated the relationship between sNfL levels and radiologic MS disease activity through monthly assessments during the 24-week natalizumab treatment interruption period in RESTORE (NCT01071083).

METHODS

In the RESTORE trial, participants with relapsing forms of MS who had received natalizumab for ≥12 months were randomized to either continue or stop natalizumab and followed with MRI and blood draws every 4 weeks to week 28 and again at week 52 The sNfL was measured, and its dynamics were correlated with the development of gadolinium-enhancing (Gd+) lesions. Log-linear trend in sNfL levels were modeled longitudinally using generalized estimating equations with robust variance estimator from baseline to week 28.

RESULTS

Of 175 patients enrolled in RESTORE, 166 had serum samples for analysis. Participants with Gd+ lesions were younger (37.7 vs 43.1, p = 0.001) and had lower Expanded Disability Status Scale scores at baseline (2.7 vs 3.4, p = 0.017) than participants without Gd+ lesions. sNfL levels increased in participants with Gd+ lesions (n = 65) compared with those without (n = 101, mean change from baseline to maximum sNfL value, 12.1 vs 3.2 pg/mL, respectively; p = 0.003). As the number of Gd+ lesions increased, peak median sNfL change also increased by 1.4, 3.0, 4.3, and 19.6 pg/mL in the Gd+ lesion groups of 1 (n = 12), 2-3 (n = 18), 4-9 (n = 21), and ≥10 (n = 14) lesions, respectively. However, 46 of 65 (71%) participants with Gd+ lesions did not increase above the 95th percentile threshold of the group without Gd+ lesions. The initial increase of sNfL typically trailed the first observation of Gd+ lesions, and the peak increase in sNfL was a median [interquartile range] of 8 [0, 12] weeks after the first appearance of the Gd+ lesion.

DISCUSSION

Although sNfL correlated with the presence of Gd+ lesions, most participants with Gd+ lesions did not have elevations in sNfL levels. These observations have implications for the use and interpretation of sNfL as a biomarker for monitoring MS disease activity in controlled trials and clinical practice.

Highly Effective Therapy Versus Escalation Approaches in Early Multiple Sclerosis: What Is the Future of Multiple Sclerosis Treatment?

Treatment options for patients newly diagnosed with multiple sclerosis (MS) are expanding with the continuous development and approval of new disease-modifying therapies (DMTs). The optimal initial treatment strategy, however, remains unclear. The 2 main treatment paradigms currently employed are the escalation (ESC) approach and the early highly effective treatment (EHT) approach. The ESC approach consists of starting a lower- or moderate-efficacy DMT, which offers a potentially safer approach, while the EHT approach favors higher-efficacy treatment early in the disease course, despite a potential increase in risk. Randomized clinical trials aiming to directly compare these approaches in newly diagnosed MS patients are currently underway.

Recent Advances in Diagnostic, Prognostic, and Disease-Monitoring Biomarkers in Multiple Sclerosis

Multiple sclerosis (MS) is a highly heterogeneous disease. Currently, a combination of clinical features, MRI, and cerebrospinal fluid markers are used in clinical practice for diagnosis and treatment decisions. In recent years, there has been considerable effort to develop novel biomarkers that better reflect the pathologic substrates of the disease to aid in diagnosis and early prognosis, evaluation of ongoing inflammatory activity, detection and monitoring of disease progression, prediction of treatment response, and monitoring of disease-modifying treatment safety. In this review, the authors provide an overview of promising recent developments in diagnostic, prognostic, and disease-monitoring/treatment-response biomarkers in MS.

Agreement Between Published Reference Resources for Neurofilament Light Chain Levels in People With Multiple Sclerosis

OBJECTIVES

To examine the agreement between published reference resources for neurofilament light chain (NfL) applied to a large population of people with multiple sclerosis (MS).

METHODS

Six published reference resources were used to classify NfL in participants in the Multiple Sclerosis Partners Advancing Technology and Health Solutions (MS PATHS) network as elevated or normal and to derive age-specific NfL Z-scores. NfL values were classified as elevated if they exceeded the >95th percentile (i.e., Z-score >1.645) of the age-specific reference range. Furthermore, age-specific NfL Z-scores could be derived for 4 of 6 reference resources.

RESULTS

NfL measurements were assessed from 12,855 visits of 6,687 people with MS (median 2 samples per individual [range 1-7]). The mean ± SD age was 47.1 ± 11.7 years, 72.1% of participants were female, disease duration was 15.0 ± 10.6 years, body mass index was 28.6 ± 6.9 kg/m2, and serum NfL was 12.87 ± 12.86 pg/mL. Depending on the selection of the reference resource, the proportion of NfL measurements classified as elevated varied from 3.7% to 30.9%. The kappa coefficient across the 6 reference resources used was 0.576 (95% CI 0.571-0.580) indicating moderate agreement. Spearman correlations between Z-scores derived from the various reference resources exceeded 0.90; however, concordance coefficients were lower, ranging from 0.72 to 0.89.

DISCUSSION

Interpretation of blood NfL values may vary markedly depending on the selection of the reference resource. Borderline elevated values should be interpreted with caution, and future studies should focus on standardizing NfL measurement and reporting across laboratories/platforms, better characterizing the effects of confounding/influencing factors, and defining the performance of NfL (including as part of multimodal predictive algorithms) for prediction of disease-specific outcomes.

Neurofilament Light Chain in Adult and Pediatric Multiple Sclerosis: A Promising Biomarker to Better Characterize Disease Activity and Personalize MS Treatment

Many biological markers have been explored in multiple sclerosis (MS) to better quantify disease burden and better evaluate response to treatments, beyond clinical and MRI data. Among these, neurofilament light chain (Nf-L), although non-specific for this disease and found to be increased in other neurological conditions, has been shown to be the most promising biomarker for assessing axonal damage in MS, with a definite role in predicting the development of MS in patients at the first neurological episode suggestive of MS, and also in a preclinical phase. There is strong evidence that Nf-L levels are increased more in relapsing versus stable MS patients, and that they predict future disease evolution (relapses, progression, MRI measures of activity/progression) in MS patients, providing information on response to therapy, helping to anticipate clinical decisions in patients with an apparently stable evolution, and identifying patient non-responders to disease-modifying treatments. Moreover, Nf-L can contribute to the better understanding of the mechanisms of demyelination and axonal damage in adult and pediatric MS. A fundamental requirement for its clinical use is the accurate standardization of normal values, corrected for confounding factors, in particular age, sex, body mass index, and presence of comorbidities. In this review, a guide is provided to update clinicians on the use of Nf-L in clinical activity.

Treatment Effect on Brain Atrophy Correlates with Treatment Effect on Cognition in Multiple Sclerosis

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the extent to which treatment effect on magnetic resonance imaging (MRI)-derived measures of brain atrophy and focal lesions can mediate, at the trial level, the treatment effect on cognitive outcomes in multiple sclerosis (MS).

METHODS

We collected all published randomized clinical trials in MS lasting at least 2 years and including as end points: active MRI lesions (defined as new/enlarging T2 lesions), brain atrophy (defined as a change in brain volume between month 12 and month 24), and change in cognitive performance (assessed by the Paced Auditory Serial Addition Test [PASAT]). Relative reductions were used to quantify the treatment effect on MRI markers (lesions and atrophy), whereas the standardized mean difference (Hedges g) between baseline and follow-up cognitive assessment was used to quantify the treatment effects on cognition. A linear regression, weighted for trial size, was used to assess the relationship between the treatment effects on MRI markers and cognition.

RESULTS

Fourteen trials including more than 8,813 patients with MS were included in the meta-regression. Treatment effect on cognition was strongly associated with the treatment effect on brain atrophy (R2  = 0.79, p < 0.001), but was not correlated with the treatment effect on active MRI lesions (R2  = 0.16, p = 0.14).

INTERPRETATION

Results reported here suggest that brain atrophy, a well-established MRI marker in MS clinical trials, can be used as a main outcome for clinical trials with drugs targeting cognitive impairment and neurodegeneration. ANN NEUROL 2023;94:925-932.

Biological variation estimates for serum neurofilament light chain in healthy subjects

OBJECTIVES

Neurofilament light chain (NfL) is an emerging biomarker of neurodegeneration disorders. Knowledge of the biological variation (BV) can facilitate proper interpretation between serial measurements. Here BV estimates for serum NfL (sNfL) are provided.

METHODS

Serum samples were collected weekly from 24 apparently healthy subjects for 10 consecutive weeks and analyzed in duplicate using the Siemens Healthineers sNfL assay on the Atellica® IM Analyzer. Outlier detection, variance homogeneity analyses, and trend analysis were performed followed by CV-ANOVA to determine BV and analytical variation (CVA) estimates with 95%CI and the associated reference change values (RCV) and analytical performance specifications (APS).

RESULTS

Despite observed differences in sNfL concentrations between males and females, BV estimates remained consistent across genders. Both within-subject BV (CVI) for males (10.7%, 95%CI; 9.2-12.6) and females (9.1%, 95%CI; 7.8-10.9) and between-subject BV (CVG) for males (26.1%, 95%CI; 18.0-45.6) and females (30.2%, 95%CI; 20.9-53.5) were comparable. An index of individuality value of 0.33 highlights significant individuality, indicating the potential efficacy of personalized reference intervals in patient monitoring.

CONCLUSIONS

The established BV estimates for sNfL underscore its potential as a valuable biomarker for monitoring neurodegenerative diseases, offering a foundation for improved decision-making in clinical settings.

Emerging imaging and liquid biomarkers in multiple sclerosis

The advent of highly effective disease modifying therapy has transformed the landscape of multiple sclerosis (MS) care over the last two decades. However, there remains a critical, unmet need for sensitive and specific biomarkers to aid in diagnosis, prognosis, treatment monitoring, and the development of new interventions, particularly for people with progressive disease. This review evaluates the current data for several emerging imaging and liquid biomarkers in people with MS. MRI findings such as the central vein sign and paramagnetic rim lesions may improve MS diagnostic accuracy and evaluation of therapy efficacy in progressive disease. Serum and cerebrospinal fluid levels of several neuroglial proteins, such as neurofilament light chain and glial fibrillary acidic protein, show potential to be sensitive biomarkers of pathologic processes such as neuro-axonal injury or glial-inflammation. Additional promising biomarkers, including optical coherence tomography, cytokines and chemokines, microRNAs, and extracellular vesicles/exosomes, are also reviewed, among others. Beyond their potential integration into MS clinical care and interventional trials, several of these biomarkers may be informative of MS pathogenesis and help elucidate novel targets for treatment strategies.

Prediabetes is associated with a higher serum neurofilament light chain level in adolescents

Objective

Serum neurofilament light chain (sNfL) level, which is a biomarker indicative of neuroaxonal damage and cognitive impairment, has been reported in several neurological diseases. There has been a lack of studies on the association between sNfL levels and prediabetes in adolescents. This study investigated whether sNfL levels were higher in adolescents with prediabetes undergoing elective orthopedic surgery.

Methods

The sNfL level was measured in 149 adolescents aged from 12 to 18 years who underwent elective orthopedic surgery at the Hunan Children's Hospital (18 with and 131 without prediabetes). We evaluated the association between prediabetes and sNfL level after adjusting for age, sex, and triglycerides using a multivariable linear regression model.

Results

The prevalence of prediabetes in adolescents was 12.08%. Univariate logistic regression analysis showed that prediabetes was related to sNfL. In multivariate logistic regression analysis, the association between prediabetes with sNfL levels remained significant after adjustment for age, sex, and triglyceride. The relationship between the two was further visualized by a smoothed curve.

Conclusions

Prediabetes is associated with a higher sNfL. Further large-scale and prospective studies are needed to verify the clinical application of sNfL as a monitoring biomarker for adolescent prediabetes in adolescents and to evaluate the performance of sNfL in predicting the incidence of neuropathy and cognitive dysfunction in adolescents with prediabetes.