Biofouling control by biostimulation of quorum-quenching bacteria in a membrane bioreactor for wastewater treatment

Quorum Quenching in Membrane Bioreactors for Fouling Retardation: Complexity Provides Opportunities

The occurrence of biofouling restricts the widespread application of membrane bioreactors (MBRs) in wastewater treatment. Regulation of quorum sensing (QS) is a promising approach to control biofouling in MBRs, yet the underlying mechanisms are complex and remain to be illustrated. A fundamental understanding of the relationship between QS and membrane biofouling in MBRs is lacking, which hampers the development and application of quorum quenching (QQ) techniques in MBRs (QQMBRs). While many QQ microorganisms have been isolated thus far, critical criteria for selecting desirable QQ microorganisms are still missing. Furthermore, there are inconsistent results regarding the QQ lifecycle and the effects of QQ on the physicochemical characteristics and microbial communities of the mixed liquor and biofouling assemblages in QQMBRs, which might result in unreliable and inefficient QQ applications. This review aims to comprehensively summarize timely QQ research and highlight the important yet often ignored perspectives of QQ for biofouling control in MBRs. We consider what this "information" can and cannot tell us and explore its values in addressing specific and important questions in QQMBRs. Herein, we first examine current analytical methods of QS signals and discuss the critical roles of QS in fouling-forming microorganisms in MBRs, which are the cornerstones for the development of QQ technologies. To achieve targeting QQ strategies in MBRs, we propose the substrate specificity and degradation capability of isolated QQ microorganisms and the surface area and pore structures of QQ media as the critical criteria to select desirable functional microbes and media, respectively. To validate the biofouling retardation efficiency, we further specify the QQ effects on the physicochemical properties, microbial community composition, and succession of mixed liquor and biofouling assemblages in MBRs. Finally, we provide scale-up considerations of QQMBRs in terms of the debated QQ lifecycle, practical synergistic strategies, and the potential cost savings of MBRs. This review presents the limitations of classic QS/QQ hypotheses in MBRs, advances the understanding of the role of QS/QQ in biofouling development/retardation in MBRs, and builds a bridge between the fundamental understandings and practical applications of QQ technology.

Regulation of extracellular polymers based on quorum sensing in wastewater biological treatment from mechanisms to applications: A critical review

Extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) regulated by quorum sensing (QS) could directly mediate adhesion between microorganisms and form tight microbial aggregates. Besides, EPS have redox properties, which can facilitate electron transfer for promoting electroactive bacteria. Currently, the applications research on improving wastewater biological treatment performance based on QS regulated EPS have been widely reported, but reviews on the level of QS regulated EPS to enhance EPS function in microbial systems are still lacking. This work proposes the potential mechanisms of EPS synthesis by QS regulation from the viewpoint of material metabolism and energy metabolism, and summarizes the effects of QS on EPS synthesis. By synthesizing the role of QS in EPS regulation, we further point out the applications of QS-regulated EPS in wastewater biological treatment, which involve a series of aspects such as strengthening microbial colonization, mitigating membrane biofouling, improving the shock resistance of microbial metabolic systems, and strengthening the electron transfer capacity of microbial metabolic systems. According to this comprehensive review, future research on QS-regulated EPS should focus on the exploration of the micro-mechanisms, and economic regulation strategies for QS-regulated EPS should be developed, while the stability of QS-regulated EPS in long-term production experimental research should be further demonstrated.

Optimum quorum quenching bacteria concentration in the better-quality cell entrapping beads to control biofouling in membrane bioreactor

Quorum quenching (QQ) by cell entrapping beads (CEBs) is known to inhibit biofouling by its biological and physical cleaning effect. Although there are better QQ media reported, due to the ease of fabrication of QQ-CEBs, this study focused on improving the quality of CEBs by comparing two distinct bead-making methods - polyvinyl alcohol-alginate (PVA-alginate) and phase inversion - and on finding the optimum concentration of QQ bacteria in the CEBs. The evaluation of PVA-alginate bead showed better uniformity, and higher mechanical and chemical strength in comparison with the phase inversion bead. Through the operations of two control membrane bioreactors (MBRs) (no bead, vacant bead) and four QQ-MBRs with different Rhodococcus sp. BH4 concentrations (2.5-15 mg cell ml-1) in PVA-alginate CEBs, the maximum QQ effect was observed by 5 mg ml-1 BH4 concentration beads. This implies that an optimum cell concentration of QQ-CEBs is crucial to economically improve MBR performance using QQ.

Application of nanomaterials as potential quorum quenchers for disease: Recent advances and challenges

Chemical signal molecules are used by bacteria to interact with one another. Small hormone-like molecules known as autoinducers are produced, released, detected, and responded to during chemical communication. Quorum Sensing (QS) is the word for this procedure; it allows bacterial populations to communicate and coordinate group behavior. Several research has been conducted on using inhibitors to prevent QS and minimize the detrimental consequences. Through the enzymatic breakdown of the autoinducer component, by preventing the formation of autoinducers, or by blocking their reception by adding some compounds (inhibitors) that can mimic the autoinducers, a technique known as "quorum quenching" (QQ) disrupts microbial communication. Numerous techniques, including colorimetry, electrochemistry, bioluminescence, chemiluminescence, fluorescence, chromatography-mass spectroscopy, and many more, can be used to test QS/QQ. They all permit quantitative and qualitative measurements of QS/QQ molecules. The mechanism of QS and QQ, as well as the use of QQ in the prevention of biofilms, are all elaborated upon in this writing, along with the fundamental study of nanoparticle (NP)in QQ. Q.

Effect of thermal hydrolysis pretreatment on the occurrence of N-acyl homoserine lactone during anaerobic digestion of waste activated sludge

This study sought to investigate the relationship between N-acyl homoserine lactones (AHLs) and methanogenic microorganisms, focusing on endogenous AHLs in the anaerobic digestion (AD) process. By analyzing waste activated sludge (WAS) samples, we examine the changes in microbial communities and the AHLs-methanogens connection. The Mantel test and Spearman correlation analysis were conducted to gain novel insights into the AD process. Our findings demonstrate that thermal hydrolysis pretreatment (THP) modifies AHL concentrations during AD, thereby enhancing methanogenic bacteria activity and regulating social interactions among microorganisms. In the Eth group (AD of THP samples labeled Eth), Methanobacterium and Methanosarcina accounted for over 80% of the methanogenic bacteria, with correlation coefficients greater than 0.5 between these bacterial taxa and N-hexyl-l-homoserine lactone (C6-HSL) and N-enanthyl-l-homoserine lactone (C7-HSL).

Biofouling in Membrane Bioreactors-Mitigation and Current Status: a Review

Biological fouling as termed biofouling is caused by varied living organisms and is difficult to eliminate from the environment thus becoming a major issue during membrane bioreactors. Biofouling in membrane bioreactors (MBRs) is a crucial problem in increasing liquid pressure due to reduced pore diameter, clogging of the membrane pores, and alteration of the chemical composition of the water which greatly limits the growth of MBRs. Thus, membrane biofouling and/or microbial biofilms is a hot research topic to improve the market competitiveness of the MBR technology. Though several antibiofouling strategies (addition of bioflocculant or sponge into MBRs) came to light, biological approaches are sustainable and more practicable. Among the biological approaches, quorum sensing-based biofouling control (so-called quorum quenching) is an interesting and promising tool in combating biofouling issues in the MBRs. Several review articles have been published in the area of membrane biofouling and mitigation approaches. However, there is no single source of information about biofouling and/or biofilm formation in different environmental settings and respective problems, antibiofilm strategies and current status, quorum quenching, and its futurity. Thus, the objectives of the present review were to provide latest insights on mechanism of membrane biofouling, quorum sensing molecules, biofilm-associated problems in different environmental setting and antibiofilm strategies, special emphasis on quorum quenching, and its futurity in the biofilm/biofouling control. We believe that these insights greatly help in the better understanding of biofouling and aid in the development of sustainable antibiofouling strategies.

Quorum sensing unveils the sludge floccule-assisted stabilization of aerobic granules in granule-dominated sequencing batch reactors

Floccules are another major form of microbial aggregates in aerobic granular sludge systems. Previous studies mainly attributed the persistence of floccules to their relatively faster nutrient uptake and higher growth rate over aerobic granules; however, they failed to unravel the underlying mechanism of the long-term coexistence of these two aggregates. In this work, the existence and function of the floccules in an aerobic granule-dominated sequencing batch reactor were investigated from the view of quorum sensing (QS) and quorum quenching (QQ). The results showed that though the floccules were closely associated with the granules in terms of similar community structures (including the QS- and QQ-related ones), they exhibited a relatively higher QQ-related activity but a lower QS-related activity. A compatible proportion of floccules might be helpful to maintain the QS-related activity and keep the granules stable. In addition, the structure difference was demonstrated to diversify the QS- and QQ-related activities of the floccules and the aerobic granules. These findings could broaden our understanding of the interactions between the coexistent floccules and granules in aerobic granule-dominated systems and would be instructive for the development of the aerobic granular sludge process.

Plant Beneficial Bacteria and Their Potential Applications in Vertical Farming Systems

In this literature review, we discuss the various functions of beneficial plant bacteria in improving plant nutrition, the defense against biotic and abiotic stress, and hormonal regulation. We also review the recent research on rhizophagy, a nutrient scavenging mechanism in which bacteria enter and exit root cells on a cyclical basis. These concepts are covered in the contexts of soil agriculture and controlled environment agriculture, and they are also used in vertical farming systems. Vertical farming-its advantages and disadvantages over soil agriculture, and the various climatic factors in controlled environment agriculture-is also discussed in relation to plant-bacterial relationships. The different factors under grower control, such as choice of substrate, oxygenation rates, temperature, light, and CO₂ supplementation, may influence plant-bacterial interactions in unintended ways. Understanding the specific effects of these environmental factors may inform the best cultural practices and further elucidate the mechanisms by which beneficial bacteria promote plant growth.

Microbial remediation mechanisms and applications for lead-contaminated environments

High concentrations of lead (Pb) in agricultural soil and wastewater represent a severe threat to the ecosystem and health of living organisms. Among available removal techniques, microbial remediation has attracted much attention due to its lower cost, higher efficiency, and less impact on the environment; hence, it is an effective alternative to conventional physical or chemical Pb-remediation technologies. In the present review, recent advances on the Pb-remediation mechanisms of bacteria, fungi and microalgae have been reported, as well as their detoxification pathways. Based on the previous researches, microorganisms have various remediation mechanisms to cope with Pb pollution, which are basically categorized into biosorption, bioprecipitation, biomineralization, and bioaccumulations. This paper summarizes microbial Pb-remediation mechanisms, factors affecting Pb removal, and examples of each case are described in detail. We emphatically discuss the mechanisms of microbial immobilization of Pb, which can resist toxicity by synthesizing nanoparticles to convert dissolved Pb(II) into less toxic forms. The tolerance mechanisms of microbes to Pb are discussed at the molecular level as well. Finally, we conclude the research challenges and development prospects regarding the microbial remediation of Pb-polluted environment. The current review provides insight of interaction between lead and microbes and their potential applications for Pb removal.

Feasibility of implementing quorum quenching technology to mitigate membrane fouling in MBRs treating phenol-rich pharmaceutical wastewater: Application of Rhodococcus sp. BH4 and quorum quenching consortium

This study aimed to implement quorum quenching (QQ) to mitigate membrane fouling in membrane bioreactors (MBRs) treating phenol-rich pharmaceutical wastewater using Rhodococcus sp. BH4 and isolated QQ consortium (QQcs) from activated sludge. Neither BH4 nor QQcs impacted the removal efficiency of chemical oxygen demand (COD) (>94%), phenol (>99%), and ammonium (>99%), indicating that QQ did not have adverse impact on treatment performance. In addition, both BH4 and QQcs effectively retarded membrane fouling, which could be attributed to the reduction of soluble microbial products (SMP). Interestingly, the TMP increase was delayed 68.7% by Rhodococcus sp. BH4, while 31.3% was achieved by QQcs. This difference may be due to the relatively higher degradation for short- and medium-chain N-acyl-homoserine lactones (AHLs) by BH4 compared to the QQcs. Furthermore, the possible presence of quorum sensing (QS) bacteria within QQcs also could have contributed to the less effective fouling control than that of BH4.

Photolytic quorum quenching effects on the microbial communities and functional gene expressions in membrane bioreactors

Photolytic quorum quenching by ultraviolet A (UVA) irradiation is an effective strategy for controlling membrane bioreactor (MBR) biofouling; however, its effects on MBR microbial communities and functional genes have not yet been explored. Here, we report on the effects of the UVA irradiation, which mitigates membrane biofouling, on the microbial community structures, alpha and beta diversities, and functional gene expressions in the MBR mixed liquor and biocake (membrane fouling layer) for the first time. The results show that the microbial communities become less diversified when alternating UVA is applied to the MBRs. The changes in the community structure are highly influenced by spatiotemporal factors, such as microbial habitats (mixed liquor and biocake) and reactor operation time, although UVA irradiation also has some impacts on the community. The relative abundance of the Sphingomonadaceae family, which can decompose the furan ring of autoinducer-2 (AI-2) signal molecules, becomes greater with continuous UVA irradiation. Xanthomonadaceae, which produces biofilm-degrading enzymes, is also more abundant with UVA photolysis than without it. Copies of monooxygenase and hydroxylase enzyme-related genes increase in the MBR with longer UVA exposures (i.e., continuous UVA). These enzymes seem to be inducible by UVA, enhancing the AI-2 inactivation. In conclusion, UVA irradiation alters the microbial community and the metabolism in the MBR, contributing to the membrane biofouling mitigation.

Effect of Aeration Intensity on Performance of Lab-Scale Quorum-Quenching Membrane Bioreactor

Biofouling is one of the main drawbacks of membrane bioreactors (MBRs). Among the different methods, the quorum-quenching (QQ) technique is a novel method as it delays biofilm formation on the membrane surface through disruption of bacterial cell-to-cell communication and thus effectively mitigates membrane biofouling. QQ bacteria require a certain concentration of dissolved oxygen to show their best activities. Despite the importance of the amount of aeration, there have not been enough studies on aeration condition utilizing the separate determination of pure QQ effect and physical cleaning effect. This research aimed to find the optimum aeration intensity by separation of the two effects from QQ and physical cleaning. Three bead type conditions (no bead, vacant bead, and QQ beads) at three aeration intensities (1.5, 2.5, and 3.5 L/min representing low, medium, and high aeration intensity) were applied. From the results, no QQ effect and small QQ effect were observed at low and high aeration, while the greatest QQ effect (48.2% of 737 h improvement) was observed at medium aeration. The best performance was observed at high aeration with QQ beads having a 1536 h operational duration (303% improvement compared to the no bead condition); however, this excellent performance was attributed more to the physical cleaning effect than to the QQ effect.

Role of nano-Fe3O4 particle on improving membrane bioreactor (MBR) performance: Alleviating membrane fouling and microbial mechanism

This study would investigate the effect of nano-Fe3O4 particles on the performance of membrane bioreactor (MBR), including membrane fouling, membrane rejection and microbial community. It can effectively alleviate membrane fouling and improve the effluent quality in MBR by bio-effect rather than nanoparticle adsorption. The lowest membrane fouling resistance was achieved at R4-MBR (sludge and membrane surface with nano-Fe3O4), which decreased by 46.08%. Meanwhile, R3-MBR (sludge with nano-Fe3O4) had the lowest concentration of COD in effluent which was below 20 mg/L in the stable phase of MBR operation. After applying nano-Fe3O4, the content of extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) and soluble microbial products (SMP) were both reduced with a lower molecular weight. From the microbial community analysis, the abundance of Proteobacteria increased from 25.06 to 45.11% at the phylum level in R3-MBR. It contributed to removing organic substances in MBRs. Moreover, the nano-Fe3O4 restricted Bacteroidetes growth, especially in R4-MBR, leading to a more excellent performance of membrane flux. Besides, the applied nano-Fe3O4 promoted the abundance of Quorum Quenching (QQ) microorganism, and declined the percentage of Quorum Sensing (QS) bacteria. Then, a lower content of N-Acyl-l-Homoserine Lactones (AHLs) in containing nano-Fe3O4 sludge. That was also prone to control membrane fouling. Overall, this study indicates the nano-Fe3O4 particle is appropriate for elevating MBR performance, such as membrane fouling and effluent quality, by bio-effect.

Application oriented bioaugmentation processes: Mechanism, performance improvement and scale-up

Bioaugmentation is an optimization method with great potential to improve the treatment effect by introducing specific strains into the biological treatment system. In this study, a comprehensive review of the mechanism of bioaugmentation from the aspect of microbial community structure, the optimization methods facilitating application as well as feasible approaches of scale-up application has been provided. The different contribution of indigenous and exogenous strains was critically analyzed, the relationship between microbial community variation and system performance was clarified. Operation regulation and immobilization technologies are effective methods to deal with the possible failure of bioaugmentation. The gradual expansion from lab-scale, pilot scale to full-scale, the transformation and upgrading of wastewater treatment plants through the combination of direct dosing and biofilm, and the application of side-stream reactors are feasible ways to realize the full-scale application. The future challenges and prospects in this field were also proposed.

Efficient biostimulants for bacterial quorum quenching to control fouling in MBR

Quorum quenching (QQ), which disrupts bacterial communication and biofilm formation, could alleviate biofouling in MBR. QQ bio-stimulus possessing similar conserved moiety as the signal molecule could promote indigenous QQ bacteria, and thus successfully alleviate biofouling in MBR. However, efficient biostimulant has been barely explored for QQ enhancement in activated sludge system. This study extensively enumerated the potential QQ bio-stimuli, and examined their efficacy on QQ promotion for activated sludge. Moreover, the effect of the QQ consortia on fouling mitigation was also investigated. The results indicated that gamma-caprolactone (GCL), d-xylonic acid-1,4-lactone (XAL), gamma-heptalactone (GHL), urea, and acetamide proved effective in promoting AHLs inactivating activity of activated sludge. GCL, XAL, and GHL intensified the lactonase activity, while urea and acetamide augmented acylase activity. While coupled with beads entrapment, GCL consortia beads, XAL consortia beads, and urea consortia beads effectively disrupted quorum sensing (QS) and controlled membrane fouling in MBR. This work found out several optional bio-stimuli valid for tuning QQ in activated sludge system, and provided easily available and economical alternatives for QQ biostimulation, meanwhile the proposed QQ-MBR approach through QQ biostimulation and consortia entrapment also proved effective and practical.

Effects of interactions between quorum sensing and quorum quenching on microbial aggregation characteristics in wastewater treatment: A review

Due to the increasingly urgent demand for effective wastewater denitrification and dephosphorization systems, there is a need to improve the performance of existing biological treatment technologies. As a bacteria-level communication mechanism, quorum sensing (QS) synchronizes gene expression in a density-dependent manner and regulates bacterial physiological behavior. On this basis, the QS-based bacterial communication mechanism and environmental factors affecting QS are discussed. This paper reviews the influence of QS on sludge granulation, biofilm formation, emerging contaminants (ECs) removal, and horizontal gene transfer in sewage treatment system. Furthermore, the QS inhibition strategies are compared. Based on the coexistence and balance of QQ and QS in the long-term operation system, QQ, as an effective tool to regulate the growth density of microorganisms, provides a promising exogenous regulation strategy for residual sludge reduction and biofilm pollution control. This paper reviews the potential of improving wastewater treatment efficiency based on QS theory and points out the feasibility and prospect of exogenous regulation strategy. PRACTITIONER POINTS: The mechanism of bacterial communication based on QS and the environmental factors affecting QS were discussed. The application of QS and QQ in improving the sludge performance of biological treatment systems was described. The significance of QS and QQ coexistence in sewage treatment process was described.

Biological mechanism of alleviating membrane biofouling by porous spherical carriers in a submerged membrane bioreactor

In this study, porous spherical carriers were fixed around the hollow fiber membrane module to mitigate membrane biofouling. Two MBRs (R1 without carriers, R2 with carriers) were operated for 31 days under identical operating conditions to investigate the effects of the carriers on the reactor performances, the production of extracellular polymeric substances (EPS), the level of N-acyl-homoserine lactones (AHLs), and the microbial communities. The results showed that the presence of carriers in MBR was conducive to nitrogen removal and decreased the total membrane filtration resistance by about 1.7 times. Slower transmembrane pressure (TMP) rise-up, thinner bio-cakes, lower EPS production, and fewer tryptophan and aromatic proteins substances on the membrane surface were observed in R2. The polysaccharides secretion of EPS in bio-cakes was mainly regulated by C4-HSL and 3OC6-HSL in the presence of carriers. The microbial community analysis revealed that carriers addition reduced the relative abundance of EPS and AHL producing bacteria in the membrane bio-cakes and enriched the accumulation of functional bacteria conducive to nutrient removal in the mixed liquor. This study provided an in-depth understanding for the application of porous spherical carriers to alleviate membrane biofouling.

Biological-based control strategies for MBR membrane biofouling: a review

Membrane bioreactor (MBR) technology has been paid extensive attention for wastewater treatment because of its advantages of high effluent quality and minimized occupation space and sludge production. However, the membrane fouling is always an inevitable problem, which causes high operation and maintenance costs and prevents the wide use of MBR technology. The membrane biofouling is the most complicated and has relatively slow progress among all types of fouling. In recent years, many membrane biofouling control methods have been developed. Different from the physical or chemical methods, the biological-based strategies are not only more effective for membrane biofouling control, but also milder and more environment-friendly and, therefore, have been increasingly employed. This paper mainly focuses on the mechanism, unique advantages and development of biological-based control strategies for MBR membrane biofouling such as quorum quenching, uncoupling, flocculants and so on. The paper summarizes the up-to-date development of membrane biofouling control strategies, emphasizes the advantages and promising potential of biological-based ones, and points out the direction for future studies.

N-acyl homoserine lactone molecules assisted quorum sensing: effects consequences and monitoring of bacteria talking in real life

Bacteria utilize small signal molecules to monitor population densities. Bacteria arrange gene regulation in a method called Quorum Sensing (QS). The most widespread signalling molecules are N-Acyl Homoserine Lactones (AHLs/HSLs) for Gram-negative bacteria communities. QS plays significant role in the organizing of the bacterial gene that adapts to harsh environmental conditions for bacteria. It is involved in the arrangement of duties, such as biofilm formation occurrence, virulence activity of bacteria, production of antibiotics, plasmid conjugal transfer incident, pigmentation phenomenon and production of exopolysaccharide (EPS). QS obviously impacts on human health, agriculture and environment. AHL-related QS researches have been extensively studied and understood in depth for cell to cell intercommunication channel in Gram-negative bacteria. It is understood that AHL-based QS research has been extensively studied for cell-to-cell communication in Gram-negative bacteria; hence, a comprehensive study of AHLs, which are bacterial signal molecules, is required. The purpose of this review is to examine the effects of QS-mediated AHLs in many areas by looking at them from a different perspectives, such as clinic samples, food industry, aquatic life and wastewater treatment system.

Effects of N-acyl-homoserine lactones-based quorum sensing on biofilm formation, sludge characteristics, and bacterial community during the start-up of bioaugmented reactors

Bioaugmentation is an effective technology for treating wastewater containing recalcitrant organic pollutants. However, it is restricted by several technical problems, including the difficult colonization and survival of the inoculated bacteria, and the time-consuming start-up process. Considering the important roles of quorum sensing (QS) in regulating microbial behaviors, this study investigated the effects of N-acyl-homoserine lactones (AHLs)-based manipulation on the start-up of biofilm reactors bioaugmented with a pyridine-degrading strain Paracoccus sp. BW001. The results showed that, in the presence of two specific exogenous AHLs (C6-HSL and 3OC6-HSL), the biofilm formation process on carriers was significantly accelerated, producing thick and structured biofilms. The protein and polysaccharide contents of the extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) and soluble microbial products (SMP) in sludge were also elevated, possibly due to the increased abundance of several EPS-producing bacterial genera. Specifically, the stability and complexity of protein structures were improved. Besides the reactor running time, the AHL-manipulation was proved to be the main factor that drove the shift of bacterial community structures in the reactors. The addition of exogenous AHLs significantly increased the succession rate of bacterial communities and decreased the bacterial alpha diversity. Most importantly, the final proportions of the inoculated strain BW001 were elevated by nearly 100% in both sludge and biofilm communities via the AHL-manipulation. These findings strongly elucidated that AHL-based QS was deeply involved in biofilm formation, sludge characteristics, and microbial community construction in bioaugmented reactors, providing a promising start-up strategy for bioaugmentation technology.

Effect of quorum quenching on EPS and size-fractioned particles and organics in anaerobic membrane bioreactor for domestic wastewater treatment

Quorum quenching (QQ) has been applied as a promising membrane fouling control strategy for anaerobic membrane bioreactors (AnMBRs). Nevertheless, long-term operation of AnMBRs for real domestic wastewater (DWW) treatment needs to be systematically studied to evaluate comprehensive membrane fouling mechanisms and bioprocess performance. In this study, the impact of QQ on membrane fouling was investigated using a quorum quenching AnMBR (QQAnMBR) deploying a bead-entrapped facultative quorum quenching consortium (FQQ) to treat DWW. FQQ was shown to prolong membrane filtration operation by an average of 75%. Reduced proteins (p < 0.005) and carbohydrates (p < 0.005) in the extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) of mixed liquor (ML) were key differentiators that led to lower cake layer (CL) formation. Additionally, reduced biopolymers production (p < 0.05) in EPS improved sludge dewaterability. The findings suggested that QQ could alter fluorescent microbial metabolites of both EPS and CL as unveiled by excitation-emission matrix spectra pattern. Furthermore, colloidal particles (i.e., particles with size larger than 0.45 μm in ML supernatants) production was retarded by QQ, thereafter, also contributed to the reduced CL formation. Pore blockage was slightly increased by QQ, which might be attributed to pore blockage by large (∼230 nm) and small organic compounds (∼51 nm) in soluble microbial products (SMP). However, QQ had no significant impact on organic concentration of SMP, and QQ was not associated with particle size distribution of biomass. QQ performance was further affirmed through suppressed production of C4-HSL, 3-OXO-C6-HSL, and C6-HSL. The overall AHLs degradability of FQQ was well-maintained even after five membrane service cycles (total operation of 70 d). Moreover, QQ had no compromised impact on treatment performance (i.e., chemical oxygen demand (COD) removal and methane yield). Collectively, this study bridged the knowledge gap to bring forward QQ technology in AnMBR for widespread domestic wastewater treatment application.

Analysis of N-Acy-L-homoserine lactones (AHLs) in wastewater treatment systems using SPE-LLE with LC-MS/MS

The occurrence and distribution of N-acyl homoserine lactones (AHLs) in membrane bioreactors (MBRs) treating wastewater has garnered much attention as they have been shown to play critical role in biofouling. There is a need to develop a single method capable of analysing AHLs in various wastewater with comparable and reliable performance. A novel and robust method was proposed for trace analysis of 11 AHLs in wastewater treatment systems treating domestic and industrial wastewater. This method utilised solid phase extraction (SPE) to extract AHLs from wastewater followed by liquid-liquid extraction (LLE) to extract AHLs from the SPE eluant, and used N-heptanoyl-dl-homoserine lactone (C7-HSL) as an internal standard. There was no need to prepare matrix-matched calibration curve for accurate quantification of AHLs in the liquid chromatography tandem mass chromatography (LC-MS/MS) analysis. The developed method was validated with six different types of domestic and industrial wastewater with regard to AHLs recoveries and matrix effects. For treated domestic and industrial wastewater, the relative recoveries ranged from 75% to 130% and the matrix effects ranged from 89% to 122%. This method exhibited remarkable improvement compared with single SPE. The results also indicated that inclusion of LLE after SPE could effectively alleviate matrix effects, which may be because of the removal of relatively hydrophilic interferences by using dichloromethane to extract AHLs from the SPE eluant composing of methanol and water. The limits of detection of the AHLs were all below 5 ng/L for the tested wastewater samples. The developed method of SPE-LLE with LC-MS/MS was applied to analyse AHLs in four lab-scale and one pilot-scale wastewater treatment systems. Wide spectrum of AHLs with alkanoyl chains ranging from C4 to C14 were detected with concentrations ranging from 2.7 to 299.2 ng/L. This method is capable of identifying and quantifying trace levels of AHLs in various wastewater treatment systems and can help us better understand the mechanisms of AHL-mediated quroum sensing in various wastewater treatment systems.

Enhanced treatment performance of phenol wastewater and membrane antifouling by biochar-assisted EMBR

Biochar-assisted EMBR (BC-assisted EMBR) was built to enhance treatment performance of phenol wastewater and membrane antifouling. BC-assisted EMBR significantly increased phenol degradation efficiency, owing to combined effects of biodegradation, adsorption and electro-catalytic degradation. Meanwhile, BC-assisted EMBR obviously mitigated membrane fouling. The coupling effect of BC and voltage led to the lower N-acyl-homoserine lactones (AHLs) and bound extracellular polymeric substances (bound EPS) contents around and on membrane surface. Protein (PN)/polysaccharide (PS) in bound EPS was decreased, led to the increase of negative charge and decrease of hydrophobicity of sludge, which abated bound EPS adsorption on membrane surface. Microbial community analyses revealed that the coupling effect of BC and voltage could enrich phenol-degraders (e.g., Comamonas), electron transfer genus (Phaselicystis), and biopolymer-degraders (Phaselicystis and Tepidisphaera) in BC-assisted EMBR and on its membrane surface, while decrease biofilm-former (e.g., Acinetobacter) and bound EPS-producer (Devosia), which was beneficial to promote phenol treatment and mitigate membrane fouling.

Quorum quenching bacteria bioaugmented GO/PPy modified membrane in EMBR for membrane antifouling

A novel integrated system with quorum quenching (QQ) bacterium Burkholderia sp. ssn-2 bioaugmented graphene oxide/polypyrrole (GO/PPy) conductive polymercomposite membrane (CPM) in MBR with electric field (EMBR) was established. The integrated system exhibited the highest degradation efficiency for phenol (100%) and COD (93.2%-99.9%) during the 120 days operation. Membrane fouling in the integrated system was notably mitigated by the coupling effect of CPM + voltage and QQ bacterium ssn-2. The hydrophilicity and antibacterial activity of CPM inhibited the hydrophobic protein foulants adsorption, bacteria colonization and attachment on the CPM surface. Extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) content was positively correlated with N-acyl-homoserine lactones (AHLs) concentration, and decreased with AHLs degradation by QQ bacterium ssn-2. The increased negative charge of EPS on the CPM surface augmented the electrostatic repulsion between the EPS and cathode CPM in the integrated system. Moreover, the coupling effect altered the microbial communities. A decreased AHLs concentration had a significantly negative correlation with QQ bacterium ssn-2 enrichment, which exhibited the dual effects of degrading phenol and AHLs, and enriching biopolymer-degrading genera Clostridium sensu strict and Acidovorax in the integrated system and on the CPM surface. This can lead to a decrease in the EPS content.

Nitrogen-Free Cationic Starch Flocculants: Flocculation Performance, Antibacterial Ability, and UF Membrane Fouling Control

In light of growing concerns about the formation of nitrogen-based disinfection byproducts (N-DBP) and the possible contribution from the use of quaternary-ammonium-containing flocculants, there is growing interest in the alternative use of quaternary phosphonium salts, which have been reported to have a lower DBP formation potential, stronger cationic properties, lower cytotoxicity, and greater stability. In this study, the performance of N-free quaternary-phosphonium-modified starch flocculants (S-BTP), synthesized through a facile one-step method using commercially available raw materials, in the treatment of bacteria-laden waters (E. coli as the model bacteria) was assessed in both jar tests and a bench-scale continuous-flow flocculation-sedimentation-ultrafiltration process. In jar tests, the effects of the cationic degree of substitution (DS) and dosage of the flocculant, solution pH, and presence of model contaminants on treatment performance were studied. One particular flocculant (S-BTP3), with a DS of 19.3%, displayed high removal efficiencies of E. coli, turbidity, and UV₂₅₄ from water, comparable with those of ammonium-based analogues and conventional alum, via a combination of charge attraction, polymer bridging, and antibacterial effects. S-BTP3 also possessed better bactericidal properties (99.4% of E. coli killed) than alum (41.4% killed) and did not cause the release of intracellular substances into the treated water. In the continuous-flow flocculation-sedimentation-UF tests, S-BTP3 was superior to alum in the flocculation and antibacterial performance, and in mitigating UF membrane fouling. The results have clearly demonstrated the multiple benefits of the use of N-free cationic starch flocculants in water treatment as an alternative to conventional chemicals.

Impacts of long-term electric field applied on the membrane fouling mitigation and shifts of microbial communities in EMBR for treating phenol wastewater

The membrane antifouling and shifts of microbial communities of long-term electric field applied in MBR (EMBR) for treating phenol wastewater was systematically investigated. The increased voltage increased the phenol degradation rate and slowed down the TMP increase rate in EMBR (G1-G4: 1.65 × 10^-3-8.40 × 10^-4 Mpa/d), indicated the enhancement of phenol treatment and mitigation of membrane fouling. Decrease of protein (PN)/polysaccharide (PS) in EPS increased the negative charge and decreased the hydrophobicity of sludge, thus abated its adsorption on membrane surface. The decrease of AHLs concentration attributed to the electrolysis of AHLs by the electro-generated H₂O₂. Besides, the AHLs had significantly negative correlation with QQ bacteria Rhodococcus and Stenotrophomonas enrichment and positive correlation with QS bacteria Aeromonas decrease in EMBRs, suggesting that coupling effects of voltage and QQ bacteria degraded AHLs, thus decreased EPS content which was positively correlated with AHLs concentration. Biopolymer-degrading genera (Clostridium sensu strict etc.) increased in EMBR and on membrane surface, while biofilm-forming genera (Pseudomonas etc.) decreased on membrane surface. These resulted in EPS content decrease and membrane antifouling.

Inhibition of biofouling in membrane bioreactor by metabolic uncoupler based on controlling microorganisms accumulation and quorum sensing signals secretion

Biofouling is a limiting bottleneck in the development of membrane bioreactor (MBR) since the birth of this technology. Recently, the biofouling control strategy based on interfering with the bacterial quorum sensing (QS) system is highly desirable for biofouling control in MBR. In this study, three lab-scale parallel MBR systems were operated over 100 days to investigate the inhibitory effect of a metabolic uncoupler (3,3',4',5-tetrachlorosalicylanilide, TCS) on biofouling and the potential mechanism for biofouling control. Compared to the control MBR, the fouling cycle duration of MBR 2 with 100 μg/L TCS extended over two times. The attached biomass on membrane in MBR 2 decreased over 50% at the end of each operating period, which indicated that the addition of TCS significantly mitigated microorganisms accumulation on membrane. The content of interspecies QS signal (autoinducer-2) and intraspecific QS signals (N-octanoyl-_dl-homoserine lactone, C8-HSL) was reduced by the TCS, suggesting the secretion of QS signals in MBR were affected by uncoupler. Although the addition of TCS induced brief fluctuations of extracellular proteins and polysaccharides, microorganisms seemed to rapidly acclimatize to the presence of TCS and then the secretion of extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) was inhibited by 100 μg/L TCS. The continuous operation of MBR was not be affected by the low-concentration uncoupler via the analysis of substrate removal and sludge growth. This study systematically evaluated the effect and inhibitory efficiency of TCS on biofouling, biomass accumulation, QS signals, EPS and treatment performances, demonstrating the feasibility of metabolic uncoupler for biofouling control in MBR.

Prevention of biofilm formation by quorum quenching

Quorum sensing (QS) is a mechanism that enables microbial communication. It is based on the constant secretion of signaling molecules to the environment. The main role of QS is the regulation of vital processes in the cell such as virulence factor production or biofilm formation. Due to still growing bacterial resistance to antibiotics that have been overused, it is necessary to search for alternative antimicrobial therapies. One of them is quorum quenching (QQ) that disrupts microbial communication. QQ-driving molecules can decrease or even completely inhibit the production of virulence factors (including biofilm formation). There are few QQ strategies that comprise the use of the structural analogues of QS receptor autoinductors (AI). They may be found in nature or be designed and synthesized via chemical engineering. Many of the characterized QQ molecules are enzymes with the ability to degrade signaling molecules. They can also impede cellular signaling cascades. There are different techniques used for testing QS/QQ, including chromatography-mass spectroscopy, bioluminescence, chemiluminescence, fluorescence, electrochemistry, and colorimetry. They all enable qualitative and quantitative measurements of QS/QQ molecules. This article gathers the information about the mechanisms of QS and QQ, and their effect on microbial biofilm formation. Basic methods used to study QS/QQ, as well as the medical and biotechnological applications of QQ, are also described. Basis research methods are also described as well as medical and biotechnological application.

Quorum sensing signaling distribution during the development of full-scale municipal wastewater treatment biofilms

Acylated homoserine lactone (AHL)-mediated quorum sensing (QS) is ecologically important in multi-species systems in laboratory-scale studies; however, little is known about QS in the biofilm formation process in full-scale wastewater treatment plants, which is driven by multiple environmental variables. Here, a model integrated fixed-film-activated sludge system was employed in full-scale municipal wastewater treatment plant to investigate the AHL distribution during the biofilm development process in response to variable environmental factors. The whole biofilm development process can be divided into three phases: initial biofilm attachment process (week 1 to 3), biofilm development and mature phase (week 4 to 6), and biofilm detachment and reformation process (week 7 to 17). N-decanoyl-DL-homoserine lactone (C10-HSL) and N-dodecanoyl-DL-homoserine lactone (C12-HSL) presented high concentrations during the biofilm formation process, which was closely related with the biofilm initial attachment process. The AHL concentration in biofilms was higher than in activated sludge. During the initial attachment process, tryptophan and protein-like substances related to biological substance were strongly positively correlated with all detected AHL concentrations (p < 0.05). Three environmental variables (total nitrogen, pH, and Na⁺) were closely related to AHL distribution in municipal wastewater biofilms. High wastewater pH was found to contribute to a low AHL concentration. AHLs in the biofilm were significantly (p < 0.01) influenced by the concentration of Na⁺, and higher concentrations of Na⁺ (10.84-18.58 mg/L) in wastewater treatment plants potentially contribute to the biofilm formation processes. In addition, bacteria with nitrogen removal ability showed QS functionality. The results of this study indicate that AHL-based regulation of tryptophan and protein-like substances related to biological substance production was significantly influenced by the surrounding chemical environment, which has been underestimated in previous studies. AHL-mediated QS potentially suggests a novel solution for the advanced AHL-based regulation of the biofilm development processes.

Control of indigenous quorum quenching bacteria on membrane biofouling in a short-period MBR

In this paper, the immobilized quorum quenching (QQ) bacteria - microbial bag was added to a short-period membrane bioreactor (MBR) and its antifouling ability and mechanism were studied by monitoring the changes in transmembrane pressure (TMP), along with the production of N-acyl-homoserine lactones (AHLs), extracellular polymeric substance (EPS) and soluble microbial products (SMP). The QQ bacteria showed efficient mitigation of TMP increase in different membrane fouling stages. In the control MBR group, the TMP reached 43 kPa on the 4th day, while in the experimental group, TMP of QQ-MBR was only 18 kPa at the same time. The detection result of EPS and SMP content of protein and polysaccharide in MBRs showed that QQ bacteria had significant inhibitory effects on EPS and SMP. Also, the QQ bacterial exhibited excellent AHLs degradation rate in MBR reaction tank.

Core-shell structured quorum quenching beads for more sustainable anti-biofouling in membrane bioreactors

Efficient media designs for microbial quorum quenching (QQ) are essential to enable maximal biofouling control in membrane bioreactors (MBRs). Here we introduce a novel, double-layered, biocarrier design, which has QQ bacteria in the shell layer with biostimulating agents in the core, for effective membrane biofouling control. Confining the biostimulant within dense polymer materials permits its controlled release over an extended period. The provision of the biostimulant from the core to the outer shell, where the QQ bacteria are encapsulated, facilitates their prolonged survival and active life. The core-shell structured QQ bead with the stimulant inside, which inhibits biofilm formation, shows the best fouling mitigation in laboratory testing of MBRs, while enhancing signal molecule degradation and lowering exopolymer secretion. This new, layered QQ bead, which has dual functions of bioaugmentation and biostimulation, supports a highly efficient and sustainable anti-biofouling strategy.

Quorum sensing and quenching in membrane bioreactors: Opportunities and challenges for biofouling control

Membrane biofouling, due to biofilm growth after planktonic bacteria attachment to a membrane, is a major bottleneck limiting the energy-efficient operation and maintenance of membrane bioreactors (MBRs). Microbial communications, known as quorum sensing (QS), are responsible for this biofouling behavior. Novel strategies for stopping this communication, known as quorum quenching (QQ), appear to be successful for biofouling control in MBRs used for wastewater treatment. This review describes recent information regarding the signal molecules and mechanisms responsible for QS behaviors, promising approaches for QQ (enzymatic, bacterial, fungal, photocatalytic, mimicking, and biostimulating methods), and efficient fabrication and use of QQ media for MBR applications. We discuss the opportunities and challenges of QQ techniques for their further improvement and practical use in MBRs.

Engineering a light-responsive, quorum quenching biofilm to mitigate biofouling on water purification membranes

Quorum quenching (QQ) has been reported to be a promising approach for membrane biofouling control. Entrapment of QQ bacteria in porous matrices is required to retain them in continuously operated membrane processes and to prevent uncontrollable biofilm formation by the QQ bacteria on membrane surfaces. It would be more desirable if the formation and dispersal of biofilms by QQ bacteria could be controlled so that the QQ bacterial cells are self-immobilized, but the QQ biofilm itself still does not compromise membrane performance. In this study, we engineered a QQ bacterial biofilm whose growth and dispersal can be modulated by light through a dichromatic, optogenetic c-di-GMP gene circuit in which the bacterial cells sense near-infrared (NIR) light and blue light to adjust its biofilm formation by regulating the c-di-GMP level. We also demonstrated the potential application of the engineered light-responsive QQ biofilm in mitigating biofouling of water purification forward osmosis membranes. The c-di-GMP-targeted optogenetic approach for controllable biofilm development we have demonstrated here should prove widely applicable for designing other controllable biofilm-enabled applications such as biofilm-based biocatalysis.

Stopping Autoinducer-2 Chatter by Means of an Indigenous Bacterium ( Acinetobacter sp. DKY-1): A New Antibiofouling Strategy in a Membrane Bioreactor for Wastewater Treatment

Bacterial quorum quenching (QQ) by means of degrading signaling molecules has been applied to antibiofouling strategies in a membrane bioreactor (MBR) for wastewater treatment. However, the target signaling molecules have been limited to N-acyl homoserine lactones participating in intraspecies quorum sensing. Here, an approach to disrupting autoinducer-2 (AI-2) signaling molecules participating in interspecies quorum sensing was pursued as a next-generation antibiofouling strategy in an MBR for wastewater treatment. We isolated an indigenous QQ bacterium ( Acinetobacter sp. DKY-1) that can attenuate the expression of the quorum-sensing (QS) response through the inactivation of an autoinducer-2 signaling molecule, 4,5-dihydroxy-2,3-pentanedione (DPD), among four kinds of autoinducer-2 QS bacteria. DKY-1 released AI-2 QQ compounds, which were verified to be hydrophilic with a molecular weight of <400 Da. The addition of DKY-1 entrapping beads into an MBR significantly decreased DPD concentration and remarkably reduced membrane biofouling. This new approach, combining molecular biology with wastewater engineering, could enlarge the range of QQ-MBR for antibiofouling and energy savings in the field of wastewater treatment.

Effect of quorum quenching on biofouling and ammonia removal in membrane bioreactor under stressful conditions

Quorum quenching (QQ) has been used to control biofouling in membrane bioreactors (MBRs), but the effect of QQ on the performance of MBR has not been systematically studied. This study investigated the effect of QQ on ammonia removal in MBR especially in some stressful conditions. The results showed that membrane fouling was effectively alleviated by QQ in all conditions. For the short HRT (3.94 h), the ammonia removal in QQ-MBR was fluctuating. In the presence of nitrification inhibitors (acetonitrile and allylthiourea) or at low temperature (10 °C), QQ induced much more significant suppression on nitrification in batch test and MBR. The number of the ammonia oxidizing bacteria (AOB) was not decreasing in these situations, which indicated that QQ only suppressed the activity of AOB. In all, comprehensive considerations should be taken into account when applying a QS tuning strategy to a bioreactor.

Immobilization and Stabilization of Acylase on Carboxylated Polyaniline Nanofibers for Highly Effective Antifouling Application via Quorum Quenching

Acylase (AC) was immobilized and stabilized on carboxylated polyaniline nanofibers (cPANFs) for the development of antifouling nanobiocatalysts with high enzyme loading and stability. AC was immobilized via three different approaches: covalent attachment (CA), enzyme coating (EC), and magnetically separable enzyme precipitate coating (Mag-EPC). The enzyme activity per unit weight of cPANFs with Mag-EPC was 75 and 300 times higher than that of those with CA and EC, respectively, representing improved enzyme loading in the form of Mag-EPC. After incubation under shaking at 200 rpm for 20 days, Mag-EPC maintained 55% of its initial activity, whereas CA and EC showed 3 and 16% of their initial activities, respectively. The antifouling of highly loaded and stable Mag-EPC against the biofouling/biofilm formation of Pseudomonas aeruginosa was tested under static- and continuous-flow conditions. Biofilm formation in the presence of 40 μg/mL Mag-EPC under static condition was 5 times lower than that under control condition with no addition of Mag-EPC. Under continuous membrane filtration, Mag-EPC delayed the increase of transmembrane pressure (TMP) more effectively as the concentration of added Mag-EPC increased. When separating Mag-EPC and membranes in two different vessels under internal circulation of the culture solution, Mag-EPC maintained a higher permeability than the control with no Mag-EPC addition. It was also confirmed that the addition of Mag-EPC reduced the generation of N-acyl homoserine lactone (AHL) autoinducers. This result reveals that the inhibition of biofilm formation and biofouling in the presence of Mag-EPC is due to the hydrolysis of AHL autoinducers, catalyzed by the immobilized and stabilized AC in the form of Mag-EPC. Mag-EPC of AC with high enzyme loadings and improved stability has demonstrated its great potential as an antifouling agent by reducing biofilm formation and membrane biofouling based on "enzymatic quorum quenching" of autoinducers.

Quorum quenching bacteria can be used to inhibit the biofouling of reverse osmosis membranes

Over the last few decades, significant efforts have concentrated on mitigating biofouling in reverse osmosis (RO) systems, with a focus on non-toxic and sustainable strategies. Here, we explored the potential of applying quorum quenching (QQ) bacteria to control biofouling in a laboratory-scale RO system. For these experiments, Pantoea stewartii was used as a model biofilm forming organism because it was previously shown to be a relevant wastewater isolate that also forms biofilms in a quorum sensing (QS) dependent fashion. A recombinant Escherichia coli strain, which can produce a QQ enzyme, was first tested in batch biofilm assays and significantly reduced biofilm formation by P. stewartii. Subsequently, RO membranes were fouled with P. stewartii and the QQ bacterium was introduced into the RO system using two different strategies, direct injection and immobilization within a cartridge microfilter. When the QQ bacterial cells were directly injected into the system, N-acylhomoserine lactone signals were degraded, resulting in the reduction of biofouling. Similarly, the QQ bacteria controlled biofouling when immobilized within a microfilter placed downstream of the RO module to remove QS signals circulating in the system. These results demonstrate the proof-of-principle that QQ can be applied to control biofouling of RO membranes and may be applicable for use in full-scale plants.