Integrated bi-layered scaffold for osteochondral tissue engineering

Cell-free bilayer functionalized scaffold for osteochondral tissue engineering

Osteochondral tissue engineering using layered scaffolds is a promising approach for treating osteochondral defects as an alternative to microfracture procedure, autologous chondrocyte implantation, and cartilage-bone grafting. The team previously investigated the chondrogenesis of mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) on a polycaprolactone (PCL)/acetylated hyaluronic acid scaffold. The present study first focused on fabricating a novel osteoconductive scaffold utilizing bismuth-nanohydroxyapatite/reduced graphene oxide (Bi-nHAp/rGO) nanocomposite and electrospun PCL. The osteoconductive ability of the scaffold was investigated by evaluating the alkaline phosphatase (ALP) activity and the osteogenic genes expression in the adipose-derived MSCs. The expression of Runx2, collagen I, ALP, and osteocalcin as well as the result of ALP activity indicated the osteoconductive potential of the Bi-nHA-rGO/PCL scaffold. In the next step, a bilayer scaffold containing Bi-nHAp/rGO/PCL as an osteogenic layer and acetylated hyaluronic acid/PCL as a chondrogenic layer was prepared by the electrospinning technique and transplanted into osteochondral defects of rats. The chondrogenic and osteogenic markers corresponding to the surrounding tissues of the transplanted scaffold were surveyed 60 days later by real-time polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and immunohistochemistry methods. The results showed increased chondrogenic (Sox9 and collagen II) and osteogenic (osteocalcin and ALP) gene expression and augmented secretion of collagens II and X after transplantation. The results strongly support the efficacy of this constructed cell-free bilayer scaffold to induce osteochondral defect regeneration.

Whey Protein Isolate Composites as Potential Scaffolds for Cultivated Meat

Modern food technology has given rise to numerous alternative protein sources in response to a growing human population and the negative environmental impacts of current food systems. To aid in achieving global food security, one such form of alternative protein being investigated is cultivated meat, which applies the principles of mechanical and tissue engineering to produce animal proteins and meat products from animal cells. Herein, nonmodified and methacrylated whey protein formed hydrogels with methacrylated alginate as potential tissue engineering scaffolds for cultivated meat. Whey protein is a byproduct of dairy processing and was selected because it is an approved food additive and cytocompatible and has shown efficacy in other biomaterial applications. Whey protein and alginate scaffolds were formed via visible light cross-linking in aqueous solutions under ambient conditions. The characteristics of the precursor solution and the physical-mechanical properties of the scaffolds were quantified; while gelation occurred within the homo- and copolymer hydrogels, the integrity of the network was significantly altered with varying components. Qualitatively, the scaffolds exhibited a three-dimensional (3D) interconnected porous network. Whey protein isolate (WPI)-based scaffolds were noncytotoxic and supported in vitro myoblast adhesion and proliferation. The data presented support the hypothesis that the composition of the hydrogel plays a significant role in the scaffold's performance.

Dual-network DNA-silk fibroin hydrogels with controllable surface rigidity for regulating chondrogenic differentiation

Osteoarthritis (OA) is a common joint disease known for cartilage degeneration, leading to a substantial burden on individuals and society due to its high disability rate. However, current clinical treatments for cartilage defects remain unsatisfactory due to the unclear mechanisms underlying cartilage regeneration. Tissue engineering hydrogels have emerged as an attractive approach in cartilage repair. Recent research studies have indicated that stem cells can sense the mechanical strength of hydrogels, thereby regulating their differentiation fate. In this study, we present the groundbreaking construction of dual-network DNA-silk fibroin (SF) hydrogels with controllable surface rigidity. The supramolecular networks, formed through DNA base-pairing, induce the development of β-sheet structures by constraining and aggregating SF molecules. Subsequently, SF was cross-linked via horseradish peroxidase (HRP)-mediated enzyme reactions to form the second network. Experimental results demonstrated a positive correlation between the surface rigidity of dual-network DNA-SF hydrogels and the DNA content. Interestingly, it was observed that dual-network DNA-SF hydrogels with moderate surface rigidity exhibited the highest effectiveness in facilitating the migration of bone marrow mesenchymal stem cells (BMSCs) and their chondrogenic differentiation. Transcriptome sequencing further confirmed that dual-network DNA-SF hydrogels primarily enhanced chondrogenic differentiation of BMSCs by upregulating the Wnt and TGF-β signaling pathways while accelerating collagen II synthesis. Furthermore, in vivo studies revealed that dual-network DNA-SF hydrogels with moderate surface rigidity significantly accelerated cartilage regeneration. In summary, the dual-network DNA-SF hydrogels represent a promising and novel therapeutic strategy for cartilage regeneration.

Microstructurally and mechanically tunable acellular hydrogel scaffold using carboxymethyl cellulose for potential osteochondral tissue engineering

In tissue engineering, scaffold microstructures and mechanical cues play a significant role in regulating stem cell differentiation, proliferation, and infiltration, offering a promising strategy for osteochondral tissue repair. In this present study, we aimed to develop a facile method to fabricate an acellular hydrogel scaffold (AHS) with tunable mechanical stiffness and microstructures using carboxymethyl cellulose (CMC). The impacts of the degree of crosslinking, crosslinker length, and matrix density on the AHS were investigated using different characterization methods, and the in vitro biocompatible of AHS was also examined. Our CMC-based AHS showed tunable mechanical stiffness ranging from 50 kPa to 300 kPa and adjustable microporous size between 50 μm and 200 μm. In addition, the AHS was also proven biocompatible and did not negatively affect rabbit bone marrow stem cells' dual-linage differentiation into osteoblasts and chondrocytes. In conclusion, our approach may present a promising method in osteochondral tissue engineering.

A bioscaffold of decellularized whole osteochondral sheet improves proliferation and differentiation of loaded mesenchymal stem cells in a rabbit model

As a Natural decellularized extracellular matrix, osteochondral tissue is the best scaffold for the restoration of osteoarthritis defects. Bioscaffolds have the most similarly innate properties like biomechanical properties and the preserved connection of the bone-to-cartilage border. Although, their compacity and low porosity particularly, are proven to be difficulties of decellularization and cell penetration. This study aims to develop a new bioscaffold of decellularized osteochondral tissue (DOT) that is recellularized by bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cells (BM-MSCs), as a biphasic allograft, which preserved the interface between the cartilage section and subchondral bone of the joint. Whole osteochondral tissues of rabbit knee joints were sheeted in cartilaginous parts in 200-250 µm sections while connected to the subchondral bone and then fully decellularized. The BM-MSCs were seeded on the scaffolds in vitro; some constructs were subcutaneously implanted into the back of the rabbit. The cell penetration, differentiation to bone and cartilage, viability, and cell proliferation in vitro and in vivo were evaluated by qPCR, histological staining, MTT assay, and immunohistochemistry. DNA content analysis and SEM assessments confirmed the decellularization of the bioscaffold. Then, histological and SEM evaluations indicated that the cells could successfully penetrate the bone and cartilage lacunas in implanted grafts. MTT assay confirmed cell proliferation. Prominently, gene expression analysis showed that seeded cells differentiated into osteoblasts and chondrocytes in both bone and cartilage sections. More importantly, seeded cells on the bioscaffold started ECM secretion. Our results indicate that cartilage-to-bone border integrity was largely preserved. Additionally, ECM-sheeted DOT could be employed as a useful scaffold for promoting the regeneration of osteochondral defects.

Thermoresponsive Smart Copolymer Coatings Based on P(NIPAM-co-HEMA) and P(OEGMA-co-HEMA) Brushes for Regenerative Medicine

The fabrication of multifunctional, thermoresponsive platforms for regenerative medicine based on polymers that can be easily functionalized is one of the most important challenges in modern biomaterials science. In this study, we utilized atom transfer radical polymerization (ATRP) to produce two series of novel smart copolymer brush coatings. These coatings were based on copolymerizing 2-hydroxyethyl methacrylate (HEMA) with either oligo(ethylene glycol) methyl ether methacrylate (OEGMA) or N-isopropylacrylamide (NIPAM). The chemical compositions of the resulting brush coatings, namely, poly(oligo(ethylene glycol) methyl ether methacrylate-co-2-hydroxyethyl methacrylate) (P(OEGMA-co-HEMA)) and poly(N-isopropylacrylamide-co-2-hydroxyethyl methacrylate) (P(NIPAM-co-HEMA)), were predicted using reactive ratios of the monomers. These predictions were then verified using time-of-flight-secondary ion mass spectrometry (ToF-SIMS) and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS). The thermoresponsiveness of the coatings was examined through water contact angle (CA) measurements at different temperatures, revealing a transition driven by lower critical solution temperature (LCST) or upper critical solution temperature (UCST) or a vanishing transition. The type of transition observed depended on the chemical composition of the coatings. Furthermore, it was demonstrated that the transition temperature of the coatings could be easily adjusted by modifying their composition. The topography of the coatings was characterized using atomic force microscopy (AFM). To assess the biocompatibility of the coatings, dermal fibroblast cultures were employed, and the results indicated that none of the coatings exhibited cytotoxicity. However, the shape and arrangement of the cells were significantly influenced by the chemical structure of the coating. Additionally, the viability of the cells was correlated with the wettability and roughness of the coatings, which determined the initial adhesion of the cells. Lastly, the temperature-induced changes in the properties of the fabricated copolymer coatings effectively controlled cell morphology, adhesion, and spontaneous detachment in a noninvasive, enzyme-free manner that was confirmed using optical microscopy.

Cells resident to precision templated 40-µm pore scaffolds generate small extracellular vesicles that affect CD4+ T cell phenotypes through regulatory TLR4 signaling

Precision porous templated scaffolds (PTS) are a hydrogel construct of uniformly sized interconnected spherical pores that induce a pro-healing response (reducing the foreign body reaction, FBR) exclusively when the pores are 30-40µm in diameter. Our previous work demonstrated the necessity of Tregs in the maintenance of PTS pore size specific differences in CD4+ T cell phenotype. Work here characterizes the role of Tregs in the responses to implanted 40µm and 100µm PTS using WT and FoxP3+ cell (Treg) depleted mice. Proteomic analyses indicate that integrin signaling, monocytes/macrophages, cytoskeletal remodeling, inflammatory cues, and vesicule endocytosis may participate in Treg activation and the CD4+ T cell equilibrium modulated by PTS resident cell-derived small extracellular vesicles (sEVs). The role of MyD88-dependent and MyD88-independent TLR4 activation in PTS cell-derived sEV-to-T cell signaling is quantified by treating WT, TLR4ko, and MyD88ko splenic T cells with PTS cell-derived sEVs. STAT3 and mTOR are identified as mechanisms for further study for pore-size dependent PTS cell-derived sEV-to-T cell signaling. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: Unique cell populations colonizing only within 40µm pore size PTS generate sEVs that resolve inflammation by modifying CD4+ T cell phenotypes through TLR4 signaling.

Integrated gradient tissue-engineered osteochondral scaffolds: Challenges, current efforts and future perspectives

The osteochondral defect repair has been most extensively studied due to the rising demand for new therapies to diseases such as osteoarthritis. Tissue engineering has been proposed as a promising strategy to meet the demand of simultaneous regeneration of both cartilage and subchondral bone by constructing integrated gradient tissue-engineered osteochondral scaffold (IGTEOS). This review brought forward the main challenges of establishing a satisfactory IGTEOS from the perspectives of the complexity of physiology and microenvironment of osteochondral tissue, and the limitations of obtaining the desired and required scaffold. Then, we comprehensively discussed and summarized the current tissue-engineered efforts to resolve the above challenges, including architecture strategies, fabrication techniques and in vitro/in vivo evaluation methods of the IGTEOS. Especially, we highlighted the advantages and limitations of various fabrication techniques of IGTEOS, and common cases of IGTEOS application. Finally, based on the above challenges and current research progress, we analyzed in details the future perspectives of tissue-engineered osteochondral construct, so as to achieve the perfect reconstruction of the cartilaginous and osseous layers of osteochondral tissue simultaneously. This comprehensive and instructive review could provide deep insights into our current understanding of IGTEOS.

A bionic composite hydrogel with dual regulatory functions for the osteochondral repair

Due to the avascular nature of cartilage, it is difficult to heal and regenerate spontaneously after injury. At present, tissue engineering has become a promising strategy for repairing damaged cartilage, but the use of seed cells and growth factors is limited. In addition, the importance of mechanical compatibility of scaffold materials is often ignored. In this study, osteochondral scaffold was designed as a bilayer structure with a dense γ-Polyglutamic acid/carboxymethyl chitosan/bacterial cellulose (PGA/CMCS/BC) hydrogel cartilage layer and a porous nano HA-containing PGA/CMCS/BC hydrogel osteogenic layer. In addition, bioactive ions were introduced into the hydrogel scaffold to adjust the mechanical and swelling properties of the material to match the mechanical properties of natural articular cartilage. At the same time, based on the structural characteristics of bone and cartilage, magnesium and copper ions were introduced into the double-layer hydrogel scaffold, respectively, to prepare the cartilage layer and the bone layer, which endowed the material with excellent antibacterial properties and achieved the purpose of the integrated repair of bone and cartilage. The results showed that, after adding magnesium ions, the tensile breaking strength of material was increased from 0.66 MPa to 1.37 MPa，the corresponding compression modulus of the material (strain 0-12%) increased from 0.15 MPa to 0.58 MPa whilst the maximum mass swelling rate decreased from 155% to 75%. The results of in vivo experiments show that the group with bioactive ions had a much better effect on the repair of osteochondral defects, compared with group without bioactive ions, demonstrating such double ion regulation strategy is a very practical strategy for the treatment of osteochondral defects.

Roles of the calcified cartilage layer and its tissue engineering reconstruction in osteoarthritis treatment

Sandwiched between articular cartilage and subchondral bone, the calcified cartilage layer (CCL) takes on both biomechanical and biochemical functions in joint development and ordinary activities. The formation of CCL is not only unique in articular cartilage but can also be found in the chondro-osseous junction adjacent to the growth plate during adolescence. The formation of CCL is an active process under both cellular regulation and intercellular communication. Abnormal alterations of CCL can be indications of degenerative diseases including osteoarthritis. Owing to the limited self-repair capability of articular cartilage and core status of CCL in microenvironment maintenance, tissue engineering reconstruction of CCL in damaged cartilage can be of great significance. This review focuses on possible tissue engineering reconstruction methods targeting CCL for further OA treatment.

Silk fibroin-based biomaterials for cartilage/osteochondral repair

Osteoarthritis (OA) is a common joint disease with a high disability rate. In addition, OA not only causes great physiological and psychological harm to patients, but also puts great pressure on the social healthcare system. Pathologically, the disintegration of cartilage and the lesions of subchondral bone are related to OA. Currently, tissue engineering, which is expected to overcome the defects of existing treatment methods, had a lot of research in the field of cartilage/osteochondral repair. Silk fibroin (SF), as a natural macromolecular material with good biocompatibility, unique mechanical properties, excellent processability and degradability, holds great potential in the field of tissue engineering. Nowadays, SF had been prepared into various materials to adapt to the demands of cartilage/osteochondral repair. SF-based biomaterials can also be functionally modified to enhance repair performance further. In this review, the preparation methods, types, structures, mechanical properties, and functional modifications of SF-based biomaterials used for cartilage/osteochondral repair are summarized and discussed. We hope that this review will provide a reference for the design and development of SF-based biomaterials in cartilage/osteochondral repair field.

Bio-inspired zonal-structured matrices for bone-cartilage interface engineering

Design and development of scaffold structures for osteochondral (OC) interface regeneration is a significant engineering challenge. Recent efforts are aimed at recapitulating the unique compositional and hierarchical structure of an OC interface. Conventional scaffold fabrication techniques often have limited design control and reproducibility, and the development of OC scaffolds with zonal hierarchy and structural integrity between zones is especially challenging. In this study, a series of multi-zonal and gradient structures were designed and fabricated using three-dimensional bioprinting. We developed OC scaffolds with bi-phasic and tri-phasic configurations to support the zonal structure of OC tissue, and gradient scaffold configurations to enable smooth transitions between the zones to more closely mimic a bone-cartilage interface. A biodegradable polymer, polylactic acid, was used for the fabrication of zonal/gradient scaffolds to provide mechanical strength and support OC function. The formation of the multi-zonal and gradient scaffolds was confirmed through scanning electron microscopy imaging and micro-computed tomography scanning. Precisely controlled hierarchy with tunable porosity along the scaffold length established the formation of the bio-inspired scaffolds with different zones/gradient structure. In addition, we also developed a novel bioprinting method to selectively introduce cells into desired scaffold zones of the zonal/gradient scaffolds via concurrent printing of a cell-laden hydrogel within the porous template. Live/dead staining of the cell-laden hydrogel introduced in the cartilage zone showed uniform cell distribution with high cell viability. Overall, our study developed bio-inspired scaffold structures with structural hierarchy and mechanical integrity for bone-cartilage interface engineering.

High-performance bilayer composites for the replacement of osteochondral defects

Two novel bilayer constructs for the repair of osteochondral defects were developed from nanofibers and ceramic particles embedded into PVA matrices, exhibiting multiple promising properties similar to those of corresponding natural tissues.

Biomimetic Approaches for the Design and Fabrication of Bone-to-Soft Tissue Interfaces

Bone-to-soft tissue interfaces are responsible for transferring loads between tissues with significantly dissimilar material properties. The examples of connective soft tissues are ligaments, tendons, and cartilages. Such natural tissue interfaces have unique microstructural properties and characteristics which avoid the abrupt transitions between two tissues and prevent formation of stress concentration at their connections. Here, we review some of the important characteristics of these natural interfaces. The native bone-to-soft tissue interfaces consist of several hierarchical levels which are formed in a highly specialized anisotropic fashion and are composed of different types of heterogeneously distributed cells. The characteristics of a natural interface can rely on two main design principles, namely by changing the local microarchitectural features (e.g., complex cell arrangements, and introducing interlocking mechanisms at the interfaces through various geometrical designs) and changing the local chemical compositions (e.g., a smooth and gradual transition in the level of mineralization). Implementing such design principles appears to be a promising approach that can be used in the design, reconstruction, and regeneration of engineered biomimetic tissue interfaces. Furthermore, prominent fabrication techniques such as additive manufacturing (AM) including 3D printing and electrospinning can be used to ease these implementation processes. Biomimetic interfaces have several biological applications, for example, to create synthetic scaffolds for osteochondral tissue repair.

Bi-layered Composite Scaffold for Repair of the Osteochondral Defects

Objective: Osteochondral defect presents a big challenge for clinical treatment. This study aimed at constructing a bi-layered composite chitosan/chitosan-β-tricalcium phosphate (CS/CS-β-TCP) scaffold and at repairing the rat osteochondral defect. Approach: The bi-layered CS/CS-β-TCP scaffold was fabricated by lyophilization, and its microstructure was observed by a scanning electron microscope. Chondrocytes and bone marrow stem cells (BMSCs) were seeded into the CS layer and the CS-β-TCP layer, respectively. Viability and proliferation ability of the cells were observed under a confocal microscope. After subcutaneous implantation, the chondrogenic ability of the CS layer and osteogenic ability of the CS-β-TCP layer were evaluated by immunofluorescence. Then, the bi-layered scaffolds were implanted into the rat osteochondral defects and the harvested samples were macroscopically and histologically evaluated. Results: The bi-layered CS/CS-β-TCP scaffold exhibited the distinctive microstructures for each layer. The seeded chondrocytes in the CS layer could maintain the chondrogenic lineage, whereas BMSCs in the CS-β-TCP layer could continually differentiate into the osteogenic lineage. Moreover, cells in both layers could maintain well viability and excellent proliferation ability. For the in vivo study, the newly formed tissues in the bi-layered scaffolds group were similar with the native osteochondral tissues, which comprised hyaline-like cartilage and subchondral bone, with better repair effects compared with those of the pure CS group and the blank control group. Innovation: This is the first time that the bi-layered composite CS/CS-β-TCP scaffold has been fabricated and evaluated with respect to osteochondral defect repair. Conclusion: The bi-layered CS/CS-β-TCP scaffolds could facilitate osteochondral defect repair and might be the promising candidates for osteochondral tissue engineering.

3D bio-printed biphasic scaffolds with dual modification of silk fibroin for the integrated repair of osteochondral defects

Repair of osteochondral defects is still a challenge, especially the regeneration of hyaline cartilage. Parathyroid hormone (PTH) can inhibit the hypertrophy of chondrocytes to maintain the phenotype of hyaline cartilage. Here, we aimed to construct a bio-printed biphasic scaffold with a mechanical gradient based on dual modification of silk fibroin (SF) for the integrated repair of osteochondral defects. Briefly, SF was grafted with PTH (SF-PTH) and covalently immobilized with methacrylic anhydride (SF-MA), respectively. Next, gelatin methacryloyl (GM) mixed with SF-PTH or SF-MA was used as a bio-ink for articular cartilage and subchondral bone regeneration. Finally, the GM + SF-PTH/GM + SF-MA osteochondral biphasic scaffold was constructed using 3D bioprinting technology, and implanted in a rabbit osteochondral defect model. In this study, the SF-PTH bio-ink was synthesized for the first time. In vitro results indicated that the GM + SF-MA bio-ink had good mechanical properties, while the GM + SF-PTH bio-ink inhibited the hypertrophy of chondrocytes and was beneficial for the production of hyaline cartilage extracellular matrix. Importantly, an integrated GM + SF-PTH/GM + SF-MA biphasic scaffold with a mechanical gradient was successfully constructed. The results in vivo demonstrated that the GM + SF-PTH/GM + SF-MA scaffold could promote the regeneration of osteochondral defects and maintain the phenotype of hyaline cartilage to a large extent. Collectively, our results indicate that the integrated GM + SF-PTH/GM + SF-MA biphasic scaffold constructed by 3D bioprinting is expected to become a new strategy for the treatment of osteochondral defects.

Scaffold With Natural Calcified Cartilage Zone for Osteochondral Defect Repair in Minipigs

BACKGROUND

Long-term outcomes of current clinical interventions for osteochondral defect are less than satisfactory. One possible reason is an ignorance of the interface structure between cartilage and subchondral bone, the calcified cartilage zone (CCZ). However, the importance of natural CCZ in osteochondral defects has not been directly described.

PURPOSE

To explore the feasibility of fabricating trilayer scaffold containing natural CCZ for osteochondral defects and the role of CCZ in the repair process.

STUDY DESIGN

Controlled laboratory study.

METHODS

The scaffold was prepared by cross-linking lyophilized type II collagen sponge and acellular normal pig subchondral bone with or without natural CCZ. Autologous bone marrow stem cells (BMSCs) of minipig were mixed with type II collagen gel and injected into the cartilage layer of the scaffold before operation. Thirty minipigs were randomly divided into CCZ (n = 10), non-CCZ (n = 10), and blank control (n = 10) groups. An 8 mm-diameter full-thickness osteochondral defect was created on the trochlear surface, and scaffold containing BMSCs was transplanted into the defect according to grouping requirements. At 12 and 24 weeks postoperatively, specimens were assessed by macroscopic observation, magnetic resonance imaging examination, and histological observations (hematoxylin and eosin, Safranin O-fast green, type II collagen immunohistochemical, and Sirius red staining). Semiquantitative cartilage repair scoring was conducted using the MOCART (Magnetic Resonance Observation of Cartilage Repair Tissue) system and the O'Driscoll repaired cartilage value system.

RESULTS

The defects in the blank control and non-CCZ groups were filled with fibrous tissue, while the cartilage layer of the CCZ group was mainly repaired by hyaline cartilage at 24 weeks postoperatively. The superior repair outcome of the CCZ group was confirmed by MOCART and O'Driscoll score.

CONCLUSION

The trilayer scaffold containing natural CCZ obtained the best repair effect compared with the non-CCZ scaffold and the blank control, indicating the importance of the CCZ in osteochondral tissue engineering.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

This study demonstrates the necessity to reconstruct CCZ in clinical osteochondral defect repair and provides a possible strategy for osteochondral tissue engineering.

Augmenting Tendon-to-Bone Repair with Functionally Graded Scaffolds

Tendon-to-bone repair often fails because the functionally graded attachment is not regenerated during the healing process. Biomimetic scaffolds that recapitulate the unique features of the native tendon-to-bone attachment hold great promise for enhancing the healing process. Among various types of scaffolds that are developed and evaluated for tendon-to-bone repair, those with gradations (in either a stratified or a continuous fashion) in composition, structure, mechanical properties, and cell phenotype have gained the most attention. In this progress report, the recent efforts in the rational design and fabrication of functionally graded scaffolds based upon electrospun nanofiber mats and inverse opal structures, as well as the evaluation of their applications in augmenting tendon-to-bone repair, are reviewed. This report concludes with perspectives on the necessary future steps for clinical translation of the scaffolds.

Bioinspired mineral-polymeric hybrid hyaluronic acid/poly (γ-glutamic acid) hydrogels as tunable scaffolds for stem cells differentiation

Aiming at the difficulty of integrated repair of osteochondral tissue, we designed a hybrid hydrogel scaffold that mimicked the microenvironment of osteochondral niches. Besides, the nano-hydroxyapatite (nHAP) was specially introduced into the hydrogel for its natural ability to promote bone regeneration. The hydrogel also exhibited good toughness (7500 KJ/m³), strength (1000 kPa), viscoelasticity, and in vitro cell experiments showed that hydrogels had quite good cytocompatibility (near 100 % viability). The results of the three-dimensional (3D) cell culture also proved that the survival rate of the cells in the hybrid hydrogels doped with nHAP and dispersion were the highest. In vitro RT-qPCR experiments proved that after being cultured in hydrogel scaffolds doped with nHAP, bone mesenchymal stem cells (BMSCs) could express genes related to osteoblasts and chondrocytes. As a result, this hydrogel provides a general for developing alternative materials applicable for stem cells differentiation and even osteochondral tissue engineering.

Narrative review of the choices of stem cell sources and hydrogels for cartilage tissue engineering

Stem cell-based therapy is a promising treatment for cartilage defects due to the pluripotency, abundant sources and low immunogenicity of stem cells. Hydrogels are a promising class of biomaterials for cartilage engineering and are characterized by bioactivity, degradability and elasticity as well as provide water content and mechanical support. The combination of stem cells and hydrogels opens new possibilities for cartilage tissue engineering. However, the selection of suitable types of stem cells and hydrogels is difficult. Currently, various types of stem cells, such as embryonic stem cells (ESCs), mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs), induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs), and peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMSCs), and various types of hydrogels, including natural polymers, chemically modified natural polymers and synthetic polymers, have been explored based on their potential for cartilage tissue engineering. These materials are used independently or in combination; however, there is no clear understanding of their merits and disadvantages with regard to their suitability for cartilage repair. In this article, we aim to review recent progress in the use of stem cell-hydrogel hybrid constructs for cartilage tissue engineering. We focus on the effects of stem cell types and hydrogel types on efficient chondrogenesis from cellular, preclinical and clinical perspectives. We compare and analyze the advantages and disadvantages of these cells and hydrogels with the hope of increasing discussion of their suitability for cartilage repair and present our perspective on their use for the improvement of physical and biological properties for cartilage tissue engineering.

Uniform 40-µm-pore diameter precision templated scaffolds promote a pro-healing host response by extracellular vesicle immune communication

Implanted porous precision templated scaffolds (PTS) with 40-µm spherical pores reduce inflammation and foreign body reaction (FBR) while increasing vascular density upon implantation. Larger or smaller pores, however, promote chronic inflammation and FBR. While macrophage (MØ) recruitment and polarization participates in perpetuating this pore-size-mediated phenomenon, the driving mechanism of this unique pro-healing response is poorly characterized. We hypothesized that the primarily myeloid PTS resident cells release small extracellular vesicles (sEVs) that induce pore-size-dependent pro-healing effects in surrounding T cells. Upon profiling resident immune cells and their sEVs from explanted 40-µm- (pro-healing) and 100-µm-pore diameter (inflammatory) PTS, we found that PTS pore size did not affect PTS resident immune cell population ratios or the proportion of myeloid sEVs generated from explanted PTS. However, quantitative transcriptomic assessment indicated cell and sEV phenotype were pore size dependent. In vitro experiments demonstrated the ability of PTS cell-derived sEVs to stimulate T cells transcriptionally and proliferatively. Specifically, sEVs isolated from cells inhabiting explanted 100 μm PTS significantly upregulated T_h1 inflammatory gene expression in immortalized T cells. sEVs isolated from cell inhabiting both 40- and 100-μm PTS upregulated essential T_reg transcriptional markers in both primary and immortalized T cells. Finally, we investigated the effects of T_reg depletion on explanted PTS resident cells. FoxP3+ cell depletion suggests T_regs play a unique role in balancing T cell subset ratios, thus driving host response in 40-μm PTS. These results indicate that predominantly 40-µm PTS myeloid cell-derived sEVs affect T cells through a distinct, pore-size-mediated modality.

Recent Progress in 3D Printing of Elastic and High-Strength Hydrogels for the Treatment of Osteochondral and Cartilage Diseases

Despite considerable progress for the regenerative medicine, repair of full-thickness articular cartilage defects and osteochondral interface remains challenging. This low efficiency is largely due to the difficulties in recapitulating the stratified zonal architecture of articular cartilage and engineering complex gradients for bone-soft tissue interface. This has led to increased interest in three-dimensional (3D) printing technologies in the field of musculoskeletal tissue engineering. Printable and biocompatible hydrogels are attractive materials for 3D printing applications because they not only own high tunability and complexity, but also offer favorable biomimetic environments for live cells, such as porous structure, high water content, and bioactive molecule incorporation. However, conventional hydrogels are usually mechanically weak and brittle, which cannot reach the mechanical requirements for repair of articular cartilage defects and osteochondral interface. Therefore, the development of elastic and high-strength hydrogels for 3D printing in the repairment of cartilage defects and osteochondral interface is crucial. In this review, we summarized the recent progress in elastic and high-strength hydrogels for 3D printing and categorized them into six groups, namely ion bonds interactions, nanocomposites integrated in hydrogels, supramolecular guest-host interactions, hydrogen bonds interactions, dynamic covalent bonds interactions, and hydrophobic interactions. These 3D printed elastic and high-strength hydrogels may provide new insights for the treatment of osteochondral and cartilage diseases.

A 3D, Dynamically Loaded Hydrogel Model of the Osteochondral Unit to Study Osteocyte Mechanobiology

Osteocytes are mechanosensitive cells that orchestrate signaling in bone and cartilage across the osteochondral unit. The mechanisms by which osteocytes regulate osteochondral homeostasis and degeneration in response to mechanical cues remain unclear. This study introduces a novel 3D hydrogel bilayer composite designed to support osteocyte differentiation and bone matrix deposition in a bone-like layer and to recapitulate key aspects of the osteochondral unit's complex loading environment. The bilayer hydrogel is fabricated with a soft cartilage-like layer overlaying a stiff bone-like layer. The bone-like layer contains a stiff 3D-printed hydrogel structure infilled with a soft, degradable, cellular hydrogel. The IDG-SW3 cells embedded within the soft hydrogel mature into osteocytes and produce a mineralized collagen matrix. Under dynamic compressive strains, near-physiological levels of strain are achieved in the bone layer (≤ 0.08%), while the cartilage layer bears the majority of the strains (>99%). Under loading, the model induces an osteocyte response, measured by prostaglandin E2, that is frequency, but not strain, dependent: a finding attributed to altered fluid flow within the composite. Overall, this new hydrogel platform provides a novel approach to study osteocyte mechanobiology in vitro in an osteochondral tissue-mimetic environment.

Effects of cryo-processing on the mechanical and biological properties of poly(vinyl alcohol)-gelatin theta-gels

Poly(vinyl alcohol) (PVA), a synthetic, nontoxic polymer, is widely studied for use as a biomedical hydrogel due to its structural and physicomechanical properties. Depending on the synthesis method, PVA hydrogels can exhibit a range of selected characteristics-strength, creep resistance, energy dissipation, degree of crystallinity, and porosity. While the structural integrity and behavior of the hydrogel can be fine-tuned, common processing techniques result in a brittle, linear elastic material. In addition, PVA lacks functionality to engage and participate in cell adhesion, which can be a limitation for integrating PVA materials with tissue in situ. Thus, there is a need to further engineer PVA hydrogels to optimize its physicomechanical properties while enhancing cell adhesion and bioactivity. While the inclusion of gelatin into PVA hydrogels has been shown to impart cell-adhesive properties, the optimization of the mechanical properties of PVA-gelatin blends has not been studied in the context of traditional PVA hydrogel processing techniques. The incorporation of poly(ethylene glycol) with PVA prior to solidification forms an organized, cell instructive hydrogel with improved stiffness. The effect of cryo-processing, i.e., freeze-thaw (FT) cycling was elucidated by comparing 1 FT and 8 FT theta-cryo-gels and cryo-gels. To confirm the viability of the gels, human mesenchymal stem cell (hMSC) protein and sulfated glycosaminoglycan assays were performed to verify the nontoxicity and influence on hMSC differentiation. We have devised an elastic PVA-gelatin hydrogel utilizing the theta-gel and cryo-gel processing techniques, resulting in a stronger, more elastic material with greater potential as a scaffold for complex tissues.

Clinical Application Status of Articular Cartilage Regeneration Techniques: Tissue-Engineered Cartilage Brings New Hope

Hyaline articular cartilage lacks blood vessels, lymphatics, and nerves and is characterised by limited self-repair ability following injury. Traditional techniques of articular cartilage repair and regeneration all have certain limitations. The development of tissue engineering technology has brought hope to the regeneration of articular cartilage. The strategies of tissue-engineered articular cartilage can be divided into three types: “cell-scaffold construct,” cell-free, and scaffold-free. In “cell-scaffold construct” strategies, seed cells can be autologous chondrocytes or stem. Among them, some commercial products with autologous chondrocytes as seed cells, such as BioSeed®-C and CaReS®, have been put on the market and some products are undergoing clinical trials, such as NOVOCART® 3D. The stem cells are mainly pluripotent stem cells and mesenchymal stem cells from different sources. Cell-free strategies that indirectly utilize the repair and regeneration potential of stem cells have also been used in clinical settings, such as TruFit and MaioRegen. Finally, the scaffold-free strategy is also a new development direction, and the short-term repair results of related products, such as NOVOCART® 3D, are encouraging. In this paper, the commonly used techniques of articular cartilage regeneration in surgery are reviewed. By studying different strategies and different seed cells, the clinical application status of tissue-engineered articular cartilage is described in detail.

Tissue Engineering: An Alternative to Repair Cartilage

Herein we review the state-of-the-art in tissue engineering for repair of articular cartilage. First, we describe the molecular, cellular, and histologic structure and function of endogenous cartilage, focusing on chondrocytes, collagens, extracellular matrix, and proteoglycans. We then explore in vitro cell culture on scaffolds, discussing the difficulties involved in maintaining or obtaining a chondrocytic phenotype. Next, we discuss the diverse compounds and designs used for these scaffolds, including natural and synthetic biomaterials and porous, fibrous, and multilayer architectures. We then report on the mechanical properties of different cell-loaded scaffolds, and the success of these scaffolds following in vivo implantation in small animals, in terms of generating tissue that structurally and functionally resembles native tissue. Last, we highlight future trends in this field. We conclude that despite major technical advances made over the past 15 years, and continually improving results in cartilage repair experiments in animals, the development of clinically useful implants for regeneration of articular cartilage remains a challenge

Functionally graded biomimetic biomaterials in dentistry: an evidence-based update

Design and development of novel therapeutic strategies to regenerate lost tissue structure and function is a serious clinical hurdle for researchers. Traditionally, much of the research is dedicated in optimising properties of scaffolds. Current synthetic biomaterials remain rudimentary in comparison to their natural counterparts. The ability to incorporate biologically inspired elements into the design of synthetic materials has advanced with time. Recent reports suggest that functionally graded material mimicking the natural tissue morphology can have a more exaggerated response on the targeted tissue. The aim of this review is to deliver an overview of the functionally graded concept with respect to applications in clinical dentistry. A comprehensive understanding of spatiotemporal arrangement in fields of restorative, prosthodontics, periodontics, orthodontics and oral surgery is presented. Different processing techniques have been adapted to achieve such gradients ranging from additive manufacturing (three dimensional printing/rapid prototyping) to conventional techniques of freeze gelation, freeze drying, electrospinning and particulate leaching. The scope of employing additive manufacturing technique as a reliable and predictable tool for the design and accurate reproduction of biomimetic templates is vast by any measure. Further research in the materials used and refinement of the synthesis techniques will continue to expand the frontiers of functionally graded membrane based biomaterials application in the clinical domain.

Scaffold-Assisted Ectopic Transplantation of Internal Organs and Patient-Derived Tumors

Xenotransplantation of human tissues into immunodeficient mice has emerged as an invaluable preclinical model to study human biology and disease progression and predict clinical response. The most common anatomical site for tissue transplantation is the subcutaneous pocket due to simple surgical procedures and accessibility for gross monitoring and advanced imaging modalities. However, subcutaneously implanted tissues initially experience a sharp change in oxygen and nutrient supply and increased mechanical deformation. During this acute phase of tissue integration to the host vasculature, substantial cell death and tissue fibrosis occur limiting engraftment efficiency. Previously, we demonstrated that the implantation of inverted colloidal crystal hydrogel scaffolds triggers proangiogenic and immunomodulatory functions without characteristic foreign body encapsulation. In this study, we examine the use of this unique host response to improve the ectopic transplantation of tissues to the subcutaneous site. Scaffold-assisted tissues preserved morphological features and blood vessel density compared to native tissues, whereas scaffold-free tissues collapsed and were less vascularized. Notably, the supporting biomaterial scaffold modulated the foreign body response to reduce the localization of Ly6G⁺ cells within the transplanted tissues. Cotransplantation of patient-derived gastric cancer with a scaffold resulted in a comparable level of engraftment to conventional methods; however, detailed immunohistological characterization revealed significantly better retention of proliferative cells (Ki67⁺) and human immune cells (CD45⁺) by the end of the study. We envision that leveraging the immunomodulatory properties of biomaterial interfaces can be an attractive strategy to improve the functional engraftment of xenotransplants and accelerate individualized diagnostics and the development of novel therapeutic strategies.

Time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry three-dimensional imaging of surface modifications in poly(caprolactone) scaffold pores

Scaffolds composed of synthetic polymers such as poly(caprolactone) (PCL) are widely used for the support and repair of tissues in biomedicine. Pores are common features in scaffolds as they facilitate cell penetration. Various surface modifications can be performed to promote key biological responses to these scaffolds. However, verifying the chemistry of these materials post surface modification is problematic due to the combination of three-dimensional (3D) topography and surface sensitivity. Time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry (ToF-SIMS) is commonly used to correlate surface chemistry with cell response. In this study, 3D imaging mass spectrometry analysis of surface modified synthetic polymer scaffolds is demonstrated using PCL porous scaffold, a pore filling polymer sample preparation, and 3D imaging ToF-SIMS. We apply a simple sample preparation procedure, filling the scaffold pores with a poly(vinyl alcohol)/glycerol mixture to remove topographic influence on image quality. This filling method allows the scaffold (PCL) and filler secondary ions to be reconstructed into a 3D chemical image of the pore. Furthermore, we show that surface modifications in the pores of synthetic polymer scaffolds can be mapped in 3D. Imaging of "dry" and "wet" surface modifications is demonstrated as well as a comparison of surface modifications with relatively strong ToF-SIMS peaks (fluorocarbon films [FC]) and to more biologically relevant surface modification of a protein (bovine serum albumin [BSA]). We demonstrate that surface modifications can be imaged in 3D showing that characteristic secondary ions associated with FC and BSA are associated with C3 F8 plasma treatment and BSA, respectively within the pore.

Bilayered Scaffold Prepared from a Kartogenin-Loaded Hydrogel and BMP-2-Derived Peptide-Loaded Porous Nanofibrous Scaffold for Osteochondral Defect Repair

Recently, a bilayered scaffold with an anisotropic structure mimicking a native osteochondral tissue shows considerable potential for treating osteochondral defects. Herein, a bilayered scaffold consisting of biomimetic cartilage and a subchondral bone architecture was constructed for repairing osteochondral defect. A hydrogel prepared by the Schiff base reaction of gelatin, silk fibroin, and oxidized dextran was designed as the cartilage layer, while a nanofibrous scaffold with a macroporous structure prepared from the polymer blend of poly(l-lactic acid)/poly(lactic-co-glycolic acid)/poly(ε-caprolactone) using the dual phase separation technique served as a subchondral layer. The subchondral layer was then treated with polydopamine coating for osteogenic factor immobilization. To facilitate the chondrogenic and osteogenic differentiation of bone marrow mesenchymal stem cells on the bilayered scaffold, the cartilage-inducing drug kartogenin (KGN) and osteogenic-inducing factor bone morphogenetic protein 2-derived peptides (P24 peptides) were, respectively, loaded on the subchondral layer. Next, the in vitro release of KGN and P24 peptide from the corresponding layer was monitored, respectively, and the results showed that both the release time of KGN and P24 peptides would last for more than 28 days. The in vitro results indicated that the KGN-loaded cartilage layer and P24 peptides-loaded subchondral layer were capable of supporting cell proliferation, and induced the chondrogenic and osteogenic differentiation, respectively. Furthermore, the in vivo experiments suggested that the bilayered scaffold significantly accelerated the regeneration of the osteochondral tissue in the rabbit knee joint model. Consequently, this bilayered scaffold loaded with KGN and P24 peptides would be a promising candidate for repairing osteochondral defect.

A biomimetic cartilage gradient hybrid scaffold for functional tissue engineering of cartilage

Osteochondral tissue has a complex layered structure that is not self-repairing after a cartilage defect. Therefore, constructing a biomimetic gradient scaffold that meets the specific structural requirements of osteochondral tissue is a major challenge in the field of cartilage tissue engineering. In this study, chitosan/Sodium β-glycerophosphate/Gelatin (Cs/GP/Gel) biomimetic gradient scaffolds were prepared by regulating the mass ratio of single layer raw materials. The same ratio of Cs/GP/Gel hybrid scaffold material was used as the control. Physical properties such as water absorption, porosity and the degradation rate of the material were compared to optimize the proportion of scaffold materials. P3 Bone Mesenchymal Stem Cells (BMSCs) were inoculated on the gradient and the control scaffolds to investigate its biocompatibility. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) results show that 3:1:2, 6:1:3.5, 9:1:5, 12:1:6.5, 15:1:8 Cs/GP/Gel gradient scaffolds had excellent three-dimensional porous structures. Channels were also shown to have been interconnected, and the walls of the pores were folded. In the longitudinal dimension, gradient scaffolds had an obvious stratified structure and pore gradient gradualism, that effectively simulated the natural physiological stratified structure of real cartilage. The diameter of the pores in the control scaffold was uniform and without any pore gradient. Gradient scaffolds had good water absorption (584.24 ± 3.79˜677.47 ± 1.70%), porosity (86.34 ± 5.10˜95.20 ± 2.86%) and degradation (86.09 ± 2.46˜92.48 ± 3.86%). After considering the physical properties assessed, the Cs/GP/Gel gradient scaffold with a ratio of 9:1:5 was found to be the most suitable material to support osteochondral tissue. BMSCs were subsequently inoculated on the proportional gradient and hybrid scaffolds culture. These cells survived, distributed and extended well on the gradient and hybrid scaffold material. The biomimetic gradient scaffold designed and prepared in this study provides an important foundation for the development of new gradient composite biomedical materials for osteochondral repair.

Chitosan-based composite bilayer scaffold as an in vitro osteochondral defect regeneration model

Prolonged osteochondral tissue damage can result in osteoarthritis and decreased quality of life. Multiphasic scaffolds, where different layers model different microenvironments, are a promising treatment approach, yet stable joining between layers during fabrication remains challenging. Here, a bilayer scaffold for osteochondral tissue regeneration was fabricated using thermally-induced phase separation (TIPS). Two distinct polymer solutions were layered before TIPS, and the resulting porous, bilayer scaffold was characterized by seamless interfacial integration and a mechanical stiffness gradient reflecting the native osteochondral microenvironment. Chitosan is a critical component of both scaffold layers to facilitate cell attachment and the formation of polyelectrolyte complexes with other biologically relevant natural polymers. The articular cartilage region was optimized for hyaluronic acid content and stiffness, while the subchondral bone region was defined by higher stiffness and osteoconductive hydroxyapatite content. Following co-culture with chondrocyte-like (SW-1353 or mesenchymal stem cells) and osteoblast-like cells (MG63), cell proliferation and migration to the interface along with increased gene expression associated with relevant markers of osteogenesis and chondrogenesis indicates the potential of this bilayer scaffold for osteochondral tissue regeneration.

A poly(hydroxyethyl methacrylate)-Ag nanoparticle porous hydrogel for simultaneous in vivo prevention of the foreign-body reaction and bacterial infection

The use of implants or indwelling medical devices has greatly enhanced the quality and efficacy of health care. However, foreign-body reactions (FBRs) and infections can lead to potential failure or removal of the devices, or increased morbidity and mortality of patients. Herein, we develop a silver nanoparticle (AgNP) loaded poly(hydroxyethyl methacrylate) hydrogel with spherical, interconnected 40 μm pores. The resulting hydrogels displayed good antibacterial properties regarding both gram positive bacteria (Staphylococcus aureus) and gram negative bacteria (Escherichia coli (E. coli)) in vitro and were highly efficient at inhibiting bacterial cell growth. Moreover, they exhibited an in vivo resistance to FBRs by reducing the immune responses, and completely prevented the formation of collagen capsules. Finally, in vivo studies of the E. coli infected mouse model demonstrated that the AgNP loaded porous hydrogels were highly efficient at resisting the bacterial FBRs and infections, while they promoted cell mitigation and infiltration. Findings from this work suggest that AgNP loaded porous hydrogels hold promise in various biomedical applications including in the new generation of implantable biomedical devices and tissue engineering scaffolds.

Chitosan-Based Nanofibrous Membrane Unit with Gradient Compositional and Structural Features for Mimicking Calcified Layer in Osteochondral Matrix

Chitosan (CH), silk fibroin (SF), and hydroxyapatite (HA) were used to prepare CH/SF/HA composites and the resulting composites were electrospun into nanofibrous membrane units with gradient compositional and structural features. The optimal membrane unit was used together with CH/HA and CH/SF composites to fabricate a type of three-layer scaffold that is intended for osteochondral repair. The bottom layer of the scaffold was built with CH/HA composites and it served as a subchondral layer, the integrated nanofibrous membrane unit functioned as the middle layer for mimicking the calcified layer and the top layer was constructed using CH/SF composites for acting as a chondral layer. The nanofibrous membrane unit was found to be permeable to some molecules with limited molecular weight and was able to prevent the seeded cells from migrating cross the unit, functioning approximately like the calcified layer in the osteochondral matrix. Layered scaffolds showed abilities to promote the growth of both chondrocytes and osteoblasts that were seeded in their chondral layer and bony layer, respectively, and they were also able to support the phenotype preservation of seeded chondrocytes and the mineralization of neotissue in the bony layer. Results suggest that this type of layered scaffolds can function as an analogue of the osteochondral matrix and it has potential in osteochondral repair.

Hierarchically structured seamless silk scaffolds for osteochondral interface tissue engineering

The osteochondral healthcare market is driven by the increasing demand for affordable and biomimetic scaffolds. To meet this demand, silk fibroin (SF) from Bombyx mori and Antheraea assamensis is used to fabricate a biphasic scaffold, with fiber-free and fiber-reinforced phases, stimulating cartilage and bone revival. The fabrication is a facile reproducible process using single polymer (SF), for both phases, designed in a continuous and integrated manner. Physicochemical and mechanical scaffold characterization, display interconnected pores with differential swelling and tunable degradation. The compressive modulus values, extend to 40 kPa and 25%, for tensile strain, at elongation. The scaffold support, for growth and proliferation of chondrocytes and osteoblasts, for respective cartilage and bone regeneration, is verified from in vitro assessment. Up-regulation of alkaline phosphatase (ALP) activity, extracellular matrix secretion and gene expression are significant; with acceptable in vitro immune response. Upon implantation in rabbit osteochondral defects for 8 weeks, the histological and micro-CT examinations show biphasic scaffolds significantly enhance regeneration of cartilage and subchondral bone tissues, as compared to monophasic scaffolds. The regenerated bone mineral density (BMD) ranges from 600-700 mg hydroxyapatite (HA) per cm³. The results, therefore, showcase the critically positive characteristics of in vitro ECM deposition, and in vivo regeneration of osteochondral tissue by this hierarchically structured biphasic scaffold.

Gelatin/Nanohyroxyapatite Cryogel Embedded Poly(lactic-co-glycolic Acid)/Nanohydroxyapatite Microsphere Hybrid Scaffolds for Simultaneous Bone Regeneration and Load-Bearing

It is desirable to combine load-bearing and bone regeneration capabilities in a single bone tissue engineering scaffold. For this purpose, we developed a high strength hybrid scaffold using a sintered poly(lactic-co-glycolic acid) (PLGA)/nanohydroxyapatite (nHAP) microsphere cavity fitted with gelatin/nHAP cryogel disks in the center. Osteo-conductive/osteo-inductive nHAP was incorporated in 250⁻500 μm PLGA microspheres at 40% (w/w) as the base matrix for the high strength cavity-shaped microsphere scaffold, while 20% (w/w) nHAP was incorporated into gelatin cryogels as an embedded core for bone regeneration purposes. The physico-chemical properties of the microsphere, cryogel, and hybrid scaffolds were characterized in detail. The ultimate stress and Young's modulus of the hybrid scaffold showed 25- and 21-fold increases from the cryogel scaffold. In vitro studies using rabbit bone marrow-derived stem cells (rBMSCs) in cryogel and hybrid scaffolds through DNA content, alkaline phosphatase activity, and mineral deposition by SEM/EDS, showed the prominence of both scaffolds in cell proliferation and osteogenic differentiation of rBMSCs in a normal medium. Calcium contents analysis, immunofluorescent staining of collagen I (COL I), and osteocalcin (OCN) and relative mRNA expression of COL I, OCN and osteopontin (OPN) confirmed in vitro differentiation of rBMSCs in the hybrid scaffold toward the bone lineage. From compression testing, the cell/hybrid scaffold construct showed a 1.93 times increase of Young's modulus from day 14 to day 28, due to mineral deposition. The relative mRNA expression of osteogenic marker genes COL I, OCN, and OPN showed 5.5, 18.7, and 7.2 folds increase from day 14 to day 28, respectively, confirming bone regeneration. From animal studies, the rBMSCs-seeded hybrid constructs could repair mid-diaphyseal tibia defects in rabbits, as evaluated by micro-computed tomography (μ-CT) and histological analyses. The hybrid scaffold will be useful for bone regeneration in load-bearing areas.

Multilineage Constructs for Scaffold-Based Tissue Engineering: A Review of Tissue-Specific Challenges

There is a growing interest in the regeneration of tissue in interfacial regions, where biological, physical, and chemical attributes vary across tissue type. The simultaneous use of distinct cell lineages can help in developing in vitro structures, analogous to native composite tissues. This literature review gathers the recent reports that have investigated multiple cell types of various sources and lineages in a coculture system for tissue-engineered constructs. Such studies aim at mimicking the native organization of tissues and their interfaces, and/or to improve the development of complex tissue substitutes. This paper thus distinguishes itself from those focusing on technical aspects of coculturing for a single specific tissue. The first part of this review is dedicated to variables of cocultured tissue engineering such as scaffold, cells, and in vitro culture environment. Next, tissue-specific coculture methods and approaches are covered for the most studied tissues. Finally, cross-analysis is performed to highlight emerging trends in coculture principles and to discuss how tissue-specific challenges can inspire new approaches for regeneration of different interfaces to improve the outcomes of various tissue engineering strategies.

Calcium Phosphate-Collagen Scaffold with Aligned Pore Channels for Enhanced Osteochondral Regeneration

This study reports the development of a bilayered scaffold with aligned channels produced via a sequential coextrusion and unidirectional freezing process to facilitate upward bone-marrow stem-cell migration. The biomimetic scaffold with collagen and biphasic calcium phosphate (BCP) layers is successfully fabricated with matching of the cartilage and bone layers. The aligned structure results in an enhancement of the compressive strength, and the channels enable tight anchoring of the collagen layers on the BCP scaffolds compared with a randomly structured porous scaffold. An in vitro evaluation demonstrates that the aligned channels guide the cells to attach on the surface in highly stretched shapes and migrate upward faster than the random structure. In addition, in vivo assessment reveals that the aligned channels yield superior osteochondral tissue regeneration compared with the random structure. Moreover, the channel diameter greatly affects the tissue regeneration, and the scaffold with a channel diameter of ≈270 µm exhibits the optimal regeneration because of sufficient nutrient supply and adequate tissue ingrowth. These findings indicate that the introduction of aligned channels to a bilayered scaffold provides an effective approach for osteochondral tissue regeneration.

Current strategies for integrative cartilage repair

Osteoarthritis (OA) is a degenerative joint condition characterized by painful cartilage lesions that impair joint mobility. Current treatments such as lavage, microfracture, and osteochondral implantation fail to integrate newly formed tissue with host tissues and establish a stable transition to subchondral bone. Similarly, tissue-engineered grafts that facilitate cartilage and bone regeneration are challenged by how to integrate the graft seamlessly with surrounding host cartilage and/or bone. This review centers on current approaches to promote cartilage graft integration. It begins with an overview of articular cartilage structure and function, as well as degenerative changes to this relationship attributed to aging, disease, and trauma. A discussion of the current progress in integrative cartilage repair follows, focusing on graft or scaffold design strategies targeting cartilage-cartilage and/or cartilage-bone integration. It is emphasized that integrative repair is required to ensure long-term success of the cartilage graft and preserve the integrity of the newly engineered articular cartilage. Studies involving the use of enzymes, choice of cell source, biomaterial selection, growth factor incorporation, and stratified versus gradient scaffolds are therefore highlighted. Moreover, models that accurately evaluate the ability of cartilage grafts to enhance tissue integrity and prevent ectopic calcification are also discussed. A summary and future directions section concludes the review.

Inverse Opal Scaffolds and Their Biomedical Applications

Three-dimensional porous scaffolds play a pivotal role in tissue engineering and regenerative medicine by functioning as biomimetic substrates to manipulate cellular behaviors. While many techniques have been developed to fabricate porous scaffolds, most of them rely on stochastic processes that typically result in scaffolds with pores uncontrolled in terms of size, structure, and interconnectivity, greatly limiting their use in tissue regeneration. Inverse opal scaffolds, in contrast, possess uniform pores inheriting from the template comprised of a closely packed lattice of monodispersed microspheres. The key parameters of such scaffolds, including architecture, pore structure, porosity, and interconnectivity, can all be made uniform across the same sample and among different samples. In conjunction with a tight control over pore sizes, inverse opal scaffolds have found widespread use in biomedical applications. In this review, we provide a detailed discussion on this new class of advanced materials. After a brief introduction to their history and fabrication, we highlight the unique advantages of inverse opal scaffolds over their non-uniform counterparts. We then showcase their broad applications in tissue engineering and regenerative medicine, followed by a summary and perspective on future directions.

Cell-laden hydrogels for osteochondral and cartilage tissue engineering

Despite tremendous advances in the field of regenerative medicine, it still remains challenging to repair the osteochondral interface and full-thickness articular cartilage defects. This inefficiency largely originates from the lack of appropriate tissue-engineered artificial matrices that can replace the damaged regions and promote tissue regeneration. Hydrogels are emerging as a promising class of biomaterials for both soft and hard tissue regeneration. Many critical properties of hydrogels, such as mechanical stiffness, elasticity, water content, bioactivity, and degradation, can be rationally designed and conveniently tuned by proper selection of the material and chemistry. Particularly, advances in the development of cell-laden hydrogels have opened up new possibilities for cell therapy. In this article, we describe the problems encountered in this field and review recent progress in designing cell-hydrogel hybrid constructs for promoting the reestablishment of osteochondral/cartilage tissues. Our focus centers on the effects of hydrogel type, cell type, and growth factor delivery on achieving efficient chondrogenesis and osteogenesis. We give our perspective on developing next-generation matrices with improved physical and biological properties for osteochondral/cartilage tissue engineering. We also highlight recent advances in biomanufacturing technologies (e.g. molding, bioprinting, and assembly) for fabrication of hydrogel-based osteochondral and cartilage constructs with complex compositions and microarchitectures to mimic their native counterparts.

STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE

Despite tremendous advances in the field of regenerative medicine, it still remains challenging to repair the osteochondral interface and full-thickness articular cartilage defects. This inefficiency largely originates from the lack of appropriate tissue-engineered biomaterials that replace the damaged regions and promote tissue regeneration. Cell-laden hydrogel systems have emerged as a promising tissue-engineering platform to address this issue. In this article, we describe the fundamental problems encountered in this field and review recent progress in designing cell-hydrogel constructs for promoting the reestablishment of osteochondral/cartilage tissues. Our focus centers on the effects of hydrogel composition, cell type, and growth factor delivery on achieving efficient chondrogenesis and osteogenesis. We give our perspective on developing next-generation hydrogel/inorganic particle/stem cell hybrid composites with improved physical and biological properties for osteochondral/cartilage tissue engineering. We also highlight recent advances in biomanufacturing and bioengineering technologies (e.g. 3D bioprinting) for fabrication of hydrogel-based osteochondral and cartilage constructs.

Evaluation of the effectiveness of a bMSC and BMP-2 polymeric trilayer system in cartilage repair

In this study a poly(lactide-co-glycolide) acid (PLGA) tri-layer scaffold is proposed for cartilage repair. The trilayer system consists of a base layer formed by a tablet of PLGA microspheres, a second layer composed of a microsphere suspension placed on top of the tablet, and the third layer, which constitutes an external electrospun PLGA thin polymeric membrane. Combinations of bone morphogenetic protein-2 (BMP-2) encapsulated in the microspheres of the suspension layer, and bone marrow mesenchymal stem cells (bMSC) seeded on the electrospun membrane, are evaluated by histologic analyses and immunohistochemistry in a critical size osteochondral defect in rabbits. Five experimental groups, including a control group (empty defect), a blank group (blank scaffold), a bMSC treated group, two groups treated with 2.5 μg or 8.5 μg of BMP-2 and another two groups implanted with bMSC-BMP-2 combination are evaluated. The repair area increases throughout the experimental time (24 weeks). The repair observed in the treated groups is statistically higher than in control and blank groups. However, the bMSC-BMP-2 combination does not enhance the BMP-2 response. In conclusion, BMP-2 and bMSC repaired effectively the osteochondral defect in the rabbits. The bMSC-BMP-2 combination did not produce synergism.

Tri-layered composite plug for the repair of osteochondral defects: in vivo study in sheep

Cartilage defects are a source of pain, immobility, and reduced quality of life for patients who have acquired these defects through injury, wear, or disease. The avascular nature of cartilage tissue adds to the complexity of cartilage tissue repair or regeneration efforts. The known limitations of using autografts, allografts, or xenografts further add to this complexity. Autologous chondrocyte implantation or matrix-assisted chondrocyte implantation techniques attempt to introduce cultured cartilage cells to defect areas in the patient, but clinical success with these are impeded by the avascularity of cartilage tissue. Biodegradable, synthetic scaffolds capable of supporting local cells and overcoming the issue of poor vascularization would bypass the issues of current cartilage treatment options. In this study, we propose a biodegradable, tri-layered (poly(glycolic acid) mesh/poly(l-lactic acid)-colorant tidemark layer/collagen Type I and ceramic microparticle-coated poly(l-lactic acid)-poly(ϵ-caprolactone) monolith) osteochondral plug indicated for the repair of cartilage defects. The porous plug allows the continual transport of bone marrow constituents from the subchondral layer to the cartilage defect site for a more effective repair of the area. Assessment of the in vivo performance of the implant was conducted in an ovine model (n = 13). In addition to a control group (no implant), one group received the implant alone (Group A), while another group was supplemented with hyaluronic acid (0.8 mL at 10 mg/mL solution; Group B). Analyses performed on specimens from the in vivo study revealed that the implant achieves cartilage formation within 6 months. No adverse tissue reactions or other complications were reported. Our findings indicate that the porous biocompatible implant seems to be a promising treatment option for the cartilage repair.

Injectable and 3D Bioprinted Polysaccharide Hydrogels: From Cartilage to Osteochondral Tissue Engineering

Biomechanical performance of functional cartilage is executed by the exclusive anisotropic composition and spatially varying intricate architecture in articulating ends of diarthrodial joint. Osteochondral tissue constituting the articulating ends comprise superfical soft cartilage over hard subchondral bone sandwiching interfacial soft-hard tissue. The shock-absorbent, lubricating property of cartilage and mechanical stability of subchondral bone regions are rendered by extended chemical structure of glycosaminoglycans and mineral deposition, respectively. Extracellular matrix glycosaminoglycans analogous polysaccharides are major class of hydrogels investigated for restoration of functional cartilage. Recently, injectable hydrogels have gained momentum as it offers patient compliance, tunable mechanical properties, cell deliverability, and facile administration at physiological condition with long-term functionality and hyaline cartilage construction. Interestingly, facile modifiable functional groups in carbohydrate polymers impart tailorability of desired physicochemical properties and versatile injectable chemistry for the development of highly potent biomimetic in situ forming scaffold. The scaffold design strategies have also evolved from single component to bi- or multilayered and graded constructs with osteogenic properties for deep subchondral regeneration. This review highlights the significance of polysaccharide structure-based functions in engineering cartilage tissue, injectable chemistries, strategies for combining analogous matrices with cells/stem cells and biomolecules and multicomponent approaches for osteochondral mimetic constructs. Further, the rheology and precise spatiotemporal positioning of cells in hydrogel bioink for rapid prototyping of complex three-dimensional anisotropic cartilage have also been discussed.

Microsphere-Based Hierarchically Juxtapositioned Biphasic Scaffolds Prepared from Poly(Lactic-co-Glycolic Acid) and Nanohydroxyapatite for Osteochondral Tissue Engineering

This study aims to prepare biphasic osteochondral scaffolds based on seamless joining of sintered polymer and polymer/ceramic microspheres for co-culture of chondrocytes and bone marrow stem cells (BMSCs). Poly(lactide-co-glycolide) (PLGA) microspheres and 10% nanohydroxyapatite (nHAP)-incorporated PLGA (PGA/nHAP) microspheres were prepared through the oil-in-water precipitation method. Virgin (V) and composite (C) scaffolds were prepared from 250⁻500 µm PLGA and PLGA/nHAP microspheres, respectively, while osteochondral (OC) scaffolds were fabricated through the combination of V and C scaffolds. Physico-chemical properties of scaffolds were characterized through microscopic-spectroscopic evaluations. The effect of nHAP in scaffolds was investigated through thermogravimetric analysis and mechanical testing, while surface hydrophobicity was tested through contact angle measurements. Rabbit chondrocytes and BMSCs were used for cell culture, and cell morphology and proliferation were determined from SEM and DNA assays. Alizarin red and Alcian blue stains were used to identify the in vitro bone and cartilage tissue-specific regeneration, while cetylpyridinium chloride was used to quantitatively estimate calcium in mineralized bone. For co-culture in OC scaffolds, BMSCs were first seeded in the bone part of the scaffold and cultured in osteogenic medium, followed by seeding chondrocytes in the cartilage part, and cultured in chondrocyte medium. High cell viability was confirmed from the Live/Dead assays. Actin cytoskeleton organization obtained by DAPI-phalloidin staining revealed proper organization of chondrocytes and BMSCs in OC scaffolds. Immunofluorescent staining of bone (type I collagen and osteocalcin (OCN)) and cartilage marker proteins (type II collagen (COL II)) confirmed cellular behavior of osteoblasts and chondrocytes in vitro. Using an ectopic osteochondral defect model by subcutaneous implantation of co-cultured OC scaffolds in nude mice confirmed cell proliferation and tissue development from gross view and SEM observation. IF staining of OCN and COL II in the bone and cartilage parts of OC scaffolds and tissue-specific histological analysis exhibited a time-dependent tissue re-modeling and confirmed the potential application of the biphasic scaffold in osteochondral tissue engineering.

Fabrication of Inverted Colloidal Crystal Poly(ethylene glycol) Scaffold: A Three-dimensional Cell Culture Platform for Liver Tissue Engineering

The ability to maintain hepatocyte function in vitro, for the purpose of testing xenobiotics' cytotoxicity, studying virus infection and developing drugs targeted at the liver, requires a platform in which cells receive proper biochemical and mechanical cues. Recent liver tissue engineering systems have employed three-dimensional (3D) scaffolds composed of synthetic or natural hydrogels, given their high water retention and their ability to provide the mechanical stimuli needed by the cells. There has been growing interest in the inverted colloidal crystal (ICC) scaffold, a recent development, which allows high spatial organization, homotypic and heterotypic cell interaction, as well as cell-extracellular matrix (ECM) interaction. Herein, we describe a protocol to fabricate the ICC scaffold using poly (ethylene glycol) diacrylate (PEGDA) and the particle leaching method. Briefly, a lattice is made from microsphere particles, after which a pre-polymer solution is added, properly polymerized, and the particles are then removed, or leached, using an organic solvent (e.g., tetrahydrofuran). The dissolution of the lattice results in a highly porous scaffold with controlled pore sizes and interconnectivities that allow media to reach cells more easily. This unique structure allows high surface area for the cells to adhere to as well as easy communication between pores, and the ability to coat the PEGDA ICC scaffold with proteins also shows a marked effect on cell performance. We analyze the morphology of the scaffold as well as the hepatocarcinoma cell (Huh-7.5) behavior in terms of viability and function to explore the effect of ICC structure and ECM coatings. Overall, this paper provides a detailed protocol of an emerging scaffold that has wide applications in tissue engineering, especially liver tissue engineering.